Discover the Results of the Twinmotion vs D5 Render Showdown

[@Carolina-mw4po]

Wow! Why are you under attack! So many harsh comments here and there. I think your video is really simple and straight to the point, specially useful for those who don't kmow anything about these two softwares and need to make a choice. So you show how they work from scratch in a very simple workflow, perfect for beginners. Good video, very helpful! It's been so helpful to me. Thanks!

[@SignataDesign]

Thank you for understanding. may have their own preferences. but I hope they have an open mind and are objective because making comparisons requires objectivity. and I will try to make other comparison videos in the future. For now I can't continue because of time and cost constraints. the reason i can compare twinmotion and d5 render, because both are free

[@ProjetosPVC]

Ótima comparação, parabéns! Estou muito indeciso entre estes dois softwares. Teria como fazer um vídeo comparando os dois na questão de animação em vídeo? Abraços

[@SignataDesign]

I will try to make the video comparison

[@khonsai8160]

great video friend, keep it up!

[@SignataDesign]

Thank you😊😊

[@carvingtheway]

Twinmotion also has direct link with sketchup this gives me a hint that either u'r newly using both platforms or u'r a pro in d5 and have no idea about twinmotion... But it's so easy u can just dive in

[@SignataDesign]

Im just new for d5 render honestly, and i know about twinmotion plugin i just want to make some comparison for both.

[@carvingtheway]

@@SignataDesign all other answers are logical except for this one 😅... I respect that u'r new in D5 however u have the direct link for D5 available... The fact that in this specific point of comparison it looked like TM doesn't have direct link 😉🙈🎯 if it's not done by mistake i would have bet on it that it was done on purpose

[@SignataDesign]

@@carvingtheway yeah sorry for that i ever used that but since i switch to PC i forgot that plug-in and until now i never use the plug-in 😅😅

[@SignataDesign]

@@carvingtheway and thank you for remembering me so next render series i will use it

[@gerdhemminger2560]

Why did you no choose a glassmaterial in both renderings ?

[@SignataDesign]

glass material that i choose for twinmotion is for replacing water material. because if you use water material in twinmotion, you will not find the reflection. and for d5 render, the water basic material is already better. so, i think i did not need to replace it with other material

[@Fikarblackproject]

we have to re material from skechup to twinmotion?

[@SignataDesign]

Actually you can use sketchuo material but still you have to do the settings in twinmotion. And also you need good texture to put in sketchup

[@My-Opinion-Doesnt-Matter]

Why didn't you match the sky and exposure, the D5 is overexposed and Twinmotion has a blue sky...

[@SignataDesign]

That is my first time using D5 render, so i still need learning more about d5 render😊😊

[@My-Opinion-Doesnt-Matter]

​@@SignataDesign ok, if you don't/can't use the same HDRI for comparison, use "Geo and Sky" in D5, enable "Clouds" and try lowering the exposure because "Auto" overexposes a bit. Also decrease the "Sunlight" if highlights are overblown, and increase the "Sun disk radius" if you think the shadows are too sharp. If you want more contrast you can up it a bit, but before that check if "Bloom" is set to 0...

[@SignataDesign]

@@My-Opinion-Doesnt-Matter thank you bro i will try it on the future comparison video☺️☺️

[@Pablo-oy7hz]

Wuaooo, D5 render is better

[@carvingtheway]

This video doesn't do justice neither to twinmotion or D5

[@SignataDesign]

This is just my opinion

[@carvingtheway]

@@SignataDesign i know but to b honest u could have given much better results for both softwares.... U r an influencer on KZbin... Putting a bit more effort for D5 and TM would have given more authenticity to d video.... Not saying that the results aren't gd but could have been much better

[@azarelthecreator7098]

@@carvingtheway Using a real voice helps as well

[@carvingtheway]

U used alot of twinmotion scenery at first to attract the viewer....

[@SignataDesign]

Because i use twinmotion way longer than D5. but honestly, twinmotion still need much improvement in my opinion😊😊

[@carvingtheway]

@@SignataDesign all platforms do... It's as if D5 doesn't??? 😉

[@carvingtheway]

Trees in d5 are d same with no organic effect same as lumion.

[@carvingtheway]

Why using PT in first place... Basic water with no PT in twinmotion is awesome

[@SignataDesign]

Basic water with no PT is really good but the render result still not better, but if you see in newest update twinmotion 2023 preview 2, the real time scene is waaaaay better than before. Is nearly as PT now😊😊

[@carvingtheway]

@@SignataDesign totally agree... The Global illumination in 2023.1 p2 is very advanced

[@SignataDesign]

@@carvingtheway yeps and i am Verry happy with that

[@carvingtheway]

@@SignataDesign 🥂

[@farhaaan93]

Are you kidding me with the water comparison? Twinmotion is obviously better. Also, your comparison is not accurate. You're different materials for both and the renders also depends on your setup. To me twinmotion clearly renders better