Disney Mulan’s Makeup Explained | Traditional Chinese Makeup

[@LifeInPink999]

When you are a princess and get in an embarrassing situation of having a stain right in the middle of your face but make a trend out of it. Legendary.

[@DanielaSilva-tv4hu]

I loved all stories it's so precious,thank you so much for tell us so much about the stories, it makes everything more special.

[@ezradja]

Tang's era is always fascinating.

[@vio3366]

Thanks for your videos! Could you make a video about the clothes in the drama "The story of Minglan"?

[@SinisterSaturation]

So, there's a huge history of women getting injured and men going "I still love you." Then everyone else decides to imitate the injury in imitation and solidarity? The plum blossom story is my favorite. Less blood. I also just like the nature shapes. They are nice reminders of standing by the one you love whatever happens to them. It's a little off putting to think that injured women getting attention has such a lasting memory. "You're blood is like a sunset." Guess we're all imitating head wounds! The little red dots also remind me of dimple marks. :)

[@lokokoro]

I was thinking the same!

[@starmelodyelizabethb7380]

This was so lovely and interesting. I love Chinese culture

[@elashaczarinapataray3996]

Me too cause I have a Chinese blood

[@leeoungtsh2743]

@@elashaczarinapataray3996 me too

[@hoshiyoshii]

im from china

[@im_starstarstar]

Me too

[@riasrevenge8049]

Same I do too. I wish I had a culture like them.

[@tanyahlifst-jacques9537]

I'm researching Tang dynasty at the moment and I noticed that along with the makeup there is also different styles of eyebrows. Do you have any information on this? Also, what was used to draw the haidan and other markings? Which pigments were used?

[@bannanaberryboard]

I know this is a little bit late, but the channel “Off the Great Wall” has some really good videos about ancient Chinese makeup/clothes/hair

[@Schneeeulenwetter]

hheii, if you want, i can send you some photos i took at the Xi An museum. (if you don’t want to share your email adresse, I am sure you can look it up just by typing” Xi an history museum, make up” and you should find the pictures. they’re from the Tang dynasty if i remember correctly

[@Mr2tails]

朱砂 Cinnabar was used quite often for red colour cosmetics

[@paulinewqi]

Love your story telling.....am totally charmed by your voice... Tqtq for sharing...💖💝💐

[@realmofthesenses]

@@Mr2tails isn't cinnabar poisonous when used too often on the human skin?

[@AYC_kaymer]

Good to know. When I saw the Disney Mulan trailer I was worried that the makeup wasn't authentic.

[@AYC_kaymer]

To be honest I forgot I even made this comment 😂

[@NataliaPessoaXOXOMAKE]

@@missy610 The yellow forehead is also known as “Buddha’s makeup,” and was especially popular among ladies during the Tang Dynasty. A yellow aura on the forehead was believed to be auspicious (Schafer 1956, 419).

[@inotaishu1]

@@AYC_kaymer Don't worry. It is rather fashionable now to scream cultural inaccuracy at Disney's Mulan, just like so many still do with the animated version. Which strangely they don't do with movies like Beauty and the Beast who are equally historically inaccurate respectively exxaggerated to keep with the colorful Disney style.

[@inotaishu1]

@@NataliaPessoaXOXOMAKE Don't tell people that, they will accuse you of being a bigot and an incel. At least that is what I got for pointing out that the phoenix in the movie is closer to the Fenghuang than the European phoenix (or how in the animated version Mushu is actually more accurate to chinese dragons than many think) or how you can see the CCP's censors at work in the movie.

[@NataliaPessoaXOXOMAKE]

@@inotaishu1 I’m sorry for your experiences. I understand your frustration, it’s very difficult to have a leveled conversation nowadays.

[@popaganda919]

my favourite is the one on the forehead, it does make the woman looks prettier. but i came here for explanation on why they painted mulan's forehead yellow xDDD but no answers here

[@NataliaPessoaXOXOMAKE]

The yellow forehead, as can be seen in the live-action Mulan, is also known as “Buddha’s makeup,” and was especially popular among ladies during the Tang Dynasty. A yellow aura on the forehead was believed to be auspicious (Schafer 1956, 419).

[@SomasAcademy]

I just found this channel and have been marathoning the videos on Chinese fashion history. Fashion history is such an underrated part of history, and Chinese history is often overlooked, so finding a channel that talks about Chinese fashion history feels like such a gift lmao

[@corycianangel6321]

Soma Hanikeri I don't think Chinese history is overlooked, but Chinese historical fashion is. And I'm glad to find a channel that talks about it!

[@SomasAcademy]

@@corycianangel6321 In my experience, people usually only talk about a few select periods of Chinese history, or discuss it in relation to other regions. I often see it brought up as an example of one of the great powers that existed at any given time, but people discussing it in detail seems relatively rare to me.

[@Abhijit29]

Soma are you from india ?

[@truehappiness4U]

So because someone hit her temple with something sharp and got a scar, these people made a trend out of it and put a fake scar on their temples as well? Woah I love that era, I wish people would appreciate scars as well instead of looking down on them.

[@Applefablestudio]

My favorite is the Huadian story. As a child, I was wondering what the marking on the forehead meant, now I know! :) I didn't know about the temple scar, thought it was the painter's style of drawing royal ladies

[@charlottedardenne6609]

So makeup ideas came from accidents, WOW Chinese culture is amazing no wonder their fashion is amazing! 💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖even if from accidents they're very BEAUTIFUL

[@Ami-gu5zi]

There are no accidents - Master Oogway

[@s20031102]

They hired wrong make up artist for the film.

[@user-qj9en1kp1m]

This was actually rather cool. "My scars make me more special, more beautiful."

[@nandinisrivastava176]

Facial marking in india don't show marital status.Unmarried women can even wear them

[@juliantotriwijaya9208]

when a scar accidentally became a new make up trend XD lol, so unexpected. also "oh no, my cheek is injured, let's turn this into a dimple make up trend " XD lol

[@hsunwei2085]

I thought Huadian was created by Yang Guifei from watching a Hong Kong drama in my childhood😅, now I know that it was created way before Tang dynasty, wow!

[@kimonodaisuki]

Beautiful and lovely makeover❤(ӦｖӦ｡) Huadian is similar as bindi of India:-) In Japan, 'kuraiboshi' (similar huadian) is seen in 'chigo gyoretsu' (parade of children in Japanese traditional festival):-)

[@user-Sea_of_Stars]

Up主感谢你在海外推广汉服，真的，这个频道太良心了，你值得更多的订阅啊，我怎么才发现你的频道(T＿T)

[@magnoliasystem]

I love hearing Chinese spoken, it’s so oretty

[@shwethadevi7252]

Hi Ally, I like all your hanfu videos and huadian. In Hindu culture bindi is not only for women, but also for men and kids. Bindi is a cultural mark at the center of the eyebrows or at the center of the forehead.

[@tula__]

Yes, in hindu culture it marks the seat of the soul.

[@thefrustratedneetaspirant7777]

Bindi is meant for women, whereas men wear Tilak

[@AYOSANATANI]

@@thefrustratedneetaspirant7777 Shaktas(both males and females) wear a huge bindi on their forehead made of vermillion as it helps to relax the muscles

[@cainthebaguette]

I love Yedian 😍😍 but what about red dots under the eyes? Are those considered Yedian?

[@FiveThousandYears]

Yedian (or mianye 面靨) are basically decorations on the cheeks, so yeah I would say so :)

[@dionysus1896]

I stumbled upon your channel while looking for patterns for men's hanfu for a sewing project I'm working on.. Could you maybe do a video on it or help me out with what the pieces are called??

[@crystalrose2607]

Informative! Fantastic shots of historical figurines, art, scrolls, and wonderful reenactments! Thank you for sharing.

[@robinfa1477]

I read the story about the plum blossom somewhere and it confused me because they said it was Guifei and yet that was a trend before her time. Now it makes more sense knowing they got the wrong person. I really like your channel. Can you make a video about Tang hairstyles?

[@milkrock.]

Me, putting a red dot on my forehead to signal my partner I have my period.

[@daynee26]

HAHA

[@yearn1314]

thank u for promoting our culture~

[@frstell8870]

This video is so beautiful. Thank you!

[@darker_than_black]

No , bindhi/ pottu doesn't indicate Marital status of Hindus.. It's actually a tradition . like huadian there are also different types of bindhis. Kids to grandma put bindhi on their forehead..

[@Clee-os6pv]

The fiercest winter strom could not destroy this makeup.

[@HalfBreedMix]

So, in short, the original markings are from palace ladies bumping into things, getting hit by swinging objects, or having stuff fall on them,,,,,,,,,,,, I never knew being a lady in the palace was so dangerous :-/

[@jsong3005]

Thank you for making your videos simple and clear. Also, for presenting the essence of chinese culture intact (authentic and proper pronunciation, etc)

[@justahighschoolboy4993]

In Hinduism people also wear something similar called bindi

[@leeoungtsh2743]

I love china , Chinese dress and Chinese culture but other Indian they don't like 😭😭😭

[@ifinallyfoundmyjams101]

Man I'm Indian and I love every culture including Chinese culture then why are you saying that Indians don't like this culture? Seems like you aren't Indian so don't say anything when you don't know it😑

[@Turtelik]

I like Huadian story and look the most! Thank you Ally, as always very informative video!

[@keepeatinggreen3807]

Great video love it.looks amazing

[@Mohairp53]

Very informative about the facial decoration. Keep up the good work.

[@MsiReadBooks]

Hey Ally, love your videos. I really enjoy learning all these things as it is hard for me to find Info on them. I was wondering if you could maybe do a video on chinese wedding gowns in history :)

[@mia_ishka]

Yedian is my fave! I think it flatters the mouth!

[@mariaclaradeiana1021]

Thank you, it is so interesting!

[@estherjessica6917]

Hello, I really love this channel, but can you give this caption? English is not my main language 😅

[@FiveThousandYears]

I'm adding it now :)

[@estherjessica6917]

@@FiveThousandYears Thankyou so much! I appreciate that 😊

[@BlackSakura33]

No bindi does not represent a womens marital status!! 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️ That’s sindur.

[@Ruchaaaaaa]

Bindi is for placed for good blood circulation

[@BlackSakura33]

@@Ruchaaaaaa No. What the hell!! It's a part of make up. For asthetic purpose. We wear a bindi for the same reason we wear earrings, to look good. Simple.

[@Ruchaaaaaa]

@@BlackSakura33 bruh no. Look it up

[@BlackSakura33]

@@Ruchaaaaaa look it up!! Are you crazy? 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️ Don't spread such nonsense superstition.

[@Ruchaaaaaa]

@@BlackSakura33 it's science

[@asgaiyawaya3973]

I always assumed it was a borrowed custom from India, but it's interesting how there is an actual history with it. Personally, I always thought it complimented the beauty of the traditional outfit. Sorry somebody is going to have to help me with the chinese name for the outfit. I keep finding Qipao and thinking thats the one with the high collar. I also like the dimples. I agree it does make the girl prettier. It's interesting because the stories remind me of something my mother once told me which is that you can always turn a bad situation into something good and that's what the different stories shows except the first one I thought that story compliments the custom unlike the other two which resulted from accidents.

[@Andi-y8e]

Hanfu is so flawless. I have two hanfu sets!

[@badlittlewolf2606]

I've always just called the huadian a Chinese bindi because it seemed similar

[@NangongReng1973]

Now , people insert plastic all over on their face . So pretty.

[@FiveThousandYears]

That’s so sad isn’t it :/

[@mallyndab]

Wow, so incredible to think that humans have been around for thousands of years and entire civilizations and eras have come and gone. What is that type of dress called?

[@shalinitiwariscorner5210]

4:37 You're wrong. I am an Indian Hindu myself and I am a student of Indian History as well. Bindi doesn't symbolise a woman's marital status. It's just for ornamental and spiritual purpose (as in Yogic traditions, it's believed that forehead is centre of mental concentration). Hence, any woman or girl can put bindi on her forehead. It's Sindoor or Vermilion(red borax powder) which symbolises a woman's marital status.

[@fathimasanayoosaf8688]

You're wrong about bindi. Bindi is also worn for ornamental purpose in India. I think you're talking about sindoor. Sindoor is red safron powder that married women wear on middle of the forehead touching the hairline whereas bindi is worn in the middle of the eyebrows. By the way loved your video. Interesting!

[@advaitaveda5671]

Bindi or bottu isn't ornamental. It has religious and spiritual significance.

[@natureaiaiai880]

very beautiful

[@luckylinda7777]

Plum blossom was my fav.

[@isidoreaerys8745]

Fascinating. Such an important cultural divide to be bridging right now

[@IamMySelf7872]

this kind video should be on trending

[@meerandah2782]

Wow. Your explanation is much clearer and easy to understand. Thank you

[@RameshBhai-yw9el]

Bindi(dot on forehead ) is no symbolises that girl is married. Wearing bindi or tika have many another reasons. You said it wrong. Unmarried or married women both wear bindi.

[@chaitralisonawane61]

Came here after watching videos on Hanfu traditional clothes I love the design on forehead called Huadian 😄

[@ricohinaro5559]

learning things while under quarantine hello 2020

[@recon441]

This was such a fun educational video 😄 I love how these trends started off as happy little accidents of sorts 😆

[@sophroniel]

I grew up with a garden full of ornamental plum trees; for anyone wondering, they look almost the same as cherry blossoms, except the petals are smooth, not ruffled at the ends. Same colour tho

[@JourneyCamera]

so rich culture

[@white_vargr1999]

“Accidentally” hit her ? Mmmh might be my overly feminist side talking but Im questioning that x), that was very informative! Thank you, traditions are always so interesting imo, especially sine my family doesn’t have many

[@morbidmistress5602]

So many online shops that sell Hanfu always give out Huadian tattoos as gifts

[@livia4276]

I've just love this video and your channel

[@ColonelMarcellus]

Americans would, unfortunately, prefer tattoo markings. And not pretty ones, either.

[@onegawilliam2422]

My favourite is huadian and love it's story too.

[@FromChinatoyou]

Super interesting as always!

[@meihwadeclerk3147]

This was very educational and interesting. Thank you so much for adding to my knowledge 🌹

[@kendo-sama9754]

So pretty how it came about

[@starmelodyelizabethb7380]

I love the plum blossom story

[@AngelinaK604]

Ally, thank you so much for making these educational and entertaining videos. It helps me to connect to my culture. Thank you for teaching us, our beautiful long forgotten culture. 🙏❤🥰

[@shermagustave837]

Mulan makeup looked like a lovely cookie painted by a traditional baker.

[@yourmajestysilveroftherats4609]

so pretty!

[@wangkaidi]

Haha just goes to show anything can become a trend if the right person does it...

[@krk6216]

You are so gracious when answering the questions on others curiosities. ❤❤

[@PsychoKat90]

I like the yedian :) very pretty

[@A2ryn]

Can everyone draw huadian on their face ? Amazing video btw

[@αιη-τ5φ]

But the makeup in mulan was I feel purposely made ugly for a reason I didn't think think they used green from eyebrows are all

[@Yue_mariin00]

Your videos are so informative yet so easy to understand!! Thank you so much for all your work ❣️

[@realshawty_exo7022]

So amazing culture

[@Myacckt]

Contouring centuries ago

[@hughdncy]

Bindi is for decoration. But sindoor, worn in the middle of the hairline is resembling women are married.

[@tillycomedy2194]

wow i just discovered your channel and i love that it's all about ancient chinese culture!

[@redpanda6125]

Thank you, that was cristal clear instructive and agreeable !

[@Andromeda2976]

Beautifully told and all the blessings.

[@Lotus_93]

Cchanged my page but still watching you Ally. Its Mika. 😁

[@FiveThousandYears]

Hi Mika 😊

[@MabeEstilismo]

La historia de la peluqueria= desvelandolapeluqueria.blogspot.com/

[@edityourname5598]

I love these. Keep them coming. ❤️

[@tanoymajumder2358]

I loooove Chinese Culture ♥️♥️♥️♥️😄😄😄😄

[@selestyah0310]

My favorite has always been Yedian.

[@MasterWingman]

very interesting

[@raisaislamkuromi]

Thanks I have acnes

[@issamoni3745]

Wow

[@LittleSpaceCase]

Since huadian are ornamental and historical, would it be okay for westerners to wear it?

[@wangqi1387]

How to wear beauty when wearing Han Fu? Hair style accounts for 20%, hair accessories account for 10%, makeup looks for 20%, and classical elegance poses for 20%. Yes, clothing itself only accounts for 30%. That is a whole sense of beauty.

[@kilipaki87oritahiti]

Forehead definitely as I my self has a forehead tattoo. A mot of styles that the western world thinks is middle eastern actually originated in the far east aka China.

[@pondokwarna5955]

Terimakasih.

[@QuizmasterLaw]

我会看看。这部电影好不好？

[@jin8339]

Can you do a video on how and what is used to draw Hua Dian. I try to Google but no information is there. And also how long it takes to do it ? Do you used paint ? Or do you used a pencil ? What brand ? This will be very interesting . Thanks ! 🌺🌸

[@nette9836]

I like the story of the scar. It is interesting to see a culture and time usually hyperfixated on beauty and perfection to instead perceive beauty in flaws. Very fascinating.