Dispelling the myths of homeopathy | Dr. Shantanu Abhyankar | TEDxPICT

Dr. Shantanu Abhyankar unravels the mystery of homeopathy and leaves us with a valuable lesson that should, in reality, be well-known to the common man. Dr. Shantanu Abhyankar is a renowned Obstetrician and a Gynecologist based in Wai, near Mahabaleshwar. A popular orator in medical and lay gatherings alike, he is known for his candid blogs about women’s health issues and his wry humor. He was bestowed the Dr. Anandibai Gaurav Puraskar by the government of Maharashtra in 1997, in view of his contribution to women’s health.
At TEDxPICT, he will be talking about his arduous journey from Homeopathy to his eventual area of expertise as he ponders upon the meaning of rational medicine. This talk was given at a TEDx event using the TED conference format but independently organized by a local community. Learn more at www.ted.com/tedx

[@spuriusscapula4829]

Every child in school needs to be taught statistics and critical thinking.

[@BhaveshKadam-yn6vs]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 Yes. Patanjali Yog Pith is doing that

[@mirzamdzadid9706]

Yes to some extent knowledge of critical thinking is good but human mind have limitations Knowledge have limitations

[@mukundsrinath4249]

I don't understand all the hate the speaker is getting in the comments. He explained that medicine should be prompted by thought and reason and then described some of the inconsistencies of reason in homeopathy. I can not see how this offends any practitioner of homeopathy. If one believes that a particular homeopathic medicine cures a disease all one needs to do is conduct a controlled experiment and publish the results. This would systematically prove the homeopathy dissenters wrong.

[@PravinPatil41]

Mukund Srinath Logic is bound to offend the cult believers.

[@deviantaffinity1626]

It is offensive because it is "attacking" personal systems of belief. There is no proving homeopathy, it requires faith. People don't do good when their faith is shown as false belief.

[@harshitbatra860]

@@PravinPatil41 true

[@lxmzhg]

*Mukund Srinath* "If one believes that a particular homeopathic medicine cures a disease all one needs to do is conduct a controlled experiment and publish the results." Since homeopathy is in the public domain, who's going to pay for any studies??

[@lxmzhg]

*Mukund Srinath* "He... described some of the inconsistencies of reason in homeopathy." Not true. He only demonstrated his own ignorance.

[@radharamandwivedi7609]

I was having skin tags near my eyes and an injury mark on my hand. I took homeopathic medicine and my skin tags really disappeared and the injury marks on my hands too. It took me around 2 months I think. Modern medicine was telling me about costly laser surgery but homeopathic worked. I challenge any of the modern medicine doctors to tell me how did homeopathy work. I even didn't believe in homeopathy at that time and it worked.

[@fariskamal5653]

May God bless u brother, wish u great health.. I suffered from Chronic sinusitis and Allopathy doctors were saying it's due to shape of my nose but xray was normal then they said it's nerve a problem... I was having some serious breathing problems specially during winters I couldn't sleep due to suffocation.. I consulted a good Homeopathy doctor, the medicine he gave was "Sambucus Nigra" and from the very first day I could feel the difference, I continued the treatment for 8 months nd with god's grace I am breathing properly for over 5 years now.

[@pallavi-nu6ow]

@@crispindry2815 pray to any god you want , what is stored for your future will happen to you so stop making fun of others and try to focus more on your life

[@nitish.anand99]

Okay clearly there is a big divide between the people who don't believe in homeopathy and the people who have seen the affects of Homeopathy. Coming from a family where homeopathy is the primary way of treatment of many health problems, I can say the effect of taking the medicine and getting healthy is something I have seen and experienced first hand, but the scientific evidence does provide a very strong possibility for something else is at play rather than the medicinal components itself. This could be the power placebo, the same thing that keeps one's faith in god. And it is one very valid way of getting healthy, however if it is ethical in nature is another question that needs to be answered.

[@radharamandwivedi7609]

@NEVIN THOMAS can you explain how placebo effect can cure skin tags. As far as I have read on Wikipedia it is helpful in pain related diseases.

[@peaceofmind9207]

Yeah its work❤

[@nileshlifesciences9601]

Every pathy is complete at is own, but homeopathy is quite advanced, as it treats the route cause, and give complete health. I have experienced personally. I have got complete releaf from asthama and back ache by taking medicines of homeopathy. Practicing homeopathy is not a joke. Hats off to all homeopathy Doctors

[@simstar6557]

It doesn't know what any root cause is. It thinks diseases are caused by miasma.

[@emmanaturopathandbirthprof1506]

@@simstar6557 actually you totally misunderstood. Homoeopaths don't believe diseases are caused by miasm. A little bit of information can be dangerous. Perhaps read a full text book on miasms so you understand what it means before commenting! Dr Kasim Chimthanawala has a textbook of miasms. Read that and then you can make an educated comment.

[@andrewwigglesworth3030]

@@simstar6557 And treated with water.

[@jahirulahmed3965]

I sustained injury in my thumb nail and it was very painful. Consulted a number of orthopedics...did a lot of tests including CT scan...took all medicines and injections as prescribed by the orthopedics from time to time but the pain never subsided. At last a friend suggested me to consult a homeopathic doctor who gave me some homeo pills. I took the pills for only seven days and my finger pain had gone away completely and till date there is no pain in my finger. I also did not believe in homeopathy...but I experienced the result and thus just sharing my experience... .

[@mytop10manhwa40]

I understand that. It's probably placebo. You can't ignore the good aspects of homeopathy but it is simply unscientific

[@jahirulahmed3965]

@@mytop10manhwa40 i I have seen a number of children getting cured of their ailments after homeopathic treatment.. Is it plecebo effect ? Does placibo apply to children also ?

[@abhinqv3490]

@@jahirulahmed3965 Placebo is more useful in children since they believe anything

[@jahirulahmed3965]

@@abhinqv3490 Babies??

[@recepie-house]

@@jahirulahmed3965 assalamualaikum which homeopathy doctor you visited?

[@caunteya]

In 2017 NHS England said it would no longer fund homeopathy on the NHS as the lack of any evidence for its effectiveness did not justify the cost. This was backed by a High Court judgement in 2018.

[@TheKingBeyondEverything]

England did a very a good job 😎.

[@TheKingBeyondEverything]

@@SKhandleYT So, you're trying to say that Homeopathic medicines are so spiritually and physically good for you and at a very reasonable price that they might ruin the Allopathic Frauds who are running Multi-Billion Industries. So, government shut them down as Those Frauds bribed Government to do so. Is that what you wanna say?

[@ObaidahNaseer]

Thank God

[@vishnupatil654]

😂

[@EdwinTyler]

Great job, no evidence, no funding.

[@blondesense1708]

It would be great if TEDx Talks had captions available on their videos. With 21m subscribers & their dedication to sharing the spoken word, it would totally be worth it. Sometimes I want to clarify a long or technical word I’ve never heard.

[@jasonbolding3481]

Especially with the mic feedback

[@blondesense1708]

Jason Bolding YES

[@EdwinTyler]

I'll translate for you, homeopathy doesn't work.

[@yourvision7033]

Its truth..... Brother the This doctor has very poor knowledge about modern science.... Homoeopathy is the scientific Knowledge about "Quantum Physics" Homoeopathy potency 30c or 200c is depend upon Quantum physics. To know homoeopathy you have know about Quantum physics... About molecules about homoeopathy medicine

[@monsieur2761]

@@yourvision7033 woo woo

[@Wisephoton]

Thank you Dr. Shantanu Abyyankar for doing this and explaining this and putting trust back into scientific reasoning. As a student of science myself it is difficult being Indian at the same time LOL!.

[@passionatebeast24]

Yes you are misguided my friend. Do your own research specially on health before coming to any conclusion.

[@Wisephoton]

Hello @@passionatebeast24 , I am intrigued by your statement. It sounds to me you have done your research. If so, can you show me evidence of homeopathic medicine having proven itself to cure or heal a cohort of patients.

[@mariamtee]

My brother was advised surgery for tonsillitis by at least two allopathic as a 6 year old after seeing much sickness due to it. He underwent Homeo treatment and was cured in a month or two. He is 36 now and never had an issue with his tonsils or ENT again. On the contrary people who underwent the surgery went on to have many complications.

[@simstar6557]

Mild Tonsilitis does not need treatment. It's simple to take them out, but they may just get better in many cases if you wait. Homeopathy is a placebo. It has no effect on tonsils. The part that has effect is the 2 month wait.

[@mariamtee]

@@simstar6557 ok but then but my cousins vitiligo not only stopped spreading but also reversed. I can show you pictures to prove it. A couple other cousins had it who were similarly dismissive of Homeo and it got progressively worse ti the point that the whole of their faces, necks and a large part of their bodies have completely turned white.

[@simstar6557]

@@mariamtee probably not vitiligo then. What do you think will happen if I give 50 vitiligo patients to your homeopath? How many do you think he will cure?

[@simstar6557]

@@mariamtee if you can get international dermatologists to agree that homeopathy cures vitiligo, then all criticism against it will end. It just needs to cure 1 disease. And it has to prove it without just stories, but through real clinical tests. I think the chance of that proof is 0%.

[@mariamtee]

@@simstar6557 well keep doubting. Your loss entirely

[@jeswanthdoppalapudi2722]

Man,people hate to know the truth if it contradicts their views.

[@aravindk7101]

Confirmation bias

[@mohamed-2711]

People are generally lazy.

[@shashanksharma6881]

Dude I'm taking this😄

[@vijimandya]

@Malda motoblogger sam very well said

[@vijimandya]

@Malda motoblogger sam I belong to india .....and I am able to get government seat in homeopathy college .....so I was a quiet curious about homeopathy ........what is your views on it???? Is it a good choice???

[@jsm33t]

I love how the retaliations are aggressive but still with no evidence.

[@samarthabarwal9759]

I am assuming you are an Allopathic doctor, So as a doctor can you please tell that in Diabetes Mellitus ( caused by Insulin deficiency/ Sensitivity) why does our body becomes Insulin deficient or loose sensitivity? Clearly if you have studied properly you would know that there is no evidence as to why our body does that. So does that mean that this lack of evidence would disregard the fact that In Diabetes our beta cells stop producing insulin.Similarly, lack of evidence as to how Homeopathy actually works, doesn’t mean it doesn’t Work. People have just not yet found out how it works. Instead of being a Homeopath/ allopath Doctor, Be a Doctor first. Work for Human Health and science.Critically think, not just digest what you are being taught in textbooks.

[@MichelleObamasBBC]

@@samarthabarwal9759 allopathy is an extinct system of medicine. modern medicine is the correct term. modern medicine is an evidence based approach unlike allopathy which was also nonsensical in the 1700s. How modern medicine works is, if an ayurvedic treatment is found to work, it will find out what makes the treatment work, isolate that compound and turn it into a pharmaceutical drug. This is just one example. Homeopathy does not work, because the logic itself is flawed. By homeopathy logic, a single drop of ocean water added to a massive reservoir of freshwater will turn the entire reservoir into a magical panacea, a cure for everything. Think about it, the ocean has a trace of every single element and compound to ever exist, and it is always being mixed around. Use your brain, my man. Don't go around proving why India has an average IQ of 85, and don't give the name Samarth a bad rep. Regards, your namesake.

[@dr.mayurmahajan1436]

Guys we cannot prevent the sun from shining in the sky...

[@dhananjayahire3092]

🤩👍 correct

[@leenasuryawanshi6473]

True

[@kunalwagh3916]

Very true sir

[@lakharamdewasi1421]

Sir I accept your thoughts

[@dr.archanaraut9514]

Truth

[@ultraali453]

Even in the end, he did not try to end his talk with a punchline. But rather a rational statement. Very nicely done ✅

[@dr.j3685]

Rip doc u will always be remembered 🤍

[@mathewthomas7616]

I've been using Allopathy for years but recently started using homeopathy for my 9 months old. Their medicine for constipation works great for my little one. If it's only water it's great, we will keep using it..:)

[@gurucomrade]

Wow.. you keep poop as the measurement of your faith. bravo

[@aswithasrinivasan4955]

Brilliant!!!

[@aswithasrinivasan4955]

@@gurucomrade if ur poop doesn't spill out properly maybe u would try measure ur faith with that too...😂

[@mathewthomas7616]

@@subrahamanyashetty5964 I can assure you that the 3 drops of water didn't make any difference.

[@WaddiaS]

good for you if it's not more expensive than regular water

[@sanjayjadhav1350]

This is "Antagonism with himself".... U r saying "we do not despise or criticize alternative systems"...And u have spent ur valuable 18 min just to criticize and despise alternative systems. The more homoeopathy is criticized, more popular it's being.... Thank you sir for helping us to be popular 👍

[@komalsharma5349]

True..

[@adsidbob]

Sir he has one more rubric... Loss of identity..

[@hunarunnat]

Homeopathy is flourishing ( because it works wonderfully when practiced rightly) so such type of insecurity is obvious. So don't worry guys, it's our victory.

[@binodtharu7157]

@@hunarunnat Homeopathy is not medicine it's a hoax

[@Rizwan_moba]

Biggest hoax in world = homeopathy 🤣

[@good123g]

Why can't homoeopathic medicines be put through the same tests like allopathy medicines?

[@swapnilkulkarni2979]

Clinically test also done by homeopathy check research papers

[@good123g]

@@swapnilkulkarni2979 Link please

[@sidarthurgortimer355]

They are put through those same tests. They fail them every time, it is always shown that they are no more effective than a sugar pill.

[@simstar6557]

@@swapnilkulkarni2979 Patil is a failed doctor who took to quackery.

[@simstar6557]

They were. They failed. 1800 of them. Not one worked.

[@chetanchaudhari293]

"Allopathy, "the Name itself is given by Dr Samuel Hahnemann, The Father of HOMOEOPATHY.

[@simstar6557]

Yes, and allopathy doesn't exist. Neither does any medicine in Homeopathy.

[@spuriusscapula4829]

2:33 chintu

[@randomvideo2389]

@@simstar6557 😂😂 problem is that your jealous that homeopathy cures with cheap. And your scamming doctor just loot and kill.

[@RishavBera]

4:50 we don't use the term allopathy anymore😂

[@upam24]

As a non doctor I really don't know the in and out of medical science. But it was once that allopathy made me put in such deep grave, I lost my all fear and hope of living. I was on allopathy medicine for 1 month. I was in Delhi then, and had visited 3 major big hospitals for this. But nothing at all worked. I had more than 20 blood tests, sonography and what not. Last left was MMR and brain scanning. It was then that my sister said let's see if homeopathy works. And yes, it did worked and I was all okay within just 3 days. I cannot express how much I owe my life to the homeopathy doctor. This is my experience.

[@pbd5417]

IIT Bombay reasearch on nanoparticles of homeopathy is proof , it works this fellow is misleading every body

[@upam24]

@@pbd5417 thank you for your information

[@pbd5417]

@@upam24 Thanks , Homeopathy works, I also failed cure from Nephrologist for 3 years and was cured by homeopathy in 6months , Homeopathy works very well if Doctor takes the case analysis properly and identify the proper medicine . Matter is not made out of matter, but energy. Matter can be converted in to energy, energy can be converted in to matter is a theory of aduality given by Nobel laureate Hans Peter Duerr. Body tries to rebuilt each time, when it oscillate between energy and particles. ... Inside and outside of our body consists of energy.

[@upam24]

@@pbd5417 so beautiful explanation. Thank you once again. Yes, you are absolutely correct that analysis matters the most.

[@simstar6557]

Its not nano medicine. The colleagues of that silly prof don't believe that junk research. They wrote this. A Homeopathic Defence Against COVID-19 Is No Defence at All 14/06/2020 ANURAG MEHRA, SUPREET SAINI AND MAHESH TIRUMKUDULU

[@mansiindic1501]

But truth is my friend whom every aloepathic doc asked for surgery for fall stone, it was desolved by using homeopathic without going for surgery

[@mansiindic1501]

@@boomerang0101 typo error.. It's gall stone

[@akshaykhatri1531]

Both of yall need to go back to school immediately

[@mansiindic1501]

@@akshaykhatri1531 ur comment shows who needs that. This is a forum where we r talking about our own experience. Damn what an upbringing ...jaahil

[@akshaykhatri1531]

@@mansiindic1501 yep calling a stranger on the internet 'jaahil' whom you have never met explains a lot about your upbringing right? I thought school would be helpful to bring the missing knowledge but I think you are missing common sense to understand what exactly is homeopathy and modern medicine Sorry can't help with that

[@mansiindic1501]

@@akshaykhatri1531 u started ur moral lecturing out of the blue. I did not invite u. Who r u even asking me to go back to school without even knowing mh qualifications ? Shows ur culture and upbringing.. Jahil to teh power infinity

[@mediamiracles-Bharat]

In India there is a saying -" angur khatte hain" , it's mean if you could not get the things; Just blame that it's worthless!. The same is here, the presenter in the video first did Homeopathy to be a doctor and to earn a lot of money out of it but unfortunately in Homeopathy there is little scope to get commission from Pharma companies and pathology labs....etc. as it's available in allopathy medicine system, so he studied again to become an allopathy doctor and to become millionaire. You cannot condem other treatment systems without having proper knowledge and proofs against it.

[@souravmaity8599]

Sahi ha

[@akhileshpatro8707]

Exactly

[@anuanubha2695]

V True..

[@amey409]

Just look at dislikes. People can't digest the truth. Excellent talk, doctor.

[@Orneyrocks1609]

The level of delusion here is amazing.

[@Maolana_ModiG]

People disliked becoz of wrong title or u can say for click bait

[@boonniki]

Homoeopathy is no more alternative but a complimentary mode of treatment Far better than Alloathy as per NHS survey ...

[@musikallyshayara4910]

It is more important to have knowledge about the disease and the effects of medicine, every doctor must know the limitations and effects of his system,also referring the patients on time is equally important I've seen mbbs and bhms doctors who refer the patient according to need of the patient's ailment either PCOS, stones or other systemic illness ,they refer the patients, without any ego homeopaths refer if surgery is important, similarly allopaths refer patients to homeopaths. Coexistence ❤

[@naeemshaikh6419]

In emergency allopathy works best but in chronic disease allopathy sucks, patient die with side effects of long term allopathic medicine.

[@simstar6557]

In the long term, we all die. Modern medicine adds 20 years or more in chronic diseases. If a person takes homeopathy for diabetes and does not follow diet advice of modern medicine, they will go blind, have ulcers on foot which get infected, kidneys will fail and they die much earlier. That's because Homeopathy is totally fake.

[@Rigvedification]

Any better alternative?

[@anupampaul02]

I suggest u must try homeopathy once then u ll understand..😊​@@Rigvedification

[@mahadevtandel1132]

First of all every pathy has its own pros and cons. Perticulary we are not against allopathy or so called modern medicine. In this video dr abhyankar said he was ex student of homeopathy stream ,the major difference between our master and him is that our master converted to homoeopathy from allopathy and dr abhyankar was failure to understand homeopathy and converted into so called modern medicine. As per his explanation converted to gynecologist after difficult to understand homeopathic concept so it was his failure to understand homoeopathy,remember pathy never fails its person who does not understand concept he fails. And moreover he had never practice homoeopathy so its just theoretical knowledge which he had which is completely different than clinical practice. Few points he has mentioned about homoeopathic drug action which are completely wrong about avagadro number recently homoeopathic drugs have been detected micronanno particles at IIT Powai lab. He has complaining about action of the homoeopathic drugs so just take one example of nitroglycerin which frequently used in icu for management of hypertension and same used in larger quantity in rdx which is explosive in nature used for blast by terrorist. At the end major difference between homoeopathy and so called modern medicine is our drugs are proved exclusively on healthy human beings not on guinea pigs. At the end i think dr abhyankar need to rethink on his thoughts or stop blaming homeopathy. From this incident our homoeopathic colleges should start making research oriented study so that overall growth of the homoeopathy could be achieved.

[@gallakochar4245]

👍🏻Agree.. He failed to understand Science of Homeopathy.

[@andrewwigglesworth3030]

@@gallakochar4245 "Science of Homeopathy" ... we have a comedian here.

[@immanuelthetruth2417]

My grandmother got some stress and anxiety issue and i take her to a allopathic dr neurologist and he prescribed medication Only for three weeks maximum or five weeks she feels better but after that she get worse than before her anxiety increase more and more Two years of allopathic medicine no changes but now i stopped giving her allopathy medicine now she feels better . Please share your thoughts on this guys 🙏❤️

[@fp1912]

Exercise is one of the best things you can do for anxiety! Exercise releases endorphins that have been proven to increase mental health! It relieves stress. Maybe take walks with her? Or chair aerobics? There are lots of videos here in YT for chair exercises she can do. Dancing could be fun if she enjoys that. Anything that gets her moving and her heart rate up!

[@Srssingh64531]

In homoeopathy we study that allopathic medicines give temporary relief and after some period the disease will return in a more powerful way than before or it will take some other serious form.But in emergency cases where you have no time, only saving patients life is priority then Allopathic medicines should be used and as the condition of patient gets better ,he or she must go for homoeopathy for complete cure .

[@immanuelthetruth2417]

@@Srssingh64531 yes homeopathy is much better than allopathic medicine but for emergency situation allopathic medicine helps

[@prasenjittripura4691]

Most of the dislikes came from homeopathy practitioner

[@shivaprasadyajaman976]

shouldn't reply without second thought. Please understand there are countless things happen which can be measured or proven scientifically and they are beyond what is called science or medical science that is what nature's healing. For instance high blood can be reversal to be normal without any sort of medicine,it is proven in my case with the help of raw vegetables come from this nature but the patients are proscribed for Western medicine.the people get feared by the doctors that they may die when medicine is not taken. This is really hoaxes. The man should try to think comprehensively and then he can search for the truth when controversy is rosen. Western medicine is culprit, one problem might seemingly solved but we don't know the other life threatening problems would emerge in our body becoming big health issues to make a way to death as soon as possible. Please read the book "biology of belief"

[@binodtharu7157]

@@shivaprasadyajaman976 That's not how science works

[@sowrabhsudevan6636]

@@shivaprasadyajaman976 homeopathy is also western. Not sure why there is so much loyalty for it in India.

[@simstar6557]

@@tausif-gaming047 medical science is based on evidence, not theories. Only quack medicine is based on theories, and disproved ones at that.

[@DrAdityaReddy]

@@shivaprasadyajaman976 vegetables aren't homeopathy.

[@conisalgado1294]

But there are pubmed studies that show how over half of women on homeopathy reduced pcos and got rid of cysts in ovaries

[@kushagragarg4251]

The major drawback against those articles you are talking about is that every article related to these medicines have very small patient count. Modern medicine undergoes double blind randomised case control clinical trials. And they undergo robust testing. Whereas all these homeopathic studies are suspicious because they lack the testing base. If you get it good. Otherwise not my duty to educate.😊

[@terminator-pf2so]

have u noticed homeopathy only works on problems which go by themselves

[@Fozias25-AI]

Sir ,I appreciate your thoughts on the difference of allopathy n homeopath ,,,but can u plz answer 1 of my question ..I was tired to get treated myself for last 6 month for irregular and heavy menses monthly bleeding ..I got treated myself by allopathy and had gone thru many test and ultrasound..I was prescribed OCP ,which worsen my situation ..after 6 months with no improvement in my condition they said I have fiberoids and have to go thru a surgical procedure ..which again will not give any assurance of not have further complication. I was tired and 1 of my friend suggest me for homeopathy .just by 3 days dosage of homeapathy ..I found relieve in my symtoms with only those small pills ..while by those many daily tablet of harmone pills I dint find ny relieve..This is practical ..I felt it how I can say that it is not effective...like me..I'm sure there must be many..so plz don't downgrade homeopathy..it works actually even in my case where allopathy made my symtoms worse

[@simstar6557]

You just dont know the difference between anecdote and evidence. I guess science is not taught well in your schools?

[@thundergaming9516]

@@simstar6557 then why are you here !...

[@simstar6557]

@@thundergaming9516 to teach you.

[@yourvision7033]

Its truth.....Homoeopathy is more scientific.....🙏😠This doctor has very poor knowledge about modern science.... Homoeopathy is the scientific Knowledge about "Quantum Physics" Homoeopathy potency 30c or 200c is depend upon Quantum physics. To know homoeopathy you have know about Quantum physics... About molecules about homoeopathy medicine

[@darpanagarwal6183]

I agree. It works well in almost all problems.

[@photographyjourneywithpriy4612]

I had a tooth problem two years ago went to the dentist there he suggested for root canal and other which cost few thousands rupees meanwhile he gave few thousands Rs Antibiotics but those haven't worked and cured me . Later, I consulted with my homeopathy dr where he gave me few homeopathy medicine of some hundred Rs which cured my tooth problem without any further problem.

[@yourvision7033]

Its truth..... Brother the This doctor has very poor knowledge about modern science.... Homoeopathy is the scientific Knowledge about "Quantum Physics" Homoeopathy potency 30c or 200c is depend upon Quantum physics.

[@beachcoffee9]

what remedy?

[@dr.harshdeshmukh2452]

Yes , because who is talking about Homoeopathy, is not understand Homoeopathy , and give admission to MBBS lol. He even know the name of Homoeopathic Medicine name called Natrum Mur not Natrum mul 😂.

[@Bekind9585]

Apologies for my comment... I came across this video while I was searching something else. . I won't comment anything about the doctor, as I myself am a Homoeopath and I respect every doctor who has learnt this science and who is serving the humanity today. The number of dislikes for this video says it all- "DEFINITELY NOT AN IDEA WORTH SPREADING" :D Just one request to the audience - Don't be so quick to believe what you hear and to all the Homoeopaths- Be loyal to your profession and keep up the good work and never waste time to defame anyone. TEDx we expect better content from your channel please :)

[@simstar6557]

Y'all just quacks. You are not helping, just making money. “The principles of homeopathy contradict known chemical, physical and biological laws and persuasive scientific trials proving its effectiveness are not available” Russian Academy of Sciences, Russia “Homeopathy should not be used to treat health conditions that are chronic, serious, or could become serious. People who choose homeopathy may put their health at risk if they reject or delay treatments for which there is good evidence for safety and effectiveness.” National Health and Medical Research Council, Australia “These products are not supported by scientific evidence.” Health Canada, Canada “Homeopathic remedies don’t meet the criteria of evidence based medicine.” Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Hungary “The incorporation of anthroposophical and homeopathic products in the Swedish directive on medicinal products would run counter to several of the fundamental principles regarding medicinal products and evidence-based medicine.” Swedish Academy of Sciences, Sweden “We recommend parents and caregivers not give homeopathic teething tablets and gels to children and seek advice from their health care professional for safe alternatives.” Food and Drug Administration, USA “There is little evidence to support homeopathy as an effective treatment for any specific condition” National Centre for Complementary and Integrative Health, USA “There is no good-quality evidence that homeopathy is effective as a treatment for any health condition” National Health Service, UK “Homeopathic remedies perform no better than placebos, and that the principles on which homeopathy is based are “scientifically implausible”” House of Commons Science and Technology Committee, UK

[@Bekind9585]

@Sim Star Respected Sir/Madam, Firstly, don't hide yourself behind some mysterious name 😅 And secondly, I have gone through your uncivil comments and after that I don't intend to argue or even discuss with you anything. Best wishes to you 😌 👍

[@simstar6557]

@@Bekind9585 it is hard to be civil to scammers.

[@simstar6557]

@@Bekind9585 and this isn't uncivil. It's science. “The principles of homeopathy contradict known chemical, physical and biological laws and persuasive scientific trials proving its effectiveness are not available” Russian Academy of Sciences, Russia “Homeopathy should not be used to treat health conditions that are chronic, serious, or could become serious. People who choose homeopathy may put their health at risk if they reject or delay treatments for which there is good evidence for safety and effectiveness.” National Health and Medical Research Council, Australia “These products are not supported by scientific evidence.” Health Canada, Canada “Homeopathic remedies don’t meet the criteria of evidence based medicine.” Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Hungary “The incorporation of anthroposophical and homeopathic products in the Swedish directive on medicinal products would run counter to several of the fundamental principles regarding medicinal products and evidence-based medicine.” Swedish Academy of Sciences, Sweden “We recommend parents and caregivers not give homeopathic teething tablets and gels to children and seek advice from their health care professional for safe alternatives.” Food and Drug Administration, USA “There is little evidence to support homeopathy as an effective treatment for any specific condition” National Centre for Complementary and Integrative Health, USA “There is no good-quality evidence that homeopathy is effective as a treatment for any health condition” National Health Service, UK “Homeopathic remedies perform no better than placebos, and that the principles on which homeopathy is based are “scientifically implausible”” House of Commons Science and Technology Committee, UK

[@pbd5417]

IIT Bombay reasearch on nanoparticles of homeopathy is proof that Homeopathy has medicine value in it

[@sabinoluevano7447]

in Mexico you need to be a doctor to prescribe homeopathic medicine. And it works well for minor things. It worked with me for my allergies, it worked with my mom for her intestinal problems, and now is doing its magic with my girlfriend's horrible menstrual pain.

[@simstar6557]

Homeopathy does not work. Never worked in studies. If it worked, it means they are marketing stuff as homeopathy.

[@hardikparmar7423]

I am not qualified to comment on this as I am not from medical field but still even if believe whatever you said is true... Than also I have seen and still hearing about allopathy practitioners having years of experience leaving their career in allopathy and choosing homeopathy as their new career... Strange! Isn't it...

[@almightyalmighty2689]

homeopathic medicines has so much side effects..if given in wrong way..it can spoil one person life..even can make him handicapped...and many more issues..which you cannot even imagine..jo mujh par beet rahe hai..am saying on that experince..my doctor has given me wrong med..in his greed and anger.Dr Ashok thapa of west delhi vikaspuri/hari nagar..he spoil my life...he is not following homeopathic rules...he is dangerous for his patients.he should be in prison..beware of this kind of doctors.

[@nielsbohrsciencewale9771]

To survive in allopathy you have to constantly change yourself with new findings and get yourself better , but homeopathy you sit back relax take your money as material was written 200 years ago, nothing to worry , which is wrong

[@bloodbrs4773]

My father and mother(retired government employee) are both homeopathy doctors. My father is well known in our city because of his treatment of pox patients and babies with various medical issues.

[@ScienceSimplifiedAcademy]

Do you believe in it then?

[@atulbhute8573]

Hope your parents dont a patient of malignancy, malaria or tuberculosis

[@Huundeblogg]

You should not "believe in it" but rather witness a cure.

[@megastarchandan3580]

Ok atleast u don't use it

[@adithyapolavarapu160]

humans believe in myths, Trust science. Yes they are different .

[@santoshsaini7930]

Doctor, allopathic doctor as you introduced yourself, you have no right to say anything about homeopathy. You had no capability to study and learnt about homeopathy. Homeopathy has it's own principles and they work very well. I proudly say I am a homeopath.

[@Tubemax68]

No, no they don't. Has never been proven in any of the hundreds of tests that have been done. And of course they always come up with excuse, and so will you.

[@sumir1701]

You didn't get enough marks in aipmt to get mbbs right? It hurts right?😂😂😂

[@pallavi-nu6ow]

@@sumir1701 ahh yesss after failling for 3 toh 4 years even in sone cases 6 to 7 years also then the students get chance toh get into mbbs . what brilliianttt students and doctors of india . 😂 there is nothing to be proud of getting a seat after failling for 6 to 7 years . and dont forget there are caste based reservations also in india. and just because of the money many opt for mbbs .

[@simstar6557]

@@pallavi-nu6ow you mean that does not happen in Homeopathy? No reservations? No failure allowed? Or everyone just passes because the hard subjects only need superficial understanding in BHMS?

[@simstar6557]

@@pallavi-nu6ow what percent of students reject MBBS and choose BHMS instead? 0%?

[@healthyminds77]

As allopathy became popular, diseases also increased and quality of life declined. Simple and live logic to understand credit of allopathy.

[@Pain53924]

Well its modern medicine now not allopathy. Homeopathy is a pseudoscience. Deal with it.

[@anandrao95]

Core principle of homeopathy is to break the molecule by diluting the sustance. This is the system being follwed.

[@shobhitbansal1504]

And death to chemistry 😂.

[@ravenhart4387]

Diluting something just reduces the number of molecules per unit volume, it does absolutely nothing to the molecule itself

[@ZaidKhan-su3ey]

@@shobhitbansal1504 many people died by your western chemistry and homeopathy saved lives

[@shobhitbansal1504]

@@ZaidKhan-su3ey homeopathy is fake Western medicine created by a quack. Read up the history properly.

[@ZaidKhan-su3ey]

@@shobhitbansal1504 then what about those who got cured by homeopathy? 🤣🤣

[@roopaliwaidande5863]

I'm really sorry to say Dr shantanu.... You haven't studied well.... So you took the easy way of prescribing an antibiotic a pain killer an antacid and a multivitamin for any and everything that comes to you.... All the best... God bless you

[@nelhed3587]

Homeopathy is fraud

[@shrinath3287]

Feeling sorry for your lack of understanding of the organon!

[@jasonbolding3481]

What did he say that was false?

[@girishmayannavar7049]

Are Sab,BHMS ache se padkar homoeopathy samaj Gaye hote to MBBS karne ki naubat nahi ATI...very sad

[@binodtharu7157]

HOMEOPATHY IS FRAUD

[@perpendicular5691]

@@binodtharu7157 The father of homeopathy Dr Hahnemann is not a fraud , your father is fraud .

[@vamthekam]

@@perpendicular5691 Your response validates the fact that Hahnemann peddled BS more than any scientific rebuttal ever could. Ad hominem attacks are the only recourse for the likes of you...not real science

[@dr.harshdeshmukh2452]

You nailed it 😂😂😂 brother

[@Shaivaite_buddhist]

@@binodtharu7157 homoeopathy founder dr hahnemann itself was a German allopathic doctor then how homoeopathy is fraud?????

[@drreemabhuptani9033]

Homoeopathy today is curing so many patients who are diagnosed having auto immune diseases ..there are some MD Drs who started practising as a Homoeopath after experiencing this system ..some of them treating cancer successfully.

[@menakamanickaraj]

Evidence please. When we ask for evidence.. we mean a double blinded randomised trial. Nothing else.

[@jonas4120]

Homoeopathi is usually given with normal medicine

[@menakamanickaraj]

Hello..anybody there?

[@gaurab197]

Can you let us know the market share of homoeopathy as compared to modern medicine?

[@bengrizzlyadams6187]

@@menakamanickaraj You mean like they should do for vaccines but don't?

[@WorldofHomoeopath]

Sir, u can't be disrespect of homoeopathy or any other pathy . Every pathy is important in their own perspective and situation. Homoeopathy is based on some cardinal principles but in modern medicine, it have no principles so u can't be called as alternative medicine , it is purely scientific , today's scenario, most of cases , which are incurable in modern medicine are cure by others pathy mainy homoeopathy,ex- autoimmune disorder (coeliac disease,DSD) . Sir , please gather information from right source & not disrespect of other pathy.

[@timepass-hb5rq]

Tq fr taking the name of our founder sir....Dr.Samuel Hahnemann♥️✌️ yet he was an allopathic practitioner...though ...we believe in the thoughts which r written by him,not by just seeing them...but by experience which led him to write🔥🔥🔥🇮🇳

[@Madara-zt8pn]

🍑🔥

[@justamedicalstudent2549]

👍👍👍👍😊😊 😊❤️❤️❤️

[@simstar6557]

@@justamedicalstudent2549 medical student? You mean like in a real medical school or a quack altie school? What did they teach you about miasma and it's history?

[@dushyantdas2749]

@@simstar6557 why are you even bother you are not even close to medical school 😂

[@simstar6557]

@@dushyantdas2749 oh look, another student in a quack school who thinks he is becoming a "doctor" 😂🙉😂.

[@atulrocks4eversever]

i was of the same notion. but believe it or not I was able to beat gastrointestinal and mental issues from homeopathy. i was subject to fluoxetine fluvoxamine and many other tri cyclic antidepressants and gaba inhibitors, homeopathy actually helped, I'm much better now. you'll believe what you want to believe 👍🏻

[@akhileshtarge4880]

Could you please tell what medication and dosages you were on ?? I too have the same problems. Please reply

[@atulrocks4eversever]

@@akhileshtarge4880 allopathy or homeopathy??

[@akhileshtarge4880]

@@atulrocks4eversever homeopathy

[@atulrocks4eversever]

@@akhileshtarge4880 telegram?

[@simstar6557]

@@atulrocks4eversever you can say it here.

[@emmanaturopathandbirthprof1506]

Homoeopathy is the greatest gift to mankind.

[@emmanaturopathandbirthprof1506]

There is a homoeopathic obstetrician Ricardo Jones doing a talk at IIMCHO maternity conference in New Zealand early 2020. There are homoeopathic obstetrician in India Dr Sagira and Fatema Chimthanawala

[@chinkara2140]

Hahaha you are so funny😂😂😂

[@sadiaakhter6797]

Lol

[@LuciferNingishzida]

I'm about to be pro

[@LuciferNingishzida]

That's odd lol. I was the 33rd individual to 'smash the like button' on this Komment. Wanna hear something else strange? I'm 33

[@viveakin]

Keep up the advocacy Doctor! Evidence-based medicine should be aggressively pushed up and communicated!

[@waltermcfarland7060]

See 10 points above on the reliability of your so called evidence-based approach

[@Madara-zt8pn]

@@waltermcfarland7060 Promise you'll never use allopathic medicines and never consult allopathic doctor.

[@nielsbohrsciencewale9771]

Lol coming from someone who follows holy books with few diseases homeopaths are crazy, because allopathy does changes that's why it is correct

[@EdwinTyler]

@@waltermcfarland7060 the fact you see evidence as something wrong shows something is really wrong with you.

[@mert78dome]

"aggressively pushed". Just like fundamentalists push Islam and Christianity down peoples throats. Truth prevails without needing to be pushed. People will gravitate to that which works. Let the people decide...

[@shivaprasaddesai2805]

DR. Abhyankar"s approach is truly scientific and rational . With due respect to him i appeal he may please pay attention to facts about allopathy revealed by DR. B. M. Hegde who is basically an allopathy doctor

[@manjulah7220]

I don't know much about medical but have basic knowledge as a Science student but I wanted to know how pregnancy is achieved by homeopathy medicine when allopathy doctor said to go for IVF and even said people can't get pregnant they've got babies without any IVF or any sort of surgeries, I am just curious to know.

[@ayush2sachan275]

Read reproduction chapter from class 8th ncert

[@akshaykhatri1531]

@@ayush2sachan275 good reply... Haha People don't know medical science are acceptable But not having common sense is just not acceptable People who believe in homeopathy are the people who believe earth is flat Just absurd beyond imagination

[@penny5011]

Placebo placebo placebo.. placebo effect can create magic!

[@ayush2sachan275]

@@penny5011 OK cure cancer with it then?

[@yado7550]

Just like how people who are told they'll never walk again sometimes make a full recovery. If they took homeopathics and recovered the homeopath would attribute that to their medicine but it doesn't mean the homeopathics is actually what led to recovery

[@ultraali453]

I like that his criticism doesn't seem to include ego. He even gave credit where credit was due (pointing out modern medical practices that were derived from traditional medicine).

[@SKhandleYT]

Well what he's saying has tremendous merit. But just to segregate your point ==> His whole speech is based on his personal ego coming from he studying homeopath (didn't score well enough but wanted to be medical practitioner) and then modern medicine finally after that hard reworking to get there. There's a prevalent strong prejudice here already. Anyway the analogies are far from drawing a parallel -- comparing alcohol treated meds with water dilution in paints to get desired colour? PS for the oversmart yet undergrown/underdeveloped (read it as under-evolved): I'm not a supporter of homeopathy or any pathy for that matter. I very well understand the principal and phenomena of homeostasis though

[@N0Xa880iUL]

​@@SKhandleYTThen what exactly is you point?

[@deepakrd7684]

Yes dude he gave credits ...Otherwise he will be banned from India. He is been funded to have such talks. Hope he is aware that Most of his surgery cases are well treated by Homoeopathic Doctors around him there and thus saved many families from getting bankrupt..

[@Drkiranburada]

Nothing like that it is complete ignorance and a fear and wanting to be correct by leaving homoeopathy.. He didn't understand his former profession well because in today's time when homoeopathy in way ahead in managing cases like cancer and every other critical disease allopaths don't talk in such a way anymore

[@shre_yaa__]

@@deepakrd7684 🙌

[@shilpar3656]

Ok what would you say about decrease in the size of goiter? By Homeopathic medicines? What about cysts being completely cured? What about renal calculi and gall stones completely cured? How about prostatomegaly ? I am a homoeopathic doctor and I have completely cured these cases not one or two many! As a practitioner I can say there are side effects of homoeopathic medicines infact if not administered properly then definitely severe adverse effects! Yes I agree homoeopathy needs modernization by accepting certain things but doesn't mean you critize a system completely just because you don't understand it!

[@laypyu]

"Yes I agree homoeopathy needs modernization by accepting certain things but doesn't mean you critize a system completely just because you don't understand it!" Exactly what I was thinking, Ma'am. People seem to evidently show that a little knowledge is a dangerous thing.

[@pbd5417]

Homeopathy healed me of chronic disease hence even my family members also Started to use homeopathy

[@jakemj03]

Please post links to the scientific studies that document and prove your claims, which should have peer reviews and challenges, that backup said claims. Your word is not enough.

[@mariamtee]

I agree with you. My brothers tonsillitis went away as did my cousins vitiligo and how could I forget my sons eczema as a baby. Not all homeos are alike and it doesn’t work for everything but when it does it does

[@mruthyunjaysiddal3613]

Placebo

[@harjeetsinghsandhu2022]

Dr. I want to agree with what you say but contrary to that I've benefitted a lot by homoeopathi c treatment of my ailment. No anti biotics no stomach trouble, 2 to 4 doses of higher potencies and everything is fine. I was plagued by Sciatica pain and there was no permanent solution for it in Allopathy.

[@ambience9647]

Do you understand what high potency in homeopathy is? It literally means more diluted. If a "potent" homeopathic medicine cured your ailment it means nothing.

[@gaurab197]

Sciatica more often gets cured by itself

[@almightyalmighty2689]

@@ambience9647 homeopathic medicines has so much side effects..if given in wrong way..it can spoil one person life..even can make him handicapped...and many more issues..which you cannot even imagine..jo mujh par beet rahe hai..am saying on that experince..my doctor has given me wrong med..in his greed and anger.Dr Ashok thapa of west delhi vikaspuri/hari nagar..he spoil my life...he is not following homeopathic rules...he is dangerous for his patients.he should be in prison...so beware.if one medicine heals ..it can harm you also..overdoses of homeopathic med. creates so much health issues in ones body.

[@arnavgodhamgaonkar585]

have you heard of the placebo effect ( this is the reason homeopaths always say you have to believe in it, try checking this term out)

[@drsovindmahi9020]

@@ambience9647 If a potent medicines cured your problem it means NOTHING . What a hilarious comment you made. If chemicals or Allopathy medicines SUPPRESSED a problem, it means EVERYTHING right ? How genius you are !!

[@MrRantWhy]

I love that he is holding a wireless computer mouse to change is slides. And the audio is clipping a lot. This is the most under funded TED video I have seen.

[@PianoGesang]

I love how he is unintelligible to most ppl

[@kelseybarton]

it's so good lmao

[@shre_yaa__]

😅

[@dr.aayushikania1750]

Your personal failure to understand homeopathy as a system of medicine - doesnt mean the failure of system. Moreover- this platform is for your own evolution and growth - not for criticisim of other system of medicine.

[@chaitrapujari3016]

Ya..its his failure..he can never be a true doctor by criticizing other system

[@Jin-cp8ff]

@@riteshsiraskar3205 Donyou think all the phones in this world belong to USA? No,not everything is for one thing. Respect all the system,or else you get a disease a never be cured with Modern medicine forever which can be cured with Homeopathy. You'll know better if you experience in reality

[@abhijeetmohanty8497]

@@Jin-cp8ff in the 20th century lobotomy was a perfect form of treatment and it treated depression for better than most modern medicines do. Why do you think people are against it these days now and don't rush to it? Certainly it has better results with a 100% cure rate? That's exactly what the issue with homeopathy is. In no way can we confirm that the solution or whatever is being fed does not have any negative effects on the body. That's why it is being discouraged, for time being. The homeopaths were given enough time to provide evidence and they went on random trails with nothing satisfactory calling their treatment ahead of time. Such a form of treatment will actually be called unethical if other practitioners were doing it and they might even be penalised for it.

[@jasonbolding3481]

@@chaitrapujari3016 criticizing a "system" that is not science based and harmful is something a doctor should do

[@vasudev8243]

@A T zandu balam treats headache and it doesnt treat cancer. And u consider zandu balam as useless product. homeopathy worked for many diseases and it has the right to continue in treating those diseases.

[@karthikvbhandary5039]

I had seviere nerve injury on my hand, it got cured by homeopathy.

[@Musafir_ki_diary]

Dr samuel hahnemann was a allopathy doctor him self the founder of Homoeopathy

[@drvikastomar]

Yes he was

[@Jayraymay13]

Could you provide a link. I can't seem to find it.

[@prasenjittripura4691]

There is nothing like"allopathy"..u can call mbbs which is based on modern medicine/ evidance base medicine..the term allopathy were termed by sammuel only... We never read allopathy in book..

[@voidhomeopathy1494]

@@prasenjittripura4691 but people call it allopathy ,thats is the power of Hahnemann ,we never told modern medicine is bad ,then y u people telling homeopathy is bad , because ur losing ur patients 😂😂

[@prasenjittripura4691]

@@voidhomeopathy1494 we r nt against any profession bhai... We r just against anti-science, quakery,where playing with human life,,, homeopathy isnt based on science...they believe in magical water idea.. If u study chemistry in 10-12 standard ,u should have used the term avogadro no law, in homeopathy medicines are avaiable with 30x,40x power,, in this so-called drug,,, didnt find a atom scientifically,, means doesnt have any drugs properties,,,. And u know homeopathy doctors alyws say they treated those,that...even cancer.....u know homeolathy doesnt have any role in pathophysiological ds... People go to homeopathy,, late the ds...later returns to modern medicine,,, but unfortunately too late to save pt,,..so people should be aware of those quakery

[@prasannaambekar5183]

Homoeopathy is best and treat number of cases where allopathy fails

[@nileshyalkar1764]

Three big problems. 1)people are not consious about health 2) a small percentage of good doctors are overloaded.cannot give enough time to patients 3)people like polarization.Instead take the best and leave the rest. We dont need lot of doctors but right doctors who are good in diagnosis. special test must be designed to filter the right person and allowed to become a doctor

[@laypyu]

That's the biggest issue. The education system just promotes people who are capable of mugging and spewing into an exam paper, and does not promote the courage or desire to instinctively troubleshoot a problem. The system is damaged at the root, so we're all bound to see products (or rather failures) like this.

[@realallthings4700]

Most of us not scientifically literate .most of the Indians are way too religious and nationalist.they don't even understand that we all are made from same chemicals .The biggest problem is education system,it doesn't promote scientific education it just tells you ancient myths ,fairy tales ,but never the real thing.Also another thing is no one admires scientists as they admire scientifically illliterate artists (actor,economist, politics etc).do a experiment ,ask a people to name 15 scientists and 15 actor/artist.

[@nileshyalkar1764]

@jass brar additionaly right eating habits,right cooking habits plus right food along with yoga will make healing journey faster.our body is the best doctor only if we let him do his work.medicines trigger our body knowledge

[@pbd5417]

@jass brar Happy to know Homeopathy is working for you, instead of taking mixture drops try single constitutional remedy from a classical homeopathy it will show wonders but very few classical homeopathy doctors are there, Single constitutional Remedy is best if some doctor can find for particular person.

[@ultraali453]

AI is probably going to really help in diagnosing illnesses. It is going to help make modern medicine much more holistic as well by connecting different medical disciplines.

[@meghahalawagal7507]

Aude sapere -Dare to be wise❤️ I believe homoeopathy

[@itsrayhandesigns]

Ok. I took Allopathy for blood pressure and heart palpitations for 7 years. It only worked for few time then I had to take dose again every day. Then I switched to Homeopathy and it took 1 year and its been 5 year I'm not having high blood pressure. Allopathy only shut down the issue for sometime. Homeopathy fixes the main issue in your body.

[@vamthekam]

"Intangible Medicine for Intangible issues". Although, in your case there really is one tangible - The money your homeopathic "Doctor" made off of you selling you snake-oil because of you were either desperate or gullible enough to believe this scam. PS: I am equating Intangible issues to your reference of "main issues" which Homoeopathy purportedly fixes. Not your palpitations, which are very real and serious and you would do well to revert to your earlier and correct recourse of allopathic care.

[@almightyalmighty2689]

lucky you are..you found good doctor..in my case..am suffering due to homeopathic med..coz my doctor was wrong person..usne gusse mei jaanbhuj ke high potency ke overdoses diye mujhe approx 2 yrs..and am suffering now..realised so late..if it can heal..it can harm you also..homeopathic medicines has so much side effects..if given in wrong way..it can spoil one person life..even can make him handicapped...and many more issues..which you cannot even imagine..jo mujh par beet rahe hai..am saying on that experince..my doctor has given me wrong med..in his greed and anger.Dr Ashok thapa of west delhi vikaspuri/hari nagar..he spoil my life...he is not following homeopathic rules...he is dangerous for his patients.he should be in prison...i cursed him.

[@Gujju000]

Homeopathy work excellently even when allopathic failed & make disease more complicated..and people who criticised homeopathy they also used homeopathy for their Family 😎 that's truth.....

[@akkishri6525]

Abhyankar Sir, i respect U even being Homoeopathic doctor, probably u have not learned probably homoeopathy as well as modern medicine as u r not very clear in perception of both. Being a Senior practitioner why u need to waste ur valuable time for anything u find foolish? Instead u should have read a paper. Its ur frustration not a proper explanation. We are not against u i hope u should also be that much positive for allopathy. Trials & research method u follow are applicable in homoeopathy as well as ayurved, & People get evidence based results as u show. So why to criticize rather come together to cure the patients in better way

[@binodtharu7157]

Name one homeopathic 'medicine' which has passed a double blind trial.

[@simstar6557]

This is trial and research on homeopathy. “The principles of homeopathy contradict known chemical, physical and biological laws and persuasive scientific trials proving its effectiveness are not available” Russian Academy of Sciences, Russia “Homeopathy should not be used to treat health conditions that are chronic, serious, or could become serious. People who choose homeopathy may put their health at risk if they reject or delay treatments for which there is good evidence for safety and effectiveness.” National Health and Medical Research Council, Australia “These products are not supported by scientific evidence.” Health Canada, Canada “Homeopathic remedies don’t meet the criteria of evidence based medicine.” Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Hungary “The incorporation of anthroposophical and homeopathic products in the Swedish directive on medicinal products would run counter to several of the fundamental principles regarding medicinal products and evidence-based medicine.” Swedish Academy of Sciences, Sweden “We recommend parents and caregivers not give homeopathic teething tablets and gels to children and seek advice from their health care professional for safe alternatives.” Food and Drug Administration, USA “There is little evidence to support homeopathy as an effective treatment for any specific condition” National Centre for Complementary and Integrative Health, USA “There is no good-quality evidence that homeopathy is effective as a treatment for any health condition” National Health Service, UK “Homeopathic remedies perform no better than placebos, and that the principles on which homeopathy is based are “scientifically implausible”” House of Commons Science and Technology Committee, UK

[@anilkumaratpadkar8682]

Brother It's Homoeopathy beyond your understanding... Lack of Knowledge...

[@patchey8019]

Homeopathy is just water and the Placebo effect, People can swallow a whole packet of homeopathic 'drugs' and not overdose because its just, fricking, water. Delusional twit.

[@nilshanful]

Hold my water bro

[@Drkiranjadeja1]

@@nilshanful broo i am from Gujarat . If u believe or not but it will not change any facts. My known female gynecologist mem , a orthopedic doctor and dermatologist Are taking treatment for their own disease at homeopathy clinic at Anand Gujarat . We should accept reality in term of results which we get from any irrespective medical science. I am eye witness for all cases .yes every science has its own scope and limitation . But homeopathy works wonderfully and cures man .

[@InvestigadorTJ]

@@Drkiranjadeja1 for those with criticisms about Homeopathy why don’t you realise that those homeopaths that are healing patients are actually helping your population… they are indeed healing and they have a practice or a clinic or hospital and making this happen.. it’s so unnecessary to just criticise a system that is not understood.. and is helping people..

[@VideoOverdose]

Wtf

[@Christs_Soldier]

I've come across many videos that give umpteen reasons as to why homeopathy is mostly placebo, and how homeopathy has many misconceptions that aren't scientific. But I've also come across people who got rid of their eczema and psoriasis and acute spondylitis after homeopathic treatment when modern medicine didn't help. As someone who's genuinely trying to understand why homeopathy has still helped in places modern medicine couldn't, despite it not being scientifically ideal, I'd like to know what makes it help. Placebo can help when it comes to the flu or headaches, but not in terms of skin conditions or spondylitis. How are there cases where homeopathy has helped? How does that work?

[@simstar6557]

It does not help. Fake Homeopathy pills, which are called placebos, also do the exact same thing. The fact is many diseases go away if you wait. That's all homeopathy is. Making people wait and charging money.

[@thelittleboy2892]

It is bot only skin conditions but also, diabetes, asthma, hypertension, thyroid complaints, HIV, Cancers and many other diseases are being treated by well known homeopaths..

[@simstar6557]

@@thelittleboy2892 quacks "treat" everything. It's all regression to mean though.

[@Christs_Soldier]

@@simstar6557 you are the type of person my original question is aimed at. I'm honestly here to understand and learn, and I would like to hear your explanation- with subjective opinions at bay.

[@simstar6557]

@@Christs_Soldier its not my explanation. It's science. Its called regression to mean. Read about it. Read how researchers correct for it. When corrected for, homeopathy pills work at the same rate as fake homeopathy pills. So that makes it a placebo.

[@combatcritique]

More Indians need to watch this😢

[@tinaibarra7956]

Everyone's organism works different. What doesn't work for one might work for the other. In case of an emergency I'm heading the the ER. For all other issues prefer to seek a holistic practitioner.

[@Huundeblogg]

As a homeopath I would say that if you are in a car crash, go to the ER, not your homeopath ☺️

[@tinaibarra7956]

@Huundeblogg "In case of an emergency I'm heading to the ER"

[@18candygal]

I happen to have a completely different issue with these alternative practitioners. The tall claims. Every single one I have visited claimed to be capable of eradicating the condition from its root...which they obviously couldn't (I mean...you can't just eradicate arthritis once it has set in) Every modern medicine practitioner will inform you of all the possible outcomes of the proposed treatment plan before beginning. They'd never make claims like that. So my lack of confidence in these homeopaths and ayurveds is because of their own failure to acknowledge the limitations of their practice.

[@simstar6557]

If Homeopaths acknowledged all their limitations, then they will have to admit that literally nothing in Homeopathy works. Tall claims is all of Homeopathy.

[@abouteverything6696]

Nobody can guarantee the outcome. Many senior allopaths guarantee coz they have cured many cases but couldn't cure all so its the same with homeopaths.. 💚

[@18candygal]

@@abouteverything6696 That’s my point. The allopaths would always let you know what to expect from the treatment and would encourage you to have realistic expectations. The ayurveds on the other hand would be saying things like “you follow my regime and I guarantee you will be free of the disease “, which mostly does not happen simply because it’s not possible

[@PrakharBaisakhiyar]

@@18candygal Dont talk about something you dont understand.

[@drsovindmahi9020]

Homeopathy never fails A Homeopath may. And there is a huge difference. Allopath does not claims , Because HE knows Moedern medicines DOES NOT CURE even a common cold. SO HOW does a Allopathy Claim anything ? Homeopathy or Ayurveda has cured millions of people across the globe , Yes Because of overdose / malpractice or Lack of knowledge now a days Homeopath aren't doing any great except a few renowned Homeopath of India . Homeopathy never fails, Why ? Because I am the youngest Homeopath in my region ( Punjab ) who has well treated Cases of Malignancy, Autoimmune disorders , Osteoarthritis etc. Can you believe ? Definitely NO ! Because you had butter experience with Your Homeopath. But Homeopathy never fails , it is the only Healing method which does work in every single disease of body. @DeekhshaSrivastava

[@dhananjayahire3092]

In this complicated situation all over the world our PM Mr. Narendra Modi, please note "our PM" Mr Narendra Modi appealed Homoeopaths to give some Preventive Medicine For Corona Virus. And you in your TED talk, is criticizing Homoeopathy & him too. ????

[@avnani5385]

They are already out bro...They call those medicines as "preventive medications for carona"

[@jonas4120]

It's like throwing pills in a lake and drinking lake water to get cured

[@menakamanickaraj]

Any luck with that.

[@jyotiprakashsaha8234]

@@jonas4120 so u think u know everything about homeopathy. Ohkay

[@jonas4120]

@@jyotiprakashsaha8234 do you?

[@naveenarya3547]

Principles of homoeopathy made by Dr.CFS Hahneman in that time are not proven wrong till now.And if you understand (too difficult)"The Organon of medicine" You will find the prognosis of a diseases of this time.Hence there is no modification of his thoughts. I was also not a believer but now I am...

[@Prvn708]

What is proven ?? Homeopaths give allopathic medicine.....why ?? Not confident of their system ??

[@NarinderSinghHere]

There's severe lack (read:absence) of Hindi content on this matter. Somebody needs to fix this.

[@valsakochukunju3795]

It can't be fixed . Look at the number of dislikes from hindi content creators.. they will oppose it with all their heart. Idiots

[@NarinderSinghHere]

@@valsakochukunju3795 haha touche but lately there is surge in rationalist content in Hindi. Hopefully awareness will be spread hereon.

[@Madara-zt8pn]

@@NarinderSinghHere I don't think. Municipal corporations in India distributed immunity booster Homeopathy pills. Wtf?

[@aldomoraigne3403]

Who is this Ted? And why is he always talking, he should listen more.

[@prakashrnair]

loved this talk. superbly put Dr. Abhyankar. Why have I seen it so late! This should have gone viral long back. 81k views is injustice.

[@zackschindler8334]

I know someone who was using a homeopathic medicine. He thought it wasn't working, so he started taking less of it. This caused an overdose and he died.

[@abouteverything6696]

CERN SCIENTISTS solved mystry of homeopathy,, they are working, the news published in GENEVA (Switzerland news paper) ,it is clearly writte american allopathic pharma lobby is trying not to pursue the study successfully.

[@dr.khushboopandey2499]

There is no need to explain the various miracles of homoeopathy. There are number of highly qualified allopathic doctors who themselves use homoeopathic medicines for their family as well as recomend homoeopathic treatmemt to patients also.

[@Tubemax68]

Which means absolutely nothing. Unless it can withstand scientific testing, it simply does not work.

[@mugogrog]

Just as there was no need to explain how snake oil worked, it just worked. Question for you Dr. if water has memetic properties, and ailments for no reason are cured by opposites how would you explain the following. Every drop of water on Earth has through history been in contact with every thinkable solution or mixture, it should retain that memory just as well as it retains the memory of the homepathic process, it has then been naturally distilled through the ages over and over again such that there is no trace of those molecules it once were in contact with. It has been in contact with Uranium, Chlorine, All types of plants, Einsteins bladder, you name it. So why are not those dilutions in the water's "memory"? The easy answer is there is either no such memory or the effects do not carry. Either answer leads to the conclusion that Homeopathy is a scam or at best a placebo. Why any doctor would use it is completely beyond me, although I have a good friend who's a general practicioner and he believes in shamanic energy transferal :p so I guess we should base what we say on the evidence rather than what doctors believe on the side.

[@vaibhavmaheshwari8125]

Just because the owner of a car company used cycle one day it doesn't mean cars are useless

[@shivanit1429]

🙄

[@rishiraj3899]

Homoeopathy will grow and flourish day by day...शौक से निकालिए नुक्स मेरे किरदार में, आप नही होंगे तो मुझे तराशेगा कौन ..!!!"

[@Madara-zt8pn]

But there is no evidence it works. In fact anyone who knows basic science can tell this without experiment.

[@rishiraj3899]

@@Madara-zt8pn take a dose of sulphur CM every hour....

[@Dr.AhmadNaved]

@@rishiraj3899 very good brother 😄😄😄😄 Sath me phosphorus bhi CM me...

[@SRKNUKER]

Good one

[@shahan484]

Here after this legend passed away from Lung Cancer. Rip

[@drswapnil2020]

Dear Shantanu sir, Thanks for this scientific explanation regarding modern medicine. And No offensives, just the facts. People generally go by the listening, not by the facts. People must listen this to clear their doubts about modern medicine. Thanks again.

[@abouteverything6696]

As per Avogadro number high potency (beyond 12c) homeo-medicines cannot have even traces of the starting material. So, how can they be medicines? If distinguishing chemical formula is the criterion, then they are non-medicines. Still, they continue to cure diseases for over two centuries. It implies a necessity to reorient our thinking. Thanks to the Structural Model backed by Quantum Electrodynamics (QED), we get the desired reorientation. QED predicts existence of ice-like structures called Coherent Domains (CD) in water at room temperature which is confirmed experimentally. These CDs are information carriers through serial dilution because their shape and size get influenced by factors like impurities, ions of other substances, large foreign molecules, physical perturbations, electromagnetic field etc. Unhindered by Avogadro limit the CDs continue their journey in homeopathic potentisation. These structures, in their turn, influence near-matching bio-molecules to serve as medicines, like antibiotics, leading to a generalized concept of medicine. The real test of a medicine should be its capability of curing disease vis-à-vis altering the state of health Homeo-medicines passed this test again and again for over two centuries. Further, Placebo cure hypothesis advanced by homeo-skeptics has serious drawbacks: (a) Placebo effect or mental cure is not valid for benefits to new born babies, animals and plants where mind does not have any role. (b) Granting a place to mental cure or placebo effect, it should have been predominant for glamorous main stream medicines instead of poor homeopathy. (c) If mental cure is so easily achievable by common people then we should throw all medicines to dust bin. (d) Mind is not known to have any quantifiable active ingredient. So, mental cure is a self-contradictory hypothesis.

[@SwapnilPathak-uk9rj]

Homeopathy works may be you should rethink and indulge yourself into the practice to understand it has always worked for me .

[@doodlingsdoodlings6085]

I wish more people considered the effects of pollution on the body. If we are healthy and active, many diseases shall pass, without having to run to any doctor.

[@viancavarma3455]

what does this have to do with the video

[@lakinverbeck6848]

Not necessarily true

[@realhumanbean7915]

That's what risk factors doctors say are. Live healthily and you're less likely to develop severe dieases. You can't just cure them *just* by being healthy though.

[@TheKingBeyondEverything]

It's true. We'll be less likely to develop diseases.

[@doodlingsdoodlings6085]

@Vic LTD why medieval? Do you consider pollution as modern? "oh my God I'm so modern. I don't care about pollution. I don't care what's going on around me." Be smart. Not oblivious. For your own sake, please!

[@jatinbhanushali3997]

Feeling sorry for the people who got misguided by Dr shantanu abhyankar.

[@jonas4120]

Your the one whose misguided

[@rohitamonkar1897]

I feel sorry for you , my friend

[@ParampreetDhatt]

Really?? If he's misguiding people, why don't you enlighten everyone by offering rebuttals on the points where you think he's wrong, instead of just making random & meaningless remarks.

[@simstar6557]

I feel sorry for people who still don't understand science and facts. “The principles of homeopathy contradict known chemical, physical and biological laws and persuasive scientific trials proving its effectiveness are not available” Russian Academy of Sciences, Russia “Homeopathy should not be used to treat health conditions that are chronic, serious, or could become serious. People who choose homeopathy may put their health at risk if they reject or delay treatments for which there is good evidence for safety and effectiveness.” National Health and Medical Research Council, Australia “These products are not supported by scientific evidence.” Health Canada, Canada “Homeopathic remedies don’t meet the criteria of evidence based medicine.” Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Hungary “The incorporation of anthroposophical and homeopathic products in the Swedish directive on medicinal products would run counter to several of the fundamental principles regarding medicinal products and evidence-based medicine.” Swedish Academy of Sciences, Sweden “We recommend parents and caregivers not give homeopathic teething tablets and gels to children and seek advice from their health care professional for safe alternatives.” Food and Drug Administration, USA “There is little evidence to support homeopathy as an effective treatment for any specific condition” National Centre for Complementary and Integrative Health, USA “There is no good-quality evidence that homeopathy is effective as a treatment for any health condition” National Health Service, UK “Homeopathic remedies perform no better than placebos, and that the principles on which homeopathy is based are “scientifically implausible””

[@Madara-zt8pn]

So you think tedx will give the stage to homeopath ?😂😂

[@appexsos]

I wonder where all the homeopaths are during this corona crisis ? 🙄

[@valeriia2887]

Royal Homeopathic Hospital, UK. Royal family is healthy and 72 y.o. prince fought corona very fast. Meanwhile young prime minister went to intensive care.

[@dr.nagendrashomoeoclinic120]

Legally allow to treat- and homoeopaths are ready. ..

[@pallavikashyapmandal2709]

They r busy in treating ppl if u want to see thn go to the GHMC in bhopal

[@cyberpleb2472]

They are peddling their snake oil.

[@Gurneetrandeep]

U will get to see them working under some allopaths and they are working privately not in front of media my brother

[@amarshendkar9738]

He didn’t understand homeopathy and allopathy till date 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@ParampreetDhatt]

Instead of making a random, meaningless statement, why don't you offer any comments or rebuttal on specific points mentioned in this talk?

[@abc124420]

U r a chutiya

[@user-mw2wn4ix2s]

And how did u understood it ?amar shendkar

[@drgauravduttdubey9608]

Brother where allopathy despair patients there come a light in life from homoeopathy...aap suffering people se poochiye...u get your answer

[@EdwinTyler]

Such an unscientific reply can only come from a homeopath.

[@drgauravduttdubey9608]

@@EdwinTyler no this reply from suffering patients

[@drgauravduttdubey9608]

Come to my clinic i show my result sir

[@SRKNUKER]

I take homeopathy by self am not a doctor cured my gout where allopathy doctor says there is no cure.

[@PremSingh-tw6mq]

He was confused before & now too....All the best Recover soon

[@santoshsaini7930]

True. He don't realise what he said?

[@dmrohit1194]

Yes sir you are this doctor is very much confused

[@mohamed-2711]

Complete nonsese. I would never see an allopathic doctor unless I have no choice.

[@naagraj9252]

I don't agree with this doctor and I am a chemical engineer ।।।।।।। Chemicals are not the same ।।।। What multivitamin given by doc works only up till it's taken but multivitamin which we get by eating fruits and veggies last long this proves that all chemical s are not same, the vitamin C tablet and lemons C are chemically same but not same 😉😉

[@shivangipawar3402]

His real issue He took hairfall treatment from Batras... And is unhappy about it... Haha

[@perpendicular5691]

🤣🤣🤣😅 mouj kardi

[@himadityachoubisa295]

With the example given by him about the diabetic patient where he was consulting an ophthalmologist, diabetologist, psychiatric, etc, he is not recommended to go to a nutritionist for correcting the root problem at all i.e. obesity. That is the summary of allopathic medicine. You treat the symptoms and not causes

[@Shakazaramesh]

You people keep repeating this over and over again, but it's pretty much the opposite of what's true. If I get a bacterial infection the "allopathic" doctors would cure the cause with antibiotics. If I got appendicitis they would cure the cause by removing my appendix. A homeopath would just give me some inert sugar pills that might make my symptoms feel better through the placebo effect, but will do nothing to treat the cause.

[@himadityachoubisa295]

@@Shakazaramesh ohhhh don't you assume that I support homeopathy, increasing potency by diluting something is as absurd as it gets. And understanding that untill you use a fuel cell to combust hydrogen to produce water, all water molecules on Earth is as older as Earth itself, the whole concept is a sham. I trust in allopathic medicine when it comes to diseases caused by vector agents and parasites or in case of physical injury and immunology and a lot more, but I will never subscribe to allopathy for lifestyle diseases.

[@himadityachoubisa295]

Homeopathy works if you believe that it will work, it is based on placebo effect and all other factors and science behind homeopathy is just mumbo jumbo.

[@Shakazaramesh]

@@himadityachoubisa295 Ok, I misunderstood a bit there. "Allopathy" is a term propagated by homeopaths and other quacks, the correct term is "evidence-based medicine". The notion that modern medicine only treats symptoms and not causes is another thing quacks like to say, but it isn't true at all. Whenever possible it does seek to address the root cause. There are some diseases where the cause is not known, or where no effective treatment has been developed yet, and in those cases all that can be done is treat the symptoms. But whenever possible the cause is addressed. Your example about the diabetic patient is obviously wrong, I know several people with diabetes and they've all been told to address their eating habits and been referred to dieticians.

[@himadityachoubisa295]

@@Shakazaramesh the diabetic example is in context to the video Cat, the guy refers the patient to a million specialist except to a dietician and personal trainer lol.

[@grvtaneja8]

I just pity this man.. He spent his entire life to prove to himself that his decision of leaving Homoeopathy was valid..

[@simstar6557]

Hey quack, here is the science. “The principles of homeopathy contradict known chemical, physical and biological laws and persuasive scientific trials proving its effectiveness are not available” Russian Academy of Sciences, Russia “Homeopathy should not be used to treat health conditions that are chronic, serious, or could become serious. People who choose homeopathy may put their health at risk if they reject or delay treatments for which there is good evidence for safety and effectiveness.” National Health and Medical Research Council, Australia “These products are not supported by scientific evidence.” Health Canada, Canada “Homeopathic remedies don’t meet the criteria of evidence based medicine.” Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Hungary “The incorporation of anthroposophical and homeopathic products in the Swedish directive on medicinal products would run counter to several of the fundamental principles regarding medicinal products and evidence-based medicine.” Swedish Academy of Sciences, Sweden “We recommend parents and caregivers not give homeopathic teething tablets and gels to children and seek advice from their health care professional for safe alternatives.” Food and Drug Administration, USA “There is little evidence to support homeopathy as an effective treatment for any specific condition” National Centre for Complementary and Integrative Health, USA “There is no good-quality evidence that homeopathy is effective as a treatment for any health condition” National Health Service, UK “Homeopathic remedies perform no better than placebos, and that the principles on which homeopathy is based are “scientifically implausible”” House of Commons Science and Technology Committee, UK

[@akshitjain2984]

I just pity you, man....

[@holistichealth6735]

@@simstar6557 har jagah bhonk mat

[@arshbirjanagal6247]

theek hai "Dr" saahb

[@vamthekam]

Homeopathy : 30C or 10^-60 Dilution. Equals to giving 6 billion people, 2 billion doses/sec for 4 billion years to deliver a single molecule of the original molecule to any patient. Hahnemanns recommended dilution. And it gets better - the more the dilution, the more potent the "medicine", because ofcourse, water memory. I pity the people who turn to you for help "Dr". Taneja .

[@drgauravduttdubey9608]

The word Allopathy give by Dr Hahnemann who discovered homoeopathy shantanu sir... I hv doubt about homoeopathy when I take admission in bhms but I see miraculous results and I continue it ..

[@akkiaaa]

Don't call yourself a doctor. You are nothing but a fraud

[@shubhamgupta-mf5qx]

Means sir please describe benefits of homoeopathic than allopathic. or how great homoeopathic than allopathic or allopathic failure and drawbacks.

[@MrRathan1991]

Ted is a great platform to record people’s evolution. This gentle man has to understand and think in a more broad picture. You have studied +2 syllables again gave entrance exam, got selected and graduated from a medical school. That’s a great job.

[@heroalom3464]

Studying +2 again is no big deal.

[@doc11sadhana]

@@heroalom3464 Then 5 & 1/2years Plz be informed before u comment

[@matthewloboelias5855]

Dr.Shantanu says he has been practicing for last 23-25 Years ,means he complains PG somewhere in 1995. I.e.he got admission for his UG in late 80s... I dont understand what entrance exams he gave when they weren't there at all.Just trying to mesmerize the audience

[@ryanroy7301]

@@matthewloboelias5855 yoo..😂😂😂

[@tackytaco8133]

@@matthewloboelias5855 college entrance exams have always existed. But tujhe kaise pata hoga anpadh.

[@vickeysaroj1555]

Before 2 years I have white hair issue at that time my friend was working under a homoeopathic doctor so he told me to try it i used it probably 2 and half month and it stopped where it was now recently i have receding hair line and again I am on homeopathy i have trust it will work

[@altafkalam2716]

Yeah, it still doesn't mean jackshit. Anecdotal evidence, placebo effect.

[@venkatarr]

Homeopathy is not scientific and it's a placebo. I lost my health and wealth because of Homeopathy. 99% of Homeopathy doctors are looters and 1% doesn't exist. Govt should impose ban on homeopathy permanently. For my skin disorder I approached more than 8 homeopaths but none found a solution. Finally i started allopathy and recovered fully. My strong advice is to not encourage homeopathy.

[@lamedvav]

And you know that the plural of anecdote is data!

[@HL-dw4dl]

The efficacy of homeopathy is not more than a Placebo. They just blame the patient of not having enough faith.

[@Jen-jd3ci]

You Mortal! Homeopathy is legit... It can (only) cure your Dehydration.

[@HL-dw4dl]

@@Jen-jd3ci 😎😎👍👍🤣🤣

[@abouteverything6696]

Nobody, no homeopaths ever did that, this guy literally mixed up with his less and dengerous google based knowledge (information i would say 😂😂😂)

[@ashilyjustin4748]

@@Jen-jd3ci 😂😂😂

[@ZaidKhan-su3ey]

so our ancestors were at placebo instead of Ayurveda, Unani, etc... Sushruta, Charaka, Vagbatta, Patanjali, Hippocrates, Galen, Ibn Sina, Razi were all fools

[@norman1291]

Why didn't you mention the most important part: cure? When people go to modern medicine with a complaint, they get treated and are free of the complaint and feel good about themselves, full of energy and vitality?

[@emmanaturopathandbirthprof1506]

Rarely, that's why many people go to homoeopaths and other "alternative" and " complementary" therapies. Because they don't get better from allopathic doctors and they don't get energy and vitality and they don't feel good about themselves at all.

[@Huundeblogg]

He's focused on long-term treatment.

[@drbhairavi]

As a student even I had many queries about homeopathy, but that was my lack of knowledge and not because homeopathy was unscientific. We do respect the role of modern medicine though homeopathy is not a pseudo science. My quest led me to find out and understand more about homeopathy rather than disregarding the science and discrediting it. And finally I experienced the results of homeopathy not once but many times which increased my faith in the system. Yes ask questions many questions, experiment experience and then come to conclusion. Modern medicine has its role and its developed by leaps and bounds as compared to those days when Dr Hahnemann was disenchanted by the Gruesome nature of practices and in establishing clinical diagnosis too it deserves full credit but the therapeutic role of homeopathy is positive beyond doubt. I would like to also add here that although modern medicine is way better than before but side effects and drug reactions also need to be looked into which at many instances are worse than disease itself. And like Dr Hahnemann Said Dare to Be Wise. Dr please go and ask patients who would want to go for so called alternatives and not modern so called mainstream medicines. You will get your answer results and experiences are always more important.

[@sauravsuresh]

A psychiatrist can do the same job as a homeopath, maybe even better

[@harikakorrapati8840]

@@sauravsuresh actually no

[@captainperiwinkle]

@@harikakorrapati8840 Actually yes, both are about convincing someone they don't have a illness... Homeopathy is a Placebo

[@dudesayingthings]

Results are important, I agree. Not experiences. Homeopathy has never been proven to work in a double blind medical experiment. Why is that? If your medicine is more than placebo, it should work just fine in a double blind. But it doesn't.

[@dudesayingthings]

@@ezhilarasis8386 i prefer reading the abstracts of the studies themselves. Got anywhere i can see those? Articles have a way of obfuscating the facts and presenting the writer's viewpoint. I would especially like to see meta-analyses of multiple homeopathy studies, to make sure that the studies with positive results are the rule rather than the exception.

[@jampoozeditzz7047]

Homoeopathy has always been my lifesaver 🙏🙏🙏 and my grandmother is a homoeopathic doctor who saved many lives🙏🙏❤❤❤

[@ayush2sachan275]

She is fraud, her whole life she was scamming people. Yeah homeopathy is good for 'Rojgaar' because this country doesn't have enough jobs.

[@briellehunter7233]

@@ayush2sachan275 eat a -- troll

[@ayush2sachan275]

@@briellehunter7233 Homeopathy doesn't save lives, that's a fact

[@briellehunter7233]

@@ayush2sachan275 Wrong

[@ayush2sachan275]

@@briellehunter7233 Not wrong, just harsh truth. Pseudoscience is crime

[@viancavarma3455]

one of the most articulate skeptics i’ve watched! proud people like u have been raised in our country

[@ehbarath]

wow, what makes you assume he is proud? Why don't you point out what he said where wrong if you know anything?

[@ParampreetDhatt]

​@@ehbarath What the OP meant was that he is proud to have people like him (Dr. Shantanu Abhyankar) raised in our country.

[@abouteverything6696]

CERN SCIENTISTS solved mystry of homeopathy,, they are working, the news published in GENEVA (Switzerland news paper) ,it is clearly writte american allopathic pharma lobby is trying not to pursue the study successfully.

[@DDBEIndia]

I agree but just one question what about few people whom i Kno who have survived through homeopathy when alopathy gave up hope... But i still go to alopathy since i don't belive in homeopathy but i have first hand proof

[@shobhitbansal1504]

Did the homeopathic patient stop taking allopathy altogether? Nopes

[@benaffleckisanokayactor]

I think the phrase “survived through homeopathy” is doing a lot of heavy lifting here

[@nitinbourai]

Only by test you can say it works or not. Say you have fever,cold so you take 1 tab paracetamol and your fever goes off so it works , so let's say you take aconitum 5 drops in half cup and your fever goes off. What do you say to this ? Does it work or not ? I have tried this with me,wife,parents,friends and it works 100% time , not taken any paracetamol from last 4 years. Is it placebo ? Does placebo works 100 % time with different individuals for a long period of 4 years ? Does placebo reduces high fever also of 103 degree.

[@simstar6557]

What you described is called anecdotal experience. Science is completely different. It is a shame that you were never taught the difference. Yes 103 C fever can come down after taking placebo or even not taking placebo. It is called regression to mean.

[@docvishvashsadhu982]

@@simstar6557 Now if I tell about diebetes, asthma you will reply that it becomes normal itself😆 Lol

[@simstar6557]

@@docvishvashsadhu982 sure, you can fix early diabetes with proper diet and your asthma is episodic. There is not a SINGLE disease for which homeopathy does anything because it does not contain anything. 😆 “The principles of homeopathy contradict known chemical, physical and biological laws and persuasive scientific trials proving its effectiveness are not available” Russian Academy of Sciences, Russia “Homeopathy should not be used to treat health conditions that are chronic, serious, or could become serious. People who choose homeopathy may put their health at risk if they reject or delay treatments for which there is good evidence for safety and effectiveness.” National Health and Medical Research Council, Australia “These products are not supported by scientific evidence.” Health Canada, Canada “Homeopathic remedies don’t meet the criteria of evidence based medicine.” Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Hungary “The incorporation of anthroposophical and homeopathic products in the Swedish directive on medicinal products would run counter to several of the fundamental principles regarding medicinal products and evidence-based medicine.” Swedish Academy of Sciences, Sweden “We recommend parents and caregivers not give homeopathic teething tablets and gels to children and seek advice from their health care professional for safe alternatives.” Food and Drug Administration, USA “There is little evidence to support homeopathy as an effective treatment for any specific condition” National Centre for Complementary and Integrative Health, USA “There is no good-quality evidence that homeopathy is effective as a treatment for any health condition” National Health Service, UK “Homeopathic remedies perform no better than placebos, and that the principles on which homeopathy is based are “scientifically implausible”” House of Commons Science and Technology Committee, UK

[@simstar6557]

@Win Rathi homeopathy had nothing to do with it. You just got better.

[@simstar6557]

@Win Rathi but you are promoting unscientific logic. It's called anecdotal proof.

[@terrio1078]

should it not be dispelling the myths of allopathy?

[@Saptarshi.Sarkar]

By looking at the dislikes, I guess congnitive dissonance is at work.

[@dastran2731]

Those might be the people who got cured with homeo

[@simstar6557]

@@dastran2731 no one was ever cured by homeopathy. There are people who confused it for a cure through placebo effect though.

[@dastran2731]

@@simstar6557 ohhh really.

[@simstar6557]

@@dastran2731 yes, really. “The principles of homeopathy contradict known chemical, physical and biological laws and persuasive scientific trials proving its effectiveness are not available” Russian Academy of Sciences, Russia “Homeopathy should not be used to treat health conditions that are chronic, serious, or could become serious. People who choose homeopathy may put their health at risk if they reject or delay treatments for which there is good evidence for safety and effectiveness.” National Health and Medical Research Council, Australia “These products are not supported by scientific evidence.” Health Canada, Canada “Homeopathic remedies don’t meet the criteria of evidence based medicine.” Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Hungary “The incorporation of anthroposophical and homeopathic products in the Swedish directive on medicinal products would run counter to several of the fundamental principles regarding medicinal products and evidence-based medicine.” Swedish Academy of Sciences, Sweden “We recommend parents and caregivers not give homeopathic teething tablets and gels to children and seek advice from their health care professional for safe alternatives.” Food and Drug Administration, USA “There is little evidence to support homeopathy as an effective treatment for any specific condition” National Centre for Complementary and Integrative Health, USA “There is no good-quality evidence that homeopathy is effective as a treatment for any health condition” National Health Service, UK “Homeopathic remedies perform no better than placebos, and that the principles on which homeopathy is based are “scientifically implausible”” House of Commons Science and Technology Committee, UK

[@menakamanickaraj]

@@simstar6557 finally someone who can think.🙏🏽

[@SaiAbitathaDUCIC]

Homeopathy does work

[@mishkapathak]

Yes!!

[@selflove3411]

Yup

[@patchey8019]

The placebo effect works, a sugar pill will work just as well if you tell someone its a real medicine

[@devanshsingh8121]

no sir it doesn't, from personal experience