Nightwish - Yours Is An Empty Hope "Live" Wembley (Reaction/Review)

[@dmusiclife5727]

As we scroll through the comments we feel we need to address something we didn’t notice at the time until later during the editing process of this post as some of you seemed to be upset with us for and that is we did not catch on that Floor was actually the one performing the death metal growls at the time! We Honesty thought it was Marko. And that Just goes to show how Floor is an absolute beast of a vocalist and she has so many levels it’s truly mind blowing. Going forward we will do our best to notice more details with Nightwish as we appreciate all your support as we continue this journey with Nightwish. Love y’all

[@markclements7767]

No worries, you are not the first to miss that and you sure won't be the last! 🤣

[@brewswillis9783]

I figured as much during your reaction but knew you'd find out through others comments. Marko's vocals are gruff enough that he doesn't need to scream or growl. Seven Days To The Wolves please!

[@arjan_speelman]

It has somewhat become a running gag/comment on most of the reaction videos :) if you want to experience some more of Floor’s growling, check out Revamp - Disdain live at Graspop

[@ronaldtenbookum4342]

I think you will like Floor and her former band Revamp with the song Desdain

[@rainertuominen4242]

Thanks for a great reaction! Just for your reference: the London Wembley Arena is the #1 prestigeous concert venue in the UK. Holds a crowd of the same size as Wachen, 80000+.

[@amborambor8469]

Master Passion Greed is their heaviest song but is never played live. PS. All the growling is done by Floor 🙂 PSS: It was the second song of the concert

[@joshuaburba1048]

Fun fact, it would be PPS instead of PSS, because it stands for post postscript. Just FYI in case you're interested.

[@jasonmarshall7572]

I concur

[@amborambor8469]

@@joshuaburba1048 indeed 😊

[@77bubba00]

After finally seeing them live 5 years ago, I can understand why the audience might get quiet. They can put you in a trance before you know it. And yes, that was Floor doing the growls. 🤘

[@PaulOutdoors]

Now that's how you open a show. Phenomenal song. Phenomenal band. 🙏😊👍❤️

[@nooaparkatti4571]

To be fair, they do have an even heavier song "Master Passion Greed" though they don't perform it live as the subject matter is kind of toxic. I would really recommend you listen to it though, as it demonstrates some more of Marco's vocals with him being the sole singer in that one!!

[@mvellis3863]

II highly recommend "7 Days To The Wolves" from this same concert (Wembley), where Floor unleashes her inner wolf!!

[@brewswillis9783]

I concur, it's one of Floor's most visceral performances for sure!

[@pabloragusa]

I concur!

[@orangeguppie6897]

I concur!!!!!!!

[@hansv.d.hooven5232]

I concur as well 🤘🔥🤘

[@vmaxbabe]

I concur

[@marcelrenes2435]

Floor is so versatile, she can growl like a man and sing the G5 like a classical singer without any effort. For me she is the best singer of our lifetime.

[@amygoodson-catlady]

Heavier? See Slaying The Dreamer live Buenos Aries or Weak Fantasy live Tampere. Start there, we'll guide you!

[@terryminator4208]

Floor is growling if you can pick up on it.GRRRR!!!

[@arjan_speelman]

Always waiting for the reactors to figure that out, but they so rarely do.

[@NeilOosthuizen]

@@arjan_speelman To be fair it is subtle until you realise its there then you can't miss it :p

[@islgrl292]

I know, he sat all still seriously watching, & never mentioned it at all. I am yelling at them to come on. LOL! Drives me crazy.😂

[@norair1010]

Many versions of this song(I've seen 3) and none of them show her or Marko clearly during that part. I am thinking the camera person wa told not to do it to keep us guessing. LOL.

[@islgrl292]

@@norair1010, you could always clearly hear Marko singing the higher register, & someone is growling. They didn't mention it all, just saying, no defense required.

[@clivematthews5296]

Your first chance to hear Floor growling on every chorus with Marko singing clean. So much more to experience.

[@markclements7767]

Hi guys, greetings from UK A great reaction, thank you 😊 Floor was growling in the chorus, maybe that is a part of what you enjoyed? I would recommend the song "Song Of Myself" from Wacken 2013 concert as a song which you may like

[@robertsheeler321]

good job , you missed that Floor was doing all the deep growls throughout the song

[@ralfmeyer9086]

Hey, as so many Reactors. Mmh, They don't understand the range of Floors Voice. .

[@RAAZR-]

@@ralfmeyer9086 So funny when npc metal fans aka nightwish fans think growling is something super unique.. listen to some Death Metal and come back. Nightwish fans some of the most unbearable.

[@arendhoek3151]

"Shudder before the beautiful" from the same concert was the show opener. You can do that one. Or "7 days to the wolves", also from Wembley. And then there is ofcourse the best of all show openers: The one from Wacken 2013: "Dark chest of wonders" . All of them pretty heavy.

[@ev.junior]

Glad you guys are enjoying Nightwish guys! Sorry in advance for the long text, but I hope you read it. I've known the channel for a long time and you know why? Because my school is Thrash Metal. I was a drummer in thrash bands for almost forty years and in all that time I knew about the existence of Nightwish, since its emergence, but I had a big prejudice against operatic vocals in metal, I thought it was too strange. I knew Floor Jansen from the beginning of her career with After Forever, but I also thought her band was pretty average and didn't care enough. Until, during the pandemic, I decided for the first time to give Nightwish a chance by watching a reaction video, and it was Ghost Love Score! I was simply blown away by it. I cried a lot because I couldn't believe how I could ignore a band that became in weeks my favorite band in life, because I consumed everything Nightwish had produced. I cried a lot because they came to my country four times and I simply despised them. This band completely changed my concepts about Metal, and later I discovered that fans of rap, Kpop, soul music and other styles, also became fans of the band, and that is very rare to happen with Metal bands. I think you should also give LOVEBITES a chance, this incredible Japanese all-female band that rescued the spirit of eighties metal in a breathtaking way mixing Thrash with Power Speed metal. Listen to "Set the World On Fire (live in tokio 2021)" or "Break the Wall (live in tokio 2020), just to start feeling the power of these amazing Japanese girls. Anyway, much success to you and once again I'm sorry for the text, but it was from the heart! Greetings!

[@brewswillis9783]

Well stated RC and I would add Nemophila as well, check them out if not already.

[@chriso6719]

From what I've heard , Wembley Arena in London holds around 12.5K for concerts. Song #2 here, Shudder Before the Beautiful was the opener. This song, and to a lesser extent, Ghost River at Wacken, are about all you are going to get from Nightwish with Floor's growls. She did more of that in her previous band, ReVamp. Disdain ,live at Graspop 2010 is a good one for that. Fairly heavy, but not quite as much as this one, is 7 Days to the Wolves from this same show. Think you'll also like Weak Fantasy at the Tampere 2015 show.

[@Thorgrim247]

This one is directed at all those internet trolls who spew their negativity. Theirs is an Empty Hope! BTW - Floor was doing the low growls on the chorus. Marko was taking the lead lines.

[@rnowak85]

Great reaction! Did you pick up on the fact that Floor was doing the death metal growls in the chorus? Next Nightwish song I would recommend Song of Myself live from Wacken or Seven Days to the Wolves live from Wembley.

[@no_onein2024]

Also Floor's previous Metal band is harder, ReVamp! Try "Disdain" Live at Grasspop 2010 and "Wild Card" Live at Bloodstock 2014

[@christianlangenberg6614]

"Weak fantasy" from the same concert at Wembley is epic.

[@ralfmeyer9086]

Floor growls deep,and Marko is the clear Voice. When you hear more, you understand the range of her Voice. More growls from her? Disdain with her Band ReVamp 🤘 sorry, forget,her Opera O mio bambbino caro.

[@christinaalgate4899]

How about Revamp Misery is no Crime for Floor Growling. Yours is a empty hope is the 2nd song and the 1st is Shudder before the Beautiful

[@jodingwall1915]

The audience energy at this show was actually brilliant. I was front row. Fantastic times were had indeed.

[@JacekBenke-vi2wq]

Oglądam relacje na zespół Nightwish nieprzyjaciela męża kolegi ale pani jest pani prawdziwa i teraz odsyłam tego dalej śledzę pani reakcję fakt faktem jestem fanem zespołu Nightwish wy kobietki jesteście naszymi szyja

[@richardhall6034]

Hi from the UK 👋 🇬🇧 division of the Nightwish army something you might like from the same concert Nightwish seven days to the wolves live Wembley arena

[@torbjornsjooander5625]

If you want to see the crow go cracy , check out Sewen days to the wolf from the same show

[@no_onein2024]

Devil and the Deep Dark Ocean and Yours is an Empty Hope are in my top 5 for sure!!! Have you guys done "Romanticide" Live at Wacken?

[@digitalhydra4332]

Greetings from Iceland. Thanks for all your great reactions. I especially enjoy your Gojira, Opeth and Jinjer ones, and now Nightwish! Master Passion Greed is considered, by most, to be their heaviest song. There is no live version of it, so you would have to go the studio route. If you want another live one, Weak Fantasy (live at Tampere 2015) is a great song. I recommend these two as your next stop on your journey. Keep it up and keep it metal!🤘

[@jaskau2462]

Definitely "Weak Fantasy" live at Tampere 2015... 🤘😎 🇫🇮 💙 💯 💥

[@rianavermeulen4316]

Nightwish is amazing ❤ loved your reaction ❤ thank you. From South Africa ❤🇿🇦

[@skeezesmith7954]

Excellent commentary. One small suggestion: After a pause backup a few seconds to keep the flow going. 😊🤘

[@PeterMcCracken-n3g]

Hi guys. I was 55 when I went to see Black Sabbath and I was head banging, end of.

[@majbrat]

LoL I thought you might catch it was Floor doing the dirty growling, but many don't. It's a great song. 😊

[@wheat70]

You guys didi not say anything about floors growling. ??

[@sasailicic]

My favorite song...FL❤❤R

[@aegonthedragon6341]

"Ghost River" is pretty heavy as well. Live at Wacken 2013.

[@tgalloway]

Floors growls on this are amazing

[@JacekBenke-vi2wq]

Pozdrowienia z Polski taki żart porwą koledze księżniczkę

[@nightgoblin29]

Love your "Death" sleeve! one of my favo bands ever sinds Scream Bloody Gore haha

[@jeffreyphipps1507]

Did you miss the growling by Floor

[@RAAZR-]

Or maybe they aren't NPC metal fans like Nightwish fans that have only ever heard one singer growl (Floor). For true metal heads we hear it every day (and also from women) so it's nothing special.

[@lujalainen1]

fun or not fact about this song in this concert. marko hietala write his stainless book, when he see his wife first time in audience when this song start ( second song ) he feeling that maybe they married have still hope,but then he falling dark and start thinking that maybe like this song name,they not have. they end they marriage soon when this concert end. thanx to great reaction and have awesome weekend :)

[@sambt123]

guys, you need to do “momento mori” -the secret. VERY fucking underrated band, the outro is as heavy as it gets, or “fire isn’t always meant to burn”

[@German_1]

I was going to suggest Master greed, but see, someone else did! You didn't hear floor growl thru the whole song?😮

[@paisa20]

thanks

[@larzakalazerath6655]

Now just the heaviest one with floor. Master Passion Greed :)

[@Klojum]

"Master Passion Greed" does not involve Floor...

[@jaskau2462]

🤩👍💥💯🎼 🤘😎 🇫🇮 💙 "Weak Fantasy" live at Tampere 2015 next by them (???) 🙄

[@Ireksojkowski]

Hi, very beautiful reaction

[@williambornn1684]

Alright you two the Hardcore 1 here. I came across a band I think you might like. They are Carnal Savagery the songs you should check out are Inhumane Sacrifice and Return of the Rotten Dead. The only way to describe this band is their band name Carnal Savagery INTENSE looking forward to seeing what you think and your reaction I request you check out Return of the Rotten Dead first then Inhumane Sacrifice both both are worthy of one word Brutality.... Much love and respect always....

[@AidenCantrell]

Check out Godzilla (Gojira) Demo songs Saturate and Locked in a syndrom, they were all still in their teens when they made them I believe.

[@ozzman123]

For more growling Floor, check out her band REvamp! Wild Card and Here is my Hell are both badass songs! ❤

[@MeanStreakGaming]

Try "Weak Fantasy" next.

[@jaskau2462]

Indeed, "Weak Fantasy" live at Tampere 2015 🇫🇮 💙 💯 💥

[@MeanStreakGaming]

@@jaskau2462 i actually prefer the one at Wembley

[@rb-wtf5111]

Song Of Myself, from Wacken🤘🏻

[@davidburkholder4764]

Hi Guys. Great Reaction. Just so you know, this is Not their heaviest song by far. Master Passion Greed is way heavier, just no video of it. Also, Song of Myself, Poet and the Pendulum, and a few more. I've been watching you guys for a long time because Tool is my favorite Band, but I'm definitely happy seeing you guys do Nightwish. They take some getting used to, but they hooked me a long time ago.

[@fearisachoiceyouembrace]

Still hoping for Weak fantasy live Tampere 2015 and Song for myself live Wacken 2013. Both are a bit harder. Thank you.

[@NicholasCorvin]

*The hardest track of Nightwish is for sure MASTER PASSION GREED.* 🔥🔥😈🔥🔥🎵🎸🥁🎸

[@kimeklund8880]

React to As Oceans Devouer - Leviathan Great first song from this new band 🤘

[@mirjamvond1731]

Just another day at the office for Kai 😁

[@ianmitnick8245]

I suggest you consider reacting to the RUSH song and video "Countdown" - it's a great RUSH rock song with great lyrics

[@matthewkilgore3916]

Master Passion Greed is the heaviest Nightwish song of them all

[@omarfernandez1620]

Try Disdain by Revamp if you love this side of Floor!

[@miguelcarpintero7602]

Master Passion Greed, Slaying the Dreamer, Tribal, are other examples of NW heavier songs…

[@goranelez9956]

Master Passion Greed is their heaviest song, but there is no live version for a list of reasons. Imagine a genius songwritter, someone heavily insults him and his friends, then he writes a full orchestral revenge song about it.

[@marcialsalas8660]

Reacciona a sepultura Inner self y Territory Live en barcelona. Gracias.

[@k.l.7788]

This song was in The Simpsons few months ago.

[@bindassladka973]

Hi guys plzzz do react to bloodywood (Indian folk metal band) song "Dana Dan" hope you like it..🤘🤘

[@franciscojaviervazquez2635]

Want heavy? First listen to "Slaying the Dreamer" (Buenos Aires) and after listen "Master Passion Greed" (heaviest song of NW by FAAAR). Unfortunatelly there is no live show for this song, because Tuomas was so pissed off when he wrote this song that he claims they will never play this song due the hate of the song and he is not that person anymore. You will LOVE IT! But need some research before listening to understand why he was angry and to who was about. Out there is a good edit of the song by Comunidade di Branca

[@chrisdavis408]

Yeah, on this one thoumas cut floor loose for the chorus. She sang much this style in her previous bands. You should check at least 1 of those songs out. I know ull like it.

[@karolinak6014]

if you like Floor and Marko together, the next song to react should be "7 days to the wolves" from the same show. You may also try"the greatest show on earth ", a 20-minute masterpiece. The Wembley version features Richard Dawkins as a special guest (the whole album was inspired by one of his books), but in my opinion the Tampere version has better visuals and Vibe in general. For more Floor growling check out her previous band, ReVamp 🤘

[@BP-pb1jg]

Would love to hear you cover some Korn

[@k.l.7788]

Do Tribal from Nightwish.

[@Mars-is4un]

🤗🍒🤘🏻😘

[@juhavaris2144]

Master passion greed i think are there heaviest song 🤟👍

[@robmac1645]

Check out norma jean "a killing word"

[@nietzscheente1271]

Master Passion Creed next?

[@Fellipeert]

react at tempere. From Brazil.

[@glenngunnis6642]

The crowd will do anything the Goddess commands!🤘🎸

[@ramrod7368]

MasterPassionGreed is the heaviest NightWish

[@dennisthemenace671]

I almost didn`t click on this cause the thumbnail didn`t look like the Wembley version .

[@marjukisuryana9237]

Please reaction Vanny vabiola .she is amazing singer .song cover I LOVE YOU

[@juanitook1125]

NO VISTE GRUÑIR A FLOOR NO SON 3 VOCES MARCO CANTA Y FLOOR GRUÑE

[@German_1]

If this isn't heavy enough, try rest calm, or pan .

[@petritapaninen2860]

I love NW , but this so far out from painkiller dood :))))

[@wjl2601]

This kind of musical theater is not for everyone. Lots of people like it. But quite a bunch don't. To much distractions and tricks, to much going on beside the music. I still see the hesitations, the awkwardness in this reaction. I understand that because this band performs on a very high professional level which is not always a plus. It makes it even hard to give it any critical notes. If it goes for theatricks Rammstein is the real deal I think. They use a special form of satire, a sort of over the top absurdness that is needed to keep the doubts away. I guess that you've seen and listened to this legendary German band already so I won't recommend them;-) Succes and have fun.

[@leftyme4568]

Alwayd rember Emppu

[@leftyme4568]

When Floor puts her hand up ....peaple float .....-.they are offerings

[@wildylupous]

Song of Myself

[@leftyme4568]

Did you just say f the Nightwish crowd????? WHAAAAATT

[@leftyme4568]

aussies just dont understand the pain they will recieve