Do dog harnesses keep your pet safe in a car crash? (CBC Marketplace)

Paws for Concern | Originally broadcast on December 5, 2014.
We love our pets. And we spend big bucks to keep them safe and healthy. But do the things we buy really work? Marketplace investigates pet safety products, putting them to the test and revealing why they could put your pet, and your family, at risk.
More from CBC Marketplace, Canada's top consumer affairs show:
Watch episodes online at cbc.ca/marketplace
Like us on Facebook: / cbcmarketplace
Talk to us on Twitter: / cbcmarketplace
Follow our hosts @cbctom and @cbcerica

[@jejwiqkeywiqueyetujr6848]

The harness that passed the test was “Sleepypod Clickit Utility “ harness

[@AIversonI]

Thank You!

[@eks1630]

Thanks!

[@wildwoody20]

Where do we buy that one ? Post the link please ?

[@melblack7412]

Thank you!

[@RadicalJinx]

Thank you!

[@triciamccutchen3227]

if someone thinks that their dog's safety isnt a priority just because they're dogs, they shouldnt have a dog

[@maisiemaisincorporated8623]

Tricia McCutchen ikr

[@fireflieswithlightelexiabe1727]

Very true.

[@julianaaraujo1949]

Tricia McCutchen rude uhhh

[@maisiemaisincorporated8623]

Juliana Araujo no its not its true

[@Crusluck]

True but In this case. The answer is don’t bring your dog along in the car

[@DarylBuck]

"You CANNOT trust an unregulated Industry" Words to LIVE by!

[@bosyeux2]

not that the regulated ones are necessarily a whole lot better... hence a large part of why "marketplace" even exists

[@Madronaxyz]

Do you really want your neighbor selling his home to be used as a nuclear waste dump? Without regulation, this could happen. Do you wanted convicted child molester working at your child's day care? Do you want someone with typhoid preparing your meals (see the story of Typhoid Mary)? Do you want people who are drunk or stoned driving next to you on the road? The marketplace exists to sell things. It does not exist to regulate things. In the marketplace, selling anything counts as a success as long as the seller is not held liable for fraud or injury. Without regulation there is no meaningful way to hold sellers liable. Only the very wealthy have enough money to sue.

[@bikinggal1]

sad thing is even our food is not as regulated as we think. A company can package food and say produced or packaged in Canada yet it was grown in China or Thailand etc. Not sure how we stop it!!

[@Nevoexpo]

They need to sue these companies, they have enough to take them to court!

[@JudithGraceffaPlays]

Yeah!!!!! I totally agree this person! Ill be the judge of that.

[@mymak-jq1hy]

Why? There’s no regulations.

[@marklittler784]

Not funny if you get hit in the back of the head by a flying dog, sounds like failed harnesses are a big fraud.

[@billyhatcher643]

yea thats a more sensible way instead of waiting for them to do something

[@marklittler784]

@@billyhatcher643 Bad publicity alone usually does the trick.

[@chriscooper3503]

LEAVE SEATBELT MAKING UP TO THE CAR MAKERS AND HIRE CAR MAKERS TO MAKE SPECIAL SEAT BELTS FOR DOGS

[@Jonathan-uo6ui]

Give your pet an 8 point racing harness

[@isthisallthereis7083]

+Jonathan Chielens it wasn't the harness that broke it was the strap that attached it to the car seatbelt

[@gregs.2679]

Actually, the carmakers aren't qualified to make seatbelts either, and they know it, which is why they buy from outside suppliers like Autoliv. It's a very specialized field employing very specialized researchers, engineers and designers.

[@blowitoutyourcunt7675]

@@gregs.2679 Actually the three-point restraint has been the same design since 1962 and it's still in use. On July 10, 1962, the United States Patent Office issued patent number 3043625 to Nils Bohlin, a Swedish engineer, for a three-point safety belt designed for use in road cars. The belt was straightforward, consisting of two straps that met at the hip and secured both the upper and lower body. Instead of sitting on the patent and licensing it out to other automakers for a big ol' chunk of change, Volvo opened up the patent so that any automaker could incorporate it into vehicles. The automotive industry took the idea and ran with it, and it proved so safe and popular that derivatives of Bohlin's original design are still in use today. www.cnet.com/roadshow/news/55-years-ago-today-volvo-received-a-patent-that-saved-countless-lives/ Where you are it's probably out sourced, not because of the design of the seat belt but because seat belt/ car crash testing standards are very rigorous and they need their own the lab to do said to testing in.

[@starrkirkham7035]

Hello from Wyoming.. Great report CBC. I too am disappointed that we were not told, the only harness to pass... I went to your site; tried EVERY one of the promts, plus a search bar; and found absolutely NOTHING on this story!! I realize that it was in 2014 but; if you're still providing the information, please don't leave viewers hanging.. We deserve the PROMISED results!!!!! In an accident, it would be even more difficult for my children, to have their 'friend' hurt also... WE CARE ABOUT OUR KIDS AND OUR PETS. ••Please fix your site: 》include all stories 》from all years 》with all the needed updates Just saying, that this would be a huge help.. Thank you again for the begining of a great report. Please Update(Finish) this report for us.. ☆

[@YukisNation]

The Kurgo harness probably would have done better if it had been attached properly to the harness instead of the leash clip. Ya know. The clip the instructions CLEARLY say NOT to attach to the seatbelt because its designed as a leash tether, not a seatbelt tether and will not hold up in crash conditions. You're meant to attach the tether around the entire back strap of the harness. All three inhanced layers of it. Not the leash clip, which was the only thing that gave way in the test(maybe because that part wasn't meant to hold up in a crash!). People spend money on these items to protect their dogs but don't even bother to read the instructions! Just assume it works one way because it looks good. I can't believe the crash testers didn't even read the instructions. Kurgo clearly states how they tested the harness and which hook up they recommend as safest. These people are saying Kurgo doesn't follow threw with their claims yet they didn't even follow the instructions! Pure idiocy!

[@SethHolmes]

Yeah, looks like a cheap carabiner to me. No way that's going to hold up.

[@YukisNation]

Seth Holmes I wasn't speaking about the carabiner in any way. I'm talking about what the carabiner was attached to. It was supposed to go around the strap, not hook into the leash clip.

[@matts9907]

but the carabiner is what broke!

[@bikinggal1]

I saw that too and thought I will go buy a really good carabiner at the climbing store

[@mfskarphedin]

They said they set up the harnesses the way the package instructed.

[@14Raine14]

One thing I've noticed: the kurgo harness, while properly secured to the dog, was NOT properly installed in the car. The packaging clearly states NOT to use the clip on the back of the harness, the carabiner should be clipped to the webbing itself. It also says the safest way to secure your dog is to pass the seatbelt through the harness

[@aliciakowalski]

Watching this video, I found the same frustrations, NONE of these looked like they had passed the seatbelt through the harness. I don't feel like they were even clipped in. I have been in several rear-endings (living in the GTA I find no one is really paying attention), and I use the Top Paw and a car seat cover/hammock for both my Boston Terriers. I slip the seatbelt through the harness and neither dog has been able to wiggle out of it, and have been safe in the car with each accident (they've only been in two while driving with me and/or husband).

[@Jonathan-uo6ui]

TIP: buy an harness bar for your car and then buy a 8 point racing harness

[@Jonathan-uo6ui]

This won't fail for shure

[@ohheckno7893]

+Jonathan Chielens sure*

[@ohheckno7893]

+IWantzBrownies sorry I have Ocd

[@SethHolmes]

Got links?

[@karissateves3489]

The racing harness is a good idea but will maybe only work for larger dogs if you can manage to comfortably strap them in. The product won't fail, meaning that it won't break but it may not properly hold the dog, so in an accident a dog may slip out of it. At the $400 price point it needs to work 100%. It's made for humans not dogs.

[@frankroppolo1305]

I wish they would give us a recommendation of what they say to use for dog car seat harnesses!

[@mannymadrox9974]

Companies say whatever they want because dogs can't make lawsuits.

[@Maxygamez]

But their humans can

[@blowitoutyourcunt7675]

@@Maxygamez burden of proof....

[@yvettevalles4202]

The bee in the Bee Movie sued people -(i joking)-

[@techguy404]

This is why I try my own way of protecting my pets... No company cares about someones pet, they care about money.

[@itsmegiselle7930]

Big B Gaming i agree 100 procent

[@Trollypolly975]

Yes.. that is capitalism

[@xXWOAT13Xx]

Trolly Polly no... it’s just not required yet. This is a new industry

[@luke_5187]

Big B Gaming I use a caribeaner on the seat belt, and a harness that for my dog

[@blowitoutyourcunt7675]

@@luke_5187 is the carbiner weighted for a thousand pounds? If it isn't rated for climbing and can take a hell of a lot of weight via the metal it's made out of, then you're just going to be in the same situation where the Carbiner breaks, just like the straps in the video....

[@youssefben8511]

11:02 who ever chose the sound effects there deserves a raise 🤣

[@catherinebarlow4323]

You folks are the ones who are misleading. The Kurgo harness SPECIFICALLY states NOT to attach the caribiner to the seat belt. It is supposed to be attached to both shoulder and lap belts. Shame.

[@cathyauscat4746]

Before I bought my Great Dane (who is now 80kg) I did a lot of research into harnesses and tethers for dogs. NONE were tested for dogs over 40kg except for one, which was the EzyDrive Harness. Testing on the tethers was even worse. I could not find ANY that were tested. I ended up going to a climbing store and buying rope and carabiners intended for humans with a break strain of 2000kg. This is then attached to the anchor bolt in the car, used for baby capsules.

[@MarijaEnchantix]

You do know that telling the owners their harnesses suck doesn 't solve the problem. Yes, it raises a question, but doens't solve the problem or help the dogs. If you mock what they use, at least suggest something better.

[@jonathandpg6115]

the idea is to bring awarness. Sugesting an alternative isnt always easy if little exist. they tested 16 and have one that protected it but they cant test them all.

[@tornadofreakasmr9177]

Dunning Kruger You’re honestly so uneducated. There are so many crashes that aren’t the drivers fault. Trust me, I know. My mother got in a car crash a couple of months ago. She got a broken ankle and lots of other small injuries. It could have been much worse, the gas tank almost exploded with her inside. It wasn’t her fault at all, it was a young man who was drunk in a fight with his girlfriend. His car sounds out of control, hit my mother from behind, and spun her full 360 into a field. The man spun uncontrollably into a lamp post, and when I drive by I still see the dent in it. The young man survived unharmed, but not my mother. It costed her lots in damage even with her insurance, and I was so scared for her. It wasn’t her fault at all, she had never been in a crash and is an amazing driver at 37.

[@no-yp7gi]

@@Dunning.Kruger that doesn't do much, people get charged with DUIs all of the time. Nothing you can do if you have a head on collision with one, we have to be more cautious in the US because of alchohol, illegal and legal drugs like weed in some states.

[@abagfullofcats4247]

In 2013 I was in an accident with two dogs. The police who arrived told me that the best place for a dog in a vehicle is in a metal crate like mine were in. It protects them from impacts and keeps them inside her vehicle. It might be less fun and inconvenient to have to kennel them every time you get in the car but it will save their life.

[@annawright4545]

How about, the car ignites and you get pulled out unconscious and your dogs will burn alive in the crate, safely. The next step to this will be a "regulated-safety-measure-crating" in the car and it'll take many dog lives for this idiocy to change.

[@kelleywyskiel8513]

@@annawright4545 exactly. Proper pet seatbelts can be cut open if necessary but a crushed wedged tight crate is just staying in the wreck. There are soft side crates like in the Pacifica that are safe and easy to remove if needed. I do understand the idea of the crate though.

[@comfortme]

@@kelleywyskiel8513yes the crates seem like a good option at first but it’d be so easy for the crate to deform and trap your pet in there. soft crates might work but they’d have to be secured just as well as a regular dog harness. at this point i believe a proper harness is more convenient and safe

[@anonwa4309]

one of the first things i learned in driver’s ed was before you move the car, all your passengers should be secure, and that includes puppers.

[@TwoPlusTwoEqualsFive32]

The product said "restrain your pet during an accident" These harnesses aren't supposed to help your dog, they are supposed to stop your dog from becoming a flying projective.

[@TresaOlson]

Doesn't look like they do

[@hardilsandhu8267]

+JordynPlays1312 it slows down the speed of the dog catipolting

[@shammydammy2610]

+JordynPlays1312 That's why Shini said...'supposed to'.

[@GeForceGG]

Sure doesn't. Even though it slows them DOWN, it does ABSOLUTELY NOTHING for your pet. It still becomes a flying projectile, and it still, WILL, get hurt. I hate to see companies offer harnesses to your pet that don't work, JUST SO they can get money off of people. What GREEDY companies they are!

[@TimeDefeater]

And it doesn't do that. :p

[@jaleshashaeb.1948]

11:02 Idk why but My brain thought she was making whale noises. I need coffee smh.

[@drywallgrass]

same

[@dumbgayenby]

Raise you hand if you think that car companies should make special seat belts for dogs that work! 🙋🏻‍♀️

[@imoffendedthatyouareoffended]

Car companies don’t make seatbelts, they’ve used the same design from over 40 years ago made by Volvo who gave everyone access to their design which is still in use to this day.

[@JelizavetaZaiko]

Very informative video, thank you. Yet, as a very proactive dog owner, I am sorry to be anal about it... 'any shampoo' will NOT do the trick as suggested as a tip Nr.1 for keeping fleas away. It is absolutely wrong! Dog's skin is less acidic, besides dogs do not have the same sweat glands as humans do. As you are earning your living by reaching out to general public, you should be more careful with your advices. Wash your dog in a species appropriate shampoo: reputable dog shampoos will be milder and will not strip your dog coat of natural oils. By regularly washing your dog in ANY shampoo your dog might ''experience'' contact irritation, dry skin, even reduced immune function.

[@paulneilson6117]

I totally agree with the pet seatbelt. I even would go as far as getting a helmet for the dogs. I remember seeing an old hieroglyph with a man and his dog in an ancient flying machine. Amazingly the dog can be seen with a helmet.

[@Cristal_Lugo]

I don't even have a dog... Why am I here 😂 I want a dog so bad tho

[@wilsongarrido8707]

Obviously it’s a sign you need to get a dog ^~^

[@Eric-lx8hp]

Get a rescue!

[@ibol13l3]

Wow, they're testing safety in Flint Michigan. Just, wow.

[@cellogirl11rw55]

I absolutely despise chemical treatments for fleas and tics. One of my dogs has epilepsy, and they made her seizures worse, not to mention irritating her skin like hell.. Now, my family uses a natural oily spray that makes their fur too slippery for fleas and tics to hang on.

[@anotherHondaElement]

My schnauzer got SARDS sudden blindness after giving the pill for fleas and a heartworm monthly treatment. I was 1 month away from showing my dog in an AKC agility and obedience trial. He only needed 1 more leg or Q to earn 2 titles. Unfortunately, my little guy never got the 2 titles we trained for years to earn because he went blind practically overnight. Years later, I see more and more dogs getting SARDS and people spend so much money trying to find a cure. It's all about money

[@Koselill]

In Norway, by law, you have to crate them, which needs to be bolted to the car. Only a recent law, but after seeing this... I’m happy we have it

[@waynedodson7360]

Very late comment, but I would have loved if they recommended products or at least identified ones that passed. I am very happy this was brought up and I will take it to heart, but it doesn’t seem to help too much - especially when most claims and evidence come from the manufacturer.

[@FukaiKokoro]

This should be standard manufactured in all cars! Just like human seat belts, doggy / pet seatbelt the the back seat a should be a mandatory!

[@bresghost]

maybe not mandatory because not every one has a dog, but the should definitely be an option and testing along side regular seat belts

[@Saracinderallasushis]

Sure moron, I want to pay for something else in a car that I don't use!

[@FukaiKokoro]

Adding one or two things you can clip an animal into for safety wouldn’t cost much at all. And it would be worth it, what if you’re behind someone or in front of someone in an accident and their dog comes flying out at your car. Think you’d have a different opinion then.

[@FukaiKokoro]

Even if it’s not mandatory, what should be mandatory is government regulation and safety testing BEFORE they are able to sell their products on a public market,

[@neptunes6495]

Fukai Kokoro Agreed. These companies only want money.

[@dothedo3667]

I really want to see _at least_ two of each harness. Obviously proper testing would involve even more than two but it would at least help us see if it's just one part of the design that's faulty or if it changes or it's possibly just "one" faulty harness. I would've liked to see the red one done again because it looked like the carabiner hinged bit broke. The rest of it _seemed_ relatively sturdy (more than the others at least) so I would've liked to see if a second would have the same result or a different part break.

[@goldenretriever6440]

Personally I don't think it's just a matter of restraint It's also a matter of keeping the dog contained in the event of an accident My recommendation is both a harness and a protective barrier that keeps the dog from going into the front Or even better put the dog in the back if you're car is a hatchback

[@badluck9949]

Digby is sooo cute omg...

[@AlaskanCookie]

Only brand in America (don’t know if they are sold in Canada) that has been crash tested and passed was SleepyPod. We researched extensively and found that they were the only ones that put theirs through crash tests and passed. So we know that our dogs are safe.

[@Opinionsareallmyown]

Sadly they do not make them for dogs under 18 lbs. I suppose we who favor smaller dogs do not get to provide them with car safety. *sigh*

[@AlaskanCookie]

@@Opinionsareallmyown Sleepypod has carriers for pets under 18 lbs. A harness on a dog that size in a car crash could do more harm than good since they are so small. So they offer carriers so your pet is safe in a cushioned space that is buckled in and secure. I hope this helps.

[@edengrostick1744]

They should just make a harness out of fire hose and test that

[@1958kyra]

My dog always travels in its steel cage and I have it belted with regular car seat belt, plus I have the sides padded to protect it if a crash occurs, I hope he never needs it, but better than the harnesses I've seen.

[@lejink]

Well... At least some of the companies answered

[@smok3daganja]

question, why wouldn't you tell us which harness is actually safe? seems very irresponsible to me, i can't even find the link to your website.

[@larainewhite]

its the clickit sport harness :)

[@blancaw6280]

I HAD ONE OF THESE SOLVIT DELUXE CAR SAFETY HARNESSES FOR MY PRECIOUS BABY SHITAKE, A 36 KG BOUVIER DES FLANDERS. All was fabulous until the day my driver fell asleep behind the wheel of my Town Car with me and Shitake in the back seat!! That is when all hell broke loose, literally!!! We veered off the roadway in to a ditch. The driver woke up and veered back out of the ditch taking out a series of mailboxes in the process. Over correcting the searing after emerging from the ditch, he then mowed down a small sapling in the opposite ditch before hitting a bolder, which propelled Shitake out the windshield and straight in to oncoming traffic. It was an 18 wheeler with a full load on lumber on the trailer. Shatake bounced off the grill of the semi truck and was propelled into a bicyclist passing by. Another car slammed on the breaks to avoid the bicyclist and was rear ended by a winnebago. Shitake was laying in a heap in the roadway with massive injuries and bleeding profusely from multiple wounds. It appeared that she also sustained a broken back but was still clinging to life. My driver had to beat the dog over the head with a tire iron to kill her and put her out of her misery. I blame everything on this damn Solvit dog seat belt contraption that failed. And to think, this was the "Deluxe" model. I can't imagine what would have happened if we had went with the standard model. Shame on you Solvit for selling such complete crap!!

[@cpetrie100]

+Blanca W I'm sorry for your loss. It is the fear of every dog owner. I agree with you, the harness sellers should be ashamed!

[@blancaw6280]

rememberxjuly Thank you honey! oh yes, I can assure you it happened. To put it in to perspective a bit though, I did not know all the details at the moment I was experiencing it of course. I pieced it all together afterwords from the police accident report that came much later. and the courtroom testimony This was all played out in court at great length due to litigation that occurred later The lawyers and eye witnesses painted the very vivid picture of the sequence of events during the lengthy deposition at trial. It was a total nightmare, believe me. First I lived through the horror and then I had to be victimized again by having to relive the horror in open court. This happened awhile back though and I have gone through a lot of counseling where I have begun to heal. For me I have found that sharing my story can be vary cathartic. If I can help save just one life through the telling of my story I find it all to be worth it. Yes you are right to be concerned with Solvit harness. If it were me I would destroy it completely so that it could never be used again and then throw it in the trash. I understand that you have invested in this item and may not be willing or able to do so. In that case I'm glad to hear that at the minimum you have modified it to hopefully function better. I hope no other pet owner has to go through the horrors I have been faced with. Be safe out there dear and thanks for replying. I am glad my story was heard.

[@bigpappi1540]

I think Bianca was kidding or being facetious.

[@boywiththebread101]

BIg Pappi I really hope so, if not that’s one sad story

[@TheThirdParty35]

isabel really? Because until the bleeding bit it sounds comical! But then again I'm English and I hate dogs.

[@lynnkeblinger1769]

Fantastic coverage and info! Thank you!!!

[@kaylizzie7890]

I just went to the Centre for Pet Safety and they have a list of approved products with links! I am definitely buying why they recommend. I didn’t have my dog in a harness before because I didn’t trust them to actually keep her safe.

[@harrydelaney851]

OK I WATCHED IT NOW STOP RECOMMENDING IT TO ME!!

[@jinxednovadraws174]

IKR

[@jinxednovadraws174]

There should be dog seats

[@victorunbea8451]

"What's going through your mind seeing that?" "My dog, if I was going to crash"

[@wilburmcbride8096]

Thanks for posting this. I always wondered which device is best to keep Spike safe.

[@h0ll0wm9n]

...all that said...these restraints may be effective to RESTRAIN a restless animal ... keep pets away from driver/pedals.steering wheel ... during NORMAL (non-emergency) driving.

[@dodie3053]

“Same protection as yourself” Oh, so I’m going to get seriously injured as well!

[@avenger25]

For full test results and info for the only one who pass the test, Sleepypod Clickit utility: www.cbc.ca/marketplace/blog/pet-safety-dog-harness-crash-test-results

[@Dexy83]

This is 5 years ago... Any updates? 🤷🏽‍♀️

[@mungnansiao401]

This was highly educational and an eyeopener 👍🏻 Kindly give the names of the companies that have passed the crash test

[@anotherHondaElement]

I can't seem to find anything good for small dogs under 15 lbs

[@madisonperkins883]

@@anotherHondaElement Dogs that are smaller like yours would be much safer in a carrier! Their bones are often not strong enough to withstand the force of a harness in the event of a crash. I’ve been doing a lot of research on this recently and Sleepypod has a few carrier options that have undergone crash testing

[@firstgoinpostal]

I'll make my own thank you. I'm currently building one out of 2",and 4"wide soft nylon cargo straps,and heavy duty industrial grade hardware. It will be fleece lined.

[@maryssalynnemedley8871]

Dude its 2 years later, please tell me how did it go? Did you somehow test it?

[@karifredrikson8492]

My dog almost died because of the flea collar. When I put it on, I didn’t realize she had an open wound,very small. About 2 hrs after, she began having small tremors. Then she just couldn’t stop moving. Because I’m an RN, I knew this was abnormal. I took it off & gave her a bath. Then I called a Vet, who couldn’t help me. The brand? “ Advantage 2”. Also an important fact, she is only 5#.

[@lizzysanchez8906]

I thought if i was in a car accident i would be able to hold my self back but now that i see how hard the crash get i feel scared

[@Jonathan-uo6ui]

Just give your dog a racing harness

[@nascarmad]

Here is my story re harnesses. We were in Big Lots and spotted a leash that was also an in car restraint system-it 'plugged' into the seatbelt. So the first time I took our dog in our car with this leash, I hooked it up to her collar. When I got to the first stop sign in our neighborhood, I realized that if I jammed on the brakes, I would probably break her neck. So I went to PetSmart (USA) and purchased a (chest) harness. I didn't read anything about crash tests etc.-it looked good with her collar et al. So THIS really concerns me. I went and found the harness but there isn't any brand name on the label. The label simply says, "L" "R" "Front" and "Patent Pending". No sh** this last bit is even MORE disturbing. But I have to think that what we DO have is better than letting her 'free wheel' in the car (and more recently, in the RV). But, obviously, there needs to be better regulation on these things. Both the US and Canadian Govt's should be EXTREMELY ashamed. It will never happen but still.

[@larainewhite]

I am watching this for my future service dog

[@WonderfulAkari]

Makes me consider making my own since I can choose the material myself and reinforce everything but so much time and I have other projects...

[@ahmednawaz4252]

How to protect dog in road accident? Suggest

[@ahmednawaz4252]

In Pakistan its main issue...I personally worried..trying to introduce ideas to protect dog faimlly

[@imario6945]

which harness passed the test?

[@MarcLloydZ]

Hartz pet harness

[@avenger25]

Sleepypod Clickit Utility

[@DarylBuck]

+avenger25 Prove it Shill!

[@avenger25]

+Daryl Buck izzz Trinity Valour indeed! At the 13:38 they refer us to the Marketplace website for the full test results and as they said ``only one pass the test`` Here is the link: www.cbc.ca/marketplace/blog/pet-safety-dog-harness-crash-test-results

[@christinawhaley7]

I thought that Hartz was one of the ones that FAILED, dude. Sleepypod is the one that passed all safety tests for all of their products with a 5-star rating, with their XL harness passing for dogs up to 90 lbs. Just google Sleepypod and you'll be able to find the website immediately.

[@idlewild]

"Get me the hell out of here," cried Digby.

[@idlewild]

EndlessFunctionality That wasn't pesticide on Grady. "It doesn't take very much to cause effects that could stay with that kid for their whole lives." Grady is so screwed.

[@okamitatsumaki5754]

I THINK I GET IT!!! Which the flea collar, I think that there’s something on/in the collar that... (thinking for like 5 minuets) either kills, or prevents fleas. That “something” gets onto the dog!

[@janp7660]

Thank you for this information. Are there any harnesses that actually do work,?

[@dlw5326]

16:07 hearthstone XD in all seriousness though.... has this problem been resolved? (pet harnesses)

[@womensarmycorpsveteran2904]

I bought a Kurgo brand car seat for my dog. Catastrophic failure, where their tether that held the clip to keep her secure would twist and twist until the clip came undone and my doggie flew out the window and shattered her leg,resulting in 2 surgeries. I wrote Kurgo and they really didn’t give a $hit. They sent me a few freebies, but they are still selling here in New Zealand. No apology, offer to help pay some of the over $3,000 vet bill and no follow up which they promised.

[@dominicoconner1973]

one of the biggest problems with these harness seat belts is the main restraint line, it usually has a cheep carabiner thats good to hold you dog in place but not designed to have any shock load on them, so they just open up. I think the restraint line should have some sort of shock absorber like a construction safety harness so it doesn't just go from slack to snapping into full straight.

[@VitalyKorolev]

Well done CBC!

[@dominiquehebert4903]

How much does their crash test doggy weigh? Maybe the "crash tested" brands were tested with much lighter dogs?

[@jayewilson4]

you give a good point only a really heavy dog could snap the belt

[@kkatherinee9609]

They said 34kg

[@mfskarphedin]

They said they were crash tested; they did not say they passed the test.

[@jamesken6182]

SLEEPYPOD dog harness for those who are wondering which harness worked!

[@Lolguy-qr6ty]

You should make 50 of the same designed harnesses all made on the same production line and then crash test all 50 times to see the top 10 most common breaking points then add some extra adhesive, metal, and padding till it doesn’t break anymore:

[@VFN556]

I have tried to access with no luck "the full results" on Marketplace's website of the 16 extra harnesses that were tested of which only one performed adequately to protect both dog and passengers. They didn't broadcast on the show the name of the one harness that worked I realize this show is about 2 years old but there has to be a way to find out what brand of harness actually works. Ideas anyone?

[@yvonneost12]

So how short should we have the grass for say Digby's size ?? as he's already on the grass because he's so short in the legs hahahahah sorry couldnt help myself he's cute though.

[@EstCrossings]

why do they make these if they dont work

[@SethHolmes]

because people buy them

[@connoriboi3160]

+Seth Holmes yuupp

[@anona]

Money

[@bioticnade]

Money

[@leerag]

The weak point of the red harness was the caribiner. Maybe retest that harness using aclimbing rated caribiner, it will cos nz 50 plus dollars but may mean the harness won't fail. My dog travels in a crate.

[@averagetomfoolery]

(10:13) They shouldnt just have just normal steel locks, they should have the ones that you have to push up, turn and then push in to put the material inside, then let go and it turns back and locks, so you have to do the same thing to lock it up. I climb alot of adventure tree courses (courses made out of wood high up in the trees, that you climb in for fun) and safety is really important so they use metal locks like that, so you cant fall.

[@chelskate17]

SLEEPYPOD UTILITY CLICKIT That’s the one brand that passed the test

[@torresnando23]

Did anyone else almost cry? lol

[@ainz_117]

No

[@pixelgalaxie2487]

Not A Doctor gtfoh crying doesn’t make you week

[@pixelgalaxie2487]

*weak

[@freak_5451]

@@pixelgalaxie2487 it does emotional

[@KathleenaFlynn]

Thank you !!! 🐶

[@KrystalNCMA]

I truly hope that they are able to make something better for my pups. I could not find which product they claim did not fail.

[@dexhivvv]

1. Thats a dog.. in a transport designed for other species. 2. If that collar would stay (not tear) on concrete 50-60-110 kmh. You dog will be handicapped or shredded to pieces. 3. An actual safe collar for dogs, can only involve a gooood air bags as a vest, that will activate with hit and turn dog into a puffer fish. Dogs cant be belted like humans, plus not all dogs are the same, dogs(breeds) with different body structures. Its a mess, it will involve a giant research spendings and end product will be too costly to be included with transport regulations. Just for the joy of driving with your dog? You have a dog in your car, know the risks.

[@EnragedDrunk]

Totally agree with this!

[@christopherbaca1342]

Maybe a paracord and bungee cord will work?

[@christopherbaca1342]

Harness (paracord) small paracord connector in the middle and two bungee cords on each side of the paracord connector so dog go can slow alittle and the paracord will grab them

[@christopherbaca1342]

Hope my idea gets seen

[@animalobsessed1]

Bungee seat belts for dogs exist. I have two

[@lynxjoker3192]

Have you guys done another test recently on these? My mom takes her small dog in the car with her. I take one of my cats with me in my car. Would like to know if you have done another test on these and if any have passed or not.

[@bikinggal1]

We have a Kurgo, and after watching this video replaced the non rated karbeener with a proper fall one....we put it right through the back of the harness. Easy fix I think...cost about $10 or so

[@sharijohnston2514]

I cannot find the one that did pass the test!

[@avenger25]

Sleepypod Clickit Utility

[@avenger25]

+avenger25 www.cbc.ca/marketplace/blog/pet-safety-dog-harness-crash-test-results

[@simsfan4ever101]

Which harness passed the test?

[@MarcLloydZ]

Hartz pet harness

[@avenger25]

Sleepypod Clickit Utility

[@DarylBuck]

+avenger25 Prove it Shill!

[@avenger25]

+Daryl Buck izzz Trinity Valour indeed! At the 13:38 they refer us to the Marketplace website for the full test results and as they said ``only one pass the test`` Here is the link:www.cbc.ca/marketplace/blog/pet-safety-dog-harness-crash-test-results

[@DarylBuck]

avenger25 Thanks Avenger. Nice to come across someone that isn't talking shit around here.

[@lindakleisath7858]

I've made my own by using Horse Halters, turn it upside down, those are Built to hold a horse up to 1,000 lbs!! Those are double stitched and have sturdy hardware. Then you use the cars/vehicle's Seat Belt to go through the harness/halter. I've used the horse halter idea since 1981 . I wish I could tell this from the Mountain Tops!! And use NATURAL Flea drops, from Good old Dollar Tree stores !! Herbal combination keeps fleas away ! Blessings everyone ☺️🙏✨

[@noldaker]

Just seeing this for first time...Went to their website found good info on other products but nothing so far about best harness for dogs in car crash test. Please post result. Thank you.

[@jacobhoyt7083]

what is the goodharnes

[@johnaayyy3424]

+sir hoyt This one: www.centerforpetsafety.org/test-results/harnesses/cps-approved-harnesses/

[@ljones2752]

+Jonathan Koshy thank you for posting that.

[@johnaayyy3424]

Leon Jones you're welcome

[@Matthew_M11]

I just don't take my dog in a car. SOLUTION FIXED!!

[@cindynguyen4299]

Matthew M how do you take them to the vet?

[@bigpappi1540]

Walk them

[@Armor23OnPatrol]

Move closer to the Vet within biking distance solution solved

[@ham-zw8qk]

Unit23OnPatrol and out you dog on a bike ?

[@ham-zw8qk]

Unit23OnPatrol And also moving is dumb just for the vet

[@melvinortiz4116]

So what's the harness that actually worked? The link on your site is broken so we can't read the list. Thank you.

[@Battle5star]

I just use a soft sided carrier and strap it to the seat with the car's own seatbelt. Admittedly this is an easier setup with my little MinPin than it would be for a larger dog.

[@nikkitokat5206]

What harness should we use then??

[@chippychin]

They said 'Sleepypod Clickit Utility' passed the test. www.cbc.ca/marketplace/blog/pet-safety-dog-harness-crash-test-results

[@joshglover2370]

Best solution to help you and your pet survive a crash? Drive carefully, pay attention to what you are doing, and avoid those around you who don't drive carefully, and avoid the whole crash all together! 😀👍

[@lesliehyde]

That's why I've got my dog traveling at all times in an infant car seat, restrained with a safety harnesses

[@LyricalLanguages]

this show is the best

[@marshasmith9713]

I am only six minutes into this video and I can already see some of the major mistakes. First of all, when we buckle children, they need to be snug with the seatbelt and car seat. The dog harness allows too much room for the dog to move around therefore in an accident they are able to catapult a certain distance due to the slack in the harness, which will allow a strap to break. I also noticed the fireman's daughter is buckled incorrectly. First off she is wearing a jacket which allows the belt to be too loose. Second, her belt is not positioned well under the arm seat of the booster which can allow it to become too loose while moving around. In an accident, Abby will have too much movement and can cause serious injuries because everything is too loose. If the speed of the vehicle is too great and Abby's belt is too loose she can be flung out of the belt in a head-on collision. Training is KEY in any seat belt situation whether it be for a dog or a child. We have a new dog and I started shopping for a seatbelt harness, and so far with how all are made giving too much slack has me very concerned. I"ll continue the video but very alarmed that even the child is not buckled correctly. Training and Advocacy !!!

[@benjay2985]

Should make it illegal to have a unbelted animal in the car. Fixed!

[@scttg5697]

Ben, put your dog in the boot.

[@KhanhLe-ib2po]

armedwatchman Bc it actually hurts everyone else

[@KhanhLe-ib2po]

armedwatchman ?

[@emilycomeau4662]

le huynh no it dosent hurt anyone lol

[@cowabunga4606]

It is in the uk now but it’s still not regulated

[@KindofaScientist]

so which brand passed your test? I cannot find any information about it on your website

[@WonderfulAkari]

The back seat of one of my cars doesn't have a head board making some products difficult. My dog hammock kinda works using the back safety handles but I am unsure whether a secure harness connection trumps airbag safety.

[@lawlicht]

Epic fail? More like epic flail!

[@fellow111411]

Are they made in China ?

[@currentlyslaying2334]

Problably

[@PokemonRangerKellyn]

I just put my big Dog in a human seatbelt . and it works

[@hammynerd2378]

Haha

[@power3655]

lol

[@HelpmegettoSubswithoutvi-rp1ys]

salt dogo a

[@jakeyoung7821]

A good addition to the red one with the carabiner clip to the harness (second to last) would be a climber carabiner clip. They have a rotating opening latch so it wouldn't break away like what happened in the crash test

[@YukisNation]

That harness wasn't meant to be attached to the seatbelt by the clip. It was meant to be attached to the entire back strap of the harness. The clip is only meant for walking and is clearly stated in the instructions not to attach the seat belt to it as it's not made to withstand crash forces.

[@jakeyoung7821]

+MoochiAndLovebug therefore they should upgrade it to a climbing carabiner clip so it can withstand those crash forces without breaking

[@YukisNation]

+Jake Young it wasn't the carabiner that broke. It was what the carabiner was a attached to. It was attached to the leash clip and not the back strap of the harness like the instructions say to do. Sorry for the confusion but the carabiner wasn't the problem. It's what the carabiner was attached to. If they followed the instructions I bet the harness would have done a lot better in the test.

[@terrigodmother]

I can't find the website episode that might have said which is the 1 dog safety vest out of 16 that passed the crash test. Does anybody know which vest it was or even where I can get that info?