Do you *actually* need the Milk Makeup Jelly Tint? Let's talk about other alternatives

[@threadsketch7267]

Thank you so much for taking the time to figure out and demonstrate the best ways to apply this product. It's frustrating because it really is an ideal formula for any makeup wearers living in climates where things are more liable to melt off or fade quickly, or wear masks and need something more transfer-resistant, but even the brand's own marketing shows application methods that are going to set buyers up for failure. I've seen plenty of others here on YT who've struggled with having it immediately stamp on their faces and refuse to blend out, and they wound up dismissing the product entirely because it seems impossible to work with. I get that showing this jelly stick being swiped on models' cheeks looks more appealing, but that's the literal worst way to put it on lol. Really appreciate your detailed breakdown of the pros and cons of the alternatives, and I love the versatility of the Rituelle De Fille blushes. I do think Milk has made an intriguing and worthwhile product; it has its place and use. When I'm in a better financial situation I was curious to play around with one of them for underpainting purposes beneath a sheer/light foundation or tinted moisturizer.

[@Nanabanana219]

I find Cha Cha Tint and Play Tint stay on well under my mask! And they're creamier than Benetint. Also usually on sale, or sometimes they have a little set of minis!

[@leahdrummond6773]

Thank you for directly comparing Chill and Benetint!

[@jillbravo5252]

I really love this product- I have three. I love how sheer they are. Perhaps it’s my experience with Asian beauty, as well as the fact that I don’t use foundation (I’m a color corrector and spot concealer lady), but I intuitively knew to either use my finger or dab on a brush. I agree that it’s best for use with “thin” products.

[@sasandbernard7862]

When we need her most, she appears! Thank you Amanda, your in-depth reviews are always incredibly helpful.

[@frescazzz7536]

I admit I’ve been intrigued by this product. It’s a cross between a push pop and the og tarte cheek stains. Thanks for the in-depth review!

[@jennibait]

love the comparisons and focus on similar products, rlly helps me be more sustainable with my purchases

[@carols.4252]

Did I need this? No. Did I buy this? Yes. Why? It brought me joy. It was more wiggly than the Undone Beauty version, but showed up the same. I got the berry shade. I mostly wanted it for swiping on in the summer and I found it terrific on the lips. I wanted that berry color. There were clear stick “face glazes” put out by Max Factor in the seventies. Ultalucent Face Glazes. Those were a bit oily. But there is really nothing new under the sun. I got the Rituel de Filles but the tablet came loose out of the compact (bad glue?) and I wound up really struggling with it.

[@starrypunk20]

If you apply by dabbing a brush on to the product and then the cheeks, its flawless. And then I find that you can actually swipe in directly onto the skin to build and it works out fine

[@RaelNikolaidis]

Wonder how long it takes for it to dry out and become an icky gummy worm in a tube? 😅

[@RaelNikolaidis]

BTW, Amanda, I would love a full review of Ritual de Fille products by you. It’s a brand that I’m very interested in but haven’t bit the bullet on. I would buy ( or not) based on your opinion . ❤

[@annab9220]

Thank you for the great review - so in depth. I am someone with cheeks that eat blush! I’m interested in the Milk product as a cruelty free alternative to the Benefit benetint ❤

[@HerGreyness]

I did - to save for spring/summer. I sweat like nobody else I have ever met. In summer heat I do not wear foundation because it slides off- I do wear blush which also wears off. So this Might be a solution for my sweat!

[@caitlinallen8400]

Same. Plus I live in the South 🥵

[@simplyellenxo95]

Thank you for actually saving us the time and the money for picking up this product…❤

[@BinaBecker]

As soon as I saw this, I was reminded of the Tarte cheek stains, which have been around (on and off) for years. I wonder if they'll finally bring them back to stay after this.

[@KateHasCats]

Tarte had a product like this years and years ago. I think they were more of this stain style than the older Milk blush sticks. However, they were much larger tubes and kind of unwieldy.

[@AmandaZ]

youre right i remember those! kind of like a cross between the milk & the undone

[@kellysblackcat]

Yes, they did bring them back a couple of years ago as limited edition but they're still available. They are so nice. I might go get another shade.

[@victoriakutcher6788]

OOOOO!! Been waiting for your review 🥰

[@lenalynn5878]

Yes! I've been waiting for this one. And did not disappoint! Exceptional reciew.

[@tina_smt]

I am sure that I had something super similar back in the day, from the drugstore. I think it was from Covergirl but can’t remember for sure. I got it for the texture back then too. I am a lover of all things gummy 😂

[@GlowITG]

I appreciate this thorough review and comparison to Benetint! I already use and enjoy Benetint, so I was curious about the new Milk product. Agree that Benetint is more user friendly. Also thanks for confirming that “chill” is basically going to be redundant with Benetint. That would have been my first choice in shade, but I ended up going with “spritz” just to have some variety. The orange wasn’t the most flattering on my lips but it was fun to try anyhow. I’m not mad I bought the Milk jelly tint but I don’t think I’ll repurchase- Benetint is still my fave!

[@stellabizani7881]

Hi Amanda! What a wonderful video and interesting formulas you featured. I can tell that for my oily skin that is literally eating blush the milk and benetint ones are going to be the best since i dont use creamy products. The product i find is also cooling, stains and has good lasting pigment is from max factor their miracle gel blushes that come in sticks and there are a few beautiful shades! Wish everyone a happy week

[@dangerbirb4981]

The Undone Beauty water blush actually works wonderfully as a lip product. I don't prefer it as a blush because it doesnt gel with my cream base but as a lip product it's gorgeous. It gives you the look of a lip stain but it's super even and not finicky whatsoever. It doesn't emphasize lip lines or flakey skin. It doesn't actually stain though. It has a better wear time than cream lipsticks but not as good as a real lip stain. The real reason I use it is because it's so effortless and the effect is very natural and pretty.

[@onipot9639]

My favourite way to apply the benefit tints is to use a flat sponge ( very specifically the kind you get in bb cream pacts ) they are thin but very bouncy / smooth and it really blends tints out seamlessly

[@onipot9639]

Also I love the colour nectar balms - they had a shade called weeping cherry that I hope returns

[@AmandaZ]

@@onipot9639 I really want that one!!

[@pappyone6062]

Glad you’re doing this because I am so tempted because it’s a stick and not a liquid. They’re sold out in the red so was waiting.

[@polinacurlywavy]

I love your reviews, they’re always thorough and honest😊 thank you so much for your work!

[@mshearer100]

I already bought it 🤦🏼‍♀️ I love it.

[@lisrisch997]

I love your videos. You’re so thorough and I appreciate the time you take to do the alternative comparisons. I literally said, “Yesss!” when you compared it to the Undone blush. Not that I own it, but I’ve considered it. Ritual de Filles is another brand I’ve only ever considered. I’m curious how the Milk would compare to the Tarte blush stains. I still own a way-too-old one of those in Blushing Bride from maybe 2012?!? 😅 Anyway, great job. Your content is top notch. ❤

[@Nanabanana219]

Thank you for another thorough video! This is definitely a novelty product that I don't need to spend the money on. I love buying new blushes (even though I really don't need them), but I'm quite happy to skip this. I have Cha Cha tint and Play Tint - they are gorgeous. And you're right, they play so nicely with all textures of base! And they're creamier than Benetint as you said. I know some people don't like how watery Benetint is, so I highly recommend giving the others a try! What eyeshadow were you wearing when you applied the first Rituel de Fille blush? So pretty! 😍

[@Marie-jz1qw]

This was so helpful, thank you so much for the way you explain everything :)))

[@Dashomin]

I remembered we had something like this back in korea in 2014 from the brand Tony moly or was it etude house I forgot but they discontinued it

[@dawnsaito2992]

Thank you I really appreciate the video. I love the benefit and use that as a lip stain too. I have the undone and like that as well. . I think you showing and explaining how to use was the best. I have used Daniel Sandler’s liquid blushes and various Korean lip/cheek stains, seeing how you would best apply this is very useful. I use the Chanel Water Fresh Tint face as well as their cheek and it so I’m thinking this would be a good product together. Thanks for the video.

[@AmandaZ]

omg yes!! chanel water fresh tint wish any of these would be so so pretty

[@ruthy102]

Love this video! You look gorgeous.Your hair and the color is magnificent!

[@AmandaZ]

aw thank you so so much!

[@zozofab02]

I just caved the other day and bought two of the shades. Chill I wanted also and got it from the milk website since it’s sold out on Sephora. I favor a light base in general and am excited to try these.

[@AmandaZ]

I hope you enjoy!!

[@kelliebennett9932]

Adore these videos!!!! Benetint is amazing!!! I liked undone but Benetint won!!!

[@TallMChannel]

Am I the only one who saw the promo and had a hard NO reaction?! I mean I enjoyed the video but there is no way I would pay money on something like this 🤷

[@catherinelynnfraser2001]

I’m with you. I don’t like the hype, the stain or the high blush colour.

[@catrice1296]

Im just worried about the integrity of the product over time. I mean maybe its fine but its jelly textured so idk

[@sbg1911]

It will DRY out before you have a chance to even finish it!

[@maddie4190]

I’m not into it for the gimmick at all, but I saw a girl wearing it on tik tok, and it left the most beautiful look on her skin. Looking for things in a formula I like and that has more product that give a similar look

[@catrice1296]

@@maddie4190 benefit benetint gives the same look and lasts an eternity unless u spill it all out 😅

[@amyamy8177]

Would you consider doing a video on the best lip stains?

[@sweetGGbaby]

Thank you for the video, so helpful! I am curious if makeup removing oil can get rid of the stain, i.e. to clean your finger tip

[@maryfrancess93]

Thanks for this, because I was so taken back by the gentle flush and dewey finish. I'm very picky about blush formula so I was looking for dupes. Because no way am I spending $24 for one make up item.

[@ronigillenson3328]

Hi there! I love your videos! Would you do a review about the new about face foundation? I’m really curious to hear your thoughts.

[@AmandaZ]

coming very soon be on the lookout! itll be my next video coming

[@Hilary19997]

Admit I haven’t watched yet, but the staining feature of this product makes it a yes for me. Can’t wait till mine get here. But then again-I’m blushed obsessed and use like 4 to 5 with my daily makeup.

[@paulagrove2193]

What about Pixi Beauty blushes? Amanda, do you use any Pixi products?

[@arielfeasts]

Hey Amanda! I was wondering if you’ve tried the Ultra brand stains. The shades look really pretty. I’ve been thinking about picking some up. And they’re only 10 bucks. Waiting for another sale since ulta brand tends to get reduced often.

[@neggieyaghooti]

I have all the colors in this and this is a beautiful product. I don’t get all the reviews warning about the blend etc, it’s blends out beautifully even when applied directly to the face. It’s not difficult to use at all. Everyone is freaking out about how exactly to use it and I don’t get the alarm at all. It is easy to use, it blends out wonderfully, no warning labels necessary.

[@ripley1828]

You have what …. cranberry sauce in a can? Hilarious. Wonder if this product would be good for sport? Maybe also over the Chanel water-based makeup.

[@jyn88]

I like lip stains but in a stick/solid format. It's so hard to find! Anyone have recommendations let me know! Thank you. I don't know any other brand besides Holika Holika Water Vibe Tint. I don't like liquids or using wands. PH lipsticks are nice. I have them in traditional bullets but they stain all similarly, a hot pink/magenta color. These jelly tints by Milk Makeup might be what I am looking for in a lipstick (don't think I'll use it for my cheeks). Not too thrilled at the price though.

[@anniecinnie7160]

Yess that's exactly a reason why this caught my eye. I want a stain in a stick. I feel like the staining waterproof power is better in a stick form and easier to apply both on cheeks and lips.

[@jyn88]

@@anniecinnie7160 agree. better to apply and control the amount or pigmentation.

[@awalker127]

Far too many stipulations to make this product work ideal. I only feel compelled to purchase it just so I can giggle it, otherwise, it's not desirable in my opinion. I've lived through cheek stains once already and I hated them then too😂

[@kateliness2]

I miss the Tarte stick blushes from a million years ago. I tried the undone, and it removed my foundation :(

[@AmandaZ]

that damn slippy texture can really do that! I totally can see that happening

[@gardenhappy4]

Maybe it is just the shade used here, but this blush does not look very pigmented, even with all the layers Amanda applied.

[@AmandaZ]

the wet sponge does soak up product! A brush is a better bet I think for building pigment

[@gardenhappy4]

@@AmandaZ Yep, the brush application was helpfully mentioned in the video, but it still did not seem to make a significant difference. Perhaps it was due to the bright lighting that you mentioned. Maybe that dulled the look of more product applied. Regardless, the video was super helpful and I appreciate all the work you put into it.

[@rachs1830]

Hi Amanda, is the reboot foundation being discontinued? 😩

[@AmandaZ]

I think so :/

[@alja_jo]

Milk Makeup is a brand that should have gone bankrupt a long time ago. They released a skin tint with an awful roller on top and that’s just one example. Their mascara is the worst thing that has happened to eyelashes since mud around the eyes and in general their packaging is just a pile of BS. The only descent thing they had the last 5 years is a gloss/lip balm hybrid but yet again packaging is like a 5 grader’s glue. This brand should just stop harassing us with its awful, low quality makeup. Thanks.

[@marye813]

This product seems like a lot work to use with optimal results. Unless it's fabulous why bother.

[@AmandaZ]

I totally get that! I think there are certainly easier products out there but I do enjoy it

[@jennys_wonderland]

Scent on the milk jelly tint?

[@cindicleee]

❤❤

[@catherinelynnfraser2001]

I do want your take on this but the product doesn’t interest me at all. I like a softer blush and I like powders mostly. I don’t like using the same product on my lips and my face. I would prefer this as a lip product but I wouldn’t want that big stick put the blush on.

[@AmandaZ]

I appreciate you watching!!

[@ndisney]

Which one of the Milk has the exact shade of Benetint? I really love benetint color but i dont want to carry around a liquid product. I wanted to try Milk jelly stain. All i need to know is the shade. Can anyone help please?

[@chadr1856]

i would say burst & chill are the most similar! burst is cooler/pinker than chill so ig it’s up to your preference!

[@jenniferturin2414]

what magic do you have on your nails in this video...?? thank you!

[@AmandaZ]

Dior nail glow!!

[@lindsaycooke361]

Glycerin just makes my lips peal

[@JH-kw8zy]

I just watched bc I like your content. It looks like gummies so I will not put that on my face. Any edible makeup or skincare is an itchy feeling hard pass.

[@AmandaZ]

thank you for watching !!

[@cristinag3507]

I'll admit that the formula and overall effect of the Milk Makeup stain interests me, but I personally cannot abide by the packaging. It looks childish and it doesn't look sophisticated. Maybe they're trying to hit a different demographic, but it looks.....cheap?

[@unburdenedcatcreature]

I think their aim is overall to be cute! Sophistication and maturity really isn’t their brand. The packaging reminds me of Maybelline Baby Lips.

[@cristinag3507]

Probably true @@unburdenedcatcreature

[@lookingatdaisies9901]

I love glossy luxurious packaging and I love cute, so I was very attracted, 😅 but I'm stopping myself because that's not a reason to drop this much money on a mere lip tint colour (I only use powder blush)

[@VMDEWBeauty]

Thank you