Does Indonesia Welcome Expats?

[@MaxChernov]

What type of foreigners should come to Bali?

[@cregitindonesia]

No matter where you come from, no matter what race, as long as you behave well and can respect each other, then we will also respect and treat you very well. ❤

[@awansetiyawan8229]

Type of people who love culture.traditions..not party people..

[@awieong39]

​@@awansetiyawan8229 All type of the foreigners with the right permits according for their needs have the same rights to visit Bali, its backed by the government laws.

[@Liburankuliner]

Everyone can come to Bali / indonesia, in Indonesia everyone is equal ,just behave & be respectful to our tradition,our culture , don't be rude & arrogant.

[@M.B.1001]

Not Russians.

[@AgustianYusufPerdana]

message to tourists, I hope to respect Balinese culture there, that culture was built from our ancestors in Bali, so I hope tourists respect it, don't be insulted or called strange, thank you

[@jotstar16]

Respect works both ways!🙏 Also respect nature, animals… look how dogs are treated by locals. Look how garbage thrown all over the place🤦🏻‍♂️💔 Look how local selling all land, destroying cliffs etc. Maybe why there’s lack respect from foreigners towards locals as see locals have no respect own place. Just my views/opinion how I see it looking in & why I think foreigners show less respect. It’s in no way an insult, just opinion.

[@Desy.Ginting]

@@jotstar16 no dear, respect work bothways is only in your own family/country. in another new place, follow them rules first, because you are a guest. Learn how they behave and all, once again you are a guest. i went to japan, i learn their way, because i was their guest. i went to singapore,malaysia,etc, i follow them rules, because again i am their guest. i went to country to country living/studying/etc some of them are suck, but i follow their rules, because I am their guest. so if you are a guest in anywhere, just follow their fking rules. be compliant or if you cannot just stay at your own house so you can make ur own rules.

[@pissedoffcrudeli]

@@jotstar16can u white fvcks stop with your white saviour bullshit? So by your logic, when I go visit New York, which is a waaaaaaayyyy nastier place than Bali (crime every where, trash every where, homeless every where, smell like a piss every where, rats every where, stray cats and dogs every where etc) I can act rude and disrespect the locals yanks because obviously they do not care about NY at all? Sounds stupid no? Exactly, thats how stupid your white saviour bullshit is. Just simply dont come to my country with your western disease. Kindly EF OFF😂

[@missoctavia83]

What? So if you come to a country who some people there make bad decision, it means you can treat all local people badly? So for people that dancing nak3d in the temple, it's actually the local fault? I think your opinion is just weird. Western people, some of them also have bad behavior, so it is okay if I come to their country and insult the local people or dance nak3d inside the church?

[@skyview1956]

Foreigners can purchase property in Bali through land use rights as long as they meet the requirements set by the Indonesian government. There are several land ownership options that can be taken by foreigners in Bali, namely Right to Use, Right to Build and Ownership Rights. Right to Use is a right granted by the state to Indonesian citizens or Indonesian legal entities to use land owned by the state or by other people who have rights to the land for a certain period of time. Foreigners can obtain Right to Use land in Bali through a company established in Indonesia Right to Build is the right to build and own a building on land owned by another person for a certain period of time. Foreigners can obtain Right to Build on Balinese land on the condition that the land is owned by an Indonesian or an Indonesian legal entity. Right to Own is the right of full ownership of the land and the buildings on it. Right to Own can only be owned by Indonesian citizens and Indonesian legal entities. Therefore, foreigners cannot have Right to Own land in Bali, but can have Right to Use or Right to Build. Foreigners are only allowed to own property in Indonesia in the form of a right of use for a maximum of 30 years and can be extended for 20 years. However, there are several alternative ways that can be done such as establishing a local company in Indonesia and having ownership rights over the company.

[@jonlbdg]

Excellent summary … the only point I would add is that even when a foreigner sets up or holds share in a company it is considered a PT w/ PMA participation- so you still can’t own the land Hak Milik (only Hak Guna Bangunan) as you describe above 🙏🏻

[@heavymetalrox268]

You wanna be RESPECTFUL? Learn the local language, don't just talk.

[@nasdean7166]

When you go other country follow their law, dont think your law

[@mursalimsalim2769]

Its normal because everywhere you we go to other country must respect local culture tradition and law ...

[@putrisekar1969]

A kitas is a temporary stay permit. You are not allowed to work or do business. You need a work permit on top of a kitas. And register with the tax office etc.

[@DiniKusuma]

I used to work in NHK's representative office in Jakarta - it's Japan national broadcaster btw - so I had several Japanese expats working there, and I was in charge as general affair that basically had to "taking care" of these expats (plus families) to work and stay in Indonesia accordingly to the law. I wasn't the one who's expert of these stuffs, so usually foreign companies always have their own "agent or representative" to handle rule/regulation/law in Indonesia, including tax, immigration, banking system, etc for example : NHK works with Ernst and Young (EY) to handle everything related to tax ... and it's my job to make sure everything about these expats, were well reported to EY - so that there will be no problem happens to them ... and this goes the same related to things with the immigrations, banks, insurances, or even the police My point is ... for foreigners who want to live or open business in Indonesia, make sure you have realible local who can handle everything related to local authorities - just imagine you want to camp in a jungle and you'll be dead if you don't bring someone who can guide you what to do, lol 😂 Indonesian's law is very tricky indeed ... and sometimes doesn't make anysense So, do believe me ... let the local (who you trust) to handle it ... also make sure this person knows how to talk with authorities, plus has "strong" faith and responsibility to do the right way The thing about Indonesian laws ... bc sometimes it's too complicated, ppl tend to choose short cut such as bribing the authorities - be careful, bc this could push you into even deeper problems ... meaning : don't bribe, even when you think it's ok

[@johnnygalt7346]

Its third world for a reason, you take the high risk to invest your life and time in such countries with tribal societies

[@DiniKusuma]

@@johnnygalt7346 third world for you bc you have no money to go here ... yet Indonesia one of the fastest economy growth in the world Just live ure life there in your "first world" country with no money ... enjoy 👍

[@DiniKusuma]

@@johnnygalt7346 ok, just don't come here, then ... easy 👍 as matter of fact ... the "third world" country u mentioned, is rich enough with abundance of natural resources that actually doesn't need "first world" countries - this "third world" country is one of those that have fastest economy growth globally and what can the "first world" countries do about it ?? fun fact : many investors come to do business here ... why ?? bc their "first world" countries have a significant decline in economy ... enjoy the irony bro 👍

[@DiniKusuma]

@@johnnygalt7346 easy ... don't go/invest in Indonesia then ... 👍 but why many investors from "first world" countries still passionately invest here ?? Ow ... that's bc these "first world" countries are now experiencing stagnant economy - even declining in some countries - while the "third world" country you mentioned, is now one of those with fastest economic growth globally ... What an irony 🤔

[@clairechloe5294]

​@@DiniKusuma - Well said. 👍💯👍

[@griffinina]

To me, she sounded like she came to Bali only to escape the unstable situation in her country. It's like she's worry about staying in Russia because of the ongoing war, then heard people saying Bali is awesome, and the next thing she did was moving to Bali.

[@novandypramana]

One more time, respect Indonesian wherever you are, not only in Bali. Don't ever make mess in my Country

[@_hob_]

As a foreigner living in Bali I feel embarrassed for this interview. Also the statements she makes about KITAS starting at 16:20 are simply wrong. That video could definitely lead to her own deportation.

[@Jeff-r3g6v]

She fell for the agent trick I guarantee she is on investors kitas with a fake pma

[@buleinbali2634]

Ive been living in Bali for 6 years and I have a complete different opinion on some topics that were spoken about... maybe should interview more than just one person to get a more general opinion about what life is like in Bali.

[@masbrewok2582]

A Rich Russians point of view

[@putrisekar1969]

Fully agree. This interview not make sense and give many wrong impressions. She clearly lives in the Russian Bali bubble.

[@dhanushkaekanayake5270]

Think tourists need to keep their cultures to themselves and respect and not look down on other cultures.

[@bossskucing8308]

I'm indonesian and i want tourist "kéré" out of Bali!!😉😊😚

[@adamabteknikinformtka5623]

😅

[@Jeff-r3g6v]

Iya bule kerek bohong kitas

[@AyuJessieM]

I want Bule that stay long in Bali, they also have to pay “Tax”. Commonly, Those Bule trick our Tourist Visa to avoid Tax and to manipulate Staying Permit. As they stay for a very long time in Bali, they also consume energy, Gasoline, and public service that are subsidized by our taxes

[@sintariasilalahi]

​@@AyuJessieMsetuju sekali mbak, enak enak aja bule itu lama lama tinggal, pakai bbm, bbm subsidi, harusnya dibedain itu, lama lama mereka keenakan sangking murahnya

[@aminreger-by6kd]

😂😂😂Padahal banyak sebagian bule kere sok sok'an bodo nekat aja maklum mata uang kita rendah makaya di mafaatin itu

[@Neillusion]

2 foreigners discussing lifestyle and culture about a country they spent less than a few years in 😂😂😂 peak comedy.

[@renvilsekawan]

Bali menarik banyak turis karena budaya dan alamnya, kemudian turis datang dan tidak mau menghargai budaya dibali, sepertinya mereka yg bersikap seperti itu sama saja dengan orang yg tidak paham dengan konsep "sumber daya berkelanjutan" Lestarikan budayanya dengan menghormatinya, lestarikan keindahan alamnya agar selamanya bisa dinikmati oleh semua umat manusia di planet ini, agar bali tetap menjadi serpihan surga di bumi.

[@ardi08]

Tapi orang Balinya jg banyak yg buang sampah sembarangan, atau pemerintahnya yg biarin pembangunan masal asal2an....wajar dikritik keras sm turis asing, malah para bulenya yg inisiatif gerakan pemungutan sampah2 di sungai2 di Bali....miris

[@wonderboy855]

Wherever you go always respect that culture of the country and you can enjoy your life

[@JonatanRamhoej]

I agree 100% about what she says about Europe vs Asia in terms of what I also perceive to be possible. I have the EXACT same feeling of a "lower ceiling" in terms of what's allowed and/or possible to do there vs here. Really cool interview!

[@mibu9500]

Having investor Kitas and working is not a trap. The rule is clear. Buying land and not doing the due diligence in advance is not a trap. Both is ignorant.

[@drarunselvakumar5009]

Bali people are lovely. Great culture.

[@masbrewok2582]

Wow....she has been in Bali 3 years.... still a visitor. Locals are not always Balinese. Bali has changed since the many thousands of Russians decided to move there. I wonder if she has taken the time to learn local Bahasa. Welcome to little Moscow...not Bali

[@ardi08]

But Russians in reality not that much in mumbers compared to Australians or Chinese

[@Desy.Ginting]

"legally not". well yall know its not legal from the first time, logically. but act like you can work it out from the first time, that not very logical mindset or structure of russian/european mindset i suppose. more like the cunning side of people. And please STOP calling yall self an Expat. most of yous come to bali using tourist visa. yall more like a tourist, some just a simple immigrant who like doing so many activities to act busy.

[@ricoadisasmita6449]

i think i know what might be the thing you both didn't understand about what the local thinks.. imagine.. you live in island, you build the infrastructure, the environment, and start your own community and start producing many kind of products for everyone.. but then, here come strangers into your island and start making the same product as you do from your natural resources too! which they sell it to your community (of course) how would you feel? its like an alien invasion trying to take away your home and everything else😂

[@TimelyTurtle]

Tourists should Respect the Local Culture

[@andreandree4384]

They don't unfortunately.

[@rdtrix]

there are many foreigners (too many), including Russians, who married Indonesians since before the Chernovs were single. Ask these immigrants. This young lady knows a lot about Bali, but not enough about Indonesia. If you understand the difference, you will understand the difference between foreign immigrant, an expat, or a long-term tourist. And I only see long-term tourists in this video.

[@masbrewok2582]

I dont think she know not all the locals in Bali are Balinese. Does she not know about Java and other islands. She is just on a holidays there.

[@rdtrix]

@@masbrewok2582 if these new arrivals only trace the mix marriages between the people from various Indonesian tribes and the Dutch and the Chinese, the differences in meanings between a bule and an Indo, or a Chinese in Indonesia with a Peranakan, they would approach the issues in a more nuanced way. So, yeah, a long-term tourist, wrapped in the generic 'foreigner' aiming to dwell in issues best solved by real expats (people who arrive by invitation) or real immigrants (who wishes to live as Indonesian).

[@imadelai]

Mutual respect ,hope locals can treat foreigner equally,don't cheat us,double charge us,and do what you promised ,dont break your promise.

[@qilimercurial5116]

Respect local first ..

[@imadelai]

@@qilimercurial5116 already respect,even cheated by locals,I forgive them.i travel to Bali more than 40 times.

[@qilimercurial5116]

@@imadelai just respect more…

[@imadelai]

@@qilimercurial5116 ok,ok,will see how you promote your business and tourism.

[@swapnilgedam2881]

Hello @Max Chernov Big fan of your videos with different content from India. Keep up the good work.

[@ekaterina_spirit]

Gorgeous, talented, self-made and aware woman. Good vibes and thoughts in this interview about boundaries in our minds and internal freedom. Thanks for this guest!

[@bamabotak]

if you want the real opinion from the expat.. come to jakarta.. jakarta have more expat than bali.. i mean real expat with real serious bussiness.. not digital nomad or long term tourist..

[@Jeff-r3g6v]

She is getting scammed by the agents no kitas cost that much money and to have a digital nomad visa you need an employment contract or if investors itas 10 billion in shares. Agents and notary’s all lie on paperwork and they won’t help is always pay pay

[@CadStr]

01:15 min….its not only about the local traditions, its about other more simple reasons😅..man will understand There is no many foregoing girl being date to local guys as well for the same simple reason😅

[@dhnitatau]

When in Rome, do as the Romans do.

[@rushdanr70]

I was in Bali in June during a heavy downpour and saw some locals persistently trying their luck with a white European girl. After repeated advances, she threatened to go to the police. It’s a risky situation for anyone to intervene-you wouldn’t want to end up in serious trouble or worse. Indonesians often have strong beliefs in the supernatural, and sometimes their tempers can flare quickly without much rational thinking. It’s interesting how their behavior can seem different when working abroad. In their own country, they can act with a certain confidence, as if it’s their own domain.

[@adhapriyo]

Untuk turis yang berlibur ke Bali, hargailah adat istiadat Bali, jangan jadi orang gila disana, catat!

[@abansalify]

Do you go to church naked or in swim suit? Same applies here.

[@impopquiz]

Sometimes u dunno ur near one is what they meant, not going into one. 😅

[@kurniajaya1989]

Balinesse is the best peolple, local communities tend to be open unless you create a closed colony and don't mix and contribute to them. Social problems will arise if you don't respect local culture and often cause commotion, social conflicts that often occur in other places are often caused by these gaps or inequalities.

[@andreandree4384]

"Guys want to try!!.". In my experience, lot of western boys like to play with local girls, not only in Bali but most of asia.. Its sad and disgusting :(..

[@Equ1n0x88]

07:50 what she just said ... makes no sense whatsoever.

[@IndustrisasiIndonesia]

9:06 Westerners seek more freedom in life Indonesians seek more comfort in life

[@yose838]

the conclusion; You can't do anything without money, even if you are smart, intelligent and have many talents

[@markstevens6682]

Smart woman…. She’ll go far!

[@DYTIII]

It's rare for Balinese girls to date foreigners. It's getting more frequent nowadays because of all the digital nomads / expats living in Bali now and because of online dating. But the amount of Balinese girls dating Western men is quite low, especially when compared to Thailand or Philippines.

[@ardi08]

Yes cause Balinese are Hindus which only few in West.

[@alansabelberg8378]

This guy again speaking to someone has no clue. Speak to the locals ,ask what they think about the Russians and Ukraine people.

[@bogdanoff4019]

You know she's full of shit when you start asking her about what's the meaning of life. lol

[@pchsdptr7681]

WHY DONT YOU INTERVIEW HER IN RUSSIAN SO SHE CAN EXPRESS HERSELF BETTER AND JUST ADD SUBS.. ITS BETTER FOR THE BOTH OF YOU.. OK CAPSLOCK BROKEN

[@introvertical_1931]

U come to bali u come to Indonesia

[@dwigunarto2091]

If tourists want to be more free and a little wild just go to Thailand, it may not be tougher than Bali.

[@AsmahHarun-l1m]

What a boring interview. She can't define things clearly ..

[@JoshuahnJackstonburg]

My traditional Balinese wife and I have been happily married for 16 years now. It isn't an uncommon thing at all here in Bali.

[@Jewel671]

Tricky balinese

[@JoshuahnJackstonburg]

@@Jewel671 Traditional

[@ardi08]

So you converted to her religion or she converted to your religion?

[@JoshuahnJackstonburg]

@@ardi08 i converted - not that religion is relevant - just love.

[@ardi08]

@@JoshuahnJackstonburg But in Indonesia ppl who wanted to get married should have on same religion at first

[@agusfirmansyah35]

In indonesia no matter the religion, no sex before marriage

[@myne00]

Everywhere says that. Everywhere has prostitution.

[@agusfirmansyah35]

@@akunakal77 bro, what’s the good and the bad lu tau lah, i just try to tell the good thing, save the bad for you lah

[@agusfirmansyah35]

@@myne00 so what is your choice?

[@far7746]

​@@akunakal77Anda boleh tahu tapi sex before marriage tolong jangan dinormalkan di negara kita. Di negara2 barat banyak single parent yang mayoritas cewek gara2 sex before marriage dianggap normal. Kasihan yang cewenya, kasihan anaknya.

[@meeveryday123]

Liar, am indonesian. Agus is embarassing try islamizing everything

[@prasadsirdesai8349]

Foreigners wherever Going the Shits there they thought we are Brodeminded But Less understanding anther Culture Bali Culture are Different then Anther South Asian Peopled Like Indonesia Jakarta So Respect to them and Don’t put ur Dirty nose to there

[@emmanuellavaux6933]

Dang i want to live in bali but i hope locals are honest people

[@MickG90]

honestly you youtubers ruin bali.

[@justviewer7021]

Okay just for tourist things only. Not genuine type of international standard of business to consider ! Unless thats the culture of things to be assimilate if intergrity is not of your concern.

[@putrisekar1969]

Love your vids Max. But with this one you go wrong. Should do better research first.

[@MaxChernov]

I need to know why

[@putrisekar1969]

@@MaxChernov many reasons. She lives in the Canggu bubble and 'pay' for it. A kitas is not a permit to do whatever you want, although many 'pay' to do whatever they want. In Bali nothing is what it seems it is. Anyway how she enjoy her life here and that's good. But there is Canggu and surroundings and all the rest is Bali. But she is not representative for what expat life in Bali really is. I am a +30yr European expat in Bali, married with a Balinese. Seen that done that. Conclusion; Bali is the best place in the world. Have seen all your vids, and well done. Expat life is an interesting niche.

[@idzhamishak9877]

​@@putrisekar1969 you say that you're European, but your name are Indonesian Common name. Makes me hard to believe 😂😂😂

[@CarlosDeOry]

3 years ago was when Bali started to be a bad place to be.

[@melaniemoka]

Banyak sekali orang rusia ,ukraina melarikan diri ke bali ....ikuti aturan yang ada ,jangan ingin menguasai karena orang indonesia bisa bertindak tegas

[@royanjunior9782]

cool ❤

[@zipzikin7084]

Locals just not to try an wasting time,wasting money,wasting Emotion and energys

[@3blinds]

Message to Locals: stop using foreigners!

[@ardi08]

Using foreigners in term of what?

[@85ewan]

back to Bahasa English subtitles i see

[@idzhamishak9877]

Yo man, you have to learn other language for your benefits. Don't be stuck up in your own bubble 😅😅.

[@85ewan]

@@idzhamishak9877 what do you mean? im already fluent in a few languages and learning a few more languages. I made that comment because I thought they gonna continue with the Indonesian subtitles

[@idzhamishak9877]

@@85ewan what i wanna say is learn English without Subs.

[@harpreetsinghnagi]

Bali is a beautiful city, and it's having a great culture. I am lucky that i visited bali and enjoyed my holidays in peace.

[@masbrewok2582]

Bali is an Island made up of many towns and cities.

[@thepainphantom]

The locals' mindset is too simplistic (for better or worse): get married and all of your life troubles simply go poof😂

[@ardi08]

Lol while raising family and children are expensive, and buying house

[@thepainphantom]

@@ardi08 Hard pass lol

[@idzhamishak9877]

Facts! They just wannabe in their own bubbles. They dreamed alot . Hahaha 😂😂

[@5u1ton]

Keren 🇮🇩👍`

[@idzhamishak9877]

Do you understand or not what are they talking in this video?

[@jambrongmbah]

there is way indonesian people to care of her family because who want everyone hurt your family???

[@adesylvi232]

Why Hooman doesn't understand meaning of "Respect Each Others"? ... Try to understand and learning in process to better adapted and adopted as Foreign-er come to Ones' culture, would be Great will y Honey..☕

[@PuteraMohdZulhaziqesqandar]

JUST LEAVE IMMIGRANTS

[@katherineevangelia11]

A Strong Woman