Don't WASTE $3000 on this Nonsense!

In the market for the fabled 5150 Block Letter amp? Don't waste $3000 before looking at what Peavey has to offer.
Get it at this Sweetwater Afilliate LInk: sweetwater.sjv.io/DK1kWb
Get Singularity Virtual Bass at: spectredigital.com/plugins/si...
Get the Norther Mauler at: smgpedals.com/en-ca
Disclosure: Peavey sent me the amp. No cash has changed hands. It's unclear if I'm keeping it, and I really don't think they'll be sending me anything else after they see this video!!
About Spectre Sound Studios:
I'm Glenn Fricker, engineer here at Spectre Sound Studios. I love making records, and after doing it for sixteen years, I want to pass on what I've learned. On my channel you can find tutorials on how to record guitar, bass, real drums and vocals. There's reviews and demos of tube amps, amp sims, drums, mics, preamps, outboard gear, Electric Guitar, Bass Guitar, and plugin effects.
We've covered Moon on the Water, played Bias FX, given you the absolute best in Stupid Musician Texts, ranted & raved about bass guitar, and this channel is where The Eagle has Landed.
Everything you've wanted to learn about recording Hard Rock & Heavy Metal can be found right here on this channel!
I also respond to your comments & questions: The best make it into the SMG Viewer's Comments series of videos. Loads of fun, lots of laughs.
Thanks for checking out my channel & please subscribe!

[@SpectreSoundStudios]

Almost 50% of Spectre Sound viewers are NOT subsribed. I need your help to grow this channel! Please hit the Subscribe button!

[@MrUltraworld]

Made in the US tubes?

[@bobonilla8443]

@@MrUltraworld /real deal?/thanx 4.D Fyi.....

[@Tixoxod102]

Maybe if You take two 5150s, result be the same. For ex - because of components tolerance.

[@Dave-Rough-Diamond-Dunn]

No chance of that, I'm too poor to get ripped off! 😥

[@Funkybassuk]

Legendary comment

[@adhaskym.a9536]

Same here.

[@destroyerdestroy87]

The IRS agent with AR 15s enters chat: are you sure about that??

[@VPROXE-HELLRAISER]

Welcome to the club

[@donbishop6994]

This comment wins the internet for the day. I wish I'd have thought of it myself. Cheers 🍻

[@vmx23]

Even the amp designer James Brown has gone on record many times that the non block letter is the exact same circuit as the block letters and sound the same yet people are still buying into the myth of block letters being a holy grail.

[@tortillaman2491]

James Brown made amps? I thought he just sang the funk.

[@kosmo926]

Transformers were different in them and Peavey only realized this when making the infective head. The news has only come to light this year in a few other youtube videos.

[@trevor4533]

@@kosmo926 No. The transformers between the Block letter, Signature, and 6505 all use the same exact transformer. The manufacturer of the output transformer changed at some point after it became the 6505. Edit: the specs remained exactly the same after the manufacturer change.

[@thelefthandofcreation1617]

@@tortillaman2491Why do you think they called him "the hardest working man in show business"??

[@rosskrause3926]

And besides just the Block lettering and the 2nd version the EVH signature on the front panel..James Brown said they are the same but some of the earliest block letter amps had the Peavey branded power tubes and they started using whatever they could get when the Peavey labeled tubes started running out...I sold my EVH signature version right before Eddie died for $575 and it was in about perfect condition...then I looked a few places online after he passed and saw some prices as high as $15-$1600 dollars.

[@reallyniceaudio]

I think if you did the same experiment with 2 5150's you might find similar results. Don't forget there are tolerances in all the components in the circuit. So even a slight change in tolerances especially with hi gain, a slight mismatch in drive levels can produce more pronounced null test. A better experiment would be to send the source to both heads and then bring them back to the DAW and phase flip the second head. Then you can adjust the knobs to see how much you can null them out. I bet you could get better null results this way.

[@slaughterhammer]

Wanted to say the same. Especially the potis are notorious for having bad tolerances.

[@stefanwerner5799]

That would be my guess too. The frequency plot between the 5150 and the 6505, those differences can be easily be explained by tolerances in coupling capacitors and would be found just as well between two 5150s that rolled off the assembly line on the same day.

[@kennethc2466]

Anyone with any Electrical Engineering background know th old saying, 100 pennies equal a dollar. Let's say those pennies are components. Now, take each penny and +/- 10% from each and every one. Now, a 'dollar' is anywhere from 90 cents, to a buck ten. Nearly all production amps use CHEAP AS DIRT 10%+/- tolerance components, including the power transformers. No two amps can sound the same, as it's impossible by those tolerances alone. My marine transducers have to use +/-1% components, or by 2000 feet of water, I'd have an inaccurate reading for the tolerance the mappers want. The oscilloscope doesn't lie, yet youtubers do. Everyday.

[@samp3413]

Capacitors in the 5150 would have also drifted over time compared to the 6505, no doubt this would have also contributed to the differences observed on the scope.

[@jordanburrill7182]

It's not just manufacturers that have to suppress the desire to cheapen products. Parts suppliers have to do the same, but are harder to catch cheating.

[@FrankiePhoenix]

I had my eyes closed while listening to the test and heard no difference in the full mix. Glad we have all these tools to help tweak the extra, barely audible sounds that can muddy the mix. Thanks for doing the test!

[@alrecks619]

at the end of the day, it's how they sound in context that matters.

[@smashallpots1428]

our eye lids are very powerful tools i wish more people knew how to use them

[@Lieutenant_Dude]

Same here. Particularly in the full mix.

[@AdaptivePhenix]

I had my eyes closed and heard horrible farting sounds. Kinda expecting guitar sounds I guess.

[@smashallpots1428]

@@AdaptivePhenix You might want to get that check out by a doctor.

[@A.J.99]

All the electronic components like resistors and condensers have some value tolerance (5% typically), so even two amps of the same model can sound slightly different. Metallica's sound engineer told that the time they used the Mesaboogie tube amps for the live gigs they had two identical amp sets and they still sounded slightly different, so the mixing engineer had to tweak the settings on the mixing console depending on which of the two amp sets was being used for the gig.

[@milamber319]

yeah i was going to say the same thing. Manufacturing tolerances are a thing, thats why you need things like paired mics because they need to sort the production into pairs because they can vary quite a bit. They don't manufacture them at the same time perfectly matched, they measure a bunch of already produced ones to find ones that are very close and sell those as paired. any pair is still going to be slightly different from each other but very different from another pair. All electronics and even all other manufactured good are like that.

[@kitko33]

Which is why today Metallica uses Fractals live. Same sound, every night.

[@KennethRrvik]

Is this slightly different noticable in a properly conducted blind test? As an electronic engineer, my opinion is that if so, fire your circuit designer. He knows not what he does.

[@milamber319]

@@KennethRrvik I mean, you heard the initial playback. Without the mirror tests and close spectral analysis you wouldn't be able to tell. And on gear that is 40 year old designs and manufactured 3 decades apart if they are that close we can put that down to manufacturing tolerances. Perhaps some wear.

[@johnarcher9480]

@@KennethRrvik The difference in the tubes alone could be enough to have those differences. Tubes age.

[@x3a3x3]

The aging and tolerance on all individual electronic components could account for the small sonic difference. I bet if you test 3 or 4 original 5150 against each other you will see some difference too based on usage and tolerances

[@jcrosslin8]

Glenn, bongs don't make people stupid, the power of suggestion makes people stupid. I've noticed that most of the guys I know that aren't great players and/or songwriters are the ones that have their self worth tethered to the gear they own/have access to.

[@DamageInc86]

They sure don't help the situation.

[@docjikar]

I would LOVE to see a comparison like that between the 5150, 6505, and the Joyo Vivo. Wouldn't even have to be a long video, just a "hey look at this graph" sort of thing. Love the video, keep up the good work!

[@pb25193]

Finally a modded vivo

[@GlennJimenez]

Joyo vivo sounds like a fun weekend

[@NuclearHeadshot]

Featuring Nickelback

[@prehistoricpoodle]

Then there should also be the "modern" 5150 III from the EVH brand, as it's the one the VIVO seems to try replicating (white color).

[@docjikar]

@prehistoricpoodle Agreed.

[@bobmartino8073]

Great video. Both incredible amps. I have owned both and neither of them ever let me down. I currently have an EVH Iconic and it stands up to both of these every day.

[@claytongouin5605]

Interesting results. I'm not an electrical engineer either, but I suppose that parts tolerances or component drifting due to age could partially explain the differences you found. You might find similar differences in two 6505's or two 5150 block letters just due to a +/- tolerance difference in components. But in the full band mix I did not hear a enough of a difference to think that the 6505 could not hold a candle to the 5150 signature. I'm still with you on the fact that if you want to make the 5150/6505 sound different, change you cab, speakers, mic type, and mic placement. Either way, the mix sounded wicked and that is the most important factor. Not the brand name or the badge.

[@xwasssabix2347]

I suspect in this case the transformer actually is the largest factor. In tube amplifiers, especially guitar amplifiers, very little negative feedback is used that could linearize both the distortion characteristics and the frequency response of the output transformer. Transformers need a fuckton (that's the technical word for it, I believe) of iron if they are to produce a flat frequency response, particularly in the low end, and guitar amplifiers tend to be very undersized due to the very high cost of the transformer (by far one of the most expensive parts in an amp). Undersizing the transformer also makes it much more likely to saturate and distort. The transformer also reflects the impedance of the speakers to the output tubes, presenting to them a multiplied version of their impedance filtered though the characteristics of the transformer, making the transformer highly interactive with the speakers and their frequency and physics dependent impedance, which incidentally is also what makes speaker changes in a guitar setup even more impactful in guitar tone than they already are in a hifi setup. Many solid state guitar amps use current feedback through the speakers to achieve a similar reactivity with the speakers to what a tube amp with an output transformer does. All that being said, I agree that in a band mix, the difference isn't very significant, and both sounded fucking great.

[@flektra175]

Also the difference in 2nd & 4th harmonic distortion may be as simple as one amp having slightly mismatched power tubes.

[@IndependenceGuitar]

Cool comparison. I love every iteration of the amp. Any differences are lost in the drums and bass, and they all are monsters.

[@cjhawkins1984]

I just picked up a 94 "Script" for $1000 USD. It came with a road case, and is in damn near mint condition. Currently running it through a v30 cab. It sounds immense.

[@DrBRockstar2000]

I have a 1995 Peavey 5150 half-stack (straight 4x12" cab with the Sheffield 1200s that ABSOLUTELY SUUUUUUUUCK) -- I tried it through a friend's Greenback-loaded Marshall 4x12 cab, INSTANT '90s Machine Head tone

[@heoftheunlight]

Comparing the 5150 signature vs. another 5150 signature in a null test just the same way would be interesting. I'd bet measurements would diverge about as much as with the new 6505. Probably because of component tolerances, especially with the transformers.

[@gregfender]

Wow, I’m surprised two real amps could sound so similar even with the same circuitry. I feel like this definitely puts the debate to rest. Thank you for this test, Glenn!

[@rram992]

If tubes=better sound, then a set of brand new pickups makes me a better guitar player 🤓

[@johndoyer]

Hold on a minute. Don't they? 🤯

[@travisspaulding2222]

Yeah, instead of paying an inflated price for the 5150 (either BL or Script) I just went ahead and got the 5153 50 watt Stealth. I have not regretted my purchase at all. If someone needs the 5150 badge that desperately, the EVH amps are fantastic. I got mine for the better clean channel and the built in midi for channel switching.

[@reverendg5937]

Glen love your show and attitude. I laugh so hard listening to you, it's the pick me up I need every day. Don't change a thing and keep rocking Brother!!!!!

[@criticalbasstheory]

I absolutely love your technical analysis part of this video. Comparing sonic profiles, inverting phase between the reamped recordings, all of it. Well done. I'll be using some of these techniques myself when doing A/B comparisons between amps and sims.

[@richy749]

Glenn you’ve saved me so much grief over the years. I can’t thank you enough for the work you do! Amazing stuff man!

[@BluesSaracenoOfficial]

Great Job Glenn! Love hearing you cut to the chase!

[@goodheartmedia]

I avoided the whole issue by buying a used Bugera 6262 Infinium (6505+ clone) for a few hundred. Swapped V2 & V3 tubes with 12AY7's to tame the gain a little and I can use this amp for anything from classic rock to metal.

[@SilasoftheLamb]

So nerdy and cool at the same time!!! :) Thank you for explaining this...

i LOVED so much that you showed us the graphs. Thanks a lot man!

[@michaelsnydermusic]

Glenn, thanks for the background research. I enjoy that stuff and it makes me watch even though I’m not in the market for this amp.

[@reyalejandrocalafellvaldes9640]

Carcass Heartwork tone is a pinnacle of death metal tone.

[@PooNinja]

🤘🏽

[@Nugmania1]

Bud, how you manage to be entertaining and annoying at the same time, lol , that is a true gift. This vid was very informative, and exposes that some companies will only think of the bottom line. Toddles for now

[@alrecks619]

it's amazing how a volume produced amp like the 5150 gets bumped up like bananas in price because of a famous artist's name being put on it.

[@SpectreSoundStudios]

And yet a used 6505 does not. Same amp

[@chaptermasterpedrokantor1623]

Nah, I am pretty much used to that by now. Once you've built a Klon clone for $25 in parts using the same circuit and parts that the original used, yet people are willing to pay more then a $1000 for an original, you know that guitar players are idiots. Only 1 grade above audiophiles in being gullible.

[@mhsandifer]

​@@chaptermasterpedrokantor1623 Don't forget the special cables.

[@chaptermasterpedrokantor1623]

@@mhsandifer 🤣🤣🤣

[@mattmanley7118]

Branding at its finest

[@drewgraysonxoxopanda]

I just got a 1992 Peavey 5150 blockletter amp. Peavey Serial number lookup verfied. Block letter 5150 were made from 1992-94. 1995 was EVH signature models.

[@leondantas]

I think this is the kind of difference expected between two amps even at the same model. There is always some difference on components like pots, resistors and transformers. You should try the same test with two amps of the same model and maybe the same year to make sure. Great video Glenn

[@pb25193]

The distortion graph is the amount of harmonic content introduced as a function of frequency of the fundamental

[@MarRecusable]

Graphs!!! Finally!!! More graphs please!!!! Thanks for the content! I got bummed out about guitar tech since I studied electrical engineering. I had never seen a producer's take on the issues that bothered me.

[@bBersZ]

Picked one up in 04, banged it around for years and once dialed in it never lost it's tone, tubes or spring. Loved that head.

[@chrisdover8507]

One of the best videos you’ve done Glenn. Great history info 😊

[@GetOffMyyLawn]

I definitely smell more ambiance from the original tubes. There is an openness to the aura from the tube glow that is hard to deny. I also believe the copper wires from the 1990's had more free room for the electrons to move through.

[@GTX1123]

I had the block lettered combo version 11 yrs ago. Don't know how old it was because I didn't have it that long. When I tried it out, I played a strat through it and couldn't believe how it nailed SRV tones so I bought it. The main reason I got rid of it was because even with wheels on it, it was backbreaking to move in and out of the car.

[@TiberiusWallace]

I love myths like this, it implies an emergency meeting where all the electrical designers, factory floor foremen, acquisitions and upper management all sat round a table and said "Look, because we're changing the font of the die cut logo we need to come up with an entirely different circuit." "Why?!" "Because of Reverb and guitar forums". "Say no more, boss!"

[@Nightdare]

"Let's make it so that we sell the new faceplate models at half of what the old amps are doing 2nd hand"

[@ViciousAudioTX]

I’ve owned like 5 or 6 different block letters and they all sounded different there was 1 that stood out hands down better than the rest

[@robertmills2058]

Yup,I've owned many,unfortunately I been trying to replace one that was stolen that just sounded much better than any of the other ones,I still remember my settings and none of the other have been set even close,I have turn the presence up past 7,the one that was stolen if you went past 7 it was was to much.

[@PetiteLameque]

I had to swap my amp’s tubes because the old ones failed. I also bought a used Jensen speaker to try out. For the price the used speaker costed me vs. the price of new tubes (the cheapest JJ’s I could find), I’ll invest faster in a bunch of speaker swaps before I invest in a tube swap just for fun! The speaker swap made a HUGE difference! Thank you Glen!

[@AmdusciasBaal]

Curious to hear the difference on the green channel with crunch on + a tube Screamer. It was a very popular use of the 5150 for rhythm guitars rather than the red channel. (But I admit it's pure curiosity/geekery from me haha !) Cheers Glenn, keep up the great work ! 🤘

[@luc_91801gh]

Hi Glen, thanks for all the info. I want to know: is there any noticiable improvement in tone, at the same final volume, when using an attenuator to crank the power tubes of an amp?

[@rmzzz76]

This is very interesting, but I'm wondering how much variation there would be between two classic 5150 heads or two modern 92' original heads. Anytime you have a board with capacitors there's always a range of accepted tolerance (i.e. variation), very small, but would still probably show up with the type of in-depth signal analysis you're doing here.

[@madmonkey7411]

Hey Glenn, awesome video man. Just curious but where have you got the information from that burn my eyes by Machine head is recorded with greenbacks? I always heard an read that rob used Marshall Cabs with V30s

[@thelolguy007]

Love how you do it in a full mix Glenn. At the end of the day that’s how we hear it, complete - whether live or recording. Btw, no opportunity to Gibson bash in this at all? 🧐

[@baneverything5580]

Man, I`m glad I only play acoustic guitars. Our band`s all Peavey setup in the early 90s (before the fire...besides the Ampeg bass amp), had a crystal clear pristine wonderful sound. When I let other drummers sit in for me I was blown away by how great they sounded. Not sure how old our stuff was but it was a beat up collection of what we could scrounge up. Hartley Peavey was always good to musicians too. I respected them a lot.

[@DillonMcAuliffe]

Amazing video! I love these informative, journalistic style videos.

[@user-kb5hk1ib7v]

What amp or speaker do i need to get the sound im trying to find? Im trying to get a mix of metallica and justice for all album, megadeth rust in piece album, sodom m16 album, slayer reign in blood album and pantera cowboys from hell album. Those are my favorite albums and i really like the guitar sound on them and i think a mix of all them would sound badass. What do you think i need to get that sound?

[@mclostinthewoods]

Knew a lot of guys back in the day that played the 5150. Was a great amp, but my default setup was a Mesa Boogie DC-100 head through two 5150 4x12 cabs (or a single slant back 5150 cab in smaller venues). I also recorded with that setup. Very versatile and loud (when needed). Our other guitar player used a Mesa Dual Recto / Marshall cabinets setup. His sounded great too, but I always preferred the EQ feature on the DC-100 head.

[@trashminx2225]

love ur videos glen keep it up bro

[@heathbarnhart1092]

Cool video. Love the seeing actual data to back up what we are hearing.

[@SpectreSoundStudios]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@MyNameIsBucket]

Just dropped money on a 5150 earlier this year and it's money well-spent. It's currently rocking a Hercules adapter, Adlib clone, and DOS 5.0 on the C: drive.

[@matthewguzman7038]

This is awesome. I remember this argument. Bought signature in 2009 for $400. Lo and behold it sounded exactly the same as a block letter in a Mesa rectifier cabinet. I still stand by you only Need to amps. 5150 and a fender twin reverb case closed

[@ZacharyMoonshine]

Man this makes me wanna go get some greenbacks more than anything. That sound on burn my eyes is insane!

[@datass666]

IMO Machine Head have almost always had The best guitar tone amongst their peers from the era... though Exodus are not far behind

[@bassinbob1965]

Hi. Im Rob. I’m not a technical guy but I know what sounds good. I really appreciate your time in making and posting these videos. I’ve learned a great deal from you and I just wanted to thank you. Rock On

[@othinus]

Sorry if this is a stupid question, but thees changing the tube in tube microphones make a noticeable difference with regards to sound output, both in a mix and raw recording? Especially on vocals where I am most interested in. Apologies for any errors, I'm blind and using using speech to text in order to make this comment. Cheers and fuck you from the Philippines!

[@johnpatitucci7919]

GLENNNNNN!!!! Serious question. I'm sure you've covered this before, but what is the tonal difference between tube vs. solid state heads? Is it a real thing, or is it all about how you dial in your sound on each? And on another note... why is my Vox AC10C1 tube amp just as powerful as my 100 watt Randall Solid State going through a 4x12? What do I know? I'm a bass player...lol

[@thehatemachinestl]

I have ruby 12ax7's in my Peavey classic 120 that have been in there since 1997 and last time they were tested they were still good and showed almost no wear. I gigged the hell out of that amp for years. Ruby's were good tubes.

[@DrVink86]

Have you done this with the 5150 and the 6505 (05 and up model) I'm curious to know if there's a difference in those. Great video!

[@TheLexluthier]

Most components like resistors and capacitors have a fairly tight tolerance these days. The potentiometers are another story. They can vary 10-20% easily. Transformers can also vary a fair amount as well. Those old Sylvania 6L6's Peavey used to use were not matched. They just grabbed a quad and stuck them in the amp. I still have the original set from my old block 5150, they varied about 10mv. Bias can affect the tone, from the factory those amps were biased cold so the tubes lasted longer.

[@harugrin]

Hi man! First of all, I really like you content, congrats! I rarely comment but I though it would be a good time to jump in. At the first comparison (around 8 min) I listened trough a JBL 7.1 headphone I could not hear any difference between the amps. After watching all the signal analysis, I was surprise - but just a little - but then again, I don't have the best hearing. May was all those shows I went in my teens in the 90`s. Peace and long life! 🖖

[@bludotone]

Fantastic video! Very thoughtful and informative. I’m curious if you have possibly considered doing a follow-up comparison with a fully re-capped and re-tubed block logo 5150? The electrolytic capacitors in the 1992 are 31 years old now if it hasn’t been overhauled. Somewhat like comparing a brand new flashlight to a 30 year old flashlight still running on the original batteries. My hypothesis is that the old one will respond quite a bit more like the new amp, and more like it did when it was brand new 30 years ago. While tubes and electrolytic capacitors will continue to function well beyond their best performance age, they do degrade over time.

[@jasonturner525]

i have an original 5150 212 combo , with a modified light intstalled and some cusotm painting on it. what do you you think a good used price would be / im thinking $800?

[@MikoHa]

If I understood it right, I can say that in terms of electronics the results of a distortion in front of the amp can be due to some tolerance of parts at the input stage that have more effect if you are going away from the range of the guitar impedance while the re-amp probability more holds the impedance (I hope the idea is understood because it’s really “not going deep in electronics”). BTW - I bumped many times into “Peavy valveking”, I saw few videos and it sounds good, do you have any experience over it? In the price range that I saw it - I think it may be something for people that want tube amp on a budget.

[@robertkidd6270]

I've had the heads...but prefer the combo which cost me £400 and kept it for over 20yrs now... I never buy new these days ..ever! So yeh even second hand prices are a joke these days...you're spot on here buddy

[@NicGarrison]

Great episode and yeah you pretty much already called out what I was hearing between the two. On the red other than the initial shift they are extremely close. The Green signal is pretty self described as you listen there are obvious volume differences. Yay music science!

[@TheAlaskanFlondr]

I'd like to see you get more 5150s and 6505s and test them because I've always heard people say their (insert amp) sounds different

[@Joey.Darkwoods-Studio]

Glenn, Could the slight differences between the two be newer components and newer tubes? Being that your old Sig5150 as over 20 years of play time on it versus the new 1992?

[@kevindaoust]

Slightly off topic, but if I may offer something about tubes I've learned from experience. The only time I felt tubes made a difference is if the sets you use have a matched plate current or not, particularly in the power section. Many years ago, I replaced the power tubes in a Reverend Hellhound with a set that I got from the store (just any EL84 they had in stock - same brand mind you). The sound didn't necessarily change, but the response and feel did. After noticing this, I bought a matched set directly from Reverend and the original feel and response came back. Another caveat was that I was not playing anything high-gain (the Hellhound couldn't keep up with that), so I don't know if matched or unmatched plate voltages would make a difference in a metal context. Anyways, food for thought...

[@ivanbrasla]

Isn't that done by turning a screw on the inside? I thought matching plate voltages was part of regular amp maintenance and something to do after buying new tubes, exactly because of what you're mentioning

[@kevindaoust]

@@ivanbrasla Yeah, that's biasing an amp. I'm not sure if its the same thing. Maybe someone who knows definitively can chime in?

[@thomasnynas3151]

@@kevindaoustBiasing an amp means finding the optimal operating environment for the tube pair (very simplified version). Matched tubes will react to bias in the same manner. Random tubes may not. Think about it like having equal tire pressure on your car.

[@markjames1713]

i just bought a nearly new condition 6505+ 112 with the intention of converting to a head after seeing your video on this now im on a mission to load a pair of 4x12s just as a vanity project mostly but it will be fun lol

[@basshippy101]

Differences that minute can even be put down to component tolerance levels.

[@AlexSMarie]

I'd be curious to see if you do the same test with 2 exact same amp, I was always told that every single amp has slight differences between each other. Most of the time, those slight differences are neglactable to my experience.

[@cunjoz]

Hi Glenn. Can you review the Fender Ton Shitster Pro? I can't find anyone to tear it to pieces when it actually deserves that, and you seem like the perfect dude for the job. Pleasee!!!

[@AlanTopham2237]

Back in the '80s I was told "you need Russian tubes, they're the bestest!!" 🤣🤣🤣

[@SpectreSoundStudios]

I remember that!!

[@KevinSparksatx]

They were probably right just by coincidence of most tubes being made in Russia

[@scottray666]

Well I'm sure you've heard the old saying they don't build them like they used to. That is true to some extent when it comes to tubes. Old tubes made by RCA from the U.S. and old Russian tubes were built to a higher standard(more robust) than modern tubes. Which means they were just better built and lasted longer which has nothing to do with tone. These people that go out and pay crazy prices for New Old Stock tubes thinking it's going to make their amp sound better are idiots.They may last a little longer but that's about it.Id rather save my money.

[@ScrambleBandOfficial]

The manufacturing tolerances also allow for up to 20% different values for potentiometers, even from contemporaneous units. The extra high end and volume is likely due to this.

[@tunesquid]

I'm wondering if it's just component tolerance differences. I once had 2 dual rectifiers that were made within about 2 months of each other and they sounded slightly different to each other as well when using a switcher to the same cab. Nothing that a tiny amount of twisting the knobs wouldn't really account for, but the difference was there. Wondering if this is the same deal. Would be interesting to see if you could borrow another few of these amps over the coming months to see the differences in the manufacturing tolerances.

[@aeroragesys]

Hi Glenn! Love your efforts to bust false guitar myths and protect consumers. I have a new video suggestion that falls into the "tone is in the hands" debate. Soft vs. Hard picking. Tied to the notion of "heaviness" of metal, it always seems like in metal it's generally cool to say that you pick hard. People argue that picking harder sounds better, especially in genres like thrash metal, but this advice both feels relative (what even is "hard" picking?) and there are many guitarists in metal that seem to pick very lightly and yet their sound still sounds huge (Bill Kelliher of Mastodon comes to mind). I know you did a video 9 years ago about tone is in the hands. I think your new video should do a similar set of experiments but this can focus on hard vs. soft picking. A) What does it mean to pick hard? (Is it deep picking depth? How tightly you hold the pick? How wide your hand motions are? Or how large the sound wave that is produced is?) B) Between two great guitarists where one is clearly a harder picker, is there any recorded difference playing the same track? C) If there is a sound difference, can you as a producer fiddle with amp or EQ settings to make the soft picking sound the same as hard picking? Might be a long-shot, but It'd be cool if you could do this test with Matt Heafy and Corey Beaulieu of Trivium since they're both great, play thrash-inspired metal, and Matt has publicly teased Corey about being a light picker. Could be a great interview/experiment video. Thanks!!

[@aeroragesys]

Also, ideally don't let them use a different pick.

[@kennethnegy9467]

Seconded! I would love to see a video on this. I've seen other guitar players claim this, too (Jens Larsen) and a different KZbin producer claim that you need to pick harder to give producers more sonic content to work with, yet there is also contradictory advice suggesting picking with less tension (lighter?) will lead to more speed and fluidity. So which is it??

[@kennethnegy9467]

Dave Davidson of Revocation also claims you need to "dig in" but plays so fast it's hard to believe he's picking hard as well (he uses an EVH 5150 III).

[@themadmattster9647]

Colin Richardson did some of the greatest guitar tones ever in extreme Metal. I also think his work on Napalm Death's Utopia Banished is under-appreciated.

[@CyberChrist]

Thanks for the measurements, I think everyone apreciates it ^^

[@larken558]

That Shefield EVH 12" speaker is amazing in my custom EL84 tube combo . I play blues and rock, and the tone is excellent

[@andrewmaher8409]

Yes. Not sure why they get the bad rap… It’s become trendy to shit on them. Yes there may be better speakers, but the 5150s aren’t bad. Just swapped some old Sheffield 5150s into Marshall 2x12 cab and they sound way better than the Celestions.

[@chasej7337]

If only there was a way to calculate how much money Glenn has helped musicians save over the years. Die hard fan of your channel! Cheers from KS!

[@KiltedTupiniquin]

Components have tolerance margins. You probably get tone shifts from the same amp from two different production batches.

[@user-te1ek5ky7w]

Great work Glenn. Love these proper analysis pieces you do. I come from a HC punk background & quite a few players in our scene rave about 5150’s. The comment about the 5150 “speaker” cab I loved. I had one for a week before I ditched it. Christ it was awful but I managed to get more cash for it than I paid new when I sold it a week later! Fools eh!!! Keep up the good work Glenn. P.s how about a look at D.I box review as cannot seem to get the countryman 85 anymore

[@screamengine]

In 2013 I picked one up for $120, original 212 combo. Dude had it sold already for $100 and I offered him an extra 20 if he'd cancel the other sale. It wasn't pumping sound because of a blown noise circuit, despite being very low hours. Got it repaired, cleaned up for $300. So for $420 I got a kickass amp that was hardly used at all.

[@BensonStrapple]

Can you do one of these vids for the Tama bell brass? There seems to be a similar reverence for this drum that I reckon you could dive right into and would be a great watch!

[@DavidWhite-iv9xw]

I love your channel. Long time guitar player, but new to home studio's. In process of puuttingbone together.

[@BXGuitars]

I'd love to see you do this with two actual block letters or two 1992 originals. Let's see what the tolerances are of the same amp because I think that would lead us to even more answers. Great video and nice to see something that's quantifiable put in front of people.

[@alanerpington5698]

I'd be interested to see this repeated with two brand new amps of the same model, just to see if there's any measurable sample variation, and how it compares to the measurement differences of a new vs old amp.

[@Rysk12]

I was going to ask the same thing. Could there be a very slight difference in the amp settings due to the dials not being 100% the same, like one dial set to 5 on one amp and just slightly off 5 on the other?

[@MnMSounds]

Do you have fresh tubes in both of those? And how often have the properly dusted and cleaned it out?

[@douglasnielson8250]

I’m amazed the Peavey 5150 amps are as reliable as they are. If you look inside one and see how they are built you would think there would be more problems.

[@user-zz6yj2tm6d]

Hey Glenn. You rock! Any chance you can do a review or at least give your take on the Gibson 70s explorer??

[@DeangerSmith]

nice one Glenn, thanks \m/

[@notnoaintno5134]

basically the pitch in Hz of any harmonic can be calculated using the formula (fundamental)*x, where x is any whole integer. so for instance you're playing a440 as the fundamental pitch, and you want to know what the second harmonic is. simply multiply 440 by 2. for the 3rd mupltiply by 3, etc.

[@vessal1]

love your stuff! There's a video out where a guys is saying the same thing about the brand new Marshalls having the cheap Vietnamese OT's. I tried to scroll down to see if any one mentioned it yet. Sorry if so! Keep it true, as always!!

[@miahmcbride5415]

I have a block letter. The only thing it had that was different were original Sylvania 6L6's... I still have them, but changed them out years ago... It'll always be a killer amp.

[@icksbocks]

This is a useful video in the sense, that the differences are very minor; I could not hear any difference in the mix. The problem is, that what difference there is may be due to manufaturing tolerances in the components etc. Can't really test that with sample size = 1.

[@bassplayer2011ify]

I couldn't hear the difference in the full mix. But the single loss is interesting and this is a good opportunity for a bit of an experiment. If your 5150 is still original you could take it to tech and have them service it. Recap it, check the resistors, solder joints, jacks, and pots. And then run this test again and see if you get the same result.

[@LambChopper678]

I’m always down to learn new things 👌🏻 Perfect

[@chriscampbell9191]

Great vid. I'm not a metalhead, so some of the earlier bands' examples really didn't hit with me, but I think your overall take on this old amp vs. new amp issue is valid, and you support it with graphs, which is cool. I.e., trying to save guitarists money so they buy into actual sound, instead of hype. As for the sonic differences, one wonders how much those differences would really matter when you've got the signal going into the amp has already gone through dirt boxes, EQ's, different guitars producing the signal, etc. Peace.

[@TVoltG]

I remember in the mid 90's I bought a full 5150 stack block letter used for $600 at Black Market Music in Walnut Creek, California.. People gave these things away back then.. I changed then shitfields with G12K-85 in one cab and Greenbacks in the top..

[@danwilhite]

Still have my block letter 5150. Got it at a pawn shop around '94 for about $350 I believe. Still rocks! Think I'll keep it.