Douglas Murray @ Lafayette, The Strange Death of Europe, Full Event

  Рет қаралды 286,417

Brandon Van Dyck

Brandon Van Dyck

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 884
@nubl37
@nubl37 7 жыл бұрын
Douglas Murray is surely one of the greatest intellectuals of our times.
@hans-joachimbierwirth4727
@hans-joachimbierwirth4727 6 жыл бұрын
Douglas Murray is surel one of the most pathetic liars of all times. He is claiming underlying reasons that had nothing to do with the events. There are indeed three reasons. First is, islamic money is driving the stock markets and whoever is invested in the stock markets doesn't want them to pull out. Second is, conservative idiots see Islam as an allie in the cold war. Third is, conservatives have no basic understanding of economy and believe in "growth" without any clue how to stimulate that which made them embrace immigration. Plain and simple. No guilt, no tirednees, but greed, corruption and stupidity. Murray is either an idiot or a liar.
@serpentines6356
@serpentines6356 5 жыл бұрын
@Boris Farage...Why?
@serpentines6356
@serpentines6356 5 жыл бұрын
@Boris Farage...What is the 'crap' he is making up?
@danstewart2770
@danstewart2770 5 жыл бұрын
You must be easily impressed. Douglas Murray couldn't have been more tepid and tentative. Too bad, when asked, he just couldn't muster the courage to forthrightly say he views the identity of Europe to be the culture of Western Civilization and the people who built it, and mass immigration-especially from Islamic countries-poses an existential threat to its future. Instead, he speaks in quibbling euphemisms and pointless parables. He utterly fails to make the anti-immigration case for Europe and the entire presentation reeks of cowardice and retreat. Ironically, much like Obama, Murray simply couldn't bring himself to say the words "Islamic extremism," in fact he couldn't say Islam at all. Not his finest hour. Abjectly disappointing. .
@moonstove
@moonstove 5 жыл бұрын
One of the greatest intellectuals of our time? Definitely one of the biggest cunts
@ed7519
@ed7519 Жыл бұрын
This talk is 5 years old. Douglas Murray is even better today (2023)! Can't wait to read all his books.
@JB-pp4nj
@JB-pp4nj 6 жыл бұрын
'I would like to keep it, if you wouldn't mind awfully'. Wonderful British understatement - Murray you are truly superb.
@affrobeat6170
@affrobeat6170 7 жыл бұрын
love the fact he can always get his points across without being offensive or even smug. not long known about him but already a big fan can't wait to give his book a read.
@maracohen5930
@maracohen5930 6 жыл бұрын
It's excellent. Just finished. I knew Scoop Jackson, he would have loved tis Young Man's voice on the scene...
@joemiller7028
@joemiller7028 7 жыл бұрын
When I first saw the title I was shocked that someone as esteemed and brilliant as Douglas Murray would speak at a typical regressive leftist indoctrination site like Lafayette. Then I listened and was very impressed with the moderators, students, and questioners. Thank you.
@ChollieD
@ChollieD 7 жыл бұрын
Maybe it's not quite the leftist indoctrination center that you think...?
@noceboaffect3187
@noceboaffect3187 6 жыл бұрын
joe kean Even if it was as you say more reason to go and speak there.
@oldmoviemusic
@oldmoviemusic 6 жыл бұрын
Actually, lots of Lafayette students have been throwing hissy fits over The Mill Series - look how horribly they treated Roaming Millenial - they even got up on the stage with her!
@Vlas811
@Vlas811 3 ай бұрын
Peace to you My Friend Brandon!!! Cool video!!! All the best to you!!! Added I like!!!
@ruara5009
@ruara5009 7 жыл бұрын
I love this man, he teaches English how to be proud to be of their own ancestry. We need more people like that in the British media. Migrant myself, I came to appreciate and love British values, but can't see myself adopting yet another sub-set of Arab values, we must always remember that that in relation to Islam we as white people have always been on the right side of History. We must remember the date of 1683 when it's all came to a head and our ancestors have made a choice for us and that is to reject Islam and Arab/Ottoman culture. Of course Bulgaria suffered long after being pillaged and raped all in the name of peaceful religion.
@EmperorsNewWardrobe
@EmperorsNewWardrobe 7 жыл бұрын
RuaRa, he suggests a preference for feeling grateful over proud of our western civilisation. A C Grayling goes into real detail about the West’s history in its great ability to grow its freedoms and rights, those which are the reason immigration happens mainly toward it not away from it
@ruara5009
@ruara5009 7 жыл бұрын
And so we should be feeling grateful. Because freedom is fragile, cultures can be broken, it takes thousands of years to build empires, and moments to break them.
@EmperorsNewWardrobe
@EmperorsNewWardrobe 7 жыл бұрын
RuaRa, I entirely agree. It’s interesting though, gratitude is a feeling of thankfulness whereas pride is more a feeling of accomplishment. In that it you can’t compete so easily over who is most thankful as you can who has achieved better, the former can’t be used to impose whereas the latter can, and I suspect this may be douglas’s reasoning. Nothing inherently wrong with rooting for one’s team, as you would your family in a community game or your country in the olympics, but gratitude is a kind of intragroup perspective, of appreciating the efforts of ancestors without being able to weaponise it, as is otherwise the case with pride. Given that we do currently have our civilisation, we are in an secure position to express gratitude of all our ancestors have done to build our freedoms and safeties, and to let these get destroyed would be an insult to their sacrifices and hard work
@bangfarang
@bangfarang 7 жыл бұрын
AND WHAT WILL EUROPEANS DO WITH THE GUILT THEY'LL FEEL OVER SURRENDERING THEIR CONTINENT TO BARBARIANS? “Exaggerated self-criticism would be a harmless luxury of civilization if there were no enemy at the gate. But it becomes dangerous when it portrays its mortal enemy as always being in the right.” -Jean-François Revel, 1924-2006)
@peterpamlockwood
@peterpamlockwood 4 жыл бұрын
the same came be said about "Socialist FEMINISTS"...where in Australia the New Law just past is, a woman can Abort(KILL) her Baby on the DAY of Birth... Cos its HER RIGHT !inc Does not like the GENDER of her Baby.That law was Passed FEB 2020.
@Anicius_
@Anicius_ 3 жыл бұрын
@@peterpamlockwood for real? After birth? Wtf can i have the source / link
@Jan-tu5ml
@Jan-tu5ml 7 жыл бұрын
The Great Replacement. But we cannot say it.
@kevin.afton_
@kevin.afton_ 7 жыл бұрын
Yes. Even if Murray had his way the population would still be replaced.
@briannxx
@briannxx 7 жыл бұрын
It's not so great!!! More like the shit replacement I mean Japanese people would have made an amazing replacement but no they pick the most unaccomplished that hold the worst ideas
@CelticSaint
@CelticSaint 7 жыл бұрын
'we cannot say it' - Yes we can! You just have, so keep on doing it.
@ImperialFile09N157L
@ImperialFile09N157L 7 жыл бұрын
Globalization for any reason is the death of any country. This has already been tried. We need to learn the value of history.
@darrenwithers3628
@darrenwithers3628 7 жыл бұрын
How is it a replacement? Are the Europeans being removed? No. Such a dumb comment.
@Pippie5555
@Pippie5555 7 жыл бұрын
"The population is leaning more and more to the right and the politicians more and more to the left". That is so true. Great video.
@garyjohnstone6422
@garyjohnstone6422 11 ай бұрын
Geert Wilders in Holland, Millei in Argentina, Trump soon back in USA, Italy/France/Canada to follow so a major swing to the Right. Hungary fixed now. Ppl have had it with socialism`s bullshit.
@Kurtlane
@Kurtlane 7 жыл бұрын
Race has re-entered American discussion in a very strange way: the more non-racist the population at large becomes, the more they (who?) scream about it being a totally racist country. I remember long ago reading an interview with a man who used to be racist. He said, "Call someone a racist too many times, and he will be a racist." It seems to me this is happening in Europe too.
@serpentines6356
@serpentines6356 5 жыл бұрын
@Kurtlane....Yes, I remember when I started to notice liberal media pushing 'racism' almost all the time. It started to be very irritating. I couldn't stand it after awhile, and had to start turning off the 'liberal ' shows.
@mrs.schmenkman
@mrs.schmenkman 5 жыл бұрын
This is because there is in fact an organized effort to manipulate all western culture into destroying itself. The divide and conquer effort is pretty straight forward. Break everyone off into groups then have the groups learn to hate anyone they see as an oppressor. Eventually everyone is an oppressor. Et al...
@jhljhl6964
@jhljhl6964 4 жыл бұрын
I have just begun reading it. A very important book.
@Aubergine1941
@Aubergine1941 7 жыл бұрын
I grew up in Austria and there were a lot of Gastarbeiter (Guest-workers). And we did think they would go back home. The clue is in the word Gast (guest). Guests don't stay - at some point they return home. Most of these guest workers were Turkish and Yugoslavian. The reason we thought they would WANT to go back home was that they earned much better money in Austria but that money was worth much more in Turkey. The Turks in Austria lived in very bad conditions in comparison to the Austrian people. This was not because they were paid badly or bad housing was provided for them but because they sent every Groschen (Penny) they could back to Turkey and had their family there build nice houses for them. In other words that money which was enough to rent reasonable housing in Austria bought them GREAT houses at home. The problem with the Turks was that the children who were schooled in Austria - and especially the girls - did not want to go to that culture. It was not a problem with the Yugoslavian people as their culture wasn't that different from our own - they just integrated and became indistinguishable.
@sbam4881
@sbam4881 6 жыл бұрын
When I was a kid, I spent 4 years in Austria as my dad was a diplomat posted to Vienna. I wasn't particularly fond of it as I felt it wasn't a place for a young kid and the demographic seemed to skew older people there, but I always thought it was a beautiful city. Last year, I want back for a visit - first time in 30 years - and the place is a dump garbage, graffity, chipped stones and peeling paint even on main thoroughfares. Went to take a few photos of the old school I went to and a security dude rushed over and gave me a quiz. Told them why I was there and the guy just didn't want to hear and just said verboten (forbidden) in a pleading tone. (I am guessing peodos targeting school kids is such a thing there now that they are petrified - and the saddest thing of all was him pleading rather than demanding - the fire has left Osterreich). So sad for Europe, we will mourn for you when you are gone. Signed: The Buddhist Far East.
@Wowplajer
@Wowplajer 4 жыл бұрын
same thing happening in Slovenia, we became a minority in our own country in just a few years...used to be peacefull now people are shooting eatchother on our streets and us the natives are moving all our things abroad as fast as possible
@alkimsalaam677
@alkimsalaam677 3 жыл бұрын
Are white people indigenous to Australia? Smh
@luciferin22
@luciferin22 3 жыл бұрын
I am a child of a bosnian guest worker in Austria. I now consider Austria as my home and I am proud of our beautiful state :)
@luciferin22
@luciferin22 3 жыл бұрын
@@Wowplajer ajde ne seri,
@nicolathompson1827
@nicolathompson1827 9 ай бұрын
He has such a brilliant mind and sense of humor, I can never understand how university audiences remain dead quiet...perhaps in awe?
@steveodonoghue2772
@steveodonoghue2772 6 жыл бұрын
Brilliant read, im half way through it right now.
@Kryptsanies
@Kryptsanies 7 жыл бұрын
I must say I am incredibly impressed by all the fantastic questions from the moderators and the audience. Well done.
@jamesmcd71
@jamesmcd71 7 жыл бұрын
He is one of the best speakers of our time.
@bienkee5278
@bienkee5278 5 жыл бұрын
Imagine the impact Mr.Douglas Murray will have on UK Immigration policy as Home Secretary rather than Ms.Diane Abbott.
@cattycorner8
@cattycorner8 5 жыл бұрын
The US needs an immigration moratorium. We need a pause to get our house in order.
@uniek10
@uniek10 7 жыл бұрын
Murray's insights are spot on. If he is not listened to Europe will perish.
@harrytd
@harrytd 5 жыл бұрын
I find this a lot with these talks based at universities: Douglas shows endless patience with some very dullard questions. I thought at the very least, university taught one how to think, digest and summarise. In other words, get to the point quickly. At least it did when I was there. What the hell has happened?
@smartypants7954
@smartypants7954 7 жыл бұрын
Any student that can't ask a question without repeatedly peppering said question with 'like?', should be ignored.
@purplemonkeydishwasher9818
@purplemonkeydishwasher9818 5 жыл бұрын
Tony Smart sometimes intelligent young people litter their speech with likes until they train it out of themselves. You’re usually right, but sometimes wrong is all.
@Jammyhorse
@Jammyhorse 5 жыл бұрын
As should the slightly older middle class questioners who prefix everything with an affectation of the phrase ‘sort of’ instead of ‘’like’.....
@michaelweber5702
@michaelweber5702 6 жыл бұрын
Douglas Murray is one of the bright lights of Europe and I think that he is a brilliant man and God bless him. In this particular KZbin maybe because of jet lag and him apparently dealing with a bad cold , he is not very clear thus unable to educate these young americans as well as he's usually capable of doing , a pity... He is a very brave and amazing critic...
@kwyzi
@kwyzi 6 жыл бұрын
great article. Love this Douglas
@btpennycook
@btpennycook 6 жыл бұрын
Another great Q and A from Douglas whom is not afraid to speak the truth unlike our cowardly politicians in the UK
@jraney69
@jraney69 6 жыл бұрын
I think the host has mischaracterized Jordan Peterson. Peterson would not say: "The only way to revitalize Western Culture is to rescue...Christianity...). Peterson would say something like: Westerners, and young people in particular, need to take personal responsibility for their behavior, fix your own life before judging others, which will improve the world. Recognize the amazing quality of life we inherited from millennia of human suffering, and don't waste it. On Christianity, Peterson's main thrust is to encourage Westerners to understand their Christian-ness, to learn Western history and the Christian archetypes that shaped who we already are. Anytime he's pushed on the matter, Peterson will not confirm his own belief in God, let alone claim we should all be followers. There is an important difference, and you've failed to understand the nuance.
@abbamanic
@abbamanic 7 жыл бұрын
Always an informative pleasure to hear Douglas speak. But seemed without his usual passion and fire this time. And the audio was appalling.
@Paul.Morgan
@Paul.Morgan 7 жыл бұрын
He had jet-lag. He was still great though.
@brandonvandyck
@brandonvandyck 7 жыл бұрын
We're working on the audio for future events. Two of our four mics were faulty, and we won't use them anymore.
@kgrlondon
@kgrlondon 7 жыл бұрын
Andrew de Mowbray I think DM did this so calmly to be more approachable and open for any students' questions, he said in the beginning "open for any subject".
@FiveLiver
@FiveLiver 6 жыл бұрын
Whenever I listen to Douglas Murray I applaud at intervals, but when he concludes I'm left with a feeling (in musical terms) of a long fade out rather than a resounding conclusion. For that I go to Anne Marie Waters.
@ssarellas
@ssarellas 7 жыл бұрын
The girl who's asking why is Sweden taking more refugees than the other northern countries... I mean, is it so hard to guess why? Sweden is lead by a feminist government, what did she expect?
@heatherm1439
@heatherm1439 7 жыл бұрын
ssarellas Expect the true feminists to be in the throws of emigrating right now..Those left behind in government are too busy creating labels for themselves & others.. won’t be long before the house of cards is blown down.
@pahakuutti
@pahakuutti 7 жыл бұрын
The ''true feminist fallacy'. You wanna know what a true feminist is? She is a communist. The ideological core of that religion is red, and that core can not be detached from the title, despite some people(most people really) forgetting, or not knowing this fact.
@Kabodanki
@Kabodanki 7 жыл бұрын
and all green party are like watermellon, green outside, red inside
@hans-joachimbierwirth4727
@hans-joachimbierwirth4727 6 жыл бұрын
More like overly riped bananas. They all went from green to yellow and all of a sudden were brownish black.
@Blacksaintknowpercapita
@Blacksaintknowpercapita Жыл бұрын
Seriously? Barbara Lewis Spectre isn’t a her organization and people boast often at their genocide of Sweden
@captainbleedinobvious5388
@captainbleedinobvious5388 7 жыл бұрын
I've read the book (TSDE) and recommend it. However I do think he should have gone over the so called Kalergi plan. It seems that these intellectuals are scared to go there, it's also the same with the work of Kevin Macdonald (who writes about what he sees as jewish involvement in immigration in the US and Europe as well as other things)
@TheZestyCar
@TheZestyCar 7 жыл бұрын
Captain Bleedin' Obvious Indeed.
@idedwards100
@idedwards100 6 жыл бұрын
I agree Captain, and whilst I love Douglas for what he does and his book meticulously TSDE explains all the symptoms and even diagnoses that the patient will eventually die if not treated - he says very little about the cause, preferring to use language such as 'lack of will' or 'temporary loss of sanity' rather than what it is: wilful ethnocide of Europeans from everywhere they live on this planet, by force. The UN, Regional, and National governments are complicit in this. The Kalergi omission is certainly one such gap in his discussion. Also the political mindsets of Peter Sutherland (UN level), and Frans Timmerman (EU Level) for example, are merely touched upon, but not discussed. Not even George Soros is dissected. The obvious conclusion to reach after reading his book is not "Oh, I wonder where the European race is heading, it's not looking too well?" it's "The European race is suffering ethnocide, not by accident (or economic or cultural benefit smoke screens) but by design, funded, and against its peoples wishes". The rest of the world laughs at us. Some may fear "are we next?" For me, Douglas takes no sides, and if he ever does his next book will be entitled: 'The Deliberate Genocide of Europeans - and Who is Behind it' (TDGE).
@ughugh3556
@ughugh3556 6 жыл бұрын
is it me, or do the students in these univeristies seem dummer then a few years ago? you can say its me.
@ChollieD
@ChollieD 7 жыл бұрын
Why were the questions put to Mr. Murray of such high quality in this forum? I don't think I've ever heard such an intelligent, penetrating Q&A.
@Foxtrotwilconiner1969
@Foxtrotwilconiner1969 6 жыл бұрын
Brilliant well spoken man.I would love to sit around a dinner table and have a good old fireside chat.Not a alarmist but just a plea to a open discussion of ones values and how we merge or mix them together to form a cohesive society.Sweden the poster child for forward thinking thought that it would work.To find who rules over you find out who you can't criticize. Or apathy and tolerance are the signs of a dieing society.
@martynspooner5822
@martynspooner5822 7 жыл бұрын
Surely the mass exodus of people into Europe like in 2015 will not be allowed to happen again. Even the German people as guilt ridden and socially conditioned as they are will not allow this to continue. The general public are seeing the negative consequences both economically and socially. Thus the rise of the AFD and similar right wing parties throughout Europe. It is a difficult if not impossible problem but the answer cannot be to allow anyone who wants the opportunity to be able to settle in Europe. It is simply not sustainable.
@weirdwelshman6191
@weirdwelshman6191 7 жыл бұрын
You sir, have to much faith in the spine of the political class and underestimate the volume of the screeching whine from the virtue signalers.
@crforfreedom7407
@crforfreedom7407 7 жыл бұрын
You have the wrong problem solving methodology martyn. You are using logic and reason. Liberals and Marxists use feelings and emotions. Each comes to completely different outcomes. It's especially sad when one realizes that the "Anglo Saxon" majority in England came in the 5th century as just a 10% immigration of males from Saxony Germany. Europe will soon be NOTHING like it's ancestors, and EVERYTHING like its majority members; Africa and the ME.
@bruceruttan60
@bruceruttan60 7 жыл бұрын
Nice thought mart, but do you really suspect that the people of Europe have any choice about their social role any longer? Socialism is the very foundation of despotism. It means that the people have become helpless slaves.
@christastempel5577
@christastempel5577 7 жыл бұрын
martyn spooner, I think you mean to mass influx, not the mass exodus of people into Europe. Exodus means, the going away, influx means to come into. I am German, born eleven years after ww2, and I do know something about the guilt that post war Germans felt. However, my Generation was also very clear about how the ordinary people suffered under the Nazi regime, and this included the Jewish people, who after all were Germans. Since ww2, the west Germans have developed a social system, based in Capitalism, which has prevailed to be efficient to this day. I think you have the right idea, but I think one needs to make it clear that the mass immigration of people from the middle east, northern African countries, and various eastern European countries, (and only few of them actually having the right to claim Asylum status) are a phenomenal drain on social security, which is not sustainable in the long run. I think we need to address the real problem of why these immigrants pose such a problem, and that is because they are largely uneducated, and have very little to offer. The majority of these people are Muslims, and perhaps because they are Muslims, they do not feel that they should give something in return for what they are given, but instead they just demand more and more, and are completely unreasonable in what they demand. I think we need to be very clear, that Islam is coming into our Christian countries via these immigrants, and we need to be very clear that Islam is fundamentally martial, violent and expansionistic. So we are inviting an expansionistic and violent religion into our peaceful countries, and we give the believers of this religion, everything they want, because we want to help. What we don't understand, is that Muslims think they have the right to receive anything they want, and that we the 'infidel' are just there to give them what they need. Muslims by their very nature, believe that they are superior to everybody else in this world, and the more we give, the less they appreciate what is given.
@martynspooner5822
@martynspooner5822 7 жыл бұрын
Yes totally agree. I meant exodus from their original places of origin , that's why I left a space but you are right it is lazy and easily misunderstood and I apologise.
@josiepie6803
@josiepie6803 7 жыл бұрын
Nice to listen to a new event with Douglas but could they not have even him a bottle of water?
@monk3110
@monk3110 6 жыл бұрын
jo ince he has a coffee Also Darren is rude
@gmac805
@gmac805 6 жыл бұрын
"There are some advantages to be looked at as a racist country." This quote ascribed to a Danish MP may very well define the future perceived wisdom of the Western political class but it has a strong headwind to fight against since "racism" is seen as the worst of all possible sins both public and private.
@gbrasil86
@gbrasil86 7 жыл бұрын
Thank you so much for this
@Victoriacariad
@Victoriacariad 7 жыл бұрын
Love Douglas Murray! Thanks for uploading this. Though he's not quite up to date with the point raised around 58:00. The monarch/royal family can marry Catholics now. They changed those rules around the time the Duchess of Cambridge was pregnant. They just can't be Catholics themselves.
@WilfChadwick
@WilfChadwick 6 жыл бұрын
My wholehearted congratulations on the outstanding sound quality, I did have a hearing test afterwards though.
@hitchslap8254
@hitchslap8254 7 жыл бұрын
Good God! The first question from the floor went on for nearly 3 minutes! Couldn't he just say, "why are muslims different to non-muslim europeans?". He can't though can he?
@IzabelParis
@IzabelParis 7 жыл бұрын
Agree with you but it was a good and well formulated Q with specific examples and an articulate person who didn't say "like" every three words, which is super rare nowadays.
@petedexteruk
@petedexteruk 7 жыл бұрын
It is like super rare these days
@ajaston6689
@ajaston6689 7 жыл бұрын
samsamm77 They NEVER can! My suspicion is that the vast majority of such people figure their own opinions (sounds of own voice perhaps?!) are as valuable to wider society if not more so, than the likes of Douglas Murray. They're in for quite a shock.
@JoeSmith-fw8ix
@JoeSmith-fw8ix 7 жыл бұрын
Have you ever tried asking a question publicly? I think a lot of these people meander because their thoughts meander, not because they're actually trying to filibuster. It's actually a bit tough to get out a solid, cogent question in public if you never really speak publicly. This is just in the spirit of being fair to these people. I find it a bit annoying too, but not everyone is used to the pressure.
@alankenworthy9722
@alankenworthy9722 7 жыл бұрын
I agree. Intellectual show- off.
@NinjaKittyBonks
@NinjaKittyBonks 5 жыл бұрын
Thank you, Mill Series.... good stuff! :)
@rogerhewland7991
@rogerhewland7991 6 жыл бұрын
Thank you for that contribution to humanity.
@martynhunter3542
@martynhunter3542 5 жыл бұрын
I'm a big fan of Douglas but he always seems to start so slowly it's a struggle to stay awake. Why he does it I don't know. He seems to have two speeds. Very, very slow and then he get's excited and speaks very much quicker. But the start is so slow it's a wonder the audience stays awake.
@jeremiahdixon9379
@jeremiahdixon9379 10 ай бұрын
It's called enunciation!
@Paul.Morgan
@Paul.Morgan 7 жыл бұрын
Those late comers were pretty rude. I'd always turn up on time to see Douglas Murray.
@JusticeHolden
@JusticeHolden 7 жыл бұрын
audience mics made me want to die.
@peteredwards8737
@peteredwards8737 7 жыл бұрын
Not just the audience. The person next to Douglas was inarticulate, irritating, had nothing useful to say, tripped over his tongue trying to say it, and couldn't or wouldn't use his mic properly.
@mrRambleGamble
@mrRambleGamble 6 жыл бұрын
Peter Edwards Yeah, Mr. "Reachin' for Nietszche". I give him credit since he's probably a college kid trying earnestly, but one of the more annoying traits of in these kind of talks is the tendency to filter responses/questions through quotes and external authority. They can't speak plainly. It's like their speaking a thesis paper out loud.
@thunderstruck1078
@thunderstruck1078 7 жыл бұрын
50:30 Poland has a great model.
@kitoharveywill5766
@kitoharveywill5766 7 жыл бұрын
But Poland were never into space.
@thunderstruck1078
@thunderstruck1078 7 жыл бұрын
Remember communism? Are you saying that space wouldn't have happened without non-Whites? And also, you don't have to be a superpower to be happy.
@kitoharveywill5766
@kitoharveywill5766 7 жыл бұрын
You're complicating a meaningless joke ;) In lots of Polish comments, they'll say "Poland may not into space but Poland stronk"
@kohvazein7798
@kohvazein7798 7 жыл бұрын
>That site was done by a group of Swedish patriots. That's not exactly proof of legitimacy... Your sources are bunk. >you better be ready to go far-right if you ever decide to know the truth Nah, centre-right is nice and warm. Already get called far-right for my views on immigration/islam >instead of believing your "reliable sources" Fucking kek "Reliable sources? pffft, here's some swedish patriots that collected a bunch of court records which is 100% not susceptible to any sort of cognitive bias. >You're fucking scum of the earth (and probably Jewish). You sound exactly like an SJW, calling me evil and scum of the earth because I disagree with your source. We probably agree on policy issues, but you're calling me scum because we disagree on why we agree top fucking kek. Calling me Jewish is no different than when SJW's discredit someone for being white. You're literally a right-wing SJW.
@thunderstruck1078
@thunderstruck1078 7 жыл бұрын
Aaaaaa, you're a part of the "skeptic community", now I see what's going on here. He he. You can't get much better source than verdicts directly from courts, can you moron. I'm SJW? *I attacked you* because you disagreed with "my sources"? Go back and read your first post in this thread. And the next one. And after spewing all that nonsense and insults you're moralizing to me about calling you scum. LOL I don't care whether we agree about policy or not. You're a waste of time. Yeah, seems I was right, you are scum. Now fuck off back to consoling Kraut for getting his ass kicked in.
@Pelamore
@Pelamore 6 жыл бұрын
I saw the problem with immigration first hand YEARS ago. I had a co-worker who was from the Dominican Republic. Almost daily he would go on these America is bad/evil/dumb and Dominican Republic is better diatribes. When asked "then why come here?" he would reply "Money. Then I'm going back." How could he sit in the US and claim DR is better when we all know it's a Third World basket case? People who dislike their country, or love yours, will immigrate and integrate. They WANT to be like you and therefore will become like you. But if it's about money they will come, take the money, but maintain their loyalty to their homeland. When they do, they will harbor a simmering hatred of the host country. In effect they feel YOUR culture is inferior but will milk it for the money. Not only do they not assimilate, they RESENT your culture and have contempt for YOUR weakness for letting them milk you. The West doesn't understand this because we have become so obsessed with comfort/wealth/gadgets that we define those things as goals. "How can they not like us? We gave them cell phones and indoor plumbing!?!" This misses the fact that many people, especially from poor countries, DO NOT focus their cultural/personal identity on wealth or gadgets. They focus it on cultural/religious/tribal identities. So in effect we are importing people focused on a tribal identity and thinking giving them a cell phone will make them abandon it......WRONG!
@johnarmstrong3782
@johnarmstrong3782 6 жыл бұрын
C Jones Murray doesn’t think as deeply about it as you do. Murray only cares about the preservation of the British upper class.
@omnipitous4648
@omnipitous4648 7 жыл бұрын
I appreciate cultural diversity. The amazing contributions different cultures bring to the table are incalculable. But I do have caveats. 1. There is a reason people, not just from war-torn countries are flocking to Europe. It is mainly because their own countries have failed them. Why do they flock to Europe? Universal freedom in the best form of culture and government we currently have. How can I prove this? Because Europeans are not flocking to these failed countries. 2. I want the essential elements of Europe to remain. I do not, under any circumstances want Islam to turn Europe into the cesspool they have created. Islam has not reached an enlightenment in any sense. They absolutely fail at science. Science has brought us in the western world to where we are now. 3. Sharia, as a vehicle to Jihad, is a sinister doctrine. It violates every concept of western rule of law. These laws have been fought for and won over hundreds of years at the cost of many lives. We cannot simply surrender this rule of law to the first theocracy which has so patently failed to implement it in even their own societies. 4. You must not conflate generous social ideologies towards a culture and relion in which these concepts are an anathema.
@martynspooner5822
@martynspooner5822 7 жыл бұрын
Omnipitous Well said, it echoes my own sentiments.
@mrs.schmenkman
@mrs.schmenkman 5 жыл бұрын
Very egalitarian. Hope you enjoy it while your world is enveloped and completely disassembled by a very organized and determined invasion of Islamic warriors. I saw what Bin Laden was teaching and I promise you they are fully engaged in the plan and you will not see it until it's too late.
@TheBandit7613
@TheBandit7613 5 жыл бұрын
You are truly a fool.
@gladysrodriguez5498
@gladysrodriguez5498 3 жыл бұрын
Omnipitous : RIGHT. EXCELENT
@Chris-dt5td
@Chris-dt5td 5 жыл бұрын
Many things labelled today as "racism" should be seen from an evolutionary biology and psychology perspective. It is a very different picture.
@nasussmith8839
@nasussmith8839 7 жыл бұрын
In Denmark if you want or need welfare you have to declare certain assets as far as I've heard. So if its good enough for the indigenous people why not the migrants?
@nicolajherskind7033
@nicolajherskind7033 6 жыл бұрын
so true.
@allthesmallthings1041
@allthesmallthings1041 2 жыл бұрын
Racist!
@angelaharvey4797
@angelaharvey4797 5 жыл бұрын
Douglas Murray makes absolute sense.
@redpeony
@redpeony 7 жыл бұрын
If the politicians 'can't do anything' they'll be pushed out of the way by people who can do something. But the longer we leave this, the more unpalatable is the likely solution.
@kingmany1
@kingmany1 5 жыл бұрын
Red Peony very good point. People forget that Europe is not adverse to genocide, they do it at least there’s times a century
@sparhopper
@sparhopper 6 жыл бұрын
*_27:14_* Imagine... _just _*_imagine_* if this question was asked of someone, *_anyone_* from say _Nicaragua, Mexico, Bolivia, Iran, Nigeria, China, Sierra Leone, Sudan, Venezuela, Iraq, Afghanistan, even Detroit, Texas, Oregon, Georgia or Chicago!_ I think, I *hope* you understand that asking someone, *_anyone_* to defend their culture is completely *asinine.*
@peterdollins3610
@peterdollins3610 6 жыл бұрын
From the sixties mass immigration into the UK met both racism and in my view genuine criticism with also, support. The criticism was met by conflating this with the racists who were often opposed by the same people. This tendency has only intensified. People such as Murray and Jordan Peterson call out such and associated evils and misrepresentations. Same time identity politics the craziness of SOME parts of the Left has pushed them too far to the Right. This is my praise and my warning as somebody who has read more than both and certainly experienced more than both. Peter L. Dollins.
@DavidMorley123
@DavidMorley123 5 жыл бұрын
Good questions but hard to hear. Maybe the microphone runner should hold the microphone since many people don't know how to hold it. Thanks for a good program.
@nicolajherskind7033
@nicolajherskind7033 6 жыл бұрын
We danes (some of us at least) are fighting for our culture. And we are called racist for it... strange times.
@gladysrodriguez5498
@gladysrodriguez5498 3 жыл бұрын
Why the muslims do not change their culture??AH AH AH. HA!
@Gozzillacia
@Gozzillacia 7 жыл бұрын
Couple of thoughts - I wonder why Douglas didn't point out Catholicism and Protestantism are the same religion at base. Based on the Bible, both have Jesus as God, and Jesus' teaching as their default return to base. If trouble between the two sects of the same religion persist even now - how much more difficult will it be for Islam (which it antithetical to the foundational beliefs/conclusions of the West), to settle - I'd say it is impossible. Also - the guy who says Turks have totally assimilated into Germany has obviously never been to Germany. And finally still much of the talk here (not from Douglas) is the same old try try try to find a way not to blame Islam. Which to me comes from two points of view, the various types of Islamophile/apologist, and those running away from the fact Islam will bring civil-war to Europe ( to the West ) sooner or later. Why will Islam bring war to Europe - because Islam is a restless amoral conquering power-system - at base.
@EmperorsNewWardrobe
@EmperorsNewWardrobe 7 жыл бұрын
Joe Rong, that final sentence especially rang very true. I’m testing a new question with anyone I meet who seems closed to opposing Islam for fear of demonising Muslims. So the question is an epistemic one, “How do you hold someone accountable without demonising them?”, after which evidence can be presented of Islam’s aggressive design playing out
@Gozzillacia
@Gozzillacia 7 жыл бұрын
I think the answer is no one is "demonising." That is a piece of hyperbola designed to discredit those who question the ideology. It's like the often levelled accusation - " you can't say all muslims are terrorists?" The fact is no one does say "all Muslims are terrorists." Having said that - just like decent Germans were weaponised while under the thumb of Nazi ideology - so will the decent Muslims be weaponised by the ideology that has them under its thumb - that ideology being Islam.
@EmperorsNewWardrobe
@EmperorsNewWardrobe 7 жыл бұрын
Joe Rong, I entirely agree, though the purpose of my question is to provoke into thought those who seem reflexively closed to criticisms of Islam because they fear they’re demonising Muslims
@darrenwithers3628
@darrenwithers3628 7 жыл бұрын
They don't like it up em islamicsupremecouncil.org/understanding-islam/legal-rulings/5-jihad-a-misunderstood-concept-from-islam.html?start=9
@darrenwithers3628
@darrenwithers3628 7 жыл бұрын
They don''t like it up em You should stop rambling on about stuff you have no fucking clue about.
@czypauly07
@czypauly07 5 жыл бұрын
"You're welcome to come, join us, but we would still like to keep it, if you wouldn't mind awfully" Classic DM right there
@forestfanatic4605
@forestfanatic4605 5 жыл бұрын
Douglas Murray is a genius everything he says is correct, along with Ayaan Hirsi Ali, Sam Harris, and Steven Yaxley Lennon
@almostafa4725
@almostafa4725 3 жыл бұрын
You’re listening to the wrong people
@anglosaxon5874
@anglosaxon5874 7 жыл бұрын
You would think they had better microphones/P.A. system for such a venue!
@johnjarman9039
@johnjarman9039 5 жыл бұрын
Always interesting ... a shame the audience questions and points were so distorted by the 'travelling' mic ...
@manusha1349
@manusha1349 2 жыл бұрын
Douglas Murray is a genius! But what a collosally STUPID question to ask 'why Europe matters' to him ... insane
@nicksim1602
@nicksim1602 6 жыл бұрын
Who else here has got to the point where they are now just absolutely fed-up to the back teeth with simply hearing the words Muslim or Islam? It is obviously a cultural problem for our country that can't be solved - as their non-integration & self-separation over the last 70 years indicates. The situation should lead our politicians to the easy conclusion, surely!
@almostafa4725
@almostafa4725 3 жыл бұрын
Than stop listening
@SicSeb
@SicSeb 7 жыл бұрын
51:15 ish. Geert Wilders wasn't disregarded by the electorate at all. They were one of the biggest winners of the elections and became the second biggest party in the Netherlands
@SicSeb
@SicSeb 7 жыл бұрын
Douglas Murray rightly commented on it I heard. I jumped the gun
@wolfwind1
@wolfwind1 5 жыл бұрын
The analysis of the Merkel tv show incident was brilliant.
@SuperBeanson
@SuperBeanson 7 жыл бұрын
5:25 I'm not sure the inhabitants of Omagh would agree that Bloody Sunday was the worst...
@simonpole3873
@simonpole3873 7 жыл бұрын
Great questions. A smart crowd indeed.
@24Matferrari
@24Matferrari 6 жыл бұрын
Thrumdi not really, they sound like indoctrinated children
@bored77551
@bored77551 6 жыл бұрын
From the Belgian perspective, we also saw many imigrants from before 2015 from turkey and marokko, they were indeed not perfectly integrated, the first generation often didn't learn the language, their children did however start integrating properly, going to school and learning the language, but you did hear them prefer their native tongue whenever speaking in public, this is all before 2015 I'm speaking of, this did indeed not sit well with many natives, and they where villified often, and many crimes that where reported on came from within their communities. People weren't so quick to call racism back then and it was a common thing to criticise harshly the acts of many among the turkish and marokkan people committing crimes. In the general public things haven't changed much at all, in the media yes, but still, when you see people dressed in bin bags walking the streets speaking a language you don't understand, it's something people still heavily oppose. The natives call these ppl strangers and for good reason.
@tommore3263
@tommore3263 5 жыл бұрын
As a Catholic I find this presentation to be of great interest. Firstly perhaps because of the Catholic insistence upon reason. Indeed , reason at the ground of being is a precondition of the reliability of reason as a guide. And it speaks to the stunning fact of the intelligibility of reality. So theism, properly understood and certainly in the Catholic or Orthodox sense , is ..no pun intended.. perfectly reasonable and nothing makes sense or has a grounded identity outside of it. I like philosophers Ed Feser and Mortimer Adler on these issues. They only deal with reason, not religion or theology incidentally although both are Catholics; Adler towards the very end of his life, while Feser used to be an atheist, ( or radically incoherent as I like to argue.... :-) ) Cheers.
@viriknavarro3165
@viriknavarro3165 7 жыл бұрын
Nothing strange about it. It's a simple strategy used on simpletons and those unwilling to think about and accept some realities of life (largely because we've been brow-beaten to not think along those lines or about those things, realistically). A think tank got together and decided to promote "love" as the only way and their version of "love" is consumerism, mass immigration and miscegenation for purposes of globalism. Globalism being a way to import cheap labor and gain control of the world's resources elsewhere. In order to accomplish their goals, they had to break down every defense the west has save for military, ensure it's flooded with people not native to western nations and then brow beat the natives by criticizing every aspect of every means of defense (this includes but is not limited to the primary religion, their in-group preferences and their role in shaping the world). After they've ushered in enough people of a specific nation, the globalists believe they can use them to influence others from their nation of origin; their ethnic and racial group(s). Globalists as before, in the old days, don't care if people are enslaved, raped, robbed and/or murdered. All they care about is their bank accounts and their own personal wants, needs and desires. Allowing and endorsing this is the west's ultimate failure.
@killercd7682
@killercd7682 7 жыл бұрын
Love your directness. I respect Murray, but he's still pussy footing around the issue, is over intellectualizing, and is afraid to look at issues of race.
@crystalclear7488
@crystalclear7488 6 жыл бұрын
Yes. It's suicide by Globalism.
@oliverlovesgorts
@oliverlovesgorts 6 жыл бұрын
Great virtue signaling bro...
@seanranklin2733
@seanranklin2733 7 жыл бұрын
that like that like like like like that like like like
@Nerdiness1985
@Nerdiness1985 7 жыл бұрын
Lol couldn't agree more. Saying the word um to pause after every few words is considered annoying and slows down a speech considerably. The word like gets used as a verb, noun and as a general filler it seems.
@HR-yd5ib
@HR-yd5ib 6 жыл бұрын
?
@christastempel5577
@christastempel5577 6 жыл бұрын
I just want to say something in addition to when Douglas Murray mentioned the invited guest workers from Turkey into Germany, and how Merkel admitted that the Germans thought they would return to their country once they were no longer needed...I think the problem is not that the Turkish people wished to remain in Germany, but that they never 'left' their home country. I think we all can understand that 'home' means not only where we live, but where we feel our roots to be. However, we need to question why Turks and those of Turkish descent, living in Germany, think they have the right to demonstrate their allegiance to a fascist Turkish Dictator, on German soil. How would Turkish people feel, if Germans were to demonstrate in any political way at all, on Turkish soil? Let's face it, it would not be tolerated. In Europe, we tolerate absolutely everything. It is ridiculous, and it is simply WRONG. When will we Europeans say enough is enough? Our politicians might be held responsible for the downfall of Europe, but they are going to hide in their privileged neighbourhoods, in their police protected houses, and in their arrogant ignorance of thinking that they have 'tried to do the right thing'.
@almostafa4725
@almostafa4725 3 жыл бұрын
“In Europe, we tolerate absolutely everything” lol stop lying
@Kurtlane
@Kurtlane 7 жыл бұрын
You need models? How about Poland or Czech Republic?
@johnybecool2810
@johnybecool2810 6 жыл бұрын
good models, but impossible to follow by countries like France,UKGermany, because 6-10% of the citizens are already muslims in those countries. what you wanna do?
@almostafa4725
@almostafa4725 3 жыл бұрын
If Poland is so great, why do Poles migrate to West? Why is it a second world country?
@aaoppe
@aaoppe 6 жыл бұрын
I'm still reeling from the fact that this q&a was moderated by Chris Hemsworth. :D
@wolfwind1
@wolfwind1 5 жыл бұрын
Hilarious : )
@killercd7682
@killercd7682 7 жыл бұрын
This point at 1:03:00 is spot on. We are coming from a secular pragmatic perspective, 'they' are coming from a religious, morally charged perspective. I wonder if our western societies are built on straw. How long has it been since the population was filled with believers?
@joebrey7052
@joebrey7052 4 жыл бұрын
I love Douglas Murray. However this was a terribly painful Q&A. The questioners were long winded and appeared to want to hear themselves talk more than hear Douglas weight in on a subject.
@CloudyMcCloud00
@CloudyMcCloud00 5 жыл бұрын
I can't get enough of Murray, but it's a shame the sound issues here spoil this quite a lot.
@conrad1on
@conrad1on 7 жыл бұрын
As ever, some of the potentially most important discussions of our time are brought to you in surround potato.
@BhutanBluePoppy
@BhutanBluePoppy 5 жыл бұрын
Very good questions from the Lafayette audience & presenters - Douglas' answers, not so much. Possibly some new perspectives were presented to him.
@YusefYandron
@YusefYandron 7 жыл бұрын
man you could get some really good 10 minute clips from this
@DesolationAngel101
@DesolationAngel101 7 жыл бұрын
I have his book, but I've been too apprehensive to read it.
@Hello_there_obi
@Hello_there_obi 7 жыл бұрын
The one thing I think Douglas missed that is key was the whole culture vs religion question. One of the students asked if it was the culture and not the religion to blame. The huge oversight made was that in most of those countries, Islam *defines* the culture and had been doing so for centuries. It is a total solution in the sense that it tells you how to live your life in giving you economical and political instructions as well. When I talk about this to people, I never let them get away with making that excuse and if they were simply unaware, I do my best to get the point across.
@almostafa4725
@almostafa4725 3 жыл бұрын
You are dead wrong, Islam doesn’t inform the culture in those countries, if it did why are those countries not Islamic states/caliphates instead of nation states or monarchies?
@jqn8361
@jqn8361 10 ай бұрын
@@almostafa4725Surely we can agree that culture is something significantly deeper than a country’s government system
@biancavonmuhlendorf2608
@biancavonmuhlendorf2608 6 жыл бұрын
excellent and true. This reasoning does nearly not exist in Germany.
@Jopacob
@Jopacob 6 жыл бұрын
Thank you Douglas, horrendous audio though.
@HR-yd5ib
@HR-yd5ib 6 жыл бұрын
BRAVO DENMARK!
@SebDangerfield-yu7cm
@SebDangerfield-yu7cm 5 жыл бұрын
An army (this Muslim invasion) doesn't need to bear arms if its intent is to overthrow by sheer weight of force at the ballot box. Witness London's Muslim Mayor if you are unsure such tactics can be effective. Once in place, such is unstoppable, as well as being impossible of being overthrown, when they have gained the upper-hand, politically.
@Dr.Kananga
@Dr.Kananga 7 жыл бұрын
Great episode but major microphone issues.
@woudwilder8324
@woudwilder8324 Жыл бұрын
I agree on most points with Douglas Murray apart from his views on Christianity. We don't need it to identify ourselves and be proud Europeans. Why would I need a belief in an imaginary being to identify myself and feel good about myself? I'd rather be burned on the stake than being forced to belief in a fantasy if I had to make a choice...
@vizveebee
@vizveebee 3 ай бұрын
You misunderstood, what he said.
@jaderozner5653
@jaderozner5653 6 жыл бұрын
these people need to learn about recording audio in live formats like this, you can take out the noise, not hard
@Marcus-xb7le
@Marcus-xb7le 6 ай бұрын
Dude is proving right for every passing day.
@kepeb1
@kepeb1 7 жыл бұрын
38:25 Can't hear a word. You need to talk into the top part of the microphone. Not the area designed specifically to reject sound.
@stanstlouis9811
@stanstlouis9811 5 жыл бұрын
Just got you and this Strange Death, all you're work is looked at by me.
@CrazyLeiFeng
@CrazyLeiFeng 7 жыл бұрын
From Wiki: In December 2015, Murray announced that he could no longer give his readers advance notice of his speaking engagements, citing "security reasons"
@bolabocha3016
@bolabocha3016 5 жыл бұрын
He not afraid to speak the truth and he is a very intelligent man. I think is not hope for Europe it is too late but Poland still has a great model.
@almostafa4725
@almostafa4725 3 жыл бұрын
So why are Poles migrating to the West? lol
@cristerowarrior1450
@cristerowarrior1450 7 жыл бұрын
Return to Christianity
@hucklebk
@hucklebk 6 жыл бұрын
Rather not mate. replacing one insane ideology with another isn't the best of idea's!
@hucklebk
@hucklebk 6 жыл бұрын
@Black Beard you are not an atheist.
@hucklebk
@hucklebk 6 жыл бұрын
@Black Beard I'm against all religions. Christianity is a shit stain. Just so happens Islam is a bigger one at the moment.
@hucklebk
@hucklebk 6 жыл бұрын
@Black Beard lmao dude you are deluded. Go back to church you clearly are not ready to leave.
@Zinner222
@Zinner222 6 жыл бұрын
@@hucklebk GO LIVE IN AN ATHEISTIC STATE IF YOU BELIEVE THAT. NTH kOREA OR VIETNAM.
@dread4836
@dread4836 5 жыл бұрын
I don't buy the paying smugglers to get into EU, I think they have been encouraged by the charities who have been financing the whole thing,
@Celticcross688
@Celticcross688 6 жыл бұрын
We in Britain do have a Constitutional Bill of Rights.. and all indigenous people are Sovereign..Americans also have a Constitution based on the Magna Carta 1215.
@felixfedre518
@felixfedre518 7 жыл бұрын
Race is still very important to British people, the majority of British people still consider a Briton to be a white person. Murray is disingenuous when he claims that British white people wouldn't mind their children marrying outside their race.
@modernist2628
@modernist2628 7 жыл бұрын
Less and less. A lot of mixed race couples in the UK.
@CelticSaint
@CelticSaint 6 жыл бұрын
Loads of mixed race couples in the UK.
@shelleyphilcox4743
@shelleyphilcox4743 5 жыл бұрын
The statistics dont support your assertion.
@Leatherargento
@Leatherargento 7 жыл бұрын
"Man. "Woman. "Birth. "Death. "Infinity." ~~Introduction to _Ben Casey_, American TV medical drama, 1961-1966, American Broadcasting Company These are the things that are eternal in America.
@tonygould1524
@tonygould1524 5 жыл бұрын
The guy with the scarf cant seem to comprehend that he has to hold the microphone closer to his mouth.
Audiobook Chapter 1 - The Strange Death of Europe: Immigration, Identity, Islam
27:25
Grant Coultrup Productions
Рет қаралды 8 М.
How Much Tape To Stop A Lamborghini?
00:15
MrBeast
Рет қаралды 203 МЛН
HELP!!!
00:46
Natan por Aí
Рет қаралды 75 МЛН
Walking on LEGO Be Like... #shorts #mingweirocks
00:41
mingweirocks
Рет қаралды 7 МЛН
Миллионер | 3 - серия
36:09
Million Show
Рет қаралды 1,9 МЛН
Douglas Murray, Reflecting on the Strange Death of Europe
29:51
Rebel Wisdom
Рет қаралды 74 М.
Progressive ideas and The Strange Death of Europe | Douglas Murray & Amit Segal
52:48
המרכז לחרות ישראלית
Рет қаралды 47 М.
Identity Politics: Lionel Shriver & Douglas Murray | The Spectator
1:36:38
Debating Douglas Murray on Gender, Reparations, and Extinction Rebellion
1:23:29
The Death of Europe, with Douglas Murray
47:16
Hoover Institution
Рет қаралды 6 МЛН
Thomas Sowell Brings the World into Focus through an Economics Lens
49:51
Hoover Institution
Рет қаралды 1 МЛН
Why Can Nobody Think For Themselves Anymore? - Douglas Murray (4K)
2:00:23
Chris Williamson
Рет қаралды 2,1 МЛН
How Much Tape To Stop A Lamborghini?
00:15
MrBeast
Рет қаралды 203 МЛН