Dr Halstead Breaks The Law To Save A Life | Chicago Med

When a patient signs a request to not be revived, Dr Halstead is confident that he can save his patient's life. But will he be able to convince the patient and her family in time?
Watch full episodes Of Chicago Med on Google Play: play.google.co...
Watch full episodes Of Chicago Med on Itunes: apple.co/2yCC3Is
Subscribe for more videos from the Chicago heroes: / @chicago

[@christinagray3708]

Every Chicago med episode ever: Nurse:”she’s seizing” Doctor:”I need a ABC and DEF with 2milligrams of a GHIJ stat”

[@josephlougheed5890]

Christina Gray lol

[@squeet6831]

If she's seizing its 5 adavan

[@IJaabbI]

Squeet r/whoooosh

[@finechina.]

I dont understand ANYTHING

[@finechina.]

Ohhhhh I get it now 😂😂🙄

[@rosyanimaljam8121]

Will: she’s gonna thank me Me:WITH THE COPS AT YOUR DOOR

[@-Jynx-]

Rosy Animal Jam IKR

[@chronicles2062]

lol⛄

[@milephakphumtitties8637]

@Harriet Antrobus hes a doctor,he dont listen to the patient, he do what is right for them hahaha

[@irenerandazzo4206]

No. She could not even say goodbye to her daughter. Her daughter and husband were heartbroken. If I decide I want to die and I see my son in such pain I will thank anybody who will gift him even one more minute of my time with him.

[@fdgod1931]

Harriet Antrobus halstead did what he thought was right even though it was wrong

[@QueenaCobra]

This scene got me. I understand the male doctor side but I understand how the mom feels. My dad died of cancer as well and at the end when he excepted that he was going to die he was the most peaceful I had ever seen him. For my dad he never even got the option to seek treatment but I would understand Not wanting to do it

[@user-vj9do7ck6w]

Send my deep condolences to your Father.

[@aliceedet8561]

Oh am sorry my he rest in peace

[@siennagrima5361]

I understand how you feel... I can’t say anymore..

[@hannahoneill5502]

Kayla B sorry ur dad died x

[@abbie799]

So sorry 💖

[@katelynko6999]

WHAT THE HECK, SHE LOOKS LIKE HANNAH BAKERS MOM AND HER NAME IS MRS. BAKER

[@rubyali4218]

OMG THATS WHAT I THOUGHT

[@felicityjohnston2061]

Omg maybe Hanna’s mom has cancer and that little girl is her but the Dad looks nothing like mr baker but looks change though....

[@felicityjohnston2061]

Lucy Love I know it’s just a thought

[@hollyxx387]

Katelyn ko OMG YH SHE DOES I JUST NOTICED

[@hannahcollinson9885]

I thought that!

[@kamaramesuinu1260]

I swear to god if i hear that little girl say "DaDdY HeLp HeR" one more time, im gonna flip my desk over Edit: um holy crap i didnt expect people to get pressed over ONE comment 😳 but i mean, thanks for the likes 😂💕 i made this comment over a year ago and people are still arguing about a comment from a year ago damn

[@kennethg1092]

And why is that

[@chronicles2062]

Because she is distracting everyone else and they are trying to save a life DUH

[@asalot9163]

Also because it's heartbreaking to hear a little girl crying that her mom's dying?

[@serenacain2162]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@sleep7018]

Kamara Service you are savage 😉

[@alexsimons3454]

Am I the only one that winces at the thud whenever they transfer a patient from a stretcher to the bed?

[@chilli3672]

Nope😂

[@chloebillows58]

Ally Simons sameee omg

[@kuragelvr]

Its worse when you're the patients its a oof and a half

[@alekkonchol7542]

Yeah same

[@caseymaxwell4524]

When I was transferred from the stretcher to the bed, the thudding sound was scarier than actually landing on the bed 😂

[@ashxs.rblx_chile9914]

Can there be full episodes I’m always missing out

[@anjanovakovic1018]

Jes

[@natalia_973]

Masala news And scary reactions I Think it would be copyright THATS why

[@ellaholmberg4894]

Where can you see the whole episodes

[@blacksoda2178]

Rose it can't be cause that's the actual company that makes the full videos

[@foreverqueen6406]

PRINCESS FATOU u can

[@ninagreenshields7185]

I can't believe he did that to the father in front of his daughter. put him in an impossible situation

[@fatoomalali528]

Nina Greenshields he did nothing he was trying to save her LIFE

[@user-vo9xe4yw7i]

Narwhal Mountain she didnt want to be saved, it just prolongs the pain for her and her family

[@jamessucks6634]

@@fatoomalali528 we listen to our patients wishes, if they wanna die the we are in no position to help

[@jimmyfergin7300]

I know

[@ladyneko5456]

Female Player it’s illegal to surpass a DNR. She could have sued the hospital and he could have gotten his medical license taken away. Irregardless, sometimes death is the greatest mercy for people. She was alive but she wasn’t living...

[@akiakiii5879]

I'm actually surprised the doctors there still have their license

[@wolfgirl4486]

It's probably because its a TV show😂

[@ehliimana.k]

@@wolfgirl4486 it is

[@jackdisbury1047]

@Heba ElHariri not really when the patient is specified as dnr

[@brammie155]

well tbh its hard for a doctor to loose his/her license irl. they always say in this tv show `its gonna get ur licesne revoked` but irl that rarely happens... unless ofc they do something highly illegal like kill patients

[@andyt2k]

He wouldn't IRL

[@peachii3991]

For people who are curious, the patient did end up dying later on in the season. The charges against him were dropped because the husband was thankful that his wife didn’t die that day, and he got more time with her. However, even after the charges were dropped, the doctor couldn’t get good Malpractice insurance because *cough* *cough* he does a lot of malpractice, and is deep in debt! :3

[@dr.maryamabid9371]

Sometimes its very difficult to choose between legalities n your emotions . Being a doctor is very difficult . I am a resident oncologist n have to deal with d.n.r patients on daily basis . It drains you emotionally ...

[@martha-hy7vq]

dang... best wishes to the doctors like you out there

[@rojdaa6192]

I want to be an oncologist, any advice? ❤️

[@ActuallyLinden]

Keep it up... you're doing God's work.

[@mjt9590]

thank you for your service

[@sairamr6886]

I'm so sorry. Oncologists take an entirely different kind of hit to the gut with Patients from all walks of life. Respect .

[@n.jboltz599]

this scene was so wrong. He wasn't trying to save her, he was superimposing his mother onto this patient and denied her wishes and a legally binding order. it must have been difficult for the patient to reach the decision she did and to have that disrespected by some doctor who thinks he knows better. even after revival he cant force her to take the trial drugit didn't even matter in the end she died anyway

[@ol1551]

if it was your mother and you saw here like she was slowly losing grip of the life she had left imagine how helpless you would feel. that child would have got more time with her mother which is priceless sometimes morals and doing the right thing is just something that has to be done even if its against the law

[@LemonSte]

@@ol1551 Wrong. My grandad died painfully of cancer last year, and I love him more than I love myself but frankly we all wish he had died sooner and so did he. There comes a point when a life is no longer worth living. I'm glad that you have too little experience with this to understand it, but someday you might have to think about what you would want and treat others the same. If I was dying slowly and painfully, I would want to die.

[@ol1551]

@@LemonSte thats fair, im very sorry for your loss and i understand as i love my father very much much love and my condolences

[@LemonSte]

@@TeoZeFei wtf is even your point? That a doctor should be able to decide you will live against your wishes - and even though you are in so much pain that you life you once loved is now unliveable - to use it as a teaching opportunity? You're a psychopath.

[@petsandthingsilike]

@@TeoZeFei They do it to suicidal people, I don't understand why they couldn't over ride any other illness!

[@MrAntiKnowledge]

If you ignore my DNR you better make sure I'm also cured of all my illnesses when I wake up or have a very good lawyer.

[@MrAntiKnowledge]

@IDxzzy XBL So you don't think someone performing medical procedures on you AGAINST your will should be sued?

[@user-hu4vo2mn2i]

IDxzzy XBL i don’t understand what ur getting at tbh

[@sumi4684]

Tbh as much as this is a drama if this happened in real life that doctor would have his medical license revoked and most likely spend time in prison. Remember people this is not real life! No doctors would do this, when she died it would have ended there.

[@humphryshan9494]

Sommie she filed a lawsuit, was started on the new drug. It was revealed she was only receiving a placebo and not the actual chemo drug used in the trial, she became too ill to continue the trial and died shortly after. Her husband dropped all charges and thanked Dr. Halstead for not giving up on her.

[@Arcaryon]

No, of cause this isn't real life. In real life people are not idealists. Sadly. The world would be a better place if more folks had the guts to stand up for what they believe in. Though I doubt that even as young as I am I will see this day, the moral idea behind this scene is interesting. If you swear an oath to safe lives and then a patient wants to die - shouldn't this patient have went someplace else? Is it worth to die for the peace of your loved ones? Was the doctor right or wrong? I can't answer those questions. But we all thought about them because of this episode. I think that is a success.

[@msplover3656]

But like .... why would anyone want to sign something to say yeah let my wife just die in-front of my daughter no problem I don’t care let her die..... NO ONE NOT EVER

[@faisalmohd9875]

Some family would even press charges over DNR issue because of the money they would get. That's reality.

[@angel_cat]

Exactly.

[@ynnig01]

Who come here In The “Your son Is A Pyschopath” Like If u seem The kid

[@casteelsimp3539]

Ginny Flores I actually did

[@unisisters940]

What time?

[@lanaclough612]

Oml I actually did

[@zeynabomar3644]

I did

[@frankysworld1121]

That how I found this show, now I'm literally binge watching it

[@batmanneedssome200]

Wouldn't protocol not put this doctor with this patient? He is too emotionally motivated to save her despite her wishes.

[@raghit]

I understand they are suppised to save lives but.... shouldn't they also respect the patiens desicion. It's their body and their lives.... and she is suffering so much but sometimes ut's just better to go than live in pain

[@martha-hy7vq]

yeah thats true.

[@monabohamad2242]

@@SweetTikTokLife I guess if it's your time to go then it's your time to go EVERY life ends sooner or later and it doesn't really matter how old or young you are but other than that I'm not sure what else to say other than...I don't think I was ever really taught that death is actually a bad thing

[@johncamplin1159]

@@SweetTikTokLife in the part of Christianity I was raised in ( baptist) we allow people to choose if they want to continue living or not. We do not force them to continue living

[@Sam-vy8ye]

@UCuBelNmMwRWry1YpqYJBoFg 1. It’s because your teacher has a different theology. Theology doesn’t differ between countries. 2. You may be thinking of euthanasia. Most, if not all Christians are fine with DNR orders. Some may even have DNR orders themselves. This is because we believe that God has the sole right and power to both create and end life. No one is ending a life in a DNR situation. One is simply just accepting that their time has come and the doctors are respecting their decision. Euthanasia is different. That is when someone with a terminal illness makes the decision to end their life before they die of natural causes, usually because of the physical pain and suffering they are going through. Therefore a doctor would assist them in ending their life. A lot of Christians are opposed to this because it is the act of ending a life unnaturally. Therefore it seen by many Christians to be murder and playing God because taking a life is seen as desecrating the sanctity of life and violating God’s sole right as the giver of life.

[@Allaroundtheworld99]

It’s difficult but you’ve got to respect a DNR! It’s hard, but it’s the law!

[@cyan6209]

Sometime right is not always right

[@Allaroundtheworld99]

Cyan Redstoneer But it’s what the family wants and sometimes it’s best.

[@kaitlintropper2061]

@@cyan6209 i know but you have no choice.

[@kaitlintropper2061]

Very true

[@Justaperson1289]

*you are bad guy, but this does not mean you are bad guy*

[@finechina.]

Wtf?

[@user-mq8tn9vy3m]

@@finechina. its from wreck it Ralph as in someone is the bad guy in the game but not a bad person

[@finechina.]

@@user-mq8tn9vy3m Okay, thanks man.

[@gloryrocks1571]

weed bang lmao your profile pic is the perfect reply to the comment

[@finechina.]

@@gloryrocks1571 LMAO TRUE 🤣😂💀

[@8bennaboo]

He didnt actually save her all he brought her was more pain.

[@Rur0mx]

My apologies for what I've said, this was 3years ago, i was most likely thinking stupidly and not maturely. You are all right, sorry for making this comment.

[@thepistachio6227]

Jannah Aspari it probably took a lot for the mother to come to the conclusion that she didn’t want to be brought back to life, the doctor should have respected her wishes. The dad was already explaining to the daughter how she was in a better place when the doctor came in, he was ready to move on and go wish his wife’s wishes.

[@alicearisu9066]

@@Rur0mx give up so easily? Didn't you hear what she said? She's tried everything and that's made her weaker and experience more pain. Cancer is very painful and tiring both physically and emotionally. If someone did that to me, resucitate me even though I said no, I wouldn't thank them because they went against my wishes and most probably subject me to more pain.

[@Brynwyn123]

@@Rur0mx the daughter has to suffer watching her mother get sicker and sicker, in horrendous pain, and then a few episodes after this the mother dies anyway. The kid would understand.

[@alexandradeguzman4223]

Shadöw Wölf8xöx she’s still young so I understand that but the little girl should respect her mother’s wishes and grow up to understand what her mom eanted

[@shapeshine2158]

“CAN YOU TELL ME HOW THIS HAPPENED?!” “hGnnnngG”

[@himankgupta9949]

This doctor is not thinking logically. DNR exists for a reason- Will of a patient. By doing this , the idiot will only serve to lose his license and in that many many other lives he could have saved. As a doctor, emotions have NO role in our job. Before u guys say crap- u will understand when u are a doctor or that it's hard, I am a doctor so I know that legal bindings to our job make it very important even when doing something which may be conventionally wrong. We need to prioritise our job so we can earn for ourselves and save lives of many others

[@rosealielycan]

Im not yet a nurse but i do want to be. I understand the legal things and ive been binging this series.... Im surprised by how many laws they broke in this show only one doctor had his license taken away because he misdiagnosed people... Then again ive only seen clips and not the entire thing just yet... Its still a thing that makes me go "why, isnt that illegal? That is illegal"

[@abhinavtonde4460]

Do you guys know? Which episode is this?

[@shara26dimpy]

I never understood why doctors came up with CPR? It's unnatural and cruel to chose a patients' suffering just to prolong his/her life rather than let them pass away peacefully and with dignity? Doctors watch death each and every day and know the horrible results of CPR on a patient yet they do CPR every time a heart goes into arrest. My uncle landed in vegetative state due to his hypoxia injury which all happened because he was resuscitated. I have began to hate the concept of CPR since then. When it's time to go, it's time to go. Body doesn't die without a cause or fight. If the heart has stopped that means it's tired and can no longer work efficiently. It's time for it to retire and for the person to move on. Why do we living people only think of our selfish needs? It wasn't as difficult to take care of my uncle as it was to know that the person we knew and loved no longer existed in that body and he continued to suffer for no reason or fault of his.

[@emilydebridge7145]

if theres anyone watching this show that wants to be a doctor or is currently in med school, DONT DO THIS. if a patient refuses to be treated, you must respect their wishes, even if it means death. if they are lucid, they are able to make decisions for themselves. as long as you lay out their options and they know the consequences for refusing treatment, you arent doing anything wrong. because if you dont respect their wishes, theres a pretty huge chance that youll end up in jail.

[@bottle3124]

Agreed.

[@lyrica_overdose]

as if you don’t learn this in med school

[@heymimiah]

Why would you activate code blue when she's DNR?? Wrong protocol man

[@HealthSpotlight]

It is an automated system... the machine is programmed to call a code

[@vixen3671]

I love how she is telling this is illegal when she herself has broken so many rules

[@nomnom4642]

Well I think he will be thanked for making that child’s life better so she grows up with a mother!

[@pmparda]

She will die anyway....

[@aimeehardings7686]

pmparda woah, no you can’t say that. That is fucking wrong! You sick person why would you say that

[@eimearkeaveney1192]

Are they? The patient made her wishes very clear.

[@melissaraisa2157]

She died after like 3 or 4 episodes

[@pmparda]

@@aimeehardings7686 Excuse me???????????????????????????????????? Do you watch the show? Why would you call me sick? SHE DIES AFTER THIS.

[@ChristineTheHippie]

This why he wasn't promoted. He has a history of breaking rules and letting his emotions get in the way.

[@StealthMode3924]

I think it’s cruel to keep someone alive against their will. If someone is tired of suffering, and has a legal DNR order, respect their wishes.

[@SheryAwan123]

i hv seen stage 4 cancer pts they are in pain believe me as a doctor i wush if they can legally allow euthenesia

[@issacyap9240]

TBH this should be on Netflix and it should be a continued story

[@beansontoast9924]

These aren't the full episodes-

[@snehasakharkar844]

I know this is all acting but I am so thankful for Doctors(my mom is one of them) that they do carry some emotions.

[@zy5992]

@gacha girl It's nothing to worry about. You bumped your "funny bone" which is at the back of your elbow. The pain should go away on its own.

[@tluangtei]

How did she know it's a collie's fracture just by looking?

[@jenmonster]

Colles fractures usually happen when people fall on an outstretched hand, so there's a characteristic deformity at the wrist where the hand is essentially not aligned with the rest of the arm

[@ashleyashleym2969]

If I ever decide to have a DNR order some time in my life I hope there aren't acy crappy doctors around that think they can override my decision on my life.

[@urgurljulesl9986]

I would've been personally really upset if that were to happen. My grandma had a DNR put on her in her final days and I would've been furious if they didn't listen to her wishes especially because she was a previous RN and also had her ribs broken from a reccesitation that happened a couple days eariler

[@omsh6000]

What have you done??? My JOB

[@berkeleymackenzenazaula1168]

It's part of his job to respect his patient's wishes.

[@Arcaryon]

@Speaking Truth No, he swore an oath: en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Osteopathic_Oath "I do hereby affirm my loyalty to the profession I am about to enter. I will be mindful always of my great responsibility to preserve the health and the life of my patients, to retain their confidence and respect both as a physician and a friend who will guard their secrets with scrupulous honor and fidelity, to perform faithfully my professional duties, to employ only those recognized methods of treatment consistent with good judgment and with my skill and ability, keeping in mind always nature's laws and the body's inherent capacity for recovery. I will be ever vigilant in aiding in the general welfare of the community, sustaining its laws and institutions, not engaging in those practices which will in any way bring shame or discredit upon myself or my profession. I will give no drugs for deadly purposes to any person, though it be asked of me. I will endeavor to work in accord with my colleagues in a spirit of progressive cooperation and never by word or by act cast imputations upon them or their rightful practices. I will look with respect and esteem upon all those who have taught me my art. To my college I will be loyal and strive always for its best interests and for the interests of the students who will come after me. I will be ever alert to further the application of basic biologic truths to the healing arts and to develop the principles of osteopathy which were first enunciated by Andrew Taylor Still." He made a judgment which he deemed to be in the best interest of all involved. His character firmly believed that the new treatment could work and that by letting her die he would disobey everything he stands for. Now, having watched the episode or just by knowing the legal background of this case, like everyone in the world you are free to judge this case. But next time, do it more analytical. He was not selfish, he could have been right. In his eyes, again; he was doing the best he could to preserve the life of a mother, to obey his oath and to follow what he stands for. There is nothing selfish about that. He didn't do it for his own glory or because he wanted to prove a point, he did it because at this deciding moment he was certain that he would have made a terrible mistake due to a patient who wished to take the easy way out because she had lost all hope. If he would have succeeded in the end, how would we judge him? He failed but he stood up for the profession he works in. To safe life's. Not to watch his patients die if there still is a possibility to save them.

[@alexandradeguzman4223]

Arcaryon if you watched other videos you would know that the doctors have to respect what their choice is. If the patient is dead you have to respect the fact that they don’t want to live anymore.

[@alexandradeguzman4223]

Arcaryon and in the law it also says you should respect someone’s wishes. So if this was real life he would be in jail right now

[@Arcaryon]

@@alexandradeguzman4223 I just quoted the complete oath dude. My point wasn't mainly about the fictional series but about the real life background and according to all sources, no you can't just let a patient die. It's controversial but it's part of most medical laws in the world.

[@expatleanie]

A doctor’s primary job is to treat the patient not treating the disease. I’d be pissed if the doctor didnt respect me or family. A good doctor treats people not the symptoms, just saying

[@aoife239]

Can we just take a minute to appreciate not only the main actors but also the actors making appearances, the mains are so talented in remembering all these difficult lines and all the appearing actors playing these people dying and nailing it is astonishing.

[@bopeep268]

Chicago Med personnel with patient that can't be saved be like: *"I ain't givin up on you!"* Meanwhile doctors in my country when I get a papercut: *"IF HE DIES HE DIES!"*

[@warh1story563]

Lol rocky 4

[@danielsadie3887]

This happened in real life. It's illegal to ignore a DNR order.

[@DiamondAviator4]

I swear, if I were Dr. Halstead’s boss, he’d not only lose his job, but his license for medical malpractice and evasion of an DNR.

[@beahppybean9250]

I don't know why I chuckled when he said " she's gonna thank me" lol 😂

[@matildabreakwell4320]

I'm sorry if a patient wants to go to heaven then let them go she has obviously had enough

[@martha-hy7vq]

yeah, she's gone through all that pain.

[@monabohamad2242]

OR you could believe in God and ask him to allow you to live AND take away the pain and suffering that's pretty much as far as I know what has happened with me and my mom we believe in God nobody should be forced to believe in God if they don't want to but if you do believe in the most powerful existing being who created us AND is VERY much real and pray he'll take away your pain and suffering it might just happen but if it's your time to go then it's your time to go again I don't want to shove or force what I believe in on to ANY BODY'S face I just wanted to share this and say what I wanted to say

[@Leahleahleah4507]

“She’s gonna thank me” PFFT YEA WITH A LAWSUIT

[@emilydebridge7145]

Jennifer Baker. Will was charged for resisitating her and the hospital was sued. We talk about her for several episodes, and the trial that jennifer baker eventually went into only made her sicker because it was a placebo. They had no choice but to take her off of it, and she died. (if you cannot watch chicago med because you are not in America, theres a website where you can watch any movie or tv show for free, its called soap2day. Im in canada and im on season 2. Trust me, it WORKS!)

[@jessicarabbit9960]

Do you know what episode and season this one was?

[@emilydebridge7145]

@@jessicarabbit9960 hmm, im not completely sure. I can say its season 1 and this is talked about for longer than this peisode

[@jessicarabbit9960]

@@emilydebridge7145 thank youuu

[@dollym1lk980]

every episode i wonder why their licenses have not been revoked

[@bottle3124]

Ikr

[@LutineAmoureuse]

compressions were way to fast

[@danlol9936]

Dominique Boucher omg i know right hahahahahah bruh he could’ve broken her rib

[@LutineAmoureuse]

ribs break from chest compressions tho but i feel like he was going off with the speed lmao

[@deathboy100]

Dan Lol They need to break the rib to get to the heart

[@LutineAmoureuse]

lol

[@jashapp289]

yeah they needed to go 110bpm but they were going like 130bpm

[@paulasmith4185]

Omg girl

[@jogailenarkunaite7906]

The two hottest people in this show are Dr Reese and Dr Choi :3

[@yummo2skittles135]

Jogaile Narkunaite I can’t argue with that xD

[@faayumcheese]

Jogaile Narkunaite helllooo?? Dr halsted ahem *cough* *cough* hottie

[@kenopsia9013]

Don’t you dare ship them and ruin it

[@alekkonchol7542]

Umm April?

[@beansontoast9924]

Dr Reece looks exactly like one of my teachers

[@anyssadjaroun1403]

Mrs Baker 13 reasons why Even looks like Mrs Baker

[@notanevilrussian9674]

Anyssa Djaroun She’s not

[@leventenagy4302]

I'm actually pretty shocked that the nurses did what Halstead told them to do

[@Jackferrett6781]

They probably didn’t know that she had a DNR

[@juliocesaroliveira6003]

@@Jackferrett6781 they did

[@Jackferrett6781]

@@juliocesaroliveira6003 and yet that weren’t held accountable as accomplices. Because they definitely would in real life

[@juliocesaroliveira6003]

@@Jackferrett6781 exactly, the Doctor would get away scot-free somehow.

[@Jackferrett6781]

@@juliocesaroliveira6003 either they didn’t know about the DNR or they did and were threatened into violating it

[@christinebrument6851]

So wrong on so many levels and in front of her child??? Disgraceful should be struck off. She made her wishes very clear and he's there playing God but he doesn't have to endure what she has to.

[@thystaworld8536]

This gotta be an extremely fd up situation for a doctor to be in. I guess that's why I never even considered to be one, I simply couldn't handle that kind of stress and responsibility.

[@marwahkhan6730]

Why do patients need to justify to anybody about whether they want to live or no??? Even if you're a doctor and you're healthy you don't have a minute of experience of their pain. Maybe they want the pain to just end.

[@hoseokismyhope3351]

very difficult situation. I understand both Halstead and Manning in this case.

[@spudd5832]

Well she did say she didn’t want to die in hospital....

[@kennethhanna5376]

this happened in real life cause i want to tell a friend about here

[@officer_henry9118]

Dad: has no ideas what happened doctor halstead breaks law kid: is mommy ok?

[@natalia_973]

4:59 you can see the girls microphone thing

[@twitchy9583]

Natalia _9 they don’t use microphones like that in tv shows they use a big boom mic

[@carlyxo2583]

You could see the little girls microphone

[@user-jp3nf9sr2w]

My mom had cancer when I was 6 she survived I was so grateful

[@theannoyingcritic9460]

Will: Shes gonna thank me! Natalie with Mrs Goodwin: FBI OPEN UP

[@jenmonster]

It might seem ironic but DNRs are not simply about choosing whether or not to prolong life, but they're also about dying with dignity! Resuscitation is actually quite a violent and potentially traumatic experience for both the patient and their families with all the staff rushing into the room, the chest compressions, tubing, etc. Many resuscitation attempts are also unsuccessful, especially if the patient is very sick. Imagine if the family's last memory of a loved one is an aggressive and invasive one ... it may be worth it in a young healthy person but in cases like this I believe dying peacefully in the presence of loved ones would have been one of the factors the patient considered before deciding for DNR.

[@Brynwyn123]

Even if you do 'save' them it's very likely they'll either have a tonne of complications from broken ribs or theyll be brain damaged/dead.

[@ZelEniqGamer]

As House once put it: "There is no dignity in death."

[@sophieangel6676]

I know this is a show but doctors pushing there own opinions instead the wishes of the patient is wrong. If a patient doesn’t want to be resuscitated or wants any form of treatment a medical professional should respect that.

[@itsmehkaykay5225]

Is mommy ok Yea she's fine *sees mum lying unconscious in a hospital bed*

[@Gabriel-qu5fb]

from a proffesional stand point what he did is actually very wrong he was drawn by his emotions which is wrong. by law too what he did was illegal and coukd get him to serious trouble but medically if there is a chance you should try and fight for it and never give up

[@pancon9947]

that kid kind of looks like summer fontana

[@trevorcook8374]

I just noticed.. lol @ the defibrillator placement??!! One near her heart and the other basically on her pelvis??

[@warh1story563]

That girl tested my patience 4:21 Dad: it’s ok, she’s in a better place Me: Jesus Christ! 😂😂

[@sydneybrouillard-coyle]

You do not EVER do this. Halstead violated this patient's consent and choice of life and basically decided that he was God, and he could decide when she lived or died. If that wasn't bad enough, he re-traumatized the husband by asking him (while his child is screaming) whether or not he wants his wife to be alive as she is dying! Halstead claims to want to save lives, but completely ignored the patient's dignity, freedom of choice, and consent. He also completely disregarded the fact that his entire team, including a fellow doctor, were telling him "NO". Halstead deserved to be suspended at the very least, if not have his license pulled. This was about HIS agenda and HIS will, not the patient's. Despicable.

[@po-tat-oesaredabest2878]

Dr.Halstead is so CUTE

[@tomasz123tt]

Well he's taken, dumbass

[@NedBoggis]

*doctors: give me his that and the other STAT. *me: I’m sorry I do not understand

[@beccablueeyes99]

What episode was this please? Thanks

[@hollyp6154]

Season 1 ep 9

[@Leah-mu5ff]

Is that hannah bakers mom omg WTF HER NAME IS MRS BAKER IN THIS OMG

[@ashliekennedy2764]

Leah 1888 that’s not Kate Walsh. Not even close

[@ridingwithamber2904]

I love it when dr. Maning is soooo kind to kids tbh i wish she was my sis or something i love her 🥰🥰❤️😌😘😻💖💗💯%

[@FahimaAhmed-r4l]

fr

[@alinashahzad7439]

what episode and season ?

[@Cassmari1986]

when my granddad got sick due to old age and a stroke and was in the hospital, my mom's brothers signed a DNR. My mom's sisters were in denial and actually fought everyone including my mom. Till today the argument is on going, my mom and her brother's made the right decision as granddad was already bedridden and wasting away.

[@jodiandbecky4372]

4:58 the mic pack

[@AzulToad]

Or it could’ve been another device for the show.

[@JCR29]

I love this episode. Do you have the rest of it? When she wake up??

[@officialgamer5703]

lol

[@brendonmetten3150]

She dies later on in the episode...

[@Amand186]

@@brendonmetten3150 how do you know where can i find the full episode?

[@cvrlejo2296]

Dr.Maning:" What have you don?!" Dr.Halsted:"I saved a life"

[@daniellouis1541]

why not tell her to live so she can save other ppl through drug trials ..

[@ludmilacervena1647]

She can only make that decision herself. They shouldn't force her to suffer longer even if it were to save hundreds of lives. It's an entirely her decision to make.

[@sandrahazeltine8720]

This video is mislabeled. It should say “breaks the law to prolong a miserable life” and not “to save a life”. And that was not his decision to make either. The patient had already made her decision very clear.

[@yasolivia8177]

It really pissed me off that he did that

[@jbfishing9537]

Is jay halstead's brother DR halstead???

[@just-a-subscriber]

yep!

[@ebonywilson6195]

Sometimes you dont know what the worlds gonna throw at you . You just have to be prepared to go through what the world has to give you

[@lilylovesanime17]

It's so funny because when it was the child m0lester video everyone was bashing the nurses saying doctors can't play God and the child m0lester was still human and deserved medical care, yet here where a doctor is playing for and ignoring a patient's legal dnr everyone is praising him for it?

[@kaoutherchouchene5638]

I want to say something when I was watching this and seeing Dr Manning screaming and saying that was illegal I remembered that time when Maggie said the duty of a doctor is to save lives not to kill your patient

[@jordansgachalife8470]

I swear to God if that little girl says "MoMmY!! D; I will flip over my desk and rip my chair because it so annoying!!!

[@chuck0y]

Law or Life? Choose.

[@starrblue8791]

In this case law. If the patient didn't have the capability of sound mind to say yes or no, then the doctors are fully in the right to try and save her life, but in this case a patient of sound mind has made her decision and withdrawn consent to be resuscitated. Life is incredibly important, there's no doubt, but when someone is mentally fit to decide that if their body degrades enough that they don't want to be revived, you would be bringing them back into a life they don't want against their wishes.

[@nandi171]

Charles Cadiente Law

[@chuck0y]

Starr Blue a good reply actually. Like!

[@florence4372]

Law

[@_edith3036]

I think life just because even though the patient didn't want it, she might still live to a reasonable age and her child will grow up with a mother.

[@samanthamayger4931]

The husband was freakishly tall compared to their child

[@DashDirect]

Law first instead of lives? Nice one

[@rose_linniw]

But she didn't want to suffer anymore

[@SakuraBlossoms151]

I thought u couldnt defib a patient if they have upper clothing on? 🤨

[@mylifeasbeth1968]

I've heard that too

[@SakuraBlossoms151]

my life as beth exactly 😂

[@ashtonvickers928]

Who would seriously think it’s better to leave your daughter motherless?!

[@fluffyavocado8154]

I mean it’s great but the girl was a little bit annoying

[@ratty_sketcher1269]

No its not

[@gemtuckey447]

People say he broke the law,he did.He had to save her for her daughter,her husband and her family.He explains earlier that his mother had cancer and had died so what was he supposed to do?Sit there and watch her daughter cry when she died?Please answer me that one

[@czechowa]

yes, there is sometimes a point where a person doesn't want to be saved and as a doctor, he should respect that. He just prolonged their suffering, good job on that one.

[@rachelcookie321]

Yes. She’s gonna likely die soon anyway. Another 2 months of her in constant pain is not gonna be worth it. She will be depressed and in pain and her daughter will just feel bad for her mum and want her to die so her suffering can end. It’s her choice and she wouldn’t of made it lightly so she should be allowed to die.

[@kendra5287]

I don't know how anyone can defend this. She made her wishes clear. A DNR isn't about "giving up". If anything, it's about being able to die with dignity and on your own terms. Him trying to pressure the husband while his child is screaming just makes it so much worse. I know it's a tv show, but things like this just really tick me off.

[@elley3438]

*_THE DAD IS TALL DANG_*

[@sophieodonoghue8262]

Why was the nurse stopping him from saving her life? I kinda wanted to go and say to her shut your mouth and just go and you’ll see how much the women thanks him, it’s almost like she wanted her to die

[@oliviathomas4504]

Why did I read this as “Doctor Halstead breaks the neck to save a child?” Like what?

[@Hijabi_eats]

Every doctor :lift on me 123 *Patient hits bed* Bed: thumpppppppppp Nurse: grunt Patient: groans

[@milaaldama1199]

Anyone else on a Chicago med binge? No just me? Okay 👌

[@NorthStar8211]

I spent several hours binge-watching these clips today.

[@emmaryan2179]

0:30 I feel bad but that was funny