DR ISHTIAQ AHMED AT THE GOKHALE INSTITUE OF POLITICS AND ECONOMIC, PUNE

#indiapakistanborder
#pakistanpolitics
#indianfilms
#filmmusic
#Subcontinentalissues
#punjab
#partition
#currentaffairs
#lahore
#Pakistan
#Pakistanpolitics
Prof. Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed was invited by the Gokhale Institute of Politics and Economics, Pune, to speak on: INDIA - PAKISTAN PEACE IN OUR LIFE TIME?

[@SirKasim666]

Dr Ishtiaq Ahmed Sir 🙏

[@ShahbazKhan-ni3ol]

Dr Ishtiaq you have been the only person who reviewed our history and your analysis is of great value when we think about our faults and reforms rectify for our future. I wish you long life and hope that we learn from your experience

[@AmitKumar-ll4qe]

A lot of love from my heart dr. ishtiyaq Ahmed sir for your great work in the field of history and contribution to spread love between India and Pakistan 🌺

[@embitplus8397]

Love

[@AmitSingh-dx8sl]

Thank u sir for share ur knowledge with us about india and pakistan

[@sudarshan3994]

Dr Ahmed has beautifuly spoke about indo_ Pak relations with his rich heritage and knowledge on the subject. His speech at the Gokhle institute of pune University is greatly acknowledged by educated despora of Indian society. Let people of Pakistan also appreciate his comand on the subject. Great regards for Dr Ahmed from my side and people of India I am born Pakistan at Gujranwala in 1940 and also love Pakistan as my home.land on basis of my birth right.

[@rpsingh7697]

Very much like your Comment.

[@azeem_lahori-punjabi]

😍

[@ravindergrewal8093]

Sir , great respect for you for trying to bring people of India and Pakistan closer and doing wonderful research work on partition history

[@rpsingh7697]

Ultimately l (we) Appreciate your holy and Pawerful speech. Nature Bless you Dr. Ishtyaq

[@rakeshjain2199]

Thanks Dr Ahmed for sharing your talk in Pune. It is full of common sense and hope that Pakistani Hukumran can enlighten themselves

[@Chetan1632]

Ishitiaq sir is the diamond in the desert of Pakistan... absolute love from INDIA

[@hemendrapowale3608]

Ishtiyaq Ahmed Sir You are the BEST... Great work ! Keep it up..

[@girdharrathi6728]

A beautiful, penetrating, frank, and friendly discourse. By Prof Ishtiaq Ahmed.

[@ShahbazKhan-ni3ol]

Dr Ishtiaq has been able to see the two people and advised peace ☮️ and friendship between divided India 🇮🇳 and Pakistan 🇵🇰

[@Albarizon1]

Thankyou for sharing your knowledge sir

[@id-Amanguptapg]

Ocean of knowledge

[@prathamgambhir661]

Sir i want my copy of your book to be signed but i was not in Delhi when you were there. Hope you Will soon visit again and i will get my book duly signed. Lots of love and respect.

[@SurajKumar-io5xz]

Sir aap ne late kyu upload kya but koi nai it's so nice 😊😊😊😊😊

[@VYDEO]

Suddenly after the Q & A started voice is not good 😢

[@AnupKumar-pz7ce]

Love you sir

[@avadheshsharma1173]

Prof. Ahmed, truly a great educational speech! Please correct the title of this post. It is Gokhale Institute of Peace and Economics not Economic as the title of this video implies. Best regards

[@Billumian47]

It is of Politics and Economics.

[@avadheshsharma1173]

@@Billumian47 Sir, there is a typographical error in the title of this video clip. Please correct it by insetingan "s" after "Economic"".

[@rpsingh7697]

Ji Dr. ISHTYAQ Saheb, mazrat, muafee chahoonga jaisey aaj ke halaat hain shayd is'sey badtar hon ya na hon, Mr. Jinna ko qsoorwaar thehrana srasar be jaa hoga. Main smjhta hooN hooN ke na to Gandhi jimmedaar the,/hain aur na hi Mr. Nehru ya Mr Jinna. Ye saari shuruaat Sawerker (iey) hindutvi tatvon ki rahee hogi, jo aaj bhi ( after Partition) apni harktoN se baaz nhien aa rahey,jaari hai. Paley bhi musalmaanoN ko chidatey the,aur aaj tak jaari hai, balkey ab lpetey me Sikkh aur Cristian bhi aa gaey hain. YahaN tak secular Hindu bhi. So Modi ism me religious Sula sfaie ya achhey rishtey qaim hona/ban'na na mumkin sa hi hai. Vaisey aapki unthak jaddojehad ki ham Qadr kartey hain . Thanks.

[@raveebn]

Dr. Saab, what is missing in understanding is, whether the fear of some one attack me is a circumstantial or pre determined ? i say pre determined ? i say same phylosophy or ideology that attacked and destroyed India by invaders since 1000 years. Second comment is you mentioned by end of Moguls rule only 20% of Indians converted, so not a big deal, thats is not small number but my point is, Invaders already destroyed enough Hindu and Budhist cultural icons which contributed to Indian civilization since 2000+ years, like 5-6 famous Universities, 6000 temple complexes(including most holy places Ayodya/Kashi/Mathura, Somanath), "renaming" historic places. What you are not getting is, say you have beautiful home in Stockhome, some one accidentally drive car and damages your house and house got partially destroyed. As a human you may pardon him with little fine or money settlement. You mayn't hate him. But if a white guy comes and damages your house with intention you are "Muslm", and destroy your holiest place where you do Namz because same reason. Do you settle with little money or have some self respect ? which one ? I have no issue with peace deal and i don't support anyone hate, but if you don't change the basic idealogy that pakistan operate which is based on hate you are putting other party in danger. Hope you think logically rather emotionally. So please don't worry or stop advicing about India/RSS all stern believer of Hinduism, which "thrives where every one is happy". Please take care of Pakistan or any other Islmk states, be lead the effort to make Pakistan "Secular", "Nation over Religion" friendship between India and pakistan will be 'no brainer' ! I heard last week few Hindu girls were abducted, since you are social scientist please write a book on what sychology makes one human forcesfully convert or abduct weaker person, here the action is pro-active again. If this is based on an ideology how shamefull this ideology for humanity, as a human rights activist why you don't work on changing it first rather advising Indians ? also please stop saying bad people in India as well as in Pakistan, may be true but bad people don't roam around freely in India. As JAkthar says terrorists roaming freely in Pakistan. When i anlyse in details what i found is, Pakistani people are innocent with respect to the religion they follow, so they do what is appropriate according to religion. This is the same reason once Musharaf said BLaden is our hero. But thats is not par with modern world humanity. My point here is if you make this ideology de-facto standard where people follow it never think that non Muslms are humans. This is the real real problem, This same ideology scares RSS/peaceful Hindus, please work on introducing these people to modern civilazation. Thats the great help to humanity. My point is please address the main problem first rather just selling your books. I still appriciate your understanding towards humanity and honest effort to achieve it. As a human many hatredness is reaction of certen actions. listed more of them. 1. Say we hear muslm prayer 5 times a day, what it says loud and clear is, "our god is only the god" how this is secular ? Hinduism teaches world is our family. 2. Who devided nation based on religion ? how muslm leage is secular as Congress RaGadhi says? 3. Just look at Kashi, which is Mecca like holy place for Hindus, where we can see Masque is built on a old temple, even kid can tell there was a temple, but hindus have to prove it. 4. See Minorities/Hindus are decimated in Pakistan, no democracy cares that why ? 5. India is the only contry where Minorities have more rights than majority. Please show me one another nation like this. 6. India is only contry since 1000 years minorities ruled ! please mention another contry . 7. Pakistan and even whole world which follows this idealogy believes Kashmir should belong to pakistan even after they know kashmir was hindu spirutual place, Hindus were native, 14th century hindus were 100% there and now they are decimated by Ismst ideolgy and reduced hindus/budhists to 2%. Lecturing is easy but facts doesn't lie, history doesn't lie. "If you don't learn from history you will be history". As a human we should have self respect atleast. Basic flaw with this ideology which is not acceptable to humanity is try to overpower by forcebly convert/kill strategy. See shankaracharya revived Hinduism without lifting a stick, all by overpowering oppenent by knowledge, win win for every one. This is the knowledge/Vedic wisdom pursuite that kept Indians iformation/knoledge flow throgh their genes for generations on the otherhand how the ideology kept Paks terrorism flow throgh their genes for generations. Pakistan did so much crime like Bangla genocide, Kashmir genocide, Minorities genocide so many but was funded and protected by USA and China. Now the life support is removed so went bankrupt so eager to make peace with India. Things to be noticed is if they economically well to do again they start the criminal activities. So question for Dr. saab is how he make sure it doesn't happen again, and what is changed in terms of idealogy ? Please don't take my question as scolding or insult to anyone, but if you can put your honest comments i will be greatful. I am also learning about social fabricks.

[@Billumian47]

Stop beating your chest and look at the facts. Explain to the Dalits that they were not oppressed for thousands of years and they were being treated they way they deserve. Honestly, I am fed of listening to one sided stories.

[@bhagwanchaudhary3190]

Dr Indian Dalit are very much good positions now, and they are regarded as well, now similar question can I ask you tell us about the conditions of Ahamdi and Shriya’s in Pakistan you talk about our interference in balochistan can you please give us a proof( pls don’t refer Jadhav as the matter is under court and not proved that he is spy) .we find from our history that Pakistan always deceived us..Corning together seems not possible because lot of differences already created between India and Pakistan,,

[@bhagwanchaudhary3190]

@@Billumian47 Such kind of answers not expect from you dr Ahmad, this is your actual Color you wants to play a Dalit card in India- don’t forget our President is also coming from Dalit community, we will not allow any outsider to talk in our internal matters

[@Desiboy646]

Suna tha ki Kasab ko fansi se bachne ke liye kuch indian rastrapati ko latter likhe the Aaj un logo ko dek bhi liya

[@disruptiantechnologies1634]

Dear Sir , add to the best of the fans you have on KZbin, I have been watching most of your podcast, I missed your lectures in Chandigarh and in Delhi by whisker. let me start with a disclaimer that I believe you are a great human being and the questions I raise have nothing to do with your individual morality, integrity and ingenuity of the cause. Also, I am not a right winger or a leftist. I would prefer to be named as centrist who looks at facts with rationality before coming to any conclusion. my questions are, while you or Dr. Khan probably represent the sophisticated side of the religion you profess, I have observed a propensity to logical fallacy of your comparing sanatani way of life with other religions ,particularly islam,mostly salafi and other imported ones, as equally responsible for all good or wrong things happening in the subcontinent. this is dangerous narrative at the outset. The societal and constitutional secularism is framed in such a way, that three generations of Hindus are rootless, powerless and westernized. if pseudo seculars plead western secularism form another 50 years and maintain the current framework for india, the main dish in the salad bowl will be a melting pot where you loose everything that is from the land.

[@c.s.nmurthy2509]

Sir It is not India which has stopped trade ties with. Now they are saying to resume trade ties India should restore Article 370 which is dream for Pakistan. The only people who are suffering are People of Pakistan with shortages and sky high prices. Sir, what is your opinion on this. With respects Murthy

[@ShahbazKhan-ni3ol]

People are not divided they’re are separated by selfish politicians on both sides They want to visit their places of Birth

[@narayansingh-ke5pv]

What made you think that India & Pakistan should come closer ?

[@rahulbhau6010]

Sir pls visit RAIGAD FORD MY & ALL INDIANS GOD CHATRAPATI SHIVAJI MAHARAJ 🚩❤️❤️🙏🙏

[@navneet8269]

Very poor video sound quality

[@rahulbhau6010]

Jai jai Maharashatra maza Garja maharashtra maza Medha, vardha, krushna, koyna bhadra godavri Akpanache bharti pani matichya ghagri Bhimtadichya tattanna ya yamuneche pani paja Bhiti na amha tuzi muli hi gadgadnarya nbha Asmanachya sultanila jawab Deti jivha Sahyadricha sinh garjto Shivshambhu la jaan Daridaritun naad gunjala Maharashtra maza Kalya chativr korli abhimanachi leni Poladi mangte khelti khel jivgheni Daridryachya unhad shijla Nidhlachya ghamat bhijla Desh n urva sathi zijla Delly che hi takht rakhito maharashtra maza जय भवानी जय शिवराय 🙏🙏

[@sadenb]

I understand that peace is important. However, without Pakistani stopping all forms of terrorism and getting their hatred of Hindus removed from their syllabi , this cannot happen.

[@VYDEO]

Similar is the case with Helmet 🪖 law in India which is unlikely to go away like blasphemy law in Pakistan 😂

[@navneet8269]

Aapki ghatiya sound quality ne pure conservation Ka satyanash kar Diya

[@AnupKumar-pz7ce]

Pl visit my place I m huge fan to u

[@ShahbazKhan-ni3ol]

We are waisting our time to discuss friendship but fight out and self destruction is the culmination of talks

[@KuldeepArya-te6sx]

Islm religion of peace. No democracy secularism in any islami nation. 21 century me duniya ko Isis Taliban jese Mohd hizbulah alkayda bokohram jese group diye Jo lakho ko mar diye Iraq Syria yamam Lebnan libiya Sudan afgnistan me Islamic state kaafir zehad khalifa rule Shia Sunni wahabi zehad k nam.per. Khud Kisi ko citizenship equal right nhi dete visa khtm hote hi bhaga dete koi sadi kre dete jbki khud ye musalman non Muslim countries Me maze se rahte minority bolke blackmail krte UK ,USA ,Canada ,Australia France me Jake citizenship Lete masjid BNA Lete sadi krte democracy secularism ki bate krne lgte real face nd double standard of islm

[@hotmail28]

It is very delightful to listen to sir Ishtiaq Ahmed a very honorable thinker and a very well researched person on India and Pakistan issue and we hope that his efforts bring two brother countries together and we live happily ever after.❤

[@premshukla7262]

Don't give them another chance, they will backstab us.

[@सत्यवादी-ख3प]

वो सब ठीक लेकिन आप इतने थके हुये लग रहे हो सर

[@Desiboy646]

Edhar to indian terrerism ka support kar rahe hai to unko kon bachha sakta hai

[@jayakumarpaliyath]

Dr. Is mixing Mohd. Bin Kasim, Jasiah etc on one side and scientific political science on other side. Please stick on one side. Either theological or scientific

[@onestar627]

Hi sir