The Evidence AGAINST Aliens! Joe Rogan & Brian Keating

[@DrBrianKeating]

Are we being visited by Non Human Intelligence (NHI)? 👽

[@ScrewdriverTUNING]

😂🤣 that’s a weird question based off this video. 🧐

[@gastronic]

I got a better idea brother Brian. Tell us about all the physics that you know about Nikola Tesla. 😁 You'll have millions of viewers in 48 hours, guaranteed ! You can do 4 shows of one hour, his history, theory and technology/experiments in reality, inventions, famous mysterious memes (everything is frequency),(hidden?) patents, and more. There's so much misinformation about this man, you need to help us out, brother, please ! 🙏 (And yes, we are being visited by alien civilizations, technically varying from 10.000 years to 100.000.000 years ahead of us. With inherent varying ways of manifesting themselves and levels of technological advancement. This is why new kids on the block small-brain-humans haven't detected them. Well, the part that was looking in the wrong way hasn't) 🪐

[@0neIntangible]

Yeah, they pop by every once in a while to grab snacks for the big game... We are the galaxy's convenience store... "Thank you... come again" ... Apu.

[@carlosortiz-sn2yd]

The category of UFO has been expanding to be as broad as UAP, not limited to traditional objects, therefore the category of aliens should expand as to include NHI entities such as spirits/interdimensional/transdimensional beings, not just extraterrestrials. If you reduce the scope the answer gets easier to be a dismissive “no.” But you can’t prove that there is no evidence, you can only disprove that certain evidence is false.

[@gaylenwoof]

Although we can't draw scientific conclusions from the testimonies under oath about a cover-up of UAP data (including actual craft, bodies, etc.), we would be foolish - downright irrational - to ignore the testimonies that have already happened (and more will be happening soon) in front of Congress. What are the probabilities that 40+ highly credible witnesses - including some high-level whistleblowers - would put their careers, reputations, and perhaps even their lives at risk by testifying about this stuff under oath if they didn't believe what they are saying? If he believes that he is telling the truth, Grush, for example, must have simply misunderstood the 40+ people who explained in great detail that they have been involved in reverse-engineering non-human craft, etc. Given what we have at the moment, we can't conclude anything with high confidence, but we can rationally say that the probabilities of a UAP coverup are fairly high. Science needs data, but significant data may be missing due to illegal/unconstitutional activity. Rationally, we are well-advised to bet on the whistleblowers, even if, due to missing data, known science can't guide us in this particular realm, at the moment.

[@Stucknthe80z]

The same egg heads were saying the 70s and 80s that it was unlikely that other stars had planets. The only thing they usually get right is being wrong

[@ZippyLeroux]

Now all you need, is to try to understand why that's a really really good thing...

[@dariuslegacy3406]

I'd like a citation please..

[@cogitoergocogito5032]

Huh ? Your argument doesn't make any sense, first you think about two identical planets, and suddenly you compare it with Earth and Mars (which has lost most of its atmosphere very long ago) and you use that as evidence against alien life? Wutttt

[@FLINTMICHIGANMEGABOWL]

“Wutt?”. Indeed.

[@thealexanderbond]

He didn't actually finish that point, Joe interrupted and then they moved on to something else. But yeah, it was totally pointless to cut this into a clip, it's like he just randomly picked 7 minutes from the interview.

[@wonmoreminute]

I didn’t hear the entire podcast, but where I thought the conversation was going, was to say, that even if life existed on Mars, a relatively similar planet with similar conditions, the chances that it evolved and existed during the same time period are unlikely. The chances that it became an advanced technological species is even more unlikely. Mars is one small piece of evidence that supports that point. But I agree, the clip doesn’t support the title.

[@gluonone]

I believe his point was going to be that Mars and earth, if observed from far away would appear to have identical characteristics. And if you knew one planet had life, you might assume the other one would have life as well. But we know that’s not the case With our solar system such as earth and mars.

[@cogitoergocogito5032]

that still doesn't make sense or makes a point, if there was life on one such planet then we already have the conclusion. Obviously at this time we can't conclude there is life on Earth-similar planets, since our observational data is extremely limited. So I don't know what he thinks is evidence against alien life but this certainly is not it. It seems to me he is in some sort of denial of the possibility there might be alien life out there. How arrogant is this title by the way? To even assume there is no other intelligent alien life @@gluonone

[@victorgarcia4399]

The analogy of Mars and earth is actually disimilar since the spectrum of requirements for life is needed and not being considered here. Also we havent dug deep enough into areas of Mars that had water and see if there is eomthing deeper, like caves.

[@timsullivan4566]

"The evidence against aliens"? I didn't even know they'd been indicted!

[@elenakehoe2356]

😊mmm....0.u.u0uuu.. u. 0uj u uuuuj uu0ju0 uu u 😊u uu 😊u 6 6 u😊6

[@elenakehoe2356]

😊mmm....0.u.u0uuu.. u. 0uj u uuuuj uu0ju0 uu u 😊u uu 😊u 6 6 u😊6

[@elenakehoe2356]

😊mmm....0.u.u0uuu.. u. 0uj u uuuuj uu0ju0 uu u 😊u uu 😊u 6 6 u😊6

[@MrLunithy]

lol🤗

[@jackmyers5540]

good one

[@redred2772]

At this point an Alien visit would only bring embarrassment.

[@Cyborous]

0:46 three words, “Roswell crash happened.” This is a pointless conversation. I’m sorry. When there’s already been downed, extraterrestrial vehicles.

[@ScrewdriverTUNING]

🤯

[@Cyborous]

@@ScrewdriverTUNING yeah it just blows my mind that scientists and people are still so far behind on it when all they have to do Is look at all the witness testimony, and look at what Jesse Marcell Senior had to say about it in his latter years of his life. That what he actually recovered was nothing like the weather balloon material he propped up with when he was younger. It’s like it’s quite obvious that that was a cover-up. To people that actually done the research and digging. it’s quite obvious they recovered something. And on top of that you have Philip Jay Corso’s lengthy testimony.

[@afedden]

Three words. 'It wasn't aliens'.

[@Cyborous]

But I just get tired of listening to scientists that have done no research or digging and then come to conclusion that there’s no evidence of ETs here. And it’s like they’re missing the boat.

[@Cyborous]

@@afedden two words you’re wrong.

[@droyal18able]

Rip little chopper.

[@Texasplit]

I came to say the same shit

[@Berindei_Stefan]

the more i hear people talk about aliens or how old the universe is and all that , the more i realize that what is really happening its just covered as much and by any means possible...

[@docmartin6348]

I just watched this episode the other day. I think a lot of people believe there must be life out there in the cosmos. It’s just a part of culture now. But if we are the only ones occupying the entire universe, that changes everything. The idea that we’re alone in carrying the torch of consciousness is beyond profound. “Aliens” give us an excuse not to hold ourselves to a higher standard and accept the adolescence of humanity. Potential life elsewhere severely attenuates an overwhelming sense of responsibility to take care of ourselves so that we may carry on to the future and perhaps understand this place. Im not a religious person, but if we’re alone, we have a mandate from God to figure out the Universe by ourselves. We cannot afford to fuck up this unbelievably rare (

[@philipbrown8014]

I have seen an alien space ship. So I definitely believe.

[@christophermullins7163]

You aren't alone. Some of these mainstream scientists live in a sea of convolution making it impossible for them to simply step back and think clearly. What makes it so confusing is the variety of aliens or UFOs. Biological, artificial, biological w/ interdenominational tech, artificial w/ interdimensional tech, interdimensional beings and other varieties.. ppl think that if they don't see a real grey alien in flesh then it is all a hoax lmao it is tough to get a sheep to wake up. 🤷

[@ET3Roberts]

No you didn't.

[@heynowpauly]

And....... no point was made.

[@theproctors3813]

A tiny “big moon” sized planet with a mass 15% that of the earth that is 45% further from the sun is the Earth’s doppelgänger? That makes zero sense. The Earth and Mars are wildly different.

[@VintagePaper]

Sometimes it is okay to acknowlege we need more and better data.

[@PedroTawa]

We are the aliens lol

[@morphixnm]

Dr. Keating has this backwards because equations and models are not evidence against anything. Evidence is what we refer to for the support of equations and models. It STARTS with evidence. To believe that existing ideas are a way to say what can and cannot exist is scientism.

[@morphixnm]

And on top of my previous comment, scientists don't actually know how life begins, which makes the Drake equation and all these other statistical analyses useless. Imagine saying you don't know how stars form and then claiming to have a solid cosmology? Oops, this error has happened as well:)

[@tomjensen618]

Imagine you had met an alien. Some "expert" calculate that it's unlikely they exist. Will you be convinced? Yes, I have. These 2 guys however?? Lol.

[@christophermullins7163]

What? Lol

[@ScrewdriverTUNING]

😂😅

[@kylorobb]

Um, Excuse me! That's like totally racist. We prefer the term "undocumented life form"

[@couldbedreaming6330]

You have what?

[@christophermullins7163]

@@couldbedreaming6330 schizophrenia

[@qigong1001]

Hmmm...not a convincing argument at all.

[@Karma-fp7ho]

The O’Hare incident is interesting

[@lc2c177]

I emailed u and followed the process but never got any reply re the meteorite you’re saying you’ll send to students. In any case, your bias is limiting the questions you’re asking. So you’ll just have to wait for the proof whilst others do the breakthroughs. You’ll be in the passenger seat along with Tyson

[@steverafferty4114]

Venus is a more relevant argument

[@ponypruhest]

Regarding the argument that we have only explored a tiny fraction of Mars. Life is ALL over planet Earth, if there are life on Mars, why wouldn’t it be all over Mars? And if it was all over Mars, we would have detected it despite us only looking at a tiny fraction of Mars. Even deep deep in deserts on planet earth there is life, so surely life on Mars would still spread all over Mars. Thus, there is no life but on planet Earth.

[@anarchorepublican5954]

Alien Life is Rare or non-existent...because Spontaneous Generation (abiogenesis) doesn't happen...

[@WayneCaissie]

Cool thought experiment, but I have to say that maybe it's because I'm an ignorant pleb... But I think that life is everywhere out there. Maybe not intelligent life, but life in whatever form is gotta be out there.

[@NOYFB982]

So two comments. 1) A better example than mars for now other life is the earth itself. We have never detected another tree of life, and contrary to Joe’s point, we have looked a lot and continue to look) for different organisms on earth. They are ALWAYS from the same lineage. New life happened only once in a place we know is perfect. As an aside, if we look at things like cell nuclei, chloroplast, mitochondria, etc., that a probably necessary for complex, let alone intelligent, life, we can see if there were more than one independent evolutionary events. 2. This aside is something that I thought you had mentioned before. The Drake equation is focused on astronomy, with life arising as a single term. However, if that term is dissected into constituents, such as mitochondria, then one can make estimates for those, and if there are enough constituents, even modestly low probabilities get to the point where other intelligent life is almost impossible probabilistically.

[@brianmclay6070]

The probability of something existing once in the universe would be unimaginably low. Life is a product of Chemistry and the laws of physics so considering everything else in the universe isn't unique how can we assume life is

[@absolutelyreel8795]

We have a sample size of one. Everything for and against is speculation. For something to be 1:100,000,000,000² (possibly more as galaxy estimates range in upwards of 2 trillion) is highly unprobablistic imo, but again, it is all speculation.

[@theklaus7436]

No conspiracy theories from Joe ! Strange

[@patrickmiller878]

:( makes me less excited about science to hear you boring it up. I think scientists are scared and anxious by something so far beyond their understanding.

[@MrJPI]

Hah, a real astrononer said Mars is a little bit bigger than the Moon !!?? Mars has a diameter almost exactly twice that of the Moon. So Mars has a surface aria 4 times and volume almost 8 bigger than the Moon.

[@reaper7264]

Mars is just a little smaller than half the size of Earth

[@jackmyers5540]

I cant prove GRAVITY but i know its there ....

[@reaper7264]

You can actually prove it.

[@pyrodiscoflash6115]

I love how Life on Earth has Started without Humans input or Expert opinions to Regulate it all away, but we are Trying to Control it now because we would have done it Correctly had we been around to advise on the Start of Life and invested more Money of Course

[@TheAloha29]

Darn. Had a lot higher hopes for this guy and his channels. ✌️

[@billgully3681]

Mars? It almost seemed to be a trick question asked of Joe. I swore I heard same conditions. It was made to sound that at the same time conditions were almost identical. Mars doesn't have the same atmosphere or quantity of water. Maybe it used to, but no longer. If the current conditions were included in the question the probability of life as being high would never have been Joe's answer. Sure, there was a point to be made about the fragility of life here, but this was just odd.

[@anthonyhunt9915]

You begin to describe a 'solar system for the environment' yet you fail to bring up all of the actual details and requirements for such an environment. Everytime physicists talk about the goldylox zone, they always fail to mention: planet rotation, number of moons, temperature of the core of the planet, speed of the planets orbit around it's star, shape of the orbit around it's star etc, each detail should be discussed due to the fact that there is life on earth currently that we have discovered can survive without some of these earthly movements. Everytime yall talk about the goldylox zone physicists only say 'distance from it's center star' as though that somehow would make a difference? As for proof of evidence, Europa, moon of jupiter, is proof that you dont need to be too far away from the sun to have a molten core. Yet yall brush Europa's existence off like it's nothing, id dare ask, what if there are moons to planets in other solar systems? You talk about mars in it's current state, but not the historical theories surrounding how it died out as a planet? why not?

[@johndwyer3357]

In the beginning God created the heavens AND the earth. The earth stands alone Joe... This includes especially life.

[@HUSTLE_MONEY]

Ok @Dr Brian Keating, you are a complete joy to watch and listen to. At the lowest level of your foundational footings, you are a "good" man. We all suffer from the human condition but your goal is to be better, to be fair; to be open minded. Your priorities are you family, are the relationships you have built. You've payed your dues, gained your tenure and now lead the search for B-mode polarization at Simons Observatory in a desert in Chile!! You're a young man and are going down in history as one of the greats in the most interesting and important fields of all humanity. Your podcast has become a joy to consume because of your subtle humor always under the surface like a quantum field waiting for excitation. That humor always popping in and out of existence like the fluctuations in the vacuum, you rush past never giving the guests a chance to catch up, the smirk fading into the next statement as if the joke hadn't been uttered. I forgot what the full purpose of my comment, something about wanting you to answer a question that Joe asked from the JRE about what God had to say about the universe, you completely controlled the narrative with narry concern to answering his question directly lol. I do get a sense that you completely love and appreciate your life. How great it must feel to be so accomplished, a mensch!

[@tybronco9563]

Would you rather have the eyes of Jesus or look Jesus in the eyes?

[@andrewmoonbeam321]

Curse of the Werewhale

[@christowell949]

How the hell do they know that’s from mars

[@TheOddsEdge]

Wft was the point in this clip? Here is a start to a point 😂

[@stephendedalus191]

So, in summary, Mars. So, there is no life anywhere else in the universe. Obviously. So, Is your mind blown, or what?

[@DarkskiesSiren]

Amazing stuff overall

[@LeadPhalanx-zv6wx]

People seem to love the topic I guess it might seem entertaining and mysterious..

[@bella0167]

👁👁👽

[@Bludger007]

Fallacious arguments from Keating.

[@arin6907]

Bros milking the Joe Rogan podcast

[@onlyonewhyphy]

He just made a pretty good argument for God.

[@dariuslegacy3406]

About as good an argument for Universe farting unicorns

[@onlyonewhyphy]

@@dariuslegacy3406 I see you watched a different thing to me. Dr Keating just made an argument for life nowhere but earth. He didn't specify why. I suggested one "why" (which I don't believe in) that's commonly used to fit the bill and I, as an atheist, can't imagine a good rational reason why Earth would be utterly alone in its formation of life. But please, if you have another train of logic, rather than the non-reply you gave, I'd love to hear it. Not everyone online needs to be regarded with distain, because they don't think exactly like you.

[@ll0013ll]

💩

[@jackmyers5540]

He wont be convinced until hes probed ...

[@bella0167]

In the bum.

[@JAYMOAP]

Very nice

[@Thedudeabides803]

Damn you Joe. How dare you veer off Brian’s cool whale information. How dare you sir. Brian’s the man, let him speak.

[@kevinweeks-b1s]

If universe is infinite then so are galaxies if only 1 in 20 trillion galaxies had 1 planet that would have life it would be abundant but more than likely every galaxy has at least 1 planet the odds are just to great

[@ScrewdriverTUNING]

That was a really bad analogy. Durring your question you ask if he see two planets next to each other that look alike what were the chances there wouldn’t be life on both. The realistic fact is if we were looking from another solar system at earth and mars we would say they look nothing alike. Trick question make this irrelevant topic for life elsewhere.

[@ZappyOh]

What is visiting us, isn't aliens. It is angles an demons. Not kidding.

[@Kerrsartisticgifts]

Whatever is going on, why do some people think that it's Angels or Demons? Why would they be flying in spaceships?

[@ZappyOh]

@@Kerrsartisticgifts To trick you into believing they are something else ... matching the current scientific understanding of everything. In reality, they are here in increasing numbers, to somehow integrate with humans, in preparation for the beast system, which is on the horizon. If you read the Bible, everything matches up. We are close to the end. But first, the anti-Christ must rule everything for a while.

[@Stucknthe80z]

Yah they need vehicles… smooth brain comment

[@ZappyOh]

@@Kerrsartisticgifts They need to trick you into believing, that they are something else. Something nicer and less scary. I mean, if everyone knew what they are, they couldn't succeed with the plan laid out in the Bible.

[@xavariusquest4603]

This argument is tragically nonsensical. There are times when it's clear Keating has been listening to himself...with the typical degree of arrogance I've come to expect for YT science creators...so gleefully and proudly that he no longer has an introspective bone in his body. The Drake equation is a terrible place to start. Hes sets up the argument through developing a purported set of important criteria...all of which are cherry picked to satisfy a solution but framed in a way for you to be surprised....that the answer is our neighbor, Mars. The problem with that is that the surface of Mars has been "dead" for millions of years. Further, the surface of Mars is bombarded by far more radiation than Earth. Lastly, Mars has no magnetosphere...the greatest protection for life on Earth. Now, it is believed that Mars was far more hospitable eons ago. The above conditions would unravel every protein strand of every organism. We have literally scratched the surface...by centimeters of digging with probes....over an entire planet. It is likely that remnants exist in Water rich environments that we know lie tens to hundreds of meters below the surface. But we cannot to that kind of excavation as of now.

[@twonicetwice]

I’m sorry, but this guy sounds like he’s on one planet only very narrowminded. So explain what uaps are And where have they come from?

[@Nicolas-xb8zv]

What a temerity!!!

[@larrocovarry9027]

Our galaxy/ solar system is 13 billion years old in the making ... therefore in the early time of our solar system, the sun was hotter and conditions were perfect for mars to support life and earth was to hot for life billions of years before then as things cooled down earth became the life zone & mars no longer could support life , if it ever did ... so why did it not have signs of greater life millions of years ago ??? Why did earth suddenly become ground zero for life ... we may never know what caused mars to lose its atmosphere and water ...

[@Naughtydoodles]

Just another bot trying to gaslight the world

[@johnbwill]

Brian Keating - proof of intelligent life. A voice of reason in a world of blathering idiots.

[@raialice5118]

He is forgotten something importend , inside his Head is working also a fully limited HUMAN brain ,but he dont want to belive this .All rhis arguements are obsoled .

[@jansmit799]

All due respect, this is nonsense

[@PickleRick_1990]

Cocaine is a hell of a drug..... "Rick James", 😅

[@leeFbeatz]

I wonder if Mars is Saturn’s Moon since the properties of Saturn overrule in high harmonic spin concentration dynamics of the light environment compositions to Mars and us within the solar system light composition arena there, Mars should be more spherical and less equator like than Jupiter

[@Bitchslapper316]

Mars is probably to massive to be a moon. It has more mass then titan and the four galilean moons combined. I'm sure it's possible to have a moon with that composition and density but we haven't seen anything like it yet. Even the smallest planet mercury which is smaller then Titan or Ganymede still has double their mass.

[@Nicolas-xb8zv]

Incredibly weak or fallacious arguments as usual…. 😂

[@dansub9795]

My gut feeling says that you are absolutely wrong on this.

[@xavariusquest4603]

This argument is tragically nonsensical. There are times when it's clear Keating has been listening to himself...with the typical degree of arrogance I've come to expect for YT science creators...so gleefully and proudly that he no longer has an introspective bone in his body. The Drake equation is a terrible place to start. Hes sets up the argument through developing a purported set of important criteria...all of which are cherry picked to satisfy a solution but framed in a way for you to be surprised....that the answer is our neighbor, Mars. The problem with that is that the surface of Mars has been "dead" for millions of years. Further, the surface of Mars is bombarded by far more radiation than Earth. Lastly, Mars has no magnetosphere...the greatest protection for life on Earth. Now, it is believed that Mars was far more hospitable eons ago. The above conditions would unravel every protein strand of every organism. We have literally scratched the surface...by centimeters of digging with probes....over an entire planet. It is likely that remnants exist in Water rich environments that we know lie tens to hundreds of meters below the surface. But we cannot to that kind of excavation as of now.

[@jackmyers5540]

yt ? how is Race relevent racist

[@xavariusquest4603]

@@jackmyers5540 wow...since I didn't mention race...what the hell are you on about? Would you like to remove your comment?