'Dropped a CLANGER' - Newcastle United must now go ALL IN to fix transfer mess

Liam, Jordan and Dom discuss Newcastle United's 1-0 opening day win against Southampton in the Premier League at St James' Park. Fabian Schar was sent off during the match as Joelinton scored the only goal of the game.
------------------------
➡️ All Geordie Journos videos are sponsored by Four Rivers Financial Planning. Providing holistic financial planning on pensions and investments. Check out www.fourriversfp.co.uk for more details, or alternatively, contact [e-mail] to speak to one of the team.
➡️ Want your company name on Geordie Journos? Contact [e-mail] for sponsorship details.
#NUFC #NewcastleUnited #PremierLeague #Football #Newcastle #NUFCfans #NUFCnews #NUFCtransfers #NUFChighlights

[@ste1887]

We need both a RW and CB if we don't get both then that's not good enough.

[@dominicstar273]

Trippier is the best right back we have had for many decades, crazy how fans seem happy for him to go.

[@TyneBridge90]

I couldn't agree more mate.. there seems to be some really strange fascination for Tino, which has produced in glimpses flashes of quality but nowhere near what trippier has produced in terms of assists from right back. Wasn't Trippier the most creative full back in Europe??? And ppl want shot ??? Absolute bonkers

[@dominicstar273]

@@TyneBridge90 I think people just love new shiny things. Luckily they aren't in charge...

[@charliesmith7256]

@@TyneBridge90 Yup. Tino is a shit Wan Bissaka, great 1 on 1. But absolutely hopeless in his positional sense and going forward.

[@britannia079]

@@TyneBridge90 Great going forward, last 12 months really suss defensively. I think most people expected a top class right winger/forward to come in and then it makes sense to sell Trippier due to his age

[@BerntWilley]

If Miguel Almiron played like Anthony Gordon today, you'd absolutely hammer him. We missed him today.

[@seanford2358]

Gordon has only had 45 minutes preseason though…after his first proper amount of time off in two years…a couple of games in he’ll be back at where he finished last season.

[@paulregret53]

Great points lads, Almiron has it too comfortable here, he is quite happy to sit on the bench and not play. Look at him in the post match team photo. He should be told we need to move him on. Howe is too sentimental at times.

[@SirMonkeySuit]

We didn't miss him today because he like Murphy would have been taken off because the red card.

[@grahamsidney9214]

​@@paulregret53 I don't think Eddie really wants to keep him. And by that I mean if a suitable offer comes in he will be sold. He has to say all the right things about miggy until that moment a suitable offer comes in.

[@owenbell307]

Compare us to villa. They've sold some big players to be able to get to that next step. Even though I think they will finish below us this season I can't help but think they're one step ahead because of the sales

[@ianrobson7827]

Thanks boys. Keeping me updated with great content when thousands of miles from home.

[@GeordieJournos]

Thank you so much for this amazing gesture 👏 We will keep trying our best! - L

[@andrewnufc9688]

Great review fellas 🙌🏻, that Longstaff tackle on Brereton after the Schar red card was brilliant, the crowd reaction was immense 😃

[@GeordieJournos]

Yes it was! - L

[@PaulFranks-cx3yd]

Great feedback Liam. Good to see you not papering over the cracks. Why play Gordon if he's not fit - he's played 50 mins since May. Barnes should have started. When Schar goes off should we have reverted to 4-4-1. Guehi at £70 million is way too much - did you see that goal Slovakia scored against England? Guehi was at fault twice in the build up. Re the service for Isak - I would like to see us go 4-4-2 against Bournemouth: Pope Tino, Burn, Kelly, Hall Murphy Longstaff Joelinton Barnes Osula Isak. Bruno and Gordon aren't fit enough and don't forget we only got 20 points away from home last season so we need to be water-tight at the back.

[@ste1887]

Great to see you back Liam.

[@GeordieJournos]

Cheers. - L

[@billrailton712]

Guys nice to see you back! As far as Guehi concerned it’s amateur hour that we have allowed it to be played out in media! I was uncomfortable at 55m never mind 70m. Parish has made us look like chumps and mugs. I certainly expect better from the owners of our club. 10 men and 3 points a huge bonus. We also still have the deadwood sponging off the club. Last season January window and this summer window is abysmal! We also need to find out what’s happening with stadium. Are the Saudi’s really in this for the long haul? First game and rusty to say least. Big Joe was immense. Being fit and match fit are two different things. We are undefeated but still a lot of work to do. HWTL

[@paulchollerton]

Great to have you all back lads👍 3 points is all that matters today

[@ToonArmyNL1892]

Weird how when a player might leave fans decide they are crap, in the case of Tripps, even weirder/not a nice side of humanity

[@peterfinkill8098]

The rule that sent Schar off apparently says "A player who when not challenging for the ball deliberatly strikes an opponent or any other person on the head or face with the hand or arm is guilty of voilent conduct unless the force used was negligible." It was certainly negligible so the Ref shouldn't have sent him off. NUFC should use this to appeal against the sending off and the 3 match ban.

[@garyd7039]

Another good watch lads appreciate the work.

[@SirMonkeySuit]

Schar has done what players do every 5 games, players go forehead to forehead. That law is not right, Schar never intended to hurt or even lost his head, he just stood him up which wouldn't have been a red last season. The officials decided that. Newcastle should appeal, I could flick somebody and cause more damage. There was zero intent.

[@GeordieJournos]

The law is not right at all! - L

[@rayakins]

We should work out our best offer for Guehi offer and if rejected move on to other targets. I was happy with malick Thiaw, thought it made a lot of sense

[@GeordieJournos]

A lot of ITK talk on Thiaw, very little substance. - L

[@roncalvert1995]

Tripper is worth more to us (in playing contribution - which ultimately translates to league position and money) than £10m or so in transfer fee.

[@peternufc1981]

Win will do me . They will grow into it after a few games and get up to pace. Joel was unreal big power house. Gordon off but that will come back isak needs a goal to kick start him . We will be ok. Need a cb and rw sorting though.

[@ItsmeAndygNUFC]

Tonali when up to speed should plug that gap we have in midfield But what Southampton did having rotating players dropping deep / stepping up gave them that extra man in midfield was very simple but extremely effective

[@TyneBridge90]

aye a remember him plugging that gap last season when we played Brighton away...not

[@GeordieJournos]

He doesn't plug the gap, for me. He is just a more technical, less physical Longstaff. Different qualities. - L

[@andrewgarrett5799]

don't think tonali will solve the problems in midfield

[@geordiedog1749]

Joelinton - first name on the team sheet.

[@DELUSIONALDANNYG]

Eddie Howe and his love for overpriced English and/or injury prone players is CRIPPLING us with PSR. How can’t the club see that we could bring in a top RW like Asprilla from Watford and a top CB from Europe for that £65M they have bid on Guehi? This is all cause Howe wants over priced players constantly. Lads why aren’t you asking these kind of questions to plant the seed in his head? Yous have a chance to say to him “why has every position been upgraded since the takeover apart from RW” or yous can ask “couldn’t that £65M be used for 2 or 3 players from Europe? Why do we need to spend excessively on 1 position” - it’s soo frustrating hearing reporters ask pointless questions when fans want to know the answers to so many things that could be asked. Howe doesn’t realise that buying Guehi for £65M leaves no room to make a profit on him in a world of PSR. I genuinely think Darren Eales has alot to answer for, he’s allowing this shite to happen.

[@connelhooley]

There's no way this Guehi saga happens if Amanda is still about, how is this happening now we actually have specialists in all roles. We used to walk away, like Lingard and Phillips.

[@antonyallen8025]

Howe isn't in charge of signings or how much is spent

[@DELUSIONALDANNYG]

@@antonyallen8025no but he makes a list of players he wants and they are always overpriced english and/or injury prone

[@levstone415]

​@@DELUSIONALDANNYG you reckon Howe always buys 24:34 overpriced players! Tripps, Burn, Bruno, Gordon, Issac...

[@johnenglish929]

@@DELUSIONALDANNYGYou are well named. You really are delusional.

[@iantelford1185]

Thanks lads, great content. First game, first win, first Oscar nomination (Diaz)! Not a great spectacle but 3 points. If Everton do want Trippier would it then be a better deal to use him as part of a bid for Branthwaite?

[@peternealon430]

Again, absolute sense fellas, all this world class stuff is nonsense, go and get the players that make the team better. If Guehi fits our style and Eddie believes he has the right attributes and mentality then just go get him. He covers us for maybe the next 8 to 10 years, even at 70 million that makes great financial sense.

[@GeordieJournos]

Fair point. - L

[@charliesmith7256]

Don't get all of the positivity .. That performance was POOR! Even 11v11 we were getting played off of the park, we should of lost 3 or 4-1. 10 men or not it was a carbon copy of Forest, Luton etc. And I mean the positivity on social media, not you guys. NOTHING has changed.

[@toonarmy3870]

Correct. Arsenal and city do not stop playing football with 10 men. We do regardless of tier of opponent

[@GeordieJournos]

Fair point. - L

[@TheCeodoc]

Responsible journalists now NEED to stop clamouring for transfers. Going 'all in' cost us Minteh, we must spend wisely so that we never ever have to do that again. Osula and Kelly fantastic signings. Hundreds of affordable players out there that can fill holes.

[@GeordieJournos]

Newcastle have the cash to go all in on at least one player they want. If they want two, I believe, a sale is necessary. - L

[@kyletomey43]

​@GeordieJournos we may have the cash, however Eddie had said we have to sell in either this transfer window or January to balance the books.

[@GeordieJournos]

@kyletomey43 that is a constant. Sales needed every year. - L

[@rogercookcouk]

Welcome back lads! Top pod as pur. Further comment from me would just rehash what you've said! So, goodbye, Auf Wiedersehen etc!

[@GeordieJournos]

Cheers! - L

[@johnwramsay1]

Great video again lads, well done. Refereeing Rant: as a previously qualified referee I am appalled at the incompetence of our so called elite referees. Yesterdays incident was completely mishandled by the on field referee and VAR assistant. This is how it should have played out. Diaz booked for push on Schar. Shar booked for push on Diaz. Both player’s second yellow for coming together therefore both players sent off. Schar was silly for initiating the coming together but there is footage showing Diaz actually put his forehead into Schar’s. The PGMOL have now set a dangerous precedent for the rest of the season by legitimizing simulation. Why can’t we have good referees and VAR assistants. I despair 🤬

[@GeordieJournos]

A very low bar! - L

[@andrewgarrett5799]

that first half an hour is a cause for concern, midfield does not work regardless of the personnel. we need a 6, cb and rw now, a cb won't fix all of our problems. hall was poor in possession

[@yougiveloveabadname2]

It's fucking one game bound to be a bit rusty

[@andrewgarrett5799]

@@yougiveloveabadname2 the same problem was there last season

[@TheJDUBMedia]

Spot on mate - Howe has not fixed that huge gaps in our midfield- had we stayed at 11 men I think we lose that game. We can only keep clean sheets playing Bruce Ball!

[@andrewgarrett5799]

@@TheJDUBMedia i thought it was worrying, so much so that i think we will finish 7th or 8th and i was half fancying top 4 this season. it needs to be fixed as the better teams will punish us

[@chrisk3189]

Parrish at Palace are taking the piss, I would have been delighted to get Guehi after the 1st or 2nd bid, but not now. Walk away, go to Europe and bring another Botman/Bruno/Isak esq CB, and with money left over for a RW. Chiesa at Juventus is available for £10m You also mention "If Eddie wants him" Do we really think Eddie now has a say in who comes in and this isnt Mitchell deciding?

[@WilliamBennett-up6gs]

Devinatly we haven't done enough in this window

[@johnnyboy11000]

Any thoughts on the rumour that NUFC were surprised by all the talk of bids being submitted and rejected as if it was the first they'd heard?

[@aidanbrophy2904]

Nice to see you all together again lads but what has happened to these tv shows you are putting on KZbin I've only seen one can't get enough of the Geordi gurnos

[@GeordieJournos]

As mentioned in the video, they are exclusively for TV. - L

[@paulchollerton]

Thanks

[@GeordieJournos]

Thanks!-L

[@grahamsidney9214]

I agree we simply have not done enough in the window to push top four. Other teams have worked us out and we havent added enough quality to change things up a bit and keep things fresh. Im worried that we are going to lose bruno and isak. Think we will get one more season off bruno and isak is holding off signing a new deal so i think come next summer he will be agitating to move to arsenal. Maybe we have to sell them coz the project they signed upto is moving at a snails pace instead of this worldwind journey we hoped for .

[@GeordieJournos]

Thanks for sharing your thoughts. - L

[@andyh323]

Nice to see the Three Amigos back 👍

[@GeordieJournos]

Cheers! - L

[@Dave-ys3nl]

Guehi, Tomori or Bastoni…..get something done, take action times running out

[@78dgray]

Do you lads think Newcastle overlooked Southampton in the first 30 minutes? Perhaps thinking it would be an easy day? If so they need to get ideas of easy wins out of their heads. Good fill in performances by Krath and Kelly. Highs and lows by Hall on D, but made the play when he needed to Sunday.

[@seanford2358]

No point going back to Palace. It’s very easy to say go back at £70m but Parish will just reject and ask for £75m…and so on…where does it stop?? Some very naive comments…even the comments about Chelsea players - it’s the owner buying an inflated squad without any input from the ever-changing manager carousel there!!

[@GeordieJournos]

I think they will. - L

[@dominicstar273]

£70m should be for a top 5 player not top 10.

[@grahamtowler1761]

Expected towards end of the season Miggy, Trippier and Wilson would have gone as time progresses their value is negligible

[@Azwaros]

I can't see the thanks button on KZbin on chrome, wanted to buy you three cuppas!

[@GeordieJournos]

Just below the videos! - L

[@ir0nMonKie]

Paying world class for a defender that isn’t world class is exactly how you ruin the future of the club. Have we learned nothing from the psr issues of only 2 months ago?

[@GeordieJournos]

It's more about if the money is there, spend it. Not overspend it. - L

[@kete3690]

My only concern is that last season and Saturday our identity wasn’t intensity. Can we get back to being that high pressing attacking shit housery team that was fantastic to watch? If we had put it on them they would have crumbled, watch what happens to Southampton when they meet a real high pressing EPl team.

[@grahamtowler1761]

The recent windows have been underwhelming we need an upgrade of someone this window

[@GeordieJournos]

Fair comment. - L

[@AllyBeee1]

Mitchell must know better targets, let him do his thing

[@geordiedog1749]

Sell Gordon buy Khvicha Kvaratskhelia?

[@loucarr90]

Why?

[@GeordieJournos]

No thanks. - L

[@grahamsidney9214]

Your point about getting rid of players is my point exactly. Seeing as no one is buying the ones we want to shift means we will have to sell one we dont. I still think we might lise gordon to liverpool this window.

[@TyneBridge90]

but here's thoughts on Gordon to Liverpool mate. If Liverpool didn't bite when we were absolute desperate for money why would they now pay more than that 2 months doon the line ? It doesn't make sense

[@grahamsidney9214]

@@TyneBridge90 yeah it doesn't but I think they are banking on us needing to sell for PSR. Same with city, the are desperate for Bruno but they still think they can get him for about 80 million. Like I say we had probably hoped to move miggy , dubs Wilson and trips on by now. If some or all of these don't move before the window close we will need to sell again next July.

[@GeordieJournos]

They're still very much there and interested. - L

[@hjc9912]

Tino defended very well yesterday, hardly got beat even when Martin brought Edozie (a dribbler) on to try and go past him. Trippier consistently got beat last season on top of the mistakes he made (Spurs away prime example)

[@GeordieJournos]

All about opinions. On current form would take Tino about three seasons to match Trippier's output in one. And I LOVE both players, but one is currently ahead in an attacking and technical sense. - L

[@hjc9912]

@@GeordieJournos Yeah they both have their strengths. You could make the output argument about any right-back we’d replace Trippier with unless we were buying Trent, plus a lot of his output is from set pieces. My point is more that Tino is a miles better 1v1 defender, less mistake prone and with Burn and Schär in the side Trippier doesn’t offer the recovery pace comfort blanket that Tino does

[@grahamtowler1761]

Beginning of the season rusty,Guehi overpriced though think the main need is a replacement for Miggy

[@geordiedog1749]

Really should have taken Gordon off and left Murphy on?

[@GeordieJournos]

Couldn't have done it, but he is definitely in a better place physically. - L

[@thenewHBK]

We wouldn't of needed a RW if we sold Almiron and kept Minteh IMO

[@chrisk3189]

Can only sell Miggy if someone wants him and not for silly money. There was a market for Minteh

[@thenewHBK]

@@chrisk3189 Saudi wanted him in January and he refused to go, his choice I get that but someone should of say him down and said he wasn't in the plans cos he's hardly kicked a ball since Murphy has come back and it's looking like he will soon become 3rd or 4th choice

[@chrisk3189]

@@thenewHBK Thats the thing you cant force someone to move. Its not like it was an offer from an Italian team or Spanish team. Maybe he didnt want to go to Saudi. And if he is happy sitting on the bench and wasting his career so be it.

[@Steve-q4h]

Our defensive problems won't be solved by buying a new central defender. We need a top class defensive midfielder!

[@andrewgarrett5799]

true story

[@britannia079]

We've got one, Tonali

[@ItsmeAndygNUFC]

He eat's spaghetti , loves curry nights at spoons And is partial to the occasional flutter

[@rogercookcouk]

​@@britannia079he's not a natural 6

[@britannia079]

@@rogercookcouk Played there for AC Milan fairly successfully

[@deanCNewcastle]

We went into that game automatically expecting a huge win, underdogs took it to us and we struggled sadly. I'm not sure with 11 men and no lucky chance for the goal we'd of drawn at best.

[@JackBurton3963]

We want to be the underdogs, it’s the Bournemouth mentality. And our fans appreciate it more than you can believe. Doesn’t win you trophies unless your Man Utd but they know how to win big finals even when their crap.

[@GeordieJournos]

I'm not sure anyone was of that mindset, not us, anyway. - L

[@TyneBridge90]

....cause he's back ! Shadys back

[@GeordieJournos]

Here to stay, until my holiday 😎 - L

[@ir0nMonKie]

You make it seem like selling players is as easy as doing it in a video game. A club needs to want the player, willing to pay an appropriate fee, and afford the wages. Then if you hit that trifecta, the player still needs to be willing to go. If selling players was that simple, Fraser, Hayden, Hendrick, and Lewis wouldn’t still be at the club…

[@GeordieJournos]

This is all common sense. No one said it is simple. But it needs done. Plain and simple. - L

[@ir0nMonKie]

@@GeordieJournos as I just said, nothing about selling players is plain and simple, regardless of whether it needs done or not. There are plenty of free players every year that I’m sure clubs would’ve rather have sold. How do you go about selling players that don’t want to leave, and that no clubs want to buy?

[@GeordieJournos]

@ir0nMonKie comment was not on the detail of selling players, more the decision to do so. However, it needs done. PSR compliance demands it to avoid a last minute rush. They have takers for players as we speak. Need to thrash it out. - L

[@lgmyhre]

Takk!

[@GeordieJournos]

Thanks! 😁

[@kendec1956]

Hall & Livramento are not CL full backs yet.

[@GeordieJournos]

Not yet. - L

[@SirMonkeySuit]

I don't why you feel like it is straight forward to get rid of players? Just sell them? Clubs need to actually want to buy them. Should we have sold Miggy to Charlotte FC for 8mil? Of course not. Business takes time.

[@GeordieJournos]

It does. Had all summer and takers for some. Need to get things rolling, easy or not. - L

[@billrailton712]

As regards sending off, regardless of lead up and what Diaz did, Schar got up and lead with his head, absolute stupidity, yes the TxxT made most of it, but Schar can only blame himself!

[@GeordieJournos]

Fair point. - L

[@westynufc90]

Isak in the 97th minute

[@brianquinn6141]

Tonali will make the difference .

[@GeordieJournos]

Hope so! - L

[@connelhooley]

If Eddie can't fix the midfield he won't be here at the start of next season. He needs protecting from himself. I don't think Tonali or Guehi fixes the midfield. It's amazing that if we had got Tosin on a free we wouldn't be in for Guehi. We've gone from being happy with a player like Tosin to wanting to splash the cash on an England player. What changed mid window? There's no strategy.

[@GeordieJournos]

Policy is fluid. It is more looking for opportunities across squad. - L

[@connelhooley]

@@GeordieJournos don't you think it's quite damning of the club's ability to find opportunities that they can't find another opportunity the quality of Tosin for a reasonable fee? Having a purely opportunistic transfer strategy just results in chaos and you can't build a consistent squad like that. Hence why we arguably haven't improved the first 11 since Gordon, and even he arguably wasn't supposed to come straight in.

[@SirMonkeySuit]

Howay Liam, you don't genuinely think you have concerns over that team against Bournemouth? Every position we have a better player. Just because we don't have a distinct Right Winger? Last season we were up there top xG, I agree that we need a right winger but if you think we are struggling against Bournemouth. That's mad man 🤣

[@JackBurton3963]

We have not beaten Bournemouth in the premier league under Howe. That could change next week. Bournemouth will fancy their chances especially at home.

[@GeordieJournos]

I've been there the last few years. They've dominated us. Hope that changes. - L

[@marcusdidius4090]

Dear all, Canny video as always👍 Cometh the Hour, Cometh the Beast👍✊💪🤘👏✋😎😁 Regards,

[@daveyeddie8176]

DOOSH😂 NUFF SAID.

[@GeordieJournos]

🤣

[@davidsomerville6904]

Is Gordon looking away? His performance today left a lot to be desired, overall the performance was very poor, two and a half years down the line I expect a lot lot better than was dished up today,

[@TyneBridge90]

2 and a half years doon the line ? We signed him last January

[@GeordieJournos]

No proper pre-season or break, so he's well off it, much like most of the players across PL who went deep in Euro & Copa. - L

[@thans7369]

Diaz - Chilean pride 😂

[@GeordieJournos]

Aye, something like that. - L

[@shearer63]

Ermmm who is that bloke in the middle lads 🤔

[@GeordieJournos]

Like a new signing. - L

[@earthrocker4247]

Le Normand

[@GeordieJournos]

Just signed for Atletico. - L

[@relayer27]

1 win down 29 to go😂

[@seanford2358]

So 8 games of losses as a PL season is 38 games!!

[@corintaylor-salter2059]

There needs to be a fan led revolt against PSR / FFP nonsense. Find me a supporter who thinks that clubs should be forced to sell their home grown talent to satiate arbitrary accounting rules?

[@GeordieJournos]

@@corintaylor-salter2059 it's absolutely madness. - L

[@deanCNewcastle]

Who's the new lad in the middle?

[@GeordieJournos]

He's on trial... 😅

[@BerntWilley]

We need 18 new players. Even Hall and Livramento are liabilities defensively

[@wouldbfarmer2227]

Is vodka or whiskey your drink?

[@britannia079]

​@@wouldbfarmer2227Both by the sounds of it, with a Southern Comfort mixer

[@davedraycott5779]

@@wouldbfarmer2227good comment.

[@GeordieJournos]

Harsh. - L

[@davedraycott5779]

@@GeordieJournos not to mention stupid.