Drunk Arthur Sings a Song And Compliments Everyone In The Camp (Hidden Dialogue) - RDR2

[@reverseflashes]

WHY DOES NO ONE SAY THANK YOU HE IS SO NICE TO EVERYONE 🥺

[@dankmeme682]

"Ah you're no fun." "Sure thing." They put a lot of detail in the game but some of these rng greet/antagonize responses just sound so NPC fake at times lmao

[@jimmyrodriguez1864]

@@dankmeme682 the Mary Beth and Hosea dialogue makes me laugh the most because they sound so off and NPCish 🤣

[@fajaradi1223]

Because he was drunk

[@nabnab9]

'cuz he's being a pain in the ass, simple as that

[@nunufyurbiznis7671]

If you really think about it, it leads to Micah making sense about the gang being ungrateful and dependent…..which is mostly seen towards the end as less important characters begin to leave one by one

[@SuperiorGothCat]

0:18. Arthur: Sweetest outlaw in the West. Mary-Beth: Errm, actually, we ain't in the west no more. 🤓🤓🤓🤓☝️

[@Iloveplayingguitar]

I always antagonize her for that reaction

[@jorg0]

​@@IloveplayingguitarI do that to Pearson for his food

[@maou1360]

So where are they actually? Genuine question

[@gtx1650max-q]

@@maou1360 NorthEast

[@Thorne-In-Your-Side]

Bless her heart, she cannot take a god damn compliment.

[@DCMook]

1:27 POV: you’ve smoked for 45 years

[@mrspo7012]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@muntadherthabit9641]

that voice looks funny here 😂

[@mysticete248]

👹👹aamonlymessinwicha

[@snaifhassnan6348]

👽

[@QueSeraSeraaaa]

"Imonlymessingwithya."

[@thiago.2473]

THE HORSES RUNNING AWAY💀💀

[@oghuzkhan6136]

Why though? Because Arthur's singing?

[@16yearsago825]

Noooo what does he do to them when he is drunk that they flee that fast 😭💀

[@mti212]

@@oghuzkhan6136 because they are wild horses

[@oghuzkhan6136]

@@mti212 Just outside the camp?

[@mti212]

@@oghuzkhan6136 they probably spawned in the area and wandered in

[@m.cullinane6692]

Arthur so confidently saying ‘my brother!’ at 0:59 is so sweet omg 😭

[@milagros1053]

1:27 🤖IM 🤖ONLY 🤖MESSIN 🤖WITH 🤖YA 🤖

[@gambler4108]

2:10 BUT THAT COWARDLY KILLEEER THAT SHOT MR MILLEER HAS LAID OLD OTIS IN HIS GRAAVEEE YAAAH

[@taesdrugdealer4458]

the way he says “YAAAH” is so cute 😂

[@liambrown7627]

lol 😂

[@snaifhassnan6348]

Just one more step..

[@unclecavi1329]

Judging from what arthur did in Valentine being drunk and his character we all can understand why most people in the camp try to have as shortest dialogue with Arthur as possible

[@jacobmachuca1173]

Even the horses

[@mrnk88]

LENNEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

[@alexv3372]

What did he do anyways that caused everyone to have short talk with Arthur anyway?? Just wanted to know

[@kamelliabuddy]

@@alexv3372When you get drunk with Lenny, a lot of chaos ensues. you end up killing someone (or just beating them up if you choose not to press X to drown) and i think animal abuse of some kind, something involving a pig or sheep?

[@Alatsno]

​@@alexv3372Well I don't know if you've ever been around people under the influence but people like Arthur are huge handful to deal with. Even if they are funny as hell lol.

[@A_very_tinly_can]

I can't stand how the default response for most npcs is just them saying okay. You got my boy pouring his soul out to these people and they just sit there saying stuff like "cool story bro"

[@JohnDelayLi]

Because he's Drunk. They just want to mind their own business without a Drunk Arthur pestering *complimenting* them

[@Randorr]

I got him drunk in a saloon a few times and he was so friendly to everyone 😭 saying stuff like “I feel amazing! *passes out*”, “Im totally fine” and one time he started shouting “LENNY! Oh no..not again”

[@Chicken_Wing91]

I don’t know i still like John’s “MR MAAAAN” 😂

[@MaxerV19]

Sometimes i wonder if they VA was actually drunk while recording the lines so it'd be more immersive

[@manzluvdrawing2006]

1:50 that true Arthur that true

[@jeremiahtorres5792]

This just brought me to thinking when you’re out riding around sometimes Arthur stars mumbling tunes to himself on a long ride out on the trail.

[@hellcat1401]

So does John. John sings about Clementine.

[@zacariahcobbert4803]

I like how everyone assumes he's drunk because he's being nice, and it makes sense too since he's rarely ever nice.

[@nocreativity2717]

1:06 LENNY’S THE CUTEST AWW

[@Neutral_1zed]

Lenny always has the funniest reply to drunk Arthur because he always find it amusing.

[@exosluckyone]

he so sweet and theyre just like alright 😭😭

[@elithelonewolf2677]

Horse Arthur: HEY! WHY THE LONG FACE? horse:🐴

[@unholyerebus4624]

0:50 anyone notice how dealing with Abigale sobers Arthur up. lol what a buzzkill

[@mr.sand7899]

John and Abigail are just trying to enjoy their morning and then drunk Arthur comes by. John: Well my day is ruined.

[@Cursed_sc0ut]

1:02 after this conversation Dutch would find Arthur hanging in his room with a suicide note reading “it’s been quite a ride”

[@insertnamehere322]

Holy shit, where did this come from?

[@Cursed_sc0ut]

@@insertnamehere322 idk

[@Doggo_is_sus]

This is the actual arthur morgan being actually honest.

[@Vidz-by_a3zi]

Love how when arthur compliments one of them they're immediately like "you're drunk -_-"

[@MattEddsworld]

1:10 is so cute omg

[@ericle5366]

Arthur and Lenny were drinking a lot at the saloon in Valentine. It’s like a wacky party.

[@anshumondolakasharia]

The horses ran away in the end seeing drunk Arthur

[@glenmarkgregorio8167]

1:13 Arthur when drunk: LLLLLEEENNNNYYYY BBBBBOOOOAAAHHHHH!!!!!!🥴👍

[@demochris1786]

even the horses was like, ah hell nah drunk cowboy's back again run1

[@Kateyangyuqing]

My Arthur is a terrible drunk but a happy friendly one who likes waking everyone up and saying "aw, just messin' with ya" and annoying everyone. Every time he drinks he gets stupid drunk. Then he lays off the drink for a while after until he has a sip and can't stop. So it makes sense when everyone goes "oh dear, Arthur 's drunk again!" I love that in his diary, his entry in chapter 2 about the time he and Lenny get shitfaced in town says "thanks to my own peculiar genius when drunk..." It just fits with my Arthur's drunken shenanigans so well

[@Raphie009]

2:06 I sucked so much air through my teeth when I heard this line.

[@skeletonjanitor]

LOL

[@Jxhnzai]

🤣🤣🤣

[@ferencjenoerdei2893]

Wtf is that line lmao

[@jlotus100]

The part where he says to Tilly, "You're one of the good ones". Oof.

[@savagerampage25]

Made me go 🤣🤣😳👀

[@rtr2096]

right! what do you mean by that Arthur🤨

[@exosluckyone]

i was like hold on a min..

[@lilben4184]

Based Arthur

[@SouljamanTWN]

Give him a break he was drunk 😂😂

[@0726Samson]

Straight on alcoholic. "Morning Arthur!" "Are you drunk?" 😂

[@BRNardy]

I love Arthur singing even more because of the way it first happened to me. I was actually drinking the boozes I had in my inventory to actually refill my deadeye core, not to get him drunk. It didn't even occur to me that it was a pretty obvious thing to get drunk after consuming that much alcohol. After the third bottle or so, Arthur suddenly goes "POOR OTIS HAD A WIFE" and the screen goes blurry, which gave me the biggest laughter ever. I was like "oh yeah, I'm dumb, that's what happens"!

[@asahel980]

it seems you get different dialogue if your drunk by the camp's booze from your own.

[@Cat_Momo_08]

Even the horse's are scared of drunk arthur

[@Tenyearsinthejoint2005]

1:10 Lenny has Flashbacks LENNY WHERE ARE YOU LENNY THERE YOU ARE LENNY LENNY MY BOY

[@connor7272]

Still, as inebriated as he is, he addresses everyone properly like a true gentleman

[@0ctalpus]

arthur singing Horses: OH GOGD OH GOD OH DHIT WE GOTTA GET OUUTA HERE

[@someokiedude9549]

I like how Abigail’s like ‘he’s being nice, he must be drunk’

[@Leon_studio]

2:10 even the horses are scared of him😂😂😂

[@zombiezworld]

I love him so much

[@chickendrawsdogs3343]

Arthur Morgan and Geralt of Rivia ruined gaming for me - because now I can't stop comparing other protagonists to them!

[@UGLYGEFRO]

same brother sameee

[@Mr.Pro55k]

True!!! Same!!! For me Geralt is the 1st and Arthur is pretty close 2nd😁😁

[@DustUSA]

who tf is geralt lol

[@buffsniper]

The protagonist of The Witcher series ​@@DustUSA

[@DaviBrito737]

2:12 Mr Milleerr has laid out Otis in his graaave YEEAAAHHH🍻🍻🍺🍺

[@CyrusChanX]

Im OnLy MeSsInG wItH yOu 🤖

[@ellerj641]

How do you get him drunk? I can stand there and have him drink 50 bottles of beer and it does nothing. I give him a bottle of whiskey or something really strong and he's only drunk for a few seconds. The longest he's ever been drunk was on that mission with Lenny.

[@AshwinY]

Few sec? Maybe it's the Wolf Trinket it prevents Arthur from getting drunk

[@ellerj641]

@@AshwinY That's what I'm thinking. I have been playing my first playthrough for so long I can't remember if I did something to prevent him from being drunk. Is there a way to turn the trinket off?

[@AshwinY]

@@ellerj641 even idk lol 😅

[@kentknightofcaelin4537]

​@@ellerj641 no, unfortunately not.

[@dojimanoryu4969]

With the trinket moonshine is the only way.

[@olalazt2664]

2:10 No one talkin about how all the horses ran from his singing?

[@noblesavage8332]

Mr. Escualla couldn't have walked any faster. To get away from author

[@nastassia19]

1:26 🤣

[@raultrashlord4404]

(Beer in hand) "Good morning."

[@Mugen_YG]

2:06 in big 1899 is insane arthur what are you doing

[@amir.music2005]

0:58 "My Brother"

[@ThumbSipper]

2:03 so... did no one at Rockstar tought that Arthut calling Tilly, of all people, "one of the good ones" sounded a little bit... weird? I know it wasn't intentional but, you know, still kind of weird.

[@EddieJackson-xl2jp]

I mean Arthur is a white guy in 1899

[@JasonJia11]

​@@EddieJackson-xl2jpHe's also drunk, so there's that

[@residentsleeper8639]

Considering the absolute vitriol with which Aurthur says the lines "Goddamn hooded robes, I'll kill all you bastards!" when encountering the KKK, I think he just means Tilly is a good person, i.e someone he doesn't mind being around, As Aurthur doesn't seem to be overly partial to people in general.

[@ZettontheGOAT]

He also said Tilly is a good girl in their last conversation, he probably mean good as in good person

[@brainrot_haver]

Yeah, in the context of him just saying she’s a good person, it makes more sense, but like… phrasing, Rockstar. Phrasing. I guarantee there have been no less than 3 Kotaku articles made in the past few years calling the company racist pieces of trash and taking that line out of context

[@Curlypiesand]

THE IM ONLY MESSING WITH YA AT 1:20 IS SO FUCKING FUNNYYY

[@DarknessOfRedbone]

Arthur: Why the long face? Horse: Am I a joke to you?

[@noblesavage8332]

This is me when I get drunk

[@jonathanturbide2232]

My favorite is "Tilly Jackson! Tilly Jackson!" 😂

[@IdkWhoIAm-1534]

1:50 Actually Dutch is the best dressed man in camp tbh..

[@nerdtom4513]

Actually it's us as Arthur if we get a good enough drip for him.

[@notfunny6606]

Bro he's getting "k'ed" every time and it's so sad

[@boltthunder2061]

to be honest if swanson could turn water into wine he just drink it all himself

[@maexpert11]

Those horses were horrified by his singing 😂

[@hypn00s197]

0:59 So... (Spoiler) Was John drunk at the end of Chapter 6?

[@jackjohnston1298]

This was uploaded on my 14th birthday and when I got this game for the first time

[@fandomotaku9921]

I love how Abigail immediately knows he's drunk.

[@kevster262]

*Uncle's voice* WOO Arthur!

[@LT.KILLIAN-14031]

i know drunk like that once he was never aggresive when drunk bro was always so nice to everyone

[@Duckkis]

The horses fleeing as Arthur's approaching them while singing.. There's something funny about it.

[@alexcasares7401]

Should've added to the title with Except for Micah

[@jesseh.5223]

2:30 this is a version of a folk song in the real world about Jesse James! I love these details Rockstar uses ❤

[@kokowoch]

0:55 John knows Arthur is drunk, when he's honest, instead of being bitter on John, lmao

[@DaveC2729]

This makes me wonder, are they going to try to add another game to this saga, or do something else? I bet they could make a great pirate game. The way Arthur says 'Yarrrrrr' near the end there.

[@imperialproductions3060]

You know your respected when you can talk to johns wife respecfully and not have him hate you

[@jonxx0333]

I love my horsey and my horsey love me

[@km-my4un]

"We all had a piece John, ask Dutch!"

[@gageballard6906]

It kinda seems that author drops his facade of grit when he’s drunk, kinda shows the man that he could be and later was when he got tb

[@absoluteunit7977]

Even more proof Arthur is lovely x

[@markkoetsier6475]

1:05 LENNAYYYYY!

[@Beef1188]

Arthur's singing is so afwul he makes the horses run away!

[@Etlsouperstar]

God if only cars drove away from you like the horses ran when you were drunk 😂

[@konohamaru77]

no one even take his compliment seriously even if he is drunk....damn arthur

[@Somedudeguywhat]

I have a half in half love for this game. It's overstayed it's welcome. (despite it's flaws).

[@Lisa-vc7cq]

Arthur my Boy always singing I love it

[@juleswoodbury58]

"sweetest outlaw in the west!' "we ain't in the west no more' 'did i stutter, you got some fierce competition since we crossed the grizzlies"

[@pvtnewb]

Mary-Beth best girl no cap

[@LordValorum]

Arthur telling Tilly "You're one of the good ones" 💀💀💀

[@lennysummers19]

I had no idea what to say. It gets crazy when Arthur is drunk most of the time.

[@Ju-jt8gc]

LENNNYYYY

[@michaelvitta5577]

Who else low key has a crush on Mary Beth, lol.

[@SmokestackOG]

Dude made a reference to otis miller , lol.

[@marilynwasthere7630]

I have never played Red Dead Redemption 2, but I've seen a clip of drunk Arthur talking to a house cat... He's so adorable, and funny thing is, the game forbids you from scolding the cat... I have only played GTA, and I've gotta say, they take GTA for granted, while RDR series are just... So full of life.

[@cashhaile7117]

You're one of the good ones💀

[@skeletonjanitor]

I was fucking flash banged by that

[@exploitativity]

WHAT DID HE MEAN BY THIS

[@zaidanahnaf9431]

Lenny and she are some of the good ones 👴🏻

[@ibrahimeljemli3822]

@@exploitativity you already know😂😂

[@lukethelegend9705]

@@exploitativityit was probably a drunk accident but him saying that to a black woman kinda implies a view that black people are inherently bad and she’s one of the good black people

[@dark_nal9732]

A drunk man's words are a sober man's thoughts so those must be Arthur's true thoughts.

[@Postal3isntthatbad]

IM ONLY MESSIN WITH YA 🤖

[@Red_Dead_Stuff]

Arthur complimenting Javier Javier: Here we go🙄🙄

[@shrimpson123]

A G H M O N L Y M E S S I N W I T Y A

[@xDarkShadowX126]

He should’ve antagonized Micah

[@saintpepsiii2019]

LENNYYY MAH BOAH

[@KindredKeepsake]

What a lovebug. XD

[@Sir_Marcus_plier_the3rd]

lEeEEEEEEnnNyY? is tHat yoU lEnny?

[@360bandman]

2:06 is crazy

[@creekboie3277]

I’d pay a million dollars to get drunk with Arthur.

[@eaten_toaster]

2:10 what is he singing here?

[@senbontorii2680]

Song's called Otis Miller.