Dumping a Dumpster

The plaintiff rented a house from the defendant. On the moveout date, the plaintiff claims the defendant blocked the driveway with a dumpster. It delayed the movers, so the plaintiff is suing for the additional expenses accrued as a result. The defendant argues the plaintiff kept delaying the moveout date, so she doesn’t owe the plaintiff anything. Besides, the plaintiff left the place a mess, so if anyone is owed money, it’s the defendant.

[@gilbertdaroy6080]

Beneath the calm demeanor of the Defendant there is something creepily OFF in her.

[@nancybez]

Totally agree! It really showed in the post case interview. I wouldn’t be shocked if I saw her on a 20/20 episode for poisoning her ex with antifreeze or something, lol.

[@HombreWithAnOmbre]

She seemed so sweet to me!

[@marleonetti7]

of course she was creepy , she was a house landlord and most landlords that rent out a house are creepy in some way .

[@deborahmueller1183]

For sure. I’m not sure why the plaintiff was ever friends with her in the first place.

[@KayB-l5h]

@4:15 Judge became real pissy. She must've had flashbacks to her construction days or got a text off camera. She even realized she was on one when she called the lady up she smiled it off and simmered back down a bit back to her normal.

[@edbrown6985]

The landlord needs to put some clothes on and lay off the booze.

[@tonyval443]

Hjahhhhaaaaaajjaaaa

[@elainevankat5353]

So true….

[@ViperBiotch]

There are some pple that rent abuse the shit out of place's for here in my town if you have specific govermental housing assistance the MAJORITY of place's won't rent to you for there's been those that abuse the system & fcks the pple who truly need it.

[@angelarose2673]

I do not like Doug. What a stupid freaking job.

[@daniellebrint2913]

Judge sounds irritated on that day😮

[@coreydbryant]

For real...

[@tonilane7979]

I came to the comments to see if anyone else thought she being extremely short on this episode. Wow.

[@crystalshaw8744]

You're right. I wonder what was up.

[@Debzie197]

I was thinking the same, she sounds so annoyed and irritated.

[@jazzymsjoyy1640]

I thought the same thing. She was irked.

[@Zaddy-Lu]

"Betsy Buxton" sounds like a character name that would be in a Nancy Drew book, or maybe an Agatha Cristie novel, lol

[@slmel7]

She shouldn't have been able to keep a penny after making the tenant pay for a 25 yr old garage door!

[@aprilpinketon2567]

Those are things you have to fight in the moment. That probably would have started an eviction process that the plaintiff would have won on.

[@XFiorentti]

You obviously have never owned anything. When you lease a place you are only leasing it. It doesn't belong to you. Anything that you damage, you are 100% responsible in replacing it. If someone leases a rennovated apartment or house , why should they eat the cost of fixing the damages that have been caused by the careles tenant???

[@lukerinderknecht2982]

Seems like there's more going on with their relationship than what's visible on the surface to cause such bad blood, as Doug puts it.

[@eisbeinGermany]

a glass top stove never lasts, my mother had one and she treated it with care and it went white

[@devisissy1]

Razor blade and elbow grease. Tell your mom to stop cooking everything on high and the spill over will be contained to the pot, you're welcome.

[@Sweetpea1128]

I would never have a glass top stove again. I bought special cleaners just for it to keep it nice. Rubbish. I cleaned after every use and it still looked awful.

[@callmejd7536]

@@Sweetpea1128 I purchased one from Lowe's years ago. I used it one time and it messed up without me doing anything. I called Lowe's the next day after delivery and returned it.

[@eisbeinGermany]

@@Sweetpea1128 i agree, as i said my mother had one, she worried more about it than us kids-lol ,and even then it got all white,

[@eisbeinGermany]

@@devisissy1 hehehhee, ok about the high heat, that was a cause of it yes,

[@rckkeller9437]

JM is in a pissy mood here.

[@anthill927]

She is. She was ok then all of a sudden was very snippy

[@lauracurtin631]

That Defendant is TOXIC. She pretends there is no problem but she's bitter, critical, judgemental and doesn't want to be held accountable. Her inner ugliness is evident to all. Yeah, the stove was a mess, but she was not a good friend or landlord.

[@TheAray6]

I agree and her charging what she did to “clean the deck” is ridiculous. Along of the bills were inflated.

[@AlibraMentality]

💯💯💯💯

[@marleonetti7]

she pretended to be a friend until she no longer needed the plaintiff"s rent money .

[@WarGrowlmon18]

That story about the garage door is just ridiculous

[@jackiemccoy6282]

I have always had that kind of range top and it’s super hard to not get it to look like that!

[@LeRoszay]

Yes mines is 1 years old and look bad 🙃.

[@claypartridge7553]

Check the warranty manual and you will find that using the special cookware is required

[@citytrees1752]

they are garbage

[@marleonetti7]

thats why im surprised the judge charged the plaintiff for that because its the nature of that type of stove top coating to start looking like that after a certain number of cleanings and months of use .

[@panamafernandez4641]

I think JM was annoyed because the Defendant made some petty moves. She basically took back over the house before her tenant moved out. Taking over the garage was bad enough but blocking the driveway was intended to obstruct. The Plaintiff was being petty about the lanai. She was moving back in & she had her own power washer, she didn't have to pay for it to be done. I love how the Plaintiff dropped the story about the power washer & the garage door. That Defendant is a Karen.

[@adlifting9824]

Moody JM today 😮

[@humaneleaguelancPA]

The tension and snarkiness is evident just like Doug says.

[@chrispellicci6587]

With ALL three women

[@andrewnyga629]

It’s the absence of a top lip, indicates anger issues

[@stephaniehowe0973]

People keep complaining about the Judges mood. This happens in real court. Sometimes the judge doesn't feel well. Is trying to get a Dr's appt

[@slmel7]

Bc this "judge" is extremely hormonal! She can't control herself and loses it on every episode.

[@stephaniehowe0973]

@@slmel7 Yet she has been doing this show over 20 yrs. Who watches you?

[@lionelluva]

JM seems a bit impatient in this case.

[@peanutgallery9927]

It's close to lunch time, Judge M is having sushi with Judge Judy 😝

[@Adniram.]

Woah!! The red head is so snotty! Something is underneath there for sure.

[@LadyWriter878]

Love Judge M.!!! Very sad things get messed up with friends, maybe it can be put back together. Some grace and thoughtfulness is the first step

[@amberhaught4428]

Love the Judges glasses matching her shirt! And such a pretty color as well! 💙

[@ParishArmstead1680]

Word Judge is a fine woman the glasses 🔥

[@citytrees1752]

Don't put glass top stoves in rentals. They are impossible not to scratch. Nobody should be responsible for scratches on them.

[@yattab4590]

Judge was NOT in the mood for this BS! 😫😂😂

[@whitneyschaeffer6251]

Defendant seems kinda nasty and bitter for some reason. Like like plaintiff her boyfriend too 🤔

[@larryblankenship8180]

I love the judge but she seems passed at the world today

[@robbbietheim2096]

The Defendant is a whole Karen and a half, SMH 😁💯

[@heathernichols7472]

I think that term gets thrown around way way too much these days. She was a woman/ home owner that was concerned her friend/ tenant was not taking even minimal basic care of her home.

[@seantimmons5900]

​@@heathernichols7472I saw OPs comment before the episode and expected... something bad. I mean, having the dumpster there was more of a dumb thing. If someone did that to my stove and such, I'd expect them to pay as well. Reminder, it was NEW. Guess expecting appropriate care of your stuff is now being a Karen.

[@stickybearskinrug2046]

The defendant is 100% not a Karen.

[@user-fr5hs4vj4d]

Stop being racist

[@lukerinderknecht2982]

She's not a Karen.

[@ZeraphineDoll]

Defendant could be Carrot Top’s sister?

[@augustmoon9973]

Damn, I don't like how JM snapped at the plaintiff. Also, the stove top seems to be a cheap one. I scratched my friends glass stove top, right after she moved in and was using a brand new pan. It left circle marks because the appliances were cheap AF, lol! That also wasn't normal wear & tear either.

[@trekgirl65]

Get used to for judges act that way everyday. Truth Augustmoon. Get used to it.

[@claypartridge7553]

Cheap or otherwise glass top ranges are susceptible to damage from using certain cookware such as bare cast iron

[@katie1535]

Would not want her as my landlord

[@chrispellicci6587]

Am I crazy, but it looks like there were 3 pissed off women in that courtroom ?

[@Jsarmy87124]

You are crazy too

[@KayB-l5h]

@12:30 the defendant had Doug stuttering 😏

[@setteam9337]

It appears that renting out property is a thankless endeavor and not worth the headache. I never met a happy landlord

[@msfranklin2650]

MORNING....WELL MY LANORDS WERE HAPPY I TREATED THE PLACES I LIVED AS IF IT WAS MINE. MY LAST LANDLORD GAVE ME SENIORITY BECAUSE OF HOW I TREATED HIS PROPERTY EVEN ALLOWED TO HAVE A CAT HE BOUGHT THE FOLDING DOOR SO I COULD KEEP THE CAT FROM MY DINNING RM LIVING RM AREA. HE WAS SAD TO SEE ME LEAVE I BOUGHT A HM BEEN HERE 19YRS I EVEN PD HIM TO DO A FEW REPAIRS. WE 1ST MET WHEN HE BOUGHT PROPERTY I WAS ALREADY RESIDING IN SO HE KNEW HOW I LIVED PRIOR. I WAS ACCEPTED FOR SECTION 8 HE HAD NEW PROPERTY MOVED ME IN. SO ALL RENTER ETC AREN'T HORRIBLE

[@slmel7]

​@@msfranklin2650If you can't afford rent, you shouldn't have a pet.

[@setteam9337]

@@msfranklin2650 God bless you, because you are the exception,

[@trilltaz3448]

Damn jus was spicy 🌶️ this case!! 😂 she was haven’t no bs!!

[@Aceofwolves]

Its NEVER a tenants job to paint. If you want it back to the original... The landlord has to do it by law. Painting has to be done at least every 3 years.

[@breastlove7117]

Land lady talking that soft and calm always dangerous and difficult to deal with

[@Ginaaaa555]

Pool man to paint lol

[@deedeeb7985]

I've never destroyed any place I lived in! I'm a stickler for taking care of any place I lived in. So that is not necessarily true

[@sunnyscott4876]

Landlady !!!!! Thank God above!!!! She finally said LANDLADY 👏!!!!! She made my day ❤️ 🎉🎉🎉❤. I'm so happy now. 😊

[@Begotts]

Somebody woke up on the wrong side of the bed….ewwwww!

[@Dapperbugbear]

Anyone notice Kevin Malone in a wig behind Harvey at 1:07 ??

[@yahboybizzy2419]

🤣🤣

[@lukerinderknecht2982]

He's been on a few of these vids 😅

[@jennifer_mertens]

JM's mood shifted..."You used to spend Christmas and Thanksgiving(together)?!? What happened"... She just showed up for the gossip😂. Also, you've got to admit this case is boring af, no wonder the Judge seems irritated with it.

[@brandyhollingsworth6816]

The defendant is too petty to be a landlord. She does not need to rent her home.

[@jeepsishumate2021]

okayyy?

[@TheMischief9]

The Judge is sweeter than Key lime pie .

[@Web19814]

I felt like she was in a mood at the beginning. Super agitated, but she pulled herself out of it. I get it, I totally understand.

[@John-co2ps]

@@Web19814I felt the same mood from the beginning. Glad she eased up

[@shannoncarlson6960]

Never understand people's desperate attempt to get appliances rammed into corners where ypu can't open doors properly. I would rather have a mini fridge that opens properly. And glass stoves are horrible. I never used a anything harsh on mine and it just turned colour from use. I sold it with my house when I moed I hated it so much.

[@MaxDalessio]

Sometimes landlords treat tenets like animals they make left difficult for the tenets i still wonder why

[@aims_plays]

Yall talking about her mood... I can tell that people aren't blunt with yall often 😅😅😅

[@leddoandroidgirl]

I think the landlady was ok being being friends when she had some sort of power over her and as soon as the plaintiff could afford to buy a home in thr same neighborhood no less i think it made the defendant jealous and act petty towards her once friend.

[@hankhill5519]

Someone pissed off JM. She was irritated the whole case

[@leofredette19]

She doesn't have to lend you her power washer.

[@tamekadavis6641]

Unbelievable ! 😮

[@WaltT-q4n]

The judge lets landlords get away with a lot of BS stuff.

[@OICU2]

I have had one for 20 years. If you use the proper scrubber and cleaner and clean up any spills before using the range top again you can keep it looking like new with very little effort.

[@ParishArmstead1680]

S/O to the painter 👨‍🎨 😅

[@MusicTennis]

lol .. the 3 stooges could have done a better paint job

[@KaktusLady]

I think she’s fine… I’ve seen her way worse.

[@howardhudson9592]

Seems like all think the same about JM

[@linn341]

The defendant is definitely sinister.

[@michelehemlokhexwhite4310]

350 to clean a stovetop? Is this for real? 350 could buy 1.5 stovetops. Ugh...

[@Greenmachine79]

She shouldn’t have withheld for the stove. Thats from normal use.. those ceramic tops are trash. No amount of cleaning will get rid of that.

[@lukerinderknecht2982]

You gotta use the right cleaner. Mine looks fine after 9 yrs.

[@popeye82]

The defendant was sliding her pots and pans around. You can't slide them on these glass tops.

[@bandhariwickette]

They're both ridiculous. The tenant thinks she can just destroy somebody else's property and the landlord thinks she can charge for stuff that she chose to remain negligent of. Doesn't work like that. They both seem like they're on some pretty hardcore prescription medications.

[@elainevankat5353]

Defendant is creepy!😳

[@ninosimone]

Why is the plaintiff wearing xmas lights around her neck 😳?

[@Blackhonda]

I love this show and always have but if you ever look at the courtroom attendants they always look like they're about to be remprimanded. LOL

[@Rumplestilzkin1981]

She has it in her bag on top of

[@shaund9759]

I’m totally #teamtenant

[@AlessandroCalzaStudio]

She drinks too much and can't tell when she does things wrong

[@bryanhenderson9637]

To me, it looks like she was using cast iron pans on the glass top. Cast iron would leave scratches like what was shown. The last glass top stove I had the instructions specifically stated not to use cast iron on the cook top.

[@XFiorentti]

JM sucks

[@cbro2807]

I get cranky like this right before lunch.

[@Nadine-bv3jm]

I would like to see receipts for the repair work done via the landlady.

[@Fhartz1337]

those new stove tops look like garbage within months, I had a brand new one and i swear it looked like it was scratched from the inside after cooking. it is awful. My older one we had to replace was 15 years old and looked almost new after all those years. there's something with these newer appliances ....

[@pipesmoker4238]

What time of the month is it?¿??????

[@charlottegunning1548]

VERY irritable indeed.

[@Bebe-og3bc]

The plaintiff is nasty!

[@rockobill7637]

judge mega caffeinated

[@newyorknewyork9790]

Range top probably depends on the good brand

[@claypartridge7553]

Valid point, plus cookware of uncoated cast iron is noted to destroy glass top range surface

[@loribryant884]

First 😅😅

[@Mimi197-f2z]

GROW UP

[@bhornannawindeedeigh5007]

A piñata 🪅 for your enjoyment. 😁

[@P3rmissionD3ni3d]

🍪 🥛

[@bhornannawindeedeigh5007]

@@P3rmissionD3ni3d Now THAT'S what I like to see - cookies AND milk... not just a cookie, because ya gotta have something to quench that thirst. Cookies are frickin dry, which is why, maybe, I've taken to handing out piñatas 🪅🪅. Although, sometimes piñatas sometimes have cookies enclosed as well, sooooo. 😬... 🥳... 🤣😂

[@evelynperez7576]

Just let u know. The estove is manufacturing defects. In not tenas fault....the stove are programa to not go to dangerous temperature. Its jus manufacturing defects.... the mirian. Charge to the tenants. Its ridiculous. Those stove are in recalls

[@lostsoul1278]

Real painters do not need/use tape

[@davidwhite3180]

Madam Magistrate should have called off today. She wasn’t feeling ppl on this day. I’m like that sometimes. I try to stay away from inessential Humans.

[@adrianknight1406]

It's always interesting to see how Milian handles these kinds of cases in comparison to others. She was much more amicable and professional here for obvious reasons.

[@chrispellicci6587]

She seems pissed off for some reason

[@neisci]

Absolutely, yt people right Adrian!!!! The audacity 😂😂. Thought you had gone somewhere else with your prejudice.

[@Web19814]

Oh lord 🙄

[@Web19814]

​@chrispellicci6587 yes she did. Especially at the beginning.

[@Jsarmy87124]

​@@chrispellicci6587so at your job you be pissed off but the word crazy really 👀🙄

[@msp.5159]

The tenseness in the air is from the judge herself. Judge needs to relax a little.