Dune: The Alternative Edition Redux (Alternate Ending)

[@cunneyes]

I can't believe this edit, this is the version I would hope they use as a guide to remaster and recut. Well done Spicediver. It's great.

[@kennethmelnychuk9737]

Yeah but Virginia Madsen looks quite lovely in the prologue

[@cunneyes]

@@kennethmelnychuk9737 absolutely gorgeous

[@totalfreefly]

Gorgeous, absolutely😅

[@residentgrigo4701]

This isn´t the Spicediver version. You can tell by the double into.

[@Fabermain]

naaa. They simply remade the 1984 in fancier dresses. And googles thinking machines with their algorithms, will make sure the 1984 die in their minds as nobody but those already in the know will find it.

[@MPlain]

I've seen this movie a frightening number of times. and yet here i am watching it on youtube.. lol. The sleeper has awakened. !!!

[@Ddamien-th8nh]

I have watched this movie hundreds of times over the past 30 plus years.

[@marianmatiasko9856]

Well ,i am doing the same now🙋 😃👌

[@StayHumanPlease]

And around 2.5hrs at 4am. The awakened has crashed and suffering sleep aponea. 👍

[@mikaelbiilmann6826]

I have never seen this movie. I was going to ask a classmate if I could borrow his dvd, bit he destroyed the dvd because he hated it. 😂 How is the new one compared to this older one?

[@hollandanish5557]

​@@mikaelbiilmann6826Like all SF it tends to date itself that said visually I think it is the richest. I love the pilots who fold time and I find the costumes over the top but in a pleasing way. I've seen the most recent remake by Denis Villeneuve loved tje fist one second one not so much. For all it's flaws I think this version is still my favorite. Watch and enjoy .

[@curtcoeurdelion]

Damn it, watched nearly every Edit Version, just saw this on my recommendation feed and decided to just sneak in for a few minutes because I wanted to go to sleep. Ended up watching the whole thing. Great work and much appreciated. Thank you!

[@ARBLACKx]

out of all the fan edits do u reckon this is the best one? its the definitely the longest out of all of em!

[@handznet]

Haha. Same here

[@guidadiehl9176]

The sleeper has awakened

[@michaelconway4411]

So much rich detail that ended up cut out of the theatrical release . Thanks for your hard work filling in many gaps Lynch was forced to leave out. Really enjoyed this 😉

[@JohnBatman111]

and even after filling the gaps, there is still so much missing from the books, it is a wise decision to split the new one into two movies

[@karljansson3906]

@@JohnBatman111 yeah I am so happy that they splite the new movie into two parts

[@handznet]

@@JohnBatman111 after seeing the new one it should have been 1 long movie.

[@kmlgraph]

One of the strong points about this film was the set design. All practical sets for interiors and some exterior shots. Very little blue or green screen, and still stunning to look at even today.

[@simman9954]

not so stunning if i may

[@eldritchwulfe]

It shows, the sets and models remain stunning, the fake 'explosions' and other special effects not so much, The shields are a toss up, though super high tech then they are dated now

[@jooei2810]

Saw this movie on premiere on the biggest screen in Helsinki. It remains the most awesome science fiction movie I have ever seen!

[@dominic.h.3363]

... then you have the knife fight that is the butt of every special effects joke.

[@sherifmohsen283]

​@@eldritchwulfe١ مرحبا ص١)

[@toastwelldunne]

The most comprehensive edit I have seen to date. A superb labour for which I am most grateful. Many thanks for uploading.

[@glensmillie5101]

Well said Sir, a tremendous effort to be sure. Bravo uploader ❤

[@SolarImage1]

Fell across this by accident - long time Dune film fan, this had a lot more going on than the version I'm used to and included a lot of cool stuff that was in the book. Excellent stuff.

[@billderinbaja3883]

I have been a fan from my first reading of Dune back in 1976. I've seen all the various productions, and I've enjoyed each one on it's own merits. This is a really interesting production with history behind Dune which I've never heard... deeply appreciated.

[@Rogermc]

how do you like the new movie?

[@DPaquette]

Wow, this is by far the best version of this I have seen so far 2021-06-29. Thanks for all the hard work on this.

[@bigbertha4080]

Did you spot any parallels to our current globe?

[@YuTuboTuTubas]

Agreed!!!! This take hooked me from the beginning. And im so lych fan

[@sospeciallyme9096]

Seriously this is one of my all time favourite movies. Fantastic movie, fantastic cast, fantastic story, fantastic world, fantastic costumes .. arghhh .. just an all round fantastic classic science fiction movie. Love it. Thank you so much.

[@justathought...1959]

I am such a great fan of this movie....finally a start to finish edition which fills the gaps from the original releasing. Awesome.

[@jmgalaxytab2325]

Wow. I didn't know this version existed. Don't know how much edit versions do exist, but his version is brilliant, loved it!!! Thnx for sharing.

[@tonywildchid]

This is an excellent work. Whoever took the time and effort to put it together should be proud .

[@Deebz270]

WTF are you on about? How is this excellent work? Time and effort? What to cut out scenes? Is that something to be proud of ? . Talk about the 'Emperor Padeshah's New Clothes' !

[@nintalespaw]

@@Deebz270 you still a miserable human being?

[@shelbyvillemusica]

​@@Deebz270choosing scenes? Remastering sound and image? Moving music? Really?

[@Colin-Fenix]

Why call the a redux version, it should be called an amateur, fanboy edition!

[@CMundi-kf9cg]

Wow, this edit is pure gold. I'm astonished.

[@seanmalik6055]

This is really amazing. All the extra parts.

[@ІгорОнищук-ж1х]

ССсс,ССсс,ссссс,ссссс,с,ссссссссс,,с,с,сссссссссссссссс,ссссс,ссссссссссссссрщш8 ссссс с ссссссссс р РРО про РРО про РРО рр@@seanmalik6055

[@glensmillie5101]

​@@seanmalik6055and one must be always reminded of how much we have lost, apparently a hefty loss, the differences of opinion between Lynch and Kubrick were vast and devastating 😢

[@juancalberto4060]

I love this movie. When I saw her in 1989 she left me shocked. For several days I was meditating on its complexities. I regret not having gone to see the day of its release, someone told me it was not worth it. Thanks for uploading it! ______________________ Amo esta película. Cuando la vi en 1989 me dejo shokeado. Por varios dias me quede meditando en sus complejidades. Me arrepiento de no haberla ido a ver el día de su estreno, alguien me dijo que no valia la pena. Gracias por subirla!

[@glensmillie5101]

She, her?!? Lady Jessica? Chani!?!

[@juancalberto4060]

@glensmillie5101 It was a friend who told me in 1984 not to go see Dune. Years later I was as a Cinematography student, observing the filming of Higlander II in Argentina. Virginia Madsen (Princess Irulan) passed in front of me, but I didn't see her. My colleagues do. I love the actresses who played the characters in Dune 1984.

[@andrewtischler9385]

This longer version is so much better - I watched the severely edited version a number of times and this one flows so much more smoothly. Thank you.

[@WERONEfishing]

One of the best Sci-fi books comes to life and an actual word for word showing in this masterpiece extended version .Thank you ever so much . 10/10

[@focast1825]

I just read the book again, and the dialogue isn't even close.

[@janespright]

@@focast1825 funny how i've read your comment 20 hours later and agree with you

[@TheEuDragon]

i must admit i keep watching this over and over, and i dont know why i keep loving it more everytime, god bless.

[@johnr7279]

This is kind of amazing. Compared to the book--best Sci-Fi novel of all time--it's genuinely tough to transform it into a movie. Dune 1984 has some amazing imagery, a very cool theme (go Toto!), and some other great features but it's always fallen short. Plus, David Lynch thought up all sorts of weirdness not even in the book. I must say, whoever edited this and pieced it all together, you made it better than the basic movie ever was. It's still not the book but what you've done to an already badly flawed movie is quite amazing and I truly enjoyed this version!

[@nickkrstich1590]

Spicediver has done a fantastic job with this. Probably the best version of this movie available.

[@MrGleamMusic]

"Thou shall not make a machine in the likeness of the human mind." Thank you for this gigantic labor and editing!

[@TIBBERS250]

Those narrations of the original Jihad are hauntingly horrifying - especially alongside those artworks which really express those very same emotions. I mean 2 men trying to support the symbol of a religious Order that would purge the machines and their slaver masters and their allies from the Universe and succeed. Brilliant!

[@DecoyJayc]

"Thou shall not make a human in the likeness of a Mind" --Culture hub

[@ebrelus7687]

@@TIBBERS250 We need that in reality. The story & the problem becomes more and more real

[@agnestwice]

incroyable! tous ses rush de pellicules que je n'avais jamais vu! et ce nouveau montage , Very good job! thank you!!

[@glensmillie5101]

We are a grateful audience ❤

[@fabricebronori]

Je pense pareil ...

[@richardpetervonrahden6393]

Greatly appreciate this edit. So wish that David Lynch had been allowed to release his original long cut. This must be close to what that would have been. Even with 40-year old special effects, this version of Dune has more classical gravitas than the Villeneuve version. Thank you again for the work put into this edit.

[@maxmeinert6264]

Now that one really improves the cinema caption or extended version I have known. So much better now. Thank you. Great job.

[@w3rkh0f67]

more elements of the book, very satisfying to watch. thank you so much for posting.

[@zainbukhari8563]

RIP David Lynch - will always be one of my fav movies to just throw on in the background.

[@mikeysuzefour]

Amen RIP David Lynch, savior of this awesome film!

[@markfudge5642]

such an improvement from the film. It has added such depth, thank you.

[@odinlindeberg4624]

Mark Fudge I haven't seen the original. Am I correct in assuming that the major change is in the form of voiceovers explaining what things on screen are and what each character thinks of the situation?

[@HenkJanBakker]

There are about 4 official versions and one has the added intro with the drawings. All movies have the 'narration' in one form or another. The way this version is edited is a far cry from the official ones and is easier to digest and even enjoyable. Specially because the introduction continues after the credits. The exposition is much more fluent and not a lengthy history lesson.

[@dannyinaus]

all this clown did was add the deleted scenes from the dvd extras package. Hardly inspiring.

[@shelbyvillemusica]

The_Man_from_Epsilon_Crucis please show me your versión

[@Deebz270]

Agreed. All Wong succeeded in doing, was ruin the original. Easier to watch? Yeah, only because it was shorter! LOL.

[@fairlane4649]

At the time of the first theatrical release, I'd read someone says the Director's First Cut was much longer than 4hours 40minutes. I don't know it for sure, but if it does exist, somebody should bring it out before I leave this planet. I really mean it!

[@CaptainTripppz]

Not unusual for Sci-Fi of the era: there is reportedly 16-24 hours of establishing shots and such from Blade Runner that RS has chosen never to release. It's pretty common in all film though to alter the story in the editing process, which is why we get a lot of 'goofs' about props moving position, the level of liquids in cups, positioning of characters limbs or accessories, etc... Differently, the prologue sounds familiar/quoted text, but wasn't the Mentat School basically just as important as the Bene Gesserit and the Guild right after the Butlerian Jihad (I think even a 4th school is mentioned in the prequel novels which trained the likes of Idaho)?

[@glensmillie5101]

​@@CaptainTripppztruly you know. But for the means of cinematic profit we the audience have been shortchanged 😢

[@shaman4611]

this is the best cut ever made, just wow, felt i like i was watching it for the first time and ive seen a few versions plenty of times

[@calvinlweir2795]

Very Nice Redux. This one makes this film STAND OUT ON IT'S OWN. Better than the other one. Thank you.

[@GuleraZarnoski]

Stilgar was so adorably fanatic throughout the movie

[@glensmillie5101]

Hahahaha 😅 Usul: ...is there wormsign? Stilgar: ...there is wormsign not even God has seen! I love this as an old friend whom visits from time to time. ❤

[@Zamolxes77]

11:30 Navigators don't fold space, Holtzmann engines do that, navigators use prescience to make sure when they come out of the fold, they don't end up in the middle of a sun, or a planet.

[@DieHardjagged]

Interesting to read this, something i didnt know yet.

[@Zamolxes77]

@Luis Abreu well, in all honesty, is not clearly stated in original books. I guess it was part of the mystery Guild cloaked itself into, nobody knew. It only becomes clear in the prequels written by Brian Herbert, that deal with discovery of Holtzmann effect and Norma Cenva.

[@ionescuvaleriumanuel9694]

Actually in "Sisterhood of Dune" Norma Cenva is able to fold space using only her mind and travel to the Imperial palace to warn against Butlerian Jihadists destroying all technology... but that is an exception.

[@Zamolxes77]

@@ionescuvaleriumanuel9694 I haven't got all the books written by the son yet, I stopped buying them after Sandworms of Dune I think, or whatever is the last book that actually closes the saga. He kept writing past that point, Paul of Dune, Jessica of Dune, haven't got those, sounds to me like he trying to milk the Dune name.

[@leonardogoulart3245]

...which makes zero sense, btw, since the volume of empty space is way, way larger than the volume of stars and planets and the odds of that happening are ridiculously low.

[@sergelemay1369]

This was good. I only remembered the Navigator scene from when I watched it around 1995. You have my sincere thanks. Now I have to go back and watch the original again (or read the books again) to spot the differences.

[@PDigsss]

i got the book on the app audible and had it read to me while i drive to work. So good cant wait for the new movie.

[@AeroAmphibious]

LOVE THE EDITING! MASTERFULLY DONE BRO!

[@mjc11a]

My mind is blown away!!! This is great! I'm a new fan and I thank you for posting a quality upload.

[@TheHuncestleo]

Thanks to all the people who continue to work on this so special movie picture after all these years the movie first came out on screen. 40 today, I was about 7 when I saw it on the big screen for the first time, and it is still passionately burning me of love for science-fiction and for english language which I've learned thanks to Frank Herbert and all the other great science-fiction novelists !=) For all the dreamers to awake and for the cinamon lovers :)

[@greatzagguratofur1791]

you must mean 33 years, as in it came out in 84 and its 2017. anywho this is a work of pure love. this makes it a Dune movie. in fact, The Dune movie. that awesome weird version that feels like an acid trip at times. but also a relentlessly close adaptation. If this is any evidence, David Lynch didnt fuck u, the damn made made the far out Dune we always wanted. the only real flaws that stay are the mind crushingly awful special effects at times. even the "bad" choices like the stillsuits and stuff, can just be accepted in the way Jodorowsky fans want all the weird and completely non-book things that he wrote to happen. In fact Jodo's version would have been waaay off the books in terms of plot and logic. it thats what you want to get mad about. now i'd love Jodo's 14 hour version too, but given space to actually tell the story, DL really did. and his way too. Now let's see the new version be the first to not implode on itself, or look cheap as shit (the scfy version)!

[@TheHuncestleo]

You're right, 33 years indeed, thank you for the correction :)

[@R3dp055um]

Meh, this is crappy. The added parts are just redundant, like that silly intro. Not only is it redundant to the Virginia Madsen intro, but it actually repeats itself.

[@66jamjar]

TheHuncestleo well said, well said.

[@Muck006]

+R3dp055um The "Prologue" is a little bit stupid, BUT it explains the history of this universe and how it became what it is ... why there are no computers. It is a necessary explanation for noobs who havent read the book. The narrative of it is extremely stupid and should probably have been redone for this version (recording audio isnt that hard and you dont really need to be that much of an expert voice actor for it). This prologue was one of the reasons why the director of the "TV version" is Alan Smithee and not David Lynch. Waiting with the "Prologue information" until they are used in this version is too late for noobs.

[@TheFabulousAdi]

Fantastic job! I enjoyed very much. The best one!

[@NeidlichesSchwert]

The music makes this better than Villeneuve's-the power of actual chord progressions.

[@glensmillie5101]

Solfeggio frequencies too 😮

[@tristantheuerkorn5124]

​@@glensmillie5101 Interesting! Where did you find them?

[@gerhardschelkmann3228]

The additional material doesn’t ruin the movie and blends in very nicely. Thx for sharing your project 👍

[@TheSilmarillian]

Only just came across this version I have no concept of the hours and the necessary skill 2 do this edit but may I say I have been blessed to see it indeed............saw the original with your editing you have far surpassed that in my humble opinion

[@sigurdkaputnik7022]

Great edit. Thanks. Before the end critics roll, there should be a final title card saying: "After Pauls's ascension to the throne, the Fremen embarked on a holy war against the houses of the landsraad, which lasted 12 years. Over 61 billion people refusing to bend the the knee to Paul Muad'dib were killed, 90 planets were completely neutralized, over forty different religions were wiped out, along with their followers and over ten thousand worlds were forced to join the Atreides Empire."

[@seanhewitt603]

Sterilized, not neutralized.

[@Del-Canada]

1984 was a great year for movies. Saw so many amazing flicks in the theatre that year. Dune, The Terminator, The Karate Kid, Ghostbusters, Gremlins, Sixteen Candles, Beverly Hills Cop, A Nightmare On Elm Street, the Neverending Story, Revenge of the Nerds, Footloose, and so on.

[@joejones8810]

You forgot George Orwell's 1984.

[@Del-Canada]

@@joejones8810 Damn. I knew I forgot a good one.

[@congorecluse8111]

The Adventures of Buckaroo Banzai Across the 8th Dimension. An absolute classic.

[@bosoerjadi2838]

Ghostbusters

[@JosefTiberius]

Thanks for this nice piece of work! I really enjoyed!

[@Didgeridoovibes]

Imagine making a movie in 2021 where they talk about a Schiihaad (intentional misspelling thanks to youtube comment filters) =D On a more serious note: Thanks for the great work

[@jooei2810]

The spice must flow!

[@miguelbarahona6636]

But if there is rain the sandworms will die immediatly, so no more spice.

[@arri1254]

In just a few words...you have done an excellent job, in my humble opinion better, much better than the original . film. Congratulations and many thanks for your fine work.

[@SeverusStudios1980]

Sam Wong, my hat goes off to you mate. DUNE you are and always will be a part of my upbringing and a tale I will take to my grave.

[@gunnarbakke]

Amen.

[@andrewfontana3136]

I saw this when it first came out, not long after reading the book. Watching it again now was like seeing it for the first time again. Very powerful.

[@victoriamorris3773]

Watched 3 times now, over time. Best Version yet. I think commented before over the years. From Australia ❤😊

[@naireretomassjoo5279]

Ive not seen or heard of this film before...i feel like im in for a big treat!!! Thankyou!!!

[@rhp0255]

this version makes so much more sense than the original theatrical version with all the edits restored, my favourite novel as a teenager!

[@mattmartley6165]

yo well done i've read every book in the series and loved the prequels, well done. youve done well.

[@ChillyDippers]

Agreed. While it doesn't quite rectify all the voids and errors this film made in the saga it does go a long way to clearing up the basis if the universe it is set it.

[@mkvector9539]

First time watching this, my god is it amazing to watch.

[@arcanusluvalus1388]

same here, amazing film

[@tahubrontak7770]

I watch the 2hours duration and it's kind confusing to follow the story.

[@glensmillie5101]

I foresee many more 😅

[@hardanheavy]

For a movie that is the screen adaptation of a series of books that can not be turned into a film, this is a fine effort. This ultimate version is an even more valiant effort. After what Villeneuve did with BR2049, I can hardly wait for his version. I trust it to even blow this one out of the water, err, sand, I suppose. And I will absolutely love it when we get lines like 'we saw you coming from the other sietch' or 'would you like me to repeat what I said, Muad Dib?'. But that would be just too geeky I guess ^^ For Shai Hulud!

[@victoriamorris3773]

Well done. Best version yet. From Australia 😊

[@Roger-cb3fv]

This film just has a soul. An epic even with its flaws.

[@Colin-Fenix]

You mean with its many, many, many flaws.

[@eisenkopf69]

@@Colin-Fenix a boring soul but still

[@dombourguignon5708]

@@Colin-Fenix Not as much as the new version with the boring Chalamet…

[@samuelmorkbednarzkepler]

@@dombourguignon5708cope

[@juanalbertomartinezmartine913]

​@@samuelmorkbednarzkepler At least in this version we know why the species is important

[@abcun17]

RIP David Lynch 🙏

[@Lizpaht]

Compared to the Original you gave the last seconds and the credits a very sinister touch. I really liked that!

[@josefmalar7837]

20 years i didnt see Arakis.... thank you. Gladly this, than the incoming movie. I am still sad, it is too short. I didnt feel it as child, i feel it now. That is why series are needed.

[@nikitaw1982]

i wonder why they didn't make a sequel soon after this one.

[@jonsimarcatapan1150]

Read the books. They are amazing.

[@gabrielgray]

i'm gonna give the new movie a solid chance, but you are right, a big budget series like Game of Thrones would be more suitable to tell this kind of story. They tried once on the space channel, but budget constraints were obvious, and casting was questionable.... it was too bright.

[@suhrabrahimi5352]

@@gabrielgray OK pl

[@dominiquebernard9414]

They are, and they exist since 2003 (scifi channel, two 'seasons' : Dune and Children of Dune, three 1h.30 episodes each), rather low budget, but closer to the books : kzbin.info/www/bejne/o4PPcn6Am7eniMU

[@waynethekorpse8665]

Its been years since I've seen this joint... but I thoroughly enjoyed it. "MUAD'DIB... My name is a killing word... They are ready to fight, yet in order to lead them, I must conquer the world..." I just noticed that Paul's woman also plays 'Racheal' in the original Bladerunner movie. Gorgeous.

[@siegejay495]

Thank you algorithm, take me to masterpieces like this.

[@peachmelba1000]

Completely bonkers movie. Totally underrated.

[@heavyj2134]

The Reverend Mother may be my favourite part of this whole movie. Her performance is masterful!

[@ChupeTTe]

Almost as attractive as Irulan. She stands really out

[@岳武穆-n9n]

1:51:08

[@tkucey8689]

I have tried to watch this many times since I was a teenager and couldn't understand it. If ever there was a movie that needed subtitles, it is this one. I still think it helps to have read the books first but this is a very good edit. Thank you for the work you did and for sharing

[@harrisonsullivan206]

Hello Tanya, How're you doing ?

[@dannyinaus]

21:41 "So what do you do for a living?"..."Oh, I mop up the goo the Navigator leaves behind"..."Charming to the last..."

[@leehaelters6182]

Old joke: when a down and out vaudevillian is asked why he doesn't quit his job cleaning up (and worse!) after elephants in the circus. Punchline: "What, and leave show business?!"

[@Sharon_McCluskey]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

[@L.A.Tex_Norway]

I have a three hour special editition on DVD, ordered from Australia a few years ago.

[@ppineault]

I actually saw the movie before reading the book. I was kind of astonished how I clued into things that the book delves into but not so much the movie. I've often recommended the book to people, telling them that it's not only the best science fiction book I've ever read, it's one of the best I've ever read, period. Frank Herbert was, IMHO, a genius and is right along there with J.R. Tolkien as far as I'm concerned. :)

[@sriranjit3684]

But Tolkein said he hated Dune,I dont know I just read it somewhere.

[@WolfxBlossomx]

​@@sriranjit3684Tolkien is a Catholic nerd.

[@Tomorer]

Everyone need thier own reedit of this movie. When there are two remasterings that make different bits looks better, its a no brainer. Cheers!

[@Paganforge]

All in all excellent, except that the quote at the end of the movie is incorrect. "When religion and politics travel in the same cart, the riders believe nothing can stand in their way. Their movement becomes headlong, faster and faster, and they forget that the precipice does not show itself to the man in a blind rush, until it is too late."

[@bonelessx]

How this epic have such a small view count etc... it is epic not just stupid commercial flick? Dune 4 EVER!

[@quintoniusmarcus7737]

Sitting here watching Dune with a bag of Spice Melange flavoured chips and a glass of fizzy Sapho juice

[@ilovehmetal]

I’ve now seen all versions of Dune and this one is still the best

[@wintermutevsneuromancer8299]

read the book a few weeks ago (two of the three). watched tho original movie again and was disapointed again. now i watched this version and it's much better. thx for the great work!! still (nothing we can do about it) very disapointet how he treats prinzessin Irulan especially in book 2. damn u Frank Herbert :D

[@tamaswittmann8768]

have never seen the original but this one worth every second. thank you for sharing.

[@JanHBuch]

Finally, a proper cut, that doesn't look like the work of drugged editors.

[@pferreira1983]

I miss the original roll call ending.

[@stephaniesadie832]

can you imagine a movie arc based on the entire 27 books, it would make all the Star wars movies look like an interval trailer. I reckon you would need at least 12 movies of 3 hours each .

[@Kevlord22]

27 books? Holy hell, this should be a series then or something.

[@vizaldrex]

ive cried 2 times from the shock of this truer than life version .... omfg good job guys

[@philiponeill6903]

I just wish someone would get rid of the most ludicrous line in the movie: "Where there was war, Muad'dib would bring peace..." Did the writers actually *read* the books?? Peace? The Fremen jihad that burned across the universe in the name of the Atreides, killing trillions?

[@booby0192]

What about the weirding modules? So much time wasted in the movie on sound guns when there was way more plot that could have helped people understand so many more things about the story.

[@Zamolxes77]

@@booby0192 Well I can see why they did that. They needed a reason why the Emperor wants the Atreides dead. In the books, is because thanks to Guerney and Idaho training, duke's men have become as skilled in battle as sardaukar. Basically, they know a deadly form of kung-fu. Fremen are just as deadly, even deadlier. So in film they dropped that and simplify it, by having the Atreides posses a special technology, instead of a way of battle. Albeit, they did it kinda poorly. They could have shown for example the raid Duke men took on Giedi Prime, to destroy Baron's hoard of spice. They could have shown them engaging in hand to hand or knife battles (remember the personal shield EVERYONE used, guns were 100% useless) slaying multiple Harkonnens soldiers, but that would have required actors trained in some form of martial arts. Much easier to make a prop and film a scene in which they yell 'chaaa' through a speaker.

[@pl_caravan4679]

this was a part of the book. when paul had one of his "episodes", he saw the fremen absolutely wrecking shit, leaving behind them enforced peace where the conquered would not be allowed to make war on eachother, under pain of destruction. Effectivly bringing about a galaxy-wide peace.

[@philiponeill6903]

@@pl_caravan4679 - that's a pretty broad definition of "peace"! :) The visions Paul had were consistently of possible futures, where every single one showed the jihad raging throughout the galaxy.

[@pl_caravan4679]

@@philiponeill6903 well not every single one, but yes.

[@divanosoba9658]

never understood negative reviews. It was always one of my favorite movies

[@ecurb10]

Had you read the book before seeing it the film?

[@divanosoba9658]

@@ecurb10 i m aware of film being disappoiting comparing to a book. So what?

[@ecurb10]

​@@divanosoba9658 So....what? Life lesson: "disappointing" = bad, "not disappointing" = good. Hope that helps.

[@ronaldcote8077]

RIP David...thnx for the rad movie homie!

[@WorldView22]

It's great to see Sir Patrick Stewart, the "Captain Picard of Star Trek TNG, in a role here!

[@TheDeathBeatsOfficial]

Very well done. How did you manage to source the additional scenes, are they all from versions that have been available previously or did any of them come from inside sources? Cheers!

[@juanpablozucco9504]

La versión que hasta ahora más se aproxima al libro, y la que tiene menos inconsistencias. The most accurate version regarding the book and with fewer incosistencies. Loved it.

[@glamabasic142]

The Quality is outstanding, thanks !

[@макслюлюкин]

one of the most mystical works and film versions

[@ГРИНГИ]

try Stalker or Solaris by Andrey Tarcovskiy

[@yo-ry1np]

@@ГРИНГИ ya

[@JoshuaSeiminlalKK]

@@ГРИНГИ a

[@JoshuaSeiminlalKK]

YTTTUTTRAKHANDYTTTUTTRAKHANDfYTTTUTTRAKHANDYTyzTyyTUTTRAKHANDfzyyy

[@JoshuaSeiminlalKK]

@@ГРИНГИ the y

[@higorsouza7765]

Thank you so much for this video. Nice shall searching for comic novel.

[@sporehux8344]

21:14 "I am not here", disappears into a giant super obvious tank with 20 attendants.

[@Emanresuadeen]

Too bad his arms are too short to put his hands over his eyes when he says it.

[@FirCorred]

@@Emanresuadeen nice one

[@spaceagemonkey8889]

shhhhhh you're to supposed to notice

[@WolfxBlossomx]

​@@Emanresuadeenhe needs a cape

[@Msmargret1]

Truly excellent. Good job! I'm very happy to have my Herbert Fix, like the first time. Thanks

[@harrisonsullivan206]

Hello Margret, How are you doing ?

[@Msmargret1]

@@harrisonsullivan206 Another Herbert fan?

[@harrisonsullivan206]

@@Msmargret1 Yeah, It's good to hear from you. I'm thrilled by your comment and beautiful looks. where are you from ?

[@Msmargret1]

@@harrisonsullivan206 I'm from the states, retired to Mexico. How about you?

[@harrisonsullivan206]

@@Msmargret1 It is a pleasure to meet you here, I am from the United States, and I hope we can talk and get to know each other better.

[@ErikCartman]

i think it is a perfect choice the way lynch showed the weirding ways. it is a great manner to imply that voice create energy. i hope in the new movie they stick to something elegant and not kung fu fights. dune is slow and relentless, not an action flick at all. its all about dialogues

[@WolfxBlossomx]

The weirding module is totally out of place my only minus with the movie, I'm glad they didn't implement that in the new trilogy.

[@willianmendes524]

I have high hopes for Denis Villeneuve upcoming movie. Max Von Sydow would be an awesome Thufir Hawat.

[@DieHardjagged]

Holy shit, i didnt even knew that there would be a Dune movie? So what is it, a remake or reboot?

[@patinho5589]

DieHardjagged completely new adaptation

[@Feroxing12]

villeneuve ...great choice

[@Spectans1]

Max Von Sydow is also in this Dune :D

[@Aedrion-]

It's not about the actors, it's about the writing. Reserve your expectations until you've seen it.

[@WarbirdFan66]

old but still better than the new one in my opinion....still a joy to watch

[@IvanKala]

aye, mostly because they butchered Liet.

[@kaartikeykusshwaha10-c8]

2021 dune is a masterpiece this one is a total failure

[@phantom1713]

@@kaartikeykusshwaha10-c8 "mastermiscastpiece", probably. Every fail of 2000 and 1984 combined can't beat it.

[@LS-ot4ho]

Paul's father looks like the guy who played the captain of the submarine in Das Boot.

[@RubyMarkLindMilly]

Lisa Simkins it is

[@mythatsabigone2500]

Jurgen Prochnow , a famous German actor

[@tommyodonovan3883]

YEAH, DumKoff

[@MrKersey]

Because he is Jürgen Prochnow, Der Alte Mann, Herr Kaleun of the U-96

[@davedogge2280]

@@MrKersey haha I was thinking that he looked familiar

[@teach-learn4078]

Very cool. Had seen the original when it came out in 1984. One thing that stood for me this time was the fact it was David Lynch directing, which was lost on me first time. I'm not a big fan of the largely dark sets and grotesque moments galore, but no question he's great at what he does (Eraserhead was amazing).

[@onelove2909]

One of the best sci fi series of books ever written and a good effort to make a film so authentic to the book, up to a point obviously. . I read them when i was young and always loved the film too. i Had never seen this or any other extended version its soo much better, I always thought it had been a bit cut up. Its a shame they cut down films for cinema time, i wonder how many other films have been ripped to shreds by editors. Would be great if they could make a remake and the other books as sequels . With say JJ Abrahams directing, with the special effects they have these days it would now be possible and amazing.

[@tvicic]

if you turn on automatic subtitles, it gets crazier. Dune is June and so forth. treat yourself.

[@juanito1005560]

Lol it talks about Moscow and killing all countries and Jesuits sound legit to me as nowadays they are genocing us like never before, kinda seems like it is actually a way to comunicate something to someone, great comment.

[@frenchyontravel]

That’s so amazing we can find such classic movie in here - would it stay any longer?? 🤔🤔🤔

[@ferix7739]

This extended version is a masterpiece. It flushes out a few scenes that did not make any sense in the original. For my money the best sci fi movie ever made.

[@Colin-Fenix]

We seriously did not need this fanboy edition 👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼

[@stringstorm]

I love the ending in this one! It rains on Arrakis and then it abruptly ends all while a powerful ominous music plays!

[@ChillyDippers]

@Slovier .a. Read the books... you'll understand the grander scope of what is happening. Localized rain does not in fact kill all worms.

[@ChillyDippers]

@Slovier .a. Read the books. The movie leaves alot of of the actual first book. There's is a large amount of canon around the freeman, worms, and arrakis that is honestly never presented in the film.

[@ChillyDippers]

@Slovier .a. notice I say first book this saga continues much further then the tiny portion the movie presents.

[@DaveLennonCopeland]

Superb original movie and wonderful books, I did not know this was a fan edit until it started; I do hope it is good. Edit: Hmm, some original scenes cut out and some original deleted scenes added. I can't see how this redux version improved the movie really. Strange that Spicediver felt this HAD to be done, each to their own, I guess. :)

[@deanblaze2000]

Absolutely love this movie since the 80s....always have...always will....can't see anything topping this aa my all time best ever sci-fi flick...its just amazing....

[@ecurb10]

Had you read the book before seeing the movie? I strongly doubt it....

[@deanblaze2000]

@@ecurb10 You would be correct in your assumption...I love the movie...but it clearly does not come close to doing the source material justice...

[@ecurb10]

@@deanblaze2000 yes I can understand someone liking the movie if they hadn't read the book, as it did have some good qualities...I did like the gloomy and gothic interiors. But to me its main problem was that it didn't even try to stay faithful to the books, or at least evoke the Lawrence of Arabia feel of them - like, where were the robes the Fremen wore? Where was the ever-present blinding sands? It really came across that the makers of the film had no particular love of the books, unlike for eg. Peter Jackson's treatment of LOTR. Judging by the trailer, the new Dune movie does seem to have the right feel at least...let's hope!

[@deanblaze2000]

@@ecurb10 I agree. Trying to fit the first Dune book into a single 2 hour movie is an impossible task. By doing so it inevitably resulted in a movie that, although visually interesting and with an superb score, was severely lacking. But in any event, I don't think Lynch would've made a faithful adaptation. Even Paul was nothing like Frank Herberts vision. Villeneuve is a true fan and understands what makes the series of books a masterpiece of science fiction. Although I'm sure his attempt won't be perfect, I'm very hopeful that he'll do a much better job....