EASY Guardian Farm | Bedrock Guide S1 EP73 | Tutorial Survival Lets Play Minecraft 1.17

[@feelgood157]

Just built the farm. Thought that I had put the tubes in wrong but actually the guardians were just glitching out of the spawn part of the tube at the top. Fixed it by putting more glass in the corners around the top 2 blocks of each tube and it works perfectly. Great farm and video!

[@christopherdriscoll8672]

Thanks I was looking for something like this

[@starwarsjournal4033]

Same me and my wife were so mad thanks man

[@tuttle332]

Thanks!

[@sam_bedford]

Honestly I really like this guardian farm as it is simple to make and doesn't require Nether Portals and Redstone, but it still gets you the guardians. I also quite like it as it is quite easy to expand upon as you go along as you don't have to add all 25 tubes in one go. Plus I drained an ocean monument, so this will be nice to stick in there

[@tektrix]

Thanks! We only got 3 tubes so far but can confirm this works bedrock 1.19 realms - Already collecting!

[@Vastmotto]

Does it still work ??

[@tektrix]

@@Vastmotto ye still working, chugging out the blue Doritos! Note: we did have to switch to peaceful to despawn and we did just go ahead and fill in the corners on the top-3 layers for each tube as other comments suggested.

[@wombie_4188]

WHERE DO YOU AFK???

[@tektrix]

@@wombie_4188 I afk near the center tube on y=35. We dried out the temple and put storage in there so we got pretty easy/safe access to everything.

[@Kate-zt1tw]

Thank you!

[@phrebh]

I'm rewatching this and only now realized that you've explained the spawning grid in the best and easiest way that I've even seen! 😀 So much easier than starting at the outside corner!

[@hippyhappyhippo]

Yeah, it makes so much more sense than other 'explanations' I've watched from other youtubers.

[@aaronbyers1488]

Agreed

[@ninjanoodle2674]

As someone who has emptied an Ocean Monument of Water and Blocks, I can appreciate the amount of work that takes. I turned mine into a Poseidon Temple as part of the decoration of my Guardian Farm, and I'm looking forward to seeing what you do with yours.

[@keanu7000]

Farm works very well on Bedrock 1.17.41 (Windows 10). But a couple comments: * The top of the grid pic @ 4:06 actually points East. North is on the left. * The grid pic walkway orientation didn't match what I built per the verbal directions. It ended up being ok, the spawn points were in the same spot. * For reference, the corner spawn points should be the third block in (X and Z axis - from edge 2 over, 2 over) from the monument's corner below. * The glass tubes should go down to Y=26, which is referenced later in the video but the first part mentions Y=28 @ 11:30. 28 is not deep enough to kill the guardians. * Definitely perform the guardian spawn test first. With the spawn columns blocked down to the temple, and the temple itself 100% sealed, you should not see guardians outside the temple after killing off / despawning those remaining. With the above addressed, the farm works almost TOO well. A serious storage/sorting system is a must, as it will struggle to keep up. But great farm.

[@ItzHatorade]

im a little confused but ty !

[@gracynbtw4435]

@@ItzHatorade same lmao

[@gracynbtw4435]

Does it work if you follow is directions

[@ariesflamethrower5418]

Fantastic farm. So simple and the lack on redstone makes it super easy for early game.

[@lexihorter7634]

This farm works as of 1.18.30 (4/22/22) bedrock as well as on a regular server (when I tested in creative) and a realms server. I had to do what the comments did and put three extra blocks in each corner around where the button and water is. Still have four tubes to build as well as the storage system, but so far so good. (: thank you very much

[@hellsng]

Thank you so much for sharing this info! Always helps to know if a farm this massive works on current versions of the game.

[@dallasdrotts4907]

Can confirm working 1.19.2 Aug 13. Built it sightly modified so that they fall through lava before falling into a cobweb and burning to death. The drops fall into a water stream and collect in a central storage. Probably not getting optimal rates since they die slightly slower than if you just kill them with fall damage, but you save a ton of iron on hoppers. Quick test showed I'm getting roughly 4,000 drops an hour, which is pretty mental. If you use fall damage I'd estimate closer to 5,000-6,000 drops an hour, but that's gonna be overkill for most people lol.

[@migjordanpayawal7856]

This is awesome. I think if you change the way the guardians are killed, you can just do ice + water streams to move the items, instead of hopper lines. Might even be cool to make a floor design that shows the items moving, like it does near your item storage.

[@Knee_High]

Absolutely loved this farm, easy, to the point and no nether nonsense

[@aintgonnahappen]

That nether portal isn't that bad to build. That farm is so good.

[@johnperish]

I did this exact thing too months ago. I thought i was nuts for doing it when the one tube trident killer was so efficient. I used minecarts to deposit everything into multiple hoppers to help with item moving. Im planning on turning the giant kill chamber into a metro station soon.

[@hellsng]

Please don’t build this unless you have some crazy need for A TON of prismarine. Just a little under an hour and you get a full double chest of items plus some. I built all 25 chutes and wow, I don’t even know what to do with all of the items. If you need just a bit of prismarine here and there, 9 pillars is more then plenty. Amazing build! -) Oh yeh, built this on 1.18.31 bedrock realms, works flawlessly

[@darnell-s5371]

Great vid. I've seen some others that are great but crazy complicated. Appreciate the simple functionality of this one!

[@Grim_Stoner]

I love this farm. I wish I would've found this design a month ago (before I collected all the tridents for the design I made). Plus, this is way less laggy than any with a Trident killer.... Gg. You just earned yourself another sub

[@benjaminrodriguezfranco7113]

As a person who really would like to expand my world and make projects, I need blocks or even XP to repair and use tools, as I progress I have the necessity to build a different farm, but from the ones I've seen on KZbin, this is the best explained video I've come across with, thanks for the tutorial 👍

[@privatenono4447]

Just finished my incredible gunpowder farm and found this, and I and extremely happy that I did because I wanted a way to efficiently get shards/crystals for the blocks so I could finish my house with them.

[@cayansc1]

On a simulation distance of 4, there is a chance that many mobs will despawn before they hit the bottom of the shaft. It seems a little tricky to find the right AFK spot in order to allow for spawning and minimize despawning. Just something to think about before you build. Prowl's spot inside the base wasn't random. Don't AFK in the sky.

[@Aggrosk8]

What we've found on our guardian farm where we use trident killers and water streams/elevators to push the items up, rather than down, you can afk in the center of the temple above, and have 21/25 of the spawn spots active. You cannot hit the 4 corners on sim distance 4.

[@rudianto2903]

Yes, This is the problem of Prowl's Guardian Farm design. It is about AFK Spot on Simulation Distance of 4. We can't use all spawn spots if AFK on ocean level and despawning problem if we AFK on the sky.

[@johnperish]

You can use Foxys texture pack to find the best afk spot and plug up the tubes outside the radius.

[@cayansc1]

@@johnperish Also, if you only use the 9 central spawn spots it will still provide tons of drops and will be easier to build. More than enough drops for me at least.

[@briand7157]

It's nice when a buried treasure chest contains 3 soon-to-be Sub to Prowl filler diamonds.

[@KILLZNTHRILLS]

Did 9 tubes and modified collection system to be hoppers from under each tube leading to 1 soul sand elevator that pops everything into a huge storage silo on the surface. Works a charm. Might do sorting system soon

[@solomon4086]

This DOES work on Minecraft Bedrock 1.18.2 (the current latest version). If you are having problems make sure that when you are blocking the spawns that you block the spawns all the way down to the ocean floor including the spawn locations inside of the ocean monument (you don't have to drain the whole thing unless you want to). Hope this helps!

[@xd_snipe_emplayz68]

thank you this did help

[@1308stewie]

it works on 1.18 for me!

[@SkyGuyJedi]

This genius dude! Was going to try and come up with my own design but why fix perfection. Thanks 👊

[@isaiahdeherrera7754]

This gays the best most KZbinrs would never respond to a comment on a video that’s 5 months old who dose that, him, He’s literally the best!

[@Nakomato]

I have to agree that this farm is very easy to make and fun! Can't wait to try to take on a monument myself!

[@Prowl8413]

Do it!

[@Silk_Sundae]

Pro tip use a conduits so you don't need to go up in the surface :D

[@Prowl8413]

Yeah didn't think about it till later lol

[@NicholasAEvans]

This is so great for early game: pretty lights and the pretty green blocks. So simple. It's definitely going to be how I start my next guardian farm in my next new world. For blocking the spawn spots, I use sand because I can just stand at the top and place until it stacks up-gravel works too. Super easy and fast. You'll only need to go into the water to break blocks so the column goes all the way to the ocean floor, and you can just skip that step-handling it when you build the drop chutes. My understanding was that structure spawns *always* use the cave cap + 1-even when they aren't under a solid block. Since you're AFKing below instead of above, you'll still want to light up the caves so those don't affect your rates. But drowned spawning shouldn't slow down guardian spawning. Maybe I'm wrong or maybe it's changed recently or will change in 1.18? IMO looting III and XP collection is worth the trident killer upgrade... This is the fastest XP farm in my personal survival worlds. If you do ever upgrade to use trident killers, most importantly: do *not* transport the guardians: build the trident killers directly around their spawn spots. A 1×1×2 or 1×1×3 kill chamber with a single water source on the spawn spot is sufficient. That creates a flow for item and XP delivery. Use a trapdoor to keep the guardians in and let XP and items flow into your water streams. If XP orbs get stuck, use a longer chamber-but 1×1×2 still gets most of it. If you aren't collecting XP you'll want to have an off switch (or burn it in a campfire or lava) so it doesn't lag your world. Use one of the trident killer designs that pokes them in the head through the corners of the glass using pistons or trapdoors. Simpler and faster to build and works much *much* better for guardians than the common whirlpool designs, which can cause them to bounce around and glitch out of the kill chamber. Cheaper too because you won't need observers (quartz). A simple torch and repeater clock circuit with trapdoors or pistons works fine. 5) With a good clock and a few Impaling V tridents in each trident killer, you should be able to kill every single guardian within 2-12 game ticks of spawning. Nether based farms might be a little faster (1gt?), but that's overkill. IMO there's no need for most players to deal with the hassle of two dimensional farming. This approach uses a lot of tridents:25 to 100! ! So if you don't have a drowned farm yet, you can just use this drop-kill design on all of the spawn spots and upgrade one spot at a time to use a trident killer. And... I heard like XP farms so I put an XP farm in your XP farm. Always cook those raw cod! 😁

[@NicholasAEvans]

Fyi sorry if this sounds critical. I really love this design. Easy early game prismarine and sea lanterns are a big deal! I predict all of my future guardian farms will be built this way, at least to start. As you pointed out elsewhere, fast XP can be gotten from other places, and looting III is probably overkill since this already produces more than most people need.

[@costachiever5212]

Thanks prowl I learned a lot from this video and the streams.

[@Ratboycure]

Thanks Prowl, always quality content.

[@Prowl8413]

Thanks

[@Paxin45]

Imo wandering traders appearing literally everywhere is the most toxic feature in minecraft

[@blackgrizly9522]

Toxic is a bit much

[@swaaaft]

and when i need them to spawn to get dripleaf, dripstone etc they dont spawn

[@blackgrizly9522]

@@swaaaft that is accurate

[@swaaaft]

@@blackgrizly9522 basically happens to almost all mobs when i want them to spawn. its almost like the game can read my mind

[@blackgrizly9522]

@@swaaaft early game you're looking for some xp but you don't got any XP farms/banks so you go out at night kill some mobs your self and grind for it but it just happens to be one of the safest nights you'll ever see on Minecraft

[@phrebh]

I tried doing something like this a year ago and totally failed. Great work!

[@bergenfox1422]

Hey Prowl, I really enjoy your videos. Your video on how you transformed and made the mob spawner farm are incredible! I have a question about this farm, will this work on Java? I play on a server and we dont have the Nether yet so my options are limited. This would be great if I can build on Java.

[@stonerjesuswthabeard3365]

Saving for after 1.18 just to make sure nothing funky happens with the farm lol Great Build

[@jezridley2266]

Absolutely awesome thanks prowl

[@Prowl8413]

Thanks!

[@thestrangersrifle1828]

In building the farm, blocking the spawns worked perfectly well and I had everything placed correctly, but after building the tubes and finishing out the build I noticed that Guardians are spawning in bunches at a few tubes instead of inside them individually. Not sure of a way to fix it, bit of a bummer.

[@GarretWallace827]

I imagine you could upgrade this farm by adding dispensers for the water spawning spaces so you can turn the farm on and off. Could also set up a switch to basically add water to the bottom where the hoppers are and redstone doors to allow the guardians to travel through some tunnels into a kill chamber. Basically you could toggle it from spawning/not spawning, and from being an afk drop farm to being an afk xp/drop farm with a trident killer or somethin. So as it is, its awesome. But if someone wants to spend a lot of extra time, you could make it a toggled design.

[@crownmeking6070]

how can you transport the guardians into a kill chamber?

[@sfisher923]

Have a question about the Next Episode Will the lighting be good for people who can't use RTX (MCPE for example)

[@Prowl8413]

I always light all my builds for spawn proofing without RTX first, then RTX lighting to finish it off

[@playmusic8056]

Gotta say you have been doing a good job of extra lighting so it still looks good when you show stuff off in RTX. I like the way you do it normally and then just show it off in RTX at the end, then fix the lighting and show it off again. Looking good.

[@m2lansky]

Hello sir! Nic content this farm is awesome, i need to confess that i got jealous about the sort system.

[@beandaddy720]

I'm playing in 1.19 and don't know if it works still. I'm seeing other people saying it works in 1.18 but I don't see anyone who's tried it recently. I just built all of the pillars and there are still guardians everywhere so I don't know if I did something wrong or if it doesn't work anymore Edit: never mind, just switch your game to peaceful then back to your difficulty and they'll all despawn. For some reason flying away and even going through the nether to another part of your world didn't despawn them.

[@Turner_Takeover]

do you know if you can drain the outside of the monument and still have it work?

[@beandaddy720]

@@Turner_Takeover I haven't yet so idk. I'd say probably because they spawn in water but you'd have to light up the ocean floor so other mobs don't spawn

[@CatDaddyJeff]

Liked for the awesome design, subbed for the wandering trader murder.

[@seanbrady8670]

You should add drip stone at the bottom so they don’t have to fall as far

[@migjordanpayawal7856]

A single pointed dripstone (the tiny one) kills the guardians at lower vertical distances AND allows items to pass through. Then you can make ice + water streams for the items. Thanks for this suggestion.

[@boxingkanga8352]

Oooh! Now this has a lot of potential. No ticking and the sorter is the only redstone you need.

[@migjordanpayawal7856]

@@boxingkanga8352 Did a bit of testing, and there is some loss with the single dripstone. Sometimes the drops land on top of it and don't get swept by the current. Instead, use a two-tall dripstone that is waterlogged. Ice is on the level of the bottom dripstone. Drops don't get stuck. Cheers.

[@briand7157]

@@migjordanpayawal7856 so from top to bottom: * dripstone (no water) * dripstone (waterlogged) * ice Or is the top one water logged too?

[@POKEXJ]

Where are you suppose to afk? I got sim4 and they deshawn

[@benjaminlenert8768]

Prowl, i love your idea!! Genius! Could i collect the guardians low to the floor via water streams or would the water streams themselves mess with the spawning?

[@isabellayoung3129]

In 1.18 we do still get water-logged and not water-logged caves. The ones I have under my monument are massive. Edit: I'm decorating my tubes to look like tridents. They look good designed at a 45 angle

[@jaram6049]

My apologies, a bit confused. Are the caves waterlogged in 1.18 or not?

[@ianbrewster6167]

I love the simplicity of this farm. However, as far as speed and amount of items (for overworld based farm), a trident killer at each spawn spot is more efficient. But it’s also way more expensive, so there’s a trade off.

[@Prowl8413]

25 trident killers would cause a ton of lag

[@ianbrewster6167]

@@Prowl8413 that’s true. For a server that would cause a lot of lag. That’s why your farm is so good :) It’s efficient, really easy to build, and server friendly

[@NicholasAEvans]

Agreed. Now that I've seen prowl's drop-kill approach, I'll probably start with that in any new world, and then upgrade one spawn spot at a time to use trident killers. I built my first drowned farm just so I could finish all of the spawn spots in my first guardian farm!

[@NicholasAEvans]

@@Prowl8413 if you use a simple tk design, there's very little lag. You can get by with a single piston, a torch and a repeater and still kill most guardians in 22 game ticks. I use two pistons per spot and it's fine on realms or my old android phone or Nintendo switch or ps3. The lag comes from not collecting (or burning) the XP orbs! That will get *very* laggy.

[@Prowl8413]

In 1 overnight AFK drop killing you're likely to get around 25 double chests of shards. So it's not really needed for the drops. Furnace xp or even gold farm is much quicker and easier xp so don't really need the XP either.

[@BirgerLanduyt]

great tutorial, it still works in 1.18. Had some problems with spawns not working Took me al while before i noticed that there where guardians spawning inside the monument that i only partially dried out

[@gracynbtw4435]

So before building the whole thing you have to drain the inside

[@BirgerLanduyt]

@@gracynbtw4435 or bring the pillares/column preventing the spawning also inside the monument

[@gracynbtw4435]

@@BirgerLanduyt yea I did quardians are still spawning and I tripled checked but hopefully once it’s finished it works

[@gracynbtw4435]

@@BirgerLanduyt there’s a cave quite far down should I light it up will it mess up anything

[@BirgerLanduyt]

@@gracynbtw4435 I would not hurt lighting it up. But should work without it. Did you check under the ocean monument?

[@UltraEvin]

Can I tear down the temple after creating the farm?

[@pathanaadilpathanaadil9098]

Nice work you got a subscriber 😄

[@shodcraft5683]

Where is the livestream of running the hopper items up through the bottom of the monument? I just placed all the hoppers underneath and was looking to do that next. Thanks :)

[@kishaangopalakrishnan9589]

does the farm still work in 1.19?

[@cybervirus8078]

I'm sorry if you said but what are the rates?

[@nikitamotov9690]

I have 2 questions 1 in what areas you need to build it and how to make the same warehouse inside

[@gracynbtw4435]

Wdym what areas and just hollow the inside and set up and auto sleeted storage

[@d4r4butler74]

Love the Farm. But how did you actually find the Treasure Chest within a few block??? Mine are always far down or missing in action. Those Trader Llamas never despawn (they have persistence by design, in the Json files) so killing them quick is good or else you will soon have the 200 mobs Bedrock allows all be Trader Llamas.

[@d4r4butler74]

@@RaythMinecraft No, I have never had that experience. They just do not despawn, even when the Trader does, and I know he despawns because he shows up in places that are safe. Of course he will also show up in places that he has no business being, like on top of a Sky Block Mob Farm that has been Slabbed.

[@gavinwoodruff7329]

Which RTX pack were you using?

[@Meme-fl3mk]

Does anyone know if this still works as of 1.19? Also I know it doesn’t increase rates, but will it still work if the whole monument is drained and destroyed?

[@raiderbub81]

Built it facing the wrong direction 🥺. Gonna tear it down and try again today. Gonna use sand though this time as taking the wool out of the columns is taking FOREVER!!

[@peterstrong772]

What y level is your afk spot? I'm guessing about y level 84 above the central spawn spot

[@mythologicalnomad6520]

He said 25 blocks down so that would be 35

[@MrZachieChan]

I had a single tube trident killer for my guardian farm up in the sky but I liked the idea of having everything come into the monument and sorting it all there and creating a new interior...drained the whole thing outside and in set up one tube, all others blocked other than my current tube of them going to the sky, and nothings coming out of the spawn tube I have going into the monument. Would this just be from other mob spawns in caves and such around me or am I not doing something right? Thanks

[@JayCubTruth]

Awesome!

[@steveweers6565]

Looks exactly like the farm I built about 9 months ago in my personal world. Glad to see someone else do it.

[@STANDRDUSER]

Is this working in 1.18? I’m really anxious on getting the Positive X and Z axis correctly place.

[@AxeJC]

Definitely making this farm much easier than doing redstone

[@Amanchoo123]

I once drained the inside of an ocean monument and found out that mobs can spawn inside it in BE. In JE nothing will spawn inside, so you don't even need to light it up if you drain the water.

[@FredBearcat]

Hello :D. Vert simply, tranks for this ;-)

[@borutohasnodecknarutonextg2779]

For the people saying it work for 1.19 it does work

[@ibrahimalmannaa551]

Í tried building it but it is not working

[@borutohasnodecknarutonextg2779]

@@ibrahimalmannaa551 because you build in peaceful

[@ibrahimalmannaa551]

@@borutohasnodecknarutonextg2779 can I fix it though?

[@borutohasnodecknarutonextg2779]

@@ibrahimalmannaa551 make pecefull mode to hard or normal But hard makes the Fram better

[@haeleyhoskie6662]

thanks i hope this still works for 1.18 😁

[@ryanclark2743]

Buttons are no longer recognized as blocks, what now?

[@clintdmellow6235]

Your conduit is lacking the horizontal ring which will make it a full conduit

[@orintrost8611]

best guardian farm on the market!!

[@Prowl8413]

Thanks!

[@RandyPrimus]

The graphic @4:04 is incorrect on east and west, if North is at the top.

[@abujaser81]

I dont unerstand

[@benbonsall1344]

I built this farm in 1.18, drained the interior of the monument and it worked incredibly fast. I then drained the exterior of the monument and noticed that the spawn rates dropped significantly. Are there any changes I need to make other than spawn proofing the entire area with slabs? I think slimes are taking up the mob cap maybe but any information would be helpful..

[@AndreaVillaroman]

Same thing happened to me! Did you figure out the problem?

[@benbonsall1344]

Yes, all I needed to do was slab the area. just need to block off spawnable spots anywhere in the 128 block radius and the guardian rates should increase again

[@GOALRUSHREAL10]

@@benbonsall1344 hi bro so have the rates increased yet? And where do I slab, where I drained or in the monument?

[@benbonsall1344]

yes the rates have increased, i do not have any actual numbers though. my monument is not slabbed, but it is lit up entirely. slabbing it wouldnt hurt. i slabbed the entire area i drained. any spawnable block within a 128 block radius of the afk spot. i had to use slabs because mine was also a slime chunk and the slimes took up the mob cap

[@GOALRUSHREAL10]

@@benbonsall1344 You are a life saver omg!!! Looking for a guardian farm to make since I drained my monument and I hit a roadblock, nobody did one on Minecraft bedrock for a drained monument thanks again!!

[@jacobmiller710]

Didn't realize there's a different placement 10/11 blocks at first but, works great now. Only did half and I get wayyyyyy more than I need I do have one single spot the guardians are spawning outside of this though, the north 10 block pillar in the center. Makes getting in and out tricky and I didn't want the full tube there ruining the entryway.. Guess I might have to.

[@kishaangopalakrishnan9589]

Does the farm still work in 1.19?

[@jacobmiller710]

@@kishaangopalakrishnan9589 yes. I just build it. I did all the tunes except the center I think north ones (where the "walkway" is and i only hollowed half the tubrs and I get wayyyyy more than I need. It's very fast. I do however get spawn from the walkway area for some reason tho

[@kishaangopalakrishnan9589]

@@jacobmiller710 is it possible for you to add me so I can see the farms and its rates?

[@robertvalencia4478]

Super random and very long after but if I was draining a temple could I just keep the water in the pillers but drain all around ?

[@Aggrosk8]

Are you toggling RTX on and off while still in the world? If so how is this possible? I would love to know.

[@ILootStandingStill]

I’m making a giant 200x200 circle down to bedrock in the ocean with an ocean monument in the center. I’ve already drained all the water from the ocean, I could still make this farm with no problems right? The only water that’s relevant is in the tubes for the guardians to spawn in?

[@_z.instinct_4189]

If youve done it and it works, can you update?

[@ILootStandingStill]

@@_z.instinct_4189 it works, took me a while to figure it out but yea it works just fine.

[@benbonsall1344]

@@ILootStandingStill did you spawn proof the entire exterior of the monument within the drained area? I just drained mine and he spawn rates dropped significantly so im trying to figure out what I need to do now

[@XS_Nerd]

@prowl8413 would it be possible to do the glass tubes as a 2x2 my ocd kinda won't lemme build it

[@Amanchoo123]

The beacon seems redundant. The conduit power gives you haste in JE and haste 2 in BE.

[@Prowl8413]

Cool fact and parity difference!

[@Turner_Takeover]

not that it needs increased rates but what if I drained the ocean around the monument would that affect this in any way?

[@nanohax3]

I want to make this farm but my base area is all ice and all 3 ocean monuments is under ice does it still work? Or will it be very bad because of mob spawn on ice

[@dannieoh8112]

Any tips on how to find two monuments next to each other? I found one and it was 5000 blocks away from my spawn.

[@hippyhappyhippo]

Using two monuments wouldn't up the spawn rate. He covered the top block of the spawning spaces to turn the Guardians into cave spawns, meaning that he can have 8 guardians in the cave mob cap which is not taken up by drowned, because they are included in the overworld mob cap. If you want to up the spawn rate, your afk spot should be above your farm, the distance depends on your simulation distance (I think...). Personally I scaffolded up 30 blocks and then kept checking and climbing further until I was seeing spawns from all the spawn points.

[@Ryscnt]

will this work if I don't use the free fall to kill guardians instead use bubble columns and have a magma killer on top?

[@Darklord-qm7jm]

Are you going to do a world download for this world at the end of the season

[@fredarmstrong6418]

Tried to build this farm this week in 1.18.20 with a few modifications, everything I tried resulted in flying (literally flying in mid-air) guardians, so I went back to following your instructions to the letter, and still having the same problem. I know this has been a bug that has been around since 2018, (MCPE-33641) but how did you overcome it?

[@tomdalton4016]

I thought guardians were structure spawns neither surface or cave spawns. But if it’s a bit of both then should you make half of spots surface spawns

[@IrishBoy317]

Does this work with a completely drained monument?

[@Andrea79_]

This farm work in 1.18?

[@briankuester1308]

Can you drain the water to make it faster?

[@matthewmcclintock9483]

I'm having trouble with the farm guardians aren't spawning at all im on a realm and it's weird ill catch one spawning outside of the tube very rarely

[@JasonTaylor-po5xc]

I like this farm. Building a proper Guardian farm is so labor intensive that it never gets done or it is pretty late game. This design seems like a good in between since I can see how this can be upgraded later to replace the chutes with trident killers and water streams for xp and items. Yeah, the rates might decrease but should be made up with Looting 3.

[@ceciliekirstinenielsen2423]

Can you do this after you’ve emptied a monument from water?

[@iLLSniper]

Wasn’t able to do the 1 wide air pocket like he has but I did 4 wide cube with magma blocks to kill the guardians and it works great

[@gulfcoastreefer6571]

Do all 24 locations work on simulation distance 4 ? Where should I afk at on a realm for the highest efficiency?

[@rayansawly3297]

To prevent guardians from despawning while falling through the tubes, the afk spot must not be in sky but inside the monument (mainly at the center). On stimulation distance 4, you would not be able able to cover all locations (maybe just the 9 locations around the center one).

[@gamingwithkrishna9340]

So how much sim distance you recommend

[@bushranasreen8292]

How much does it give per hour

[@gryffongaming2847]

Holy hopper lag having all those drop chutes connected via hopper.

[@Prowl8413]

With nothing else in the area it's fine. I have 5x this at my main storage system area.

[@playmusic8056]

You could always use water to move it along if you like (hopper to dropper, drop into water streams and bubble columns).

[@gryffongaming2847]

@@Prowl8413 Don't know if it still works as I haven't tried it in 1.17 but you used to be able to water log chests. Mobs would still take damage when falling on them and items would move off of them. Would make it so you could just water stream everything into the sorters and minimize hopper lag. Just a thought Incase someone wanted to make their base inside the temple.

[@Sheajosphferry]

Hey do you know how many blocks you need

[@Vex-Lex]

Does it still work on 1.18???

[@evanmnbishop]

I dont understand how Ive copied *exactly* what you’ve done to block all the spawns, yet they’re still spawning even if I fly away and come back

[@TyranitarTy]

If I already drained a temple, will this still work?

[@Domarnett]

I’m thinking drop them slightly less to leave them half a heart and have 25 trident killers… wouldn’t be good for realms, but my solo world could probably handle it…

[@orintrost8611]

if u use the trapdoor trident killers you will be fine, they don´t cause as much lag.. or u transport the guardians to one central area via minecarts(activator rails to get them out of carts)

[@raybordier4798]

Is there an optimal spot to stand for this farm?

[@Turner_Takeover]

25 blocks below the "green wool" in this case

[@bragify8382]

is there a way to make it so you get the xp?

[@hippyhappyhippo]

Not if you're just killing them using fall damage. If you want to kill them with a trident killer, or multiple trident killers then it would take more time and keep the mob cap filled longer reducing the rates for the farm. There are other farms that will give you the XP but they are totally different from this.

[@NatiionEU]

How have you done it so you can see underwater on Bedrock? Kinda confused

[@rjbestm]

What about the rate of this farm ❤️

[@DavidPetty1]

I give it 3 days before JC plays copies this design and uploads it with his monotone counting.

[@timariugabriel6175]

Well..it will happen sooner or later

[@Prowl8413]

Let me know if it happens.

[@Bitsinator]

he actually already has one.

[@rudianto2903]

No, he will not. He will only copy a farm with the simplest design. This design is not as simple as his because of the glass tubes and the AFK Spot.

[@DavidPetty1]

@@rudianto2903 actually you're probably right lol.