Eat It Or Yeet It - Music Festival Food!

[@shelbyhyoung]

Some of this food was truly vile.... and I loved every second of it 🤢😂 Thanks for having me frennnnns!!!

[@mazingtiger804]

I looked fun

[@mareneaufrance5096]

I hope you'll be on more often!

[@NateyCat]

You killed it!! Super fun!

[@Managuan]

You were a great guess for that show, I loved your dedication.

[@LunarHuldra]

Hope to see you again at this ! :D

[@EOtekk]

Noah: Literally melts his tongue off and dies. Shane: "Yes, this is sour".

[@ariqsyafwan4987]

Coming from Shayne, then that cookie probably taste like a battery acid

[@christianwise637]

A typical reaction from Shayne "grave mouth" Topp

[@laurenlong4321]

This is the best comment!

[@Evar0se]

i bet if shayne put the entire cookie face down on his tongue like noah the acid would finally affect him

[@whenitsover3479]

did…. you not see the difference in their bites??? did NONE of you remember that in the replies either??

[@Hase0XVX]

Shayne IMMEDIATELY knew what was gonna happen and got the bucket for Noah.

[@theredoakshieldvirus5791]

Ya if you watch the smosh tour of the new place you see garett has already made it.

[@Emily-tv1iz]

You can see the moment it clicked too. He glanced at Garrett as he goes "wow!" and then DIVES for the bucket.

[@crashgaming01]

Garrett really only stopped Noah so Shayne wouldn’t get the MA big bite

[@hunterbrown2001]

The cycle has been broken 😂

[@bricks_mortar]

Garret found a way to beat gravemouth

[@SzandorAdinsx]

He really got 20 dollars to do something he was probably gonna do anyway.

[@TheLoserface45]

Garrett was DONE

[@okaton6559]

Malic Acid doesn't affect shayne much so probably why

[@matthewmireles3498]

Courtney frustratingly shouting “f**k” uncensored while looking for the yeet bucket made me laugh more than poor Keith

[@brownie_tea3214]

Where😕

[@moren321]

That’s my favourite part about eat it or yeet it videos, Courtney always flustered and frantic when someone needs the bucket lol

[@matthewmireles3498]

@@brownie_tea3214 After Keith tries the sauce a second time around 7:30

[@T2TheDart]

FACK

[@MrBlakeD82]

@@matthewmireles3498 Okay, I watched from 7:00 to 9:45 again and I'm just not hearing it. Did they go back and edit the video? EDIT: Nevermind, finally heard it.

[@zevo9314]

the pure confidence of noah eating that cookie was the best

[@garrettpalm]

He’s one of my favorite guests because he’s like a goldfish!

[@amandacrawford7340]

Followed by the IMMEDIATE regret😆

[@cliffs7315]

My chest hurts from how much i laughed at his instant regret 😭

[@terryberrycherry]

Didn’t know I needed Coachella Garrett, but here we are, thank you.

[@Braithekaikiller]

what you talking about? thats just regular garrett

[@alexisscholtes1206]

Garrett should keep the flower crown year round tbh

[@mideon84]

BOOMER!

[@Bongosaurus_0]

His outfit is looking snazzy

[@Bongosaurus_0]

He looks kinda like a hippy mum

[@Sarah04527]

I have immediate respect for Shelby saying “Mick mouse” in reference to New Girl

[@janaloff]

yaaaaasssss

[@nunyabinnis6417]

Mick maus mick maus!

[@matthewpadilla6905]

Haha I like how Garrett had to hold Noah just so that Shane didn't get the malic acid again 🤣 😅 😂

[@Cripplified]

Honestly given the show's history with malic acid Noah really should've seen that coming when there's a big bite cookie covered in powder.

[@marianaamor6319]

@@Cripplified the powder on top was cinnamon. I think he baked the cookie with malic acid

[@disneydork100]

And he got 20$ out of it!

[@zadzart7544]

For further context, Shelby is one of Shayne's oldest friends. She was in his graduation video.

[@supercalime]

I knew I recognized her!

[@lepanzon]

Wasn’t she also in shane’s funeral?

[@love2manythings]

You can tell their close bc she didn't eat from the other side of that sandwich lmao 😂

[@ldarkllrevanl181]

@@lepanzon no

[@ariqsyafwan4987]

@@lepanzon no she's not, there's no guest star on that Shayne's funeral video

[@kayleehog]

Garret tackling Noah so Shane wouldn’t get the malic acid again is peak job performance. Dedication to his craft. 😂

[@LMR23]

Shelby was a fun guest. Hopefully she comes back more.

[@tickledtoffee]

Yeah, she was awesome! I hope she’ll be back

[@lexmcdufflepants4332]

I would love to see her again!

[@justine11012]

Love her energy with the rest of the cast

[@panic_to_not_try5884]

Fun fact: She played the pink haired girl from Lazy Town.

[@lexmcdufflepants4332]

@@panic_to_not_try5884 woah!! That's crazy

[@JohnWilliams-cr2sz]

Can we have Shelby on every Eat or Yeet It going forward? Because she is just a delight.

[@vickyofficialunicorn3912]

No

[@JohnWilliams-cr2sz]

@@vickyofficialunicorn3912 Sad.

[@LoungingPotato]

@@vickyofficialunicorn3912 I must have missed the announcement that Vicky OfficialUnicorn now owns Smosh

[@WhamBamThanksSam]

@@LoungingPotato haven’t you heard Ian stepped down as CEO it’s Vicky now

[@Verylengthyapple]

@@LoungingPotato realistically, it would simply become boring to have the same guest on forever

[@WiscoDbo]

Garret coming in for the "No Malic acid for Shane" save by pushing noah under the sour bus.

[@Jack-SecITGuy]

I'd love to see a Eat it or Yeet it cross over with TNTL . Whoever fails to get a laugh, must eat. Whoever is on the stool must eat if they laugh at everything total. Whoever gets the laugh is safe. Each round, the item is revealed, and then the comedy round happens. Food can be good or bad, the group has to decide when to use their best jokes.

[@jayrose2933]

That’s a good idea! Would definitely raise the stakes. Like TNTL hard mode, but with punishments! :)

[@maniquizmiguel6099]

So like a combo of smosh Games and pit. Wonderful idea

[@D0nut42]

Yes! Fantastic idea!

[@stephanieann6622]

Agreed

[@stacyinsane]

i suggested this on a different video not that long ago

[@AdamMan187]

"DesertMouth" Damien and "GraveMouth" Shayne, such a delightful combo

[@somethingsomething479]

Hear me out: Easy Bake Oven Eat it or Yeet it. Half the items are genuine easy bake desserts and the other half are garrett's vile creations made to look genuine.

[@theoutsiderjess1869]

Sounds like torture either way 😂

[@penelocent]

Smosh should see this!

[@camppresentmoment]

YESSSS!!!

[@CecilieSHoejberg]

Shayne saying "I've never heard of The Grateful Dead" is a fun little Goldbergs easter egg lol

[@devilmikey00]

When even Shayne has to note that it's sour, that must have been a nightmare for everyone else.

[@bricks_mortar]

The moment Garret blocked Noah from the bell, my spidey sense was tingling about the last bite lol

[@LMR23]

Here’s and idea for a future Eat It or Yeet It: Musical Chairs EIOYI - Played like regular musical chairs, the loser who doesn’t get a chair gets that rounds dish and the overall winner gets what ever the big bite is despite being good or bad. I’ve suggested this before, but it seems like it could be fun.

[@mariamazzioli2815]

omg i love that idea, i hope they do it

[@skullgamer7493]

And they should play different smosh songs as they play lol

[@lexitabor4094]

Wait this is so good

[@xerxesmontes9828]

Hope they see it. And the idea above that they use different smosh songs.

[@Shadowlrd265]

Garrett out here holding Noah back to make sure shayne wasnt the one to get the Malic Acid cookie is so funny to me

[@maniquizmiguel6099]

The part when Noah shouted "Shelby your gonna do it!. Made me burst into laughter. Lol😂

[@emz2969]

ITS FINE ITS GOOD

[@kimberlymarie3775]

Garrett is feeling his Coachella fantasy in the back and I LOVE it

[@bilbofaggin5]

He looks like someone's rich auntie and I'm here for it

[@kimberlymarie3775]

@@bilbofaggin5 oh my gosh YES!!!

[@TomBydand]

we love when shelby hangs with the smosh buds. this was fun.

[@yaboicolleen]

I love the offscreen "BOOMER!" at Garrett when he mentioned Grateful Dead

[@mdycus3]

I love how Shayne was reaching for the bucket almost immediately for Noah because he knew

[@ariqsyafwan4987]

I think when Garrett restrained Noah so Shayne could get the sandwich is a dead giveaway for Shayne that the last bite is a malic acid

[@mdycus3]

@@ariqsyafwan4987 yeah on the twitch VOD Garrett accidentally restrained Shayne at the sandwich part and they had to redo it where he restrained Noah lol

[@appleschloss]

Keith has just fully embraced the cheatin at this point lolol he's like "idc im gonna reach anyway cause no one gonna stop me"

[@psyber6469]

They can easily bring back the damn wheel if they're going to keep Keith. They just seem to believe that it's "funny content." It fucking is not.

[@appleschloss]

@@psyber6469 yeah it gets to me a bit too xD

[@jamescarlislegenavia26]

I actually skip Keith's parts cuz he yeets EVERYTHING anyway

[@footsi35]

Garrett's evil laughing as Noah is absolutely dying 😭 Also that cookie must've been PACKED with malic acid because shayne went "yeah, this is sour." when he usually has zero taste at all for malic acid.

[@cheesegavioli]

Shelby's energy was so perfect for this! She really melded well with the cast.

[@SleepyKerboro]

"maybe I'll skip this one" "NO ITS REALLY GOOD!!" Had me crryyiiing

[@bgb0072]

Thank you Noah for providing the actual response we've all been waiting for (slash wanting) since this show started! And thank you Garrett for finally creating the creation we've all hoped for to make this moment finally happen!

[@maltesefalcon85]

garret stopping shayne from getting the malic acid 😂"you wont defeat me this time grave mouth"

[@Svakhen]

1.5 Seconds after he put his favorite cookie in his mouth - the worst moment in Noahs life and I can't be happier we got to see this. So many tears of joy have been shed.

[@Molly_inthemountains]

They may have already done this but I think an episode where they don’t get to see the food before they ding the bell would be really entertaining 😂 have Courtney say one of the good ingredients and they have to decide off of just that lol

[@Masqueraide]

The moment Garrett held Noah down, I was like, the next dish has Malic Acid in it doesn't it... But I could NOT predict Noah's reaction XD

[@thefissers194]

I’d love to see Shelby in more stuff. With how quick on the draw she was in this video I bet she’d kill on TNTL

[@Ramonerdna]

16:12 the pure joy and excitement in Noah's eyes compared to the unhinged chaos that happened after is absolutely one of my favourite Eat it Or Yeet it Moments

[@4Revan27]

I so knew that the big bite is going to have malic acid in it when Garrett restrained Noah, so that Shane wouldn't get it 😂

[@EmyN]

10:42 “It’s weird” Garret: “thank you” 😂

[@alexhammett3292]

I like how shayne already knew it was malic acid when Garrett said " Wow thats great" and immediately gave Noah the bucket. 🤣

[@jackt4648]

the pure CONFIDENCE in Noah's big bite instantly devolving into chaos... Grade A content right there

[@EnycmaPie]

Everyone else: Dying from malic acid. Shayne: Yea, that's pretty sour.

[@UnicornzRreal92]

Shayne Damien and Garrett are my favorite Smosh people❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@georginalithco7461]

Shaynes "no" when Shelby asked if anyone wanted to try her dish 😂 the Aunt Carolyn stank face and hand killed me

[@caffeineandmemes]

Shelby seems like the sweetest person and her chemistry with everyone else at the table this great! I love it when guests are pumped to be there. Also everyone in their festival sparkles and flower crowns is so cute

[@FatBabyToodles]

😂😂😂 everyone dressed up... Shayne just looks like Shayne 😂😂😂❤❤

[@tylerb5764]

I knew immediately why noah was restrained, I just went like "yup, malic acid is on the big bite"

[@Ghv5t]

Damien literally went through the 5 stages of grief with his bite

[@simplefishinguy6816]

I knew after Garrett held Noah back that it was going to be malic acid for the big bite. Noah's face literally had me roll out my chair even though I knew it was coming lol

[@abhimanyuroy8371]

It's so nice to see a guest who actually likes the show

[@mikhael8151]

Garretts Coachella fit for this video was so good! I loved how everyone chose to "dress up," they look radiant.

[@LilKitLen]

They should do some popin cookin' !!! Being all powders there's a lot of room for tomfoolery, I'd love to see either an individual video for it or the ready-made ones on eat it or yeet it.

[@colonelsanders4937]

Someone handcuff Keith’s hand to the table that releases on the countdown of 3 please 💀 poor shayne has been so bummed about him hovering over the bell before and it happened again :(

[@madgenus]

I have to say, i enjoy Keith getting bad things every time he reaches that cheaty lil dang hand over the table before he should

[@ryanng777]

Facts

[@christianwise637]

Cheaters never prosper

[@needyverse]

When Garrett grabbed Noah, I knew the final dish must involve malic acid 😂 He did NOT want Shayne eating the final dish and not reacting to malic acid for the millionth time

[@SupremeLeaderKimJong-un]

Shelby Young, Tom Kenny, Grey DeLisle, and Dee Bradley Baker... *the four horsemen of the voicepocalypse* Love how Shelby predicted that there'd be a malic acid one in this 💀

[@ariqsyafwan4987]

How could you forget Tara Strong, Frank Welker and Peter Cullen when talking about legendary VA??

[@TastyTempura]

I love Courtney's entire fit this episode, so good. Love the cute punk combo.

[@MMassey2008]

We need an episode titled eat it or Keith it, and it's just every food Keith has yeeted.

[@Kirsikkalyhty]

Ok, that was one of the best reactions in this series at the end :D

[@shurpples23]

OMG SHELBY!! I was so excited when I saw the notification so I’m glad y’all had her as a guest :D

[@distracula5933]

How did shelby harness damien and Shane's power so well, all we needed was an "Ooooooopppsss"

[@hernameispekka_Rebecca]

I know you probably know by now already but Shelby has been one of Shaynes closest friends for like half his life. They've known each other since they were teens.

[@UhDewSea]

Such a fan of Shelby for her work. She's one of the most beautifully talented people in the industry for sure

[@jonathandoherty9082]

Noah's reaction was the best I've ever seen on this show.

[@CoinMatze]

omg Damien's reaction at Keith's "salty in the back of my throat" 😂 Love you, Damien!

[@matthewcollins7498]

3:28 the sneaky bastard got me

[@evoryjhunmayapit2057]

Garrett wanted to see a genuine reaction to the big bite because Shane's taste buds are dead😂😂

[@User24x]

12:13 It was actually "revealed" on the twitch stream of this eat it or yeet it that Shayne gets the malic acid one so often that at some point they started to reshoot it whenever he gets it so that he doesn't get the malic acid one. Source: 03/25/2022 Twitch Stream

[@emilioherrera6345]

The pure chaos with the malic acid cookie was amazing 😂

[@daniell.8341]

Damien "Desertmouth" Haas is back with the newest Dryest Thing He's Ever Put In His Mouth!

[@G.Lonnie]

New Driest thing I’ve ever put in my mouth just dropped

[@chefernandez563]

shelby fit into the cast so perfectly

[@alawnawatson5548]

Dude I had an awful day at work and my drink spilled in my car and I was upset and once I saw the Eat it or yeet it episode it made feel better, but once I saw Noah's reaction to the big bite that really made my day. Thanks for making another entertaining episode of eat it or yeet it

[@hfzeg]

Damien and Shelby: *Saying words at the same time* Shayne: That should be me 3:00

[@thatonespoon_]

Noah just simultaneously gave us the best eat and the best yeet...the absolute DEDICATION

[@Tinycarlos20]

Nunca me había reído tanto en un "eat it or yeet it" 😂😂😂😂 The Big bite and the reaction of Noah was the most hilarious thing on the video for me 😂

[@demaunix2723]

Damien: If you laugh you're immature, anise. Courtney & Noah: 🤣🤣🤣

[@nytemarequeen2365]

Garrett grabbing Noah like,"NO! You will NOT let Shayne ruin another sour dish for me!" lmfao

[@SaintBigfoot]

The absolute chaos after Noah put that devil cookie in his mouth is anazing

[@yahgirlsarah]

as soon as garrett held noah back i knew the big bite must involve malic acid 😂😂😂

[@angel-rs1cj]

you guys should do another cast vs. crew eat it or yeet it!

[@YourWhoAgain1]

Shelby’s vibe is great for the show. HIRE HER!!

[@EmyN]

12:33 “you can have this one” the psychological games begin 😂

[@Rusty2FTW]

Noah's reaction after he ate the acid cookie was insane!! Noah would blend well at the Open Air Wacken Fest (Metal Festival in Germany)

[@noneofyourbusiness7055]

Whoa, Noah's Yosemite Sam impression was dead on! 16:44

[@jenntegt]

They need to stop thr countdown to bell if someone cheats *cough* Keith. No false starts.

[@psyber6469]

If Keith is in it, there needs to be the wheel. Even then, he'd find some way to cheat, though.

[@WonderUne]

Noah freak out was so funny 😂 it made me cry 😂😂😂

[@dakotacavnar9776]

Im down for Shelby being part of the cast! Ian, Lisa make it happen!

[@twistedthrills]

As soon as I saw the cheese sandwich, I knew this was shade at Frye Fest and had to contain my laughter to not wake up my neighbors!

[@Brickheadunofficial]

Please have Shelby back! She’s amazing!

[@mateocertain4592]

i love how damien and shelby are both just so chill

[@kittyphyrie2664]

Garrett stopped Noah from getting the sandwich one so we would actually have a full on reaction to malic acid cause Shayne has grave mouth to it 😂😂😂😂😂

[@theoutsiderjess1869]

He's like we need a normal reaction to malic acid

[@kittyphyrie2664]

@@theoutsiderjess1869 definitely we need someone to just go insane from it not just a smile and saying "its good" 😂😂

[@Emily-tv1iz]

16:43 you can see Shayne internally do the math of "Garrett made sure I didn't get the big bite + he's really excited by Noah shoving the whole cookie in his mouth = *OH GOD MALIC ACID GET THE BUCKET!!!"*

[@danielgarcia4898]

Now we see why Garrett stopped Shane from getting the big bite 🤣

[@EStramel09]

Shelby was so much fun in this video! She vibes with the group really well. You should totally have her back!

[@bearium91]

Noah's reaction was hands down the BEST ever on it a EIOYI. 🤣

[@Yeetmiester]

16:42 Garrett lmfao “Woooow, that’s great!” 💀😭

[@jessicalee989]

The fact they didn’t know the last one would be malic acid the moment Garrett held Noah back proves they still have too much trust in him. 😂

[@ricardocristobal5222]

The reaction at the end. Priceless 🤣🤣🤣 Garrett really preventing shane on getting the malic acid again 🤣🤣🤣

[@derekmitchell9469]

Geez, someone needs to duct tape Keith's hands to the table until the countdown is done. Someone stop the hover king.

[@misterkayy]

2:31 lmao noah's always in awe of Garrett's "cooking" skills since the peanut butter banana blew his mind