Is New York Pizza REALLY The Best? (Eat It Or Yeet It)

[@Mattriarc]

The mental breakdown of Damien feeling like he's been gaslit by Garret over it not tasting like chicken feels like such a Smosh main channel idea but was actually real 😂

[@LMR23]

Tank was a fun guest. He genuinely seemed like he was having a fun time.

[@harryallsopp9136]

I was not prepared for the hand transplant line

[@pucca7113]

I haven’t seen Garrett this emotional about eat or yeet it since the last time he gave Shayne malic acid 😂

[@dizzysic66]

When Garrett finally snaps and poisons everyone at the table.. he will be screaming at Damien's face while it turns blue like his hair.. "IT'S CHICKEN, DAMIEN!!!"

[@wayababaya]

lol

[@Grace-px2gg]

@@dizzysic66 of mmm. Milk mniojii

[@dizzysic66]

@@Grace-px2gg I wish I understood 💀

[@Meepers_the_Great]

Ahahaha he’s so mad “That’s CHICKEN, DAMIEN!!!!”

[@lichtheimer]

The little "oh" from Tank after smelling the cookie just fully acknowledged Kimmy's pain and his sympathy.

[@rachellizzie889]

Tank is just the sweetest guy. The way he explained Garrett's dish probably made his day.

[@TeeComedian]

Given how last time went, I have mad respect to Shayne for coming back this episode!

[@Fierywaffleman]

his strategy changed though. I've rarely seen him go first, he may have become one of the "get it out of the way" players after that whole experience

[@braidij7598]

What happened last time? I cant remember

[@TheGreatPanda2311]

@@braidij7598 he ate a dick

[@TeeComedian]

@@braidij7598 he was served bull penis, and was told mid chew.

[@maskedpriest913]

@@braidij7598 he ate a dick

[@OllieOxyn]

The chicken being so badly cooked that Damien thought it wasn't meat is hilarious to me for some reason

[@harryhealey4298]

And Garrett being defensive even though everyone told him he way overcooked it. That’s what made it even better for me.

[@notsanni]

Shayne quietly saying "This tastes like the Truman Show" killed me

[@LMR23]

I’m going to suggest a Musical Chairs EIOYI yet again, because why not. Musical Chairs EIOYI- played like regular musical chairs, the loser who doesn’t get a chair gets that rounds dish, and the overall winner gets whatever the Big Bite is despite being good or bad. Could be fun, could be a big mistake. Nobody knows and there’s only one way to find out!

[@curtissonofaries3147]

How bout a roulet version where they play and the winners eat a good version of what it is and the loser eats a bad one

[@gracefulbarbie]

YES YES YES PLEASE

[@translivesmatter9063]

@@curtissonofaries3147 I think they have done that before.

[@isabellaamo7928]

@@curtissonofaries3147 they did that, it's one of my favorite eat it or yeet it's

[@kv7254]

love this so much!

[@kevindolan9]

Damien has the best luck on this show Period. Like I think he’s only gotten 2-3 really bad things being the super spicy jello and the Wasabi Poptart being the most notable ones.

[@HexGirl420]

The burrito with toothpaste too

[@taramaheshwari4491]

Or that he has better tolerance than others? He usually enjoys a wide range of food

[@kevindolan9]

@@taramaheshwari4491 that’s usually the case in later episodes like the Trivia Ramen he said was Vile and he still went to town on it. So it has to be very rancid in order for Damien to show complete dissatisfaction.

[@Morster]

“Oh, there were apples in it? No potatoes? 🤨” I love Tank’s confusion after he inhaled the salad 🤣

[@jessewinter5826]

Shayne coming back to this show after eating literal peenpeen last time is either the greatest courage or self loathing I've ever seen.

[@hamzaabbas9795]

He doesn't care about trivial stuff like that

[@EverydayKiki]

he’s so attractive in that way

[@San-xd7gr]

I feel like Tank was one of the best guests they've had. He was funny and just so sweeet! Give this chaotic show a calm vibe..

[@Comet_Coyote]

Garret honestly is so happy doing this show. Like hes just so happy everytime

[@unrealtalks7242]

I feel like they keep having bigger guys on as guests just to make shayne feel smaller. we’ve had josh, shane, and now tank 😂😂

[@everychannel1025]

Don't forget Jujimufu

[@kaitlynrain899]

The transition lately from smacking the bell as fast as possible to waiting for absolutely anyone else to hit it then slowly ringing it is so funny to me

[@tessmarino5710]

ian’s “bro…” was so out of pocket for him and the way he said it made me laugh so hard

[@donjay710]

My dad actually made General Tso's Pizza once, served it along side some Ramen noodles and other American Asian foodstuffs, and now I'm a lifelong fan. It was so incredibly satisfying to find the Big Bite was that! It's a dynamite combo, especially with homemade pizza crust! Serve with broccoli florets and bell peppers for the optimum delicacy!

[@goldfishtactics8813]

Every eat it or yeet it has so many twists and turns and I already know it’s about to be crazy

[@UndeadxPenguins]

15:48 Shayne's uncensored F-Bomb genuinely made me laugh.

[@snaxchn]

Eat It or Yeet It but delicacies of different countries, it can be exotic or not. I want to see them eat balut, fried tarantula, century egg, halo-halo, biryani, etc.

[@DARKISANDY]

Smosh already had Fried Tarantula and Century Egg.

[@awhellyeah12]

They did all of these!

[@dr.fritzknobel1806]

I wanted to say that Kimmy was lucky Damien wasn't doing his trademark smack on the bell, but her cookie stopped me from calling her lucky. ;-)

[@ViciousCat]

The thing Kimmy had is something nearly every German bakery has. We call it “Amerikaner” which just means “Americans” in German. It is very delicious cause normally it’s chocolate and icing 🥹🖤

[@aepceallach]

I absolutely love how bad the editors are at catching swearwords. Shayne drops a whole-ass "fuck" towards the end lmao

[@gracecw]

i feel like towards the ends they just stop caring 😭 especially when spencer or rock edits

[@EverydayKiki]

I heard KZbin only really cares for the first few minutes of a video

[@Jopeymessmusic]

In reference to Shayne's comment about Garrett training turtles. "Splinter" is a significantly better nickname than "Milkbean."

[@overcomer109]

Damien "I have had so much meat in my life" Hass

[@Nat3YT]

Garrett is the only person getting younger each episode, I swear he is 🤔

[@justdrop]

After every episode, he drains the life of an intern to extend his own.

[@ariannamae6114]

People eating his bad food gives him more youth.

[@Nat3YT]

@@ariannamae6114 damn, there might be some truth in that 😂

[@Nat3YT]

@@justdrop ah yes, its all coming together now

[@matthewelliott7294]

@@Nat3YT the only way to reverse it is Eat It or Yeet It Revenge videos.

[@annabelledionisio7018]

i think that Tank has been one of the best guests on this show!!

[@Jjapanda]

Eat or Yeet: European Odyssey Garrett tries or tampers with 5 classic and iconic dishes from across Europe. Items could include anything from French Creme Brulee to Hungarian Goulash.

[@sydnie292]

so close to Smosh Under The Influence! can’t wait to see the show!

[@KameronSkye]

Man I love this series so much it always makes me laugh and its so fun seeing everyone interact with eachother and seeing the weird food combos

[@werderlebenslang4576]

Shoutout to all the german grandmas celebrating the 4th of july.

[@CaptHayfever]

The Candy Land comparison makes perfect sense with the "no talent required" slogan on the box: Candy Land is a game of predestination; after the deck is shuffled & the order of turns is decided, the outcome is already fixed, with neither skill nor luck having any further impact on the game.

[@BrandBisch]

Ian really just pulled a Damien with his dish

[@itsnotnotjonathan]

Kimmy: _"It's just really overcooked chicken...."_ Tank: _"This is cardboard."_ Yup, sounds about right.

[@cohosalmon9399]

i love the recent garett damien duo of damien describing a dish and garett being like thats wrong

[@zaydenmYT]

Tank has to be one of my favorite guests on this show so far. I hope to see Influencers in the Wild on Board AF soon!

[@MopTopMase]

Tank watching Ian eat that hotdog like a deer in headlights has SENT ME🤣🤣💀

[@albertescobedo503]

Seeing Shayne and Tank next to each other is like seeing The Rock and Kevin Hart next to each other.

[@DeathstroketheTerminator]

Amazing though that just from the taste he correctly identified the salad as being a German dish, and it's a bit old timey so it would fit that you're grandma would be making one of those

[@justdrop]

German potato salad is a style in America that uses vinegar outside of just straight up mayonnaise.

[@thebadpoet]

Waldorf salad isn’t a German dish, though. It’s distinctly American.

[@justdrop]

@@thebadpoet Beyond that, Germans don't use mayonnaise in their potato salad.

[@Jonnzon]

@@justdrop They/We do, but there are many local varieties. Generally, in northern germany, potato salad is often made with mayonnaise, in southern germany it‘s mostly without mayonnaise.

[@justdrop]

@@Jonnzon I mean you do, but it's not German potato salad if it has mayonnaise.

[@celiaargan9238]

i dont think courtney get enough praise for hosting so well!! girl you kill it!

[@kerrih6620]

Make an Eat It or Yeet It: Is It Cake Edition, where the foods are either cake or real 👀

[@cassiebradley01]

"THAT'S CHICKEN DAMIIEN!!" That needs to be on a shirt haha

[@lifenothingbutasong]

I would buy that 😂

[@ssjbears]

Whenever Courtney says "Good biiiite" I get serious fun babysitter energy

[@ashleyjohnson9651]

really brings me back to my daycare teacher days lmao

[@liliuwu4340]

Damien's joke about Garret training turtles in new York actually put me and my mom in TEARS it was so fucking funny

[@the_seabunnyboi7004]

1:30 Ian's eye staring into your soul casually.

[@crabsos]

surprised that shayne’s here after the testicle tragedy

[@Mezzy..]

What??

[@crabsos]

@@Mezzy.. in the last eat it or yeet it he ate bull testicles😂😂😂

[@hydraglyphics]

@@Mezzy.. He ate testicles on the previous episode

[@cassandracarlton400]

@@Mezzy.. the last episode. Where they made the joke about “for everyone who’s ever told Shayne to eat a dick”?

[@melthenewqueen]

@@Mezzy.. Watch the last episode

[@Seraian1]

You guys should re-introduce the wheel and modify it a bit more, so that once you spin and it lands on someone, the section of the wheel for that person grows smaller while the rest grow bigger. That way no one is safe and no one is out, since it's a shame when you guys bring guests and they are out after one tasting. Also keep the bell in and change it's use a bit. You may ring the bell while the wheel is spinning but if you do you have to eat the ENTIRE dish, if you manage to do so. You are out from the rest of the game.

[@EverydayKiki]

this is GOOD

[@matthewelliott7294]

Better yet, make it so only the Garrett section is the only one that grows larger, no matter what.

[@Bafael_Reyna]

I still think we need some Eat or Yeet Awards!

[@ginger_d_lite]

i really hope to see Tank and his game on an episode of Board AF!

[@mitchellvanderbaan4954]

I like the fact that whenever someone asks 'what's marmite' the most common answer is 'it's like vegemite' as if everyone knows what that even tastes like.

[@ballafett]

Eat it or yeet it: blind item edition. You need to the ding the bell before the food is revealed. Either before the cloche is lifted or the dish is teased through a silhouette like it’s a blind item

[@BPDon007]

It would be fun if you guys did an eat it or yeet it with Rhett and Link. Josh and Garrett could make the food together!

[@CyberEJ]

I love how Courtney just said “fucky wucky” in a video some months back, and now every once in a while we hear someone say it. It’s almost like it’s become a thing behind the scenes and we get to see it occasionally. It’s always hilarious

[@josiebruntzel3105]

tank was so funny and enjoyable. i would love to see him again

[@brycewalburn3926]

3:58 - lol he says "little more bitter" in perfect time with the drums

[@madie9640]

When I first saw Tank, I thought he was an MMA fighter or a powerlifter or something, so finding out that he's a memelord made my brain explode.

[@Malifique96]

I’m so excited for Smosh live, gonna be 3am July 1st for me but y’all bet I’m gonna wake up n get lit with y’all 😂😂

[@emilymorgan1994]

*EIOYI always coming in with the unexpected collabs?? wow*

[@AdolisYT]

I love Tank dude 😭 he seems like such a chill but fun dude. Gotta see more of him at some point, he’s dope.

[@snaxchn]

Eat It or Yeet It: Weird Pregnancy Cravings Edition

[@HunterPup13]

@Michelle Thomas my friends mom had that craving while she was pregnant. A lack of first hand experience doesn't mean something doesn't exist

[@skylertrotta3547]

@Michelle Thomas pickles and ice cream (in separate bowls) is pretty good tho

[@bihexualwitch546]

We don’t put grapes nor walnuts in our potato salads 😩 but this episode was really good. Thank seemed so genuine, he should appear more often!

[@Music-vr7sz]

Smosh Live is a virtual event. There are no seat limitations. They should charge much less for tickets and they'd sell more.

[@Sullyk0]

It’d be fun if they brought in someone to make hyper realistic cakes to really add some confusion lol

[@chrisnixon1991]

I knew I saw Garret! he was yelling out "I'm Gauc'in HERE!" in the middle of Time Square! *Shout out to Olivia for the comedic history!*

[@alexspain9103]

Watching them slowly like more and more of the cursed food over time is like watching someone in 40k succumb to the corruption of Slaanesh

[@troysands9260]

So many likes for this.

[@gothictrashqueen9109]

I’d love to see Tank again!

[@StormBoy95]

These dishes on this episode of Yeet it, or eat it looked absolutely delicious! I wanted to eat every one of them and now I’m hungry! P.S. Can you do an episode where the food is from Texas?

[@TheLoserface45]

every time they bring a really muscley guy on Smosh, I feel like Shane entirely changes form somehow

[@stephensommers4628]

You should do a cartoon food versions. Like a Krabby Patty with actual crab.

[@itsqueengg]

I just love how Damien describes foods, for some reason it sounds very poetic 😂 also the passionate look he gave the pizza dayyuummm

[@ameliarose47]

Got my Smosh Under The Influence wristband in the mail today along with my sloshy cups. Ready to roll Thursday night!

[@kevinramsey5092]

THATS CHICKEN DAMIAN needs to be a shirt

[@marinamyers1233]

Because it's summer they should do a camp food episode like smores,, hot dogs, random vegetables wrapped in aluminum foil on the fire

[@neilisalive4892]

15:10 love when the editors let a bleep slip lol

[@dika_hilman]

Legends said that Damien is still denial if it's a chicken pizza

[@arrowpride5468]

Alright Milk Bean you hit Cali and NYC. It's time to diversify your portfolio. COME TO ATLANTA BRO

[@3lttlbrds]

Garrett shouting 'THAT'S CHICKEN DAMIEN!' was crazy hilarious 😂😂😂😂😂 Garrett is the best ❤

[@ur2jealous]

Do a Is It Cake episode (maybe for someone’s bday) where each item is a small personal cake with a fondant outside but may or may not be cake inside

[@dio-chu]

10:35 Perfect reaction to Garret’s food

[@rexyggor6417]

I still think everyone should eat until they hit the bell for the round. So there are 5 portions first, then 4, 3, 2, 1 for the Big bite. The words "Safe from the game" make little sense when they volunteer to eat (until the big bite)

[@sagegreeeeeeen]

“THATS CHICKEN, DAMIEN” damn,Garrett

[@ArtisticMusicRebel]

Courtney needs join in on this. I wanna see her eat or yeet 😂

[@otp1203]

Two teams of 5: -Dish is revealed, teams decide which member to send to eat. -Person to eat most of the dish wins a point. -Team with the fewest points eats the Biggest Bite (100% guaranteed awful)

[@echostwitt9648]

Now I want to try General Tso's pizza. Also, as an employee of Walmart, I appreciate seeing the Great Value water bottles at the Garrett care station. I'm proud to say that Smosh drinks our water.

[@Shabba6884]

Gotta be better than La Croix, right? ;)

[@echostwitt9648]

@@Shabba6884 So much better. I tried La Croix once, and I don't know how they drink it.

[@RaeofLight13]

Garrett yelling “Damien” just reminded me of the Omen in this epi lol

[@dshiznit40]

Love when Shayne reps the Broncos!💯

[@jypsridic]

I like waldorf enough that I almost punched my screen when the count down for it happened.

[@bones727]

Gossip girl theme i love this episode

[@raseon97]

I love that they put in the time to coordinate that opening announcement and then there was a typo in the text on the time (PDT instead of PST) 😂

[@soniabouillon9800]

I wish Garrett brought them a chopped cheese 😭 those are mad good

[@CaptainHarpo]

Eat It or Yeet It: Scoville Scaling. Each dish is spicy and is in a random order. First dish could be the spiciest or not.

[@LOLWAAHH]

Tank looking concerned when Damien was about to take a bite lmao

[@haileyberlynn]

I love Shayne's old school Broncos shirt

[@mirandap7034]

y'all should do one of these but it's recipes from the 50s. party cheese salad. jello everything. cream cheese crimes

[@The_Broke_Gamer]

I died at cream cheese crimes 🤣 💀

[@hunterpowers2568]

00:15:46 uncensored Shayne

[@LardZardd]

Waiting for Rhett and Link

[@AJFilms14]

Did Garrett try to ruin a salad by putting a little garlic in it? Lol

[@tortugapoet]

Granted, a fruit salad... but still! 😆

[@perrymorris6011]

IM SO FRICKN EXCITED FOR SMOSH UNDER THE INFLUENCE

[@KynrieFairy]

You guys saying you have no talent but you all are so funny like on a professional level. Your improve skills make you more talented than many of the top youtubers because it feels like practice was put in but also all you have a natural talent for humor is seems. Ty for making us laugh