Eat, Treat, or Trash These Magic Kingdom Restaurants | Disney Dining Show

In this episode, the team looks at the Magic Kingdom and decides which restaurants they'd eat at every time, which restaurants they'd treat themselves to, and which restaurants they'd trash and get rid of.
Get a FREE No-Obligation Quote on a Disney vacation from Dreams Unlimited Travel today!
www.DreamsUnli...
For more information on Walt Disney World, Disney Cruise Line, Disneyland, Universal, and more, head to www.disneyinfo...
Visit www.disunplugge... to hear more from The DIS Unplugged team.
Subscribe to the DIS Unplugged KZbin Channel!
/ disunplugged
Like us on FACEBOOK: / disunplugged
Follow us on TWITTER: / thedis
Follow us on INSTAGRAM: / the.dis
Become a Patron of the DIS Unplugged and receive exclusive content, early access to certain vlogs, and much more!
/ disunplugged

[@trudisabaj2741]

Pleeeeze make Ryno go eat at every place in MK and report in. Rotate who goes with him! The dear boy needs to expand his eating range because I love his opinions! 🥗🍔🌭🍱

[@jennirhodes]

I love this concept - hope to see the same format for all the WDW locations.

[@tobone4116]

Someone pay for rhyno so he can eat at table service guys

[@ck2d]

It's all paid by Pete.

[@nicholasc1188]

pete plz feed this man

[@elizabethgeoghegan5167]

Definitely enjoy this format to the updated version

[@michaelharbuck7847]

My closest is johns picks both plaza and skippers but if i were to get rid of one it would be tonys

[@jonnyboy7885]

We need a Dining Review for these guys at Skipper Canteen, it's so good!!

[@DISUnlimited]

Soon!

[@citizenofcorona8783]

Except they took the seafood stew off the menu.

[@tcraig62]

Best meal in MK

[@dawnbeinlich2390]

You guys are great at thinking up new ideas! Love this and didn't realize Cosmic Ray's was so hated on. I'm a fan of just grabbing a standard burger or chicken sandwich there...lots of seating and not super crowded for the same burger you can get pretty much anywhere in WDW.

[@alexisbk9576]

Love Sonny Eclipse at Cosmic Ray’s!

[@princesspeaches8525]

Me too!

[@loracaro4427]

Same

[@jasonzambricki1669]

We ate at Skipper's Canteen last March(2022), and the Orinoco Ida's Cachapas appetizer was one of the best things we have ever had on property

[@VoidedMirror]

I love this group.

[@iowaopoly]

Ryno with the phenomenal Producers reference 🤣

[@Clemens1984]

Love the format! Please more shows like this!

[@sarab3749]

This was a really fun video! Thanks for posting it!

[@Normalyzer]

Pete recommended going to the resorts, so we do. We walk, take a boat or monorail. We do love Skipper Canteen, another Pete recommendation and go every trip to WDW.

[@Normalyzer]

Trash Tony’s

[@jimmyD2484]

This was a great episode! We need this for ALL the Parks, Resorts, Springs & Water Parks. I think you are on to something fun with this concept! Thanks for the content.

[@debbietummel5732]

I agree with Pecos. Miss the toppings bar

[@GAN-0]

I love the concept! But I’m thinking more ….”Gobble, Graze, Gag”

[@jeniferbeck3501]

My favorite is Skipper Canteen!

[@Parkpulsend]

Well, before it was Cosmic Ray's, it was Tomorrowland Terrace. Additionally, where Sony sits, that really is an elevator; the first was a a 5-member band and then later a Moog Machine. They both came down from the ceiling.

[@citizenofcorona8783]

Panda has a point. At least at Cosmic Rays you get to see Sonny Eclipse play. At BOG you don't get jack.

[@andrewleblanc9836]

I really like this idea. I look forward to it in other parks and maybe a general resort version (maybe break them up by value, moderate, etc.)

[@dkelly387z]

Why did Craigery sound like he was being broadcast on a 1940's Philco radio? I kept waiting for him to say he had to 'go mend the fence posts' or 'varnish the banister' LOL

[@lizciampa]

I love the Plaza. The Monte Cristo was insane. And nobody beats Sonny Eclipse at Cosmic Rays!

[@dee_mcgee11]

I agree with Panda that Be our Guest is not great and not worth the price since getting rid of the breakfast and quick service lunch.

[@annemariec7659]

Been to all the table service and counter service at Mk. None are great sadly. Lunch at BoG when it was "counter service" was fun but not now. We always go to a resort to eat now on a mk day.

[@kat_9999]

Eat- liberty tree Treat-crystal palace Trash- cosmic ray's

[@ianwaynemcdonald]

I'm with Panda. My family and I ate are Be Our Guest once and would never go back again.

[@hilaryjudis994]

I think this would have been even more fun, especially with this group, to exclusively stick to snacks

[@maureenlong3727]

My list is the same as Ryno! Pecos bills and skipper canteen are fantastic

[@tlw1950]

Eat: Columbia Harbor House Treat: Skipper Canteen Trash: Cosmic Ray’s

[@annasamanthahazel]

You know in all my years of going I’ve never been to Plaza! I just forget it’s there! I’m also not that big on sitting down for long meals at the parks so there is a good chance I never will. Crystal Palace will always be my choice if we have to sit down. I’m from London and I love that they made a restaurant based on a real place from my home town.

[@TheFantasyXIX]

Gotta say, I agree with the take for Trash when it comes to Be Our Guest. Say what you want about Cosmic Ray's or Tony's Town Square, but at least I feel like they serve a purpose: a quick bite to eat to appease picky eaters at Magic Kingdom. What exactly does Be Our Guest have that's supposed to be a draw? The food? A majority of places in the park can serve similar dishes that not only taste better, but are lighter on your wallet. Heck, for a short time, you could get the Gray Stuff cupcake at Gaston's tavern. The atmosphere? Maybe, but half of the time the West Wing is completely booked, the ballroom is a noisy cafeteria, and then the... art gallery(?) is the only place left. (Seriously, why didn't they make it the East Wing or Library to dedicate it to Belle?) If you want to dine in a castle, even if it's expensive, Cinderella's Royal Table isn't too far away, and you can meet a wider array of characters. You only get to see the Beast at Be Our Guest, and on top of that, only at dinner. The only selling point it really has is "You can dine in the Beast's Castle." That's it. It might be pretty to look at, but it's to distract you from the fact that the food is subpar and make you feel better about the absolute hassle of trying to get a reservation months in advance.

[@jennifercarroll3934]

Liberty tree tavern is thé best

[@elizabethraley3992]

I hope you do this for all parks

[@DISUnlimited]

We will be!

[@chrissatterfield4569]

More shows like this and go to restaurants you have never been too.

[@katherinedeliberatefare]

Marry Plaza!!!! My favorite

[@justinschrank4806]

Eat: be our guest. Treat: spring roll cart. Trash: Casey's corner.

[@1978rga]

Eat- Columbia Harbour House, Treat- Cinderella’s Royal Table, Trash- Cosmic Rays

[@michaelmadsen1222]

I agree with Panda on Be Our Guest vs Cosmic Rays. I would rather go get a cheap burger and fries than pay a bunch of money for a meh meal.

[@dkelly387z]

Also, it's good to see fun, game like, concepts returning. It's been a bit of a 'meow fest' for quite a while. Having some real fun will reinvigorate the show.

[@brianburke4409]

Enjoyed the light discussion! Eat - Liberty Tree Tavern, Treat - Skippers Canteen, Trash - Be Our Guest. 😉

[@sherylmailath9193]

Loved this show please do all parks and then hotels by category

[@laurieobrien3761]

This was fun! I hope it becomes a regular show topic!

[@MrChrisDanger]

Strange suggestions yeah food alone some maybe not that good but immersive Theme experience but I haven´t much of a nice experience either in the BatB Restaurant the best was meeting the Beast and the dessert but they squeezed me into a corner couldn´t much see of the immersive flair and presentation there. Will see how DLP will have on Touch of the Restaurants and Quickservices Pym Kitchen Walt´s looking pretty nice like Stark Factory and so on.

[@louisagalaska5713]

Sleepy Hollow! Nutella waffle!

[@ibowers819]

As far as I'm concerned, the only GREAT sit down restaurant at Magic Kingdom is Skipper Canteen. Be Our Guest is fine (I don't hate their food like some people seem to) but the atmosphere shines there over the food.

[@PrincessMeggala0913]

Yeassss. This is perfection ❤

[@seanroge]

I would assume Scarf, nibble, barf would be what Pinky and the Brain would play.

[@Gandalfs_Grey_Hat]

Having a super rough week. Thank you for all that you do DIS Fam.

[@seanhefmusic]

Hope you weekend turns around!

[@tswanson7354]

I would say Skipper Canteen for sure has to be my treat. I want to cheat and make my eat Steakhouse 71…. It is our new favorite place to take a late lunch at a day at MK. For sure Be our guest can be trashed. Unless of course if they would bring back the quick service lunch!

[@ivanperez4585]

Im with Panda! Plaza is a solid choice to stick with. For a Treat it's Crystal Palace. It's never let us down. Trash is atie with BOG/Cosmic Rays

[@dawnps5671]

Big miss by not not including Sleepy Hollow! #nutellawaffle.

[@tracyl5112]

My marry choice as well! Chicken sandwich, nutella, strawberry funnel cake.

[@cpillsbury9]

I think my treat myself and comfort is Liberty Tree just have to have a home cooked meal when traveling we don't usually get this

[@DISUnlimited]

Thanks for sharing!

[@cpillsbury9]

@@DISUnlimited maybe another episode like this at the other parks. This was a good episode thanks for sharing your thoughts

[@danimartin818]

I can't imagine wanting to "marry" Casey's Corner! 😂 At least you guys don't go for the trophy spouse!

[@trudisabaj2741]

Ooh put it in order: Nibble, Scarf, Barf. Because isn’t that how it happens? 😉

[@runaroundsueaccessibletrav6357]

Really enjoyed this can't wait the the other parks

[@nicoleslagoski8779]

Thus was fun. More of these please!

[@frankcarney4882]

How about spring roll cart especially the pastrami and cheese

[@loriminard6460]

Another great show guys !

[@evanhart9481]

Fantastic!

[@shaneestes372]

I think we can all agree Forky would be the perfect mascot for this game! LOL After all, "TRASH!" I could see this format being done for attractions but in every land but it'd be called "Return, Keep, Close!" I guess stores, bathrooms, and restaurants could be included too! For example, in Tomorrowland, I'd return Stitch's Great Escape (yes I'm still crazy!), keep Buzz Lightyear, and close Tomorrowland Speedway! Make sense? And for MK, my E,T or T is Eat at Jungle Skipper Canteen, Treat at Be Our Guest, and Trash Starbucks. I like Starbucks, but there's literally one on every corner in the world! LOL

[@mr.patrickaloysiusbartholo4727]

Can we get a Portillos Dining Review?

[@LizzieMcT]

Eat would be Pecos Bill. Treat would be Sleepy Hollow. Trash for me would be Pirate y Perrico which I think is now Tortuga Tavern or something

[@Scaloozy]

Eat: Casey’s! Treat: Liberty Tree Tavern! Trash: cosmic rays

[@citizenofcorona8783]

Best QS: Columbia Harbor House Best TS: Cinderella's Royal Table

[@sharonsmith8607]

What about Chew, Spit, or Slash?

[@GetNLine]

I love Cosmic Rays. I'd eat Cosmic Rays over BOG

[@chaotic.expression]

YESSSSS Eat, Treat, Trash!

[@swonnenw9974]

Trash Skipper's Jungle Canteen. We ate there 2 weeks ago and it was overpriced for gross food. Also, it was the worst service we had on property. I'd love a great recommendation for table serve at MK.

[@DISUnlimited]

Be Our Guest if you want the steak or pork chop. Plaza Restaurant is good comfort food, but it’s also priced high for what it is like all of WDW.

[@justinschrank4806]

Just had be our guest. Food was exceptional.

[@Nicerobby]

im dying @16:48

[@elizabethgates7024]

I feel like the order should be "Treat, Eat, Trash" if we're going based on the order of the game.

[@michaelfenton9370]

How about the Plaza? Easiest restaurant to trash at MK.

[@jskeasler]

Was this filmed before Panda did the latest dining review at BOG? He seemed to enjoy his meal in that video so I was surprised he trashed it.

[@DISUnlimited]

Yes, he mentioned this in the BOG review knowing he was eating his words a bit.

[@garystocker9450]

Nothing to "eat" aside from an occasional egg roll at the cart... liberty tree to "treat"..turkey leg to "trash"..edited...Casey's is basically school cafeteria food.

[@meisteckhart]

I'm concerned Craig has never had great Italian food. I can certainly make good Italian food at home. I doubt I am capable of making some of the best Italian food I have ever had. Though admittedly, none of that food was at Disney World. Il Mulino perhaps. That was pretty good.

[@DISUnlimited]

I mean I spent two weeks in Italy…

[@meisteckhart]

@@DISUnlimited fair. Best I have ever had was in Florence. If you’re ever in NYC though, Upland in Manhattan is my favorite.

[@DISUnlimited]

Best pasta we had was in Rome. We walked into a small family restaurant that we found in an alley where no one spoke any English and we had to rely on Ryno’s partner trying to find similar words/phrases in Spanish. It was incredible and I wish I knew the name to go back one day but if I walked in I would recognize it instantly. Best pizza was Naples but we also had outstanding pizza at a shop in Rome up the way from our hotel completely away from all of the tourist spots and figured it had to be decent when there was a line out the door of only locals. We found a pasta to go shop in Venice that was better than most American Italian restaurants and was under 10 euro each. I think I gained 15 pounds that trip.

[@builderphil13]

I agree with Erica. Casey's is always a must do.

[@ChrisFromOrlando-ml6cv]

NICE

[@larkendelvie]

Thanks all -- you all need to actually go record and eat at Skipper's and at Plaza, I think Liberty Tree has been reviewed fairly recently. With the Splash Mountain changeover (can't remember what new ride is called) is there going to be a big change in quick service in MK? I think it would be great to do this categorization with each of the parks but also with the hotels by meal -- Breakfast - which hotel restaurant to Eat vs Treat vs Trash then the same for Lunch and Dinner.

[@DISUnlimited]

We will definitely take this to the resorts and love your suggestion for how to do it. Honestly, a breakfast edition for this would be perfect for all the parks.

[@Michelleybellin]

@@DISUnlimited Yes, a breakfast series would be awesome! We prefer breakfast for table service, since it is less expensive, and if you schedule a later seating, it can carry you through to the evening (with a snack along the way of course!).

[@rvgtfn]

Please go to the eat & trashed locations!

[@casolo8107]

I had to laugh because Casey’s is my trash restaurant; every time I’ve been there I’ve wondered how they can mess up a hot dog so much and their corn dogs are nothing compared to Disneyland’s. My treat is Skipper’s Canteen too. TBH I don’t love the food at Magic Kingdom, it is my least favorite park.

[@Nathan-yg6wh]

Casey's is the place that I always want to eat at but I'm consistenly disappointed every time I eat there. Bad hot dogs and worse buns.

[@DISUnlimited]

I understand the buns. Nothing worst than a stale bun, but for me the hot dogs themselves taste better than anywhere else.

[@Nathan-yg6wh]

@@DISUnlimited I’ll give them another go! Keep up the good work.

[@treasures_untold_vlogs]

We went to Tony’s as a joke to see if it was really that bad… and it was worse.. lol… 😂😂😂

[@frankcarney4882]

Casey's corner trash, the Catalina dog at HS was way better

[@DISUnlimited]

They are pretty great too.

[@rdutennis]

Pecos Bill post Covid is the most disappointing spot. From an (A-) to a (C-) in WDW standards.

[@princesspeaches8525]

I kept shouting Cafe Agrabah at the TV then remembered its only at Paris. 😆 It's so good. 🤤

[@DISUnlimited]

Hahahaha unfortunately I don’t know if we’ll get to do this for Paris unless the company wants to send us on a research trip?

[@robertsestito6821]

Give me turkey legs or give me death

[@MadManMcGirt]

How is Casey's any different than Cosmic Rays, other than Cosmic rays offers more than Caseys?? You guys make no sence. Now I don't think either is a top pick to begin with a few restaurants that are diamonds in the rough in the Magic Kingdom, are Skippers Canteen, the Crystal Palace, the Diamond Horseshoe review, and If you have the money and the pull....33. Liberty Tree Tavern has some very interesting things as well, As Well There is a small Restaurant on Tom Sawyers Island, which is only open a few days a year, which was always a real treat

[@DISUnlimited]

I think because it’s harder to screw up a hot dog than a hamburger or anything else at Cosmic Ray’s and the hot dog is a sodium boost on a long, hot park day.

[@tobone4116]

lol nobody wants to make homemade tomato sauce on vacation , come on now

[@DISUnlimited]

Wasn’t suggesting someone makes their own Italian food on vacation…

[@jbrossable]

Erica ❤

[@Icharis]

Loved the idea but I think this topic needs to be revisited in the proper format. You have to pick three items up front and then the people have to put them in the right category.

[@DISUnlimited]

I thought about doing it this way, but felt this approach would generate more conversation and help with someone like Ryno who maybe hasn’t eaten at a lot of places and would just go this, this and this but I have no reason why I put them in this order because I’ve not had any.

[@DISUnlimited]

But we may try it for individual snacks or even as like a bracket game later on down the line.

[@Icharis]

@@DISUnlimited you could do all the trash ones and then do eat treat trash with those

[@DISUnlimited]

I like it. I think I might have the team rank the restaurants before we record and do ETT with the top 3 and the bottom 3. Or do a poll to get the top 3 or bottom 3.

[@cassandraihasz5735]

The Plaza is a trash for me. Went once and the food was gross. Waste of my hard earned money

[@tobone4116]

eat- be our guest treat- dole whip trash- cosmic rays

[@don3181]

Skipper canteen this year was a total yuck. The fake lion eating the rubber and plastic zebra in the jungle cruise ride, was having a better meal.

[@DISUnlimited]

Second comment like this. We need to try it soon.

[@hairdresser1300]

Ioi

[@matthart4465]

Kinda getting tired of the sexual innuendos that keep popping up in these vids lately.

[@chain2822]

Eat- skippers Treat- crystal palace Trash- Tony's

[@tonydeeugenio1489]

Harbor house sorry flat out slop

[@DISUnlimited]

Harbour House is a solid choice.