Edward Dutton's CONTROVERSIAL Views on Different RACES

Anthropologist Edward Dutton explains his hypothesis about how woke people have mutated genes, and what this means for conservative natured people. Dutton and I engage in a heated debate about racial harmony and David Duke, after he explains his studies and hypotheses about woke mutants.
Watch the full podcast here: • The Genetic Weakness o...
#narcissism #genetics #debate

[@Anne_Onymous]

Everyone's allowed to prefer to be around their own kind except for 1 specific group.....

[@spodoinklehorse]

Fk me, I've never thought about it like that, but it is unfortunately true

[@sacredgeometry]

There is only one kind.

[@donwildmoon6765]

@@sacredgeometry grow up

[@sacredgeometry]

@@donwildmoon6765 Elaborate?

[@jimmymags6516]

@@sacredgeometry there’s only one human race, but obviously there’s many sub-groups within our species. Surely you’ve never confused Australian aborigines with Swedes?

[@speedypete4987]

It is better to be aware of and admit our innate biases rather than deny them and pretend we are all Ubuntu and Kumbaya.

[@jamesgill6213]

why do we have to pretend

[@zoso2000]

Because of FEAR!

[@ColmPadraig]

Because of the hosts tribe

[@jamesconnolly5164]

The oligarchs are super antiwhite and have infinite money to throw at propaganda (especially in entertainment and youth “education”). I don’t pretend to know why they want to erase us so badly, it makes no sense, but they clearly do and you have to pretend because they are a formidable power.

[@dalebaker5030]

a lot of people in for a rude awakening in this country, especially those who like like to wear valuables.

[@mikesheffer3690]

We are creatures of nature. Like squirrels or birds, we humans have our own nature, it makes us what we commonly are. To say that groups of people prefer the company of people who are very like them is not a value judgment -- it isn't an 'ism.' It simply is. Baboons don't hang out with lowland gorillas. We humans are far far happier when we learn to live with our nature, not fight against it. Reach out to all. Hug your own.

[@Ajax-t1q]

Yes agree. Human history, being wary of the others is an instinct of survival .

[@SusanBlakely-pd6mp]

Can you loan me a fiver?

[@aldo874]

Reminds me slightly of Muhammad Ali’s quote about crows not flying with seagulls they fly with other crows.

[@Tinywars]

He's absolutely right. It's not racist its fact. Of course we are more comfortable around our own. We need to stop lying and we need to be honest. That's not to say we look down on others because they feel the same way and from experience aren't afraid to say it which I'm happy with. I don't have an issue with that at all. It's natural.

[@benh715]

You weren’t listening to him. It is racist. And it is fact. What he said is he isn’t interested in whether it is right or wrong, not that it isn’t wrong.

[@kartheeshk5519]

What about mixed race people?????

[@ColmPadraig]

It is though, but that word is a gaslighting tactic to shame people for a natural feeling.

[@Tinywars]

@@kartheeshk5519 ..What about them? They may be mixed but they always look more like one race then the other.

[@rigavitch]

I ♥DUTTON Never seen Andrew so uncomfortable.

[@grimwulf8547]

human beings need to live among their own kind in their own territory. It is hard wired into our genetic makeup. a core tenet of life itself

[@LemonScreech]

Nothing shocking here. Apart from the pathetic comparison about “the corner”. People are tribal and this eventually results in the same outcome.

[@Ajax-t1q]

Yes agree, we are tribal it's in our DNA. To think not is a dissociation with human history.

[@manofculture584]

It's not a pathetic comparison. It's pointing out that you can control how you behave even if you are biologically predisposed to do something

[@3rdEyeWide]

We developed higher reasoning for a... reason.

[@ColmPadraig]

​@@manofculture584 I dont want to be controlled in that aspect. I want my own lands for my own people.

[@Grover3364]

Yes, ironic that on a video about group differences there’s a spam thread where Nigerian scammers try their luck

[@rw9854]

Just a common sense man basically. Nothing remotely controversial

[@teevans8370]

It's also about shared cultural reference points. I've lived and worked in Asian countries and notice time and again the expat staff hang out together, and the bond is often stronger amongst those of the same nationality. No one is being deliberately cliquey but you naturally find you have more in common with those of a similar background. It can take a conscious effort to break out of that pattern and form meaningful friendships with people native to that country.

[@GiacomoSorbi]

What is "controversial" (all uppercase) in his view? That people prefer to be in environments with people of the same perceived group?

[@sacredgeometry]

Ethnicity isnt as arbitrary as "race". Not all British people look the same. Plenty are brown. And potentially culturally identical. People like to be around culturally similar people.

[@superspecky4eyes]

It's a click bait title.

[@martinjackman2943]

@@sacredgeometry "British people" are an administrative entity : neither ethnic or racial .It irrelevant to this argument .

[@sacredgeometry]

@ When I say British people I mean anyone that was born and raised on the British Isles.

[@sacredgeometry]

@@martinjackman2943 Just to be clear what I said is the same of you swap british out for English, Welsh, Irish or Scottish.

[@haydenwalton2766]

I enjoy much more these conversations where people challenge ideas, rather than just being in furious agreement

[@edmunddengler7687]

Andrew is so desperate to protect the modern urban monoculture.

[@benh715]

I would love some monoculture.

[@notsocrates9529]

Early life.

[@ColmPadraig]

He's ✡️

[@ColmPadraig]

✡️

[@avemarduk]

I think it's mostly attributed to nothing more than social pressure. Most people over the past 2 decades grow up, entirely inculcated into the metropolitan, cosmopolitan, hyper-urban, default-liberal monoculture, and it becomes the *_aesthetic with which all your friends have adorned themselves in as well lol._* And so most people espouse this desperation to preserve it, not because they actually care about preserving it, but because they're just experiencing social pressure that is warning them that if they don't tow this particular party line as it were, they're likely to face reputation destruction of some kind and be evicted from their peer groups, social circles, etc. I phrase it as *_"maintaining a reservation at the shit-lib cool kids table"_* lol. That's all I ever see when I hear people like this, squirm & writhe for the painfully obvious reasons they do, at the sight & sound of reality whenever they're met with it. Also indicative of the overwhelming effeminization of Western Civilization over the past several decades, now that our society abuses the classic tactics of female anti-social behavior whenever we're trying to enforce any sort of broader cultural conformity, that being the egregious abuse of reputation destruction. That's why Andrew feels so uncomfortable, he can feel his head being slowly pushed towards the guillotine, simply being in the same room with Edward Dutton as he's speaking these hyper-spicy truths the monoculture would NEVER tolerate lol. It's because he knows the monoculture would NEVER genuinely hear the facts Edward is speaking about.

[@ThaMassDebater]

We are tribal and on a sub concious level we have a bias/ preference towards the advancement of our own tribe.. If you look at the results / outcomes of the Athletics in the Olympics and World records held, could you make the claim that Black people are superior track athletes? If you can make that claim, why is it such a reach to make the claim that certain races are superior to others in other aspects of life? Why is it so controversial to say that one race or collective group/ tribe has a higher overall IQ then others? If we can acknowledge that a certain race is in general athletically superior why can't we acknowledge the possibility that a certain race could have a higher IQ collectively?

[@LOCATION_REDACTED]

It’s not even sub-conscious, it’s very conscious.

[@v.roni007]

I am enjoying all your channels . Many thanks ❤

[@pp-bb6jj]

Controversial? You mean sensible.

[@Rydonattelo]

I watched Brittanicas trip to Finland with Edward and it was fantastically funny.

[@jamescole3925]

Baseline is biological truths and we need to base society around that, fair or not. Ignoring these facts can only be more harmful to us on the long term and everyone will have different strengths, that is the true beauty of diversity. They are just too scared to see just how wonderfully diverse we really are as a species

[@Torquemada70]

Didn't hear anything controversial. Or anything CONTROVERSIAL either.

[@DarthPerkins]

This is perfectly natural. It goes back to when we were tribal and had to rely on the people we knew and a distrust of strangers was a wise precaution.

[@redlizard865]

Its almost impossible to tell the difference between Swedish person and Finnish person from physical point of view and Edward Dutton claims that they can tell that his not Finnish simply because of shape of his nose. I mean right there, that is pure utter pseudoscientific nonsense.

[@jurgalt2005]

it is natural to be drawn to a more familiar group. I live in the uk for 15 years, however once i go to eastern Europe i feel so much easier to be around my own nationality people, it feels it is easier to open up to them, i feel energetic connection instantly (in comparison to other groups), they feel safer and friendlier to me. Biology always tells you what is natural actually. It is natural to be drawn to your own group because it is interconnected with similar conditioning, roots and values, even body rhythms, ( or character: e.g. some nations are known to be more introverted and others extroverted), closer genetic make up, it is definitely easier to understand and connect. I did connect with some British people of course and have friends, however it is Always easier for me to feel deeper connection with my own people, and it is on subconscious level . so i do not think we should fight our nature.

[@danielshagman]

Refreshing to hear someone talk about the worst elements of their following, rather than pretending they don't exist. If we're going to come through this without significant issues, we need to call out the real far right, as much as we call out the fascists on the left. Bravo.

[@imdo301]

We are discussing the obvious here.

[@davehoper_319]

Glory!!! After so much struggles i now own a new house with an influx of $115,000 every month God has kept to his words, my family is happy again everything is finally falling into place. God bless America.

[@jackielpowell]

God is greatest how do you make such monthly?? I'm a born Christian and sometimes I feel so down to myself because of low finance but I still believe in God

[@jackielpowell]

I'm inspired. Please spill some sugar about the biweekly stuff you mentioned

[@davehoper_319]

Thanks to Deborah Lee Clark Her top notch guidance and expertise on digital market changed the game for me

[@parissindy1990]

Yes!! That's exactly her name (Deborah Lee Clark) so many people have recommended highly about her and am just starting with her from Ottawa Canada🇨🇦

[@parissindy1990]

This is a definition of God's unending provisions for his people. God remains faithful to his words. I receive this for my household

[@notsocrates9529]

David Duke would be an improvement.

[@GUISNIP]

I was born in and live in Canada but when I visit my cousins in my familial small town in southern Italy, I feel instantly at home and more at ease. There is a naturalness that is unavailable to me anywhere else.

[@roneythetube]

Great to see the Jolly Heretic on your show Andrew. Two great minds.

[@ciarancosgrave]

Mohamed Ali essentially said the same thing decades ago using his famous birds analogy

[@chrisroberts2681]

I am really curious about his study that produced the results that people of Ashkenazi Jewish heritage have a higher average IQ than the General Population, because (If Ture) I am really interested in the reasons for that. Is it because of how small the population group of Ashkenazi Jews are, as well as in combination with a culture that values high academic achievement and learning? Because it definitely seems those two factors are vital for this aberration to occur. For example if your were taking the average IQ of The Han Chinese Population the shear number and varied economic and social differences between this large Population, would have to have a negative correlation to average IQ scores, even though the Han Chinese also have a culture that values education. I'll have to read his study and see if his research shows any such correlation.

[@benh715]

I’ve seen some stuff about this elsewhere (can’t remember I’m afraid). East Asian IQ is higher than white which is higher than black. Ashkenazi Jews are top of the average IQ. Interestingly, the range of IQ in whites is broader than East Asians, so whites have proportionally more dumb people and more smart people. Why that is 🤷‍♂️

[@benh715]

The point about cultures valuing education and learning would lead to sexual selection of intelligence. How strong this is compared to other selection factors would be fascinating to understand.

[@ColmPadraig]

Leather Apron club did a video on this

[@stormhawk3319]

I’m white English and simply prefer being around other white English people. I can’t connect with any other race or culture, just not within me.

[@lordsneed9418]

Why yes, I do instinctively feel more warmth, comfort and trust around people of my culture and my ancestral background for the same reason that I instinctively prefer my relatives. This is called in-group preference or nepotism and it's natural and rational since its evolutionarily a successful strategy to help those who are more genetically similar to yourself. It's also good and beautiful. What could be more good and beautiful than love between family members? BTW every other race of people actually feels more in-group preference than white people, who are the most individualistic and colourblind. You can see this from the ANES 2018 pilot survey.

[@jonhstonk7998]

How’s anything he said considered controversial? It’s just objectively true…

[@ThisVids4U-c2w]

Mohammed Ali understood

[@Sam-m6o3j]

His name suggests otherwise ;)

[@ThisVids4U-c2w]

@Sam-m6o3j you should listen to him on Parkinson, the UNCUT version. Birds with birds. Bees with bees.

[@anneominous7172]

Basically all races understand, it's only whites who pretend not to - because they're coached to.

[@mindfuldrone]

Skin colour variances is incredibly recent. A few thousand years. The idea that there is some deep evolved response to that (other than tribal markers) is inherently unlikely.

[@devanman7920]

What? A few thousand years ago they would have killed the person with a completely different skin colour almost instantly 😅

[@georgezee5173]

It's not about negatively reacting to specific different skin pigmentation per se, but negatively reacting to people that clearly don't look like you, which instinctively implies they're not part of your tribe and so they're intruders that might want to take over and destroy you (if you're a male) or grape you (if you're a female). It could be just a different hair colour, a different way of clothing themselves that triggers the individual into thinking they are outsiders and therefore intruders. For the longest time humans lived in small tribes that had to protect themselves from each other.

[@Exgrmbl]

It's not about that specifically but simply commonalities/patterns which can be easily seen

[@aires69uk]

If you are interested in this video of Andrew's then you may also be interested in Simon Webb's video: - kzbin.info/www/bejne/n5atl393lJpgeposi=DKsUnli1BshmCByC

[@crabtonia]

My daily double-dose of Heretics keeps me alert to my own (unrecognised) prejudices...thank you...dgp

[@angrycandy5441]

Controversial?

[@davidbrims5825]

Birds of a feather flock together.

[@BPchadlite]

Voicemaxing

[@Wtizreal]

8:12 This This This is everything What do you do when you are cpnfronted with a truth and this kicks i. What do you do?

[@turdburglar123]

Ed is based

[@ElodreamXO]

I feel like this Applies Only to people with high amounts of Anxiety. Who feel the need to dumb down and simplify the world to feel better. I honestly don't care who i'm around as long as they're decent. I'd rather be around 100 amazing people who don't look like me than a dozen terrible people who do.

[@CircumlunarFeasibility]

Funny that you say conflation, right after you stated an entire group of 10s of millions were hating your IQ statistics. Sounds a bit hypocritical.

[@Dean-A-L]

this seems like a nature vs nurture case. Are we naturally predisposed to this amygdala response, or is this socially/ environmentally primed? It seems more plausible that this is an environmentally based phenomena, and that people not used to seeing different people will have a stronger response, and people who live in a diverse community would have less so. Therefore, I think he strongly conflates a) a recognition of what we can call 'other', and b) a biologically rooted negative response to 'other'. I think he needs to argue more convincingly that these two are tied together. Ultimately, I suspect if you were to do his amygdala experiment on people who have been brought up and live among people who don't resemble them, we would find their response is similar to the original response to indigenous people.

[@HiNi.]

Why would it be more be more plausible that this is an environmentally based phenomena`?

[@manofculture584]

@@HiNi.because early people only were around people that looked like them and the only time they saw strangers was probably when they were raided and pillaged

[@GrecianWarlock]

I don't think that's biological. That's sociological.

[@jamesgill6213]

its biological

[@haydenwalton2766]

from my experience, it's generally the social constructionists that are the idiots in the room

[@sroth2021]

Sounds like you want it to be sociological. The part of the brain that recognises faces is less active when looking at other races faces also...

[@skillbopster]

Tribalism is biological. Men evolved to fight invading foreign tribes because every time they came they tried to conquer.

[@drew699]

Evolution & instinct is far deeper than sociological.

[@theobull6630]

This gentleman’s making a mistake. Yes there is a desire to preserve genetics there’s is also a desire to diversify, both exist in a balance.

[@Joe-sg9ll]

you wish

[@theobull6630]

@ "we want be with our own" meanwhile Ebony and Asian are the most popular porn genres?

[@theobull6630]

@ Prove me wrong bro, have sex with your sister 🤷🏾‍♂️

[@theobull6630]

@@Joe-sg9ll “We want to be with our own” mean while Ebony and Asian are the most popular porn categories? 🤔

[@theobull6630]

@@Joe-sg9llI’ve replied like three times why can’t I see my replies?

[@AmeliaHouck-o9j]

"YOUR FEELINGS" DO NOT GIVE HIM A STROKE AS YOUR FEELINGS DO NOT MATTER AND THIS ANNOYS HIM!!

[@almurabitun]

Gold is a wolf in sheeps clothing

[@goranmiljus2664]

If "They" are so smart, why do they continue to make the same mistakes , over and over and over again?

[@ShimobeSama]

WHAT? Edward DUTTON of all people has controversial views on RACE?! 😱🍿