He Claims to Follow the Quran, Can't Even Read It...

[@abumansaray7]

"Get the Arabic Quran and I'll prove it." "I can't read Arabic." 💀😂

[@ghias-dc5hw]

@abumansaray7 Little 'Knowledge' is Dangerous and very Misleading..... This hyper gentleman came all the way from SWEDEN @11.23....... Allaah O Akbar

[@odeebob7826]

It’s easy to catch a liar, especially when they try to act smart but aren’t. 😂 Thank you brother Imran and Abass

[@naztvnaztv]

he is just another victim of scam, by people who purposely mislead people by creating website full of misinformation about quran and islam

[@abdolahalamin6232]

Perfect Dawah is not a Quranist. He believes in Hadith but authentic ones. The title is a great lie. You are no match to Perfect Dawah.

[@Maximumm_]

​@@abdolahalamin6232 is this your burner account? 😂 You also clearly reject the Quran too.

[@shawngegen8768]

Efdah said cutting off the hands is barbaric.. in order to prove Hadith authority thry said Quranic aayat is barbaric..

[@abdolahalamin6232]

@@Maximumm_ I follow his Dawah and you will be answering Allah S.W.T in Ghiamah for lying about me and him because non of us reject the Quran but we reject your interpretation of the verse.

[@MohdYusufAbdulHamid]

“Im asking you to read the Quran and you are asking me to go to website” - that cracks me up.

[@joyboyboy5149]

this is just embarassing..

[@xpacnwo2000]

grown men arguing about nonsense. Religion = immaturity.

[@harriskhan7671]

this guy is living in Wonderland.

[@andristefanus]

it's easy to lie, the hardest part is maintaining it

[@chinesecovidanalswabs4752]

Yup. The more he was pressed the more his façade started to fall apart.

[@moneyslaves1945]

THIS GUY IS NOT A MUSLIM

[@abdolahalamin6232]

Why you say that? He is doing Dawah in many years. How can he be not a Muslim? Just because he disagree with you? He is called Perfect Dawah.

[@Maximumm_]

Rejecting Allah's word and commands takes you out the fold of Islam. Plus just because someone does dawah doesn't mean they're Muslim. A Christians can do dawah. Dawah mean you call people to something. Allah swt talks about people calling others to the fire as a form of dawah.​@@abdolahalamin6232

[@rakanal.2925]

Saying someone is not a Muslim is not something anyone should throw at other people be careful of that as the 1st replayer said or he could be of little knowledge

[@moneyslaves1945]

@@rakanal.2925 IF YOU WERE A MUSLIM YOU WOULD UNDERSTAND

[@moneyslaves1945]

@@abdolahalamin6232 WHAT? DAWAH ? YOU DONT KNOW THIS GUY SO PLS GO DO YOUR HOMEWORK ON THIS GUY BEFORE YOU START JUDGING...I KNOW THIS CHAITAN U DONT

[@penghapuskezaliman]

he embarassing himself..

[@Black-White-BW1]

Indeed

[@Black-White-BW1]

But then again Islam is an embarrassment itself.

[@umairakhtarbahawal]

17:29 Forgiveness on the part of Allah does not mean that the hand of the thief should not be cut off. It means rather that one who repents and becomes righteous by purging his soul of the sin of stealing will be spared the wrath of God, Who will remove the stain of that sin from him. But if after his hand has been cut off the person concerned does not purge himself of evil intent and continues to nurture the same impure feelings which led to his stealing and thus to the cutting off of his hand, it is evident that even though his hand has been severed from his body, stealing remains ingrained in his soul. The result will be that he will continue to merit God's wrath as he did before his hand was cut off. The Qur'an therefore directs the thief to seek pardon from God and to try to reform himself. For the hand of that thief was cut off for the sake of the judicious administration of human society and the cutting off of a hand did not automatically purify the soul of the person on whom the punishment was carried out. Purity of soul can be achieved only by repentance and turning oneself to God. Traditions mention that after the hand of a thief had been cut off in compliance with the Prophet's order, he was summoned by the Prophet (peace be on him) himself who said to him: 'Say: "I seek pardon from God, and to Him do I turn in repentance.'" The thief uttered these words as directed by the Prophet (peace be on him) who then prayed for the thief, saying: 'O God, accept his repentance.' (Abu Da'ud, 'Hudud', 8 - Ed.)

[@LeilaMaxmed]

“The worst kind of arrogance is arrogance from ignorance.” - Jim Rohn.

[@ALzzanam]

جزاكم الله خيرا

[@umairakhtarbahawal]

RAED THIS PLEASE: The injunction is to cut off one not both hands. There is consensus among jurists that in the event of the first theft the right hand should be cut off. This punishment has been laid down for theft alone. The Prophet (peace be on him) declared: "There is no cutting off of a hand for he who embezzles.' (Abu Da'ud, 'Hudud', 14; Tirmidhi, 'Hudud', 18; Ibn Majah, 'Hudud', 36; Nasa'i, 'Qat' al-Sariq', 13 - Ed.) This shows that the punishment prescribed for theft does not cover acts involving embezzlement and other dishonest practices. It is applicable only to acts involving the seizure, by stealth, of someone else's property. The Prophet (peace be on him) also instructed that the punishment of cutting off a hand should not be applied in cases where the value of the article stolen is less than that of a shield. In the time of the Prophet (peace be on him) according to a tradition from Ibn 'Abbas, this was ten dirhams; according to a tradition from Ibn 'Umar, it was three dirhams; according to a tradition from Anas b. Malik, it was five dirhams; and according to another tradition from 'A'ishah, it was a quarter of a dinar. Owing to this discrepancy, there is disagreement among jurists regarding the minimum value of the goods stolen which merits the punishment of cutting off a hand. This value, according to Abu Hanifah, is ten dirhams whereas according to Malik, Shafi'i and Ahmad b. Hanbal, it is one quarter of a dinar (three dirhams). (For traditions on objects and amounts of things on which the hand of the thief is to be cut off, see Bukhari, 'Hudud', 13; Muslim, 'Hudud', 1-7; Abu Da'ud, 'Hudud', 12, 13; Tirmidhi, 'Hudud', 16; Nasa'i, 'Qat' al-Sariq', 5, 8-10 - Ed.) Moreover, there are several things the theft of which would not necessitate cutting off a hand. The Prophet (peace be on him) directed, for instance, that no hand should be cut off if the stolen article was food. According to a tradition from 'A'ishah: '(The hand of) the thief was not cut off during the time of the Messenger of Allah for the theft of trivial things.' (Ahmad b. Hanbal, Musnad, vol. 3, p. 464; Darimi, 'Hudud', 4, 7 - Ed.) Furthermore, 'Ali and 'Uthman gave the judgement - and none of the Companions disagreed with it - that a person's hand should not be cut off for stealing birds. 'Umar and 'Ali did not cut off the hands of those who had stolen from the public treasury, and on this question no disagreement on the part of any Companion has been reported. On these grounds the founders of the schools of Islamic Law exempted certain things from the application of this penal injunction. According to Abu Hanifah a man's hand should not be cut off for stealing vegetables, fruit, meat, cooked food, grain which is not stored in a barn, and instruments of music and play. Likewise, he is of the opinion that a hand should not be cut off for either stealing animals grazing in the forest or for stealing from the public treasury. The founders of the other schools of Islamic Law have also exempted the stealing of certain things from the punishment of cutting off a hand. But this exemption does not mean that the guilty parties should receive no punishment at all. (See the commentaries of Ibn Kathir, Ibn al-'Arabi, Qurtubi and Jassas on this verse. See also Ibn Rushd, Bidayat al-Mujtahid, vol. 2, pp. 441 ff. - Ed.)

[@abdolahalamin6232]

If this is what the Quran says then why not saying one hand? Why making people confused? It is someone's hand not cucumber. This guy is Perfect Dawah and he is right. If you know what you are talking about, then debate him live.

[@umairakhtarbahawal]

@@abdolahalamin6232 How do you know the process and steps of salah? Rituals of hajj? Percentage of zakat? Months of hajj? Etc etc etc… Through authentic Hadith of course.. So this also explained by the prophet PBUH in a authentic hadith.

[@abdolahalamin6232]

@@umairakhtarbahawalDid I reject all Hadithes? I just said if a Hadithe goes against the Quran, that Hadith is fabricated. It doesn't matter if all scholars say it is authentic.

[@isahibrahim7414]

​@@abdolahalamin6232you just asked why the Qur'an doesn't clearly say everything in detail about the cutting of the hand and you were referred to the hadiths for the clarifying details and you're further confusing yourself saying it contradicts the Qur'an, what even is your point??

[@abdolahalamin6232]

@@isahibrahim7414 Which Hadith I referred to? I never said that we should refer to a Hadith. Why the Quran is clear about one hundred lashes and it doesn't leave it to Hadith? Why the Quran is clear about Wodu that wash your hand from elbow?

[@faramohamadi1706]

😂😂😂😂😂😂. What a clown 🤡 Wallahi I feel so bad for people like these guys . May Allah guide him 😢

[@LADHA-z1l]

He forgot his own name for a second. His phone doesn't work here, but what about his grey matter.

[@AmericanDeen777]

This is why you don’t form your own religion based off of what you interpret. Arrogance and ignorance will lead you astray

[@ShoaibAhmedNZ]

A quranist that can’t read the Quran! What’s next?

[@economician]

@ShoaibAhmedNZ A hadithiyun that cannot read his own authentic hadith that clearly says ” we have the Book of God and it is sufficient for us.” ( the hadith of pen and paper).

[@stevemcroy2020]

​@@economicianAlso the Quran says to follow Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). So how do we as muslims do that? We follow the authentic hadiths that lead all the way back to Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). So what's the problem?

[@nbk2134]

​@@economician the likeness for these Quranist was prophecized. There were no ignorantly confident boneheads all these centuries until very recently. So consider the below Hadith as a form of warning to your nonsense. The Prophet (ﷺ) said: Let me not find one of you reclining on his couch when he hears something regarding me which I have commanded or forbidden and saying: We do not know. What we found in Allah's Book we have followed. Abudawud:4605 Grade: Sahih (Al-Albani) Sorry there was no nice way to refute you.

[@Hudaifah_Ebu]

Since social media. Speakers corner has turn into circus, crazy clowns, absolute ludicrous.

[@economician]

@stevemcroy2020 The problem is that you do not follow your authentic hadiths because your authentic hadiths clearly state: ” we have the Book of God and it is sufficient for us.” The Quran does not tell you to obey prophet Muhammad. It tells you to obey the messenger of the Quran by following and judging by the teachings of the detailed Quran, the best hadith. Watch Grayson Brocks interview with Baba Shuaib.

[@waleedsharif618]

He seems Iranian so its normal for them to be like this

[@Ibrareidika]

Is he thought that moslem doesn't read Quran in Arabic? Really? And confidently go to SC meet with Mr.Abbas & Dr. imran?😅 Subhanallah...😂 Many of us not memorize Quran, however we can read it perfectly.

[@thehourglassfan3515]

Great quality! Sounds like he got exposed on 5:38. He cannot accept what it says because it doesn’t meet his whims and desires. May Allah guide him.

[@publicpm8809]

Ameen

[@Black-White-BW1]

Next time when you seem you go on your knees apologize.

[@umairakhtarbahawal]

No hand should be cut off in the following circumstances: 1: Embezzlement 2: If the stolen article was food 3: Theft of trivial things (Things of little value or importance) 4: Stealing birds 5: Stealing from the public treasury

[@TheDragonaf1]

Simple question to these people: without hadith how do we know what is and is not Qur'an? 😂😂

[@economician]

@TheDragonaf1 Simple question: why do your ”authentic” hadiths tell us: ”We have the Book of God and it is suffiecent for us” ( the hadith of pen and paper)

[@MFZ00]

@@economician Quran doesnt tell us how to adzan, how to wudu, how to praying, etc. Can u tell us how to do all of that if that is not from hadith??

[@economician]

@MFZ00 It is more complex than that. For example the wudhuu is fully detailed both when you have access to water and when you do not have access to water. See chapter five verse six. Some details for the contact prayer are in the Quran and some are not. For example we read in chapter seventeen verse one hundred and ten that we are to utter the contact prayer in a moderate tone not in any other tone. In chapter twenty verse fourteen we read that the purpose of the contact prayer is to remember God and nobody else such as various prophets and their families. All this leads to the conclusion that the contact prayer predates the Quran and that the Quran does not seek to introduce the contact prayer but rather to correct false innovations introduced into the contact prayer. Nobody has learned the contact prayer by reading the hadiths alone.

[@MFZ00]

@@economician yes. on that verse Allah only said to wash this and that on Q5:6. so where do u get the detail if its not from hadith?? i mean, how to take a proper wudu?? in Q17:110, dude. that verse only said to take the prayer. and my question is about HOW to pray. and same with Q20:14. did u understand my question??

[@economician]

@MFZ00 I stand firm by my statement that 5:6 is fully detailed when it comes to the widhu. The tone of voice in the contact prayer is a detail and the commandment to remember God and nobody else during the Contact Prayer is a detail. Where can I find a complete hadith tutorial in the hadiths for the Contact Prayer? Notice that I do not want to ask my parents or relatives or the ulama or the old exegetes but I only want a pure hadith tutorial on the contact prayer with each single detail written. Where can I find this tutorial in the hadiths?

[@rehtafrey]

its nice to see him holding the microphone so hard so that it can save his claims.

[@mohammedsalem7378]

If the original say something, why he ignoring that and ask to go to a random website?

[@mohammedzahid1990]

SubhanAllah

[@raniayoussef5599]

الله اكبر

[@asrarextravlogs]

قطّع and قطع he mean this yes there is differences ..because of that little punctuation on top of the letter ط

[@abdolahalamin6232]

This guy is Perfect Dawah and he is right. There is not chopping of the hand in 5.38.

[@thehourglassfan3515]

@@abdolahalamin6232Liar.

[@ariefnoerhidayat3870]

Well... speakers corners is always in need of clowns from another dimension to give laughters. 😂

[@Black-White-BW1]

Islam is providing these clowns😂🤣

[@nedmilburn]

The poor man... Pray for Allah to calm his spirit...

[@Abz786-v5w]

Allahu akbar. He lied so much he said multiple times he can read the quran. Once a liar alwayd a liar.

[@aryob5092]

Part 2 please....

[@tawAAkul]

There is an irony with this chap having a channel called perfect dawah😅

[@Crocodilesbread]

I am Confused about How they Can Know the Concept of Shalat based only the Word Shalat?

[@fakerealnews1]

I'm sweating for him!

[@FromNothingComesNothing]

This is pure entertainment 🤣

[@CMDRyassuu]

He is probably affected by علي الكيالي, he really made his way all the way to London, bru😅

[@Cut-thieves-hand-new-law]

Very, very agitated the dude , How would he be the day of judgement ?!

[@nosh121081]

What a fool..

[@josantai2691]

It'a very easy to catch an Ask Hold when they tried to LIE...

[@mohammadsaheidmiah8282]

I met many Iranians like that

[@ramizqarizada1811]

I know he is Iranian but I can not prove it :D

[@AMR-yg7td]

Brothers, all the major punishments (Hadoud) are in the Quran. The stoning is not in quran, It is mentioned in the hadeeth, and it's hadeeth dhaaif.. it's from the Israelite tradition stories...

[@Olivianielsen1996]

Please come to Sweden and make dawah

[@rakanal.2925]

Why tf would a 3rd party website be of any matter when you have the primary resource on your hand 😂

[@josantai2691]

Surah Al Maeda verse 38 وَٱلسَّارِقُ وَٱلسَّارِقَةُ فَٱقْطَعُوٓا۟ أَيْدِيَهُمَا جَزَآءًۢ بِمَا كَسَبَا نَكَـٰلًۭا مِّنَ ٱللَّهِ ۗ وَٱللَّهُ عَزِيزٌ حَكِيمٌۭ ٣٨ As for male and female thieves, cut off their hands for what they have done-a deterrent from Allah. And Allah is Almighty, All-Wise.

[@yonetmen81besiktasli21]

Why is he yelling? If can speak normal or read normal everybody can hear him too right?

[@abdolahalamin6232]

Because the don't allow him talk.

[@yonetmen81besiktasli21]

@@abdolahalamin6232 Well they. He just don't want to listen to them

[@Black-White-BW1]

@@abdolahalamin6232They allow you talk and answer their question but you refuse.

[@shokydance]

These guys are super goofy. Don't believe in the Sunnat. Clown 😂

[@UmarAlAsad]

this uncle logic is "i am not a cook but i know more about cooking than chef Ramsey since i learn to cook from a barber"

[@abdolahalamin6232]

You are absolutely wrong because you say majority of Muslims do not know the Quran because they don't speak Arabic? This guy is called Perfect Dawah and he is more knowledgeable that majority of Muslims on the planet. Do you want to try him and debate him directly? I can arrange it.

[@thehourglassfan3515]

@@abdolahalamin6232The majority of Muslims do not claim to be experts of Islam. This person claims to have knowledge of the Quran yet doesn’t know the Arabic language in which the Quran was revealed. Big difference! That’s actually the reason why there are scholars and schools of thought in Islam to make access and understanding of the religion easier to the layman who might not have extensive knowledge of the texts. The thing is if he disagrees with you, he doesn’t let you speak. I have been to his streams a couple of times. A brother known as Yeager also tried to explain the wisdom behind the rulings of Islam but he would keep interrupting. When I spoke to him about 5:38, I could barely get a word in. He doesn’t want me to talk to him about it anymore because I think he knows I have the answers but he doesn’t want the Truth out. By the way, his whole argument for rejecting the verse are very weak, all I got was “barbaric, if ruler himself is, let the one who is without a sin let cast the first stone.” Purely emotional, no evidence from Quran and Sunnah whatsoever. He keeps running to other verses, ignoring the whole context. I would love to debate him on that, could you arrange that?

[@ziasamad704]

He got Iranian accent so most like is/was Shia

[@mohammadsaheidmiah8282]

Old man is hyped up on something surely

[@NaveedKhan-tp3rh]

He is a liar that's why he is very aggressive and agitated..

[@noorhassanayoubi9577]

Kinda confused,May Allah SW guide him back to the right path Aameen!!

[@soltan861]

He’s Sheia not a Muslim

[@isahibrahim7414]

This guy would make a better Christian than Muslim with his preaching skills

[@Black-White-BW1]

But Muslims with such preaching skills are indeed like perfect Dawah or a bit better. 😅

[@freydey6191]

The ayat from Allah is very clear. Cut off the hand of the thief. This guy is on sth.

[@jackaboo2941]

12:25 liar got caught

[@Damdam1000]

Literally two minutes after saying my phone doesn't work here he pulls out his phone and it's working 😅

[@Saaale-m2j]

This is too funny 😂

[@DD23-1]

Brother said read the Quran, but the G started reading English HAHAHAHHAAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHA

[@sashabraus1125]

clown detected

[@D14nDahlan]

This is not real right? This is just not happen right? 🇮🇩INDONESIA🇮🇩

[@hajjyello8953]

My phone's not working here now is working 😂😅

[@abdolahalamin6232]

Some people are so ignorant because his phone didn't have UK internet not that it was out of order. Do you understand the difference?

[@Black-White-BW1]

@@abdolahalamin6232you mean you didn’t have UK internet.

[@markward3981]

السلام عليكم و رحمة الله It is not funny but painful watching the ignorance combined with stubborn refusal to be taught on the part of this guy. Ya Allah help us

[@tokancorner327]

busted

[@ummhanef]

lol! 😂😂😂

[@fumanekoenanemohamadou9877]

He doesn't speak Arabic but he got an Arabic speaking translator of the Quran to change his translation????? How does that work?????😅

[@abdolahalamin6232]

You don't need to speak Arabic for understanding the logic of the Quran. In that case majority of Muslims have blind faith? They don't understand what they believe in?

[@Jaysonjay]

Seems like a farsi/sun worshipper, still reeling from the demise of the sasanian empire.

[@NaveedKhan-tp3rh]

I think he is a hadees rejecter

[@KC-tm1yq]

Heard the accent. Hes persian. His opinion is waffle. Case closed

[@r.rahman12]

a show off guy.

[@freydey6191]

A lost & astray guy more like it.

[@faseehaariff8594]

*showing off his ignorance with pride, kinda guy

[@nkurdi08]

You now translate 4 me the meaning. So back to English then? What was the point to go to the Arabic. I think he wanted a free Arabic lessons on the shadda fut-ha etc. 😂😂😂😂😂😂 But nahh they trapped him they tricked him. Repetive fools. May ALLAH guise them inshaALLAH

[@Seanus32]

He claims to follow the Quran? Sounds like he thinks it's a moving object ;)

[@Blitzblaz69]

hm perfect dawah at it again i see facepalm

[@jamelb2230]

The fact that you guys are debating on this while people are being bombed and massacred in Gaza and Libanon is unbelievable and out of touch with the reality 😮😮😮

[@JesusChrist_myLordmySavior.]

The book of confusion.

[@Black-White-BW1]

That’s Quran for ya.

[@faramohamadi1706]

You probably never read the Bible . Read it that day you will become the confusion itself 😂

[@tin_k_oo]

Quran did not confuse anyone. This balded man just dont even know how to read Quran and he is the confused idiot. Bible is the confusing Book.

[@Black-White-BW1]

@@faramohamadi1706 Both the Quran and Bible are confusing and full of contradictions.

[@Black-White-BW1]

@@faramohamadi1706 Both books are confusion and illogical 😂🤣

[@abdolahalamin6232]

Perfect Dawah is not a Quranist. He believes in Hadith but authentic ones. The title is a great lie. You are no match to Perfect Dawah.

[@Abdur-rahman-alhamdulillah]

This might be the most embarrassing comment I have ever read

[@abdolahalamin6232]

@@Abdur-rahman-alhamdulillah Why?

[@thehourglassfan3515]

@@abdolahalamin6232Bukhari and Muslim are authentic.

[@Black-White-BW1]

You aren’t fooling anyone.

[@Black-White-BW1]

Stop the act, perfect Dawah, we see you.

[@SebastianPohl-f4z]

If preche gospel in islam country you are deth

[@MoeCamera]

Source: trust me bro!

[@Noble_One]

this dumb a$$ doesn't know that oldest existing churches are found in Egypt (Islamic country) . hate mongering bigot!

[@Black-White-BW1]

Islam belongs in the middle-east.

[@Black-White-BW1]

@@MoeCameraTaqiya: you

[@syhillahmed3824]

Quranists pray salah , the method of salah is not mentioned in Quran only in the Hadith .

[@Damdam1000]

He just said my phone doesn't work here

[@NabeelHossain-dp4xs]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@asrarextravlogs]

If a person is hungry and have no money to buy food and no job too but the king of the country is enjoying his life in his castle and giving himself the rights to cut that hungry man hand because he took a can of food from a big supermarket to stop his hunger is this fair?! I don't think so Allah will never Allow this such things but human do and yes there is a big difference betwen قطّع and قطع just look at the punctuation on the top of that letter طّ

[@umairakhtarbahawal]

The special circumstances i.e dispensations are also explained by Allah & the prophet of Allah PBUH.

[@umairakhtarbahawal]

The injunction is to cut off one not both hands. There is consensus among jurists that in the event of the first theft the right hand should be cut off. This punishment has been laid down for theft alone. The Prophet (peace be on him) declared: "There is no cutting off of a hand for he who embezzles.' (Abu Da'ud, 'Hudud', 14; Tirmidhi, 'Hudud', 18; Ibn Majah, 'Hudud', 36; Nasa'i, 'Qat' al-Sariq', 13 - Ed.) This shows that the punishment prescribed for theft does not cover acts involving embezzlement and other dishonest practices. It is applicable only to acts involving the seizure, by stealth, of someone else's property. The Prophet (peace be on him) also instructed that the punishment of cutting off a hand should not be applied in cases where the value of the article stolen is less than that of a shield. In the time of the Prophet (peace be on him) according to a tradition from Ibn 'Abbas, this was ten dirhams; according to a tradition from Ibn 'Umar, it was three dirhams; according to a tradition from Anas b. Malik, it was five dirhams; and according to another tradition from 'A'ishah, it was a quarter of a dinar. Owing to this discrepancy, there is disagreement among jurists regarding the minimum value of the goods stolen which merits the punishment of cutting off a hand. This value, according to Abu Hanifah, is ten dirhams whereas according to Malik, Shafi'i and Ahmad b. Hanbal, it is one quarter of a dinar (three dirhams). (For traditions on objects and amounts of things on which the hand of the thief is to be cut off, see Bukhari, 'Hudud', 13; Muslim, 'Hudud', 1-7; Abu Da'ud, 'Hudud', 12, 13; Tirmidhi, 'Hudud', 16; Nasa'i, 'Qat' al-Sariq', 5, 8-10 - Ed.) Moreover, there are several things the theft of which would not necessitate cutting off a hand. The Prophet (peace be on him) directed, for instance, that no hand should be cut off if the stolen article was food. According to a tradition from 'A'ishah: '(The hand of) the thief was not cut off during the time of the Messenger of Allah for the theft of trivial things.' (Ahmad b. Hanbal, Musnad, vol. 3, p. 464; Darimi, 'Hudud', 4, 7 - Ed.) Furthermore, 'Ali and 'Uthman gave the judgement - and none of the Companions disagreed with it - that a person's hand should not be cut off for stealing birds. 'Umar and 'Ali did not cut off the hands of those who had stolen from the public treasury, and on this question no disagreement on the part of any Companion has been reported. On these grounds the founders of the schools of Islamic Law exempted certain things from the application of this penal injunction. According to Abu Hanifah a man's hand should not be cut off for stealing vegetables, fruit, meat, cooked food, grain which is not stored in a barn, and instruments of music and play. Likewise, he is of the opinion that a hand should not be cut off for either stealing animals grazing in the forest or for stealing from the public treasury. The founders of the other schools of Islamic Law have also exempted the stealing of certain things from the punishment of cutting off a hand. But this exemption does not mean that the guilty parties should receive no punishment at all. (See the commentaries of Ibn Kathir, Ibn al-'Arabi, Qurtubi and Jassas on this verse. See also Ibn Rushd, Bidayat al-Mujtahid, vol. 2, pp. 441 ff. - Ed.)

[@asrarextravlogs]

​@umairakhtarbahawal some hadith maybe right but not all anyway no one should loses their hand for steeling also as I mentioned in my previous comment the word itself in Quran not necessarily mean to cut off hand using a knife because in arabic the verb قطّع is different from the the verb قطع because of the punctuation it could mean stop the hand from steeling like in arabic we say قطعت علاقتي مع شخص means I cut off my relationship with someone it doesn't mean I took a knife and cut off the relationship.

[@umairakhtarbahawal]

@@asrarextravlogs Thank you my friend. But, this explanation does not fit with the verse itself. Allah SWT says in the same verse right after the commandment of cutting off hand that “It is a punishment of God for what they have done”.. If Allah is telling to the people to stay away (cut off) from stealing then what is the point of mentioning that it is a punishment for what they have done. What are your thoughts about this?

[@asrarextravlogs]

@umairakhtarbahawal it could be cut off hand stop the hand or prevent it from steeling by giving them a punishment that everyone else agree about it, because if the thief lose the hand how he or she is going to work and make their own living,! also, the Quran is very clear and easy to understand, but we need to work on properly understanding the real meaning of every single arabic word because one arabic word gives a different meaning at the same time. the Quran is for all centuries, and for all times the past, present and the future.

[@VSM-cq8tp]

This is why Islam is confusion