Understanding Edom #1 - Esau & Amalek

[@raf_abreu]

Love waking up with a notification of a new lecture from Efraim! Amazing teachings as always, Baruch HaShem!

[@MarjorieBernal-v5b]

Last night, the last thing I did was to listen to one of his shiurim and I just turned on my cellphone and I'm being blessed. HaShem wants me to listen to another one!

[@Yossiloveu]

Amen, baruch HaShem❤

[@dkbrain3434]

Agreed! My day is uplifted today.

[@Growthisinthedirt]

Me too!! Love Rabbis work and lessons!! 🎉

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thank you all for the kind words!

[@slilach78]

How are you not more famous, Rabbe Efraim? Your lessons should be taught worldwide!

[@Superiorvirus]

Agreed hate Rome this time is surely hard angels appointed from above

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thank you so much!

[@haemeth42]

his videos echoe worldwide

[@rachelklein2319]

I don't speak for this rabbi, but I don't think rabbis give shiurim for fame.

[@slilach78]

@@rachelklein2319 of course not, but this kind of wisdom should be spread to benefit the whole world. I wish someone with a large platform and millions of audience would interview the rabbi to share his classes for all to listen and learn.

[@Yossiloveu]

From the sea to the river, Abba Elohim will deliver❤

[@susanathompson1458]

Vimru Amen

[@abedejong6799]

From Euphraat-river to the Mediterranean sea

[@TupacMakaveli1996]

I'm Muslim but this was powerful. Let's see what we can do here together. Peace to our Jewish brothers.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thank you, peace and blessings to you as well!

[@AverageAmerican]

Shalom, family. Much love to you! hal le lu YAH

[@JudeaEloise85]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/rqfHlJKwj9-Slbcsi=AoJqZMBsYJCSHC50

[@JudeaEloise85]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/sHWYf4Csir2Bos0si=kwkOACC7d845cXcH

[@FrankReynolds-y1y]

Says the lamb to the wolf 😂😂😂

[@lzimmerman1762]

I agree with the other commenter! You should be worldwide famous. Your teachings are incredible!!

[@JoshuaLeon-b2s]

Rabbi Efraim, I had a strange journey to finding your channel and also many other Rabbi's channels. I grew up Christian(LDS) specifically and never felt too connected to that religion and the teachings didn't seem to be based in truth. 3 years I've worked at my current job, and three years a Rabbi would come during grape harvest to ensure the grape juice is Kosher. This year I asked if he would answer some questions I had. He told me about being a Noahide and answered all questions I had. You're lecture on being a noahide was how i find your channel. I would come to learn on my breaks and after work would spend hours talking with him. I love the way you speak in Hebrew but then explain what was said in English. Many Rabbi's talk in Hebrew with jo explanation and i get lost. Thank you for your content and god bless you.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Glad to hear, thanks for sharing :) May God bless you too!

[@iraseiden]

Steady as you go. Enjoy the journey and learning. Certainly a huge percentage of us who are Jewish find Hebrew daunting... yet, starting with basics and it becomes a natural learning process. Many Rabbis teaching use the Hebrew words as they hold the real wealth of meanings - plural. Learnt the aleph bet. Learn some of the names you know Israel, Jerusalem, Abraham, Isaac, Sarah, Naomi etc. Take your time.

[@onlythetruth883]

​@@EfraimPalvanov Are you New Testament Christian as well?

[@EfraimPalvanov]

@@onlythetruth883 Nope. See 'Judaism vs. Christianity' here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/gJjJaJt4fNatgK8

[@Viral_Christology]

Christianity represents the new covenant based on the atonement provided by the Lord as prophesied in Tanakh: *"And I will establish my covenant with thee; and thou shalt know that I am the Lord: That thou mayest remember, and be confounded, and never open thy mouth any more because of thy shame, when I provide ATONEMENT toward thee for ALL that thou hast done, saith the Lord God."* Judaism is the EVL that Moses prophesied in Deu.t 31:29 would befall the Jewish people in the latter days. Hope it helps.

[@plstewaf3]

First time viewer here! I learned something new around 13:20 (Gen. 26:26-30) about how the Philistines of old did what Hamas is doing today. They destroy what Israel makes and then want to make a treaty and also play the victim card. Some things never change. As a Christ follower, I learned that one weakness of mine was not understanding the Hebrew culture and writings (including various Dead Sea scrolls). Removing my so-called "Western mindset", it opens the Word of God in a dynamic and living way. Keep up the teaching.

[@steveryder1174]

If we judge everyone from their ancestors the children of Israel be condemned.

[@AWBR_777]

You are e dumb 😂

[@jimwnek9098]

The Israelis and CIA made hamas just like Bush and company with the CIA invented ISIS both for never ending wars and for $$ for Satanic agenda

[@paulawallace8784]

Without the False Teachings of Jesus/Cult of Christianity there would be no Islam, no False Teacher Mohammed, no Hamas, no Nazis, no Isis, no Killer Crusaders, no Hezbollah, no Inquisition, no PLO, no Pogroms, etc.,.

[@paulawallace8784]

Both cults of Jesus have STAINED the Land of the Living with the Blood of Gd's Firstborn Son/High Holy Ones, Israel the Jews.

[@barberton3695]

I need to thank you Rabbi, for the wonderful way you teach your lessons, all the research you have put into each class. May HaShem bless you and protect you, always.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thank you, and may you be blessed greatly as well!

[@TS_12345]

Yes...we must be aware of the good part of Esau/Edom who is now making amends and helping heal the world. Thank you Efraim. You are a treasure - a master teacher.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thank you so much for the kind words.

[@calsimon7975]

Listening to you is like putting the pieces of a Torah puzzle together.

[@DesirePurity1]

Thank you for this well-organised and informative shiur. May HaShem continue to bless you.

[@isasalaam5055]

Cold day ahead here in Dublin. I have all your five books to start studying. But it can all wait as I watch this video for the first time with a hot drink of tea. Thank you...

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Cold here in Toronto, too :) Thank you so much for getting the books!

[@isasalaam5055]

@@EfraimPalvanov Thank you so much Efraim for scripting them....:)

[@martiendejong8857]

I love this analyzing of scriptures. Although I have little affinity with judaism myself I am intrigued by the stories and metaphors and it really helps me form and evolve my beliefs.

[@drewaksparky1013]

“Old Testament”, as we Christian’s say it. Since it is Old I generally pay little attention to it. Then I happen to come across your channel. Old is now vivid, I can see it, actually hear it. Thank you Rabbi Efraim. May Yahweh bless you and your family.

[@Namko78]

Looking forward to part 2! Thank you

[@gedcaeneus4628]

I really appreciate your forthright description of your beliefs. I wish more rabbis were like you.

[@tatianaabdurazakova3839]

Toda Raba dear Rabbi !!! Thanks to HASHEM for the great wisdom which He gives us through you !!!

[@EfraimPalvanov]

My pleasure!

[@CherLombard]

His wonderful name is YHUH Yod Hay Uah Hay pronounced Yahuah. He is the Elohim of Abraham, Yitsaac, and Yaacob.

[@SoliDeoGloria-s5u]

I'm not going to pretend to know more about the Old Testament than you do Mr. Palvanov but I discovered something I think is worth looking at. When Ezekiel prophesied to Gog of Maygog I ask myself who inhabited Central Asia during that time period and what I discovered was Cimmerians and Scythians inhabited the region as the Turks came later why is this important? This where Indo-Iranians and not the Arabs living in Iran. These people settled North of the Caucasus Mountains what would be southern Russia. Also striking the Russians consider themselves there own unique civilization as well as inheritors of the one and true faith once Constantinople fell even considering themselves the 3rd Rome. They are looking for a messianic figure in the form of the last Tsar. And the red color you mentioned in the lesson brought this to mind. Again humbly I am not pretending to know more than anyone else but there are parallels that should at least be addressed. Thank you for your time and insights and may God bless you.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Absolutely, spoke all about this in the old series on the Third Rome here: kzbin.info/aero/PLS68IUQOA2itggHThMzjQMnzoC4epda5d

[@martiendejong8857]

Aren't the Indo-Iranians the ancient Aryans that the nazis were so fond of and thought was their ancestry?

[@michelles5439]

@@EfraimPalvanovare you living in Israel rabbi?

[@EfraimPalvanov]

@@michelles5439 Not yet, hopefully soon.

[@SoliDeoGloria-s5u]

@@EfraimPalvanov Thank you sir and I don't know if this is correct but to tie these peoples back to Daniel there God was Santa the God of war or the God of forces. I'm watching the refenced video now. Thank you for your time.

[@Chanaross144]

Thank u rabbis! U speeches are so clear and down to earth!

[@jodijustice4140]

Thank you for shining a light , a help to everyone to see more clearly.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

My pleasure!

[@GraceCadwallader]

Great teaching ❤ i need to watch more! Thank you

[@andrewbales8579]

He is amazing. Whats interesting is the Torah does not use the term שֵׂעִיר (Se’ir, typically meaning “goat” or “hairy”) in the context of the goat hair covering of the Mishkan. Instead, it explicitly uses עִזִּים (Izzim), which directly means “goats.” The term שֵׂעִיר is used elsewhere in the Torah, often in the context of male goats for offerings or other symbolic uses, but not in the description of the Mishkan coverings. This distinction is significant and aligns with the Torah’s precision in language as the Rav states in his shir.

[@taniaoliveira7979]

52:25 - Timna was rejected and produced Amalek. On the other hand, Ruth was not rejected and produced Mashiach.

[@yazl8419]

Toda rabbah Rabbi Palvanov. All your schiurim are so very special. I was made aware of the awesome HaRav HaGaon HaYanuka many years ago, ever since he spoke of Keter Elyon/ Corona. You both love Hashem and that speaks so much to my Noachide soul.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Glad to hear, thank you :)

[@jeffwarren9274]

Thank you for bringing clarity to this issue, Efraim. I’ve been studying the Word of Hashem, and the words of the Sages very hard over the last year especially, to bring clarity to this. Your video here has brought a lot of clarity for me. Baruch Hashem

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Glad to hear, thanks!

[@brandysheriff2515]

I'm so glad I came across your account! Thank you for sharing your lesson. I will continue to learn from you!

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Happy to hear, thanks :)

[@j.lsantos9106]

Excellent delivery and quality service

[@ikbdim]

Iam now addicted to your lectures. This is masterpiece information. Emes is clearly seen. ברוך יי .

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thank you!

[@arroyonpr]

❤ Thank you! Superb as usual. Looking forward to part 2!

[@EfraimPalvanov]

My pleasure!

[@Jasn_Chvz]

Every time I listen to these my mind is blown. Thank you sir.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Glad to hear, very welcome!

[@AshleyLovesTheLord]

Whoa! Instant subscribe to your channel! I wish the Bible was taught like this to us Christians in the West. Our English translations don’t even give us 1/5th of the full story! We really need the Hebrew unlocked to have the full story! This is so cool! Thank you!

[@EfraimPalvanov]

My pleasure! Thanks for subscribing :)

[@justinallen2408]

It's all been purpl9sely rewritten

[@justinallen2408]

By Christians

[@TheMalka770]

YES. Another good one! Pics of maps and Articles help .

[@conniemason-bennett1800]

There is a story of the wheat and the tares growing together until the end. You can’t point a finger at anyone, Europe, America, Iraq, Egypt…as being Edom. Tel Abib has more Law-less ones than San Francisco. Did you not see the Buddha at the dance party that was attacked on Oct. 7, 2023 ?

[@RodrigoOswego]

What's wrong with the Buddha?

[@conniemason-bennett1800]

@ ,nothing if you want to worship other gods.

[@RodrigoOswego]

@@conniemason-bennett1800 he's not a god though, just a man who taught people how to meditate and to follow a set of moral rules.

[@johnobtrains]

Uhm, Russ or Ruse, the Red Nation, this one seems elementary but I will try to learn from this presentation.

[@johnobtrains]

Yup, the idea is don't deweed the "Garden" as to not disturb the good fruit.

[@AmPa-ve3bf]

Appreciate your content. Thank you so much, Rabbi Efraim. Your students are very blessed to have you. We are blessed as well. ❤ Noahide

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thank you for the kind words :)

[@wickiezulu]

The Rabbi Sacks quote immediately brings to mind Gad Saad's notion of mind viruses and idea pathogens, as mentioned in the Parasitic Mind and elsewhere.

[@CarlJohnson-kk4pr]

Rabbi Efraim your speaking of what i have been studying on as forever!!!!

[@Superiorvirus]

Open all the doors of Edom

[@glenanleitner2606]

Thank you for this Very good teaching

[@dianefester9663]

Thank you. I like hearing you and your perspective on things. I have learnt something.🎉

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Very welcome!

[@mare6419]

Oh joy! Another wonderful shuir! Thank you! Do you do zoom classes? It would be great to hear these live. ❤

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thank you! No Zoom classes at the moment. If you subscribe to the newsletter on my website, I will notify about future Zoom classes. (There should be a couple later in December, in collaboration with 'Jews for Judaism'.)

[@mare6419]

@@EfraimPalvanov great! I already follow Jews for Judaism and Rabbi Skobac.

[@Growthisinthedirt]

Yaaayy!! Zoom Classes!! ❤

[@rhodapillay9200]

As a Christian, I love the old testament tied to the new .In the morning I read the old Testament and evening I the new testment.All that you mentioned about Ismail is so true.

[@giffica]

Here. We. Go. 💯

[@Superiorvirus]

So maybe my grandpa looked into my eyes as well they both saw in Torah ?

[@spiritandtruth4773]

Have you considered the posibility of beeing Edom ?. When I read the curses in Deutenomy 28. It does not describe the people who now live in the land of Israel... Something to consider, Shalom

[@fransrabie6609]

Spelling backwards meaning "mode" "fashion".

[@AbdullahiSaint]

Edom Noihsaf

[@Superiorvirus]

Gossip girl xoxo they used the system I should really see the first born however the cave was in

[@user-pd7il3xz5j]

You are mixing Hebrew words with English words. English is not the Holy language that Hebrew is, so that's only a coincidence. If anything, it just shows you have an insightful brain.

[@peterslapak]

Your comment at 1:13:00 told me everything. I know now what is this presentation all about.

[@AllegedlyDave]

You are Edom, true Israel is awake and we know who you are.

[@Galaxy_1-kys]

👍

[@CrowdKillerSN95]

Who is the real goyim ?

[@Mikaelyahsharal4450]

YES!!!!!!!! And they're trying to hold on to their lies.

[@CastorTroy-x2y]

You gave an incredible speech rabbe efraim.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thanks!

[@francisvaccino2753]

A note though. The Philistines were historical Greeks. The modern Palestinians are of Arab origin, of Jordanian, Egyptian, Lebanese, Judaean and Samarian, descent.

[@bbmbezalb2697]

And the modern Jews are mostly western Europeans and their country s government is a genocidal Rothschild khabalistic demonic system

[@RodrigoOswego]

Modern Palestinians are a mix of many nations. There's plenty of genetic data available on the web.

[@ggpmf]

Im a christian.Thank you for your generous sharing of your knowledge.

[@KosherGoddess]

Thank you so much! Your lesson are the best out there, I can't wait for next one, meanwhile relistening to so many others!

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Glad to hear, thank you!

[@wickiezulu]

Esau originally approached his uncle Ishmael to propose an alliance of convenience, saying to the effect of - "You kill your brother (Isaac), I will kill my brother (Jacob) and we will both inherit Abraham's legacy to rule the world together". Only for Ishmael to see that Esau was mad and would likely kill him not long after in order to be sole inheritor, until he was reassured by Esau who married his uncle's daughter Malahath producing Reuel (who otherwise had a seemingly unremarkable life).

[@IamDaniel247]

Phenomenal lesson Rabbi 👍🏼

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thank you!

[@MrSparkums]

Obadiah 2 Behold, I have made thee small among the heathen: thou art greatly despised. 3 The pride of thine heart hath deceived thee, thou that dwellest in the clefts of the rock, whose habitation is high; that saith in his heart, Who shall bring me down to the ground? 4 Though thou exalt thyself as the eagle, and though thou set thy nest among the stars, thence will I bring thee down, saith the Lord. .... 18And the house of Jacob shall be a fire, and the house of Joseph a flame, and the house of Esau for stubble, and they shall kindle in them, and devour them; and there shall not be any remaining of the house of Esau; for the Lord hath spoken it.

[@airborneexplorer]

I want to convert to this line of scripture and history. Raised in Christianity and open to all tribes of God. However my faith is being tested and I'm failing so bad. This teacher on this 1 video has woken my mind to my current situation. I don't know where to go from here but thank you for this video. God bless all and please be peace

[@dkbrain3434]

Visit your local Chabad and speak with a Rabbi.

[@Viral_Christology]

Why would you want to leave the salvation (Yeshuah) of our God the Father for Judaism (referred to as evil in Deut. 31:29)?

[@pegiecrouch5716]

Thank you so much for your teachings, I have a question, upon reading Isaiah 34 regarding the nations particularly Edom which apparently was an actual place at one time I believe you did state that in your lesson, but I read in the-commentary from the Jewish Study Bible that The Edomites converted to Judaism en masse during the late 2nd century BCE & were among the most zealous Jews during the conflict with Rome in the 1st century CE. Is that correct?

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Very welcome :) Will speak about the Edomite conversion in Part 2. Stay tuned!

[@Viral_Christology]

@@EfraimPalvanovThe Jews are descendants of both Jacob and Esau. Those of Jacob are Christian while those who gravitate towards Judaism are of Esau.

[@alisonlangridge7431]

I wonder is that to do with King Herod attempting to kill Jesus As a baby in Matthew 2:3-12? Later Jesus said to beware of the Herodians?

[@rachelkennedy2161]

Brilliant lesson, you always make the knowledge easy and exciting to follow. Thank you so much for sharing Rabbi 😇💜💯👏🙏

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thank you Rachel!

[@jeffwarren9274]

What are your thoughts on the Jesus crucifixion narrative, specifically in regard to its parallels with the goat sacrifice to Azazel? Of course, I’m mainly referencing Jesus Barabbas VS Jesus Christ? In my opinion, this drama story & the revelation noted in the apocryphal work “The Apocalypse of Abraham” gives a very concerning message regarding what Christianity truly is. It’s terrifying for unassuming Christians, in my opinion. Have you looked into these things, Efraim?

[@EfraimPalvanov]

I have not, though I shared my general thoughts on Christianity here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/gJjJaJt4fNatgK8

[@jeffwarren9274]

@ Thank you for taking the time to respond. I’ll listen

[@Kantbeewrong]

​@@EfraimPalvanovof course not

[@carlosa.n5100]

As a Noahide, I attended an American sports event last night after 6 years. I can say this with 1000% certainty. If you are Jewish or Noahide, run away from the cities! I felt such an evil emananting from the stadium, and I understood that God wanted me to see the true face of the city. Go to Israel or prepare to leave the big cities. I don't know what's coming, but my spirit felt such a disturbance. Many people had the faces of dogs and gluttonous mockery.

[@judgeholden849]

What do you mean a “Noahide”? I am familiar with the concept but I have never seen anyone self-identify with it. Usually “Noahides” identify with their faith, ie Christianity, Islam

[@user-ue4he3li8b]

What of Israelites "going into the wilderness where a place was made for them" during such times? Sorry, but that Dome gonna BLOW.

[@Viral_Christology]

Noahide, Are you aware that the so-called covenant of Noah was made with all living creatures meaning your pets and the cockroaches in your kitchen are your fellow Noahides?

[@Rahel8811]

@@judgeholden849made up religion from the rabbis

[@carlosa.n5100]

​@Rahel8811 it's not a religion. It's basically God fearing gentiles. Like Noah, Shem, Eber, Job... etc etc

[@andrewbales8579]

Asav and Rome are connected through TZepho, the son of Eliphaz, son of Asav. When Yaakov Avenu was being buried at Machpellah, and Asav tried to stop the 12 brothers and their sons from accessing the kever, the brothers battled with Asav after Hushim, the deaf son of Dan killed Asav. The battle ended with some sons of Asav being captured by Yosef et Tzadik and others killed or ran away. Those captured included TZepho who was brought back to Mitzriam. After 50 years when Yosef et Tzadik, passed away, Tzepho escaped and eventually came to Rome. He became the father of Rome. Consieer this was 3500 years ago and Rome was founded about 2800 years ago.

[@Viral_Christology]

Edom is the people of Judaism No doubt about it

[@VirusVanquisher]

Another great lesson, thank you!

[@Superiorvirus]

Time to go to sleep

[@Superiorvirus]

Thanks plans

[@EfraimPalvanov]

My pleasure!

[@nuggetoftruth-ericking7489]

This was interesting. Thanks.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

My pleasure!

[@kellykonrad9273]

It sure is an eye opener & quite disturbing to see how Edom (Esav) & Ishmael are collaborating together these days, against Israel.

[@jrutt2675]

Jews are Edom!

[@iaintmadatcha]

Wait until you get your head deep into the prophecies and you realize who the Israelites today really are. Not only will Your eyes be opened , your mind will be

[@jrutt2675]

@iaintmadatcha Yeah, White Christians fufill3d all the promises given unto the house of Jacob!

[@spaceghostcoast2coast614]

They're not known for receptive revelation 😂 ​@@iaintmadatcha

[@megaape]

@@iaintmadatchawho are they?

[@michaelstriemer5179]

Genuine question here, My family is originally from Silesia Poland. One of My Ancestors was born in a place called Kalish his name was Rabbi Jacob Ben Joseph Striemer, he was an Ashkenazi Sage in 1700. He was an early follower of Sabbatia Zvi before he violently opposed him for his apostacy for claiming to be the Messiah. I mention this because many in my family Converted to the Mennonite faith and traveled to Odessa Ukraine, and between 1917 and 1956 3/4 of my Mennonite brothers were murdered by the Bolshevik's and we had to flee to Canada. From my understanding Sabathia Zvi was a Jewish Mystic who lived in Turkey and later Converted to Islam for fear of death from the Sultan. A man by the name of Jacob Frank claimed to be the reincarnation of Zvi and was one of the big players in modern Marxism and was heavily involved in the Occult. From my own personal studies Edom was in what we call modern day Jordan, which in itself is a nation of Edom, Moab, and Ammon. I understand Edom is also Kittim and Kittim is also Rome. But I also stumbled on that in 200 BC the Jews under John Hyrcacus forced converted the Edmomites and assimilated them into Judea. So with all respect, do you think it is feasible that Marxism and its atrocities which Karl Marx was the father of may have been due to the intermixing of Jacobs and Esau's bloodline., which was always forbidden in the Torah? Secondly I have been studying the Dead Sea scrolls which predate Christ and they appear to resemble Christian theology more than Rabbinic theology. I have just finished the Testaments of the Patriarchs and found it an incredible read. Does anyone have any thoughts? I am convinced the Nazi's were involved with the Occult from my research and were responsible for some of the most savage atrocities in human history. They were famous for the Roman (edom) salute. Could it be possible the Soviet atrocities may have had a similar occult connection?

[@element2138]

Is all this the same subject? Do you have sources, you're be able to share?

[@RodrigoOswego]

@@michaelstriemer5179 the Erev Rav came with Moses out of Egypt. Google Rabbi Alon Anava and Erev Rav together. He does a good job tying all those people and subjects you mentioned together.

[@RodrigoOswego]

@@element2138 Google Rabbi Alon Anava and Erev Rav together if you want to understand.

[@lilianaedwards503]

Rabbi Palvanov, I'm blown away at how you present your material and information, make it so interesting to listen and learn. I wish they taught like this in schools.. Do you ever come to NY? Would love to have you speak in our community. Please let me know if that's possible. May Hashem bless you to continue spreading His light into this world. 🙌

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thank you Liliana. Send me an email and we can discuss. May Hashem bless you as well!

[@joshuaerinoehler2377]

I love your teachings and I am so glad that I found you. Thank you for the invaluable body of work my friend.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Happy to hear, my pleasure!

[@smariscal24]

Evil existe because of balance? ying yang? ... nah, evil exist because of free will.

[@AmPa-ve3bf]

Look at the broader spectrum. Rabbi only mentioned just this. HaShem created good and evil. Of course, people have free will. The existence of evil forces is not from freewill.

[@shirleyannelindberg1692]

HaShem creates ALL, good and evil • • Isaiah 45:5-7 We have been given free will, and it’s incumbent upon us to choose Life, HaShem says: Deuteronomy 30:19 “I call heaven and earth to witness against you today, that I have set before you life and death, blessing and curse. Therefore choose life, that you and your offspring may live.”

[@shirleyannelindberg1692]

HaShem creates ALL, good and evil • • Isaiah 45:5-7 We have been given free will, and it’s incumbent upon us to choose Life, HaShem says: Deuteronomy 30:19 “I call heaven and earth to witness against you today, that I have set before you life and death, blessing and curse. Therefore choose life, that you and your offspring may live.”

[@caos870]

Dear Rabbi Efraim, could you make a video about "Astral Projection"? It would be really interesting, bringing together this topic with Judaism, specially with your in-depth research. And maybe answer some questions, like: - What does Judaism say about this? Is it true or just a "illusory dream"? - If true, is there a prohibition against intentionally cause it? - I'm not sure, but I heard something like Moshe was the only one that could talk to G-d "face to face", while the others talked in dreams. Could it be possible that these "dreams" were astral projections?

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Will add it to the list of topics. (Might be a while before I get to it.) Thanks for the suggestion.

[@TovaRW2850]

Love it! Question what are your thoughts on the Torah Anthology set? Me’am Loez please 😊

[@EfraimPalvanov]

I am a huge fan of Rabbi Aryeh Kaplan and recommend all of his works.

[@haemeth42]

I appreciate your stand Rabbi Yosef concerning the convertions.

[@blakena5043]

Thank you. Much appreciated.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

My pleasure!

[@CarmenRizzo-k8q]

Teach the Truth , " Takes Two too Tango " , " All I want is the Truth " ❤

[@Zackadamchaussette5228]

Amazing wisdom rabbi shalom and thanks a lot my 2 baby boys and myself are learning.. blessings for YOU and your Love ones and all the jewish People...a plus

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thank you, may you and your family be blessed as well!

[@doctordove]

Great stuff as usual!

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thanks Dov!

[@doctordove]

@@EfraimPalvanov Only 966 comments this time? ;) Amazingly great that you stay on top of this. You're a machine, man! More importantly, it was great learning all you downloaded into my wee brain from this talk. Edom#2 coming right up!😆

[@EfraimPalvanov]

@@doctordove Thank you! Hope to see you soon :)

[@MrSeadawg123]

15 minutes in. And it is pretty clear. That this is a very well crafted fictional story! I really have to ask. How can anyone not see this. As just another fictional manmade creation story.

[@jeremiahWNM]

Read the Talmud. A bunch of fictional stories. The toilet/bathroom demons and resultant rituals is a really funny one.

[@EvelynVolsi]

Toha rabbah Rabbi! As always, an amazing class! I problay watched all your classes and I am always eager to hear more and more from you. May Hashem bless you and your family endlessly! May you be right about Mashiach and soon we will hear about it! ❤❤ Shabbat Shalom!

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thank you Evelyn, may you and your family be blessed tremendously as well!

[@Viral_Christology]

@@EfraimPalvanovAre you an x-Christian?

[@EfraimPalvanov]

@@Viral_Christology Nope, 100% Jewish and always have been.

[@avisting]

Great lesson as always

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thanks!

[@ladyhawkNone]

I just discovered you! I've learned so much here. Ty

[@nurit-uz9te]

great as always toda raba

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thank you!

[@ahavahyisrael]

Thx for this chidish about musk and yanuka. Also there was Yehudit, a resident of beeri

[@asafgozlan]

Miss you down here bud, hope all is well and not too cold up there... going with the guys to learn with Dovber Pinson tonight and will mention you to him if I get the chance

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thanks Asaf! Hope to see you guys again real soon :)

[@franhunter-r9r]

So great! Subscribed your lectures are terrific!

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thank you so much!

[@sherylkruger3344]

Amazing. Thank you so much Rabbi

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Very welcome :)

[@caseysvision]

Thanks for addresing a question i had for years. But I am still wandring. Where does Aisov end up on Europe?

[@EfraimPalvanov]

See Part 2: kzbin.info/www/bejne/Y4vbh3tvZs57htU

[@my2cworth4U]

Fascinating! You are a gift to humanity. Thank you 💝

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Thank you so much!

[@Growthisinthedirt]

Your topics are always exciting!! Thanks Rabbi!! 🥳🎉🌹✡️🌌

[@EfraimPalvanov]

My pleasure!

[@Growthisinthedirt]

@EfraimPalvanov I'm half way thru and haven't heard you speak of Esau killing Nimrod that day for Adam and Eve's magical clothes that he wanted (studied that in Sef o. So he was hungry after the murders and that explains part of why he was so hungry. I think he thought H' is going to kill me for what I've done so I don't need my birthright. I need food now. 🤗

[@Growthisinthedirt]

@@EfraimPalvanov I read this backstory in SEFARIA. Maybe a Targum, not sure tho. We talked about this once before how Rabbis don't share this back story that makes the birthright sale for soup totally make sense. Thanks for all of your hard work. 😍 From Memphis Tennessee 🤗

[@onlythetruth883]

How are the "two sticks" related to all this? And where are the ten lost tribes in relation to Judah? What is the connection and the future of them?

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Please see the class on the Lost Tribes here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/iIOvcmx-jtCXnas

[@grandfrosty]

Have you heard about the Hopi indian prophecy with the "Red Hat Man". Then we have Mr. Maga with his red hat fun. I thought it might be relevant, as an aside.

[@AverageAmerican]

Red haired giants might be relatives of Esau. Bcuz he married Canaanites.

[@chuckdeuces911]

Yeah, real relevant... Did you make that up to make yourself feel better for now?

[@1GoodDag]

Yes I've heard this.... interesting times no?

[@1GoodDag]

​@@chuckdeuces911 hey troll.... we are correct you are wrong..... 🤷‍♂️

[@rocdajacable]

Are you aware of the Egg 🥚 = mork from Ork Fred Flintstone Happy Days Cobblestone masons Orson wells War of the World's all have in common just a few

[@RykDavid]

Thank you! Reading Zohar, "And he lived ...", currently (Volume 7).

[@EE-eu9vo]

I never thought I would say this…but Covid opened up the Torah to us like never before in history! Baruch Hashem!

[@suzipuzi2001]

After thinking about it for many years, the beginnings of the pandemic motivated me to finally become shomer Shabbat, at age 40. And also to tighten up my kashrut.

[@suzipuzi2001]

The beginnings of the pandemic motivated me to finally become shomer Shabbat, at age 40, after thinking about it for many years. And also to tighten up my kashrut.

[@rebecaoquendo7363]

I so appreciate your lectures, i wish I could send my son to your Yeshiva

[@annettemccoy7458]

I'm a Christian and I am learning a lot from your lessons. Some of this I have learned but not from a Jewish perspective and not in such depth. Thank you for your lessons.

[@kittykat632]

Did you know that the liquid that the "trophy wives" took to make them barren was stated in the book of Enoch?

[@Kazat0pia]

Do not be deceived. Judea fell long ago to these people who pretend to be Judah (yet God is not truly within them). What does Jesus tell us about them?

[@FlacoLaPalm]

​@kittykat632 really I've listened to Enoch but I must have missed it. What is it?

[@batyalevy5876]

So for all these generations we've been pretending...learning Torah,keeping Shabbos and holidays,praying to G-d, circumcising our boys,suffering progroms etc Do you realize how ridiculous that claim is?!​@@Kazat0pia

[@annettemccoy7458]

@@batyalevy5876 You've been deceived by some Jews in name only. They call themselves Rabbis and Priest but they really work for Satan. Only the people at the top know this, not the dear brethren who love and worship God. They know the Messiah came, but they didn't want to lose their power and status. Why do you think there has not been a Temple and sacrifices since 66 AD? After Christs death and resurrection, God directed the destruction of Jerusalem and the Temple and also the Roman Empire. The remaining unbelieving Israelites and the remaining unbelieving Roman's came together to create a new society of their making, the New World Order. That's the partnership that created the modern day Holy Roman Catholic Church and modern day Jewish religion in Israel. They are the "elites" in secret societies who infiltrate everything and corrupt everything in order to gain more global power. Even Christianity has been corrupted by these people. It's up to us to learn all we can from God's inspired words to his prophets and disciples of Christ, as well as, what we can from documented history to find the truth. Praying for everyone to find truth! May God protect us all from these unseen predators, their deceptions and their weapons!

[@CarmenRizzo-k8q]

Selfishness Jealousy , " You're still too worldly " you are all the same

[@jeniferlalite3374]

All of you are Esau Descendents.

[@ZackWolfMusic]

Yup they wanna ignore it 😅

[@AWBR_777]

And you probably as well 😂 1/3 of 🥷🏿 in America come from a 🙋🏼 granddaddy down the line. All of you have a minimum 20% 🙋🏼🧬

[@ZackWolfMusic]

@@AWBR_777 nope 🙅‍♀️

[@AWBR_777]

@@ZackWolfMusic Regardless of who you are. These are facts. 🥷🏿 don't believe in 🙋🏼 science unless they are trying to prove they *"ain't the father."* Then, and only then, do they start dancing and acting like 🤡

[@ZackWolfMusic]

@AWBR_777 you is edom your words are just like there's aka the white man

[@gracejoy5339]

How is it IDF can see to know which buildings & towns to target but not machines & materials & fuel to build tunnels. And how many hours they didn't see Oct 7? I was enjoying your shiur until then. Now I'll take a break before listening to the rest, which so far is excellent. Thank you 🙏

[@fightingfinn1503]

Good cameras. 😉

[@MrSparkums]

Something tells me you won't be pointing out that King Herod and his "Herodians" were Edomites.. Or that Gog/Togarmah's brother is Ashkenaz.. Or that according to the Jewish Encyclopedia 👉"In his letter Hasdai speaks of the tradition according to which the Chazars dwelt near the Seir, Serir Mountains(Edom); he refers to the narrative of Eldad ha-Dani, who thought he had discovered the Lost Ten Tribes; and inquires whether the Chazars know anything concerning "the end of miracles" (the coming of the Messiah).".. 👎

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Actually I do plan to speak about it in Part 2. Herod will be a major focus of the class (currently subtitled "Trump & Herod"). Gog and Ashkenaz are in my notes, too, though will probably have to leave that for Part 3.

[@MrSparkums]

​@@EfraimPalvanovI think you should do more research into all this, see the Haplogroup J Y-DNA geographical map.. Who else was the Bull associated with, in "Israel"? Who was promised the fruitful blessing "his seed shall become a multitude of nations", "in thee shall Israel bless", "he shall push the people to the ends of the Earth"? Who was it said would be regathered and rejoined with actual "Judah".. Islam's origin comes from Edom, hence the Saturnian symbolism..

[@uiticus]

Can you do a video on the power of reciting the Tehilim?

[@EfraimPalvanov]

I hope to start a series on the entire Tanakh soon (one class per book). Stay tuned!

[@francisgalton2678]

Oh brother. The land was already as prosperous as it needed to be. I can watch videos of Palestine before 1940. It was doing fine. Just because people can flood down there from Europe with European money and implements does not make Palestinians Edomites in the repurposing of the Hebrew Epic. Please.

[@EfraimPalvanov]

First of all, I never said Palestinians are Edomites. Palestinians are Arab Ishmaelites. Second, the Holy Land started to prosper once more starting in the late 1800s due to Jewish migration, investment, and hard work. Prior to that, it was dead and barren - read how Mark Twain or Ulysses Grant described it when they visited. And please see the class on the 'Hidden History of Zionism' here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/haLci4ijZZqibdk

[@dkbrain3434]

@@EfraimPalvanov🔥

[@francisgalton2678]

@@EfraimPalvanov ok, I will accept your points but if it was so barren and if Palestinians a Arab Israelis and they are clearly the descendants of Edomites and nobody in Europe is descendants of any edomite or anyone in the deserts of Palestine, then why was there such a need to push more than half a million Palestinians into a refugee status and off into other places? It's so obvious that Esau is not red because he was some kind of Celt or European, Edomites are probably indistinguishable from Arabs before they started mixing with other pedigrees, they are not Europeans genetically or culturally. These stories about curses on babies are clearly not prophesies, they are hate speach created after the populations became rivals. Hate speak is the root of Bible history and it's the glue that keeps the notion as a indivisible Jewish genetic identity going. If Esau breeding with Hotties makes Europe Edom then so does it make all the European Jews Edom but being red and hairy does not invite the inference that Esau is the origin of Europeans red hair and hairy arms. I have heard a great deal of this hate for Europe expressed by associating them with Esau or Amalek, frankly it's something that only a cult religion can follow. It lacks any more linguistic, archeological or genetic support than the claims that the lost ten tribes of Israel became Europe. Anyone can see that those who cling to the notions that Esau was the father of the baddies would have to marvel at how good they actually became in reality. Who has blessed the whole world and how did they do this? It certainly has not been through tax collection, money lending, debt financed wars and terrorism. If Esau had a nature that you are impugning the European mind with, and it seems that this is exactly what you and other Rabbis do for fun, then, why is it that Jacob always wants to live among us? Why not China or India or Africa someplace without following European pioneers to these places? Europe had some bad leaders, the worst leaders have always been those that picked up the ideas that the Hebrew Epic was playing out again among themselves and taking on new meaning, for over a thousand years Rome was persecuting Europeans and others, Rome was no friend of any red haired people. Rome never met any Europeans that they liked until they had been destroyed by the Norse and the Goths and Rome became less Roman. Rome didn't like the Gauls Brits or the Germans, or Phoenicians either, wouldn't that make Essay a strange Red Haired "Viking" prototype? . No, Rome looked more like Palestinian Arabs than Celts, and it's unlikely that he was actually a real person because in creating the Hebrew Epic, the actual Hebrew are mysteriously left out of the story and we find instead Canaanites, Hittites and Arabs. If we take Hotties for proto Iranians and Greeks and Philistines for cousins, then it's difficult to see any reason why Esau being red should make it easier to buy the claim that the Romans were Edom. Now if you want to say that Edom was populated by Arab Israelites, ok, now I can see some possibility to work that out, but the rest of the world should not be factored into Noah's nutsack or Abraham's nutsack. I have no issue with the claims that Hebrews are a very large part in the ancestry of southern Europe, but they were not descendants of Abraham and they were not Arabs, maybe they were descendants of Noah, but that's as far as I think anyone can go with the claim that Abrahams nutsack is related to any European people.

[@EstSchom]

What I appreciate about your teachings are with sources and it’s very שכלי . In this Messianic era , I want to hear things as they are straight from our books

[@mare6419]

Listening to this shuir again and noticed how you mention you don't like "conspiracy theories" I've heard many people say this recently, the "fun" part of conspiracy theories is how many of them are conspiracy fact! I look forward to more of your lectures. ❤❤

[@ElkadyLeech]

Rabbi Efraim Speaking of Amalek and the disbelief of God and the afterlife. I am dating a Jewish girl, she is a good human being but she has been through a lot in her life that led her to become a disbeliever. What is good approach to get her back on the right path?

[@EfraimPalvanov]

Send me an email and we can discuss.

[@ElkadyLeech]

@ thank you What is your email?

[@EfraimPalvanov]

@@ElkadyLeech Contact info on my website.

[@CarmenRizzo-k8q]

Judah split from Israel , Wake Up. !