Red Dead Redemption 2 | New Austin Map Comparison | RDR 1 vs RDR2 Evolution

[@Doublepulse]

Imagine for a minute if RDR 2 would continue into the story of the first game and its just one huge game lasting over 150+ hours lol. Like both games in one package.

[@TheVboyfresh]

Steven Blanton dude I thought the same shit lol

[@Jboooog18]

god you're ambitious, I love it lol

[@StillAutomatic]

I swear they need to remaster RDR 1 asap !!!

[@TheRedRaven_]

Actually I thought this too, like they just took all the new assets from RDR2 and continued right off into RDR1 as like a huge surprise for fans of the original. Oh well, missed opportunity I guess.

[@EpicMinecraftFail]

@@TheRedRaven_ dlc.

[@guilleno77]

Red dead redemption still looks very good !

[@antifeminazismachirulo9626]

on xbox one x yes.

[@supermx507]

only on xbox x sadly !

[@infernal-toad]

The reason that the difference between red dead redamption 1 and 2 is so large, is that rdr2 has fucking 105 GB next gen graphics!

[@supermx507]

@@infernal-toad don't forget reddead online !!

[@fattymcbutterpants9700]

@Salt Maker More ripples doesn't automatically make it better. The water physics are great, they interact with weather. The reason it looks flat is because there is no crazy weather. Rdr2 is better tho

[@camilorivera4241]

I feel like those people who never played the first game, simply can't understand how much we (people who spent years and years in Red dead 1) appreciate John.

[@janitor_arya9011]

I've played RDR2 and really enjoyed it, looking to play RDR1 but i don't have PS3 or Xbox 360

[@evangelicae_rationis]

I'm aware than he was considered the greatest protagonist in gaming history, well at least until black lung appeared.

[@themagicalgamer6522]

@@evangelicae_rationis nah john still solos cowpoke

[@rulingmoss5599]

@@themagicalgamer6522 Arthur is objectively better than john in every way, and I love john.

[@themagicalgamer6522]

@@rulingmoss5599 Imo they tried to give arthur many layers that, while feel good in retrospective (his failed love life/fatherhood, his blind devotion, his countless bad deeds), they basically all round up to him being unable to leave the outlaw life (the only one he has ever known) and how it subsequently took him to the grave. When i think of john, i think of how he went from a selfish, inmature, hot headed jackass that called her girl a whore and his son a bastard; To that man struggling to breath due to the blood obstructing his throat and falling to his knees because of his inmesurable love to his family. He redeemed himself by letting his past catch up to him. It just moves me to tears I still love arthur, i finished prologue yesterday and am thinking of beginning a new game bc of him. But John is miles ahead

[@Nelbone]

Going into Blackwater the first time in RDR2 was surreal.

[@mrgamerwatch100]

matt nelson Felt amazing

[@david12278]

Going to armadillo

[@Nelbone]

Muse Nico don’t get shot

[@unoriginalhazard]

@@david12278 armadillo felt underwhelming considering the situation. Was surprised by herbert moon though.

[@rickardsamuelsson7753]

Sure was a flashback

[@brucewayne-cn4vd]

Really makes you wonder what video games are going to be like in the next ten years.

[@MacGuyver85]

I think you already get an idea what is going to happen with RDR2. The graphics are awesome but what's most impressive is the increase in behavior and interaction with people/wildlife etc. You'll see AI be applied to make NPC's creepily real. So I think the biggest shift the next 10 years will be gameplay wise, instead of graphics wise.

[@Stefantius]

You're a fool if you think you're going to get a game as beautiful, or as detailed as RDR2- Most games can only dream of buying as advanced as this game is

[@Skumtomten1]

I was thinking that 10 years ago, safe to say I am disappointed.

[@JYMAHJAMES]

@@Skumtomten1 Disappointed? wow you're hard to please

[@yoda301]

Skumtomten1 ummmmmm... I'm going to pretend you didn't say that

[@MrFusion]

Tall Trees in Red Dead 1 = Creepy Tall Trees in Red Dead 2 = Calming, aside from dead bodies and maniacs trying to kill you

[@kiyavas1879]

red dead *redemption* as whole has a creepy wibe to it(maybe not mexico)unlike rdr 2 which is calming

[@lilchad-ig1oj]

And rdr1 has snow full of bears in the north when rdr2 is more trees with very little bears

[@esco5593]

Tall Trees always been creepy... back in 2013 I used to explore RDR myths (like the haunted house in Tumbleweed) and I heard a guy at Manzanita Post say the area was cursed Native land or something. There's a campfire at Manzanita Post in the first game that randomly dies out and starts again, as well as whispers you can hear at Bearclaw. Now we just have to worry about Skinners, and my theory is that along with Tall Trees being cursed land, in RDR1 it's also haunted by the people killed by the Skinners

[@kpsa7108]

@@esco5593 my theory too. Tall trees is definitely haunted by Evelyn Miller and all those tortured souls or skinner victims

[@giantrunt]

Tall trees, The bayou and roanoke are still scary.

[@BillyCobbOfficial]

RDR2 makes RDR look like it came out on PS2

[@mignonthon]

no

[@juririgged]

yes

[@xXSilentAgent47Xx]

Well, RDR was planned to be on PS2 till new gen came out.

[@cowboyofnoname5358]

It has a good graphics for ps2, dont say bullshit nigga

[@jpesicka492]

@@xXSilentAgent47Xx you're high. Revolver was on ps2, mad difference from redemption. The scale of redemption alone it would have cost it dramatically in graphics. Gta games on ps2 were broken up sandbox less detail compared to the details in rdr on xbox 360/xb 1/ps3

[@SyaninSs]

watch in 144p, they both have same graphics 👍

[@rinkorizeroing6699]

Eh ada abang

[@eff0165]

No shit

[@gamersindo15]

SyaninSs bang bahas alur cerita rdr1 ama rdr2

[@triplip2217]

No, rdr 1 better

[@SmilingSquares]

Well obviously a real life video and a game would look the same in 144p

[@3rdcoasthdz]

1:23 oh how much i miss that noise

[@Multi9LiVES]

Straight up I miss it too much

[@ClemsonFan46]

RDR2 is the superior game no doubt, but yeah those musical stings from the old game are just so much better. I got so excited when I heard that Mexican trumpet in RDR2 while riding along the river in New Austin.

[@miceonrice]

yes i miss it so much the joy it gives me is unlike anything else

[@ReservoirPunk]

@@ClemsonFan46 Well, that's your opinion. I myself find Red Dead 1 to be the much more enjoyable game.

[@mess6654]

Hector Hdz what is it? I only played reddead2

[@Jam29Josh]

The ending of this game should leave you feeling hopeful for John and his family but knowing what eventually happens just makes it kinda sad. Also roaming around New Austin as John feels so weird. Like there's familiarity but also strangeness because things are different. I guess it's the feeling one would get if they traveled back in time.

[@jaris4435]

I get the same feeling except I'm disappointed with new Austin if there aren't gonna be any missions in that area they should have saved that bit for online or dlc

[@Jam29Josh]

@@jaris4435 My guess is it'll be utilized more for the online

[@xtrariceplz6424]

aramdillo in rdr 2 is depressing its so empty and lifeless but gives me moneu from robbing the general store

[@jaris4435]

I really wish you could Rob banks freely aswell

[@movielover3416]

@@xtrariceplz6424 Yes Armadillo made me feel so strange sad and depressed tbh, like times long gone.. exept its in the past of RDR1.. very confusing and mixed feelings

[@painkiller7703]

Has anyone seen Gavin? GAAVVVVIIINN!!!

[@funnyguy5746]

I've lost my friend

[@ridwandarmawan6868]

I hate that bastard.. so i drowned him, now he could meet gavin wherever he want

[@painkiller7703]

@Gavin Corlette GAVIN!! :D

[@evoljfe48]

Yeah I saw some guy calling himself Gavin, he said he was going out west

[@infamousparagon412]

Where's that bloke at? I've been searching for 5 in game years. You don't know? Then sod OFFfff!

[@ugosmith7529]

I love how most of the places are actually less developed, still untouched or partly unfinished in RDR2 compared to their RDR counterparts, that is some pretty solid attention to continuity

[@yungk6043]

Kids are actually complaining about that. I just....dont understand. Kids need to pay attention more when they play games i swear to God.

[@sergeanttentacles1359]

A lot are just less developed because of less game development

[@bamcr1218]

A lot are also less developed because they aren’t old enough to appreciate such things

[@Mexican20067]

@@sergeanttentacles1359 wat

[@sergeanttentacles1359]

@@Mexican20067 It’s well known that Rockstar rushed to push out the old areas from RDR1. That is why there is little game content in those areas and they are not as fleshed out as the main RDR2 areas.

[@andy86i]

So.. who would buy. RDR1 remaster? They have most of the map made, all of the voices, just need to re-map mexico. They could release it as dlc.

[@teukka623]

Andy C i would buy if it wasn’t 70. Dollars

[@slendernugget125]

You look like that weird looking girl on TikTok

[@cianmulvey5552]

They would need to do the animations again to the standard of rdr2, the dialogue system, all the mechanics, re-do most of the map again to make 1:1 with RDR1 - and for what? Lots of effort for not much reward. You will never see RDR1 dlc for this game.

[@denkt]

No thanks, I'd rather have a new story than one I've already played through. Plus, a remaster would only improve the graphics, so you're not going to have one that plays anything like RDR2.

[@SpartanElite216]

The game already runs in full native 4K on the Xbox one x and looks fucking beautiful, a remaster would be completely pointless and only idiots would buy it.

[@hibbityhoopla]

Never thought I'd say it but, I prefer Arthur.

[@wolfspirit5361]

I beat the main game and I miss him so much

[@Derp009]

Right lol. When I beat the game I instantly missed Arthur I have to look up vids cuz it sucks playing without him

[@佬空]

Same I love Arthur

[@yeaiamtrill]

@Joseph Kennedy rockstar are fucking gods of character development

[@dylanmartin8529]

@Joseph Kennedy no one hates John. They just grew attached to Arthur. If they were to play the first RDR now with all the added backstory of the second just to see John die again, im sure it would hit them even harder. Lol

[@edwardmerriam6970]

Is it just me or does New Austin feel slightly creepier in RDR2? It's so barren and empty, and the cholera epidemic going on and so on gives it an ominous vibe.

[@esco5593]

It's barren because it was less settled back then, but I think it's less creepy. Idk what it was about RDR1 but that entire game's vibe was just kinda creepy imo

[@giantrunt]

Tall trees, Bayou nwa and roanoke is what's creepy.

[@cobussy]

I think compared to RDR1 it seems more creepy because like you said it’s so much quieter. In RDR1 you were always running into a stranger encounter or a group of bandits shooting up a town.

[@e14ee]

The only scary place in this game is imo Ambarino and Tall Trees. Tall Trees in the first game wasn't scary because snow is calming to me and all there was were bears. The bears killed you but it was in their instinct, so not really scary. But in this game? Skinners. Since tall trees is a pretty small place you run into their camps often. Ambarino is scary because it's unsettled and you rarely find anyone there, I only saw one person in Grizzlies West and they were running on a horse and I couldn't catch up to them

[@EduardoSalamanca1960]

Deserts never seem creepy to me not even at night. I feel much safer in new Austin than in bayou nwa, Roanoke ridge, and tall trees.

[@alvinhinal9183]

Rdr2 - year 1899 Rdr1- year 1911

[@sweetibluu]

Rdr1 is in the year 1914 when you beat the game.

[@sweetibluu]

@@dieterrosswag933 It's actually still long enough to make stuff very different

[@motionblur9200]

The epilogue takes place in 1907. So there’s only 4 years’ difference here.

[@sweetibluu]

@Silviu Popa i don't get what you mean.

[@kostasspirou1010]

@Silviu Popa rdr1 is in the year 1911, and rdr2 in 1899.

[@Dolphinman300]

That railing on the armadillo saloon is still broken 12 years later

[@yoda301]

Dolphinman 300 4 years*

[@Dolphinman300]

Gus Castillo yeah, I had written it before beating the main story

[@JM-bi6yx]

Gus Castillo 12**

[@SerpentSupremacy]

Jacob Macdonald online?

[@jaffamix9111]

@@JM-bi6yx *4 years

[@ligmaballs2694]

Imagine this: After you ended the epilogue, there's an Abigail mission. When you start this mission, the rdr1 story starts. You have the choice to keep your horse, weapons, money and your other stuff or you start with nothing. The game has the same physics and options like rdr2. Interactions, weapons, train robberys... I would like if they would make new conversations about Arthur, Sadie and Charles.

[@Daniel-8160]

Maybe an even better transition: There's a mission for you to go to Blackwater to buy some things for the ranch, and as soon as you come back you see agents Ross and Fordham with a car ready to take you to Saint Denis to hunt down... ...Charles

[@ligmaballs2694]

@@Daniel-8160 💥💥💥💥💥

[@vinizin8291]

@@Daniel-8160 That would be awesome, i can imagine a mission out of that.

[@RaccoonCityPoliceDept]

Arthur died in 1899.

[@Daniel-8160]

@@RaccoonCityPoliceDept Conversations about him, not with him. I'd imagine they'd at least mention his name in passing

[@Byron_Smart]

Me : No other game will top off GTA 5 Rockstar: Hold my beer

[@dabroly5195]

Lol Rockstar always topping their previous games.

[@bulldozero]

gta 5 is shit, man

[@Winterfellen]

San Andreas was better than gta v ffs. Nothing to do in gtav after the story was over.

[@Byron_Smart]

Nonse Xenon It wasn’t shit when it came out. People were hyped

[@AdeelKhan-ox1bs]

Both game are made by rockstar lmao

[@themindofceline]

love the lighting/colors in rdr2. really makes the environments feel warm and heavy

[@giantrunt]

rdr2 is beautiful

[@GTAandApplechannel]

Celine H and make it feel solid

[@featheryfemme]

Different strokes, it seems. That’s exactly what I don’t like about it. It makes everything look dreamlike and hazy, but the colours in the first one make it feel grounded and realistic.

[@MisteryDMOR33]

Not for me, I wish Armadillo had the the same light yellow and bright enviroment like in RDR1 or a Sergio Leone film, instead of this orange/brown filter

[@harrybarnett839]

@@featheryfemme Rdr1 felt alot more like a classic western while rdr2 depicts the west in a much more realistic way.

[@DubStepZz]

great video, really well put together

[@Dead_ass123]

Ae

[@shayh.3556]

New Austin seems like fan service now, but there is no way in hell Rockstar remade that huge chunk of land for nothing. There is gonna be a DLC down there, I'm almost positive of it. Either the original game will be added or another story line because it is almost empty at the moment with the exception of exploring/hunting.

[@TheHongKongHermit]

My thoughts too. I'm still on the "they'll update New Austin to 1911 buildings and tell the RDR story in this engine" camp. So much work already done, and PC gamers never got to play the original. Sell it as DLC if not including it as a surprise free update (hell, I'd buy again), and resell Undead Nightmare too. A ton of Rockstar content that is currently trapped on last-gen consoles and Rockstar do not like leaving their main games in the past like that. Even the old PS2 games got ports to both PS3 and PS4 (and mobile), only RDR is left hanging in the wind right now. And with this much work having gone into bringing New Austin into RDR2? At the very least, the VERY LEAST, they are keeping their options open.

[@shayh.3556]

@@TheHongKongHermit If Rockstar brings back RDR/Undead Nightmare and makes the wanted system slightly better, then I'll be happy

[@priceG]

Honestly, it might be just a treat for the fans who played RDR1. Or it might be needed for RD Online. GTA Online was set before the events of the single-player story, will RD Online be set AFTER? Maybe set in 1911 (same year as RDR1)?

[@shayh.3556]

@@priceG Of course NA will be used for online but I have a feeling the single player will get a nice dlc for this game

[@Softlol]

Its probably gonna be used for multiplayer. No way they would let us explore it all in this game if they were gonna use it later for DLC. That seems kinda strange? What if new people use many hours playing there, then they add a DLC. Then they already explored everything

[@ethanludwig9318]

Should have had one of John jumping into water in RDR compared to him jumping in to water in RDR2.

[@Fannyherz]

@Joey Stalone Thank heaven, now John's horse can swim.

[@sbraypaynt]

Joey Stalone yeah well Arthur can’t really swim either

[@huskytzu7709]

Julia G. I think he can

[@Fannyherz]

@@huskytzu7709 look: kzbin.info/www/bejne/amjakKWZja-CfMk

[@huskytzu7709]

Julia G. I was talking ablution arthur. Replied to the other guy...

[@DomImaBoss]

While playing RDR so many years ago, I thought to myself, "videogames are NEVER going to look better than this." Now I watch this video nearly 10 years after playing the original and its breathtaking to see how far graphics have come. As I sat and loaded up RDR 2 for the first time a few months ago, i thought to myself, "there is no way videogames are ever going to look better than this" I wonder what ill say in another 10 years.

[@mmundle941]

Gta6 should be interesting

[@brianmcdermott281]

@@mmundle941eventually games will look too lifelike and it’ll be weird as hell lol

[@john_mccarthy_hi]

it almost makes you nostalgic, for something that never really was...

[@SerpentSupremacy]

John McCarthy unless you played the first

[@boogiewithnotahoodie8917]

John McCarthy yeah i played the first red dead when i was like 7, i still remember black water very well

[@brandonmartinez476]

RDR is a good looking game until you put it next to RDR 2 lol

[@sweetibluu]

Yeah.

[@tjrex1915]

Good for its time

[@Dunkacino]

RDR is more colorful imo

[@jlabsy9699]

No, red dead one still a better game.

[@Noble_Isaac]

@@jlabsy9699 not trying to argue with you but may I ask why?

[@I_am_a_cat_]

It still blows me away just how beautiful both of these games can be.

[@sengin1534]

i miss mexico...

[@MatthewZmusician209]

sengin I actually having Mexico more than the new stuff in red dead 2

[@sengin1534]

@@MatthewZmusician209 i loved in rdr, how the language changed to spanish, the music changed, the whole atmosphere changed when entrying mexico...it was awesome...rdr 2 seems to look and feel like the same at every part of the map.

[@Luis-bl8mc]

sengin I have to disagree with you, rdr2 does not look the same throughout the map. There are different biomes like the swamp and desert, each with its own music to suit the biome. In addition, the law is different depending on which town/city you are.

[@shayh.3556]

@@sengin1534 RDR2 has more landscapes than the original. Far better western map, hopefully they do open Mexico and bring back the Mexican style music, that'd be awesome.

[@Phulax.]

Shay Hickman That would indeed be amazing. Would also be great for a Red Dead Online ‘roadtrip’. From New Hanover to Mexico.

[@DiegoMoreno-yb6fj]

I really hope they make a dlc with the remade rdr1, i want to see blackwater and armadillo with life again with this graphics!!

[@ImAvaiil]

Diego Moreno it’s all about Rhodes and Saint Denis now

[@kinggay6463]

Diego Moreno no

[@jpesicka492]

Hate to be the bearer of good news, but it is a xbox one x enhanced game. See for yourself. As far as ps4 no bc...ps3 for ps users. and we won't ever get a port or dlc for that...

[@fatboi3603]

I was just saying we can have a whole RDR1 remake.with this map

[@joon-young9589]

Doubt it, it took them nearly a decade to make red dead 2. You think they goner invest more time to make something that’s already there. I still think red dead 2 should have ended with Arthur’s story. John story feels out of place. New Austin is very nice place, l never got to play red dead 1. Shame there is no missions to do

[@agentzero0seven735]

donno why but I guess rdr 1 had better western background music in comparison to the 2nd installation

[@akshat3516]

"Donno why", It's very easy to figure it out, it's just your opinion that RDR had better western background music.

[@randyortonsbulge]

But rdr2 uses most of the riffs from the forst game go stand down in armidillo. You saying thia one isnt as good is false its as good or better because it has the old tracks in it. The more you know.

[@jasonhammond871]

the music was so much better in RDR1, it has this hint of Ennio Morricone in the strings, had like an almost unsettling atmosphere at certain parts. it was so unique and cinematic. the new one was like american backwoods banjo style which makes sense in the game world but wasnt as vibrant of an atmosphere created. i just kept thinking constantly that I missed the old soundtrack as i played

[@agentzero0seven735]

Jason Hammond same here, mate

[@Ancienregime8090]

Rdr1 is at the same time more creepy and more satirical at the same time. It's hard to compare the stories of RDR1 and RDR2, RDR2's story is more deep and complex, but doesn't have the same satire as the first game.

[@spxrta8699]

Up to this day I still think about Arthur...

[@jackd6157]

xSpartaaaTV I feel you man, it’s not the same anymore, wish I free roamed more as Arthur

[@spxrta8699]

@@jackd6157 Me too. It's just so damn hard to forget something you are attached to.

[@AnguisticCycle]

I cried when he died i swear

[@佬空]

@@AnguisticCycle same! I wish I could still play with him after all.

[@jackd6157]

They did a good job of making you connected to the characters, it doesn’t feel the same without Hosea, Leennny, Sean, ect.

[@Shkar047]

I finished the game and now I miss arthur and the gang😢😢😢

[@佬空]

Same

[@angrycommander5747]

rockstar should have made arthur go find mary in my opinion instead of killing him

[@seujuan6826]

@@angrycommander5747 thanks for the spoiler xd

[@amysteriousviewer3772]

Angry Commander I got the peaceful ending and I just tell myself he did just that. Hung out on top of the rock for a while, got his TB cured by the Indians and told Charles to fake his death by creating a grave for him.

[@civilservant9528]

Crybaby

[@AcherontiaStyx]

The only thing I wish RDR2 ported over was the ambient sounds and music. I feel like the birds/insects in 2 are much quieter as well the louder classic western background music in RDR1 I just prefered

[@arthurbutler971]

Seeing John in his rancher outfit gives me anxiety

[@simianto9957]

Why

[@simianto9957]

@@nicolasfarias7078 Ah

[@lorenzinorod23]

@@simianto9957 spoliers

[@bunnitomoe3866]

@@lorenzinorod23 game been put for 11 years now

[@xLanzer]

@@bunnitomoe3866 why is that suppossed to make that it stop from being a spoiler?

[@dcaseng]

I actually come away from this more impressed with the original RDR. Obviously the RDR2 graphics are a huge improvement, but the original still holds up in comparison to many modern day games. The differences here aren't as dramatic as i would have thought.

[@Wintd1]

RDR1 came out in 2010 and was made to run on systems that had 512mb of RAM (Xbox 360) and 256mb of RAM (PS3) respectively. It's very impressive when you consider the hardware they had to work with, and it's even more impressive when you realize that they crammed the entire game in to a single DVD for the 360 version.

[@Skumtomten1]

It also has better color palette, more natural looking imo. I think they really overused some lighting effects in RDR 2, it looks almost white when you look at the sun/moon at times, it really doesn't look good.

[@mordor1779]

video games graphics evolution is getting slower and slower man, difference between PS1 PS2 and PS2 PS3 was huge, difference between PS3 and PS4 not that much, and i'm sure it will be even slower between PS4 and PS5

[@gplgs4640]

Oxycontin “Difference between PS3 and PS4 not that much” Look at the goddamn video, you dunce.

[@mordor1779]

@@gplgs4640 the difference isn't that big compared to the difference between PS1 and PS2 and PS2 and PS3 dumbass, you would know if you weren't a 10 year old kid who discovered video games 2 years ago. Considering there is 8 fucking years between RDR1 and RDR2, yes, the difference is very small, go compare a game from 1998 with game from 2006 and the difference will be absolutly huge

[@skylined1239]

This game made me think about my own life differently

[@zarrowthehorse]

What??

[@29subhra]

Lol

[@egel7736]

@@Pandel2017K Too dramatic for a game, I think they meant.

[@orange3623]

I think the most impressive technical feat of RDR2 is the lack of popping and the amazing draw distance compared to RDR and other open world games.

[@GoulouMalouku]

yes that's what impressed me most... going high on a mountain and seeing the whole map is crazy, even GTA V didn't have that much draw distance

[@supsquark505]

Rockstar had that shit down before anyone else, they're pioneering in it again

[@ArthurKnight1899]

What does it mean I don't understand, someone explain please

[@RandalfElVikingo]

@@ArthurKnight1899 Well, think about Vice City or San Andreas when you're in a helicopter and you only see geometric figures like cubes with no detail until you get close. RDR2 you will never notice that or some random object appearing out of thin air and that's an amazing feat not even GTA V managed to do.

[@ArthurKnight1899]

@@RandalfElVikingo thanks!!

[@spliffwordmedicalz8423]

I've never been so emotionally invested in a character like I was with John Marston. I want to dust off my PS3 and play red dead again.

[@tommyvercetti9434]

Players: It would be so great if R* remade the first RDR into RDR2 as DLC. They already have more than half of the map, most of the original voice act- Online bullshit: NOPE!!

[@Ronjontcb]

To many animations and interactions to remake for no point

[@Ronjontcb]

Maxim Kik unrealistic?

[@naoaquieopatrickpatrick8565]

why would people ask rockstar to remake the same game with rdr2 mechanics when you can play RDR1 by buying it on PS4 store or via backwards compatibility on Xbox one? i would preffer Undead Nightmare II as a DLC for rdr2 rather than play the first game again... also they would prebably cut something out from the original RDR since not every VA would be present... just buy RDR and play it instead of asking for a remake... it's not that old and it still is very fun even with the old mechanics...

[@walo351]

@@naoaquieopatrickpatrick8565 you need a ps3 to buy the game in the ps store or buy ps now and ps now is bullshit

[@Desmond-xp4wr]

@@maximkikena622 erm are you those who comment bullshit and jst walk off type of guy?

[@hockeytalk13]

Armadillo is disappointing in RDR 2, but definitely check out tumbleweed. It’s before it was abandoned and is really cool

[@bigcoffinhunter5500]

hey thanks! will do!

[@somerandy500]

Why’s it disappointing?? it’s almost like there should be people living in a cholera ridden town right?

[@gplgs4640]

Is it possible to shoot up Tumbleweed and kill everyone there, turning it into a ghost town again?

[@hockeytalk13]

doubt it, I'm assuming the town will just respawn when you are away@@gplgs4640

[@JBtheExplorer]

Back when RDR was released, about the only thing I wanted changed, map-wise, was for Tumbleweed to be a populated, normal town. Pretty cool that Rockstar made that happen in RDR2.

[@isaaccuenca3429]

RDR 1 is still amazing.

[@blessedxxiii5583]

Agree bro and the graphics look better in RDR1 in my opinion.

[@Manny_619]

PurpleHayez XIX lol

[@gamesplash8668]

@@blessedxxiii5583 lol bro rdr2 has much much better and beautiful graphics

[@Ronjontcb]

Reclaimer XXIII that’s just false

[@edersone8345]

True

[@JoCE2305]

You should've shown beechers hope after the house was built aswell.

[@dylanmarshall2906]

How cool would it be if they offered RDR1 as an addon in the future? Seems like they left New Austin open for a reason.

[@GoulouMalouku]

either that or a dlc.. it's also surely going to play a big part online I bet

[@giantrunt]

It's the only way they can port rdr1 to pc.

[@bendaonfire0078]

Well tech john was never supposed to be there according to rdr1

[@Adrian1981]

Red Dead Redemption had better controls, quicker reactions still looks amazing today, GTA V was fun but not as engaging (for me at least) now RDR2 is a technical masterpiece but it's perfection is also its downfall as I don't find it as engaging, the pace is far slower and it actually feels less of a western when actually being set in 1899 it should feel more of one

[@mainnlander]

Because it's not set in western lmao.

[@TANuclear]

Sad we won’t ever get DLC because Rockstar’s greediness & all the brainless cows they’re milking in online.

[@wrapp1000]

So, a lot of deforestation happened within years. This can also be counted as a good detail from Rockstar!

[@roaringmoon88]

I miss some old characters: Nigel West Dickens, Bonnie and Seth.

[@DeadX2]

Marshal irish landon

[@aveteranplayer6403]

4:13 we can see the Rdr2 map from the first game perspective, now I imagine if there was a Rdr3 we can see the map from a Rdr2 perspective...

[@SnuffySpaghetti]

There shouldn't be a RD3. I think this game did the story justice, how could they even proceed at this point? Jack being an outlaw wouldn't make sense, civilization took over in the early 1900s almost entirely. A DLC maybe, but anything more would ruin it.

[@exonimas]

@@SnuffySpaghetti By going back even further, to the height of the Wild West? First game was 1911, second was 1899, so maybe 1888 for RDR3? But I think you may be right that it doesn't need to involve the Van der Linde gang. Maybe just references to them in Newspapers or something.

[@canisjay]

It gives a different vibe on RDR1, It is só far away, like we would never get close to touching it. I always feel very melancholic staring at the distance in video games.

[@Cyber_Smoke]

New cast of characters, map expansion west of West Elizabeth and above new austin. Atleast that's my guess for the setting, maybe north of Ambarino aswell.

[@seamuswbiggerarmalite3379]

@@SnuffySpaghetti you could make a good story with the lemoyne raiders the powerful KLAN and the mafia in saint denis you know gun running moonshine militia ambush gun running southern things

[@rodrigo9554]

8 años y RDR se ve muy bien. Claramente el vídeo no compara gráficos porque sino ganaría RDR2, pero es increíble ver que los edificios que se estaban construyendo en el segundo, en el primero ya lo están. La cronología de Rockstar es increíble, no se saltan ni un detalle.

[@miseri45]

Ya viste que el caballo galopa bien feo en el nuevo juego?

[@nauangarcia2251]

@deloreandmc85 Look at the channel's name

[@andygarzia524]

Me no speak taco

[@KASTASPELL]

@@andygarzia524 Pretty fucking rasict if you ask ME

[@Beanu1968]

d a b s

[@PauloSilva-cl3gv]

8 years of graphical evolution :)

[@UlyssesM]

8 years of hard work

[@Tbizzz42]

@@UlyssesM Yet still at 26-30 fps.

[@UlyssesM]

@@Tbizzz42 That's hardware limitations dummy

[@Tbizzz42]

@@UlyssesM That sucks. PC has none of that.

[@UlyssesM]

@@Tbizzz42 Yea because it's a PC???

[@anthonybaca6671]

One thing that bothered me is the lack of the barn at mcfarlanes ranch, if you go back and play the second mission in the original bonnie mentions her father built it when she was just a little girl yet it hasn't been built in this game yet...

[@TheDayMang]

@DChief94 Early mission dialogue where Bonnie rides around the ranch with John

[@yungk6043]

Huh? Of course the barn is already built and they built more of it 4 years later. How is that so hard to understand? 😂

[@nikofernandez8837]

Rdr2 get bored bro i don't know why i think i play it for several time lol😂 now i need to play rdr1 how to get that

[@Gianni.chellini]

@@nikofernandez8837 download xbox 360 iso and emulator xenia and u can play it on pc

[@vuccorbilla7802]

Hats off rockstar.Im speechless

[@ardanzaasier]

RDR2 > RDR 1 > Fallout 76 I'm exaggerating, I know but it's almost true.

[@vishvadeva8084]

True

[@mauricioneri829]

Agree, that always online sucks

[@vishvadeva8084]

Bethesda fucked everything up using the same engine on f4, they fucked everything up even more with fallout 76

[@JR7noir]

True. Fallout 76 is like 4 and the nuke has shitty graphics

[@Lukin79023]

RDR2>RDR1>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>fallout76

[@knyixx838]

Wow I forgot rdr2 took place before rdr. It’s awesome seeing the unfinished buildings and stuff. Cool to see the devs pay attention to detail rather than copy and paste the buildings

[@joon-young9589]

New Austin is soo empty in rd2 there isn’t anything to do no quests or anything.

[@annhentaiuser6658]

Maybe its empty because of the Cholera plague.

[@xXSilentAgent47Xx]

Yeah it's shame. I think original plan was starting in NA to steamboat and Blackwater massacre then on snow area but they scrapped it for some reasons.

[@xXSilentAgent47Xx]

+360Ragequit The map had drastic changes after reveal, making it look fake now. They removed some of north part, expanded west part and prison island is bigger. All that was because of NA... Well at least if PC port be there people won't brag about not getting RDR on PC because NA looks more like fan service while it's completely useless because it has death invisible wall for Arthur. And because it doesn't add anything with the story, seems very fishy when it started from the snow instead of from NA to steamboat and Blackwater massacre then on snow.

[@dutchchiefofministry1983]

Just wait for online or an dlc

[@Maha-bv7wn]

Joon - young finish chapter 6 after arthur dayin you will see many quests with jhon on black water

[@habes1486]

Gives the feeling of nostalgia for something that has yet to be. Well done, Rockstar.

[@idontknow20404]

I hate how John looks like a completely different person in rdr2

[@Danziii]

Honestly, the first game still looks REALLY good, I thought looking back on it now it might look really bad in comparison, but it looks great, still. I haven't really played it since it first came out and I completed it

[@JR7noir]

So, John once upon a time knew how to swim..

[@goldgojira6101]

Except he still can't swim.

[@travismeta3727]

Juan Rios now he doesn’t even try to flap his arms to swim anymore. He just accepts his fate 😂

[@dancollin3465]

I hate to say it but I really hate the end of the game... correction I love the way the game ended I hate that I have to be playing as John now I lost my good horses and now he can't swim and he sucks at drawing so I don't even want to go and discover new locations and get a five-year-old's sketch of it

[@OGR-42]

Dan Collin I completely agree, but I still like playing as John. It really sucks you couldn't go to New Austin as Arthur and be able to swim.

[@Nonchalanty]

Haha na he drowns if you try to swim

[@KeTur6903]

Where can i find the song of red dead 1 that is played at 0:46 ? , you know that weird song when you do nothing in the game.. please i realy need to listen it, it reminds me lot of memories

[@authurmorgan2325]

My god. This game looking better than uncharted

[@gaviano7]

Hell no man are you out of your mind ! Uncharted 4 is a graphical masterpiece

[@randomthingz2showrandomthi208]

@@gaviano7 but linear.

[@davidsousa1575]

Noop

[@pauloroberto-bi4ky]

@@gaviano7 Red Dead Redemption 2 in graphics and details is far from superior than Uncharted

[@theaces3697]

@@gaviano7 it doesnt mean much in uncharted or god of war as those are small linear games, for an open world to look as good as RDR2 is a technical masterpiece

[@justsometimber1nthelake873]

well back then the graphics looked much better lol

[@Rizzatouille]

Hell na

[@ED_Rodriguez]

WTF!?

[@animebhopper]

Get a pair of glasses young man

[@justsometimber1nthelake873]

By “back than” i meant that red dead 2 takes place before red dead 1 and so i t has better graphics.. that’s the joke lol Back than the jokes didn’t fly over like this lol

[@thechosenone172]

Then what?

[@Soldier.505]

Yo why does RDR1 graphics looks so good even tho it's been 11 years since it got released

[@Auldus]

6:08 "Yes.... this will do. Isn't this a nice spot?"

[@pastorofmuppets4552]

Not the same area.

[@vampirethespiderbatgod9740]

@@pastorofmuppets4552 same area.

[@pastorofmuppets4552]

Vampire The Immortal God, No it’s not. 6:08 is Broken Tree. Not Beecher’s Hope.

[@vampirethespiderbatgod9740]

@@pastorofmuppets4552 it's been 4 years you intellectual being.

[@Andres-Gomez]

Ahora compara la fisica de las bolas de caballo :v

[@dmente16]

Andres Gomez está viendo mucho al rubius 😂😂😂😂

[@sendmags2640]

no quiero ser ese tipo pero en el 1 los caballos eran yeguas asi que no tenian bolas :V

[@dylannichollph1934]

Andres Gomez I don’t speak Japanese

[@yakushi7962]

@@dylannichollph1934 my too

[@esco5593]

Without using Google translate, they said something about comparing horses from both games

[@rubyfirefly2582]

Great job. Thanks for doing this. I've noticed a lot of differences in the towns, but one thing I had forgotten about RDR1 was that there was a lot more people and traffic (being later in time the towns were more populated and advanced in terms of commerce). Very cool.

[@LeadSwitchKick]

I remember being so blown away the first time I entered Blackwater in the first Red Dead Redemption. Looking back at it now, comparing it to Saint Denis, it looks so small. Imagine how I felt walking through Saint Denis for the first time, though!

[@postmanpat8166]

When I first discovered Saint Denis I peed my pants a little

[@stevenplayzzz172]

@@postmanpat8166AYO WHAT THE FUC-

[@deadishonor]

Seeing the improvement of rdr and Rockstar is amazing. Can't wait to see how gta 6 will look.

[@Desmond-xp4wr]

@@maximkikena622 ok boomer . Why not you try to be a man and not to run and hide after commenting some bullshit? You sure you go home with that atittude? Bless you

[@dungcheeseMORK999]

If they brought back the music from RDR1 into RDR2 and if Arthur's story were allowed to head into New Austin I'd have love to seen him interact with some of the RDR1 characters.

[@raykuus9396]

And now just imagine how awesome it would be if Rockstar would remaster RDR1 in form of a DLC for RDR2! Wouldnt mind to pay at least 20 or 30 bucks!

[@raykuus9396]

Wheres the problem? Should I say remake?

[@raykuus9396]

Hayden Rhead Oh Yeah, didnt even recognize Buffalos comment. Instantly thought it was adressed to me. Yeah I think he doesnt know what the point of a Remaster or, in this case, of a Remake is.

[@deimosthechosenone8914]

They did a great job of putting in the rdr1 map and utilising it in the epilogue. Just wish they added mexico as well but that could potentially be added in over time.

[@xBPxTHECOWARD]

the multiplayer in rdr 1 was way batter than rdr 2

[@ranjabdulsalam6145]

Both are 11/10 games

[@WeegeeSlayer123]

There are some things that don't make sense. There SHOULD be a barn in Macfarlane's Ranch, as Bonnie stated in the first game that it was built when she was a little girl. And there are quite a few buildings missing in Macfarlane's Ranch and in Thieve's Landing. I doubt all of those buildings were built in under the span of just 4 years, cause some of them looked pretty old and weathered to me.

[@lilchad-ig1oj]

Ikr

[@TheDayMang]

Also Blackwater/West Elizabeth has no railway, which is in the very first cutscene when Ross & Archer escort him from the ferry... Just a bizarre amount of discrepancies to be resolved in 4 years.

[@edgarallanpoe8045]

I don't know why, but in my opinion RDR1 has a darker atmosphere than RDR2

[@WICKET.7]

Yeah while in RDR2 there is sadness and happyiness in RDR1 there is only sadness and no happy end 😢

[@Agumon5]

Red Dead Redemption looks quite amazing for its age. I honestly wouldn't mind if current gen games looked like that.

[@davidr9954]

Red dead redeption 2 looks like a remake of the original

[@Kyle-ek4gr]

maxp240 it’s a remake of the old map

[@NoiFox]

Kyle with more content

[@ThePudgeGaming]

Both games are incredible. And the way they tied 2 into 1 in the way that they did was amazing. Was not expecting it at all

[@LRZN96]

RDR is my favorite game of all time. RDR2 took everything RDR had and improved on it, except for the story. Don't get me wrong I really enjoyed RDR2's story but it wasn't quite on the same level as RDR, and I'd take a good story over graphics and game mechanics any day.

[@domersftw1503]

LRZN one thing I did not enjoy was that if you shoot someone with a revolver in the face more then 5 times it explodes like I get it with a shotgun but sometimes you just want to put bullet holes everywhere on someone’s face.

[@NikFerxo18]

04:37 no se ustedes amigos, pero en ese momento del video prefiero el RDR 1, me gusta mas la profundidad de campo que utiliza y la iluminación sobria de ese cerro, en el 2 se ve como que muy saturado y sin profundidad, y la vida real no es así.

[@personadesconocida9803]

En eso puede que tengas razon los graficos del RDR 1 realmente lucen como un western pero en si la calidad grafica del 2 es muy superior a la del 1

[@giovanniandresramirezjaime7596]

Puede ser por la hora del día o el clima en parte, en RDR1 casi nunca está completamente soleado

[@TheBoxNasty]

Red dead 1 still looks amazing

[@Deyone_Jackson]

Interesting.. sometimes it looks more modern in the first game and sometimes it looks more modern in the second game.

[@miguelbarlaan3741]

Oh my GAAAWWWDDD !! I fell in love with playing red dead 1 and it still holds a special place in my heart. That game really changed my life.. and now that I've upgraded to a new console and playing red dead 2... It just SOOOOO surreal and soooo exhilarating!!! You can really feel the difference between the two games... Idk bout u guys but I feel more tension in the story and gameplay of red dead 2.. it's just a whole different t experience filled with so much things to do!!! I luv both games and both games have changed my life forever!

[@gaminggoof1542]

RDR1 is better for New Austin no question. Just way more atmosphere. Too bad the developers kind of just made it mostly arid in RDR2

[@giiotm8272]

Did anyone else try swimming to mexico as John & end up drowning? lmfaooo. even on horseback it won't let you swim across.

[@cenourattis]

Yep. Saved before since i knew he could not swim and didn't trust rachel's lungs. Got half way though

[@Derp009]

Yep. Best horse in the game can’t even swim across. Maybe gonna try and find a boat to cross over with lol

[@ungobungo7986]

Did you try taking a boat yet?

[@Derp009]

Amman Saleem yes. About halfway past the river John jumps out of the boat automatically and drowns himself lol, then the boat sinks. Feels bad man

[@ungobungo7986]

@@Derp009 oof

[@LilBiscuit1]

mIcAh In ReD dEaD 1?? 5:39

[@GlennDavey]

The colours are really cranked in the new game. I find myself watching the original game in these side by side comparisons. I miss it’s muted palette and gloomy spaghetti vibe.

[@seanquinn4540]

RDR 2 has the objectively better graphics, but I prefer the aesthetic of RDR.

[@alextaylor9615]

DewsJaz I think he means that the first RDR has better story, soundtrack, and atmosphere n stuff than the 2nd game

[@noamias4897]

@@alextaylor9615 I just think he meant that RDR had a different style in the environments like colors and stuff, RDR also has thicker outlines

[@giantrunt]

I prefer the realistic aesthetic of rdr2.

[@jordiboo]

My mind is totally blown by this game. Not only was it an incredibly lengthy and masterfully told story with a bittersweet ending, with vivid and deep gameplay and detail - it also gives you a huge nostalgia trip that I personally didn't see coming (I knew Blackwater and Great plains would open up but had no idea I could also visit armadillo, tumbleweed etc.). If they really did just put New Austin in there for the nostalgia then that is a beautifully daring move. Though I hope there's a RDR1 DLC. Bravo rockstar. Truly the best game ever made.

[@sagelight7777]

The reveal of new Austin was such a love letter to the first game. Red dead 1 still looks good and is still an amazing game. Possibly the 2 finest games of their generations

[@tnm1697]

I love seeing how close everything is to the locations we see in the first game but still different enough to know time’s past

[@lana6430]

When I finish rd2 I'm gonna play rd1 to continue on since (SPOILERS OF THE STORY) Arthur dies so you are john marston and then you play as him about 10 years (idk how many it's just an estimated guess) before rd1 starts. It's just so amazing and unexpected the storyline and I used to go to armadillo all of the time and I rememberrm the scenery and everything and when playing rd2 I'm like "omg I remember these canyons heading down to Armadillo!" Also I used to go to the saloon and when you go in and then go to the back of the saloon to the right there's 3 doors, I remember the one on the left was a bathroom lmao. And upstairs you could freely go into people's rooms but now most doors are locked and it's really sad to see the town I loved all deadly and ghostly and everyone has like a disease and stuff. Omg also that movie theatre! I remember that too. And omfg the mcfarlain ranch (something like that) where that girl lived omg it's all coming back to me

[@IKIGAIofficial]

its like red dead 1....but with more LAYERS.

[@tommymckenna4707]

triplesix ogres

[@cbecks2051]

U dont say

[@Derp009]

THICCER

[@user-gn2kp7id1f]

triplesix lol no

[@sergiom3765]

A día de hoy el 1 es una brutalidad y eso que ya hace unos años..

[@JonyCr95]

Lo único feo es la distancia de dibujado en los edificios

[@chrishansen9181]

Rdr1 looks good even now.

[@personadesconocida9803]

Si tienes razon pero el 2 tambien luce fabtastico para ser un mundo abierto de tal magnitud

[@angelomdz2401]

Que esperabas de un juego de Rockstar :)

[@personadesconocida9803]

@@JonyCr95 jaja me jace recordar a gta 4 de xbox que las cosas renderizaban a 2 centimentros de mi cara y eso era una mierda miles de veces perdi misiones o choque por eso pero lo de RDR 1 no es tan grave

[@jeffknott1975]

Would of been better if you'd of shown some of the rdr1 locations in the daytime so we can see properly!

[@AidenR19]

1:15 That doesn't make sense!

[@axtaria01]

Fun fact rd1 is only 7 gb

[@FlamespeedyAMV]

What a shame that the port we got in 2023 sucks. And we didnt get dlc for RD2 that continues to RD1

[@davidstinger1134]

You can see that RDR1 was made in that era when, for some reason, all games were trying to be brown and grey, like Gears of War.

[@thatssofetch3481]

Yep. See fallout too.

[@thegageinator805]

Rdr1 is also one of the brighter and most colorful games I've ever seen, so you're dead wrong in this analogy. Gta 4 maybe

[@A_HDMI]

I just like to be in RDR1 maps, Mexico is my favorite place to be, Imagine if RDR1 and RDR2 maps are combined.

[@threecrows1756]

They will open Mexico, but prob not for a bit.