Elisa Meneghini ITA Qual Fx Olympics Rio 2016

[@giogym]

Can we just take the time to appreciate how bad ass this routine was! I mean she slayed this routine and she completely just blew off the fact that her team was eaten by the beam and went out and did the floor routine of her life!

[@brianpatterson1827]

Absolutely badass. The Latin vibe reminded me of Esther moyas Olympic routine in Sydney 2000 from Spain and she also I feel got robbed of a medal in the Floor Final in Sydney. And here meneghini I felt out entertained Fasana and also had very clean Landing's. The crowd agrees with us. =] if she was put later in the lineup I think she also would've had better chance of beating fasana into the final. If artistry scoring this quas was applied here Elisa def IMO would've beat fasana into the floor final spot she got.

[@brianpatterson1827]

Both meneghini and moya were scored harshly and artistry and entertainment value should count for more even if the difficulty in routine is a tenth or few less than say Fasana here who best Elisa into the floor final. Alsobshe should've been put further unto the lineup but I feel like they wanted to get Fasana and Ferrari best chance at the building score move that coaches think actually works still lol.. This is artistic gymnastics after all. I'm glad they finally implemented more deductions for lack of artistry in the Execution score now.

[@brianpatterson1827]

Super underscored for Elisa. she's beautiful!!

[@arathgomez615]

Brian Patterson she got a 14.233 but like where?!? This was so good

[@dpguinee]

its the low d-score. 5.6 is decent, but if she could upgrade a bit she would be up there!

[@brianpatterson1827]

Arath Gomez I know Arath!!! I thought maybe a bit low because most of her execution was pretty solid even with the Difficulty score at a 5.6. Just love this routine and her dance and all. She was outstanding and super fun to watch.

[@leandroaraujo7133]

the dlo had separate legs, the whips too, I think those were the most important errors, then maybe landing deductions, and the difficulty score was a little low.

[@brianpatterson1827]

+Leandro Araujo Yeah they really butchered her tho when Fasana and Ferrari had very similar deductions and I think Elisa had 4 passes she basically almost stuck. I'd say 3-4 tenths in all of the landings. form okay take 6 tenths. that's 1 point. Idk about these judges but difficulty being lower than fasana or not. Her routine was MUCH better and much more entertaining.

[@davebrown5274]

she should have. been. into the. final. !!!!!!

[@brianpatterson1827]

yupppp

[@elvisesteban4651]

In the 2004 COP maybe

[@Ariom76]

Two per country: Italy had two athletes in floor final.

[@aksjdbf4112]

This routine makes me cry. It's perfect.

[@natashabessonova3692]

The Italinas were so great on floor.

[@juliakrystal19]

Natasha Bessonova right

[@Sara-jm2rl]

simo Carobbio forse sei tu a non comprendere la sua lingua perché ha fatto un complimento alle italiane

[@martinamassaro3249]

Natasha Bessonova right! I am italian and I know gymnastics

[@saraliberati755]

Mh the american is better than italian girl (i am italian😂)

[@martinamassaro3249]

Sara Kawaii (visto che sei italiana ti parlo in italiano) si hai ragione anche le americane sono fortissime al corpo libero, però non dobbiamo sottovalutare le capacità delle fantastiche ginnaste italiane che abbiamo

[@juliakrystal19]

totally underscored!

[@lb7617]

This is the best floor routine I have ever seen from her! Beautiful form and almost stuck every landing as well :)

[@mlily2481]

Another example of why many people complain about the new scoring system.

[@irenemantica1158]

So underscored

[@MrMaurino58]

bravissima Elisa, orgogliosa che sia italiana!! Linda

[@pedrojorge1912]

Before the Games, Lara Mori's coach complained about the squad selection, saying something like Elisa wasn't a floor specialist and was unstable and inconsistent, she could get over 14.5 or 12 depending on day. Well, 5th highest execution of Quals (behind USA girls and Ferrari), scored enough for finals with medium difficulty and won the crowd with every tumbling, now we know how she was on that day and what she did for her team.

[@rahrah8449]

Italy's best events are beam and floor for shore

[@chor_cho]

Rah rah and for mountains?

[@tyronebranch2946]

The Italian team did a phenomenal Jon on the Floor Excercise.

[@MrMaurino58]

la vedrei 100, 1000, 10.000, volte!! Linda

[@sapresta9652]

Non so tu. Io sono arrivato almeno ad un migliaio di visualizzazioni. Mai una routine di corpo libero mi ha appassionato come quella di Elisa.

[@brianpatterson1827]

crowd started booing at the score lol I would've too smh

[@brianpatterson1827]

Even the crowd boo'ed at the score. No other way to put it. Ferrari, Meneghini, etc. all don't have great form. But All of her landings were on point. Should've been in the finals. Period.

[@lucasmatosaraujo7772]

Essa apresentação foi digna de ouro em outras olímpiadas...Very underscored.

[@jovanazagorac1986]

She deserved a spot in the final! Underscored!

[@PhenixJoe]

This has NCAA energy with elite class. Love her!!

[@solongastoria9657]

This routine is to die for. I'd love to speak to the judges

[@valeriadipa1475]

Fantastica

[@simonegattulli8771]

Troppo sottovalutato...

[@angelaaiello9388]

concordo

[@noemicarta2405]

purtroppo la regola due per paese l'ha mantenuta fuori... Non capisco però il punteggio così basso.

[@stevenvalencia6353]

someone tell me why this girl was not in floor finals common that was great landings on her tumbling passes

[@elenalang5559]

Steven Valencia Two per country rules ! Ferrari and Fasana did better ☺

[@roycheung9210]

This girl score 14.233 and fasana score 14.333

[@brianpatterson1827]

Roy Wilson.C should've been the other way around. Fasana had visible errors on her first tumble. At least .3 off. Then some of her leaps were not great, especially one which looked totally weird. Elisa really deserved that 14.333. =\ Hope she continues gymnastics on the elite level because she quickly became one of my fave international athletes after this floor routine.

[@ROUWAGDeArkan]

Brian Patterson Dont be hopefull because the new girls from italy are really good, take a look at the series called "Fate" on KZbin to see them, i am Impressed, Asia d'amato has already done Amanar

[@brianpatterson1827]

+Darya De Krappen So am I. I agree with ya. I need to check that out. Thank you

[@mrsSuperLaLa94]

Fantastica Elisa!! farai grandi cose!

[@MrMaurino58]

Il mio non è un giudizio semplicemente nazionalistico, ma, questa ragazza meritava di più, al mio parere. Mah, io queste giurie spesso non le trovo giuste; bisogna essere russe, che io adoro tra l' altro, cinesi, americane! Giuria molto ingiusta!! Nonostante tutto, continuo a vedere lo sport in generale,non certo per le giurie di molti sport, sono molto spesso vergognose ed ingiuste! Seguo molto il pattinaggio su ghiaccio e adoro la nostra Carolina Kostner, la quale, e' caduta nella sua ultima gara alle olimpiadi invernali appena finite ,e questo l' ha fatta andare al 5° posto, un errore non te lo perdonano; mentre, se cade una pattinatrice russa, l' hanno fatta vincere lo stesso e precisamente al 1° posto. Non so, giudicate voi! Non vuole essere nazionalismo, ma il giudicare come vanno realmente le cose, grazie a Dio, ho gli occhi per vedere. Che schifo, che molto spesso mi sta venendo da un di anni nei confronti di alcune giurie! Snche l' Eurofestival, lo stesso discorso. Lo schifo vedo che c' e' anche a livello mondiale, contono le Nazioni potenti: Russia, Cina, America, ecc. Per questo, quando vince un mio connazionale, lo ritengo veramente bravo, perche' a noi non regalano niente, anzi......! Linda

[@dianatorcolini9226]

Verissimo

[@MrMaurino58]

Diana Torcolini grazie!!

[@erenjaeger2317]

Mauro Avallone vero

[@benedettascuttari6983]

Io pratico ginnastica artistica e ti posso assicurare che le giurie sono molto severe poiché in questo sport bisogna fare attenzione ha molte cose Secondo me le giurie sono giuste perché questo non è uno sport facile e quindi anche un minimo dettaglio pesa sul Giudizio finale

[@fabriziodalpozzodannone586]

Hai davvero ragione

[@andressamarques4984]

Incredibile Elisa!

[@cristinasantini9063]

È stata perfetta.. ingiusto..

[@leofederer]

Underrated.. grande Elisa!

[@chrismccaffrey8256]

Slowmo shots are so cool. Showing us exactly how the body moves to do amazing tricks like this.

[@valedipa6617]

Se era americana le mettevano molto di più

[@MrMaurino58]

Purtroppo, anche nelle giurie ci sono ingiustizie, vengono favorite le atlete dei Paesi potenti: America, Russia, e compabnia bella. Vergogna! Questa nostra atleta e' stata eccellente, ,o dice il pubblico con i suoi applausi .

[@MissIvery14]

This floor routine should have had a much higher score 😒

[@guizzo9]

I totally agree!!!

[@MartyyTV]

Che c'è frega della Biles noi c'abbiamo Elisa Meneghini!!!😍

[@pedrocastro882]

Wow this is one of the cleanest routines that I've ever seen!

[@brianpatterson1827]

Still re-watching 7.5 years later. One of my fave floor routines. Reminds me of the fun rputine ftom Esther Moya circa 2000 Sydney Olympics whwre she got robbed of a Bronze medal i feel in the floor final. Unreal. Damn khorkina. Like if those routines were done in this quad deduction wise for errors in tumbling etc. That Moya would've bested and gpt the bronze and Meneghini of the current artistry execution deductions were in play in Rio, then i feel Meneghini would've bested Fasana into the floor final here. Too much fun and entertainment as well as dance that fit the music. It flowed from start to finish perfectly. Fasanas routine to me in comparison. Boring and she had a few noticeable errors whereas overall Elisa really rocked all her landings and her leaps were dynamic and crisp. A shame. Still feel the same way like i will with Moyas robbed bronze. I always will. The CoP finally gives the word artistic in this artistic gymnastics sport a reason to be called just that lol when many tenths can be taken away for lack od diff artistic execution checklists per routine it shows who has the less difficult routines but can be rewarded by artistry and get a score reflecting that and be competitive because of it. Love it.

[@gikka3373]

Bravissima! Orgoglio italiano!

[@melinacaminiti588]

Bravissima veramente

[@cla3355]

Bravissima 🪁

[@brianpatterson1827]

Truly thought Elisa should've been in the event finals on floor instead of Erika Fasana. Vanessa Ferrari deserved her spot but Idk. There were seriously visible errors in Fasana's routine.

[@aksjdbf4112]

Brian Patterson Yeah but Fasana had a higher D-score, that should have convinced the judges she deserved the spot better than Elisa. It's not fair and I love Elisa's routine, but I would say that after Erika's 14.533 on EF they were right.

[@brianpatterson1827]

Agreed but Meneghini with artistry and entertainment value really overshadows that little difficulty value. This quad with artistry being more paid attention to in execution scores. I think Meneghini would've went ahead of Fasana here. Her leaps and tumbling is very efficient here. Maybe less difficult overall but really very great landings and the crowd really is the equalizer for me it. To Me they seemed to really enjoy the routine and that definitely means it was artistically sound for sure. Yeah catchy music but the dance when she had the chance went along with the whole Latin vibe. Fasanas artistry to me is lacking. I guarantee this quad if difficulty value were the same and the artistry scoring change was applied here. Meneghini would've been in the final. IMO of course.

[@milenasuriano7232]

fantastica

[@anngranit4794]

Super!!!

[@giovannipoggi8374]

Sei stata da 10.....lo hanno visto tutti.

[@romain77200]

only 8,6 on execution? so slow, it's a joke, legs are close and jumps clean

[@FerKzrs]

toot otot I think the judges were very harsh on two of the four landings, as her chest was notoriously down. I suspect those two alone resulted in a whole point of deduction.

[@elettramalvezzi1750]

SPIEGAZIONE PUNTEGGIO: Anche se questo esercizio è ormai vecchio di 3 anni, noto che fra i commenti molti ritengono che il punteggio sia ingiusto, e che sia stata sfavorita in quanto "non americana". Agli occhi di persone non esperte questo esercizio potrebbe sembrare praticamente perfetto, ma se si sa cosa guardare si può capire la ragione del punteggio: nella prima diagonale le gambe sono completamente staccate (-0,1 o -0,3 a seconda di come l'hanno giudicato i giudici) e fa un piccolo salto all'indietro (-0,1), nella seconda le gambe sono scomposte (-0,1), i piedi non sono piegati (0,1), il petto è basso (0,1) e fa un piccolo saltino (-0,1), nella terza ha perso 0,1 per le gambe staccate e 0,1 per i piedi, e nell'ultima i piedi sono tutt'altro che tesi (-0,1) e fa un piccolo passetto (0,1), infine in 2 dei 4 salti l'arrivo a terra è impreciso (-0,1 per ognuno). Il punteggio finale di 8,633 quindi è più che giusto. Detto ciò, questo resta un bellissimo esercizio, probabilmente il migliore della sua carriera, e uno dei migliori visti a rio. Tenete inoltre a mente che 8,633 è tutt'altro che un punteggio basso, basti pensare che Aly Raisman ha ottenuto 8,833 per il suo esercizio in finale, ed era una delle migliori al mondo su quell'attrezzo. Spero di esservi stata d'aiuto!

[@trickortripslao8607]

D aiuto ed interessante la analisi di un esperta. Io purtroppo non sono del settore,nel senso che non capisco una cippa della parte tecnica e dei punteggi insomma. Ed il mio occhio non riconosce e nota tutti questi dettagli.

[@elettramalvezzi1750]

@@trickortripslao8607 grazie! Ci tengo a specificare che non sono un giudice di gara né lavoro nel settore, sono semplicemente un'appassionata che segue la ginnastica artistica da una vita e che ha (più o meno) imparato come funziona il sistema dei punteggi. In particolare se si cerca su internet si può trovare il Codice dei punteggi ufficiale della Fig degli ultimi quadrienni, in cui si spiega come si calcola sia la difficoltà sia l'esecuzione dell'esercizio, è così che io ho imparato :)

[@MrMaurino58]

Per me, molte giurie dono di parte , ingiustamente pignolecon certe atlete, quando on sono russe, cinesi o americane , 2uesta e' la verita' per me! Io, sto iniziando a non guardare piu' lo sport, mi da schifo morale e materia,e quando nello sport entra la politica.

[@elettramalvezzi1750]

@@MrMaurino58 una volta era così, ma fortunatamente negli ultimi anni sto vedendo molta più imparzialità nei punteggi, poi chiaramente i casi in cui il punteggio puzza di favoritismo ci sono ancora, ma sono molto rari

[@thatonehanstan2075]

I love Fasana but Meneghini DESERVED that final!!!!! (When a Brazilian crowd boos in favor of you, you know you did great!!)

[@Matthew-jh6oh]

Should’ve been a 9.0 execution score

[@arthurvanellisilva9603]

i would rather see Meneghini on FX EF than Fasana

[@juliakrystal19]

jeez she is good!

[@gchiarykewaii4233]

e bravissima

[@JohnSmith-qd1zl]

I think we should just consider that the double pike was her WORST landing. like and it was still a pretty good landing

[@romain77200]

Wooooooow so clean on execution, impressive

[@jimin-shi5302]

La mia Mini😍

[@tomsawyer4901]

Just another physically awesome lady of gymnastics

[@vanishcamilletti6115]

doppio teso altissimo e pulito, arrivi ben stoppati, bella serie artistica, nessuna pausa prima di iniziare le diagonali e sopratutto ESPRESSIVITÀ; molti esercizi al corpo libero hanno la parte coreografica solo perché è obbligatoria! Non capisco perché un punteggio così basso, questa ragazza ha fatto un esercizio a dir poco perfetto...

[@cookiesareyum1043]

Wow a very clean routine omg

[@isaimartinez2133]

una super super super super! rutina.

[@sapresta9652]

Perché il D-Score è stato valutato 5.6? Gli elementi artistici non sono tutti delle C? Mi aspettavo un valore di partenza di 5.7...

[@sapresta9652]

Dispiace solo che oltre ad una ottima serie di difficoltà acrobatiche non abbia inserito difficoltà artistiche più elevate di una C. Peccato.

[@robertmoura4314]

As italianas fizeram um verdadeiro espetáculo no solo dos jogos do Rio 2016.

[@connormccool9310]

at first I was mad at the fact that she wasn't in the final but after seeing 5.6 difficulty I was less confused. Her e score was great, the only people meeting that e score or higher were Biles, Raisman, Hernandez, Marine Brevet, and Ferrari. she had the 4th highest e score of the entire olympics. just too low difficulty, not underscored.

[@simocarobbio248]

Che atterraggi fantastici

[@AsenathWaiteDerby]

abbiamo perso anni dietro alla ferlito quando avevamo questa forza della natura

[@alfo03]

UNDERSCORED

[@anthonycastillo1851]

Tbh I agree with the comments, this routine was quite underscored, on my opinion it was like a 14.5-14.7

[@AliceDecolle]

Brava la mia mini

[@knequestrian93]

Unfortunately we Americans have set the bar so high sometimes that we don't give other gymnasts a chance.. and I mean it too. Not saying it to brag. I do miss the competitive side. Hopefully this quad will bring some

[@connor3983]

she didn't make the final because two ITALIANS scored higher than this routine!!! the US is dominate but her placement was about how good the Italians are on floor!!!!!!

[@mrkastro5932]

Linda apresentação, pra uma nota tão baixa.

[@steffra4756]

Non capisco come non abbia vinto con questa esibizione. I giudici stra tirchi, che rabbia

[@jeremypiron9790]

Is it me or at the very end of the video people booed at the results??? Like she didn’t get the right score she deserved. Her floor routine was AWESOME. that would not shock me that the judges slashed her according to the people’s reaction

[@raffaellacorevi9207]

The name of the song?

[@alicegennaro5934]

Il mio prof di matematica fa di cognome meneghini!

[@Chadhogan111]

Gold medal for warm up

[@matthewhines9787]

I feel as though her difficulty score was low.

[@zacharybielefeld9282]

Matthew Hines yeah only a 5.6 but score was 14.233

[@lucasmatosaraujo7772]

Her execution must be 9.500

[@Ariom76]

Ma alla fine dell'esercizio abbraccia Erika o Vanessa?

[@johnscott9845]

Does elisa speak English

[@amethyst.panther]

Still can’t get over how low the score was 🙄

[@lucasmatosaraujo7772]

Execution 8.6? Undescored

[@user-bw8vq2yo8f]

🙊

[@fireemblem2770]

WTF where’s the bleach OST

[@cc_ysd]

Wrong gymnast, Erika Fasana used bleach

[@fireemblem2770]

@@cc_ysd If you ever feel stupid, remember that at least you are not as stupid as me, gracias

[@barbarapiatti2619]

if it had been American it would have taken 16😂😒

[@mirimiri8922]

so low score

[@alienigenadesouza1617]

Uma nota de partida baixa, meu bem, qualquer brilhante apresentação tem nota baixa.

[@lvelyxheartgacha4346]

She can't speak English

[@PhenixJoe]

Well she is Italian and this was in Brazil. Not sure why her English is relevant...