Flub Drums: Why I Dislike Them

[@EMCproductions]

Apparently I misinterpreted the sports analogy 🤦 He's saying: Good Flub Drummer = JV Pitcher, and Bad Snare/Tenor/Bass Drummer = Varsity Outfield. ...but wouldn't the flubs be on the varsity team? IDK. Sports are confusing. EDIT - I *flubbed the sports analogy.

[@afriendlyreminder6072]

How can you deem yourself worthy to wear the baseball shirt and then commit such a flub, rookie mistake honestly😤😤😤

[@SeanLaMontagne]

I interpreted it to mean flub's is like playing outfield for the varsity team, and being put in pit would be like pitching for the JV team. Because let's be honest with ourselves, in the eyes of most high schoolers, being on flubs is just one step above being in pit. And to a lot of high-schoolers, Pit is where you go if you can't play anything else. This is not a good way to view mallet percussion and rack, but nonetheless this is the modern high school band mindset.

[@tacos8910]

Arcadia hs has an A line, an open line, and a world line. So basically frosh, JV, and varsity.

[@devinrichardson2314]

I went straight to the comments after you said it lol

[@RedDogMamaHD]

It's always nice to admit when you have flubbed your analysis ... (Like your review of "Drumline" ). 😜

[@Austin_Bass]

Haha flub is a funny word

[@Austin_Bass]

@@norb-of-the-dorg very fnuuy

[@jetster_b4139]

bibbers is funnier

[@Jaketheaxman]

It probably is used to describe yo mama

[@alyxl4mb904]

If you're high

[@TravisAlanHall]

Lol diddle still makes me giggle sometimes

[@lightningmcqueenfanpage4103]

My schools had a flub line once, because the directors kid wanted to be on snare but wasn’t good enough so he made a whole other line for him.

[@cletusj.johnson1850]

😂😂😂😂

[@randomdude1890]

F

[@bencunningham6298]

Well at least they didn't throw him on snare which I've seen happen

[@SeanLaMontagne]

Ah Flubs. The "you're not good enough for snare, but not big enough for bottom bass, and the pit tech would kill me if I dumped you on him" section. I feel like everyone says "they're to train you for the harder drums" and then only write quarter notes and half note impacts.

[@jasoncrocker881]

It's definitely goes both ways. Some people just aren't good enough, and some people are actually put on there to be built up for another instrument. Like last year, 3 of our snares, all 3 quads, and the bass section leader were on flubs their freshman year. We won percussion at our state competition. It's all about the program and if you have good techs or not

[@lucscott3631]

@@jasoncrocker881 lmao we don’t even have a tech

[@jasoncrocker881]

@@lucscott3631 Y'all are screwed then

[@WilliamBottka]

Hey there, former flub player here, at my group personally I learned a tone from playing on flub, as we still played a hard part like many of the others, it allowed me to reform my technique and gain some experience playing harder music, while still allowing me to be part of an ensemble. I plan to play snare for that group next year, flub in the correct circumstances works, look at chino hills I see many of their flub players playing on the snare, tenor or bass line the next year.

[@SeanLaMontagne]

@@WilliamBottka Why not play in front ensemble and spend an entire season developing your mallet and auxiliary percussion skills? Lotta cats that are in drumline for every year of band end up with glaring deficiencies in any non rudimental percussion setting. Not always the case, but you'd be amazed how many top-tier snare and quad guys haven't the slightest clue how to play with 4 mallets by the time they get to music school. But I guess that's what music school is for, right?

[@anthonyowens8822]

What the kid actually said, was that he would rather be the star of the B team instead of an insignificant player on the A team. The drumline version of this is not between the A drumline and B drumline, but it is between snare/tenor/bass(the A team) and flubs(the B team). He is saying he would rather be an awesome flubs player, than a crappy snare/tenor/bass player.

[@mrvladimirputin9828]

then he should play the snare and get good problem solved

[@greggchaffin1596]

Still a terrible thought process no matter how you put it. Let’s take the NFL for instance.... Would you rather be the best player on the Browns team or the worst player on the Patriots team? This should be a no brainer. You get better by playing with people better than you. You don’t get better by playing with people less experienced.

[@hunterrussell9263]

Yeah the kids gotta have a bit of an ego to even think about it in those terms. You really shouldn’t think about how you stack up to the rest of the people in your band. As long as you improve from day to day you’ll get where you want to be.

[@anthonyowens8822]

@@greggchaffin1596 I've realized that sports analogies do not work well for this so I will just explain it in drumline terms. The options are, 1. playing snare/tenor/bass but not being ready for it yet and dragging the whole line down. 2. playing flubs and getting better through experience while still learning from those around you and then being ready to play snare/tenor/bass during the next season. or 3. not being a part of the drumline at all and not getting any better. As someone who has never personally played flubs, but has seen what others can gain from spending a season on flubs, I would say that a flubline can be very beneficial to a drumline in the right situation. For my drumline in particular, we don't have any more room on snare/tenor/bass but we don't want to turn people away and not let them participate, so they play flubs. It really depends on two things, the size of your drumline, and the level of performance. Like I said, if your drumline is very big, a flubline could be a way to let people participate while not dragging the drumline down. If your drumline is small, then just put them on snare/tenor/bass and help them get better. Then is the difficulty. The schools they showed in the video, Avon, Carmel, and Centerville, all have very high levels of performance that would be very difficult to reach without much experience. In their cases, they need experienced players on their snare/tenor/basslines to reach the level they are shooting for. In less competitive bands, the level of performance needed is achievable by less experienced players over the course of just one season. Not all drumlines should have a flubline, but many can benefit from them.

[@thejohnleos]

Yeah, the outfield vs pitcher analogy was pretty dumb. But he’s a kid. So whatever

[@Finetales]

I legit didn't know flub drums were a real thing until this video lol

[@bluwolf098]

It doesn’t exist in smaller schools. Also I have never seen a small band use flubs before. I have only ever seen clubs in bigger bands what have maxed out their sections.

[@psychedahlia]

When he said "instead of just going to pit" with such disgust in his voice... That hurts man.

[@sunnydfangirl]

Well I don't think it was intentional; I think more just it can be detrimental to a prospective snare/tenor player to spend a year on mallets and letting their budding drum skills get rustier

[@isaiahmumaw]

I know Avon and their program definitely is much stronger in the drums than the pit, at least when I last saw them. Unfortunately it’s a lot harder to find good pits than it is good drumlines in this state.

[@SeanLaMontagne]

@@psychedahlia it's been almost 30 years since we got the front ensemble, and we still have this pervasive perspective that front ensemble is somehow lesser than drumline, and does not contribute anything to personal growth as percussionist. Despite front ensemble containing a wider variety of percussion instruments than the Drumline. This goes both ways, the kid who stays on snare for 4 years is just as behind as the kid who stays on marimba for 4 years. Maybe they're both Masters at that one specific instrument, but in terms of being a well-rounded percussionist, essential if you want to be a working musician, they're both far behind.

[@amazngdrummr27]

Your opinion is biased, good sir. YOU'VE NEVER EVEN MARCHED FLUBS!!!!

[@Amadea27]

I was just going to comment, even before watching the video: What do you think would Steven say 😂 I would never dare to dislike the Flubs with you as a section leader...

[@juandalepringle1658]

Steven has a point

[@brettjc0483]

Exschacktly.

[@Zequintiny]

Our drumline was big enough to have a flub section. For reference, we had a ten person cymbal line at one point. The director wanted an experienced player, so when we went to sectionals, someone knew what they're doing. Just like that, I'm Flub Section Leader. I gotta say, though, that it definitely got freshman marching and playing without hurting the overall sound. They were also super light, and almost fun to march with.

[@seocster7677]

I agree, as a part of my high school flub section

[@theredhun]

These are 3 of the best high school bands in/around Indianapolis. They have fully developed recruiting and training programs.

[@harpsechord1755]

I can verify this; my high school frequently competed against Carmel and Avon during the main marching season (Lafayette Jeff High School here; last I knew they went to the non-competing sector of marching band, but I haven't checked on that in the last few years) and lost out to both high schools in state semi-finals multiple times. (One exception being 2014, where my school did finally make it to State Finals and got 7th place)

[@cadenhall2834]

I think the flubs are a good tool for tone and accents.just like any drum it's just a different sound. but if I was on a flub line I would definitely be embarrassed.

[@JMako-6]

I have never marched flubs but I have played the flubs in our indoor percussion but they actually called them impact drums when I was in 8th grade and now I'm a junior as center snare and battery section leader.

[@theTenorDrummer]

Way to move up!

[@TheAmazingRaptor]

Me who’s still on flubs 👀

[@jacobhanekamp2534]

That school that has 5000 students has more students than the 2 high schools in my city

[@xanderrouk]

It has twice as many students than in my entire district

[@maxalain9948]

There are whole towns smaller than that high school

[@Brian-rj1un]

lol i go there ya schools pretty big. We have 8 snares, 4 quads, 5 bases this year

[@aether7841]

@@Brian-rj1un You still in the marching band?

[@Brian-rj1un]

@@aether7841 yeah

[@georgefritze7795]

President: *Is elected* EMC: FLUB DRUMS

[@GrandpaLui711]

0:16 yoo not to alarm you but there are ghosts behind you in the recording of this lick

[@Amadea27]

Indeed 👽💀

[@tacocraft604]

WHAT THE FU-

[@spoderman9638]

what happeneddddd😫?????????

[@qwertyuiop-jf1lm]

@@spoderman9638 I think Eric Carr had to record himself at different drums and spliced it together to look like he duplicated himself. So, I think its the editing.

[@Amadea27]

@@qwertyuiop-jf1lm i think the ghosts didn't notice spocktober has already passed.

[@joseph-2028]

I’m a sophomore at a big high school and I wish we had a flub line. I want to be in drumline, but keep getting put in pit. If I was on flubs, I would at least learn how to march with a drum in and help develop those skills.

[@johnkosch2757]

I’ve actually never heard these called flubs- the term I’m familiar with is “impact drums,” which is a lot sexier than, you know... “flub.” It helps to have them not only when you have a big line, but a greater disparity in proficiency between members of the line, I.e. someone who would be bored with your current bass crew but that would lag behind those currently playing snare and tenors

[@acousticfoam4184]

my school used flubs one year, and my band director called them "mono-tenors" he would get pretty annoyed when people called them flubs.

[@emperorofgaming8146]

I see you made this too. Scroll up and you’ll see mine, Felix ;)

[@acousticfoam4184]

@@emperorofgaming8146 whats good Payton

[@foistboinder]

Back in the 60's single tenors were a thing and perfectly respectable.

[@emperorofgaming8146]

@@foistboinder yes, but these weren’t actually single tenors, they were flubs. They had muffled heads.

[@AnkothOfficial]

@@foistboinder In Drum and Fife bands single tenors are still a thing.

[@castleheadcams5383]

It’s kinda like marching practice pads.

[@Amadea27]

3:05 Bassdrums *inserts picture of his beloved cowbell*

[@csmitt6565]

I AGREE they are for people who can’t play snare drum

[@cactusfishy1596]

They are for inexperienced future-snare drummers

[@trombonimacaroni]

Nice name bro

[@DouglasStevens0521]

At my highschool we just called it the tom line. Since we had a fairly large drumline we would have a ton line in the fall but in the winter we had two groups so we did not use toms. If you didn't make the varsity group then you went and played in the JV group. That way everyone can play the instrument they want to get better at regardless of skill. That worked out very well for us and it helped the group improve a ton over the years since we started doing that. So for any educators reading this, if you have the members to make this work I highly encourage going for it

[@seanoreilly9950]

send this to a flub player

[@123whistle]

I have no friends ._.

[@marcelszekowski315]

Shadow the Hedgehog friend is different than flub player

[@seanoreilly9950]

@@123whistle u shouldn’t be friends with a flub player anyway

[@sujanshadrak6110]

i just finished freshman year marching flubs, our school's flubs (or as we call them toms) play the same music as the snare except maybe a few rimshots taken out and some rolls that the snares need to have clean and our book is fairly hard so I think that flubs is a great way to get younger kids ready for snare in the years to come. We played basically everything the snares play. and our drums were actual parts of old tenors not just sawed off.

[@youtubecentral8645]

EMCproductions my school never has had a flub drum section this year. The reason why this happened is because since we’re short on time due to COVID my teacher wanted to add a pregame show and putt the people from pit into flubs or cymbal lines.

[@michaelreidy1800]

Imagine taking care of your snare drums all through high school (tuning, head changes etc.) working to make them the best they've ever sounded only to have them converted to flubs after you graduate. Wait just me? Ok

[@russellcratic]

This has always been interesting to me. Especially because single tenors (Just called tenor by most) in the HBCU and Pipe Band world are very important. While in the corp styled world it’s just to help build chops to move on to another part of the section. I would love to see a comparison from Eric about this.

[@fluffly3606]

"Flubs are the most important instrument in the entire marching band! /s" Is that a challenge to write a marching band composition that depends on the flubs?

[@tycoy998]

Eric, I must say. The video quality is becoming phenomenal! Keep up the great work!

[@michaellaton]

The indoor program I went to called them T2s. We were treated like a second tenorline...almost. It was a good learning experience for moving to an independent group from high school and established us in the group.

[@BossMann644]

Flubs are kinda weird I agree with EMC on this one

[@redbeardsfireworksshowcase]

I think the first interview was of one of their snare drummers. As an active adjudicator, I’ve always wanted the performers to add in some way musically. These instruments are rarely featured and often hidden. Being exposed at whatever performance level you are helps you get better. Thanks for the video!

[@shaanfliesplanes]

How dare you insult my instrument that I'm currently playing... Edit: Now I'm playing snare lol

[@elizabethvazquez875]

Im being put on flubs my freshman year 😔

[@shaanfliesplanes]

@@elizabethvazquez875 Don't get me wrong it's a lot of fun. I'm playing snare drum this year and playing flub has really helped. Good luck in your season!

[@elizabethvazquez875]

@@shaanfliesplanes thanks!

[@Etan1]

@@elizabethvazquez875 yeah i got put into a flub this a couple months ago, im actaully quite glad i did because if i got put into snare line i would have a rlly hard time playing the music they gave us, playing the flub has helped me lot with marking time, wrist movement, and I personally think (biased opionion) that every beginner should play the flub before going to snare line.

[@elizabethvazquez875]

@@Etan1 Now that I've been marching for awhile being flub is actually really fun! Last night we got 2nd place in percussion and beat some really good band so we celebrated! I've made some great friends as well 😊

[@drumhead89]

5:00 ERIC, RUN! There's a ghost behind you!!

[@tacocraft604]

0:16 ._.

[@NASA-sl6yg]

There was probably somebody walking so they far to edit them out

[@tacocraft604]

@@NASA-sl6yg Probably something to do with the 3 separate shots

[@NASA-sl6yg]

Yeah

[@UNOwen-yc3es]

@@tacocraft604 All this time I thought it was just really tall midgets and cloned and dressed into him. Nice drumming though.

[@OmegaTurtle]

My high school started doing flubs (we called them toms) my sophomore year. The percussion section was certainly big enough in my opinion and they didn’t make cuts from the ensemble, just possibly from sections, so it was always getting bigger. The only issue I always had with them was our writing for them. It was always extremely simple, so it wasn’t that great at getting them to get experience and learn how to play harder stuff. This past year though we had two really good freshman that were actually put on snare for outdoor since they were almost hanging on and were playing traditional, but for indoor they wanted to keep the line smaller and easier to clean, so they ended up on toms. We did though have a new person writing our battery music for indoor and he actually gave them good parts. So a combination of good players and a good arrangement made it a lot cooler.

[@TripleRevolution]

If one person picks up sticks and plays music because of “Flubs”, then we have achieved a very important goal. Not everyone needs to be a champion.... just enjoying the art of playing music is enough!

[@lym3f]

Our college line used 5 players on tri-toms (3 drums and a spock), tuned to the space between our tenors and bass 1. I think it filled out the sound nicely, but of course, I am heavily biased. Edit: Almost forgot the best part. Our tri-toms had cowbells too.

[@D1lts]

We call flub drums at our school “Altos”. Geez 😒 😂

[@maxalain9948]

I mean...... if ya think about it that makes sense. Snares (Sopranos) Flubs (Altos) Tenors Basses

[@mogmason6920]

Viola Drums

[@lucscott3631]

@@mogmason6920 underrated comment

[@PinnacleofRacing]

I can relate to this very much, during my freshman year (I’m now a senior) I was Flub line section leader and we had the de-tuned snares as what we called “Toms” and I was sadly put in this group after failing to keep up with bass music and I wasn’t the most fit since before this I was used to middle school advanced band which requires no activity haha... the judges would be so confused when we listened to tapes and they would call us “Extra snares in the corner” until they realized we were flubs. Ultimately for our school we had a huge roar of attendance in band and so my instructor made the line more or less for me to stay in the line somehow and also we just happened to get some new kids who were placed there so I was the only one with some drumming experience. Eventually did bass 5 drumline season of my freshman year and now I’m tenors since sophomore year! Flubs definitely taught me my way around the drum and I got exercises down... also yes I’m more fit now

[@adrianmixit1998]

The Flub drum is from the tenor drum family. If used correctly you can get great sounds. The sound it makes reminds me of the caribbean sounds and Sepultura.

[@RyanAlexanderBloom]

Flubs are for “training” but it really is for HUGE bands only. We thought about adding flubs for all these reasons… but we didn’t do it. We added an extra bass drum to the line instead. I mean, we would have had 2 flubs. 1 real bass is better. We weren’t maxed out though. If we had 5000 kids we would probably march cymbals, flubs, and a kitchen sink. At 1200 we still have room to add “real” parts. Side note, lots of bands march vertical single tenors. I.e. like 4-6 bass 1s. They have their own part. They’re not a training tool. People want that thudding midrange. Not me or any band in my state, but lots of college bands and bands in the south.

[@dpacula63]

My high school had less than 1000 students. So thus the marching band was small. But I think I like that better. It just felt like everyone was important and the director could give more attention to everyone

[@bward666]

Couldn’t get past the fact that Jeff Queen was the snare lead for the Blast broadway show on DVD

[@deltablaziken3325]

As someone from a high school Indiana that has to deal with these schools on a regular basis. “They’re freakin’ huge” is right.

[@teacheroxford]

I've never heard of a flub drum. But thank you for helping realize this is exactly what I need in my band! 😆😆😆

[@SeanLaMontagne]

*Ouch* at that "pit is just playing outfield for the A Team" comment The marimba player in my heart just cried a little bit. An ensemble I taught at for a minute did a 2 snare, 2 quad, 4 bass, 4 cymbal and 3 flub line once...

[@kirapfeifer1866]

This video was made 3 years ago today. Happy birthday

[@EmergedBird]

Avon high school has two drumlines: Avon World and Avon A. Plus, the kid in the interview went on to be center snare for Avon world and marched for Shadow dbc

[@gc1215]

That's actually epic oh my goodness

[@odeefromdawic]

I joined percussion after already spending 3 years on a wind instrument. My percussion section was extremely over saturated and I played flubs before bass because I wasn’t used to marching percussion yet. But I genuinely think the year on flubs helped my technique and confidence, as well as my drive to be good at bass my other years. The other 2 flubs I played with ended up ended up being a snare, and a quad player the following years.

[@joshuaduran6993]

Speaking on the topic of Varsity and JV marching band, my high school had a pretty dominant hold on our local marching band scene (only a school of 600 but the band was almost 200). No matter how hard we worked the bigger, richer schools near the biggest city in our state would always give us good competition at our state competition. My friends and I got bored and decided to do some research on these schools and found that one of them has THREE full marching bands that all meet separately. So yes, Varsity and JV marching bands do exist. And apparently JJV exists as well.

[@0Aquamelon]

I definitely have to say that's a good point for what you said, that schools with smaller drumlins shouldn't have a flub line, and it's better to play the instrument you're supposed to play instead of a different one. Though, flubs were a resource I wish we had back in my high school. my drumline was also too small to have a flub-line, so I wasn't mad that we didn't have one, but the inexperienced drummers and the freshmen got put on the BASSLINE! this lead to our baseline being pretty crappy, and also giving freshman a harder time to transition to snare or tenor because the technique was completely different. If we had a flub line (and our drumline was bigger ofc) we would be able to have three options for freshmen to move up into, the freshmen would be able to learn good technique for snares and quads, and we would have a better bassline as juniors and seniors would be on it instead of freshmen and first year upperclassmen. But again, there are ways to use them improperly, and the circumstances you made up in your video make sense.

[@4_yd3n58]

I’m a flub member and we use snare parts on flubs but we use match grip

[@actipton80]

As an Avon alum (not a drummer, but my younger brother was) I can confirm that they have had two winter drumlines since the 2004 winter drumline season. They are the A line and the world line. They have had a huge line in the fall since 2003, but I don't know when they added flubs. The footage in the video was from 2018 I think. The school was nowhere near as ginormous in 2003 as it is now.

[@riotkiley675]

This had me in tears. Literally the best call out on the internet for drums. I will share this with ALL of my friends and drumming pals . . Lmao

[@colbynuckles5402]

at my school we dont have a "varsity" or "jv" band but we have a comp band and a football band that has everyone in the comp band in it. the comp d-line only has bass tenors and snare, and the football band has flubs and cymbals added in. if you play flubs or cymbles and want to be in comp band then you have to try out for the pit, also there is no football pit

[@6or7breadsticks]

I woke up upset because the sun woke me up. I saw your thumbnail and heard in my head "GOOOD MORNING!" and I smiled, laughed, and the day is better

[@outdooroperator714]

"If you got a problem deciding if you like flub drum or not then you ain't in my drum line" -Corn Pop

[@mediocreanimator]

7:10 That girl in the background: *Mr. Stark... I don't feel so good...*

[@nickfournier3375]

In my first year of high school, there was no front ensemble during marching season because of COVID. So they just stuck all the freshman (myself included) on flub

[@smytofficial7032]

I think the flub has a way to be a sound part of the ensemble. Revelation percussion uses a T2 line which is a single tenor drum with a Spock, both tuned high and a cymbal mounted to it. This allows for members that would otherwise be put on a cymbal line to be marching a drum, creating an option to let a t2 fill a snare/tenor/bass position if a member is unable to finish the season AND fills the floor with more visual opportunity AND is audible to the audience. So big ups to rev for re-engineering the flub to be a core member of the ensemble

[@Ethang1103]

I’m from Pike HS (northwest Indianapolis) and when we saw Carmel compete they were about 3x as big as our marching band

[@Ethang1103]

It’s also common knowledge for everyone to hate them bc they always think that they’re better than everyone

[@Jazzvibe3071]

Star 93 and Thom Hannum named them the flubs. There is a small section in the show with a flub line.

[@leemcd56]

The closer

[@trombonimacaroni]

"Ready to play snare, tenors, or bass drum" * snare, tenors, and cowbell appear on screen *

[@ryanb5175]

My school had flub drums lady year in indoor and they were board out of their minds because they only played downbeets and their feature got cut. 😂

[@nitrox4578]

My school calls them impacts we also have 3 impacts 3 snares 3 tenors 5 bases and they all sound good together

[@LandonPrizeIverson]

I’ve never been able to get into band before (except in 4th grade when I played the flute)until now where I’m going into high school, and I finally can join marching band, and I’ve been teaching myself for about 2 years now so it’s gonna be really nice knowing how things work in marching band thanks to you, thank you EMC 😁

[@SJdrumz]

Update?

[@daelightyt]

5,000 students at a highschool?? my highschool only has 609 students 😭

[@pfunkbro]

We use single Tenors in Showstyle HBCU marching bands.. The difference is we play with Traditional tenor drum Mallets or small bass drum Mallets. We fill in percussion in gaps and play syncopated grooves. We use 14-16 inch floor Tom's converted into Marching single tenor drum. We call em tenor and we called multi tenors quints sixes and quads.. Some section play em like a snare drum and some play em side like a bass drum.. They have even developed a style of Mallets flourishing without using strings but its looks like using strings..

[@wordsmithpiko1784]

Didn't Star of Indiana use flubs in 1993 or were those just two-head tenors? Not a percussion person here, I couldn't tell the difference from the multi-cam.

[@justinpeng1352]

our school marched flubs in the form of 4 playing two tom drums sets (duos) and 4 playing two timbales. they were mostly used both for training new members, as well as to add more effects to the overall sound since the duos had a tambourine and the timbales had a cowbell installed. our drumline was huge, however, we marched like 9 snares, 6 tenors, 4 duos, 4 timbales, 6 basses, and 12 cymbals and still had alternates who would sub in if anyone was sick. check out olentangy orange high school marching band!!

[@archivedinformation7689]

You explained the analogy wrong, he said what you said. “It’s better to be the pitcher for the B team rather than being the outfielder for the A team.”

[@kirapfeifer1866]

I just checked, and my highschool has 866 people going to it

[@TromboneLoki]

My high school decided to have two marching bands once our band got to more than 300 people. It got to be too much to handle for the staff that we had at the time.

[@theguitaristthatdrums6062]

My school is so small. Literally like less than 800. Our whole indoor season this year is gonna have 1 snare, 1 tenor(me), 3 basses, 2 marimbas, I xylophone, and 1 rack person. Sad. I was also the only tenor last year and probably will be for the rest of highs school. (I’m a sophomore)

[@coastermaniacs]

Might as well strap some tom toms on from a dumb set

[@nickj9616]

My high school(Allen High School) has a varsity and a JV Drumline with 9 snares on varsity and we didn’t even have a flub line until this year.

[@calebdadrummer7764]

Small percussion section this year we have had 3 percussionist and what we did was we took 1 snare and 2 base drums we have all tried to tell our director to let one of us be on tenors one of us on snare and the another on base like we did on the Christmas parade you can see a photo of our Christmas parade in my profile photo

[@Ucannod]

Agree with Queen especially at schools developing a drum line and schools with an overflow of members. Corps used a version of the flub in the earlier tears before tenors - marching timp like SVG 78 and the single tenor drum. HBCU still use the single tenor.

[@friedpancakes266]

For concert season, many schools have bands sperated by years. The only exception to this at my school was percussion. We had our own percussion class, and performed with every band on top of our own music

[@ebach615]

fun fact: i marched snare at an independent open group but I was hella bad so they flubbed my drum lmaoooo

[@Ray-ij8ot]

Rip🤣

[@bshaboogie]

100% Agree with you here ... I only once had the luxury of teaching a line at a huge HS, and we a sizeable battery that did not have flubs ... those students with less chops were assigned spots that best utilized their level had of skill ... some were in the cym line, some in the front ensemble. But 99% of the other schools where I taught, we were lucky to field a battery of 10 people total... I guess I understand the flub idea (if the line if huge, or if you have 7th & 8th graders to participate)... but it;s not a practical idea for the majority of schools.

[@nickdeig6315]

3:26, Well that’s Avon marching band for ya

[@MGNate]

My school uses snares that make no sound if you aren't ready for the main snare line. But you still play all the same things as the main center drums you just don't make any noise.

[@evanvargas1536]

7:10 my man in the background just faded into nothingness

[@averageotaku1993]

In my high school drumline, if you weren’t good enough to play snare, tenor, or bass, you played cymbals. You could also play mallets.

[@captainkiwi77]

The WGI group I marched, alchemy fielded flubs the year after I left. Or as they called them the “electronic snare line”, they were just the previous years snares with vocoders for the ballad, I have to say the concept was cool but not well carried out, and the sheer size of the line made cleanliness impossible, between the like 12 snares total and 6 basses and 5 tenors and cymbals, it was just never gonna work. But I did like the idea they were going for. Personally I love flubs but only in the context of a high school with to many members. I think a flub drum with a cowbell can really add something to a group. What I do is I write for flubs in my cadences so that if you have a line you can use that but if your pit is in the stands with nothing to do then you can basically play the flub part on like timbales or something similar. But I do prefer them as a starting option for less experienced members as opposed to starting them on cymbals or bass or rack, cause cymbals and bass aren’t easy instruments and putting a beginner there when you don’t have to can be a disservice to them, as for starting beginners on rack I feel like rack should be the starting instrument for prospective front students as opposed to just battery cuts, having been a battery cut on rack, with the other rack player being also a battery cut, and both of us being centers at our high school, it’s a really weird dynamic where you don’t quite fit in with the front kids, and interpersonal dynamics greatly affect your groups playing, starting your least experienced front folks on rack let’s you put more experienced players on vibes so you can write an actually good part instead of the super easy stuff we see in many high schools

[@MetraBoy]

I go to carmel high school and there is actually about 350 kids in the marching band and 20 in the Drumline. I played fulbs in my 8th grade year because of covid which was a snare without the snares but now I'm on quads my freshman year so, big flex

[@ScarzzzYT]

I competed at state finals for winter percussion at Avon this year!

[@DWkoukimonster03]

I've never heard of this flub drum, but I remember this massive DL from my high school days that had a 10 man snare line. I remember watching them warm up and noticed the 3 outer most snares on each side were detuned with no snare and I thought they were cheating..... I guess I just learned what was actually taking place lol

[@Jarred.Hickman1627]

You should do a video on what its like being in a drumeline, what to do to prepare for drumeline, and what to do to prepare for a musical carrier. Like this video so Eric can see please. Thanks!

[@billholden20]

I think the A team/B team analogy was a nice way of saying he didn't want to be center marimba, he wanted to march, even if it is not a real instrument.

[@bestdirpy]

5:01 Bro in the back spawned in 💀

[@ralyks._rgw]

At my school, we had too many members joining the Drumline so we decided to have a Flub line, but we didn’t have any flubs so we just detuned some snares from the local middle school

[@alexmontanye4583]

My high school had a varsity and JV Drumline. It was always the same people though. Varsity was serious and we played our main instrument and JV we would try something new

[@grubblepidd2567]

I remeber when I was in marching band 7th grade, our drumline had 2 tenors, bass 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 snares, 2 cybals, 2 marching glockenspiels (With weird harnesses) and a single flub. His name was cooper and that was his first year in marching band and drumline. Most people including him called the flub "Bass 0"

[@medleysa]

My high school had 3500 students. We still didn’t use flubs. We had 5 bass, 5 snare, and 3 tenor. We stuck extra kids in pit, on cymbals, or just had them play in the stands only and had them shadow a snare or tenor or bass at practice and fill in when kids were sick.

[@jasoncrocker881]

Our best quad, snare, and bass last year were all flubs their freshman year. The point is to get them ready for whatever instrument they choose to go to next. We won state percussion back to back years with them as the top people in our drumline. There's a reason for flubs.

[@gc1215]

I think the Avon guy making a sports analogy has to be my favorite piece of foreshadowing I've seen in a while

[@Chaos_at_the_max]

I love that I competed against these schools this season :) they are all huge bands and sound amazing

[@bobbob4173]

our school doesn't have this but we have a "snare b" line which are snares with a silent head. They play all the same parts as snares. It accomplishes the same thing as flub drums without adding a whole other section. Also our drumline is huge so we aren't missing out on other sections, the people put on snare b would otherwise have been our 17th 18th and 19th cymbal lol. also im snare b this year hoping to improve and be a snare next year

[@danielperry7600]

I would never add a flub drum section, but I would add a double tenor section. I have a tenors that are 8,10,12,13, I would use double tenors 14,16. Run bass drums starting at 18. Use the double tenors to bridge the sound between the quints and bass drums. Again would arrange the ensemble with the doubles part of the overall sound not just something added on. This could be helpful if you are dealing with an ensemble of younger players who can’t carry big block tenors.