Ep 002D Symphony Musicians React | Disturbed - Sound of Silence LIVE - Rolando

[@panerdar]

Can't believe you talked through pretty much the entire song.

[@whotakesallmynames]

Well, he lead with that he is a trumpet player, and I have a theory about musicians. So trumpet players a lot of times take the lead melody and let their notes ring out above what they consider to be the more background music in a piece. That's the role they're used to playing in an arrangement. So yeah, he talks over everything because he doesn't think or doesn't realize that listening and really paying attention to what he's reacting to is more important than talking over it about what his opinion is (of the ten seconds he did listen to). Which is what, is it ironic? That the song talks about the inability to really listen and take in and understand what other people are saying? (I was a trumpet player myself for a few years when I was a teenager, not half bad until I got braces. See? Even I'm still tooting my own horn.) *I'll concede that his ears are more trained to listen to the instrumentation and not to the nuances of David's voice and all the little things he does with it that contribute to the performance. The vocalists who react all pick up on the little things in his voice and sometimes don't mention the instruments at all. But come on, David's voice is clearly the star here, that's what makes the cover what it is.

[@SARA-11-1]

I don't know how anyone could actually talk or stop this song while playing, it takes me to heights when listened in i's entirety, I just want to enjoy and appreciate.

[@kathryngreen8665]

You talked right through the best parts.

[@billcale6312]

This guy literally talked through the whole song! He wouldn’t shut up! I like it so much better when they wait until the end.

[@scottrandall1546]

His facial expressions are not for dramatic effect, it is LITERALLY the correct way to do a "vocal fry" (grit in voice) by placing it more in the front by scrunching up the face. Because he does this, he has been able to have a VERY long career.

[@duncanmccann2715]

I think that's known as 'talking over the best bits'.

[@watchinout1897]

You literally were talking over the best parts!!

[@bdmention]

I recommend commenting while the video is paused.

[@andremesq]

My thoughts exactly.

[@mariegiroux6251]

Dude, word of advice, when making reaction videos, listen to the damn song then talk about it, dont talk over the song.

[@scottrandall1546]

Or at least pause it to make your comment then start it back up. I have seen SO MANY reaction people MISS COMPLETELY funny or relevant material by talking over it.

[@stabehlphotography]

Might be without even knowing it, but... an effective way to avoid copyright strikes. The KZbin bots listens for recognizable music pieces. Even if you pause things, it will just look for it on the up pickup. Talking over it though, confuse the crap out of the bots. Not sure if that is the reasoning behind his talking over, but effective never the less. I will agree with you though. He did talk right over the very thing he in the start was talking about expecting to hear from Disturbed.

[@SpearM3064]

@@stabehlphotography Or, you know, just a lack of experience, never having done a reaction video before (or only having done one or two before).

[@stabehlphotography]

@@SpearM3064 Leaning towards that myself too. Just pointing out the benefits in a copyright strike sense. Do I personally think that is why he did it ? nope. Doesn't become me as a "pro reactor" by any stretch. I think he is a professional musician and likely just didn't want to pause a nice piece

[@ruthiewohlforth5464]

Agreed!

[@Hayseo]

It’s a good song. You should listen to it sometime.

[@chriscummings6997]

Sorry, Larry, it is a SUPERB song!!

[@jamiekendrick5057]

Agreed, instead of talking through it, He should listen to it.

[@gandalfthesober5502]

Yeah. What they said. 😁🤘

[@ruthiewohlforth5464]

Couldn't agree more!

[@TheTibbott]

Yeah. Shut up already.

[@paddy3030]

After three Ep 002D on this song.... All three talked over the best parts. Think I'll just watch it on Conan when I need my fix.

[@nrsvlda70]

This is a really great version of this song... you should hush and listen!

[@holdon4992]

Ah, funny about the faces. Watch how vocal coaches explain it. Especially when he does the vocal fry, the physicality of pushing his face forward is how he is keeping his vocals cords from getting damaged. The fact that the facial expressions fit the song so perfectly is just a bonus. The spat of musicians reactions I am now seeing is interesting. You all are looking around him to see the orchestra and naming the instruments and when they would come in. I suppose when music is your career, it’s difficult to disconnect from the mechanics of music making to actually just feel the music. Oddly, listening without hearing, the theme of the song! You kind of personified it right there.

[@jillgambone8316]

You said exactly what I was thinking! Right on point!

[@jillgambone8316]

I’m glad I wasn’t the only one who didn’t like all the talking.

[@holdenkyleamazing3950]

++++++1million

[@donnfornash6153]

You talked through the vest part of the sing!

[@davidkrutsinger5414]

stop talking and listen man

[@Coonfused57]

The way the song built as the instruments came in brought in a lot of emotional content.

[@sharonlambchoporeggio5761]

They were nominated and didn't win??? Are you kidding me!!!! This band was amazing!!!

[@jimreadey4837]

"babd"...?

[@SimbaOS]

You've missed the best part of the performance by talking and not listening.

[@chriscummings6997]

Dude, how can you comment on a voice when talking over it? Very poor.

[@rafzonrhode7090]

I have seen some really bad reaction videos, and this was one of them. One main point of a reaction is to show a reaction, not a commentary. How can you react to something that you are obviously not really even listening to?

[@tamwheel5818]

Your so right , David never strains his voice he has a wet rasp so he keeps it very clean and effortless. He is highly trained in voice and his octave range is amazing.

[@robinbrainard4301]

I agree about his voice. I'm surprised the trumpet player could hear David over himself.

[@lizawake614]

Silence is a good idea when listening to this

[@coolcat9423]

You ruined that song . Maybe you should listen to it again ,you may even appreciate it .

[@sydneywellington22]

Draiman covers roughly two-and-a-half octaves from bottom to top. His vocals are so distinctive. If you are speaking, you cannot really listen. ..."People hearing without listening". Are you really a musician?

[@trucker4272]

Put a muzzle on him.

[@alanfoster6589]

You wouldn't like it if you were doing the trumpet part near the end of Bantock's Hebridean symphony and somebody reacted by constantly talk over it.

[@ellienesmith4016]

AMAZING...Favorite song version ever! No one, NO ONE does it better! David Draiman is amazing!!!

[@susanenglander9977]

Please listen. What did he say I couldn't hear. But I do know the room was blue

[@kayeaton1691]

He has a unique voice

[@BitWrecker]

Dude....You talked right over the crescendo

[@johnblund700]

So opposite to "reagular" reactors. They pause and say what they want, you speak in the middle of all the excitement, so we miss all the good parts :(

[@manuelruen]

4:44 It wasn't quite zero strain he actually talked about singing this song in a documentary. He was actually sick during the performance he had the flu! It's crazy that he was able to pull this off while he was sick!

[@gregwilliams135]

Dude u talked right thru the best parts

[@sarakaster]

when will reaction channels ever learn. If you talk you pause. If they sing you shut up.

[@dennisboulais7905]

Spentway too much time commenting on stuff that just doesn't matter.

[@jimreadey4837]

Rolando, I think you had a really good reaction video happening, excepting only a one-minute span from 4:30 to 5:30. This was the song's climax, and you kinda missed it because -- I believe -- you had gotten so excited about what you'd just heard, and your excitement caused you to talk over this part. I don't blame you for being excited. It's a great, great song. Please do, however, consider adding additional footage where you replay at least the aformentioned minute-- in silence, of course. And please excuse any rude comments here. I think a lot of us just felt disappointed we didn't get to see you react to our favorite part...we wanted to share in that with you!

[@whotakesallmynames]

thanks for posting this thought in a really constructive way! Talking like that helps people to really hear what you are saying, instead of some of the other more terse comments that tend to shut down good communication

[@s.kenthamilton8745]

I'd be very interested in seeing all of your reactions to the symphonic metal band Nightwish. Perhaps their "Ghost Love Score" live at Waken 2013 or "The Greatest Show on Earth" live at Tempre. The orchestra in both of those is tracked rather than live though (London Philharmonic does the backing track in both of those if I remember correctly).

[@Aravah1887]

as long as he doesn't talk over Floor, especially the end note

[@metalmellie4371]

Dude, next time pause when you're talking. Geez

[@marablemorgan8292]

David Draiman was classically trained as a Cantor!

[@therealspooks]

Trumpet player myself, horn paid for school, drummer as well and yes I saw Maynard Ferguson live 6ft away and shook his hand...great video!!

[@007tallguy]

how can you react to a song that you're not even listening to? you got a pause button for when you want to comment on what you're "hearing" then again, as the lyrics go..... "people talking without listening!!"

[@Sandy-tj4wn]

Those 2 songs can't be any more different from each other. I feel an urgency in his way of saying the words. S&G never felt like that

[@1995BONEDADDY]

You must give pentatonix a try. OMG they are a accappela group, they are amazing !! They cover sound of silence and hallelujah. Chilling.

[@garywilliams5661]

Nice voice just couldn’t hear it

[@deco9863]

Horrible reaction. Less talking...more listening. Peace.....

[@adamedwards2261]

He was a cantor as well as highly classically trained.

[@carolcornell6332]

Listen !

[@DeRochaJ]

It is such a powerful cover of the original. 10/10

[@jonathanwobesky9507]

I've watched 3 "symphony musicians react" videos and two were clueless, this guy talks through the vocal and lyrical climax, blabs about David's relaxed sound Just as he brings the grit and anger so he missed it. Ep 002C was good with the pink haired violinist

[@Onlymeonlymeable]

Enough of me talking, and then you talk and and talk and talk.

[@georgeibrahim7945]

You have to check out the best vocalist from down under John Farnham singing the Beatles song "Help" live with the Melbourne Symphony Orchestra. His vocals are crazy and he's an entertainer, the way he interacts with the crowd is awesome. John Farnham is an Aussie icon.

[@mrme123ee]

This guy could fuck up a wet dream. Geeze. It's like sabatoge.

[@geetee8665]

Nothing wrong with silence bro.

[@rickmcgibbon6290]

You mentioned the instruments, his voice, the lighting but you did't comment on the lyrics ?? As the original was focused, that in 1964 the folk music of the 50' and early 60's and their powerful messages were being drowned out by the British Rock Invasion where the beat and rock sounds were the most important. Not just the distraction of TV and the limiting of conversation. This newer version makes me think that we are bowing down to our new distraction, the "smart phone" and even less conversation. S&G folk version was a poetic warning, and David's version is a rage that no one seems to have paid any attention to the earlier version. Slainte

[@karencimino8843]

He is god .that voice

[@Dreams4U2]

If you're talking during the performance, how can you 'hear' the performance?? Along with the fact that it's annoying. You should pause the video when you want to comment on elements.

[@ricklarsen7438]

Not bad for being sick. Ran a fever during this show.

[@Rellj16]

This song is amazing! And this performance of this song is the best version of this song ever. Phenomenal! For another best version of a song EVER, y'all should definitely check out Post Modern Jukebox's cover of Creep ft Haley Reinhart. You will not regret it!!

[@discussdebate]

This is so far removed from their typical music that anyone (EVERYONE?) is blown away!! Not until this was released (12/2015) did anyone feel these lyrics so intensely!! This is way more dominant and dynamic than the 1965 original; not necessarily better!! This song can and SHOULD be listened to by anyone who likes music; all genre listeners should experience this song!! IMO, check out Heart paying tribute to Led Zeppelin (2012) in front of the boyz!! Beautiful/Powerful/Incredible Version!! = kzbin.info/www/bejne/bpaVl32cnsmXrpY and then listen to Johnny Cash play a Nine Inch Nail song... and own it!! = kzbin.info/www/bejne/bnKrdJmQibd6n6s

[@maureencanty3350]

Classic trained

[@richardroberts5570]

You’re hearing without listening

[@lovetocheerx0x0]

How can you react without listening? You talk through the entire performance. So how can anybody listening hear the UNBELIEVABLE performance that was being sung. Who cares that you’ve seen them in concert. Many people haven’t. I have, and it was really madding. If you want people to listen to your channel, stop talking, and let the listeners make their own assumptions.

[@selenaignjatovic3566]

First time I see a reactor talking over the song. Such a turn off, honestly. Just pause it and speak, because masterpiece like this is not meant to be talked over, just saying.

[@joansmith3129]

Why?Why? Why? do all ppl talk through the fucking video instead of just LISTENing then reacting....such a fucking turn off!!! this was one ot the best songs ever!!!!

[@powerdavid6235]

Too much talking, you're not even giving a chance to listen to it... It just shows you like the sound of your own voice rather than the sound of singer.... awful reaction, I won't be visiting your channel again.

[@SpearM3064]

Too much talking, you're not even giving him a chance to learn from experience what the best way to do a reaction video is. This is, what, his first reaction video? Maybe his second?

[@lisaschultz469]

How about next time you keep your trap shut or pause video. How could you possibly have heard one note he sang?

[@alibebee6463]

Too much talking during the song. Watch video for full effect.

[@jackdanereacts4527]

Well another first. You basically talked over the entire song. Think about pausing the video to talk. Sad.

[@TruckernutzBJL]

Try not to talk during the video and focus more on the performance and comments after or pause it if you have to

[@joeno-say5504]

I'm guessing this guy has been a band show or drum corps show judge before. They have to record their thoughts in the moment over the performance, so the judged group can listen and make corrections for the future.

[@angguzman]

Saludos, creo que la mayoría de nosotros esperábamos ver tu reacción cuando llegara la mejor parte de la canción y tu no paraste de hablar, hasta parecía que la música te interrumpía al hablar y en lugar de pausar el video, te esforzaste por arruinar la reacción y nuestras expectativas, creo que la mayoría estará de acuerdo conmigo, te aconsejo poner mayor atención a lo que haces y escuchar a tu audiencia, ya que a ella se debe este canal.

[@ksks8135]

your supposed to pause the song for your comments!!!!! DUH??????

[@onstone]

You had two ears one mouth--use in that order!

[@suzannepatterson5548]

You talked thru the whole thing

[@ericblough491]

You shouldn't talk so much over the video, basically ruining the video. To, me it means you aren't really listening to David's voice or the amazing arriangment of the song. You destroyed it by doing that, it is early in your quest and it won't go well if you continue doing that.

[@SpearM3064]

Finally! Someone who at least realizes this guy hasn't done a lot of reaction videos. Give him time. He'll learn. (Or not, but that's on him.)

[@jamiekendrick5057]

If you do a react video again, suggest you NOT talk over almost the whole song.

[@jillgambone8316]

You talked through the whole thing. At least stop it so you can really hear what is going on with his voice!

[@alasandraorali6798]

shhhh less talking more listening, after it you can comment, you missed so much.

[@thanosdarkseid8695]

david is jewish and highly trained in their style of singing and still ....i am not jewish so i don't know what it is called David Draiman is an operatically trained cantor tho and has gone back to study more...FYI IN THIS LIVE PART ONLY ONE PART HE USED AUTO TUNE TRACK HE WAS VERRRRY PISSED SAYIN NO MATTER DONT USE IT BUT THEY SNUCK IT IN AND YOU SEE WHEN HE TURNS HIS HEAD IN ANGER LIKE FUCK REAL FAST ON THE BUILD UP///HE WAS VERY SICK HERE BUT REFUSED TO POSTPONE THE SONG...

[@missyfitch4004]

He was trained as a Cantor(sp?)

[@chriscarter1323]

So Rolando,what have you learned?

[@lolof9227]

Listen to it again and shut up, you might enjoy it more....

[@charmmh4054]

Shhhh

[@corneliusantonius3108]

Sabaton 40-1 (live at Woodstock Festival 2012) : kzbin.info/www/bejne/iqqQZZ2hbph5qKc 💕💕💕

[@mirandasalinas451]

U didn't really even listen to it, u talked over it damn near the entire song!

[@Ultra54able]

I appreciated your commentary. I have listened to the song 300 times today so some commentary is not a problem.

[@andresjuan8783]

Opera Rock. From Spain please. React to Camilo Sesto: Getsemani ( live 1977 )

[@elenadinu7576]

Really nice reaction!! 👍👍 David Draiman's voice is so powerful and versatile, I just love it! And I love this rendition as much as I love Disturbed.

[@steveharwood5184]

Don’t talk!! Listen, take breaks if you want to comment!! One video just spoiled.

[@SpearM3064]

@@steveharwood5184 I wonder how many people would tell him he ruined it if he kept pausing every 10 or 15 seconds to comment on something.

[@steveharwood5184]

SpearM75503 obviously you can use common sense, other reactions seem to strike a nice balance.

[@jeffrawe6486]

Completely spoiled by the beard talking through the song.......give your opinion AFTER the performance.

[@clintgroom8213]

re-do this. pause when you want to speak. please.

[@alfredrestivo2713]

All you had to do is PAUSE for the comments and I would have subscribed. But alas, you didn't. There IS a reason your subscriber count is so low after a year.

[@robertheckman8013]

You should listen first, talk later. You missed the emotion of the song. Nobody else cared about the color!

[@jonathanlindsey463]

talk before and after.. NOT during.. it’s hard for u to appreciate it when ur talking and not listening... plus it ruins the listening experience for people listening

[@OhioPrepperOne]

Talk less, pause the video when you talk 👍🏻

[@RobertErnestLewis]

Who is Simon and Garfrunkmal ??

[@chrishunt4584]

I'm sorry I couldn't tell if that was disturbed or not over all your damn talking. Dude sit back watch video appreciate then comment.

[@ahernandez95]

You will receive no like only because you talked over the best parts of the song, please redeem yourself with a reaction of the official video.

[@creepylonghair]

cant watch till the end too much chatter byeee

[@bertiesark]

Sorry I can’t finish the video you talk way to much over the music

[@ruthiewohlforth5464]

Dude.....don't talk the hell over it!!!!! SMH.....

[@d.d.1189]

just so you know.....As most people know by now....that day...the singer was sick as hell....So you might want to check the 'official version' of that song :)