EP-04 II Mukalmah II Fikr e Ghamidi awr Rewayati Fikr ka Mutaliah

[@wasimwani3326]

Salam alaikum ...." dekhiye baat ye hai " aapka ka taqya kalam sunne me maza aata hai hafiz sahab

[@sufiahmed9510]

Two Brilliants Face to Face... Technical Questions-- Authentic Answers....

[@numan683]

ma shaa Allah

[@j.b9598]

Jo usool se mehroom hua Wo manzil se mehroom hua

[@khurramjawaid6211]

Great Work very knowledgeable discussion

[@mosambis123]

1:00:00 only a expert PhD can answer this question with such ease. Ma Sha Allah may Allah protect the shaikh

[@drcolmunirahmed9065]

MashaAllah very healthy discussion of two eminent scholars hafis zjbair has criticissd every eminent acholar as per his understanding, asim mughal seems to be impressed from javid ahmed ghamdi so a very fruitful n conclusive discussion

[@drcolmunirahmed9065]

very intellectual response!/critisim on fekre ghamdi compiled by dr zubair ahmed a very narrow /negligible difference /manipulation of words very concerted effort of giving explainin to let dr Zubair ahmed to reconcile on his criticism on javid ahmed ghamdi

[@muhammadtahir7527]

بہت اچھی علمی بحث ہے... ازراہ تفنن حافظ زبیر صاحب نے عاصم بھائی کی پرائیویٹ جہاد والی بات پر بہت سمجھداری سے بالکل کوئی تبصرہ نہیں کیا کیا... حالانکہ اس پرائیویٹ جہاد کی سند رسول اللہ صلعم کے قدموں کی بجائے امریکی ڈالروں تک ہر طرح سے ثابت ہے😅

[@youshaysiddiqui2572]

Bhai Asim Mughal needs a ustad to even learb critical thinking. He has bot answered anything. Hafiz saab is real scholarship

[@tawheedulbari8636]

ماشاء الله زبردست شيخ محترم

[@liaqataliabdullah9612]

tremendous effort BarakAllah

[@anwar4cs]

ماشآء اللہ ،بہت خوب

[@mightybrisk7612]

Ma Sha Allah Ma Sha Allah

[@AbdusSattarJhujh]

Ma-sha-Allah ❤️

[@kashifkhokhar2760]

Jzakallha Hafiz sahib

[@mosambis123]

1:29:00 Statement is the basis of next 8 videos.

[@sabirakram923]

SUBHANALLAH

[@muhammadarslan6885]

jazakAllah

[@drcolmunirahmed9065]

dr hafiz zubair ahmed should eneumerate/point aut ahadees wherein all 27 sunnats eneumerated by javid ahmed ghamdi to correct? ghamde sb

[@asifkar]

it took long to reach at this point 45:40

[@wajahat_ahmad]

Hafi i appreciate k riwayt ko support krty huy apny riwytibtreeqa ni apnaya.. Its a good gesture. BTW. Ak acha host rkh lyn mughal sb k replacement main. Ta k hmain b mza ajay.

[@eyeofthebeholder9376]

This is a great effort I am sure and praiseworthy. But it is the kind of discussion that the ordinary person cannot benefit from fully because of its technicality and hard technical terms. Ulema have never made an effort to make the deen easy to understand for the ordinary person similar to the classical church that stressed the bible has to be read in Latin and only the clergy understood Latin. So that the church had hedgemony on bible interpretation. This discussion too might as well be in Latin. Only the few people who understand these technical terms will benefit from it and the ordinary masses will continue to be misled by wrong beliefs and continue to be hijacked by munkir e hadees people or people who claim to invent new interpretations in deen. Or even people who claim to be prophets

[@mianzarrar3796]

Asim sahab hadees ko context mai smjna ki bat mai theek hai jo kay Ahle hadees nai krtay sirf zahiri ratta lgatay hai likin insay Quran nai smja jata.😅

[@Sadiqjamil8590]

EP 3 KZbin par nhi mil raha hai agar link deden to bahut maherbani hogi

[@talhahassan2233]

Mohtaram janab k pas, jb zubair sahab k sawal ka koi Javab nhi hota to farmatay hain k ye aj ka mozu nhi hai.or is pr bad Mai behas karengy.janab jis concept or nazarye ko ghamdi sahab pesh kr rahay hain ,uskay aik nukaat ko bayan krnay mai 4 episode guzar gai or wo namukammal he rha..tou sekhnay mai kitna time lagay ga..phir amal jannat mai ja kr krengy kia..afsos ghamdi sahab nay mantiq ki bunyad pr deen ko samjha or samjhaya.or logo ko amal krna mushkil kr dya.ye nazrye e ghamdi do( 2) musalman samajh nhi pa rahay., gheir Muslim kia samjhay ga.

[@talhahassan2233]

@@hammadanjum8518 janab mai nay ghamdi sahab ko suna hai.aik dafaa nhi.mutaddid martaba.or mai ghamdi sahab ko kisi or ki nazar say nhi dekhna.or na kisi riwaiti aalim ko riwaiti nazar say dekhta hu.mai sirf apna zehan aik aam musalman ki taraf sada bana kr jaisay Arab k baddu they.us taraf kr k sunta or samjhta hu.na modernist na classical.jb mai is taraf krta hu to ghamdi sahab k deen bagheir daleel k or mushkil nazar ata hai.sirf baat krnay ka style acha hai bus.back mai koi daleel nhi hai .sirf mafrozay or mantiq hai...or jb classical ko sunta hu to aik baat k pechay hazaro daleel or mabahis miltay hai.or asaan lagta hai.janab mai ad deenu yusran manta hu.ALLAH PAK ka deen samajhna itna mushkil kesay ho Sakta hai.ye gaon dehat k logo ko kia samajh aiega jb k master or phd nhi samajh pa rha.yassarnal Quran ka asaan deen hai janab

[@talhahassan2233]

@@hammadanjum8518 Wo 23 aetrazat ki videos menay suni hai.Dallas mai Huey hai ghaliban.usko sun kr he wazeh hua k ghamdi sahab ki aik soch hai.us soch mai WO Quran e pak or hadees e sahiya ko dhalnay ki koshish krtay hain.jb k apni soch ko Quran o hadees k mutabiq dhalna bandagi hai.ab rahi baat ulma e kiram ki..to mai to ulma ki baat he nhi kr rha is waqt..mai to sources ki bat kr RHA hu.mujhe koi bhe masla pesh hoga mai Quran o hadees mai talash kruga.laikin ghamdi sahab us maslay ko apni soch k mutabiq Quran o hadees mai dhal k mujhe bata dengy..phir mera aamanna wa saddaqna kaha gya.ye to maazAllah ghamdi sahab ki bat ko or soch ko manna hogya..mujhe na ghamdi sahab say koi duahmani hai na zubair sahab say dosti.mein to daleel mangta hu .WO mil jai.bus kaafi hai.jbkay ghamdi sahab 2 ghanay agar bolengy to daleel nhi logic hogi.bus itni si baat hai.or akhir mai ye k ghamdi sahab k yaha apko asani nazar ati hai WO is liye k ghamdi sahab nay bohat kuch Islamic taleemat say minus krdya hai.maazAllah.is liye jb amal k liye kuch hoga nhi to asaan he lagay ga na dost...ye to papayyit ki riwayat maloom hoti hai.shayad.Wallaho alam.

[@muhammadamanullah3903]

جناب مجھ تک دین کیسے پوھنچا عملی تواتر سے یا خبر احا د سے میرا اپنا تجربہ یہ ہنے کہ میں نے اپنے والدین کو آس عمر میں نماز اور روزو و دیگر عبادت کرتے دیکھا جب مجہے اس کا شعور ہی نہیں تھا میں نے اپنے والدین کے عمل کو اس وقت اپنانآ شروع کیا جب مجھ پر عبادات فرض نہیں تھیں. خبر تو مجھ تک اس وقت پہنچی جب میں دس بارہ سال کی عمر میں اس قا بل ھوا کہ تھوڑا بہت سمجھ سکوں کہ دین کے بںیادی تقاضے کیا ھیں. اب ڈاکٹر صاحب مجہے بتایں کہ مجھ تک دین کیسے پہنچا.

[@Sadiqjamil8590]

@@DrHafizMuhammadZubair میں دل کی گہرائی سے آپ کے لئے دعا گو ہوں یقیناً میں عامدی صاحب کے افکار و نظریات سے بے حد پیچیدگی اور تذبذب میں تھا الحمدللہ آپ کی باتیں سے مجھے بہت فائدہ ہوا

[@Sadiqjamil8590]

@@DrHafizMuhammadZubair آپ سے ایک بات یہ پوچھنی تھی کہ کیا قرآن کریم کے متعلق بھی جب یہ سوال ہوگا کہ یہ ہمیں کیسے معلوم ہوگا کہ یہ وہی قرآن ہے جو عہد نبوی صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم میں پڑھا جاتا تھا ، تو کیا اس بات کا بھی علم ہمیں خبر احاد ہی سے ہوگا

[@hassanafzal2083]

@@DrHafizMuhammadZubair Hafiz sahib ap jo kah rhy ha kay parents say shirk bi pohancha ha or quran . Iska matlab hum tak quran ijma say pohanch gya ha or ye allah ki kitab ha ab hum jab iska simple sa tarjuma parhy gay then inshallah hamara wo shirk jo parents ki waja say tha wo door ho jai ga

[@drcolmunirahmed9065]

sunnsts r not derived from akhbare shad

[@muhammadarshad2680]

انٹرویور صاحب، غامدی صاحب کے مقدمے کی پیروی میں آپ کے دلائل بہت کمزور ہیں،

[@TalhaTamseel]

Asim bhai ko zara tahamul rehna chhiaye . Baat ko kata mat kren baat arhy hoty ha to wo beech me boldyty hain

[@umedullahkhan3170]

6:22 Ajeeb baat hai Asim bhai jab quran isko mauzo nahi banaya tu phir aap ne is ko usool kis bunyad pr bana ya BHAI ASIM aap bahas me mukhlis nahi hai jahan aap ke paas dalil nahi hai aap ne kheh dena chahiye mere paas is ki dalil nahi hai

[@saminabajwa8391]

Video time thora kam kr den to zayada faida ho ga

[@j.b9598]

Jaruri nahi me khayal me

[@gm10120]

Very weak counter arguments against Ghamidi sb fikar and very illogical way of explanation, bias and poor reasoning of Zubair Sb. I didnt understand your single thing.

[@123mrkhalid]

This anchor needs to do his research be opening his mouth. Its obvious he has an agenda.Hafiz Saab on different level.

[@khurrammasood1403]

Asim mughal is looking confused . Can't understand the basic concept of shariah. Need more mature person from makteb e farahi or ghamdi group to counter Dr zubair. MA SHA ALLAH..

[@adafridi]

Isko hata dia hai. Fazul host hai yun hi shuru hai

[@afnan_a]

Ab tak ki episodes me Asim sahib confuse e nazar aa rhe hen, pta nhi unko ghamidi sahib ki smajh nhi i ye phir unko ye nhi pta k wo kya keh rhe hen or unko kya kehna hy ... kabhi idhar kabhi udhar tamak toyan maar rhe hen, jab keh Dr. Sahib bilkul seedhi seedhi baat kr rhe hen jo k ek aam aadmi ko b samajh aa sakti hy, mjhe to yun lagta hy k ghamidi sahib b ek confuse insan hen

[@drcolmunirahmed9065]

dr zubair ahmed should think that he he is not obliged to /given contract by Almighty to criticise on every one at least books should be avoided to put oneself on opposite sides of china war rediculous on part of dr zuubair

[@shahheenashahid6685]

I think ghamadi just want to be popular as a mujtahid in this modernist era ,that why he make new principals against the classical school of thoughts.but unfortunately he have only few followers because his school of thought have no match with the islamic teachings and have no proof with quaran and hadees.

[@muhammadarshad2680]

عاصم صاحب، آپ غلط کہ رہے ہیں، غامدی صاحب ماڈرن فکر والوں کی حمایت میں بہت دور نکل جاتے ہیں، ایسا لگتا ہے وہ ان سے endorsement لینا چاہ رہے ہیں،