Epic Cake Recipe for our famous Cinnamon Toast Cake | Cupcake Jemma

Sally's back sharing the recipe for one of our absolute favourite cupcakes.. in cake form! Cinnamon Toast! It's buttery, full of toast & cinnamon sugar and finished with the tastiest little cinnamon toast cereal pieces!
Buttery Toast Crumbs
6 pieces of standard brown bread
Unsalted Butter
Cake
310 g Unsalted Butter
310g Caster Sugar
5 Eggs
60g Toast Crumbs
250g Self Raising Flour
3.5 tbsp Whole Milk
½ tsp Vanilla Extract
3 tbsp Caster Sugar
1.5 tsp Ground Cinnamon
Cinnamon Buttercream
350g Soft Unsalted Butter
675g Icing Sugar
2-3 tbsp Whole Milk
¼ - ½ tsp Cinnamon
Pinch of Salt
More cinnamon sugar for decoration
Cinnamon cereal for decoration
JOIN THE BAKE CLUB FOR FULL DOWNLOADS: / cupcakejemma.com
BAKE AT HOME KITS & MERCH: cupcakejemma.com
CAKES & COOKIES: www.crumbsanddoilies.co.uk
INSTAGRAM: @cupcakejemma
CAKESTAGRAM: @crumbsanddoilies

[@VC-fo3ls]

Yay Sally's back. Just love when you make the videos, you show excitement on each video, which makes no boredom.

[@CHarr1991]

cinnamon lovers rejoice!!

[@CupcakeJemma]

HURRAH 🤣🙌🏼

[@natepoon-lj4cb]

Hello

[@kates7277]

Yay Sally! The Thursday sunshine is back 🌞❤

[@mindfulbaking]

Awh cutie x

[@RojoYoda]

Sally's back!! 😄🧡

[@CupcakeJemma]

YEAH SHE IS!! ❤

[@timothyupham1475]

YEEEESSSSSSSS!!!!! Brilliant. I am making this for my children. They eat that cereal every day and this cake looks so good. Great job guys!

[@imransiddiqui445]

Her smile at the end is priceless! Outstanding, thank you!!

[@mominetti]

Nice to see you Sally, cos’ we missed you, really! 😍🙋🏻‍♀️ I love cinnamon toast cupcakes, so I bet this cake must taste really scrumptious! 😋🧁🍰

[@mmakomanyatja5213]

Well come back Sally this very good thank you so much bless to you nd your family

[@CaribbeanLife101]

It's Sally. Yayyyyy. So nice to see you again. Cake looks absolutely delicious. Thank you for the video. See you soon. 😊

[@smileygirl6457]

Yum. Welcome back Sally.❤

[@andreaguerrerovallejo7026]

Yayyyyy Sally is back! I was wondering when we would see you again

[@lindabarling7719]

My mom would use toast crumbs to make cookies and cakes. She always called them "thrift yummies." Now, I'll be making yours. And I can forget the "thrift" part, due to the strange people in my family. Thank you much for bringing back lovely memories from my childhood. And for sharing your recipe.❤❤❤

[@mindfulbaking]

Love this

[@stephensantay578]

You've got mad skills, Sally!

[@itsjustme1211]

Fabulous cake! Love the different elements in there ❤❤

[@thebigmeringuetheoryelliot595]

Yet another amazing video with Sally Dell's. Can't wait to see more 😜

[@abdulahmed-hg9cx]

This cinnamon toast cake looks really good and cute ☺️

[@michelefrost734]

Sally's back! And you made a cake just for me!

[@mitchlippman4382]

Another wonderful video! This looks amazing!! Thanks to Sally and the gang for the Thursday pick-me-up ❤❤❤❤

[@watercolourartincapetown2919]

Me: bread 🍞 and cinnamon equals cinnamon toast Jemma: lets make toast but then turn it into a showstopper layer cake 🍰 😯

[@sxerosie]

Looks amazing, Sally is so cute! 💖

[@hasnabam263]

this cake looks delicious, thanks for the recipe 😃

[@mI6sanand]

This looks delicious!! Can't wait to make it.

[@rhas20]

This cake gives me beach vibes. The cinnamon sugar and toast crumbs look like sand

[@seetalpardesi2590]

I’m so excited to make this

[@CupcakeJemma]

You'll love it!

[@carolinegapit]

Wow this cake is so beautiful and to beautiful to eat it

[@hansybunnys7748]

Will be trying this in the half term and glad to see Sally!

[@sajaniekanayake9823]

Good to see Sally back!

[@jakesbakes607]

I love these recipes!!! I have booked it in to make at the weekend!!!! Good Work Guys xxxxxx

[@LeeBlackman5]

Missed you sally!! Xx

[@samiraesmaili7021]

What an amazing recipe. I'm always looking for unique cakes made with unusual yet ordinary ingredients and this cake definitely is one of those. I'm sure it'll become one of our favourite cakes. Thanks for sharing fabulous recipes❤

[@bevharrison8157]

Mmmm, I’ll be trying that for sure. Thanks

[@angeltabot3932]

I see you and Jemma just got your hairs done haha. Both gorgeous but I love Jemma's grey hair it suits her too.

[@BakingWithElliott]

This cake is incredible - I need a slice!

[@cyng166]

I can't wait to make this❤

[@IOANNA333]

Damn, I’m late to the party.Welcome back Sally!👏🏻😉

[@ajuarez1866]

Looking yummy!! 😋

[@dianahande2052]

This looks great I have to try this.🥰😁

[@inganesemann9926]

This cake looks incredible, I love cinnamon!!!

[@CupcakeJemma]

Cinnamon is the top tier spice right?

[@inganesemann9926]

@CupcakeJemma Totally agree! I put in and on everything. 😊

[@cardiacarrest862]

Super Sally looking even hotter than usual. Cake looks divine, love the new hair cut.

[@Nyszka85]

Soooo this cinnamon sugar over cinnamon buttercream gives me sooo much of a beach vibe ⛱️ just throw on some beach theme descriptions and you're good to go for any beach party cake😊

[@BelindaNeal66]

I bet this flavour would be lovely at Christmas time, instead of a fruit cake....

[@CupcakeJemma]

Delicious at Christmas, all that warming cinnamon 🤤🫶🏼

[@JulieCheah-wm3le]

Miss you Sally, welcome back😘

[@carolschneider1404]

Sounds yummy

[@jessicat9901]

Yasssss!!! Been waiting for this video 😍😍 u had me at cinnamon 🎉

[@CupcakeJemma]

RIGHT!?

[@judithkilkenny2202]

I swear that cinnamon is ‘human catnip’. 😂 Sooooo good in sweet or savoury dishes. It is my weakness and a similar euphoria and blissed out reaction when eating it. 😆

[@becspresso]

I want this cake!!!!

[@jenniferhorton6965]

WOW!!!! Way better than a bowl of cereal.

[@cidk59]

WELL DONE YOU!!!!! 🤣 Just love this cake!!!!

[@iamahay]

Loving the hair! 🤩

[@beanie7547]

Absolutely will be making this.

[@CupcakeJemma]

You won't regret it!

[@beanie7547]

@@CupcakeJemma sally needs to be prime ministers. She’s feed the world into submission and all would be beautiful as she.

[@saira5476]

Beautiful yummy ❤

[@minchoman0506]

Like a dream❤❤❤❤❤

[@marthaluciaviana1524]

Como siempre nos sorprenden que Rico😊felicidades🎉👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👍💛💙❤️💐

[@sophieg8522]

Lightbulb moment: Ran out of biscuits for cheesecake crust? Do what Sally did to the toast, add sugar and cinnamon and BOOM "cookie" crumbs!

[@ssuperduperweird]

Hi Sally! For the cake, we don't need to use sugar syrup to help moisten to sponge? Cheers!

[@suzanne8284]

Is that mixer pearlescent pink?!?!?! OMG Gorgeous

[@CupcakeJemma]

It is indeed! DREAMY

[@lolomaqbool]

Sounds super delicious 😋 😋 can we use all purpose flour instead? And the butter is not too much? I HAVE to try this cake😋😋 thanks

[@candacewebb120]

Jemma ♥️

[@aucklandsam]

This looks amazing. I find American buttercream too sweet so would make a Swiss or Italian meringue icing for this cake (even though fiddly to make)

[@caelanrobertson7005]

Cupcake Jemma and team, you are legends. Thanks for always being a ray of sunshine in this world. I have been strongly inspired by your amazing baking and endless positively, I am a huge fan even though I'm kilometers away, down under. I have been inspired to start my own cake making business thanks to you. Love you all queens.

[@kathelijnechys3141]

Do you have a cupcake recipe for this? It looks so so so delicious! 😍😍😍

[@RhysPosnett]

Hi sally it was so fun at fort park ❤🎉

[@gamingwithfred8599]

Wow! And that cake board is amazing, where is it from please?

[@ASK-hn3di]

I love this!!!

[@leenabarbary6729]

Wow

[@katewannenburgh820]

A novel idea to use toast in a cake👏👏....must be delicious. I'd also love to try the same recipe but with ginger instead🤷‍♀️. Well, actually; I'd really like 2 cakes...1 cinammon & 1 ginger😂

[@daysbakes]

Ohh love the cake board links please ? ❤

[@swestgarth1]

Hi...i see at the beginning of the video that you said you may put ingredients underneath for different sizes. Ive looked but cant see any. Can i possibly have the measurements for an 8 inch please?

[@NightFairyGirl]

Looks almost like a sandcastle 😁

[@adamwinters448]

Love you guys . Dane get on the next one . I can't keep watching the old ones

[@sonalmalhotra3197]

What would be the measurements for 6” round cake tins?

[@laurabrown9511]

Hi Sally 😊😊😊

[@GVGandolfo]

Are you using 8” or 9” round cake pans?

[@lillianlee1360]

Hi sally, thanks for sharing this recipe n video. Can I make it into a cupcake instead? Anything should I change in recipe, baking time or temperature if I do so? Thanks in advance ❤

[@sweetmalissa]

How long to bake as cupcakes instead?? And how many would yield be??? 😌💕

[@deborahhughes6755]

Hi just making my first cake (vanilla sponge) from your new Crumbs & Doilies book. The tins are 8" however are they 2" deep or 1. 1/2" please. Loving the book by the way, read it front to back before deciding to start baking from the very first cake! 😊 X just about to start now.

[@sophieg8522]

Most people have 8" or maybe 6" pans. Any chance this recipe can be baked in those kind of pans? If so, what's the adjustment?

[@ummehabibasalahuddin4090]

Yum I beg please share rocky road brownie recipe

[@CupcakeJemma]

We don't have a rocky road brownie recipe.. yet!

[@susuhabibi]

please please please please do a recipe on the oreo NY cookie you sell !!!

[@leemiddleton8318]

I watched the buttercream master class video a long time ago and have lived by it ever since. The one thing that was missing is how to know, or decided, when it's the right consistency. I never know if it's soft or firm enough until it's too late. Is it time for an updated master class?

[@cocomo8]

Yay Sally 🎉 the channel just wasn’t the same.

[@user-li9tr3mx8o]

How would I make your little bento cakes using this recipe?

[@sndlp1]

❤

[@phoebegodsmark56]

I only have 8inch cake tins is there a way of doing this with 8inch cakes

[@user-wv7ru8ko7p]

Hi just wondering could you give rough measurements for 8 inch instead of 7? Thanks xx

[@live7katie]

Why do I, a celiac, find this channel’s videos so soothing haha?! Been watching for years 😊

[@Pembroke.]

Hi Sally, now you're not going to sit down and enjoy this whole cake by yourself are you? Don't forget to share over a cup of tea

[@pramiladesai5450]

Hi sally can I use 9by13 inch pan instead as I don’t have three of the same size tins 😅thanks in advance 🤗🙏

[@mindfulbaking]

Yes this would work fine x

[@pramiladesai5450]

@@mindfulbaking thank u soo much for prompt reply 🤗Godbless 😘🤗🙏

[@lynzeeatkins5387]

I've tried to make the sponge with toast inside and it always turns out really dry! Do you have any tips?

[@MothraVsTheWorld]

Can I get slices of cake at your bakery?

[@yusufchiwandire6170]

Could you give us the measurements for 2 8inch tins

[@lucassonoda1939]

Hi Sally it's me Lucas Sonoda , I was wondering if you can make cinnamon roll cupcakes with a brown cinnamon cream cheese buttercream frosting and small bits for shortbread pie cookie crumbs? Do you know cinnamon is a medium golden orangey brown color? You can brown, and orange food color into the cinnamon cake batter and the cinnamon cream cheese buttercream frosting.

[@Taylenax4x]

Are Sally and Gemma related, you guys are so similar to me!!

[@mikepennington8088]

Can you give separate flour and baking powder measurements for those of us who do not have the resources to keep self-rising flour on hand?

[@_Yve_A]

Two teaspoons of baking powder to 150g of flour😉

[@CourtyardPigeon]

I'd think this would be dry

[@markcooke729]

Marry me! LOL

[@user-xe7wd1wt7f]

This cake should come with Health Warning. Even a small piece of this cake is all our calories for a week 😂😂delicious but our arteries will be fat solid 😂

[@rowenadixon8015]

Out of interest why didn’t you trim the outside of this particular cake?

[@GodMother.]

Sorry but no. cant stand Cinnamon

[@CupcakeJemma]

WHAAAAT?!

[@priscillaayd2007]

Your cakes are too over priced. 6 inch cake for £78 why that's ridiculous. I remember the days when that was the price for a 9 or 10 inch cake.

[@thoibinao9257]

Rip hygiene.... touch cake again hair again