Epilogue - John Hears Voices Of Arthur & Dutch at Old Gang Campsites - Beaver Hollow - RDR2

[@pratayshankar4984]

This is actually scary, John still thinks about Dutch and Arthur, how Dutch left him to die, Arthur saving his life.

[@Darkeye]

Talks about being left to die in the first game too

[@witchclub]

I don't think he actually thinks about them it's more like ptsd can't control it

[@ishowlight]

Yes

[@rampage4333]

@@witchclub ptsd?

[@WeBothAre]

@@rampage4333John for sure has ptsd but it just wasn’t a thing back then

[@cosmicspacebub5978]

The past hurts sometimes when you look back

[@Walrus-fg8ch]

Uncle can’t because of his LUMBAGO

[@crissnvin6402]

Wherever you go remember we still have a plan

[@Goofyahhmf123]

Yup

[@pascalg16]

The loneliest people smile the brightest?

[@Lineproof]

@@Walrus-fg8ch please learn to make an actually funny joke.

[@Woodland46]

“Get the hell outta here and be a god damn man.” “Youre my brother...” “I know... I know...” *cries*

[@katar89]

get the hell outta get the hell outta he get the hell outta here and be a goddamn man

[@trickz2216]

Fucking weeb

[@davidmartinez2407]

@yee gamer no arthur would have died anyways

[@mob8757]

Strauss was Arthur’s killer…..

[@SpookusMcDoofus]

@@mob8757 Arthur was his own killer, like he said, “I guess you can’t live a bad life without bad things coming to you”

[@drphil1415]

1:11 “MY gOdDaMn plAn” - Dutch

[@octobermostmisunderstoodlibra]

😂😂😂

[@Comet.237]

😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@nota13xxsfbiagent32]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😁😂😁😂😂😂😂😂🤦🏻‍♂️😏👌🙃🤧🤣🧐😍😁😃😭😅😉😩 *calls emoji police

[@Iseeyoumyman]

plÆŇ

[@julidee_]

HAHAHAHHA

[@ryanwells5348]

That 1 dislike was probably micah

[@25Dark]

ryan wells and bill

[@ChengTeoh]

@@25Dark that's possible but I like micah being one of the dislikes. XD

[@cian2168]

Micah, Bill and Javier.

[@cosmicspacebub5978]

Now it’s 3 dislikes leading us to infer they are from Micah, Joe and Cleet

[@ryanwells5348]

@@cosmicspacebub5978 is joe one of micahs gang members because i have never heard of him

[@Onishiro]

I had a god damned P L A N!!!

[@nab_tm]

100th like

[@jr_5270]

It's it me or did people cry when they heard Arthur's Voice saying get the hell out of here and be a goddamn and when he said we both are not going to make it 😢 😢 ?

[@pencilRC1]

I was already crying

[@kaitlynboatright8156]

This is so touching and emotional! I literally balled my eyes out listening to this...it is so hard listening to the good times the gang had and then it is almost impossible hearing Dutch turn on Arthur and John and when gang started falling apart....😭....

[@TJ-ce1lz]

This is new to me! I didn't think Beaver Hollow had these voices despite visiting numerous times and only encountering Murfrees, every other camp I've successfully triggered dialogue :) these ones are especially a punch in the gut for sure

[@ChengTeoh]

yep this was definitely one of the trickiest sites to get the voices to appear. it feels like the RNG gods do not favor this spot, lol.

[@zebruskie]

​@@ChengTeoh How did you trigger it? I've been here for days trying to get it to say something at least.

[@shahryarahmadi246]

IMO, if arthur had high honour before death, whenever john visits each camp, there should be a dear at the center of the camp looking at john, and then running away.

[@StephenMckeighen]

They do as far as I know, but I don't think a deer standing still would be an option in Beaver Hollow on account it being the Murfree Brood's base of operation

[@Jackdaboy]

*it’s a buck

[@adamz1988]

Expecto patronum

[@ramilplay7069]

I remember when I played rdr1 for 4 time and completed dutch's death mission, in Beecher's hope's enter I see 4 bucks, I presented them like Sean, Lenny, Hosea and Arthur

[@lilypaigeham]

I believe that does happen at Horseshoe! Maybe Clemens Point as well!

[@bobbyberro8107]

It would have been great if we heard John remembering him shouting about how Dutch left him in rdr 1 1:11 and John here’s memes of the future 😂

[@619KJ]

He does hear the line where he came back to beaver hollow and shouted at Dutch for leaving him

[@hassetjifrebro8222]

I imagine there’s so much mixed emotions for John there. An outlaw was his whole life. Who he was. His family was that gang. It felt right to go back with John. I know I’d have a hard time not feeling conflicted about it all and wishing it ended very differently.

[@K0BYN]

The only place I heard voices was at the house where you stay in chapter 1 up in the snowy mountains ...I heard abagail talk about jack

[@kolyasmirno9116]

i wish you'd found Arthur's Caravan.

[@sathlasdalaraynidridlendar6875]

Where did it even go? When Micah was telling people to pack up it had disappeared.

[@wrench4203]

J. Branson Pinkertons either took it or it got burned from the fire in camp

[@Soern04]

Thats sad...

[@sawyersengel3044]

Yeah so the pictures of his parents, hosea and Dutch, etc. were all destroyed

[@kolyasmirno9116]

@@sawyersengel3044 yeah,Fire cleansed it all sadly there's only a memory that faded away with Arthur(

[@suna3000]

If i was john and heard "I HAD A GODDAMN PLAN" every again i would get PTSD (Post Traumatic Stress Disorder)

[@johnmarston9999]

I miss Arthur.

[@oguzhangulsay2942]

When the time comes you gotta run and dont look back.

[@dylanhultman3922]

John looked back.

[@bramlems2601]

@@dylanhultman3922 and he died because of it

[@tenchu006]

Word of advice. Don't watch this before bed

[@ChengTeoh]

That's actually a good advice in general since the glow from a screen will definitely disrupt your sleeping pattern. XD

[@jordandennis6794]

@@ChengTeoh you are my son. I was going to subscribe to you!

[@jr_5270]

Why

[@mfrosty198]

@@ChengTeoh you were supposed to destroy the boomers not join them!

[@danielprado5881]

@@mfrosty198I mean... He's right

[@xMTxcameron]

The feels I get from this.

[@elguapito8701]

2 years later came to the camp again, Then Arthur’s voice comes out saying (When the time comes go and don’t look back, This is over) i immediately went to ma family beecher’s hope and ate dinner with them

[@warfsbubblegum]

I don't think I have the willpower to finish the game....

[@The_real_fbi]

Restart The game and begin with a happy and well Arthur and dont let anyone die and thats how you Actually win

[@beedykh2235]

@@The_real_fbi Our fates are already written. There is no escaping it. Learn this.

[@beedykh2235]

@Kira You are making me not sound wise and cool. :l Just let it slide XD

[@jordanaxelson3356]

This game lowkey makes me wanna cry. Ik it's just a game but I miss Arthur and when everyone was happy and when everything was well

[@rayn136]

I heard voices in colter and i was scared

[@xcyanidegamerx4402]

I just got all kinds of goosebumps

[@galaxy_mooncat779]

2:09 apparently If visited during the epilogue, Arthur’s old caravan can be found destroyed and flipped over where it was abandoned.

[@Mythem117]

That's just sad and then seaing a shadow then wans your close to it it runs away

[@fredricksivits5517]

Imagine hearing this irl at old homes your friends use to live that are now abandoned

[@GiornoGiovanna-wo1nb]

I just went to Clemens Point to pay respects to Sean's grave and heard the conversation of when everyone's singing :(

[@masterassassingaming692]

The way he says you left me to die in the beginning sounds badass to me for some reason

[@smileysatanson3404]

John: dutch was so wise... too bad he went crazy Dutch to Pearson: it needs. more. T H Y M E

[@iwanium88]

This didn't happen to me so far but omg it's just so sad to hearing the voices it gave me goosebumps 😮

[@Kieran_Duffy]

Hearing Dutch saying “I had, a Goddamn, PLAN” in a flashback just gives me the creeps

[@VioletMilks]

Beaver Hollow ain’t look right without wagons, beds, and campfires everywhere

[@midnight9497]

They should make this voices quiet,then it could more interesting. Or add some Arthur and John dialogues to Arthur's death place.

[@idrink10litersofgasoline876]

@@Overlegion Midnight meant where John last saw Arthur alive.. Not his death place but his last sight of him alive

[@ponditmiddleton8950]

the dislikes were from dutch, micah, agent milton, javier, bill, agent ross, colm, leviticus cornwall, cleet, joe

[@JodeneSparks1989]

This just hurts so much

[@Slasher_X420]

I wish u could change characters

[@ChengTeoh]

There is actually a hack where you can play as Arthur in the epilogue.

[@Slasher_X420]

Cheng Teoh Yeah but could u get banned for doing it

[@ChengTeoh]

Sorry for the late reply. I think that you could be fine if you turn off the online feature on the console while playing the single player part of the game. If I were to do the hack and wanted to avoid the chance of being banned I'd do something like (1) save the unaltered game on USB-1, (2) use the hack to alter the save state on the ps4 on a separate usb-2, (3) if I were to want to play the online version of the game I'd use the unaltered save from USB-1 and overwrite the save from usb-2. But of course I would probably do all this on a separate account that isn't attached to a psn account that has games bought on it. Of course I'm not saying you should do this if you are worried.

[@Slasher_X420]

Cheng Teoh it’s alright also thanks

[@Slasher_X420]

Cheng Teoh or just restart the game and Ignore the mission were Aurther dies😂

[@ali_mira]

My heart 😭 it hits hard hearing Arthur's last words to john

[@Money_Mindset420]

0:48 😢

[@vibinwpsilocybin1424]

everytime u look back it only hurts more

[@danielleharrison5765]

When Arthur said get the hell out of here to John and then John said but Arthur you're my brother I really think that John wanted Arthur to go with him

[@anonxo4914]

I went to horseshoe overlook before I finished epilogue 2 and the voices appeared but they didn’t come anywhere else.

[@ChengTeoh]

Really? I only triggered the voices after finishing the epilogue.

[@anonxo4914]

Cheng Teoh well I literally just finished the epilogue now. So I’ll see if I get more voices but I heard a conversation between John and Arthur that lasted a few seconds in horseshoe overlook.

[@polishjerry5474]

same exact thing happened to me. I thought I heard something at shady belle but it was the lemoyne raiders having a conversation.

[@anonxo4914]

PoLIsH jErRy yeah I only heard one conversation in Shady Belle

[@kb4ua]

Great Shooting

[@6string42]

I got voices to appear once at beavers hollow before I even finished the epilogue. Now I've finished it and I cant get them to spawn anywhere. Even using this guide. Nothing. Damn the inconsistencies of disembodied voices!

[@ChengTeoh]

Oo, that is very weird. Sorry this guide wasn't helpful. So even heading towards Colter in the morning didn't help? Usually that's a pretty reliable place to get the voices to appear.

[@LadyRaven85]

Same for me on my third play through. Worked on my first, but not this time. Glitch maybe. Idk. My second playthrough I stopped at a point before the TB progresses, so I can still play Arthur at times

[@6string42]

@yee gamer I don't even remember what we were even talking about here, but I think it's time to dust this game off and do another run of it. Such a great game!

[@martiniman9430]

0:29 this one just hurts

[@bloedekuh]

You don't have to 100% the story. I never finished the epilogue because I don't want Charles to leave. And I can still hear voices at old camps. It just doesn't appear every time. You need to leave the camp and return, or sleep at the camp if you can, to trigger it.

[@Natushh]

I cant hear voices

[@ernestandrews3723]

@@Natushh you have to wait

[@Natushh]

@@ernestandrews3723 i waited like 20minutes

[@kate86ss]

I got a plan and that is TAHITI

[@HeyImSupercoo]

Dutch....what has happened you let our family get destroyed by that snake. My son arthur is gone, my boy lenny shot in the chest, sean through the head, poor kieran was decapitated, and you....you went insane. Im sorry

[@Randut6169]

There were not only enemies in Shady Belle and Beaver Hollow, you also need to do it for Clemens Point...

[@PHZanoni]

No, there is not any enemy there, they must be bounty hunters.

[@polishjerry5474]

If you visit graves as John he wipes his eyes when you get back on your horse and ride away.

[@_chancey_c_]

I am one mission before American Venom and I heard voices at Shady Bell and Beaver Hollow. You kill the enemies, go down the street and come back, then the camp should look open and difderent and you should hear voices.

[@idkwhatuser8484]

It’s really sad cause it must be hurtful to listen to the gang

[@dishonourable_junkie690]

I went to Horseshoe Overlook, Beaver Hollow, Colter, Shady Belle, Clemens Point in the game and it didnt work 😐

[@phillipwalling7470]

You must complete the Game 100% first.

[@deborahsiahaan9261]

@@phillipwalling7470 really?

[@phillipwalling7470]

@@deborahsiahaan9261 Yeah, that means do every single Mission in every chapter.

[@PHZanoni]

@@phillipwalling7470 Hardly think so, because this guy's game is not on 100%.

[@phillipwalling7470]

@@PHZanoni 1:32

[@Mythem117]

Imagine seeing a shadow then it runs away

[@marishkinovrossinski1380]

My first playthrough I didn't 100% and I still heard the voices.

[@joaopaulofrazao8126]

I heard Arthur's voice when I picked up a gun to clean while I was mounting the horse...

[@Dodders274]

All 9 dislikes are Micah Bill Javier Cleet Joe Dutch pinkerton's agent Milton and agent Ross

[@Zz0Z79]

And la studio do la FARABATCINO du la cornwall la puto du ma sba

[@alboorts]

and micahs gamgt

[@crystalwater505]

John sounds like Gollum when he gets shot.

[@Xaptlas]

Does it have to be 100% becuz I still can’t hear voices. I forgot the times again too

[@ChengTeoh]

you need to complete all of the epilogue story missions before the voices get triggered. once you are done with that the only thing that you'll need to do is step onto the old gang campsites during the early morning hours. from many hours of experimenting the only times I could get the voices to pop up is from around 7 am - 11 am-ish. most of the times the voices pop up within a minute of stepping inside the camp zone, so if that doesn't happen initially I'd give it another 2-3 minutes of waiting and if nothing still happens then I'd recommend setting up camp outside of the old gang campsites and sleeping a day or so and going back.

[@rinzler1801]

sometimes it doesn’t work but trust me keep at it and eventually you’ll hear them

[@sbrw4316]

Jin Sakai do you need 100 percent

[@Raven-5790]

@@sbrw4316 no you don't but you have to wait a couple of minutes for the voices to show up

[@chrishee6592]

All your used to be campsite got voices when you visit as John in the epilogue.

[@PLEASEHOLD2]

For some reason the Murfrees keep respawning even after I take them down MULTIPLE times

[@thefoundergaming5029]

I returned to beaver hollow as John but instead got into a gunfight with the damn murfees

[@da-7mo]

Yhe feeling when you get it💔💔💔💔

[@beanos9975]

It’s so sad how Arthur dies

[@bradrev1779]

three dislikes are dutch, micah, and agent milton

[@nadja9055]

0:50 what’s that from

[@infernotara870]

If I were John I would’ve cried

[@micahbell7530]

0:00 I hear the voices that voice

[@yomems_]

Make sure to make ur Volume to 100 to hear it real!

[@ChengTeoh]

lol, so true. I know a couple that were so low audibly that I thought it was just background noise. XD

[@AstrozimBS]

1:09 i HaD a gODdaMN pLAn!

[@crabdragon4226]

Can I just say that this is kinda sad I feel bad for John, but hearing Dutch say I had a god dame plan for some reason make me laugh.

[@GoldenGaming-th9oc]

Got the Easter egg but out of nowhere some murfrees charged me while Dutch was taking lol

[@kingofsciencefiction3808]

Maybe Karen disappeared cause she was captured by Murfee Brood

[@stitch7687]

It’s implied she died of alcohol poisoning

[@kingofsciencefiction3808]

@@stitch7687 true but nothing's set in stone. Tilly reckons she did but I guess it's purposefully ambiguous. Maybe it was part of the cut content that they scrapped and just added the alcohol poisoning statement at last minute but who knows?

[@sbrw4316]

She never died

[@kingofsciencefiction3808]

@@sbrw4316 she could've done. There's no clear cut answer. I remember a random encounter in the epilogue where there was a woman who wore similar clothes to her in a ranch somewhere near Armadillo, but it wasn't her

[@yomems_]

Also does somebody knows this in Chapter 6? That if you sleep 20 hours and you get Yellow Stamina Core?

[@hellcatsquad3143]

1:08 I Had A Goddamn PLAN

[@mrshadow5132]

1:09 even that

[@yamum191]

BTW guys this is fucking scary is all hell I heard uncle singing and dancing when Sean arrived back at camp with everyone u hear it all something about singing cat they all sung it

[@skinny5513]

Holy shit.

[@melissaburch6014]

I’m in chapter 4 - I’m across the river on a ledge and I hear a man’s voice as clear as day but I searched the entire area and can’t find anyone. Does anyone know who this is and how I find them???

[@sathlasdalaraynidridlendar6875]

What did he say?

[@melissaburch6014]

It was the guy with the wolves. But now my husband is halfway through Chapter 6 again and we heard a female say something about “going home.” But it comes and goes and isn’t constant like in this video.

[@ShadowReborn03]

It's a ghost..it's next to beaver hollow in a misty forest

[@siansutherland22]

Look up the whispering trees by a KZbinr called Fizhy. I think that video should help with what you could be hearing in the game

[@nathing03]

G A V I N

[@natee990]

I had a different voice at the fr camp u go to after the snow it was a different one and Arthur was saying it

[@Mythem117]

You mean Colter

[@AyubuKK]

Makes me quite sad.

[@jonwilli8631]

I just recently played this for the first time. I also never played much of RDR1. Not knowing any of the characters or story besides John, therefore not knowing that things would inevitably go south....this game broke my heart.

[@hajoofm4127]

I love this story she like real

[@mycaht364]

How did John know about the I had a plan part he was in siska at the time.

[@AlexKS1992]

The ghosts of the past coming to those in the present to remind you of your pasts.

[@typicalinstincts6392]

Does he know he can mark enemies in his dead eye ability :/

[@ryzen799]

Whenever i go to beaver hollow its full of murfree brood and i dknt hear no voices

[@mrshadow5132]

But what about hear voices in arthur's grave?

[@Raven-5790]

You can't there is no voices at Arthurs grave

[@BlueDemon823]

How do you get the voices whenever I got to the old camos I don’t get to hear them do you need 100% game completion?

[@Healthtymento]

yes, 100% story completion. Not full game completion as far as I'm aware.

[@Ari-lz6lb]

how do you get the voices to appear? whenever i visit those old camps, either gangs have taken up the place (and, even if i get rid of them and stay, the voices don't appear) or it's empty and i still hear nothing. i've only checked after finishing the epilogue btw. i have no clue why they don't show up for me.

[@marishkinovrossinski1380]

it does this to me time to time. best time I've gotten the voices is between 8-10am in game. maybe at noon but the only one giving trouble still to this day is Beaver Hollow. I only get dutch and John no Arthur and John. wonder if honor affects it too though. I'm max low as John lol

[@beastak2207]

JOHN REVIST THE BEAVER HOLLOW Arthur Be Like: GET THE H*LL OUTTA, GET THE H*LL OUTTA HE, GET THE H*LL OUTTA HERE AND BE A GODDAM MAN John: OMG😱😱😱YOU ARE ALIVE BUT WAIT, YOU'RE MY, YOU'RE MY BRO, YOU'RE MY BROTHER

[@lukrosi_326]

Does this not happen every time I go to a camp site?

[@Bobhuman00]

There was just some Murphy's brothers there i couldent here any voices😕

[@ChengTeoh]

you need to eliminate all the enemies in the area and then set up camp for a day or so then return to the area in the early morning hours to get the voices to trigger.

[@Bobhuman00]

@@ChengTeoh thank you this worked

[@ChengTeoh]

@@Bobhuman00 glad it worked. there's also another camp site where you'll have to do the same thing in order to trigger the voices.

[@iiflaeqq8188]

2:15 just like old times

[@chriscathey3403]

I don’t ever hear voices like anymore why ???

[@ChengTeoh]

It's entirely possible that if you cycled through all the voices that they stop appearing anymore, but that's just a thought. I've never had the voices stop, but then again I have not 100% the game.

[@Jarqueivies]

Do you need positive honor or can it be neutral/low? edit: I found out you can have low honor

[@ChengTeoh]

i'm not entirely sure about that as I've only been able to trigger it with above neutral honor.

[@Jarqueivies]

​@@ChengTeoh Same here. I had neutral honor and didn't hear anything at colter or horseshoe, but then I said "howdy" a bunch of times and the next time I went to horseshoe, it immediately worked. The honor logo didn't even move a notch, so I guess you just need at least 1 honor point above 0 edit: nevermind, I just got an audio flashback with hella negative honor

[@Von-iw2bw]

theres multiple???

[@PHZanoni]

I can't hear voices no matter what I do.

[@ChengTeoh]

did you complete the entire story include all of the epilogue missions with John? the voices don't trigger until that's all done. once you finish up all those missions you'll also need to arrive at those locations during the early morning hours since that's the only time they'll pop up.

[@PHZanoni]

@@ChengTeoh I did all that

[@ChengTeoh]

@@PHZanoni hmm, did you go to the first snowy camp site at the beginning of the game? i think that if you can trigger that one, it'll unlock the voices for all the other spots. that's what happened to me, i wasn't able to trigger the voices until it happened in the first camp site. hope that helps, i've got my fingers crossed.

[@PHZanoni]

@@ChengTeoh thank you

[@PHZanoni]

@@ChengTeoh I heard it in Horseshoe!! I left the game in overlook, and then i came back to go to colter, and it started playing

[@bababoowee8157]

Where!!! Show where!!!

[@adinwng]

1:10

[@aymennaili7258]

when i went to beaver hollow some weird people was trying to kill me :(

[@SasukeUchiha-gj7ku]

I realized at the end of the game when the first time I was playing, I played rdr2 finished it as good ending helping John, Arthur tells John to not look back meaning don’t come back or even remember this. And what does John do come back to take revenge on Micah, I also feel like After John was killed so was Sadie and Charles even tho they were in different places still felt they got killed somehow.

[@henryb5008]

Imagine only playing RDR2 and not RDR. Go play the first game

[@SasukeUchiha-gj7ku]

@@henryb5008 played it in the ps3 but ty lmfao

[@SasukeUchiha-gj7ku]

@@henryb5008 I said, I felt like John was killed, which he was I also meant it towards Sadie and Charles. So no need to try and make a problem :)

[@henryb5008]

@@SasukeUchiha-gj7ku Oh sorry. It seemed like you were making a prediction as to what happened to John after RDR2 and hadn’t played RDR, my bad

[@SasukeUchiha-gj7ku]

@@henryb5008 it’s all good.