Epiphone 1959 Les Paul vs Gibson Les Paul Standard Historic R8 - Side by Side Shootout - Part 2 of 3

We get pretty full-on 'Nerdsville' this week as the Epiphone '59 meets our Gibson R8 to compare hardware, software, underwear, and sounds. For many this is ultimate in guitar pornography but for others it's ok as there's also some relaxed chat and a fair bit of playing.
But if you don't like some the talking or the playing bits in this video we've made it easy for you to skip along to the next chapter in case something more interesting is happening...
0:00 play in coming up
1:10 whats happening today
4:15 guitar nerds only warning
5:05 tuners and headstock
6:38 weighing the guitars
7:15 neck angle
9:00 sticky tape conundrum
10:30 body finishes
12:50 weighing bridge & tailpiece
14:29 neck pickup cavity
17:55 bridge pickup rings
19:06 pole piece heights
20:20 pickup outputs and control cavities
21:08 bridge & tailpiece posts
23:34 plastics & binding
25:45 neck measurements
26:20 nuts, 'boards, & frets
27:26 strings & pickup heights
29:06 ready for action
29:40 final checklist and talking
31:15 at last some playing!
35:00 what do we think?
35:47 what do they feel like?
37:20 opinions on sound differences
39:35 will pickup upgrade make a difference?
41:50 join us next week to find out
42:35 play out
Signal Chain Info:
Amp: Marshall JCM900 & 1960 4 x 12 live into Protools via AKG414 & SM57
Drive: Klon KTR
Looper: Boss RC3
We run this channel to provide therapy for our gear addiction and for an excuse to buy more. Re-Launched during lockdown 2020/2021 we are experimenting with ideas to see what sticks, so any feedback you give is most welcome. Please like and subscribe if you would like to support the channel!
#epiphone1959 #sunburst #lespaul #guitaraddict #theguitaristas #guitarist

[@williamdesmarais4931]

This has got to be the most honest review I have ever had the pleasure of watching. I've owned MANY epiphones, gibsons, grecos, and burnys over the years and to be honest burny is my favorite. Epis were always hit or miss but I think I may pick this one up based on your in depth comparison. Thank you for taking the time to do this. I'm definitely subscribing.

[@theguitaristas]

Hey William thanks for comment and sub! I don’t think you’d be disappointed with this Epiphone... the current range is a cut above! Cheers 👍😎🎸

[@TerryChimes123]

I have a Burny made in Japan 1989 black custom les paul. It's superb.

[@riadmiah3342]

Forget about the scarf joined headstock.... what about the size of the Epiphone headstock. It's wide and clunky. Les Paul himself would disagree with the fact it lacks any grace. It's just dumb looking

[@williamdesmarais4931]

@@riadmiah3342 Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. From my experience no headstock shape has ever given me better tone, and while I'm playing I can't see the bugger anyway. Not sure what you mean by big and clunky since epi headstocks have always been narrower than Gibson headstocks (unless my eyes deceive me). I do believe it is a bit pretentious to assume to know what another man would or would not approve of. Since Les Paul started with Epiphone and played both Gibson and Epiphone thru his long career, I think it's rather safe to say that he didn't hate them.

[@sdfswords]

Great demo, I love the way you highlight the basic guitars without getting lost in a bunch of effects and overdrive.

[@moparbryan]

I’ve never understood why people get weird about scarf joints they’re actually stronger than a continuous piece of wood. You get a better grain angle in the weakest part of the guitar

[@theguitaristas]

Hey Bryan, yes I’ve always heard that... they never break at the scarf joint. Maybe it’s the tone thing? who knows what s best! 🤷‍♂️🎸

[@thepatriot4355]

Scarf joints are much stronger

[@paulolsen6870]

Taylor used them for a reason. ✌️🤘

[@JunkBondTrader]

I always thought it's about tone, not strength. Just try not drop your guitars :p

[@joetowers4804]

I know this is controversial, but wood plays a negligible part in tone. It's the pickups and electronics that play a major role in a guitar's tone, along with the rest of the sound chain.

[@JHKNVY02]

The detail in this video is absolutely spectacular and the driving reason why I love this channel. Spectacular work! There is no doubt that to produce something at this level and for the length it is, that it took an amazing amount of work. Truly one of the best channels on KZbin or anywhere for great information.

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers man that’s appreciated! 😁👍

[@MrShockleader]

Thanks for this series of reviews, you've helped me make a decision and the Epi it is!

[@paultownsend6043]

These are the type of video's that make KZbin great, thanking you Guitaristas.

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks so much Paul that's really appreciated! 😁👍🎸

[@PeteEllson5656]

Really outstanding review. The Epiphone sounds really good. Also, great playing on the sound demo. Thanks.

[@theguitaristas]

Hey Peter, thanks for the kind words that's appreciated!

[@MartinBryan]

By far, the most in depth comparison I have seen. Well done sir!

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks Martin that’s appreciated! 😎👍🎸

[@birdman316]

no "skipping along" here mate! i stay for the whole show! great guitars brotha!

[@jeepnypitpits]

Now watching!!, thank you for all the nitty gritty details now I don'have to open my Epi 59, watch and finish all the commercials only way I can give back for your good work for us, will be waiting for the part 3.. ♡♤◇♧.

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks that’s really appreciated!... I think it’s ok to skip the ads though if you don’t need what they selling 😁 they still pay us for serving them up! Part three in production now! 👍😎🎸

[@SavvyCrypto]

Bought the Lemonburst 59 after seeing your video. Can't wait to get it. I am a seasoned player as yourself. Also, very tasteful playing!!!

[@MattBaker-zd8nq]

I went to Beale St., Gibson factory about 20 years ago and they had a gold top and a black alligator skin case man I wanted to guitar so bad but it was $3500.20 years ago

[@brianrobinson1259]

So glad I stumbled upon your channel! Absolutely fantastic review!

[@asyraftamizi4866]

What a specific comparison review! Great work! I do really enjoy your review. What a lovely R8 you got there.

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers that’s appreciated! 👍😎🎸

[@asyraftamizi4866]

@@theguitaristas oh btw, your R8 gives out a much more pure clarity tone compare to the epi '59. Which I would say epi is no way near to the real historic line ups. But, their quality seemed to improve nowadays. Thank you for making this great review sir.

[@USTTRM]

I have been singing the praises of this Epi guitar myself. Lovely playing and review!

[@theguitaristas]

Quite right too... it’s a fab affordable version! Thanks for supporting! 👍😎🎸

[@charlieniner1552]

I have an Epi LP II . Its pretty good for $230

[@theguitaristas]

@@charlieniner1552 Cheers Hamish, yes I owned one for a while... really cool guitar for the money!

[@savage3960]

This is the kind of channel I've been searching for. Thanks for all your hard work sir.

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks man, glad you found us! 😎👍🎸

[@willknight7848]

This is so interesting. I haven't picked up my Epi Les Paul for ages till I watched part 1 last week. I love the anorakishness, (?) of this. I like your playing, who are your influences, I can hear Duane and Dickie, a bit of Bernie Marsden and Peter Green of course. Keep up the sterling work. Thanks for inspiring someone who's forgotten the joy of just playing.

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks Will that’s good to hear! I’m flattered if you can hear any of those guys in my playing! ☺️ I’ve certainly listened to all that stuff over the years but also I think more recently Frank Zappa, Mick Ronson, and Steve Hunter / Dick Wagner (listen to Sweet Jane from Rock n Roll Animal Lou Reed) have helped me begin to improve I hope? Also making these films has inspired me to try and play better and I am actually enjoying improvising again... well at least some days when it’s all working out! 😂 Glad you got that vibe again too! 👍😎🎸

[@GitarrenimNetz]

Again as every week - brilliant playing - love it - and a fine comparison!! Greetings from Germany Thomas

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks Thomas! 😎🎸👍

[@Robert_Bubba_Baker]

Another great show. I am really looking forward to next week. I believe we all know what the results will be next week. Have a fantastic day!

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Bu.bba! 👍😎🎸

[@martinpearson2742]

Looking to buy an epiphone 1959 and stumbled across your channel and I'm so glad I did!!!! At last a guitarist who is genuine and says it like it is! Also one that doesn't shred the neck constantly...... but can actually play!!!!

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Martin, so glad you found us and thanks for kind words that's appreciated!... I say go for the 59 if you can you won't be disappointed.

[@oza8578]

Very lovely playing demoing both guitars! Great tone, great notes....very tasteful.

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Oz! 😎👍

[@jackhood4448]

Great video man! Thanks for all your work. Keep it up!!

[@christianwalsh7082]

As some one with a very high end Gibson and fender and who’s just bought the epiphone 59 les Paul ltd edition in lemon burst, (it bloody rocks by the way) it’s so good to see a channel that gives epiphones a time of day and acknowledges how good they CAN be these days!

[@syzygy9358]

You deserve more subs! i'm really enjoying your style of reviewing and i think we all do. Sometimes i even just leave your vids to play in the background even i already watched em, lol. Cheers! 😁👌🏻

[@theguitaristas]

I appreciate that!

[@pinkiewerewolf]

I can almost smell the pine trees in Georgia. Great playing again. I love that burst on the Epiphone. It's a sexy guitar!

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers man, it's a great guitar!

[@tomrosa4248]

Thanks for another informative review, I always enjoy your commentary. After seeing this it makes perfect to get the Epi but here I am saving up for a Custom shop R9 🤷‍♂️

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Tom, you have absolutely got to go with your heart and get whatever makes it skip a beat 😍🎸

[@eurcoupe]

Ordered an Epiphone 1959 back in February and still waiting with most recent update another month or two, That said, looking forward to receiving it. Want to thank you for your thorough comparison and also compliment you on your skill playing and your music choices. Outstanding!

[@theguitaristas]

Hey Bob thanks for kind words, hope they don’t keep you waiting too long now man! 👍😎🎸

[@lordPix3lUK]

How come you're waiting. They're In stock everywhere in uk

[@lucassuarez6637]

La reseña que necesitaba para poder comprarme la Epiphone 1959. Gracias loco!!

[@Boosty_Boost]

"that was quite interesting" - yup, your own words sums up your video :D thanks for making these. And youre selling the forthcoming third video in this series really, really well ! :,D got me on the edge of my seat almost to hear them next pu's !

[@The8-bitMisfit]

I just discovered your channel, and believe you give the best reviews of guitars that I have heard so far (and I have heard many.) You convinced me to buy the 1959 Standard, and it arrives tomorrow!! I'm so excited. My second Epiphone Les Paul. The first one was in '91 when I was 14, and the one coming tomorrow happens to be the same exact color, being the Cherry Burst. Thanks for the video!!

[@theguitaristas]

Nice one man I think you will be be delighted how good they are these days! 😁👍

[@brianrobinson1259]

How’re you liking yours? I got mine about the same time as you and love it! I have a Gibson explorer and I find myself going to my Epiphone more and more. My Gibson isn’t inferior but this thing is absolutely fantastic!

[@ericsmodsandgear8098]

This is the best review on KZbin of the 59 Epi. Great channel, Subbed. Now I'll be off to the music store, I must try out the 59 Epiphone.

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Eric, thanks for the kind words and support... glad you found us man! 😎👍

[@tedstryyker374]

Fascinating comparison - well done! Props to Epiphone!

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Ted! 👍😎🎸

[@papablue3015]

I did both! Got a new epiphone 1959 and a new nissan frontier truck! I've got 43 guitars now and 1 new truck! Worked out great! 😅 thanks

[@markotter5937]

Great review. Have been considering one for a while now, GG received a delivery last week, so I’ve just bagged one before they all go again. Thanks.

[@theguitaristas]

Nice one Mark... hope you love it! 👍😎🎸

[@stricknine8623]

With something that requires such a dissecting ear and splitting hairs approach when comparing,..The obvious winner is the $800.00 guitar. VERY NICE video, thankyou for the upload !!

[@CastlesMadeOf...]

another brilliant vid. This is my go to channel atm. Looking forward to part 3 and I am a Tele guy! Would be interested to see a comparison with just changing the bridge hardware, even before the pups have been changed. Part 2.5 was excellent as well. Used to go into Chandlers on my way to work - another great shop missed!

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Jimi Jam that's appreciated!

[@moose6676]

What a brilliant video. Thanks again 👍🏻

[@aureliusandthespiral]

Nice video! I dig my 59 Epi, but my heart goes to my 50s standard Gibson. Such a different feel for them being so similar.

[@Blues-man.]

Great video as always, enjoyed your playing as well.

[@wallyh24]

Came for the reviews....stayed for the playing...enjoy your style very much...

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks dude that's appreciated!

[@TheChrisfinley1]

Ok so I just purchased my 59 I’ll have it in a few days and I absolutely cannot wait thank you for the awesome review

[@theguitaristas]

Nice one Chris let us know how you get on! 😆👍

[@TheChrisfinley1]

@@theguitaristas will do for sure

[@HankMartin-ll4pi]

I think you’re right my friend i’ve just got the Epiphone 1959 dark aged like yours fantastic value for the money...... The frets had levelling problems at first but after that was put right, Wow what a fantastic guitar it is !!!!! 🎼🎸🎶👍🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿

[@jamesmacdon9351]

Very well done. I just purchased the ‘59 Epi last week in aged dark cherry. I bought in Canada and was about 1300 dollars total. I am primarily a Strat man however love LPs and SGs as well. I was quite surprised at the quality and sound of this guitar. I had to tweak the set up and I use Elixir Optiweb 10-46s. I have never had an Epi LP that I liked (do not like those slim D taper necks) until this one. I subscribed to your channel and very much enjoyed watching your laid back, real simple review. Cheers !

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks James, nice one... like a lot of others discovering that these Epiphone’s are a cut above those of old! 😎🎸👍

[@johndaugherty4127]

You have the best vibe I have experienced in a while.

[@theguitaristas]

😊🙏

[@jessejorgensen3931]

Firbird still on back order. Bought the lp custom last yr. Some electrical issues but swapped out the electronics. Put a jb4 in. Preferred the probucker. Today, I came across an epi 59 in lemonburts 250 off plus a case. What a dream. Blows the custom out of the water. I feel like im cheating on my custom. I love it. The custom was a bday gift. This thing came perfect out of the box. I mean perfect. I wasn't planning on being this surprised or happy. Damn what guitar. 2 yrs interest free payments. I know im constantly thanking you. You never let me down.

[@theguitaristas]

Happy Birthday Jesse! 😁👍👍

[@bravestarr8857]

When you put that insulation tape on your nitro finished custom, I almost had a bloody heart attack!😂Love your videos. I'm not that good of a player, but that Epiphone is seriously flirting with my bank balance. Great video - many thanks.

[@pauliezx5134]

Excellent video and playing. I too have Gibson R8, and recently purchased Epi 59. This is best Epiphone has ever done-.

[@theguitaristas]

Nice one Paulie!... so which neck do you prefer?

[@pauliezx5134]

@@theguitaristas .the Gibson R8.

[@jamesteddy1379]

Nice playing demonstration 🎉🎉🎉🎉!!!!!

[@billwinter6417]

I’d love to see the guitars compared with the same pickups. LOVE your channel!

[@dennypassialis5376]

It Really Should be That Would be Perfect

[@mikedwiles]

Thank you for doing this series. Really great review. I finally found an Epi and it will be here in a couple of days. Really excited. BTW, I know exactly what you mean about guitar shop playing or in front of the red light.

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Mike! 😎👍👍

[@JeremyChildress]

Love your channel it’s quite smart and your great! Subbed

[@robertgallagher2226]

Sunday morning with my coffee, my guitar and the newest Guitaristas vid. 🙂

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Robert have great day! 😎🎸👍

[@evengar81]

I like your playing so much, sounds awesome!

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks Andrey that’s appreciated!

[@HitItDeep5]

Love all your reviews. Thanks

[@MarshallAmpMan]

Love your reviews Nigel, really good. Best on You Tube!

[@theguitaristas]

😂 spinal tap reference? Very kind good sir very kind! 😎🎸👍

[@MarshallAmpMan]

@@theguitaristas No sir, I don't know your name, I really did think it was Nigel, my sincere apologies, what is your name please?

[@theguitaristas]

@@MarshallAmpMan Ah no worries it's Colin 😀

[@EmptyMirrorMindful]

Not sure if others have commented already but it sounded like the bridge post on the Gibson was screwing into metal in the body to me and the threads looked like machine threads vs wood screws, but it was hard to say for sure from camera distance. They did sound very similar. Which is a big plus for Epi. Awesome job as usual! A guitar geek's dream video. Cant wait to see the pickup change effect now.

[@theguitaristas]

No, I’m pretty sure they screw directly into the wood as unlikely as that sounds.

[@catdaddy57]

Great playing Colin....

[@theguitaristas]

😊🙏

[@seancostello7608]

Great video ~ thank you. I have the Epi and it’s fantastic.

[@raiderrich8355]

Great video and great playing sir.

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Richard that's appreciated!

[@wojtekwisniewski-influenti3776]

Thank you for a great review. Really interesting guitar!

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers dude that’s appreciated! 😎👍🎸

[@DadRockKid]

Respects to you Sir! I see an older version of me here...surrounded by gear and opening up guitars and indulging in geekery! Subscribed and look forward to more... (BTW also a gibby & Marshall fan)

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks man that’s appreciated 👍... and you’re a dad rock fan too so definitely in the right place! 😎🎸

[@chasiebabe]

Great video Colin, really impressed with the Epi, a lot of guitar for the money

[@650thunderbird5]

Always an enjoyable video, cheers! 👍🏻👍🏻

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers dude... I just sometimes wish I could make them a bit shorter! 😂👍🎸

[@650thunderbird5]

@@theguitaristas Perfect how they are. Plenty of short vids by others, sometimes we just want to sit back and watch without searching all the time.

[@theguitaristas]

👍😎🙏

[@richfiryn]

I just paid off my 2020 Gibson Les Paul 50's in Dark Cherry Burst and it's a killer guitar. But i must admit the itch to get the Epi just because having "just one more" guitar is always the correct choice !! Great video here and i'm looking forward to seeing the next with the Monty's PAF's in it. Cheers

[@theguitaristas]

Ah yes I completely get that... interest free credit I’m guessing? That’s how I own all of my CS guitars, it’s just like ‘saving up’ but you don’t have to wait! 😁👍 It would be silly not to take full advantage if you can eh? 😜 cheers dude good luck resisting that itch! 😂👍😎

[@BCTGuitarPlayer]

I love listening to guys my age having the ability of intelligent humor;) Thanks, old salt👍 By the by...as a rule, use blue 'painter's' tape;)

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers man, thanks for support!... no blue painters tape to hand so improvise next best thing... I am thankful had some masking tape, it could have been far worse! 😂👍🎸

[@jameshughes6049]

I own this exact Epiphone, same color & all. It is an amazing guitar.

[@mikeshumate1840]

This is such a great video, thank you!

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks that's appreciated! 😎👍

[@planzed463]

Maaaan, lovin your content 👌🏼 brilliant, thanks. Hope you’re very well

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks that's appreciated... you too brother!

[@warrendreher9316]

Great playing and great honest evaluation. I have several Les Pauls. 1970, 2008, 2011, 2012. Great guitars. Run them through a Blues Deluxe. Also have a 99 Epi Sheraton that I can't rave enough about. 10 years ago I bought what I thought was an Epi but turned out to be a "Chibson" which I think for a while were back door Epi's. Gibson bought Epiphone in the 50's to get the rights to hollowbodies. Can't afford an ES 335 but the Sheraton comes close. All by way of saying that Epi's are really great guitars.

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks Warren, that’s appreciated! 👍😎🎸

[@madhatter8996]

Sure got cold after the rain fell...thanks for the comparison

[@sneifert1968]

Watch as the unsupported Gibson neck breaks, while the scarf jointed epiphone silently laughs🤣

[@timmoyer7131]

Great comparison. Really liked this video! Went into great detail on everything. I'm looking into getting one these, wonder if I can get historically correct rings for an Epi? 🤔

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Tim, very good question... when I pull the pups out I will measure and check where the holes are to see if they fit right on. Watch out for part 3!

[@MrSnapKing]

Good nerd comparison! Got my epi way before vid btw, definitely great guitar.

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks! 👍🎸😎

[@Aceroxx02]

The first run of Epiphone 59's had the tall pickup rings. I have the AMS exclusive Aged Southern Fade - it came stock with the tall pickup rings.

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Jeremy, good info! 😎👍🎸

[@MikeSuttonXerox]

This is awesome and looooooove your channel!

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Mike! 😎👍🎸

[@TheYjmfan]

Great comparison found that interesting. Just polished my 59 with guitar carinuba wax taken off all that roughness looks &feels so much better

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Col, nice one... mine has hand prints and spittle on it... I guess we all have our own methods? 😁👍🎸

[@ewal8556]

Which carinuba a wax did you use? Thanks

[@TheYjmfan]

@@ewal8556 I went all out and stripped the hardware off and used t cut then used kyser guitar polish, looks absolutely superb. So much better than the horrid dusty, rough Finnish.

[@ahiwalter9153]

the finish was horrid, dusty & rough but you still bought the guitar mate? 😵‍💫

[@SuperBroncosguy]

It was that sweet tone.

[@creamysoundcoustic]

super and detail review man...🙌🙌

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks! 😎🎸✌️

[@nellayema2455]

No worries about the tailpiece studs, sir. There are metal bushings in that R8 top. They don't have a flange on top--they're more recessed into the top, so they're not as obvious as the ones on the Epi '59. If you look close, you'll see that there's finish on the top of the bushings. That's how my '82 30th Anniversary Gold Top is, and it's modeled after a '57. With no metal threaded bushings, there would be no way to ground the tailpiece. Another fine vid, btw.

[@ivanjulian2532]

Really nice concept the way you did the back to back comparisons to the backing track. And you went from A to B on each toggle switch setting too. Very smart move. All too often I see people do comparison videos and it never occurs to them to play the exact same piece on both guitars to truly provide a back to back comparison for the listener. They tend to do all sorts of non cohesive blues licks that change from guitar to guitar. THIS is the way to do it. Interestingly, to my ear, the middle switch setting is the one I heard a bit of difference.

[@theguitaristas]

Hey Ivan, thanks for the support and kind words! Yes I tried to do something that was consistent... I think the idea worked but I still always (afterwards) wish I'd chosen maybe different settings or pieces. Funny someone still commented that I'd played one guitar with more emotion and attack... can't win anyway eh?! :) Cheers man!

[@ivanjulian2532]

@@theguitaristas if your copyright restrictions allow it... consider A+B testing in the future doing the opening lead to Since I've Been Loving You. There are backing tracks on the net you could do that to. Just the first 20 seconds on each guitar in each toggle setting. I make that recommendation because the opening 20 seconds of SIBLY features Jimmy playing on all three toggle settings. One things's for sure, that Epiphone 59 Standard after you fitted the after market pickups is sensational.

[@theguitaristas]

@@ivanjulian2532 copyright can be an issue and I got nabbed for the greenie moore 'need your love so bad' I used on this series so try to steer clear now. And I'm not into using backing tracks so I will find a way... easy to do my own SIBLY anyway as its a good old blues progression. Thanks for suggestion I shall look at that in a future thing I love that tune!

[@ivanjulian2532]

@@theguitaristas I believe Rick Beato gets around the copyright problem by creating some of his tracks completely himself if he's dealing with "known blockers".

[@theguitaristas]

@@ivanjulian2532 Ok thanks Ivan, yes I could create my own tracks but just prefer using simple loops as I think it's something that everyone can do at home, and perhaps shows off how the guitar sounds more effectively?... and to be honest it's a lot less hassle! Plus, any recording of someone elses track is likely to breach the owners copyright... I have had films de-monetised (90% of the advertising revenues are sent to copyright claimant) for using my own recording of 40 seconds of their track in a 40 minute film. Figure that one out!... it's just not worth the hassle so I try not to cross the line. Hey and don't forget you started this thread by complimenting me on how I did things! 😂👍

[@rooftopboxer5970]

Fantastic video! I’m trying very hard not to go buy this Epi. But you’re making it difficult 🤟🏻🔥🤟🏻

[@theguitaristas]

😂 I told you to unsubscribe it’s the only way!... if not then I give it a week until you order one ... two at best. 🤣👍🎸

[@buzzburb1]

great review as normal. I see you have the Gibson anti damage mat out again! ha , wonder what the Epiphne mat woudl look like ,would it look more like a table top ?

[@gustafrenstrom8549]

Another great video! Epiphone have come a long way in the last few years. I hope they do morecustom shop collaborations in the future with SG and 335s.

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Gustaf, Yes that would be great eh?... and firebirds maybe? 😍🎸👍

[@gustafrenstrom8549]

@@theguitaristas yes i love firebirds so a real vintage spec firebird in collaboration with the custom shop would be amazing! The new standard epiphone firebird also looks really interesting, perhaps one for a future video?

[@theguitaristas]

@@gustafrenstrom8549 Yes we have to do a firebird one day soon... my preference non-reverse!

[@gustafrenstrom8549]

@@theguitaristas aall firebirds are great but there is something special about the non reverse. If only epiphone made one.

[@lemonhartsour]

Fantastic video. Appreciate your smooth, easy going style, mixed with a little humour and a whole lot of knowledge and practical perspective. Great playing too, very tasteful. Both guitars sound great in your hands. Just subscribed and will be watching more of your stuff. 👍🏼

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks for the kind words it’s appreciated!! 😎👍👍

[@bobtheblindbedroomguitaris8742]

Thank you for your video I find it very helpful. Although I've already decided I'm going to purchase the 59 Epiphone it's nice to see well I'm blind so it's nice to hear your take on this whole thing since you own a R8 and the Epiphone side by side it's interesting. I was under the assumption assumption that burst fuckers were made to emulate the pafs. I think the two and three's were a bit hotter or maybe more mid-range either than the original pafs which I guess are just regular burst buggers I don't know how they how they name them trade-wise but that was what I was under the sort of. But looking forward to the number three which I just have to find because it's already been done lol. Thank you again having trouble finding your first video the demo of the 59 epiphone. My problem is is that when I go into description where usually links are my screen readers don't allow me to differentiate between any links so the links become kind of superfluous or useless to me I wish it was different cuz I miss out on a lot of stuff like that. As far as links go. Again thank you I think I said that enough huh LOL sincerely yours, but the blind bedroom guitarist

[@theguitaristas]

Hey Bob, thanks for checking in! There is a playlist for this whole series of 5 episodes on my channel if that helps? Cheers man! 😎👍🎸

[@DecReynolds1234]

Brilliant review just ordered the last one I could find which was an ex demo which had a neck break interested to see if this still sounds as good

[@theguitaristas]

Nice one!... sounds like a bargain maybe too?

[@lonnie4337]

I have this exact epi and the neck pick up is just killer tone. Better than all my Gibsons

[@deanmccaskill5495]

I’m waiting for the right price on an R8 to come along. That’s a beauty. I’ve got it bad for Gibson LPs. I have 5 ha ha. No custom shops though. That’s next. Great video!

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Dean... there is definitely something about those Gibson's that draws us in!

[@davidpask4232]

I bought the Epiphone 59 yesterday from Andertons at a very good price. My only gripe was the neck pick-up seems to have a lot of side ways movement. I personally think the spring on the adjuster is not strong enough, but was assured they are all the same.

[@BillZad]

Nice way to end with sweet playing, and for a second, I thought that was Lazarus, then the headstock says Gibson........... ;-)

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Willy! 😎👍

[@Sammywhat]

Nice episode! I suppose the real deal is in the feel. Does one resonate more when certain chords or notes are struck? (especially without an amp behind it?) I would be interested in seeing you do a double blind test. Of course, you'd need someone to assist, but that could help eliminate any bias towards the more expensive outlay of funds. Just using your fingers or ears may reveal another side of the equation. Thanks for sharing our journey with us!! 🍻

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Sammy thanks for comment! 👍😎🎸

[@Mikkeyboyy]

great series on the Epiphone 59 wonder how it would sound just putting the gibson tailpiece on the epiphone

[@Edward1312]

I enjoyed this and it further supports what I have always believed, that there is no need to spend £1000's on a Gibson if you want the Les Paul sound. Guitar collecting and playing for most of us is nothing but a luxury so if an Epiphone gets as close as this and you only have to spend £700 then you are on to a winner. The majority of the extra cost you will spend on a Gibson is for the made in the USA badge, Gibson history and heritage, Gibson employee wages and the additional US environmental and legal legislation that has a big impact on production cost. Of course none of the above effects the sound and playability of a guitar but does massively effect the price of a guitar.

[@enlightenedchristian3183]

It started as a log with pickup attached with a neck and strings nuthin's changed Gibson corporation have been ripping us off for years .

[@MrBrammerca]

You just explained why you should buy a Gibson.

[@patrickmccutcheon8860]

There are good Epiphones out there, especially nowadays. But trust me when I say that there’s something about the fit, finish, and playability of a Gibson that isn’t the same as Epiphone in general. But with that being said, Epiphone has stand out models like this one that are great guitars. Also, with that being said, somebody told me once that if you want a Gibson Les Paul, no matter what Epiphone you get you’re always going to be comparing it to a Gibson guitar, and you’ll never have exactly what you want no matter how good the Epiphone might be because of the fact that it says “Epiphone” and has a different headstock. Basically, get what makes you happy and play the shit out of it.

[@enlightenedchristian3183]

@@patrickmccutcheon8860 Of course it's to be expected but a good working guitar does the job you don't need a Lamborghini to get to work is the point.

[@MrBrammerca]

@@automatoncollectives7237 agreed

[@gerdesrm]

Recently found your channel and subscribed. Great reviews and excellent playing. However, can I humbly suggest more lighting when you are filming? It’s a bit dark… I find myself wishing I could flip on the lights! Looking forward to more from you!

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks Robert that’s appreciated. Good to hear that feedback... I constantly try to tweak and improve the lighting and it’s a struggle to get it right sometimes , but I expect it will improve and become more consistent in time! Bests 😎👍🎸

[@donge9589]

Great part 2, I'm surprised at how small the gap is sound wise between the two. It's great that you can get in the ball park for a lot less. I can't wait to hear the result of the pickup swap your planning for part 3. I doubt I'll be able to pick the 59 up, by the time I can afford one i reckon they will have been snapped up. I may opt for the new epiphone slash signature version which is around the same price but with Alnico 2 pickups in ,given that I already have the 50s goldtop it'd give me two slightly different animals.

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Paul, that makes good sense as 50’s is real close in a lot of ways so you’d probably not ‘need’ both.. those Slash signatures look cool don’t get me started! 😁✌️

[@donge9589]

@@theguitaristas I imagine they are similar to the 50s standard construction wise just with the different voiced pickups. I actually ruined a vintage lemon drop by slapping some slash seymour Duncan's in. I say ruined as although the sound was fantastic and really great, it wasn't possible to retain the out of phase sound in the middle position.

[@theguitaristas]

I reckon so but maybe not long neck tenon?... and as you know that is where all the tone comes from! 😜🤔 just played my vintage lemon drop... sounds good but fretting out everywhere so needs a bit of love... 😎🎸👍

[@alexscott7226]

love that bit of Mac in there... Peter Green RIP...

[@theguitaristas]

😎👍👍

[@cliveburgess4128]

If I wasn't watching the video, I would have picked the Epi as best sounding, when you played it I heard Dicky Betts, the 59 I heard a bog standard guitar, quite surprising! look forward to the next round.

[@IanLuckett]

Thank you for this in-depth comparison. Once the YT compression (and I guess Pro-Tools will have had its impact too) have been taken int account I can honestly say that there was very little discernable difference in tone to my ears (which I hope does not indicate anything wrong with my hearing!) I am guessing that for most of us the way a guitar feels in the hand, and the way we respond to all the myriad of slight differences between guitars is really important. I know that I have guitars no one else would consider playing, but which I love because they feel good to me, and of course my hands are entirely different from anyone else's, so my needs are therefore different. That said, in complete honesty is there anyone watching this who would not be somewhat swayed by the price-tag. Think of the legacy value for our descendants! As a player though, much as I really did like your Gibson 58, I would probably go for the Epiphone, and make a few changes to it.

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Ian, I guess it’s always eventually going to be about which guitar makes us feel good and want to play it... chasing these small differences is never going to matter much in the real world but it’s fun to experiment! For some people holding and owning a £5k or whatever guitar is what it’s all about, but others would be far happier only spending £500 and getting much the same feeling and sound from it. Personally I love both ends of the spectrum! Whatever you play enjoy it and don’t care what anyone else thinks eh!? 👍😎🎸

[@jmartini8875]

Love both guitars. I own an Epiphone 59. Very nice. I bought the cherry burst. Killer guitar for the money. Just wondering if you've ever checked out a PRS SE custom 24? I own two of them. Another great budget guitar. 😎

[@dantaylor1724]

Great comparison video ! The Epiphone sounded great, but, not surprised, the Gibson had the edge. Very close though !

[@theguitaristas]

Cheers Dan!

[@agipandi4482]

god... I love your playing!

[@theguitaristas]

Thanks that's really appreciated! 🙏😊

[@zerosforever]

Ciao, mi sono iscritto al tuo canale. Complimenti per come sei stato onesto. Non è sempre scontato e facile essere obbiettivi, ed esaltare una chitarra di fascia bassa o medio alta in confronto a una di fascia altissima come la Gibson. Te sei stato imparziale nel dire e riconoscere che la Epiphone non è affatto male e non ne esce sconfitta da questo confronto, sopratutto perché obbiettivamente è un confronto impari e potrebbe risultare scontato che la vittoria assoluta l'avrebbe avuta la Gibson, mentre invece, proprio perché la Epiphone costa 5 volte meno merita tanto perché si avvicina molto al sound Gibson. Complimenti e grazie. Ciao dall'italia. 🇮🇹 🎸