Erwin's GENIUS Plan of Fear & Paranoia - Overanalyzing Attack on Titan & Retrospective

Today at the Mystery Shack, we continue our retrospective analysis of Attack on Titan and episode 42 - "Reply". Join me in overanalyzing every single detail of the show and generally nerd out about anything and everything!
Social Media :
---------------------------------------------------------------
Patreon : / korotosmysteryshack
Second Channel : ‪@KorotoTV‬
/ korototv
Twitch : / korotosmysteryshack
Twitter : / korotoms
Starforge PCs (Affiliate link) : starforgesystems.pxf.io/B0nnd0
---------------------------------------------------------------
Further reading & links:
---------------------------------------------------------------
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roderick
www.behindthename.com/name/ge...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold
www.thebump.com/b/aurielle-ba...
www.jstor.org/stable/26160143....
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clacton...
web.archive.org/web/201211181...
www.outfit4events.com/eur/art...
www.cedars-sinai.org/blog/sci...
LEMMiNO - Siberian
• LEMMiNO - Siberian (BGM)
CC BY-SA 4.0
LEMMiNO - Firecracker
• LEMMiNO - Firecracker ...
CC BY-SA 4.0
The 25th Hour - Schlatt Crossing
• The 25th Hour - Schlat...
Download here! pmmusic.pro/downloads/
Creative Commons ► Attribution 3.0 Unported ► CC BY 3.0
Composed by
Philip Milman ► pmmusic.pro/
CGI Snake by Chris Zabriskie is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. creativecommons.org/licenses/...
Source: chriszabriskie.com/divider/
Artist: chriszabriskie.com/
LEMMiNO - Blackout
• LEMMiNO - Blackout (BGM)
CC BY-SA 4.0
LEMMiNO - Encounters
• LEMMiNO - Encounters (...
CC BY-SA 4.0
LEMMiNO - Nocturnal
• LEMMiNO - Nocturnal (BGM)
CC BY-SA 4.0
----------------------------------------------------------------
Timecodes
---------------------------------------------------------------
00:00 - Episode 42 - Opening Sequence
01:01 - Episode 42 Title - Reply
02:14 - Gallows, The End of the Scouts & Council's Plans
04:20 - Shield & Spear
05:46 - Uncanny Hypotheticals
09:23 - The Council & Charter of Humanity
12:06 - Shifting Perspectives
13:37 - Council's Names
14:44 - Two... Or More Sides
17:31 - The Coup
21:07 - Pixis, Nile & Zachary
22:07 - Flegel & The Public
25:24 - Midcard - Underground Chapel
26:13 - Erwin & Zachary
28:05 - Eren & Historia
29:45 - Enter - Founding Titan Magic Shenanigans
32:23 - Closing Thoughts
33:03 - Outro
#attackontitan #shingekinokyojin

[@recyclops-juanignacio147]

Overanalyzing AOT dropped at the beginning of my lunch break?! The gods shine upon me.

[@Koroto]

🙌🙌

[@jackabee3277]

deadass

[@DiscoDogPacmanFrog]

Same here

[@qambarmadad7661]

30 min break??? You got a decent job mate😂

[@LuisSierra42]

Today is our lucky day

[@ColonialSun-mg6tq]

Scholar’s ponder to this day how Erwin’s horse could hold the weight of his massive balls

[@eugenekrabs516]

sources say that the horse’s own sack acts as a counter weight keeping them both suspended

[@agapsmiku]

thank you for making me laugh

[@MeuesenexD]

First watch, i assumed the Beast titan was Grisha, and that Eren just happened to get his powers as a result of some weird genetics thing. It wasnt until the end of S3 that i realized what happened at the Wharf and with Grisha and Eren.

[@sourMaxipoo]

I'm with you on the Grisha Beast Titan thing, not sure why I thought that though lol.

[@jamsteroffthewheel4731]

@@sourMaxipooit made sense during the first watch through, because grisha suddenly disappeared and we had no reason to assume he was dead. Plus something in his eyes made him look like a jeager, and we didn’t know zeke existed.

[@shepherdhearth]

I had the same conjecture first time around. The Beast Titan face looked like Grisha’s and when we see Zeke pop out the first time, the silhouette (especially glasses),made it look like Grisha. My only misgiving at the time was the hair color did look blonde and not dark brown, but I wasn’t sure if that was misdirection by him being in front of the sunlight in the shot.

[@RadicalEugene]

As a paranoid truth-seeker myself, I loved Erwin Smith so much and felt his sacrifice to the bottom of my heart.

[@angelamengualcortinas3614]

Nah, I didn't get Eren ate Grisha until the show told us. In fact, i think that's the first plot-twist (not the last one of course) when i remember audibly saying to the screen ''W-wait...WHAT? EREN DID WHAT?''. Good memories.

[@marishkaparker8097]

The "crystal catacombs" is now an inside joke on this channel.

[@Koroto]

👀👀

[@christophertracy7136]

Yep, it was made by the Founder!

[@metzger5850]

I like how the kids called it a paradise before they got slaughtered. I wonder what was actually in there.

[@originaozz]

I love your take on Pixis! He can be calculating and not entirely trusting, but he always put the Eldians' survival first. Erwin is a hero in our eyes as he's cool and correct in terms of the bigger pircture, but for many Eldians, he really is a devil who would sacrifice lives without flinching.

[@monohe4d380]

Litterally jumped in excitement seeing this episode getting posted.

[@Jayjay_07]

I still thought Grisha had done something to make Eren transform and I was in denial about him getting eaten, up until it was confirmed. And I think the crsytal catacombs is the new (Levi) Ackerman-paradox. It might be never stated that it's called the crystal catacombs, but it is.

[@renegadegameboy4946]

Ya know, you never mentioned it in the video, But the Crystal Catacombs is also a location in Avatar. Cool that the two CANONICALLY have the same name. (This comment was brought to you by the Royal Government of the Walls.)

[@krtkjkr]

Such a great analysis, as always. Can't wait for Return to Shiganshina! ❤ I just want to add that Erwin carried out this coup without casualties, lowered the SC losses by 30% by creating the long-range scouting formation, and his "huge costs" come from the fact that he's, well, a military commander who's supposed to give deadly commands, and all soldiers under him were never forced to join the scouts and were warned about the risks. But even considering that, he always blamed himself for all the deaths, wished to go to hell for what he's done, and in the end just wanted for all those deaths to have meaning (just like Levi, who's arguably the most selfless character of all). He's not heartless or cruel, like some imagine him to be (in the aot world and in ours). Afterall, he was forced to be the devil, like Levi will later say.

[@codybrown8202]

Just wanna say I appreciate all the time/research/effort you put into your videos. It’s aggravating how certain channels do the literal bare minimum and have crazy view counts while you probably spend hours working on these just to receive a fraction of that. Keep up the good work man, your effort is not unnoticed!

[@BlackStarofStarClanStarlords]

Series has been great so far! Keep up the great work!

[@TK621why]

Repeat after me... There are no Crystal Catacombs in Ba-Sing Se

[@aperson3125]

OH going on the spear thing i remember that during the first episode of season four i think magrath says that zeke is their spear and reiner is their shield. Because of zeke's help/plan you could say that he is also the spear that brought marly down. Its a bit of a stretch as Eren had a plan with them but idk it went with the bit thing.

[@Lycox15]

I actually had a funny moment when it came to the revelation that Eren ate Grisha. Somehow I managed to process what had happened without looking at it as a big deal, because when someone asked me how Eren became a titan, I just casually mentioned that he ate his dad. Then when they asked when they showed it, I couldn't remember, outside of the flashback of Grisha about to inject Eren.

[@Ksteven131]

In my mind, I’ve always referred it as the Crystal Catacombs as well. Even as you speak about scenes of it, that’s what comes to mind. So yes , you’re not the only one.

[@lukaslambs5780]

The founding titan/future me has implanted memories in my brain such that I am physically unable to not hit the like button on any and all Korotos videos.

[@Koroto]

Founding Titan W

[@BackLashGaming]

Can never get enough AOT content

[@xoShortee93]

Ugh, I love this series so much! In fact, this video made me realize something and I'm curious to know if I missed something or if I'm ~overanalyzing~: in the video, one part I love is how it's deliberately called out that Hange made sure to recognize the acts of individuals to make these tough calls and the breakdown in general of how a "group" doesn't accurately reflect the choices of everyone. That being said, I could never fully place why the Eldians outside the walls rubbed me the wrong way, even after learning and understanding the predicament they were in, and this video made me realize: even though we see why they think and behave the way they do, we don't ever really see any of them really choose to make that difficult choice of going against group. I know I'm speaking broadly, but I think of Erwin who, despite the death of his father, was still driven to uncover the truth, and I believe it's indirectly stated that Armin's parents were killed for similar reasons. The entire ending is Paradis once again forced to fight amongst themselves, to kill friends to do what they thought was right. So it's established that regardless, speaking out in some way puts you and loved ones at risk. The Eldians of Paradis (again, knowing I'm speaking broadly here) still chose to fight amongst themselves for whatever they thought was right, but the Eldians of Marley weren't ever really shown to be willing to make that same sacrifice. I think it's very realistic and very human, but it does make me wonder. Everyone lived in fear of something, but outside the walls the groupthink didn't waver until the Rumbling. Granted, I also recognize the Eldians were forced to live with the "shame" of their ancestors and the Eldians of Paradis were not, so maybe that's it and I typed this all out for nothing, lol. But it's something I've been stuck on and I'm curious to hear other opinions!

[@Heylon1313]

I'm camp "literally forgot Grisha didn't just die when Shiganshina fell"

[@exequielgaleano9947]

To me, the tittle "Reply" meant to point to the Council's answer to the whole ruse. Because of the way they react and the decision they make without a second thought, everybody simply realizes that they're probably better off folowing Erwin's proposal. As you say, the story even questions whether choosing Erwin's perspective is better or not. So, in this case, the council pretty much just fell into Erwin's game, reacting exactly as he was betting they would. Had they acted at least a little bit differently, maybe because they had an idea of how close they were to having the powers of the founder in their hands, things might have ended in their favor. So, that makes their "reply" the one that is decisive here. It's because of their response that all the other players take the stand they end up taking. At least that's how it felt to me watching the episode.

[@young__blacksmith]

The level of hype every time a see one of these videos on my feed is immeasurable

[@robertloveall4842]

I thought Grisha was working with the titans and turned people into titans but was still out there alive somewhere

[@gg_sam7847]

23:09 I got a Discord notification right when Floch appeared and I thought it was an intentional joke as part of the video, it genuinely made me laugh

[@ayshajayne8654]

YESSSSS THANK YOU FOR THE SEROTONIN

[@BunnyStupidHandles]

"almost as if the entire story was about not getting lost in the sauce and not perpetuating these cycles of death" The amount of people who don't see this is genuinely scary

[@qaush]

I dont think ive ever clicked a video faster XD LETS GO

[@zer0deception706]

real

[@teddyasdf9783]

clicked SO FAST justin time for me to do my makeup listening to aot in the background

[@allanchon1361]

Im excited to see your analysis of the "armor" jar eren conveniently eats just in time to unlock hardening. Ive rewatched the series 4+ times and thats still the only plot point that makes me go "what the hell man 😂"

[@___AVARICE___]

Could quite possibly be a vial of armor titan spinal fluid from the past that they're saving for an emergency. Something along those lines

[@starknit]

​@@___AVARICE___yes, similar to how marley makes their warriors eat parts of other titan shifters to gain abilities

[@mikeheiser3728]

I paused and liked the video for the 42.

[@Dibbz_TV]

13:41 😂😂😂 - it’s true and we love you for it

[@johnelvinmwangi1871]

Best anime analysis video

[@LuisSierra42]

Yeah, I didn't even notice all the images that subliminally suggested that eren was a perpetual slave

[@D3__]

I don't remember what I thought about how Eren got his powers on my first watch anymore. I've rewatched this show so many times, all my thoughts and theories bleed together and I don't even remember from what cycle they stem

[@sigma.analysis]

Omg, I just discovered your channel and I'm absolutely in love with your AoT analyses. This is everything I was looking for

[@michaelcoleman5227]

Love the in depth, much appreciated rumblings on AOT. Sending positive energy towards your health!

[@SirTimsta]

It’s a great day when these come out, love the content!!

[@gl22222]

I legit get happy when I see you upload a new video. Keep it up, love it!

[@willawake]

These videos are always such a treat

[@Bruh-el9js]

If I come back in 30 years to this channel and these videos have been deleted, I will find you

[@gamdo8219]

Alr know its a good day when i see one of your posts, much love ❤

[@StolenTheif]

I always assumed Grisha died during the attack on Shiganshina but never guessed he'd play such an important role in the story

[@twinnedgecko1213]

You deserve more subs

[@zionisalive_]

I love this series so much, makes my day every time I see it

[@Wessield]

I love this series. I LIVE FOR THIS SERIES! ❤️

[@gabrielnascimento7718]

Thank you for another great video!

[@DourFlower]

Erwin will forever be my favorite character

[@jams1070]

Was having TERRIBLE day, and this just made it instantly better

[@tylerkoepp]

I really appreciate these videos

[@PeterHSPeter]

Absolutely love your videos! Watching Aot with my GF right now, it's my first re-watch and her first watch. As soon as we're done, I'll link her your channel!

[@GeoGeo303]

ANOTHER EPISODE FOR MY FAVOURITE SERIES

[@SystemSeven]

I don't know why, but when Connie's mum was seen as a titan confirming that titans were people and made me think Eren ate his dad but while his dad was in his titan form.

[@Racaless]

overanalyzing AOT videos are always good keep up the good work

[@kazedae]

Literally get a solid recap of the show with this series

[@bboi1489]

I wish I had your analytical skills, id be doing so much better in literature. Watching these analyses is like seeing the show for the first time again.

[@twinzzlers]

Something happened a little bit earlier so I'm happy you put this out

[@FRAXI0S]

Absolutely obsessed with this series. Thank you!

[@tristanh5270]

cant wait till the final chapter is covered

[@god0z598]

gotta love the over analysis

[@TheHungermonster]

I always guessed Grisha was dead and Eren had something to do with it. I found it so weird that Eren never tried to find his dad. He just had this key and wanted to go back to the basement, but never cared to ask where tf his dad was lol.

[@IDGAFRANK]

I'm so happy for the 42 mention

[@longsh00ter]

get well quick! I cant wait for your vids god damn :D

[@sbuskauhis]

LETSS GOOOOO i don't have to rewatch the other over analyzing videos (i would gladly)

[@cocoabeans544]

Saw this when I was about to clock in and wanted to scream because I had to wait until the end of my shift 😂

[@BenGTheSun]

I know thess videos take a long time to make but I swear I could watch them for hours on end 😂 Keep up the good work you deserve a lot more views!

[@whisperingwooper1763]

Ah my favorite series returns!

[@jaredrazack1396]

I love this series! Yeah overanalyzing!

[@Futuresorcerer]

Douglas Adams in a over analysis of Attack on Titan. Never thought I would see it happen.

[@thewholeunit5715]

Wait, so they're not actually called the crystal catacombs? I always thought that too XD

[@Koroto]

🌌They are 🗿

[@kiiturii]

22:41 damn bro this hits too hard

[@Primz125]

The title of the episode could also be translated as "answer", so your #42 theory might not be as far off as you think

[@kunkkaralho]

In his case his selfishness turns into a desire to help humanity and uncover the truth to me it was always hinted that he ate his father. he transformed, turned human and was holding the key

[@khoreybrown4349]

I figured he ate him, but that mainly came from the part where Hange was telling Eren about the tests they put his Titan form through. Specifically trying to communicate. They said that they believed Eren's Titan is incapable of speech, most likely because of it's jaw structure, but is capable of understanding and at least able to write. Hange also said that Eren's Titan began writing out something about his father however it also became illegible after a bit, and he seemed to sit there mourning for a bit. I don't remember the chapter, though, sorry. I can't even remember if it was before this stuff, but it definitely solidified my belief that Eren ate Grisha.

[@reubenkimber]

Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy mentioned!!

[@BigPanda096]

Koroto got us good. He said at least a few days, when no ones lookong "heheh syke suckers i meant in one day!"

[@Wpbcj]

First vid I see when I wake up. Good day ahead

[@DourFlower]

I love this series so much that I risk getting spoiled on the final parts every time just to watch it, keep up the great content! Once the dub finally releases ill be able to relax and stop keeping my hand on the fast forward button

[@jacofonta9482]

Dub is already release bro

[@DourFlower]

@@jacofonta9482 man thats awesome thank you! i had no clue, i thought it would take 8 months like the last part

[@fekkakidriss6562]

I was so happy to see the episode drop. I have a 30min train ride. This is peak luck

[@Nothing-1w3]

Definitely my favourite part of aot

[@theshadowcollective8450]

Return of the king

[@joeprice999]

Waking up to this on my recommended page 😩

[@ayshajayne8654]

I love that you pointed out the spear aspect, I never noticed that!!!! Historia and Eren both being killed by spears *chefs kiss. The love of Eren's life kills him. And the love of Ymir's life leads her to death, really. Mikasa always fought the fight. She never wanted Eren to fight and I always hated her for it... until I had retrospective. It's such a wonderful story. I so appreciate you nitpicking this so we can share more perspective!!!

[@ayshajayne8654]

Not 29:26, breaking my fragile brain

[@lyricistrito]

QUIET EVERYONE MY FAVOURITE KZbinR UPLOADED ‼️ (thanks for another video!)

[@ToonWorld-ir7re]

Babe, babe, wake up! The new Koroto AOT video is out!

[@preachcaleb]

I was definitely in the Grisha escaped to safety and was just hiding camp. From just watching so many tv shows over the years, if an important character goes missing, odds are, they'll turn up alive at some point. Plus, when I first watched it, I just couldn't put together exactly when Eren became a Titan. There didn't seem to be any time. Suddenly he just wakes up with a key around his neck? When did that happen? And how come nobody noticed? And then Eren apparently just sits on his Titan powers for some five years? It didn't make sense to me. Overtime though, with multiple rewatches, and the help of videos such as these, it all makes sense now.

[@bearwitty9690]

THE NEW KOROTO AOT VIDEO JUST CAME OUT GUYS. HELL YEAH!

[@nolanpagay3410]

Man I love the Crystal Catacombs and how that's the official name and it's always been that way 😁

[@byeolbitch]

14:15 had me choking you're doing GREAT with all pronunciation I promise

[@MysticMylesZ]

22:40 why must you hurt me this way 🥹

[@justinvalentine2950]

I enjoyed the Attack Titan's power graph, at the same time it opens up a whole new can of worms about time loops

[@ArKamMLG]

I binged every episode in a couple of days a little while ago and have been silently waiting for God to bestow heaven upon me once again.

[@StolenTheif]

I mean crystal catacombs is pretty accurate considering what they're used for

[@MysticMylesZ]

Too me see the entire series and watching vidoes about it and finally being here to understand thatb😅

[@ZeroCGR2]

I thought the Beast Titan was Grisha. For some reason I thought it was him at the end of season two, because of the glasses. But I never gave a thought about why would he give Eren Titan powers and than run off. I was to busy enjoying the show

[@realstrixy1229]

12:26 That's... why I'm here.

[@prestonarmer277]

Went a whole day before this came up on my algorithm

[@Koroto]

Unironically would recommend clicking the bell if you don't want to miss an upload. Some videos in the series have already been hit with demonetization and YT just doesn't promote those at all (I mean like a 90-95% drop 💀). With where the story is headed, that'll probably happen at least a few more times 😬😅

[@prestonarmer277]

@@Koroto I never use the bell but for you I will turn it on

[@peculiargloat4040]

Love me some crystal catacombs

[@BigPanda096]

I was always on the "eren ate poppa fo sure why else would he just vanish?"

[@frenchtoastmafia1]

32:14 I always assumed that Eren ate his dad

[@DesertFoxAxis]

Let’s gooooo!