Eunji vs Luna : High Notes Vocal Battle | 루나 vs 정은지 : 고음배틀 ~ Bb4-G#5

[@Avatarkyungsoo]

*5:22** is an F5 for Eunji, I mistakenly thought she lowered the key, my bad*

[@adellianaura7910]

Eunji: Belt, power, vibrato, range, lownotes Luna: versatility, resonance, breath, support, falseto Both: highnotes

[@sabrina5361]

Luna. If only sm give her chance to show her full ability. But it okay now she enjoying her musical performance.

[@beutypanda3230]

I love eunji.

[@jiji0893]

Its nice to read Eunji Stan praised Luna n Luna Stan praised Eunji..both of them is an amazing singer n I hope they can collaborated together.

[@dumb2115]

they did collab together! it wasn’t just the two of them, though, solar from mamamoo and ailee were there too

[@wabis_1381]

Eunji no.1 I Love Eunji

[@cryssapink9281]

I love Eunji, she is just perfect.

[@働田]

I've always acknowledge Luna's voice as one of the best: in terms of technique, skill and control. But I just can't get enough of Eunji's voice.

[@pearlcorgi5853]

Eunji is always enjoying singing🎵

[@Ahyyfink]

Eunji is my favorite singer. But I judged this without bias. Eunji is more stable than Luna. Great job my Eunji 😍 Luna did a great job too

[@willbyers3534]

the way eunji hits those high notes is effortless. like a piece of cake

[@jaythesoldierjts5419]

Luna is better but both are great vocalists. But the kpop blog can confirm that Luna is better. Love them both though. ❤️

[@badbada3003]

Well eunji has better f5 and c5 more relaxed and well supported so she's better

[@badbada3003]

@@mewmew9412 yeah luna has more developed head voice

[@zeff8820]

@@badbada3003 luna can support Eb5 and E5, she's better

[@badbada3003]

@@zeff8820 eunji has supported Eb5 too even though it's very consistent but talk about low notes eunji is better she support G3, while luna only support A3

[@pedropaulogomes6703]

@@badbada3003 Luna supports down to G3 too, she has shown moments of support down to F3.

[@fendy9733]

I don't care who wins. I just love seeing Eunji reach the high notes with a smile :)

[@richardjun5726]

yo I'm getting teary eyed all these comments are so sweet you can just tell that Luna and Eunji stans are amazing

[@dailytiktok6726]

Factly, eunji is the best for me we have different opinion but luna is also a nice vocalist. I love eunji❤️❤️ so much

[@sweety-alyssum2866]

eunji

[@gregoryahogarth]

I thought for sure Eunji would win in the A#4 - C#5 range, but Luna didn't come to play either. 3:14 was...wow. It's close, but overall Luna for me. 5:22 was an F5, by the way.

[@Avatarkyungsoo]

Greg Hogarth fuck I thought she lowered the key lmao

[@yoonalim7981]

What the song 5:22 ?

[@jinki9106]

@@yoonalim7981 All for you

[@yoonalim7981]

@@jinki9106 thankyou

[@jungkooksbeautifulvoice7326]

I love Luna's C#5s so much

[@Kafk13]

i love this.. light lyric vs full lyric soprano.... very pleasing to the ears.. i'd say it's very close tho, with luna having the edge for having a brighter mix as they went higher above Eb5

[@mohamadfirdausbinmat2577]

both are light lyric sopranos. Eunji has weightier voice but more traits to her voice lean towards the light lyric category

[@hyunsukim4394]

Eunji !!!

[@fullmetalgaara2]

I'm heavily Luna biased, so of course I choose her. I love the emotion she puts into her performances, but Eunji is a really strong vocalist. Actually, Apink as a group has very solid vocals. I hope they can have a comeback in the future that really showcases their vocal ability. Thank you for taking time to make this compilation :)

[@apink8943]

Sure eunji is win Here voice so amazing really not because I love her but really here voice is win Luna here voice so beautiful but eunji's voice beautiful more luna's voice This is my opinion

[@el.c.8858]

Apink에이핌크 Hi, I think you should maybe change your comment to ‘Surely, Eunji wins for me’ as some people think that you’re stating it as a fact not as an opinion of yours😊.

[@lvnsuji5672]

the two best vocalists in kpop for sure. this was the hardest battle, both resonant, have very developed mixed registers... god i really don't know

[@putraaditya77]

Eunji

[@manaldraoui3619]

Eunji wooooow😍😍😍😍😍

[@rosevieodarve6841]

The difference between them is that eunji sings from her heart and shes like singing with a story. While luna sings highnotes and a good singer too. I love both of them but i prefer eunji❤❤

[@kirstintacandong6340]

Luna! If they have give luna more performance to showcase her vocal talent

[@tinxxb]

I love LUNA!

[@mailanapriyolestariyanto3740]

Luna's C#5 from Rebecca musical is so nice !

[@ittipatlehnsherr5442]

Eunji voice is so beautiful. Luna is on SM standard.

[@fathirizkimauladi8790]

Both are my fave. But if i have to choose one... i just cant lol. Luna's belt on upper register is better but eunji is more consistent. Technically speaking, luna is a betger vocalist id we include her hv. But eunji exceed her in lower range. This is a tie for me. Both are great main vocal. I wish they will have a better carreer in this industry.

[@lastly4431]

Fathi Rizki Luna being more consistent with hee Eb5's indicates she's better in their mixed voices alone. They almost share the same technique. Luna and Eunji brighten their mix.

[@eiryves8554]

Luna is my heart and soul, but honestly, if we consider: Clarity, Tone, Power, Range, Breath Support, Support, Resonance, and Fluidity. Eunji wins. However, I do like Luna's vibrato and her presence just as much or slightly more than Eunji. Just my opinion here. :)

[@justaboy343]

Eunji: Belting, vibrato & performance Luna: Technique,Head Voice,Show off vocalist

[@현-l8o]

은지의 고음의 끝은 어디일까

[@whynot-sr8wn]

I think luna is the winner Even tae is better than Eunji Compare with sm main vocal Lina>Luna>Tae>Eunji>Wendy>Bada>Jessica>Ningning

[@m.cluisevandyangan9717]

Eunji 4 octav same to wendy

[@nurul_ovro]

Eunji is number one Only she can sings high and low notes perfectly no one can't do like her

[@nurul_ovro]

Eunji 💖 *eunji is the top vocalist in kpop... her live singing is so stable and flawless* *she can reach any highnote easily* :) *and her lower note is so deep which is touch anybody's heart* _luna uis good to but in vocal technique eunji always win_ ;)

[@lxhizy]

I didn't know Eunji was as good as Luna. Even some of the Eb5s and E5s I would dare to say that they are better than Luna's. Both of them have a very similar timbre and a very similar mixing, so I would say it's a tie in this video.

[@SuperPianogirl123]

Nate Sparda You're a lawyer, right?

[@tornadocrossfire544]

Jung Eunji duh best and highly trained in vocals

[@gaminggalleryph]

Ah, this is the tightest vocal battle ever!!! Both of them supports up to E5!!! This is gonna be epic!!! Note: Luna is just weak in low notes.

[@leejihan3632]

Luna..... I love you

[@mailanapriyolestariyanto3740]

Eunji still has more ease to reach upper notes, but technically singing Luna more skilled with some consistent D5s-Eb5s.

[@jinji4609]

Actually Luna has some tensed D5 and generally lack of resonance above C#5, most of time is just supported, Eunji is pretty consistent resonance on D5. Luna’s Eb5 is more consistent than Eunji

[@mailanapriyolestariyanto3740]

@@jinji4609 what do you mean ? pls edit your comment, because i dont understand what are u actually mean😁

[@jinji4609]

@@mailanapriyolestariyanto3740 Luna strained her D5 in Mom, there is some tight note too. that mean Luna is the one who less consistent at D5

[@mailanapriyolestariyanto3740]

@@jinji4609 Luna has nice support & resonant in C#5-D5/Eb5, what do you mean she lacks resonant above C#5 ?????? 😂😂 She has inconsistent resonant in Eb5s yes.. but her A4-D5 very rounded, support & resonant.

[@jinji4609]

@@mailanapriyolestariyanto3740 kzbin.info/www/bejne/qnu5aWeMat2cp68 4:30 full strained D5 in the clip, 3:53 only supported, see how much fuller of Eunji's resonant D5 later. also 5:05 D5 right before Eb5 is pretty lack of openess. Luna' Eb5 is better but Eunji's D5 is better D5-Eb5 in her cover of wildflower only supported too. her resonance is less present above C#5

[@008seba]

This is what needed

[@santokki50609]

I think they are both Fair at range of G4 up to B4's - C5... they are both great at high ranges but Eunji is more effortless reaching those notes and still can manage to smile , while Luna taking her time on Effort and Agility

[@user-rr9xm5yq4z]

Both are very well developed in their technique, instead of choosing who wins I'm just enjoying good singing B-D this is a blessed video thank you

[@sharifahariana2910]

Eunji of course Top 3 for the best singer Top 1 too for best singer

[@지민-v1d]

우리 은지♡ 우리 Apink eunji♡ 사랑해요 정은지! LOVE eunji♡ 아유~~ 우리 은지 넘 잘한다♡ 우리 핑수니들한테 덤빌사람있슴 나와바! 팬으로서 보면 은지가 넘 잘하고여! 팬이 아닌 일반인으로서 보면 은지가 넘 잘해여! 어터카지...? 이렇게 잘하는데 핑수니들은 못하는게 없는디 어떠케 안반합니까! 판다님들 쏘리질러~~~!!!

[@joshuachhakchhuak6799]

Luna's support and resonance tho

[@diasdemierdiaz]

Oh God, I know Luna is way better objectively but fuller voices like Eunji’s really get me delusional + the notes from Bb4-E5 used for Eunji are probably are her best that could literally fluster you of her vocal ability lol. Anyway Bb4 -E5 they were even here I guess but subjectively Luna’s C#5’s are my definitely my faves out of all kpop vocalists along with Yuju’s resonant ones lol. They were winning over each other in some notes from D5-E5 with Luna having the edge and (almost) making them even except Eb5 which is Luna territory as her resonance is better there so Luna mostly wins on Eb. Two nice E5’s for Eunji and One resonant E5 for Luna so Eunji edges Luna here. Above that they both get tense but have good placement so it’s all really subjective on F5 and above. Definitely two of my favorite main vocalists from kpop groups voice wise. EDIT: made my analysis and thoughts less biased towards Eunji and actually saw the video with an open mind lol.

[@이상기-z9i]

고음은 정은지가 짱~♡♡

[@yoon7838]

마지막노래 3옥솔샵 은지노래 뭔지 아시나요??

[@장준혁-r9o]

@@yoon7838 2016 에이핑크 콘서트때 은지 개인콘서트때 부른 all by my self 에요!

[@kledi3817]

Lunas C#5 are just godly. such amazing support

[@adrianaaguirre2609]

simplemente eunji es la mejor❤

[@shirleyz8571]

both are amazing artists 💜

[@SuperPianogirl123]

Eunji is more consistent, but Luna supports higher.

[@lastly4431]

SuperPianogirl123 what does that mean? HAHAHAHA.

[@lastly4431]

Luna is more consistent on support and resonance on D5/Eb5 than Eunji, a semitone higher.

[@SuperPianogirl123]

DBZXC last Eunji is more consistent on D5, but Luna supports Eb5s. It's not hard to understand. Luna was straining D5s during Immortal Song and King Of Masked Singer because she isn't as consistent above C#5.

[@joshuadelacerna5631]

is it because she's easily fatigued???

[@lastly4431]

+SuperPianogirl123 your statement is quite hazy. HAHAHAHA

[@merve11083]

Eunji👍👍😍

[@bluepearl8528]

Luna's vocal is art 💜

[@adellianaura7910]

I think i prefer Luna She sounds effortless 😂

[@alexandrajhenell7485]

Let’s be honest here. I CANNOT CHOOSE

[@nurul_ovro]

Queen eunji 😍

[@lffdgfhggfhgh4204]

Apink Eunji my love

[@edenpontillas5264]

Eunji🥰

[@reekssjdija5953]

eunji 👑

[@SYEJ92]

i think Eunji is better but Luna is amazing too

[@liamseravali2291]

I agree! Eunji is a bit better but both are great vocalists

[@xinyuxie2905]

Eunji is the queen. Please remember when eunji sings the high notes she is smiling is more easy for Eunji to sing the high notes!

[@heyitshier1302]

Xie Xinyu smiling doesn't make someone better lol😂both of them tie...eunji has better low register while luna belting is slightly better...their technique kinda similar

[@gaminggalleryph]

Luna is actually good up to F5 as Eunji, but Eunji still slays up to G5. Luna's G#5 is needed to her vocal line on the song, not bad...

[@지민-v1d]

은지 사랑해♡ l love eunji♡ 에이핑크 사랑해♡ l love Apink♡

[@alejandrofloresleyva6950]

Luna ❤️

[@shirleyz8571]

Luna💜

[@krystal6797]

Luna!

[@실력파보면우는인간]

은지도 자기 고음 어디까지 올라가는지 모름...그냥 노래 따라불렀을때 다 부를수 있대요

[@bbakhh_1154]

은지가 더...헤헤

[@kmgwons]

Both of them😍

[@sanfonea4125]

I love both

[@savindigamage1533]

Luna.

[@p_m_x_g56]

they are the best.

[@chldnjsrb09]

고음배틀??? 믕지는 듣는 사람 부담 없는 선까지만 올려 부르고 절제하는 것 같은데..

[@jennifersanchez615]

Eujin es mejor en el control de las notas altas pero luna es mejor en el F#5

[@giant_pengsu]

은지 승..

[@zeff8820]

4:52 that's one of the best Eb5!!!

[@hotissue4948]

that's was supported or no?

[@zeff8820]

@@hotissue4948 that's a full, big, heavy Eb5 it had ringing quality and maybe one of the best Eb5 in kpop industry, also that Eb5 has a better quality than luna's entire carer and better than eunji's belts in her entire carer.

[@zeff8820]

@@hotissue4948 but luna is very inconsistent, and also Eunji, she doesn't have a ringing quality but she has a good depth.

[@hotissue4948]

@@zeff8820 okay how about this 5:40 supported or no

[@zeff8820]

@@hotissue4948 the term 'support' and 'unsupport' is very vague, even it becomes a misused now, i blame that amateur analysis for spreading a misconception about that, there is only one support and it's breath support. But now the term 'support' is only for a good note, back then it's called a good tonality. If you ask me about Luna's E5 there, yes, it was still a good belt but it's not that good because it had a small tonality, and it doesn't have a ringing quality.

[@whynot-sr8wn]

5:57 link please

[@김문이-c7f]

👍👍👍👏👏👏❤❤❤

[@loverofkpopboyandgirlgroup]

Luna

[@mikep.universe60]

Luna is better than Eunji but i like the unique voice of Eunji Idk what think xd

[@HuuHanh2701]

Remember. Luna was Mask King.

[@liamseravali2291]

It doesn't matter cause they don't judge about tachnique.

[@macely]

both better

[@Cloud_for]

믕❤❤❤

[@onlyforyou6363]

Luna was better, she have support E5 with consistent now. And her headvoice very good better than eunji..

[@nurul_ovro]

Lol eunji can hit E5 will laying down ;D

[@onlyforyou6363]

@@nurul_ovro wkwk.. But still, luna was better in technique..

[@nurul_ovro]

@@onlyforyou6363 kzbin.info/www/bejne/i6vYc2uLpZKJitk its jut a normal things for her :)

[@richardjun5726]

2 VOCAL AND GAY QUEENS HOW DO UOU PICK

[@finaamrina2756]

Eunjiii

[@baepinkobsession]

What song in 6:45 ?

[@Avatarkyungsoo]

Rojé 0805 their group cover of “I Will Survive”

[@empresscassandraleigh553]

Luna is way better 😍😍 but I love eunji also they're both my fav Korean vocalist. 1. Ailee 2. Hyolyn (Sistar) 3. Taeyeon (SNSD) 4. Luna (Fx) 5. Eunji (Apink) 6. Wendy (Red Velvet) 7. Yuju (Gfriend) 8. Solar (Mammamo) 9. Jessica & Seohyun (SNSD) 10. IU & Suzy

[@kpoplovers2622]

Luna better than Taeyeon

[@khenialazcano7796]

Eunji and Luna are better than Taeyeon*

[@normalperson1847]

Check Lina ex CSJH(The Grace)

[@m.cluisevandyangan9717]

10 minzy /soyu not IU suzy Susi tier E

[@cuttarisa1675]

I choose LUNA

[@luethajak]

someone ruined the line here 🤨 5:47

[@yoon7838]

What song?? Eunji7:18 luna7:13????

[@tonkaw324]

Eunji - All by myself Luna - And I am telling you I’m not going

[@eunjijimin7989]

Eunji

[@leonaartananda3615]

eunjiii

[@loveliz370]

eunji

[@pinkprincesrojas3736]

Eunji

[@philong2293]

Eunji