Every Controversial Problem in BFDI

[@FrazzleDesignPro]

21 views in 3 minutes? bro really fell off

[@Beep123Four]

237 views in 57 minutes? Bro fell off

[@The-yz5rn]

258 views in 1 hours? bro fell off really hard.

[@FreonGalaxyy14]

965 views in 5 hours? Bro rlly fell off

[@BombAnimates]

yeah totally fell off 🙄

[@FrazzleDesignPro]

@@BombAnimates fell off haaaaaard frrr🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑

[@frozenstarry28]

5:25 "family friendly" Immediately shows Needle burning to death

[@NotTheRealFirey3672]

Imagine a mom seeing that one scene in tpot 9 with pillow

[@ElusivG]

Don’t forget “Pen island, all caps, no spaces!”

[@mrricedoesstuff]

Wait till you find out about SpongeBob

[@GlaceonStudios]

Good juxtaposition

[@Thediscombobulatedtippytipson]

and then book being ripped to shreds

[@SoupEarthOfficial]

If people were mad about the Lolly joke how did they not yell at the Pen Island joke?

[@deductionsdiary105]

Because it implies a lesbian kiss I think and there's a surprisingly big number of homophobic ppl in the osc

[@yoshicrafter7608]

@@deductionsdiary105 OH thats why people were mad ;-; he didnt explain that in the video (which makes sense)

[@JaredtheNacliFan]

I added it to the controversy page but then someone removed it because they said it’s not a controversy and no one has ever gotten upset about it. Like what?!??! (Also the page got deleted)

[@booiscaredyou.]

@@deductionsdiary105 WAIT REALLY 😭😭😭 winner and taggy are literally non binary how bro

[@alexandrevachon541]

As for the Pen Island joke, it became a meme of its own :D

[@GreenGuyAnjo]

"They rigged the elections" -Fans whose favorite contestant gets eliminated

[@thelagbotroblox]

wait a minute ELECTIONS!? don't you mean elimination?

[@Tanthemanreal]

That’s just American voters

[@GK08_Productions]

To be fair, they could just “rig” it if the difference of votes is short (Flower). Now that voting is done through google form, there is no excuse for altering the votes

[@certifiablyRad]

@@Tanthemanreal"battle to be the president or something i dont know man im bad at titles" coming never

[@carissatiah]

I don't get the hate on Post Split BFB. It was kinda cool, seeing a small cast again. And I feel like the viewers are forgetting that TPOT is also result of the split, but then again the OSC has a very short attention span.

[@PatrixxYT]

Yeah and now people are complaining about how the scenes are slower? Like that just shows how extremely low they’re attention span is

[@Sploingy_]

finally someone else that doesn't think bfb post-split is terrible

[@Seedy2]

Is probably due to post splits writing ruining quite a few of the characters within the season, 4 being one of those characters who just became kinda annoying to watch (imo) plus just the writing in general just feeling bad in general. You could also say the choice of the cast for post-split was just kinda generic as well..

[@Feishy]

yeah taco went from so good with interesting arc to "noo blocky don't be your usual self grrr" ​@@Seedy2

[@kutekatkk]

I have a stupidly short attention span and even I think it’s fine 😭

[@cianroe3233]

You forgot to mention that we saw the underworld again in TPOT 11, where Pencil opened a door leading to it where Robot Flower was due to getting crushed by Team8s last episode, this clearly gave Pencil bad memories, and I think it also give us the terrible realisation that characters ended up in the underworld not just by getting crushed by the compactors, but just any time they have been crushed or flattened to death, that’s now something we have to realise!

[@imfumrsaqjed]

I don't like the new cameo / guest animator stuff they're trying to do

[@donutmaxgaming9674]

So was 8-Ball in the underworld in BFB 8

[@cianroe3233]

@@donutmaxgaming9674Likely.

[@cianroe3233]

@@imfumrsaqjedCan you be specific on what you mean.

[@OmarEssawyGD]

pretty sure it isn't fully "terrible memories" since in bfdia 10 when she was recovered from the underworld ruby says "how was it like when you were dead" and she said "i dont remember"

[@Grapes_The_AxolotlOSC]

7:11 This incident has made it so that I cannot hear the words “five nickel plushies” in that order without laughing at least a little

[@oliver_editzz61]

I AM HIGHLY OFFENDED -nick le

[@kori1939]

tbh. most of these arent even that bad man. the lollipop line is literally just like the pen island line.(which is funny that it isnt here) there are some bad ones here but they are mostly not bfdi's fault(like the riggings)

[@4mfjt]

Naaah, Drakes getting disrespected by BFDI fans he cannot recover from this 😭😭🙏🙏

[@superstar64]

I'm sure Boyinaband would get along well with Drake

[@entitypolyhedron]

@@superstar64YIKES 💀💀💀

[@joaozindaartist]

Recovery center reference?

[@entitypolyhedron]

@@joaozindaartist 😓no

[@Tired_Tortilla]

i don't think the whole dislike of the underworld was because it didn't fit bfdia or made people uncomfortable but mainly because the joke just wasn't very funny and dragged on way to long

[@yoshicrafter7608]

the first time it popped up, it was pretty funny but it kept on happening for like 2 minutes at a time like 4 more times, resulting in a long episode for NO reason imo

[@kandiiprod]

"the joke just wasn't very funny" oh okay so YOU decide what's funny now huh? people like you are a plague, I just wanna enjoy a funny internet moment without having people scream into the ears of everyone in the comment section how much "ewWwW THis jOkE is NOt FuNny😫😫😫", yeah I'm gonna DO THE SAME, I'm just gonna call you and everyone you love unfunny yknow, piss off🤬

[@sudokuacrobatics]

A joke? I thought it was supposed to be unsettling lore

[@Lucas.pcport85]

​@@sudokuacrobatics then you missed the part where every one was talking in extremely formal manner

[@jasperjpeg]

i sorta found it funny harrass me all you want i dont care

[@AbsoluteDoofusHaha]

I just enjoy any games/show without caring about what the fandom/community says.

[@blober9994]

You're right, right...

[@omegadadragon]

Yes

[@kidcat2064]

The 5 Nickel plushies is an incident that the Osc wont forget 💀

[@justnotterxo]

My online friend group (we're all bfdi fans) always joke abt the 5 Nickel plushies post to this day 😭 idc if that sh was satire or not, that was unironically funny and dumb asf

[@Jaradao88]

Really? Because I forgot it happened

[@LuxembourgishMapping]

Because some people thought it's vote to ve out

[@blueheracross]

5:26 I LOVE HOW SAYS IT WHILE SHOWING THOSE SCENES OH THE IRONY

[@ST4RS._.4U.82]

5:11 HELP IVE ALWAYS FOUND THIS SCENE FUNNY THO

[@Bubbles_Alt]

FR MAN PEOPLE COMPLAIN ABOUT EVERYTHING

[@noahluvrr]

because it is funny and people are just sensitive

[@Bubbles_Alt]

@@JaredtheNacliFan That's different and it's sexual assault. Lollipop was only joking with Bubble and didn't actually force her to do it. Thats the big difference between the real thing and the joke.

[@PlumFromTheForest]

@@JaredtheNacliFan UGHHHH PLEASE STOP SPEAKING

[@bubblegumCrystal]

​@@noahluvrr I t i s a k i d s h ow

[@spherius2account]

1:37 it's literally the point

[@lancer0327]

Well yeah, but this one is an uncanny valley

[@tamagho]

@@lancer0327that is too, part of the point lol it’s meant to be as weird and uncanny as possible

[@retroclassicpablo]

Pin's suffering was the most normal controverisal thing that was going to happened

[@LightningShade12]

I don't think the Flower winning BFB was rigged considering she had a whole redemption arc sort of thing going on and a lot of people wanted to see Flower improve herself, even though Gelatin is undoubtedly my favourite character. Also am I the only one who doesn't mind the 3D thing in BFDIA that much?

[@lunamig1006]

The 3D thing is funny, And it was supposed to be funny, I don't know why people took it seriously.

[@omegadadragon]

​@@lunamig1006 Same

[@GK08_Productions]

The 3D thing is a good idea of where the dead contestants would be before they were recovered

[@spacesoccercowboy6091]

My main complaint with BFB post-split is that they just forgot how to write Four. He was originally a crazy, chaotic host that you never knew what he would do next. Like in the flipping previous episode, he pulled Death PACT out of him, gave them a menacing stare, and gladly announced their safety. Post-split made him into a whiny child of sorts, like geting burnt by Firey Jr. In BFB 16 for some reason despite that not happening before?

[@NotTheRealFirey3672]

0:02 Eminem ain't got no competition 🔥🔥🔥🗣🗣🗣

[@sheepboi1873]

4:38 you missed the perfect opportunity into saying "He was tryna strike a chord that was probably A Minorrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr"

[@Fluffcontainer]

never even noticed how Controversial bfdi rlly is 💀

[@f.u.m.o.5669]

Not to be rude but the fandom is kinda...

[@advance64bro]

That’s why I left the community

[@oliver_editzz61]

I don’t care about bfdi being controversial tbh I still love it

[@AbsoluteDoofusHaha]

any community is controversial. I just enjoy bfdi without caring the community

[@DaccaKoolade]

You should be happy this video is only 8 minutes, you should see the other communities controversies. just some little things people got mad over, no need to worry lol

[@50bucksies]

1:37 HOW are people genuinely getting uncomfortable from that😭

[@ItzBIULD]

Maybe it's uncanny valley, but I cannot see that being controversial levels of uncomfortable

[@TheCreator-178]

People getting mad at it looking weird is crazy. Like, that’s the point 💀

[@grezzoin]

Sensitive people who would crawl up into a ball when someone touches them in pony town

[@DefNotEnder]

When I watched that episode I was a mix of dying of laughter and uncanny valley but I wasn’t mad at all (only cinema sins type of mad)

[@ddlcfan2763]

They should've pointed out thay coby is a zionist

[@Prettycoolpeashooter19]

4:38 SOMEBODY LOOP THIS

[@theturkeeflee]

that would be awesome!

[@littleegg2558]

The worst part about Nonexisty not debuting is that it was said that if he had been the most voted he would have actually debuted, which means that there was literally no reason for him not to join.

[@DefNotEnder]

He actually did join though, on Death PACT again and then CloudYAY

[@WishingLime]

People should cut the BFDIA hell scenes some slack. BFDIA I meant to be unexpected and weird. What makes BFDIA special is that you really never know whats to come

[@62mainstreetnewarknj58]

some of these controversis were dumb af like the kissing joke and the pin suffering like how were these even "controversies" 💀

[@nojoke4182]

When I heard "Controversial Pen Line", I immediately thought of Pen Island.

[@cupcakeカップケーキ]

"PENISLAND"

[@paolaplana5957]

PEN ISLAND :D PEN IS LAND :) PENI-

[@CringeySamOSC]

@@paolaplana5957PENISLAND

[@WitchWerewolfEdd]

PENISLAND

[@yinyangyt8749]

I thought post split was pretty good. I mean it shorten the series and we got actual character development and not a single character was bland. Pre split didn’t have time to give screen time to every character. The only thing that sucked about post split was Four’s behaviour. That’s it

[@Albertaso01]

you could've talked about the teardrop joining tpot controversy, a lot of people disliked that because teardrop joined tpot despite deciding to stay in bfb and placing 3rd, plus, alone on her own team meant that she got into an immunity streak that lasted until she willingly sacrificed herself

[@40Ccents]

6:55 those people should not have been mad, like in paper it would be fun to see nothing compete, but like, there's other good debuters and it would be a little bit unfair for a team to have less than 1 member

[@guywhoateallthepizza1031]

If they had zero intentions of making them a contestant, they should never put them up for voting. It was a huge slap in the face, "we know who you voted for, but we are ignoring it anyway."

[@thebenhettyshow4354]

5:14 I hate it when kids act like kissing is so gross and plus it didn't even show

[@vannillaAJofficial204]

all they did was make a silly little joke. dont get the hate either

[@notnarella]

tbh I thought it was a bj joke

[@DefNotEnder]

Kissing isn’t even that inappropriate (I’ve been to 2 weddings and watched several Disney movies with kissing and I’m not even 13) but people act like it is as bad as nsfw

[@JaredtheNacliFan]

I think it depends. If they are characters that have been married for a long time (like a mother and father) or are characters that are actually in love, then it would be ok. However, bubble never really interacted with lollipop and was uncomfortable with the joke, hence why she slapped her. So that could be not okay for a kids show. It’s just my opinion

[@Beardash123]

5:26 “Not family friendly” *needle casually burning slowly*

[@cheesepizza98]

1:28 YO IS THAT MY FAVORITE GAME IN THE BACKGROUND!?

[@ick567]

FINGERDASH

[@AkramsChannel]

Gd

[@CEORabbid]

fire in the hole

[@eknomwolley]

bom bodets bedenedwi

[@Qbxyz-_l]

The funny thing is that most of the controversy aren't even the creators fault for this except for the air joke, but how people took it in a wrong way, or how people or KZbin made it wrong.

[@DefNotEnder]

Something else controversial: ships. I support them (as long as it’s purely romantic or platonic) and even ship a few but some people hate ships for the same reason people hate furries, stereotypes and because of cringe culture. I understand that the creators said that ships weren’t canon (as well as 4x being canon I’m not quite sure which one is true) but people can still ship them and people get mad at gelatin being shipped with anyone because he’s “11” which he said as a joke in one episode (not sure which one) and characters have no canonical ages so yeah

[@Shiners1740]

Honestly, looking back Post Split was soooo overhated. Obviously it has missed potential and things to improve on, but it’s still way better than most people give it credit for.

[@blober9994]

It's literally worst episodes of the entire searies, what did you expect? The idea of split was terrible

[@noahluvrr]

@@blober9994 they split because the twins didn't want a big season and wanted to go back to something like bfdi. that's not a horrible idea.

[@blober9994]

It just made not much sense, like, TPOT still has 42 contestants after all. And that's all by sacrficing the quality of BFB, split only made worse for BFB and left us with controversial 5th season​@@noahluvrr

[@noahluvrr]

@@blober9994 Well still, TPOT and BFB don't have much controversy and are pretty much ONLY hated because of the split. At least that what I've seen. I've almost only seen people hate on BFB Post-Split because it split, which is a horrible reason to hate something. BFB still had good quality and episodes. It might've not been AS good but it was still good.

[@blober9994]

There more cons than pros in BFB post-split, don't hide it​@@noahluvrr

[@theactual_artiscool8540]

In Bfb i wasn’t really mad Leafy got eliminated despite being my favorite mainly because she didn’t put up a fight against it- But i didn’t really expect her to not join the brb. Also Firey and Leafys friendship is my favorite 😭

[@penntopaper9305]

the five nickel plushies thing is so so so fucking funny

[@tjr_ezra]

oh yes, kissing, such a nightmare, not like kids are exposed to their parents kissing each other or something!

[@JaredtheNacliFan]

I think parents kissing is ok since they have been married for a long time, but bubble barely new lollipop and wasn’t comfortable with the idea of kissing her

[@thebeemangd]

I think spongy rejoined because he got screwed in the script of BFB 14 so bad that the creators thought he deserved a second chance.

[@VositoTheGoat]

In the BFDIA 9 credits scene, You could see in the 3D animation credits that it was Coby Pal. So it was Coby who animated that cursed animation.

[@Podgrzybiarz]

2:10 fingerdash in the bg lmao

[@idk_012-3]

4:43 Bro really just said :btools 💀

[@tamagho]

I think most of the “controversies” exist because the OSC fanbase tends to be on the younger end

[@penntopaper9305]

nowadays people whine about the split bc for some reason everyone hates that four and x got character development which i absolutely can not wrap my head around bru. esp four like literally everything tracks in context and it started way before the split. his personality is not that inconsistent. in fact, i'd go as far as to argue it isn't inconsistent at all. i think it makes perfect sense and meshes well even with most of early pre split, especially after rewatching it, and with his appearances in tpot

[@RngGm]

Wasnt nonexisty added, but because it didnt affect the total number of players, one more was added, meaning that nonexisty could technically win the game along with someone else?

[@carlosmattessich3883]

If I recall, they slammed the door on his face in TPOT 1 (I think)

[@JaredtheNacliFan]

Hi I am the guy who wrote the Bfb 20 kiss joke on the wiki just so you know

[@Gjeea]

good vid fireycanon!

[@FireyCanon]

Thanky

[@Gjeea]

@@FireyCanon np

[@quagsire_lover3235]

1:54 WHAT THE HELLL

[@artinrmzisgooder]

why has no one replyed to this

[@StarboyDavidChiem]

Oh god.. so much controversy.. I HATE CONTROVERSY!!!

[@BatriAlbach]

But don't you also hates hating controversy???

[@volly9387]

the hell is supposed to be disturbing, and non-existy is literally non-existent, i am so glad actually that the creators dont listen to community sometimes, bfdi fandom can be really bad

[@ddlcfan2763]

The hell scenes were made by a zionist

[@mmtasty-s6k]

me when i enjoy a scene/character/show/game/pretty much any piece of media but then so much people hate it and theres a whole 40 minutes documentary video of how it's bad:

[@bowserredbird]

People got upset over Lollipop being weird with bubble? I guess they didn't remember about pen's "pen island" name idea.

[@Alcalop.]

7:11 “I am HIGHLY offended!”

[@Cocobutter_]

Loving your new forms of content FireyCanon!!

[@Yewstewtiktok]

Pin got everything back but her limbs. She kind of got legs but they are robot legs and then she got total plot armor and she even became supercharged and made them up for elimination

[@DefNotEnder]

She didn’t get her limbs because in IDFB she gives up her color for her limbs and they are planning to continue IDFB once BFDIA finishes

[@tzarg]

2:49 BFB is the third season now I guess🤨🤨🤨🤨🤨🤨

[@Millymullfoxyblueagain]

Yea

[@omegadadragon]

Oh yeah, it's technically the 4th.

[@DefNotEnder]

Cuz IDFB was basically just one of the short videos unrelated to the competition

[@Badnamesarecoolio]

6:49 NO WHY THIS VIDEO…☹️

[@TheManBehindTheSlaughter-fs1qk]

1:39 that is literally the damn point.

[@IJustAnimateXD]

Is it weird that bfb 29 reminded me of TAWOG’s episode “the sell out”

[@AugmentedRoblox]

5:18 I always thought lolly was talking about her "built in straw" Her stick thing

[@DefNotEnder]

Honestly that would actually be bad

[@Eevee_from_paldea]

5:07 this is like… the best joke in post-split

[@Nether_Portall]

ADDING THE CLIP IN 7:53 IS CRAZY NAWWHH 💀☠🙏🙏

[@Splatrakuzilla31]

What is it?

[@Tronked]

nsfw​@@Splatrakuzilla31

[@Spookin2763]

What is it...

[@ellacorcoran9045]

What is it? (From because it's very cute)

[@Nether_Portall]

@@ellacorcoran9045 I posted the link.

[@AxolotlPuppyWithAxolotlKitty]

Ok but when lollipop said"care to give me some air? No straw needed" is still crazy imo☠️☠️☠️

[@Jaspery-lm9wl]

The most unfair part about flower winning is that she survived over taco by ONE VOTE and then over blocky by only a few hundred votes IN THE NEXT EPISODE

[@Echo.comicsGlennon]

This must’ve took you long time to make keep up the good work❤❤❤

[@Door_Animations]

Amazing video

[@FlurryPie0]

Not like us playing is how I know this video is gonna be surprisingly brutal

[@Alex-ke2ht]

2:48 “3rd season” *shows BFB* *IDFB crying in the corner*

[@tariqthehedgehog]

It’s funny how the Bracelety recommender drama wasn’t mentioned

[@teardropteam]

Wait what happened

[@Vashkella1937]

That is an amazing intro

[@xX_K3LLF1RE_Xx]

4:07 That’s actually the thumbnail for the 23rd episode “Fashion For Your Face”

[@SleepyLuigi]

you forgot to mention the profiley controversy! Tbh I actually really liked profiley.

[@MajoLaura]

The CGI Hell scenes definitely feel way out of place and just doesn’t fit BFDI, if you remove those scenes in BFDIA 9, nothing will change but improves the pacing And I hate how Pin keeps getting tortured like having her face removed and shrunken. It’s no wonder she said BFDIA sucked in TPOT 2

[@WishingLime]

I dont get the hate for the hell scenes . BFDIA is supposed to be unexpected and otherworldly. You dony know whats coming and thats what makes BFDIA special

[@joaquinm9148]

@@WishingLimeYeah, and it definitely has more comedic potential than “Poopy Mayonnaise”

[@WishingLime]

@@joaquinm9148 agree, i found the hell scenes so absurd and random, thats why I absolutely loved it

[@101searcha]

Yo a new firey cannon video!

[@baconking13]

the reason why derpy hooves did that is because they felt bad that teardrop cant do much and she stills stays in the show.

[@Accordian]

Kendrick lamar and bfdi goes together like water and oil, and I love it.

[@booiscaredyou.]

the hate on winner made me so mad. like we saw a chance for a good storyline and thats what we voted for (and got). winner has been my favorite since tpot 2 came out which was when i first watched bfdi seriously (i had watched episodes when i was like seven, its kinda funny how i was brought back to the osc)

[@cakesjay3064]

There was also the wait for bfb 14 that was getting the fans out of hand

[@Ilikecatsl0l]

*ETERNAL TORTURE* is crazy

[@Yoyleland_Potato13]

1:28 nah this isn’t the underworld, this is hell

[@WizinPara]

Hey that's my candle asset i made,i feel so famous

[@M4cintoshSE]

Pin kept losing her limbs so that she could hate bfdia, making her line in pre-split bfb accurate.

[@TotalNormalFry]

Pin's Suffering explains how Pin said BFDIA was not fun in TPOT I bet

[@invertedLOL]

It’s important to mention counting votes in the comments isn’t going to be accurate for much longer. Most people will realize the google form exists. The only reason we could do it last episode was because people hadn’t realized the change yet.

[@Discoverwithkate]

The intro is so fire 🔥

[@sup_42]

I think the reason the writers torment Pin is because they need a reason for Pin to hate BFDIA.

[@thirteenly13]

Its OUT!!!! 69th like🤣🤣 I love all seasons!! I did not know this silly drama happened lol 😭 1:20

[@alejandroocaranza1048]

You forgot when pin showed the middle finger!

[@Ayazzzzzz]

so you're saying got pissed off at that BFDIA 9 scene because it was disturbing. That is literally the entire point of the Gag. It is a scene that exists to make the viewers say "wtf?"

[@Syndicalist]

"if nickel is safe i will give away Five nickel plushies!"

[@TheCoolnessOfNineOSC]

“saw once said” i will start. hey hey stop fighting cmon guys we’re teamis!

[@well3669]

Not like us caught me off guard

[@GoobySnoobers]

Cary sounds like vector

[@Hedgehogspeedthesmilingcritter]

4:05 help why did i think firey and taco were kissing

[@XDCheezy48]

Five nickel plushies, Cause of teardrop getting eliminated, And the one who made inanimate insanity, ANIMATION EPIC :(

[@Aiden_7688]

1:40 bro what 💀🙏

[@nicklas400]

aint no way bro got the "i remember you was conflicted, Misusing your influence, sometimes I did the same Abusing my power, full of resentment Resentment that turned into a deep depression Found myself screamin' in the hotel room I didn't wanna self-destruct The evils of Lucy was all around me So I went runnin' for answers" 💀🙏

[@owenplays3770]

0:00 THE CLICK REFERENCE?!

[@Branchkid4575]

I think i remember playing your gind the markers roleplay