EVERY EYESHADOW PALETTE I'VE TRIED IN 2024 (so far...)

[@lauriedomino3559]

Your eye make looks so good here!

[@CaitlinCostello]

Thank you!

[@tanialeee]

ND is definitely for the subtle girlies, even with their colorful palettes, she makes them wearable for the simple girlies who want a subtle hint of color. If you see people posting their ND looks, they all look light handed. If you watch a ND ranking video, there are a bunch of people who say “it’s not the best” or “she’s had better formulas” etc, when it comes to a lot of the palettes, but the ones that are always at the top, are the neutrals and/or the newest release. Also, a brand that repeats shades in palettes is just not exciting….like the newest gold palette has like 9 repeated shades or something like that, it’s not necessary.

[@CaitlinCostello]

I couldn't believe it when I heard about all the repeat shades that ND does! Final nail in the coffin for me!

[@GabriellaFrances]

U look so glowy and gorgeous! Love the eyeshadow 💚

[@CaitlinCostello]

Awee thank you so much!

[@jjbeauty.001]

Your eye look today is GORGEOUS!! And of course so are all the looks you created with the palettes!

[@CaitlinCostello]

Thank youuuuu 🥰

[@destinyhall8436]

Favorite videos of life❤❤ lets get it!!

[@kayla4702]

So happy for you to have been gifted product! You work so hard!

[@CaitlinCostello]

I'm still baffled haha

[@ananyaferguson9238]

Love this eye look. Can you show us how to do this look?

[@CaitlinCostello]

It's just my pan that palette on the outer corner and then some greens from Botanical on the inner part. Plus Pavo from the pastel roses!

[@ananyaferguson9238]

I tried to dupe this today. So pretty. Coral and mint. But not as pretty as yours❤

[@janetmyers68]

I love that Beaty bay pallet. The looks you did with it sold me. On that palette. Love the look you have on now. ❤️

[@CaitlinCostello]

I still can't stop reaching for it!

[@janetmyers68]

Ohhh those titanium Foxes palettes look beautiful! I want to try this brand now. ❤

[@CaitlinCostello]

They're one of my favorite brands!!

[@not-the-founder-of-rome]

I can't remember if you already have, but you should roll the Poppy Storm palette into your pan that palette as a companion palette. I think the shimmers would go well with some of the remaining shades.

[@CaitlinCostello]

Omg you're so right!!

[@abigailkirkham9120]

Such a positive and upbeat post i can tell you truly love what you do

[@CaitlinCostello]

Awee thank you so much!

[@alexandreaturcot8921]

Great ranking so far this year! I dont feel like you have brought in too many palettes... I have a huge collection and palettes I have not even played with yet....😊

[@CaitlinCostello]

Palettes are always my weak spot!

[@Babymuexlue2]

Love this eye look in the video. ❤ Also I love speed reviews and ranking videos too.

[@CaitlinCostello]

So glad you loved it!

[@coleoftheball]

Okay I think I need to try titanium foxes both these palettes look sooooo beautiful ❤❤ love this look too ❤

[@CaitlinCostello]

1000000/10 would recommend!

[@ritas140]

I saw a post in a facebook group today. This woman got that odens eye palette and has emptied it! She started panning on 1st March! Isn’t that wild?!

[@CaitlinCostello]

That can't be real?!?!?! Whattttt!

[@ritas7851]

@@CaitlinCostello I agree. She also finished a Pat McGrath mothership palette in 10 months. I just don't see how it's possible!

[@abigailkirkham9120]

Omg you need winter wonderland from cosmic brushes i have them all because the quality i love muse

[@CaitlinCostello]

I was going to get it but never got round to it! Looks so stunning tho!

[@fabiolaaguiar9713]

I wanted to buy one of the titanium foxes palettes but they say in their website that they use carmine 😢