EVERY MARIO GAME: Don't Touch the Color Black Challenge!

[@RealBathanielNandy]

After this color challenge, we're gonna try something a bit different next time where I'll play through just one game trying to avoid a color, and we'll have a counter for each time I hit a color. So no getting booted out of the first level like usual lmfao, thanks for watching! :)

[@Llama78_9]

That’s a welcome change, but I will miss you losing in most levels!

[@EvanJack06]

Early gang

[@DraftyDaftyHubertOHare]

Thank you, that’s significantly better

[@EvilRiceGuy]

Alright

[@jcwred]

I think that's better

[@glitchyyt4282]

"Outlines don't count" **proceeds to lose due to an outline a bunch**

[@hank2188]

“We’re not going to count outlines, just stuff thats actually black like goombas eyebrows” *counts brick outlines, coin outlines, ect.*

[@LittleLexi24]

It annoys me & makes me kinda hate this series….

[@casjp12]

for the coins he counted the black inside the coin, this is really noticeable in the yoshi coins

[@ultlifeform]

@@casjp12 Which is just even more confusing, because he also keeps mentioning how high the eyebrows on the Goombas are, being unsure if he could safely jump on them, and in Lost Levels, he only lost to the brick when he touched it from below, because only the bottom was black... So in some instances, he only lost when touching the black part on an object, but in other cases, he lost as soon as he touched any object that had any black on it at all, whether he actually touched that part or not.

[@randomvidsshorts2322]

It makes me rage, it makes me want to make my own color challenge to show how strict his rules are

[@19videogame]

I think I understand the challenge. The outlines were not counted but anything that had a black interior. So the Brick Outline was not counted but since the brick had black lines inside it that is what counted. Same thing with the Yoshi Coins in SMW. Yoshi’s shape was made in black lines which were inside the coin. Another good reference is the eyes of shine in SMS since the black eyes are in the shine that is why it counts.

[@AJReid-od7ut]

Rules are still kinda unfair not gonna lie

[@crocornaw]

“Can touch black outlines” *proceeds to touch black outlines and fails the game*

[@cheeseburgermonkey7104]

Finally, a color where the Super Mario Land games will actually be dangerous to play with

[@idkgaminglol818]

White: am i a joke to you?

[@cheeseburgermonkey7104]

@@idkgaminglol818 I said a color, not the color

[@idkgaminglol818]

Oh, sorry man

[@cheeseburgermonkey7104]

@@idkgaminglol818 It's all good

[@idkgaminglol818]

@@cheeseburgermonkey7104 k thanks

[@EBTKSPaddy]

1:46 perfectly sums up this entire franchise, and i'm glad there's gonna be changes soon

[@randomvids319]

I like these color challenges but I feel like the more color challenges we get the more the challenge is how short can I make this video and touching either no black at all or the tiniest bit of black that most other people wouldn't count

[@mahranislam3554]

What im wondering is when does he stop playing, cause the editor probably counts something that he wouldn't have counted

[@randomvids319]

That is very true

[@randomvids319]

I almost forgot to say that actually his mario party color challenges are going good Cuz you can't mess up mario party like you can for these mario games the same can be said with the golf always get a birdi

[@mahranislam3554]

@@randomvids319 but I think the most annoying could be that he stops after beating 1-1 in the mario ones, cause I want to see how far he could hypothetically go instead of just calling beating 1-1 beating the challenge.

[@randomvids319]

@@mahranislam3554 yes that is annoying too I almost forgot about that

[@Shadex_Joestar]

"Don't touch the color Black" *Bowser has left the chat*

[@Shadex_Joestar]

@Henry Allred even Black Bowser from Color Splash

[@LegoAndrew08]

@@Shadex_Joestar even dry bowser (the eyes)

[@LegoAndrew08]

At 9:30 on the game over thing. I used 0.25x speed and Bathaniel Nandy didn’t touch the black

[@alexanderdahms4001]

@@LegoAndrew08 i mean hid editor pretty stirct

[@NormansWorldMovies]

5

[@MariuigiKhed]

Hold on: for the SMB Goomba Bathaniel said "can touch Goombas, but not their feet or eyebrows" meaning that, if he kill a Goomba without touching these parts he would have been fine. Then why touching a mushroom with black eyes does count then? If he doesn't touch the eyes he's fine

[@ritzplushfilms2666]

Who the heck is Bandy?

[@MariuigiKhed]

@@ritzplushfilms2666 nickname of Bathaniel. Oh, wait, that just Nathaniel surname. Nvm

[@ritzplushfilms2666]

@@MariuigiKhed no Bathaniel Nandy is his real name

[@SmashBasher123]

Yeah I feel like the rules switched midway through, at first it sounded like touching anything that had black somewhere on it was fine as long as you didn't touch the black part itself, but then stuff like the black eyes of stars/shines counts when you could easily touch those without touching the eyes?

[@MariuigiKhed]

@@SmashBasher123 I feel like this series is not "Don't touch color" is more like "Let's see on what level of lazyness is the editor". Cause, even the 3D Land bit: "Anything but the middle would have been fine" then why didn't you count it on the SMG2 bit when Nandy CLEARLY pass in the middle of many bushes?

[@coolguyyy9071]

“Luigi it takes all colors to make a rainbow, EXCEPT BLACK”

[@idkgaminglol818]

I love that reference, and it really fits

[@Toaster003]

There’s no black in a rainbow!”

[@skeletonking27]

"There's no black in a rainbow Luigi."

[@waitwhat519]

Oh no! Bowser mixed all of the colors into black paint! Now he has become Black Bowser!

[@Toaster003]

@@waitwhat519 **bowser’s fury happens**

[@AdrianCosman]

“I have the best rule set” *Proceeds to use the dumbest rules possible*

[@LiterallyDrew]

I feel like everyone of these videos are a waste of uploads

[@dragonlynx]

What kind of bs is touching something that contains the colour counting? If he just removed that rule, it would be fine.

[@chrisbrochu3663]

His editor does it not him

[@zarthy4169]

@@dragonlynx Also, in 3D Land when he touches the middle of the bush it says “Anywhere but the middle would have been just fine.” Why doesn’t this rule apply to the bush when it applies to literally everything else?

[@zarthy4169]

@@dragonlynx Also, he says with goombas that it would be okay for him to touch anywhere but the eyebrows.

[@thelanktheist2626]

Brick: *is dark brown* Bathaniel: Is this black?

[@randomvids319]

He even says it's dark brown

[@JPReckless2444]

I usually try to avoid big essay-like comments, but I have to address my thoughts. It's great that Papa Nandy is changing the format & rules after this because tbh these particular color challenges needs a proper system. I get he likes challenges, but you have to be able to pass the challenges. The current [or i guess previous] rules are too inconsistent & making it impossible to clear one stage let alone a level. Same with Mario Kart games. i believe he shouldn't count an item or enemy that a primary color has other one on them. Example: in this challenge, the goombas [outside of SML 1 & 2], the blocks in SMB, the mushrooms, & the Sunshine shouldn't have counted. If they were all black or at least under a dark shadow, fine, but they have a different primary color. Goombas are brown, the Sunshine/Stars is gold yellow, etc. also, I see comments like "he's making the rules up as he goes along cause he wants to keep these challenges short" or "the editor is too picky with these rules so he doesn't want to edit for a long time" I seriously doubt those are the cases, but I understand most like his longer videos & understandably skip these color challenges. I don't want him & his team to overwork themselves, so hopefully the new rules can accomplish more for both Nandy & the boulder brigade. Also, i don't think shades of a color should count either.

[@veggiet2009]

I agree, If outlines do not count, then the black stroke on a coin should not count as it's a contour outline. Same goes for the brick. Background should not count at all as you don't interact with it... only interacting should count as touching, so walking in front of a semisolid: fine, walking on top of a semi-solid: questionable. I DO think that the goomba's feet and eyebrows should count, if it is determined that they are black.

[@veggiet2009]

But I will say that in 3D I think that black accents like eye color shouldn't count

[@camila_lt]

Shades shouldn't count as long as the color for the shade is more like other color than the challenge color, a orangy black counts, a dark orange doesn't

[@gowildler]

@EntityGaming That’s the name of the world’s savior.

[@marioortegosanz1614]

6:16 Bathaniel: actually fairly simple Also Bathaniel: "touches a Goomba and dies"

[@e-pointer2262]

You could've kept going on Sunshine had you touched the sprite from the back

[@EvanJack06]

You should do these challenges for sonic games

[@pinkypotatoe01]

Yes!

[@chrisgamer6898]

Yes

[@qwerty273]

I feel like these would be better rules: 1) If your sprite (or model) touches the color (either in view, or out) you lose 2) The color has to be within a 16 RGB range difference (all channels can be +16 - -16 range of the color)

[@gowildler]

Ohh, nice!

[@gkoonie]

You shouldn’t lose when you touch something that has the color you are trying to avoid if you don’t touch that thing’s part like the shine

[@LittleLexi24]

I so agree!

[@kirlixen]

I just began watching his "color challenge" videos and I only lost braincells as I continued to watch each of them.

[@riasg-b9w]

“This is fairly simple” DIES TO GOOMBA

[@hectorsanta76]

1:07 oh, come on... I know Mario touched the black but I still think that's a little to much... 1:45 not "LOL" that's the backround! (I think...) 5:36 If you would've gotten it from the back, you could've probably kept playing.

[@papramayro46]

Super Mario Bros The Lost Levels: Mario didn't touch the black part of the brick so he is fine. New Super Mario Bros 2: the note block has black on it so you lose.

[@borkedluck]

Anything that's simply just heavily dark shade: exists Editor: "yo that's black!"

[@hakai1014]

Bathaniel: Dont touch black Also Bathaniel: Wears a black beanie and sweater

[@Gamer14867]

Mario literally has a black mustache

[@koopatrol9027]

6:15 Actually fairly simpl- Proceeds to die from a goomba

[@theyeetplayer8724]

If the door in smb2 counts, why doesn’t the black background count?

[@arachniguy8433]

cuz its not interactable plus it was the trim that turned from black to blue

[@NetneykTheMusicProducer]

He did literally not touch the yoshi coin so IT SHOULD NOT count

[@thisisasupersayin376]

And all the black on the Yoshi coin is an outline, this is unfair!

[@thatdude7325]

"interactable objects will not be counted" proceeds to step on a brick and count it as a fail

[@FunnySunnyKitten]

**proceeds to bounce off of a noteblock**

[@Meshona_]

Technically, mario didn't touch the yoshi coin when he collected it so it shouldn't count.

[@thisisasupersayin376]

Same with the Electrogoomba in Galaxy 2

[@LittleLexi24]

This is how I would do it

[@toeyboi9488]

I don’t know why but I’m going to have some Oreos and milk why I watch this video

[@TheCreationOfDread]

7:09 Slow down and keep pressing play till this one frame where Mario,s eyes arent closed when he dies

[@moadot720]

6:16 LITERALLY fitting!!!! 😂😂😂😂

[@mega8525]

Bathaniel Nandy when he goes out in public be like:

[@lincolnioane7605]

Bathaniel: “outlines don’t count” Editor: Imma pretend I didn’t hear that

[@arishnicoff2621]

9:32 Mario didn’t even touch the black note, he just touched the white part. He shouldn’t have lost this one.

[@toeyboi9488]

Your not the only one I commented that over a year ago

[@Animefan20044]

I’ve been waiting for that challenge.

[@kirbyy9]

Im confused you say the goombahs only count when the eyebrows are sticking out and can touch you but since the stars have black on it they count

[@zacharylandrum4789]

Spoilers: He fails every single game in this video.

[@dawnhargis9664]

Kill me

[@dawnhargis9664]

@@ZingZangZote bruh

[@exotictoast9931]

@@dawnhargis9664 bruh

[@dukkadukkah3155]

2:12 Again! That's an outline!

[@dukkadukkah3155]

1:06 that IS an outline! And what the hell is an "outer line"?

[@user-ot4nv4xb9o]

Do every Zelda game, don't touch green or one with the sonic games

[@thepersonwhomakesbadconten323]

Wait but link wears green

[@SonicVGamer]

*G R E E N H I L L* *Z O N E*

[@ibreathedojacat]

i hate zelda

[@TheDerpyDolphin]

Don’t touch green would be impossible for the zelda games except for links awakening and maybe the nes original since link walks on grass a whole lot in the other games

[@ibreathedojacat]

@@SonicVGamer dude thats sonic not zelda

[@LM10CR7EDITS]

Bathaniel:Don’t touch color black His headphones are black

[@kingknight387]

“This is pretty simple” touches black half a second later

[@toeyboi9488]

9:32 he touched white not black

[@andrejvoloskov1531]

Hi BN. I hear that you helped Nathaniel destroy the curse of Lego Mario. Well done dude. I'm impressed.

[@MINE_OK]

Bathaniel’s most controversial color challenge

[@Dashiell777]

I don't really like the challenges I feel like they're over too fast. Maybe you should change some rules a little bit

[@dimitri8262]

All the other color game: Easy Black and White Mario: “I HAVE A PURPOSE NOW”

[@notthatntg]

Bathaniel, I'm sure the black things on the SMB bushes (y'know, inside them) count, don't they?

[@Iamyes7]

“Note blocks should be safe” Congrats, you confused everyone

[@Brody2621]

for smb1, i would say the black lines on the brick block dont count, its just there to show the empty space between the bricks

[@TRITON_gaming]

Your hat is black. Your headphones are black. Your jacket is black.

[@xq2g47]

I liked the editor tbh. He was great.

[@reemademashki7656]

I got an idea every f zero game but DONT touch blue!

[@sans3279]

the first color challenge where Bathaniel plays the Super Mario Land 1 and 2

[@thelegendaryzonaiwarrior6400]

He still hasn’t done grey yet. That’s literally the only color he hasn’t tried to avoid in every Mario game.

[@hiddenbricks6163]

finally a color where super mario land is actually impossible

[@multimayo5735]

8:20 Had Such An Unlucky Moment Of Contact With Black (But Funny)

[@GamerFunOriginallyAarush]

Do Every Kirby Game: Don’t Touch The Color Pink!

[@pineapple1428]

"THEY ARE ROCKS" -Nathaniel

[@ianfinrir8724]

In the 3D games, you lose automatically because Mario's shadow is black.

[@gdmrhotshot3731]

The first time super Mario land isn’t just a complete success

[@hazelordwebtv]

you AND redfalcom have done dont touch black vids, that doesn't feel like a coincidence

[@justasupercalifragilistice9508]

The bricks shouldn’t count as being touched unless they break, you stand on them, or bump into them from the side

[@joeytaylor1021]

It returns!

[@ashtonwilaby]

Finally a challenge where Mario Land is impossible

[@dukkadukkah3155]

10:41 Oh, come on! That's his shadow! That shouldn't count!

[@its_saber1525]

How about next time, for games like M64, stars don't count for colors

[@SmashBasher123]

I feel like just touching something that has black eyes but is primarily other colors shouldn't count unless you actually touch the eyes themselves, so you can collect stars, shines, etc from the back where they're primarily yellow/gold

[@just_viben07]

Man this color challenge was confusing and I'm just watching you do it

[@ruben._._34577]

How about a no touching substances like sand, carpet, grass, water and more

[@BabyBillIsCool]

This is like the first time he fails the Mario Land games

[@thesusmaster]

Finally the Rocks are back

[@sunshine_bypolar8769]

Yess you made a new video!!

[@m.d._doe]

Bathaniel lost right away, as his hat, headphones and shirt is black.

[@GiovanniKody100]

4:44: “Now to deez n-“

[@alexdissington]

this was titled dont touch black, but in reality it was just dont touch anything because half of these things shouldnt have counted at all brick blocks and goombas are brown the noteblocks were white etc etc stop being so nitpicky but other than that enjoyed the video bathaniel

[@brandonfazbear4219]

What about the black spots on the Question Mark Blocks on the 4 corners. They're not outlines. I believe they're bolts or screws.

[@Taceria]

You touched the question mark block!

[@uiinpui]

yay its back

[@opal_fruit9584]

The most iconic intro I've ever seen

[@lynettemalice8110]

Can we see a Mario Party don’t roll one?? I think that’ll go over better than 10 since you can get a one in every game 💖

[@Benjawin6671]

At the thumbnail I thought the SML stood for SuperMarioLogan 😂

[@skizoo5739]

You should do one of these, but the color randomly changes every turn

[@Inactive18302]

3:16 Eh, he was done anyway, lmao

[@equinox9799]

Do every game Don't touch orange colour challenge

[@The-young-master]

I've been waiting for this🙂

[@ryanr27]

On the original Game Boy, it was shades of GREEN, not black, so for the Mario Land games, I’d consider the whole game safe, as it’s all green

[@Aether558]

FINNALY MY REQUEST IS MAGIC btw this is the first time my idea was accepted and made into a video omg

[@yaboijuanito1460]

Lol that was a hard challenge cuz touching black is the hardest to avoid. On mario games some of them has black and some of the doesn't but i hope you have an amazing day bathaniel

[@liran8799]

Why are you fine when you're touching an outline in one game but you're dead if you touch an outline in another

[@LuckyLukedy]

MY MANS GOT A YIAY HOODIE LESSS GOOOOO

[@GiovanniKody100]

Bruh, don’t touch black? That’s fine since it’s social distancing. But why Nandy Player from Amogus Logic?

[@JaydenmasterVR2025]

Uhh bro I totally suggested this idea in don’t touch brown challenge

[@wCongo384]

This will probably be the only video where super mario land 1 and 2 are relevant

[@Yair547]

EVERY MARIO GAME: Don't Touch the Orange Challenge

[@randomvids319]

Just orange left and also gray if he wants to do that one

[@sergeants9227]

Wait if ur not allowed to touch black then u dead Mario has a black mustache

[@kylerisepicsauce]

The only time Mario Land can fail

[@poopypickles679]

The white challenge

[@EL01-h4c]

Can you do every Mario kart game not getting hit with a shell (any type)