Every Team's Worst Trade Of The Last 5 Years

No matter how good your management is chances you get a couple trades wrong so let's looks at every teams' worst of the last 5 years!

[@KanersCabride]

Huberdeau can’t stay away from a video without a negative form lol

[@MikeBartner]

HAHAHAHAHA

[@GigiSon-q2f]

He just had 3points vs allmost full oilers roster

[@farkuso]

By far the goat of hockey youtubers right now. Your channel is so underrated man

[@MikeBartner]

Thank you!

[@michaelkeller5927]

Oilers trade for Keith was a very good trade for the oilers just for Keiths locker room presence. Oilers worst trade is trading back in the 1st round in 2021 to get a useless extra 3rd round pick causing them to pass on the #1 goalie in the draft - Jesper Wallstedt

[@MikeBartner]

Fair that deal also stinks, but just didn't put it because Wallstedt hasn't proved anything yet

[@Marixa1979]

The Keith trade was supposed to be extremely good as he was set to retire and the cap implications according to how the CBA was structured was going to be incredible for the Oilers, but the NHL step in after and eliminated it.

[@Diamondback0006]

The Burns trade was way worse than the Hill trade. Grier gave up a 1st pairing defenseman and retained salary for nothing! The Sharks gave him away for free! Do people forget this?!

[@Jayzinho_twitter]

In a few years we will look at this Buf-Edm trade with McLeod for Savoie and it will be a disasterclass from buffalo

[@MikeBartner]

Verrrryyyyyy possible

[@ponyboy9765]

I always wondered if Aidan Hill would have ever hit his stride if he stayed in SJ. I was punching the air when he came out of nowhere and led Vegas to a cup.

[@nolan6475]

jake Allen was solid for the devils post trade deadline, and I think he will be solid this year as markstrom’s backup.

[@justinspiewak1482]

Knew it was the Ullmark trade for my Bruins. That 1st round pick was actually the Bruins own pick that they got back in the Ullmark trade

[@MikeBartner]

Yup that they gave up in the Bertuzzi trade!

[@justinspiewak1482]

@MikeBartner Yep and then Detroit gave it to Ottawa in the DeBrincat deal

[@LucaC27]

Murray is probably the worst, but Derek Stepan to Ottawa for there own 2nd (i think it turned into Doan) is brutal

[@MikeBartner]

Yea that stunk as well

[@patrickn594]

Love the video, I think you should do the best trades from each team soon

[@MikeBartner]

The only probelm is like 75% of the best will just be these trades but reversed!

[@patrickn594]

@MikeBartner Oh ya hahaha that's a good point

[@gocanuckurself1]

Just gonna assume it’s the OEL trade for the Canucks lol. All those deals were expiring and they brought in an albatross in return, while giving up a 1st round pick. That was ridiculous. If the trade had to be made, we should’ve gotten a high pick for taking on such a ridiculous contract and helping Arizona open up so much cap space that following Summer. Benning was such a dumbass. 🤦‍♂️

[@gocanuckurself1]

I do love Garland though. This coaching staff has turned him into a beast and maximized his potential. Now he’s a guy I could see buying a jersey of.

[@MikeBartner]

Yup and the fact Guenther looks like a young star, rough.

[@gocanuckurself1]

@@MikeBartner who knows, they could’ve taken Johnston. Either way, FUCK! Lol

[@BloodRider1914]

Love to see my team having multiple fleeces on this board

[@Jayzinho_twitter]

The debrincat trade was ass for Ottawa too. Kubalik was A S S💀

[@MikeBartner]

They flipped that 1st into Ullmark tho! I agree that was pretty ass but given DeBrincat had all the leverage, Murray is worse.

[@Jayzinho_twitter]

@@MikeBartner I know buddy but I think the trade itself was ass for the Sens. But of course every Sens fan would trade kubalik, debrincat and some picks for a Top 10 goalie

[@LaurenKutovas]

Honestly Tampa trading J.T Miller was far worse

[@oliverquach9614]

Great video, would’ve been nice to have a trade image up longer, barely have time to read it and take it in.

[@MikeBartner]

Noted!

[@sewerrat9086]

I am so looking forward to Provorov being gone by the trade deadline. That dude was such a liability at times last year and hopefully he plays well enough under Evason to get us a decent return and free up a space for Mateychuk

[@Canucksnate]

Ekman-larsson trade was terrible but garland is doing well though

[@MikeBartner]

Agreed!

[@justforgaming5059]

For Edm I'd say trading 2 second round picks for Athanasiou in 2020 was worse

[@MikeBartner]

Shit true that one was horrible

[@colbyricketts3825]

As a pens fan I’d say the kapanen trade from the leafs is the worst

[@gablefisk-govphost817]

He was soooooo bad. And to think Ron Hextall extended him.

[@nicholasonciul5770]

Kinda sad that as an Oilers fan before watching this video I have no idea if it's gonna be the Wallstedt pick trade, the Athanasiou trade or the Keith trade. We've had so many bad ones. (I would probably pick the Athanasiou one personally cause Brock Faber and Aaty Raty would be nice to have)

[@JesterRace139]

Sharks fan here.. I'd go with Burns instead, all the assets we got back for him just evaporated into nothing. I'm actually ok with that though, for all that Burns did in SJ it was owed to help him land on a legit team to finish his career, even if it cost us a little. No sweat off my back. Adin Hill? Stings a little that he worked out so well for Vegas, but guaranteed when he was traded nobody in SJ felt it was an underpay.

[@MikeBartner]

Burns had a massive contract, they were never goin to get serious assets for him.

[@JesterRace139]

@@MikeBartner Sure, because they were probably only talking to like two contenders that could make it work and Burns would accept. You retain 34% and make Burns available at $5.2m to the rest of the league and they probably actually get something measurable in return. CAR gave up nothing, I'd be shocked if they don't do that trade 1000x over and Grier didn't really even have to do it, it was for Burns. And going back to Adin Hill - on what planet would they have been able to sell him higher? Can't judge one on how things worked out in hindsight and not the other, and to reiterate, Adin Hill wasn't a franchise player.. no offense to him but literally nobody in SJ cared when he was traded.

[@gregvogel9859]

I would say for Seattle it’s trading Vanicek to Washington mainly because it paved the way for Grubauer, which is their worst contract

[@MikeBartner]

Fair but more so was just looking at each isolated trade

[@bxrrysykes136]

Thankfully the Theodore to Vegas trade was like 6 years out that definitely was a horrible move

[@sharkhaos_probably]

I have a feeling Erik Karlsson's coming up, maybe more than once...

[@MikeBartner]

For the Sharks it was over 5 years ago and the Penguins they moved out some bad contracts

[@unibrotherjohn7378]

You should rank every trade in nhl history from worst to best

[@tomas4999]

Huby bounce back for next season 💪😇

[@MikeBartner]

Would be lucky to get 65 points on that team lol

[@tomas4999]

@@MikeBartner idk 🙂 I would guess over 70 points but i'm kinda worry about +/- atribute 🙂

[@ValS781]

for the Devils it is cleary Sharangovich and a 3rd for Toffoli. A disastrous trade

[@MikeBartner]

Nah Toffoli was fine and lived up to it, the rest of the team collapsed.

[@ValS781]

@@MikeBartner toffoli was old, slow,one dimentional player on expiring contract. The Devils traded young fast player for 4 months of Toffoli and after 4 months of the last season Devils didnt have both. Worst trade for the Devils in a long while. Allen trade was OK.

[@jameskingscomicsandenterta3504]

@@MikeBartner Kings trading Toffoli away in 2020 2 days after he scored a hat trick was disastrous. A rule for whoever team has Toffoli: win for whoever team gets him, lose for whoever team trades him away. He may not be top 10 in the whole NHL, but no matter what team trades him away, they always get way less in return

[@ValS781]

@@jameskingscomicsandenterta3504 "no matter what team trades him away, they always get way less in return". Tell it to Calgary. They must be furious with what they got for Toff😅

[@adamnash3645]

Nino for Rask is worst for the Wild.

[@MikeBartner]

It would be if it wasn't on January 19th 2019 so over 5 year ago.

[@adamnash3645]

@@MikeBartner oh!!! Well I feel dumb. Hahaha.

[@BloodyInspired7]

I’d say the mark stone trade is way worse than the Murray trade

[@MikeBartner]

2019 trade deadline is over 5 years ago

[@michaelli9316]

wb when the golden knights traded fleury for essentially nothing?

[@MikeBartner]

He was making 7 million and wasn't a 7 million dollar player in that 2022 season, that was a good deal.

[@michaelli9316]

@@MikeBartner fair, it was not a good deal (and a tad disrespectful) for vegas when it happened since he just came off a vezina season.

[@mcj44]

Giroux for Florida IMO

[@m4t67u]

Giroux had all the leverage there. He didn’t want to be traded anywhere else.

[@mcj44]

@@m4t67u Still a bad trade