Everything Right and Wrong With Pikmin

With Pikmin 4 coming out in under two months, we’re going to go on a journey through all the Pikmin games starting with the first one. Full disclosure: I played the Wii version of this game, but there’s only slight differences between it and GameCube original. I do think the Wii version is the better version, but that’s just me.
Custom thumbnail: Caio Blade Lyrics

[@tonysonic456]

1) My thumbnail artist recommended that I try something different with the ERAWW format which is why the counter's and subtitles look different than in the previous two videos. What do you think? 2) If you have played Pikmin 1, what do you think of it, and would you buy a Switch remaster?

[@juliannocartagena2007]

I like the new thumbnail style. Oh and I noticed you have a PS3 now.

[@tonysonic456]

@@juliannocartagena2007 It’s not a new thumbnail style. It’s a new Win and Sin Counter style. Also, yeah, I got a PS3.

[@juliannocartagena2007]

@@tonysonic456 Ok. I guess I didn’t see your text correctly. My apologies. Oh and speaking of the PS3, I recommend Ni no Kuni: Wrath of the White Witch. (I mean, yes it has been ported to Switch and PS4 but still it’s a great game)

[@darkeneddaylight5422]

I love Pikmin 1, and no I wouldn't. Why? Because I know Nintendo isn't gonna make it for a few more years.

[@ningrlpwr]

I like the new style. Liked the old style too. Just like the videos I guess. 😂

[@micahheyward5342]

He calls his ship a Dolphin 🐬, that's a win for me 😁

[@juliannocartagena2007]

It’s a reference to the GameCube’s codename.

[@micahheyward5342]

@@juliannocartagena2007 That I didn't know, still a win though

[@justaguy3498]

number 1 sin: *Wollywog’s hit-box*

[@whyluigi926]

Aside from luigis mansion, THIS is my favorite Nintendo series, after seeing the promotional video in the settings of luigi's mansion i fell in love with it, thanks for making a video pointing out the good and the not so good points of the game

[@jaygooese4242]

I love this game even the sequel

[@Benjawin6671]

10:43 aged like fine wine

[@davidthemusicman1046]

Surprised that this game didn't give you a lot to say I was expecting you to cover all the games in one video but I guess it would be a bit much I'll definitely be ready for the next games for this series

[@fnaf6491]

Pikmin is my favorite game franchise ever Ranked 1. Pikmin 3 2. Pikmin 1 3. Hey pikmin 4. Pikmin 2 5. Pikmin Bloom

[@markerikson7423]

Hey! based

[@theghostwiththemost789]

I am a brand new pikmin fan. I played all of the games in preparation for 4 for the first time and I liked all of them but pikmin 1 just hits different for some reason. I feel so much nostalgia for the game despite only playing it recently. It’s weird. The game is so short but that’s what makes it so amazing. Because of it’s short length it’s easy and fun to replay. kind of like the first Luigis mansion game. The music is incredible. It fills me with nostalgia for a game I’ve just recently played. I know The other pikmin games have a lot more meat to them, but pikmin 1 is my second favorite game in the series (my favorite is pikmin 3). I genuinely think it’s a masterpiece

[@CSTH1]

I've seen these characters talked about a lot, but I didn't feel inclined to figure who they were and what purpose they served. This game looks pretty interesting, but it's sadly something I would most likely never play. That being said, I still enjoyed the video! :)

[@aidanhammans9337]

Prophetic aren’t you

[@paulwilliams5949]

The only thing i don't like in this game is the crush glitch where if i kill a bulbor my pikmin get push through the stage and that counts as them getting killed but i like how when my pikmin carries a part and enemys are in the way i can have olimar distracted the enemies

[@OsoandPals]

This guy is to nice, I like cinema sins and charii5 since they over exaggerate for comedy Still a great video.

[@luigigx1172]

I hoping you do more of these Right and Wrong videos they really interesting despite its simplicity also it’s probably good for it to short you don’t want to patted out for the sake of long video unless you have lot of things to say about the subject like in the hat in time one anyway looking forward to next one Tony

[@evanrosman9226]

I have a Pikmin video called "Pikmin Hybrids". In the video, I reveal my Pikmin type ideas. You might like it.

[@susiehaltmann3342]

Remember when this game had its trailer in the original Luigi’s Mansion for some reason? Good times

[@micahheyward5342]

Couldn't pick much to talk about from Pikman could you?(This purely for pun's sake)

[@cdplaygame1992]

Hey Tony, personal opinion,chari should change his name to sonic or something right? just saying only because most of his videos are about sonic.

[@masterm1863]

Hi, Have you seen Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse ?

[@tonysonic456]

Yes I have.

[@masterm1863]

How would you rate it out of 10 ?

[@tonysonic456]

@@masterm1863 I guess an 8?

[@masterm1863]

Do you think it is the BEST Spider-Man movie ?

[@tonysonic456]

@@masterm1863 No. Spider-Man No Way Home is the best Spider-Man movie.

[@fnaf6491]

Honestly the Forest Navel is my favorite area of the game

[@tonysonic456]

Why?

[@fnaf6491]

@@tonysonic456 1. It's visually unique And 2. I really liked the challenge of the area over the Distance Spring

[@tonysonic456]

@@fnaf6491 It is unique, but that doesn't mean it looks appealing. It's just a bunch of browns and grays with only one section of real color.

[@cdplaygame1992]

Is there any Pokemon game you would like to review?at least one,is all about friendship and adventure with puzzles,gen1 to 4 set in different parts in Japan,gen5 in New York,gen6 in France,gen7 in Hawaii,gen8 in united kingdom or gen9 in Spain.

[@tonysonic456]

I don’t play Pokémon.

[@cdplaygame1992]

Is okay, no worries.

[@snakeman12.0]

This was a a short, but good video. Also I was wandering, are you ever going to do a video where you talk about Smg4?

[@tonysonic456]

I don’t know. Maybe?

[@snakeman12.0]

Also have you finished Pikmin 3 yet?

[@tonysonic456]

@@snakeman12.0 No.

[@snakeman12.0]

@@tonysonic456 Good cause i actually have a tip for the final boss that could come in handy. Basically just have 100 fully flowered Rock Pikmin and the fight should be easy.

[@tonysonic456]

@@snakeman12.0 Okay. Thanks.

[@PiffleNEO]

Tony is a persona fan??? I would love to see persona content

[@tonysonic456]

I’m actually not. I was just throwing Persona fans a bone.

[@PiffleNEO]

I dont think they really need that much of a bone

[@someanimedweebiamsure7071]

I’m surprised you didn’t mention the Smoky Progg. That creature is rather notorious for all the wrong reasons.

[@tonysonic456]

I actually missed out on the Smoky Progg. Didn't even know it existed.

[@someanimedweebiamsure7071]

@@tonysonic456 Huh, weird. I was pretty sure you’d discuss it. Anyways, for the video on Pikmin 2, could you talk about the Submerged Castle and the Water Wraith and how creepy and frustrating they are? I’ve never played any of the Pikmin games, by the way, but I did watch a let’s play of Pikmin 2 and Creepy Time Limits 12 by whoisthisgit on that particular cave.

[@ArdaOzcan2009]

Can you do more Everything Wrong with Charriii5 making wrong with games, Especially, more Sonic games. It's been 6 months.

[@tonysonic456]

No. I'm done with those.

[@ArdaOzcan2009]

​@@tonysonic456 But why?

[@ArdaOzcan2009]

​@@tonysonic456 Also, why the fuck were you and Charriii being assholes together? Stop bullying, arguing and fighting each other. That is NOT funny! Enough of you two fighting each other, that's very cruel of you two. So... Just. STOP!

[@TheDMan2003]

What’s with the weird distortion at the sides of the screen during the GCN footage? I know it’s a widescreen hack, but I’ve never seen that happen before.

[@fnaf6491]

This might sound weird but I prefer the GameCube controls over the Wii's

[@tonysonic456]

Why’s that?

[@fnaf6491]

@@tonysonic456 I played pikmin 1 on the GameCube and I played pikmin 2 on the Wii and I just got adjust to the GameCube controls

[@meta527II]

Why did you take WAAAAAAAY too long with the first win? It literally plays for over a minute before you finally talk!

[@tonysonic456]

Wow, impatient much? I was letting the game speak for itself. Besides, a little over a minute isn't that long of a time.

[@meta527II]

@@tonysonic456 It’s still way too long a wait. Cinemasins and I never make our audience wait anywhere near that long.

[@tonysonic456]

@@meta527II Well, I'm not CinemaSins or you. Some scenes require the full context to be understood, and CinemaSins is notorious for cutting context.

[@meta527II]

@@tonysonic456 I guess that does make sense. Though I didn't know Cinemasins was NOTORIOUS for cutting context. I knew they didn't always show the context, but I didn't know they were NOTORIOUS for it.

[@cdplaygame1992]

I know you're not a Pokemon fan but do I wait for gold and silver to either be reremaked or wait for the original ones to be on the Nintendo switch online...or... do I download the ROM and play it on my tablet?

[@tonysonic456]

I think you should either wait for them to come to NSO or just download the ROM.

[@cdplaygame1992]

Everything wrong with true crime new York city please yes?

[@tonysonic456]

I’ve literally never heard of that.

[@cdplaygame1992]

Is a GTA imitation, you play as a cop,is good, check it out.

[@tonysonic456]

@@cdplaygame1992 Yeah, sorry. Not my kind of game.

[@cdplaygame1992]

Is okay,no worries.