Everything Wrong With Ghost in the Shell (2017)

[@SkashTheKitsune]

"this movie could have been dialogue free and still made the same amount of money" Funny enough, Wall-E, the first time I saw that was in french, couldn't understand a word of it but could understand the entire run of it and what was going on, it basically was dialogue free for me and my eyes were glued for hours and I paid for the experience I rewatchd it in English and still got the same experience

[@InimicalWit]

@Kryptoskillet Wait, what? He sinned it for having so much dialogue compared to the original films; which he consistently referred to as better films. I think you got your wires crossed,

[@jacek-jan]

How about "Shun the sheep" in Portuguese?

[@aaronmazur8056]

@Kryptoskillet don't be butthurt over a sin. He sins stuff he likes and sins stuff he doesn't

[@leszken]

Fun fact Shaun the sheep movies and series were worldwide in non English speaking countries was advertised as " dubbing".

[@Swift_LN]

I know this movie is trash and all, but the *biggest* sin it has is forcing the fact that the Major is "beautiful". In the original, the Major uses the cheapest and most common body you can find on the market, it's described as borderline ugly and usually used by the lower class. This leads to some pretty trippy scenes where you can see other people using the same body in the background, specially in scenes when they're in the slums. This not only trimmed the production cost a little, but was also way more deep and meaningful.

[@chriscorley6478]

Sayonara Chainsaw Tell that to WETA WORKSHOP who did an amazing job.

[@TF2CrunchyFrog]

We are not blaming WETA Workshop, they are craftsmen, but they also build what they're being told to build. We blame the scriptwriters and director.

[@sanai97]

Sayonara Chainsaw this takes out from the original and the Stand Alone Complex, and in the last The Major was explicitly sexy, so I guess that explains it (?)

[@joaquimpereira4995]

Sayonara Chainsaw I didnt think the movie was thrash at all

[@alexwhip326]

Hollywood thinks the main character always has to be "special".

[@mbrsart]

"It's like this movie put Blade Runner, The Fifth Element, and Attack of the Clones in a blender, added Pop Rocks and Diet Coke, smashed it with a baseball bat, then f*cked it." I have never heard a more accurate description of something in my life.

[@briankentpirrie5228]

and akira and the total recall remake.

[@1975KyleDavid]

Akira has yet to be remade!

[@briankentpirrie5228]

directed by james cameron

[@Alondro77]

Akira... written by M. Night Shyamalan, directed by Michael Bay.

[@uzumaki403]

When I heard him say that it was so unexpected I laughed on spit lmao

[@tsopmocful1958]

This movie did everything bad that I expected Hollywood to do to the source material. So bravo to Hollywood I suppose for at least being completely consistent.

[@6ixlxrd]

Shit, nothing against Japan or anything, but imagine how much worse it would be if they were the ones who adapted it. I swear Japanese can't make a live adaption to save their lives. I'd take Dragon Ball: Evolution over those two Attack on Titan movies any day. And don't even get me started on Death Note.

[@thepickygamer4450]

If you're going to disappoint, do it consistently. -Jesus

[@tubetubecommentor4795]

"I'm still gonna add sins for that"

[@cagneybillingsley2165]

the part where she stands up on the ledge at the end, the muted music is finale by danny elfman for batman 1989

[@MarkoGh]

When you said: "something that has never been explored before in the terminator, the matrix, ex machina..." actually Ghost in the Shell 1995 was actually the first one to come up with that concept and from there the matrix took inspiration even the director of the matrix when he was making the matrix showed his producer the ghost in the shell 1995 anime and said he wanted something like that

[@thepickygamer4450]

Time is irrelevant here.

[@AdamLacy228]

Did you forget he mentions Terminator, Blade Runner and Robocop, which were ALL from the 80's and early 90s?

[@s.y4580]

Adam Lacy The concepts of both those movies are different to ghost in the shell

[@MarkoGh]

@@s.y4580 true by there is inspiration. The scene where Neo and Trinity fight with all those guards in that hallway was heavily inspired by the last fight of Ghost in the Shell 1995

[@s.y4580]

XM I’m saying that terminator, blade runner and robocop are different to ghost in the shell, even though they came out in the 80’s and early 90’s. Other than that, i know the matrix took inspiration from ghost in the shell

[@jeanleon1637]

The thing I hate the most about this movie is its divergence from the original philosophy of the movie. Things like asking if what makes us human holds us back, and if that is a bad thing or not, being replaced for a movie that is mostly about "EVIL" coporations like every other dystopian piece of fiction is just not right.

[@pwnorbepwned]

Here is the actual worst part about the movie: everything you just described was supposed to be in it. Half an hour worth of scenes depicting the Major dealing with the philosophy of spirituality was cut from the movie, because they all involved her befriending a monk named Pazu. A Tibetan monk. China threw a hissy fit, and the movie bent to their cultural racism by cutting out all of those scenes. They had all been filmed. Tricky was Pazu’s actor. The star-power of this film would have been four-strong (Scarlett, Chin Han, Takeshi, and Tricky) with three of them being Asian, but instead we got three. So this movie did indeed suffer due to racism. Chinese racism.

[@EvilExcalibur]

@@pwnorbepwned actual worst is right. Goddamn that could've only helped with the dullness of it all

[@brandonbanks32278]

blame the screenwriters and directors.

[@domiasmoth]

@@pwnorbepwned You would think that a movie studio could do basic research about the markets that would make the most money

[@Awomanontheinternet]

What do you expect from the director who said he thought the original story had too much philosophy

[@TheFaithb420]

LMAO!! "The ads are all for cybernetic enhancements, how are people going to be reminded to drink a coke??"

[@kayefore7185]

The giant hologram ads were kind of copied from the original Blade Runner movie. And those ones DID have ads for coke. :)

[@actualmadscientist]

Faith B Best criticism of the film yet! I highly recommend looking up some real Japanese Coca-Cola advertisements, some of them are super bizarre but all of the ones I've seen are interesting.

[@rohmarts]

Faith B Hundreds of corporate marketing departments choose "we'll pass", imagine the shock and consternation at those board meetings.

[@starr555]

The moment that "i will find him" line came out of major. i knew there was going to be a taken reference. lol

[@Doomsword0]

It feels like this movie wanted to be be two or three different movies and it all got mixed together.

[@GTONeko]

It did. I've seen it, didn't hate it, but didn't love it. Just rent it or stream it to see for yourself.

[@pwnorbepwned]

Dan Walsh You're not wrong. The first villain himself was a mashup of three different GITS baddies. (Kuze, Laughing Man and Puppet Master.)

[@jrex3]

Overall the movie was good it isn't amazing but I really enjoyed it and would watch it again.

[@OmniscientWarrior]

Well, the Puppet Master was also the Laughing Man and the leader of Individual 11. At least, his motives and stories seem to paint him that way. The big problem was, the Puppet Master wasn't a bad guy, yes he hacked people to take advantage of the ghosts they had, but would not do anything to harm them or endanger them.

[@ServantofBaal]

Well... Puppet Master was actually the overmind construct of the Stand Alone Complex. Laughing Man got the ball rolling, but it became something much bigger than himself when everyone who felt oppression saw him as a hero and created a format to continue his legacy. And his character was more supposed to be a tragic hero fighting for justice for all the needless lives lost over the greed of corporations. His hacking was more of a self defense measure that he only used to censor or conceal his presence or deliver messages under circumstances that he himself could not be there for. Quite admirable, that he used his skills for hacking in an attempt to use a nonviolent approach to the solution

[@iangrey8436]

This movie looks like shit as compared to the Anime but looks pure gold as compared to other Anime movie Adaptations 😅😅

[@PyraJord]

Ian Grey PREACH THIS!

[@TeruteruBozusama]

Thingog apparently the Gintama movie is really good too! I hope the FullMetal Alchemist movie will be good..!

[@tetragrade]

Dragonball evolution looks way better than this.

[@austynwiles5414]

Ian Grey you haven't seen the Ruronin Kenshin movies have you?

[@nilasmp6907]

Watch Rurouni Kenshin triology. It is the best anime adaption.

[@alyssaanzalone8018]

Please do the Netflix live action "Death Note".

[@theghouldon891]

Alyssa Anzalone I haven't seen that yet, and I so fucking scared to watch it (but damn it.... I have to watch it)

[@alyssaanzalone8018]

I couldn't even finish it, it was so fucking bad.

[@percyperanamus7432]

the netflix white washed version was hella corny

[@percyperanamus7432]

pug wizard gaming you don't have a problem with white washing because it's an american movie ( about Japan ) so are you saying there are no asian people in america who could have played these roles?

[@percyperanamus7432]

So if you dont care about the race of the character you could argue then that it would be no problem to cast asians in asian roles

[@k1ngk4gl3]

I'll tell you what I couldn't stop paying attention to during this film: ScarJo's weird ass posture/walk.

[@MegumiHayashida]

The walk was mimicking robotic mannerism, well.. an attempt, at least.

[@darthbrooks4991]

She walks with her butt sticking out. I noticed that in "Under the Skin"

[@alexreilly6121]

That odd word right before walk is a very odd way to spell Posterior.

[@michaelellis772]

@@MegumiHayashida what? The original Motoko walked like a human, something about her being a cyborg and not a robot. She just has bad posture.

[@vampiraJ]

No hate on her, but this was a poor remake.

[@TF2Legacy]

An HOUR AND 15 MIN -- I mean ONE MINUTE AND 15 SECONDS OF LOGOS made me laugh my butt off

[@coopgaming1514]

bracket Scrap me too

[@DuffBeer2nd]

I just saw this movie today and for crying out loud, I thought of CinemaSins the second these logos started rolling in.

[@davidflores3279]

"when I saw Rupert Sanders was a part of this film, I was surprised, since by taking this job, there was no way of cheating on his wife with Kristen Stewart" that was savage

[@P1NKM4U5]

me to dude ! :D

[@MurasakiBunny]

Why is the lie detector connected to the internet? Hey, we live in a world TODAY where they're trying to force you to hook up your juicier to the internet or it won't run.

After the USB coffee machine (I shit you not), nothing surprises me.

[@kaitlyn__L]

and the pacemakers can be remotely controlled with no password but the manufacturers say, don't worry, people have to be near you first, like that precludes all malicious attacks that way? literally giving someone nearby a heart attack through a little wireless controller.

[@SFO14]

@The Laughing Rabbit IoT Your car can be connected to a network today.

[@ruben307]

a good lie detector would need connection to a database which means internet.

[@e1123581321345589144]

A good lie detector would connect to that database through a secured VPN. Just sayn...

[@seanieboi3100]

6:15 I agree. The original was much more interesting. Seeing the different versions of The Major's model and how built up everything was made you think about a few things like identity, etc.

[@mutesiimmaculatek8308]

"My programmer Liam Neeson told me so"... Deaad😂😂

[@nguyen3545]

Ah yes, the reference

[@kaseyrolow]

I read this comment as he said this lol nice!

[@nabahmadi5012]

😂😅

[@JackSilver1410]

The Major keeps referring to being "designed" and "built". I'll admit it's been a while and I committed the cardinal sin of watching the english dub, but I'm pretty sure she was still a human consciousness in a full prosthetic body. Why is she talking like an AI? *sin ping*

[@icannoteven]

yeah one of the best existential crisis scenes is her voicing her concerns about what becoming a "full-replacement" cyborg would mean. would she still be herself? "what makes me Me?" i hate this remake so damn much lol

[@Godzirra-San]

The anime version of this film was one the inspirations that lead to The Matrix... Damn I really wish they put more effort into this

[@Sorain1]

Because the idiots in the movie have the backstory that post wiping her memory they tell her she's an AI. They're an evil corporation willing to brainwash someone to put their brain in a killer robot body, but are for some reason unwilling to erase the records, destroy/buy out and change/ruin the apartment and eliminate the mother... because then the plot falls apart.

[@kaitlyn__L]

the 1995 anime movie also directly inspired the matrix!

[@caseyogden7105]

Darth Karnis because she doesn't think she's human

[@gyst8878]

This movie was dumbed down for the American Audience, and that's a fact. FUCK I was in the theater and someone actually thought this was a Marvel movie..smh.

[@chosenArchitec]

Gyst lol you actually went and watched it but much respect though 😁

[@xMetalhead2000]

Gyst why does Hollywood think movies need to be dumbed down for americans anyway

[@chosenArchitec]

American patriot R it was too deep in in thought zzzzz 😅

[@Daxank]

Because well... just look at America, honestly...

[@raven.8073]

Fuck yeah, America

[@BrowncoatGofAZ]

15:31 that was the point. She threw the consent lie back into Cutter’s face.

[@whitezombified]

I just hate how they beat you over the head with the plot OVER and over , hand holding you. Telling you who is who, what's going on , who's the bad guy, why this is important . OVER Explaining lines or metaphors. The original never did this , it knew it's viewers were functioning conscious adults lmfao

[@ShaneRimmerWorld]

They killed me right at the beginning when they felt like they had to explain the movie title: "Mira, your body was damaged. We couldn't save it. Only your brain survived. We made you a new body. A synthetic shell. But your mind, your soul, your "ghost," it's still in there." I half expected everyone to pause and look at the screen like a scene out of Austin Powers to make sure everyone was up to speed.

[@13th_hero]

Which is why I fell in love with anime at a young age... Akira, GITS, Ninja scroll .... Movies geared towards adults, but even a child could grasp the gist of... Akira took some revisiting as an adult... Lots of shit went over my head when that first came out.

[@Mareritt]

@@ShaneRimmerWorld I haven't watched Ghost in the Shell: Arise, but since this live action is based on that, do you know if they did this much hand holding in Arise?

[@klericajohnny3990]

Mareritt yes, bc the new views are all idiots

[@gtas321]

@@ShaneRimmerWorld Because the majority of people that will actually see the movie have not seen the anime???

[@hexerin]

Everything Wrong With Ghost in the Shell (2017): It is a raw cash grab riding the fame of a classic movie.

[@chriscorley6478]

Hexerin Null Wrong. Since fans were so unnecessarily hateful before the movie even released, it didn't grab enough cash to make an escalated action sequel.

[@dannovarius]

It was still an attempt at an easy cash grab from the studio. They failed at that too. Luckily. This kind of behaviour shouldn't go unpunished.

[@HuaEmpyrea]

Not even remotely so, it had many passionate people making the movie, it just suffered because of the dumbing down of the plot for cohesion to casual viewers

[@SageVallant]

Right, the major flaw of the movie is Remake Syndrome. Which sucks because the world itself is beautiful, the acting is mostly good, and the effects are flawless. The problem is the generic plot substituted for the thing that mattered the most about the original film; the plot, the story, the characters.

[@reesealva5295]

bee chang The Great Wall is actually a co-production with Chinese studios and Universal. Which Universal was down for since it could release it here with the star power of Matt Damon, but also they wouldn't have to worry about it not being allowed in China since co-productions are exempt of China's 34 revenue sharing imports limit.

[@thomasspeliers9602]

"you were not autorized to deep dive the geisha" - "yes I was ! I paid a 100 bucks" xD nice one

[@tog-gers]

Yea-aww

[@mee091000]

That had me rolling

[@gayleprobe4321]

Ghost in the Shell is my all-time favorite anime and this MOVIE JUST UGH GODDAMNIT ALL

[@RealILOVEPIE]

also all the movies you reference as it being derivative of are derivative of the original anime this movie is based on

[@shizukaryujoukai2465]

ILOVEPIE i know it's was really funny to me when he mentioned those like ghost in the shell ripped them off lol

[@ServantofBaal]

When you *don't* do your research..

[@Kaidantonio333]

ILOVEPIE ironic that this derivative of successful derivatives of a successful source is rubbish.

[@Comkill117]

It's sad because it feels like it was made based on those rather than the real Ghost In The Shell.

[@MichaelAarons1701]

Blade Runner is an adaptation of a 1968 novel and came out in 1982. So it actually isn't all of them #NotAll dammit! HASHTAG!!!! That said, visually between '89 manga, '95 animation, 2017 film the visual aesthetic is more pulling from the things made in between. The original and film seemed more Blade Runner while this film seems more Fifth Element. But that just leaves this an ugly, muddled, overly busy eyesore half the time.

[@Unknown-nn6hc]

Next video: Everything wrong with sharknado, in hopefully less than 50 years!

[@justincho7017]

Unknown The fact that the movie even exists is the biggest sin of all.

[@sandsjourney3170]

WHAT!!!!! I loved, absolutely loved Sharknado3. Sharks in space? Right up my alley! Hehehehehehehehe

[@NecronADM007]

There is nothing wrong with Sharknado, they made the perfect movie! I laughed and laughed and .... what? It was meant to be serious.... Oh!

[@_Muzolf]

As a friend of mine said it as we were leaving the cinema. "It was a reminder of a better movie." I should rewatch the originals.

[@GrizzlyTank]

"To officially become a sentient human, you must ingest a massive dose of LSD" You know, that's pretty accurate

[@Loopy_Kick]

12;44 If we can say one thing about this movie, it's that they made Aramaki a kick-a gunslinger. XD I think they should have based the movie on the animated series and got it as close to the show as possible. They can't touch a classic like the movie, but they could have possibly pulled off that cyber-punk Law and Order: SVU vibe.

[@rileyracies8624]

i saw the original 1995 version when i was very little with my dad, the part where she ripped off her arms fuck me up man.

[@obsidironpumicia4074]

yoyourcrazy _ Eh, it's just an arm. You have a spare one on the other side.

[@CTyler84]

Not in the '95 film, no. Both arms completely ruined.

[@jamesclark5132]

yoyourcrazy _ Same man. I watched this with my dad when I was little too. The arm ripping scene was pretty epic though for me.

[@OmniscientWarrior]

If that tank wasn't reinforced, she would have won that fight. That is how BA Major is. She can go hand to hand against a fucking tank and win. She almost did against a reinforced one.

[@Echowhiskeyone]

In the 95 film she was totally fucked up, no walking away from it.

[@ryannovakovic5046]

Every thing wrong with cinema wins

[@majoropaque7535]

I liked this video just for the line "Do fish even need advertising?" I hope there are more sins like that in the future.

[@tomwilde5778]

If you feel like you sin movies in the theaters imagine how this guy feels when hes just trying to watch a movie.

[@Juicytins]

I can't thank you enough for bringing out the major differences between the original and the live action remake. Makes so much sense to why the remake felt so weird when watching it

[@mathieuleader8601]

Did you know that Sony Pictures now have ownership of Funimation studios so we have alot more of subpar adaptations of anime for the cinema going public

[@PyraJord]

Mathieu Leader But this film was a FANTASTIC stepping stone to good adaptations. This film you have to admit was a much needed improvement from previous anime adaptations.

[@christopher961]

Ok one thing I need to correct you on: Funimation does not make anime. They just dub and add subtitles. Sony owning Funimation now has NOTHING to do with it. Because Funimation is an American company and the branch of Sony that bought Funimation is also American. American Companies are not IP Holders/owners of anime.... Now if Sony had say owned Madhouse or an actual anime studio like Gallop (aka Creators of Yugioh) , then your original post would make sense, because before something like a Live Action movie of Foreign Media can be made, the company that is going to produce the Live-Action movie has to go the the Original License Holder (whether it's a studio or person) of said IP and ask for permission to do this and that. Same went with Death Note, Netflix can't just go to Viz Media and ask to do this and that. They have to speak with Madhouse, and possibly even the Creator of Death Note, before any live action movie could be made.

[@christopher961]

Also, pissed off at Funimation for some of the bad subtitles for Shin Godzilla.

[@mathieuleader8601]

thank you for the corrections

[@mathieuleader8601]

if they had good people at the helm m

[@greta7163]

Forgot one sin - where was no Tachikoma. I was waiting all movie to see it

[@LinkinMark1994]

there were no Tachikomas or Fuchikomas in the original either

[@greta7163]

But Kuze also wasn't in original

[@thatoneguy-7387]

Not like the movie actually had "Kuze" in it either

[@RidleeFox]

The "original" wasn't even the original. The Manga, which the original anime movie was based off, had Tachikoma and was more like Stand Alone than the anime movie....or this one.

[@blorgin1]

aww damn really.. i haven't seen it yet

[@moonlightwarriorgaming743]

Hey, Jeremy, is the director Kong: Skull Island still having a hissy fit.

[@annienunyabiz6627]

Yep. Three days and counting.

[@mucsdnop]

Sadly this is the only reason I checked the comments section.

[@LaddRusso91]

Kaleb Cranor what happened?

[@Holret]

Skull Island was freaking brutal. At least it had originality..

[@moonlightwarriorgaming743]

@LaddRusso91 The Director of Skull Island is waging war on CinemaSins for one of their most videos.

[@lordatheist2621]

When u do the emoji movie: 1) 1000 sins bcuz it exists 2) Bonus round sin *1000 every time an emoji appears

[@nzixlpaybackforarthurrap6978]

osmen whitaker Bonus Round 2: x3 for every second of the Movie

[@lordatheist2621]

nzixl lol true

[@connorbutler6727]

+100,000,000,000 sins for no B emoji

[@nzixlpaybackforarthurrap6978]

1,000,000 Subscribers with 0 Videos no

[@no_4259]

3) 100,000 sins every time there is a product placement lol

[@MisterPrince01]

"Discount Tropic Thunder Jack Black." I died.

[@wildman2012]

All the CGI in the world can't save a dull story line.

[@6abial]

Kuze's voice is so fucking cool

[@skazwolfman8622]

My first thought was, "So, Professor Hawking is The Puppetmaster?"

[@genuineentertainment2016]

it was cool. i loved his voice too. all broken and stuff. hahah

[@ROBLOXGamingDavid]

5:13 "You know, for a story that's supposedly set in Japan, there's VERY little Japanning happening" Hong Kong: Am I a joke to you?

[@西光寺るみ-o7y]

BTSいつまでもうだうだうるさい!あえるときがきたらそれが答え!今わ!うるさい!

[@jdvr3891]

Pretty much expected this film to take a dump on the original. Thank you for confirming so I don't have to waste 2 hours of my life to watch it. Cinemasins providing an important public service :)

[@patar3323]

It's so weird how they got rid of cyberizing, was such a cool creepy concept in the anime. And how do they explain thought comms and Major uploading her consciousness if they aren't cyberized? Just technology I guess lol

[@somedudewithanappleonhisfa6819]

This movie was quite disappointing. It took everything from the original that was good, threw it out, and tried to be original and failed in the process. Check out Nerdwriter1's video about how to not make a remake. Its fucking awesome.

[@danzansandeev6033]

THANK YOU!

[@chriscorley6478]

Some dude with an apple on his face Wrong. It gives you way more origin story, than what's in the anime. Nerdwriter only has a one-sided generic 1:1 adaptation opinion, as the live-action is a beginning story -- gracefully setting up a second chapter sequel.

[@danzansandeev6033]

Chris Corley what origin story? You mean that origin story which was only implemented cause they wanted to explain why Japanese girl look like Scarlett? Cmon Original movie didn't have that kind of origin story and it's still way better movie

[@Panzerjager2344]

danzan mokoto is not japanese, she is a construct. the character is based in japan but herself not native. her shell is ambiguous

[@pyrobandit]

Danzan Sandeev b

[@Mr_Tza]

I was in this film as a featured extra. I played three different characters and you can spot me in a scene (yay). Thing is 2 of the three scenes I was in were cut from this film and I think that is the problem with this film is the studio cut the shit out of it as Jeremy rightly said to dumb it down. This could have been soooo much cooler and having met Rupert Sanders the guy was really cool, not arrogant and very approachable (bear in mind I was just a lowly extra though he still took the time to chat with me about a shot I was in which I found rare, his willingness to talk to a pleb like myself, I mean the conversation did start with me telling him that the shot was f&*king amazing, but still we chatted for a few minutes, very rare for big shot directors). Anyway, my point it, like David Arye on Suicide Squad, I feel for Mr Sanders as I could see the love he had for what he was making, I saw some of his vision, then I saw this pile of shit and I knew the the studio would have cut the f*&k out of it. I wouldn't judge the director on this, I would however tell the studio to fuck the fuck off, stop dumbing down movies and allow the audience to think for themselves, movies aren't tv where we a constantly reminded of shit, movie are there to challenge and make people think, studios don't like people thinking. Anyway, thats my little rant, cue the haters and people to flame me for whatever reason.

[@mikepuppetz9]

You need to do an EWW Kings of Summer. Jordan Vogt-Roberts is pretty much asking for it at this point...

[@jerrygodeep4787]

Phil Michaels then they should do his short film lol

[@squidgybuffalo]

I mean the thing with Major is she is a mass production android body (this is true in all GitS media), of course she won't look like herself. It's a rough movie and very shallow but they did at least consider some of these things

[@thesfactor2544]

Don't mind me. I'm just using my magic to find the legendary Clorox bleach. Still no sign of him on youtube for the last few weeks.

[@briciolaa]

oh hell no

[@marcelgardner8497]

Stephen Strange He might be in a time loop somewhere. You know how tricky those incantations can be.

[@crofregernish4695]

Stephen Strange I saw him a couple days ago on a makeup video.

[@thesfactor2544]

I've been tracking him for weeks. Searched in every youtube channel he likes to watch; and still no sign of him.

[@britbloc123]

+Stephen Strange Lol i admire your dedication to hunting him down. I think he frequents Rekt Feminist Videos occasionally, I'll give him a heads up that you're closing in!

[@magicmulder]

6:30 It‘s pretty common to understand a language without being able to speak it fluently (for me with Italian and Dutch), so not a sin. Also both may be wearing Star Trek style translator devices that translate into their language whatever the other guy says.

[@TraceBerlin]

11:00 I was so happy to see this scene, cause i really thougt there will be the epic dialogue/monologue like in the original....but then....well...chit-chat :( It was such an important scene in the original.

[@JamesonTylerBynum]

I really don’t understand why people complained so much about “white washing”. She literally looks EXACTLY like the anime character this was based on. And the Japanese loved the movie. Being as Ghost In The Shell CAME from there, I think their opinion of it holds a hell of a lot more weight then we do 🤷🏻‍♂️

[@junioraltamontent.7582]

Yeah it's a shame. I'm normally not one to complain about "cancel culture" but this movie was one of the first to really suffer a disproportionate response from the internet. Most of the angry mob on Twitter hadn't seen the movie, or even the original.

[@boisycopelandjr]

She looks nothing like that character at all, plus they should have got a Japanese woman to play.

[@StratosphereTHAI]

"this movie suppose to locate in Japan" *Internationale Commerce center locate in Hong Kong appear in the background* lol, k

[@arielfetters5662]

Actually, it IS supposed to take place in Japan. It's being in the movie is what's wrong. Of course the entire movie is wrong so it's just another turd on the pile of bullshit pretending to be GITS.

[@xelaalexloki]

Have you ever watched the 1995 ver or other works of GITS? Its being in the movie is nothing wrong.

[@YukyDoodle]

The designs of those places in the anime ARE inspired by Hong Kong. It's basically just a Hong Kong town in future Japan, like Chinatowns in the U.S..

[@hectorsoy]

And the unmistakable Bank of China Tower in Central, Hong Kong also clearly seen! What a farce this movie is!

[@ArchdukeSpook]

so the company trying to fill Majors head with fake memories and erase her actual identity are supposed to make her robot body look exactly like her original one? Doesn't it make more sense that they would change as much as possible to distance her from her true self?

[@luizfelipevbf5567]

Joel Marxhausen it would, but we when logic was part of this?

[@SuperMerlin100]

The creators are the ones who actually made the decision. They were aware of what it would look like.

[@michaelramsey82]

Seriously? Not one reference to the Black Widow hallway scene from Iron Man 2?

[@annienunyabiz6627]

Thought I was the only one that thought it was a frame-for-frame remake of the Iron Man 2 hallway bit.

[@MissChinBK99]

I wish I'd thought this through Ikr, and here I thought that was in Avengers 1 lol

[@MrTaxMan666]

Yeah... lol

[@Cyprienroche]

Iron Man 2 is the one and only movie in the Marvel cinematic universe (Avengers 1&2 and all the individual movies) that I haven"t watched for some reasons, I heard it was total shit but I also heard that Sam Rockwell was the villain and I love this actor; especially when he play a villain, so should I watch this tonight, or not bother with it? I wasn't a big fan a Iron Man 3 (the villain was kinda cool I guess) and I enjoyed the first one, just clearly not as much as the majority. Thanks in advance for your advice

[@michaelramsey82]

I'd say go ahead and watch it. It's a lot like most of the other Marvel movies. I'd say it's better than Iron Man 3, and certainly has some great scenes, but the plot doesn't fit together quite as tightly as Iron Man 1. Yes, Sam Rockwell is in it - not as the main supervillain, but as the evil corporate guy who ends up working for the supervillain. It's far from his best role, but he does a decent job. The best part of the movie is definitely Black Widow's action scenes, and I'd say it's worth watching for that alone, but it's also a fairly decent Marvel movie. It's a bit underrated, honestly - it's not a perfect movie but it's far from the worst in the MCU.

[@izzysimmons9269]

The Matrix, Robocop, AI, Ex Machina. Where influenced by the original ghost in the shell. Not the other way around.

[@patrickquick1762]

AI was based on a book that came out in 1969 and the original Robocop came out in 1987, two years before the manga that the anime was based on. The Matrix was definitely inspired by Ghost in the Shell but it and all of the others borrowed heavily from the works of Isaac Asimov such as the collection of short stories called I, Robot which came out in the 50’s. Sorry, lol, I’m a big sci-fi nerd and I enjoy talking about this stuff 🤷‍♂️😂

[@steelman296]

I loved the fact that originally you didn't know if the major was truly Male or Female as she was under classified information due to the nature of the department she was asigned to plus the experiment of full cybernetic augmentation. I felt the reason why the Major preferred the female body was no would suspect a woman to do the things she does, lighter and more agile than any male form and finally the creator was nothing but a naughty person who loved the female form.

[@kitty-xf9ku]

Last time I was this early the floor was still the goddamn floor

[@nunyabiznasty8914]

hmmm yes the floor here is definitely made of floor

[@Yerick157083]

I like how he gives it a sin for being like the matrix when the matrix was inspired by the ghost in the Shell lol

[@askaliu2943]

how does she create so much force to brake the window = .=? you do realise she is full cyborg right? an no, batou has a dog in his apartment, we get to see him interact with the dog a couple times in the new series

[@jake38ful]

Now it's time to wait for Rupert Sanders to have a meltdown on twitter.

[@emberdrops3892]

Ok you can dislike the story and characters as much as you want but the aesthetics and general visuals were absolutely phenomenal.

[@xoxardnekoxo]

I'm surprised there's not a video for Everything Wrong with Baywatch. :D Waiting for that, and still waiting for Everything Wrong with Fifty Shades Darker. :D

[@nyctoshade6302]

That "3 movies in a blender with pop rocks and a diet coke" joke was on fucking POINT! Hurt my gut to laugh!

[@tbmadpotato]

Do everything wrong with Diary of a Wimpy Kid to cheer us up about the new one please

[@victorj1415]

What's good in blockbusters today ?

[@divorcegaming2881]

nothing is wrong about it

[@lkc7253]

When are they gonna roast the Sir Patrick Stewart out of The Emoji Movie?

[@SWFG2341]

Toucan Once it comes out on DVD, so that they can actually do it.

[@paulcoddington664]

I've heard that everything about the Emoji movie is crap, except for Patrick Stewart.

[@mbruso42]

Toucan that would require making someone watch the emoji movie

[@WhumpusPlumpus]

Paul Coddington TECHNICALLY he's crap. He's a literal piece of crap

[@jimb.7523]

Whumpus P. Mcgrumpus The irony, since he's the only thing about that movie that isn't shitty.

[@subjectdelta4758]

"Thanks batman!" 😂😂

[@DaLHunt44]

I searched "Ghost In The Shell ANIME", and the most of the videos are about this film. That shows how much you love this film. Digit tells.

[@Saiaxs]

This, Attack on Titan, Fullmetal Alchemist and Death Note are all testaments to why anime doesn't work in Live action. Dragonball Evolution too

[@Alphasnowbordergirl]

Sad thing is, Death Note and even Full Metal could be done live action if done right and given the proper treatment. Especially Death Note, yet it never works.

[@wlthomas67]

Another version of "Martha."; " Why did you say that name"

[@potterfandf]

I notice that your thumbnail has rounded corners. Nice.

[@ns6438]

potterfandf Huh... Thanks for pointing that out. That's really cool.

[@pyroparagon8945]

potterfandf it looks awful with dark themes

[@DagobertX2]

Maybe CinemaSins trying not to be that edgy. Eeeeyyy :)

[@JustinTotino]

What is the significance of the rounded edges?

[@elg6197]

Justin Totino It's new. New is always better. So bow down to this new better artpiece.

[@lautlos3]

I honestly never understood the people calling whitewashing. The major always looked caucasian. In the manga, the movies, SAC, everywhere. There is so much valid criticism you can give this movie, but whitewashing is NOT part of that.

[@snek9353]

Motoko's "look" is purposefully generic. But the character is very much Japanese. The Motoko character is very nationalistic and ethnocentric.

[@lautlos3]

@@snek9353 I've watched pretty much all there is to watch from GITS several times and I never got those vibes from her.

[@snek9353]

@@lautlos3 The easiest thing you can do to see it is watch Solid State Society, have you seen that one? The ENTIRE premise of Solid State Society is ethnocentric and pro-Japanese. It's about the declining Japanese birth rates, family structure, and the drain from the elderly in Japanese society. Spoiler below ............ The "villain" in Solid State is stealing Japanese children from abusive families who are unlikely to give the children a future to raise them by the state as perfect Japanese citizens. Then also stealing the savings of childless elderly to support them and reduce their drain on Japan. This is being done to save the Japanese culture and race. In the end though this villain is Motoko herself, her alter ego created out of her desires.

[@snek9353]

@@lautlos3 The second easiest thing to do is watch the Japanese versions. The US/English versions have a lot of the anti-west pro-japan dialog removed. Then realize she's very much a statist, she's a soldier for Japan, always fought for Japan, and has always worked for the Japanese government. All of the stuff about the "American empire" "article 9 issue" "Japanese constitution" Much of this is about Japan's loss in WWII and the results. It's about the resentment that Japan is a vassal state to the US and frankly still occupied. Japan is very ethnocentric, non-Japanese can not be full citizens in Japan. The refugee issue in 2nd gig is a very real thing in Japan.

[@snek9353]

Motoko's look is generic because Motoko is a pragmatist who realizes a generic but attractive appearance serves her needs. It has nothing to do with her race. This is covered in many places in the Manga and SAC.

[@Hiraghm]

"Y'know, for a story that's supposedly set in Japan, there's VERY little Japanning happening..." Exactly how is Japan supposed to look in a technological future? I guess you're right, the cities in this movie look so much more like Rock Island, Illinois than they do Tokyo...

[@RockSolitude]

Idk, like Japan? With Japanese writing? And civil planning? And things? And people?

[@nhokonhokopuala]

Everyone that bothered to watch this movie are unaware how beautiful the anime version is, I know I broke a sin, but that's the absolute truth. I feel your pain brother...

[@glencoconut]

why does this videos thumbnail have rounded corners but all other sins videos have pointed corners. did they think no one would notice? because i noticed and now its bothering me

[@ArinJager1]

because they did it to bother YOU, specifically, because you're sooo important -_-

[@wingsandash]

Seeing the utter greatness that is Takeshi Kitano here is like a stab through the heart.

[@pandasiah5264]

BTW any of you thinking "why didn't they get an Asian actress to play Major to be more culturally accurate?" Even in the original manga and anime, the android her consciousness is in is supposed to resemble a more European person. Dunno if anyone asked that but thought I'd just share that

[@BrianRrrrr]

15:49 it's doge!!

[@isselasantina3773]

nicely spotted :)

[@MemberBerry-cu9qi]

shiba inu

[@nocwopezbekenstien1797]

Doge is dead

[@TheHordeQ]

People bitching about the whitewashing obviously know nothing about the original writer of the manga. She's supposed to be americanized... ffs. Still going on 2 years later.

[@TheHordeQ]

Whitewashing can certainly be an issue in film. My main problem is when people jump on the bandwagon of one particular part that isn't the problem, they take away from the validity and strength of the real issues.

[@ulysisxtr]

Too little sins... pump those numbers, kid!

[@moonmun]

After watching the anime version just a few hours ago... Watching this finally... Boy the live action is painful.

[@dhruvashishchongder686]

15:49 is that doge in the background?!!?!

[@isselasantina3773]

yep, I'm kinda getting the hang of distinguishing the Shiba inu (read: Doge) from the Akita (e.g. Hachiko the dog who waited for his master every day on the train station) (^-^)

[@jaimecarter7847]

IT IS!

[@GL-ky9ot]

Obliterator 101 Tim

[@Villeful]

Went to the cinema to see this with a friend. It's the only movie I have ever walked out of before. There were 16 people in the cinema at the beginning. I left after just over an hour (inc. adverts and trailers) and there were 7 people left when I went.

[@Godzirra-San]

this is why I don't pay for movies anymore... Well that and basic plots that really don't entertain anyone with half a brain

[@chest250]

or just watch it online

[@percyperanamus7432]

especially when they disrespect the source material this badly im all for pirating movies

[@hooligan9794]

Salana Salamone Art Did you feel the same when Idris Elba was cast as Heimdall?

[@percyperanamus7432]

Hool Igan Didn't watch any Thor movies, have no opinion on it

[@jaredweiman2987]

This is a bad take tbh. Nitpicking the minor details is irrelevant when the movie has several major issues; like throwing out the entire philosophy behind GitS.

[@edwardcm9175]

if they'd just followed the anime movie to the teeth, would've been perfect

[@julian1127]

Then people would have said it was an unoriginal copy, people just dont know what they want.

[@steelphoenixindustries2949]

I agree, it also would have made a shitton more money.

[@WickedFireBird69]

First off I love cinemasins, I find them hilarious! That being said, how do you feel about the fact the director of Kong is pissed at you?

[@CthulhuChow]

Really? LOL.

[@kayefore7185]

Really? Link, please? Sounds a fun read! :)

[@ashantisimons2369]

Kaye Fore same

[@CTyler84]

Holy crap! He just goes on and on for ages too! That is the most embarrassing butt hurt ever.

[@CTyler84]

googleitfor.me/?q=Jordan+Vogt-Roberts+cinemasins

[@starswater]

Seeing this hurt me a lot more than I thought it would, and here I thought I might one day give this remake a chance. This makes me realize this remake is much worse than I imagined even after having had a lot of the changes described to me prior. I'm going to go rewatch the original again and pretend this never happened.

[@Iwantamansonguitar]

"Discount Tropic Thunder Jack Black", I had to take a break after laughing this hard. :D

[@trashrat9740]

You’re in a desert walking along in the sand when all of the sudden you look down, and you see a tortoise, it’s crawling toward you. You reach down, you flip the tortoise over on it's back. The tortoise lays on it's back, it's belly baking in the hot sun, beating it's legs trying to turn it'self over, but it can’t, not without your help. But you’re not helping. Why is that?

[@trashrat9740]

Blade runner america is more Japanese than this film

[@philbertchow5425]

We are not programmed to be cruel.

[@decaf4450]

Her strength didn't really come out of nowhere, in the water fight scene she kicked him several feet and she's built to be a soldier, is super strength _that_ unexpected?

[@Goldenxbih]

MAJOR IS NEVER MEANT TO LOSE HER COOL LIKE EVER

[@cliffordcostley9798]

Major was not her name. It was her military rank. Watch the entire anime series and you will find that this movie has very few ties with it. Pity, sort of like what happened to, Tomb Raider. The original first and second movies that is. The third had little to do with anything.

[@shaneedmundson7506]

One of my all time favorite quotes: "Its like this movie put Blade Runner, The Fifth Element, and Attack of the Clones in blender, added Pop Rocks and Diet Coke, smashed it with a baseball bat then f*kd it*" LMAO!

[@patrickm5217]

I dont understand why people dont like this movie Its one of the best live action adaptations I've seen. Some just like to complain I guess

[@leandergihr9598]

I would put it this way. I would probably like this movie if I did not saw the original. But I like to add a few things. The first 10 ish min are awesome. The assassination, the intervination from the Major and so on. But I was off put by her human appears and unessecary sexuallisation of the Major. EX machina did a great job with beeing esthetic and dehumanize her at the same time. And for god sake. What's with the fish?!? But the movie itself is visual appealing and tries something different. If I want something like the original I watch the original. Right?

[@MegumiHayashida]

"Thanks, Batman" Ahahahhaha I knew it

[@Alondro77]

If Scarjo and Keanu Reeves had a kid, would it be the Meh Emoji? ;]

[@Freeman_Actual]

11:05 almost snorted my drink up my nose at your joke here... lololol

[@klaudiagandziarowska2884]

MY PROGRAMMER LIAM NEESON SAID SO IM GAGGING

[@JohnJohnson-jj6rh]

Major was "white" in both the Manga and original Anime... why the continued outrage over this? Hell, the original author blessed off on ScarJo's casting...

[@ssrobs2552]

Because people need a purpose, and in modern western society that takes the form of fighting for a "cause". That cause being fighting against racism. And when no racism exists, it must be manufactured. The question here is, why are so many people so stupid and lazy to not see this and find a real purpose? It's not as though real racism is non existent entirely, or there aren't other things that need to be fixed.

[@Paulafan5]

Because googling it takes 0.03 seconds and journalists are either too stupid or too agenda driven to do their homework.

[@mykemech]

Exactly. The original was based on Carey Ann Moss's character in the Matrix

[@Spiritcr1jsher]

@@mykemech no it wasn't....

[@mykemech]

@@Spiritcr1jsher the major in the original movie was. Directly from the director's mouth in the extras on the dvd

[@francish.1630]

fucking died at 2:33

[@pwnorbepwned]

Francis H. I'm going to refer to Jack Black in Tropic Thunder as "discount pre-Sec9 Batou" from now on.

[@iz723]

lol

[@francish.1630]

pwnorbepwned not that part but the next one is what i meant lol

[@65MaX73]

The best part of the video imo

[@doubledoubleusmokymirror4d405]

Arsène Lupin yeah awww.... 😁😑

[@aztn19]

6:10-6:19 is the PERFECT sin to describe how I felt watching this film!