Everything Wrong With Mr. Peabody & Sherman in 19 Minutes or Less

[@KC-zi7pw]

"Sherman, i've got to get you out of here before you touch yourself" deserved a sin off and I will die on this hill

[@Owltownmilk]

yea

[@Dragonlord13]

I will stand with you brotha

[@Releaselightning]

I’ll be on the hill with you

[@Orsonster]

I am standing with you as well.

[@Owltownmilk]

i will also die on this hill

[@BatmanFan76]

In my opinion, this movie is very underrated. Granted, it has two cast members from Modern Family, but it still has Patrick Warburton. So, I still count this as an underrated gem.

[@TeardownDestruction-bm8wo]

I forgot this movie even existed until I saw this video

[@LastGoatKnight]

I agree

[@SpeedwagonZaidan]

What's your beef with Modern Family?

[@MrGabeanator]

As do I

[@bengilhooly3616]

@@SpeedwagonZaidani think they’re implying that some people might not consider it underrated as it has two cast members of modern family and would therefore be more known. But they still consider it underrated

[@joyunicycle]

Forgot this sin: So the principal takes pictures of Penny's bite marks and sad face, but neglects to take pictures of Sherman's neck, which she nearly strangled, or ask the dozens of witnesses in the lunchroom.

[@travissmith2848]

What? The girl is always the victim and boys can never be such. Unless they are trans one direction or the other. Isn't that what all this feminism stuff has been building towards?

[@SleepyLuigi]

That should be included.

[@jzombie1744]

Dont expect this channel to actually consider good reasons to sin half the time, it's a 50/50

[@Luna_who]

I am the 666 person to like this! :D

[@poweroffriendship2.0]

- _DOWN WITH THE QUEEN!_ - _DOWN WITH THE MONARCH!_ - _Wait! What kind of cake?_ (Punches) The third peasant gets down with the cake is personal. No wonder why he ordered a knuckle sandwich instead.

[@Bacteriaboi29]

Ok,btw I’m pretty sure it’s monarchy

[@TheSheep1]

“ *WAIT!* does the queen have that gyatt?” “Man, shut your bitch a-“

[@thetapperhatz_laboratories2574]

WAIT! Does the queen have that gyatt? (I’m not a 5 year old brainrotten child, I just have a sister who watches a ton of that crap)

[@MinionFan15]

@@thetapperhatz_laboratories2574 shit!!

[@TenshiTheAngel]

@@thetapperhatz_laboratories2574 i mean im not either, it just shows up on my fyp

[@furretthefuzzynoodle3896]

I love the whole “no I’m extremely poor” bit

[@Jonathan_Collins]

Interesting to note: Jay Ward's daughter Tiffany Ward made sure her father's work would be done as closely to the original source material, so she served as consultant to this film.

[@motherplayer]

You know, it's funny how I personally feel that this indeed gets Peabody and Sherman, and at the same time, don't think it's a very good film? Maybe it's because it's better for their handful moments rather than a big theatrical showcase, which they rectified with a better show afterward.

[@ThatCoalSoul]

Quiet you (neeerrrrd)!

[@josebrown5961]

That was nice. If they had made it 15 years earlier…

[@NicoAnimation]

She didn't do a very good job consulting, in that case.

[@TheAllSeeingEye2468]

This movie takes time travel and just beats it to death. God knows how many paradoxes this dog created just because he wanted to educate his son

[@jonathanmarkoff4469]

In the original series, it is explained that the WABAC is a should-have-been machine that goes to ridiculous cartoonish versions of the past, not the actual past. Peabody programmed a self enforcing safeguard against alteration.

[@shadowflame8647]

😂😂😂

[@joshbobst1629]

Lol

[@cooldude2794]

womp womp

[@monsterberger7728]

Because doing time travel with accurate paradoxes would be a giant pain in the ass to write around so they decided not to because its a kids movie and why would you so that in a kids movie. It also adds nothing to the plot.

[@sinosthefox8523]

15:03 Being foolish enough to believe that Mr. Peabody is dead rather that knowing he will ex machina himself from this, because he is in fact a main character.

[@silvrnightingale]

I have quite a few sins for you, Jeremy. 1. Sinning this movie. 2. Peabody waited until bedtime to ask Sherman his side because as a dog of high intelligence, he knows better than to ask a child questions when they're still heated, so he gave him time and space to calm down, like the good parent the movie is trying to show Peabody is. 3. There are no security measures on the W.A.B.A.C. because Sherman is a well-behaved kid. Peabody has no reason to not trust Sherman when it comes to the machine. 4. They had multiple people jump out of the horse with only 1 knocking on the door because they are in the middle of a war. Going out to do anything remotely risky (like knocking on your enemy's door) requires backup. They are soldiers. They know that they have to watch each other's backs. 5. Penny was smiling at Sherman when he wiped Tut off the window because Tut creeps her out. That smile is an appreciative one. Also, seeing as Tut is completely fine at the end of the movie, that only makes Sherman an attempted murderer. 6. This might come as a shock, but people know what George Washington looks like. His face is on the American quarter! Did you skip high school history class or something? How have you gone your entire life never seeing a picture or painting of the first president!? Can't wait to see Birdman's thoughts on this video.

[@FanaticMitchell1]

Yes

[@szabok1999]

This might come as a shock, but CinemaSins is a comedy channel and isn't meant to be taken seriously. They intentionally over criticise and nitpick movies, that's their thing.

[@alphabloodpaw3233]

I don't think they care because this channelmisnt keant to be taken seriously at all

[@swr.nezumi]

@@szabok1999 hasn't jeremy said at least once he puts genuine opinions in the sins

[@redthefoxisWritingUpAStorm]

​@@swr.nezumi Not all of them obviously.

[@Rembreiker_lychec9257]

The fact that a dog has a human for a child is a great and wonderful story. It's good thing that I was eating macaroni and cheese while watching this reaction with you Tim.

[@thefoxyfox6508]

I also happen to be currently eating Mac and cheese.

[@emilyriesett8086]

@@thefoxyfox6508 me too

[@CrêpesSuzette-u8b]

whos tim

[@karencarter18042]

The disapproving look is cause Sherman is de-nile-ing his feelings.

[@Ath3nx_2]

pun lover stamp of approval

[@carsonmurr322-2]

This movie was so good idc what anyone says

[@dominoxbelovaxv177]

So much nostalgia. 2014 was amazing

[@Theloneclone]

I really like this movie

[@joshuaquinones9760]

Fr, it was my first movie too

[@andrewmangano3618]

Not a more real statement here

[@rasberrylemonad_]

real honestly it just gives me so much childhood nostalgia, i watched it sooo many times when i was 6-7. this videos funny but also kinda being too hard on it lol, like yeah youre not enjoying it, youre not the target audience

[@christianparrish3292]

The cut off when you said pretty woman made me chuckle.

[@Marvelfanatic3658]

Cringe asf. .

[@1000Master]

Thanks, guys. I had almost forgotten about this movie completely.

[@Joey-fm1jh]

17:46 Bill didn’t even time travel He just showed up

[@TaitLawrence-xl2xb]

I think that might be Bill Clinton

[@Fathimir]

​@@TaitLawrence-xl2xbThe demographic that found this movie even remotely watchable would say "nah, Bill Clinton didn't wear stovepipe hats."

[@EpicMomentMaker]

Hiding cake under a skirt was s tier😂😂

[@EpicMomentMaker]

No way I got a heart🫡 thx bruh

[@davedixon2167]

more like "A" tier amirite *rimshot*

[@d00mbr07]

NO ONE SAID THAT THERED BE MATH!!!!

[@tinkerstar6522]

How

[@trayvondixon9661]

W manz

[@MarvelousKing-gu5vt]

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

[@osirisjojo6876]

@@MarvelousKing-gu5vt No. *DING*

[@Baklavann]

There wasn't a "Sphinx + sphincter = Sphinxter" joke? I probably shouldn't be disappointed, yet I am.

[@ZokariVirek21]

"Go watch Bluey, you monsters" Best advice ever on KZbin

[@locomotivetrainstation6053]

0:11 not even one second on the timer and you already screed up

[@happyaccidents523]

Screwed*

[@gunier.j.kintgenanimations]

3:29 Lest we forget the original show this is based on was called "Peabody's *Improbable* History".

[@swurrytwo]

That makes me kinda sad peabody's improbable history is so iconic

[@brentenjs550]

No sin for the fact that they’re all there in the future but seem unfazed by it and each other?

[@pokevonforretress3761]

I’m pretty sure that “present day” thing just means the date that the movie came out.

[@szabok1999]

I'm pretty sure you don't understand very basic jokes.

[@wood5241]

@@szabok1999 Thats not just very basic joke, its called very basic lame ass attempt of a joke. If that even giggled your ass to consider it basic joke then youre 10.

[@wegotthechoccies]

I grew up as a closeted trans boy. Sherman was my actual transition goals and I can say for certain I now do look like him. I love this film so much.

[@Yeepfunnymoments]

Bro switched teams💀

[@TheShowblox]

bruh

[@eileenbutterfly7856]

Ok, is it just me, or does anyone else understand that "present day," is supposed to mean the point in time that Mr. Peabody & Sherman as characters inhabit when they're not time traveling. With the clues I've been given, I'm inclined to say that point is sometime in the early-mid 2010s.

[@randallbesch2424]

Whenever you see the movie is Present Time.

[@eileenbutterfly7856]

@@randallbesch2424 I'm just saying that when Jeremy took Present Day to mean 2024, a lot of the other dates found in the movie stopped making sense with how literally he took Present Day to mean his present.

[@spektacles1927]

​@eileenbutterfly7856 That is the whole point of the joke, calling out the stupidity of putting "present-day" knowing how it ages like milk as the media gets older, whereas if they just stated the year of release which for this movie was actually 2014 btw, then that problem wouldn't exist

[@lleeoo110]

the Mr Peabody Sherman 42 Wallaby Way, Sydney, Australia bit got me hahahahahah

[@gooberDoesStuff-idk]

“SHERMAN, I GOTTA GET YOU OUT OF HERE BEFORE YOU TOUCH YOURSELF-“ Best fucking line in the movie

[@theonecalledtate]

“Don’t tase me bro.” Was probably the funniest part of the movie I feel like it was in the trailer still has me dying 😂

[@shuttittuppitt9355]

I _own_ the movie (& I even made/edited a subtitles file for it), so I can _confirm_ that "Don't tase me, bro" IS what he says in the movie. & I'm not confusing the movie's line with the trailer's line, because I've never watched the trailer even once.

[@Alsarnia]

I like the "Why do they think George Washington could change the law at a whim like this" as if 90% of the American population wouldn't kiss the ground he walks on

[@leoc.7514]

15:46 Missed opporunity that you didn't use Archer's "Hey, phrasing !".

[@menzel17]

Pretty much every time travel movie always mentions how you shouldn't change the past, including this one. Meanwhile, Mr. pissbody casually interferes with multiple historic events and wonders why all that bs falls from the sky later on.

[@ZGlove.]

Mr. Pissbody and Shitman

[@LivingFire_BurningFlame]

The history teachers should use this movie to make the history class and subject more interesting. More students will learn faster if the subject is interesting.

[@RealMikeWazowski]

Funny enough that happened to me

[@tamas9554]

They'd probably pull out their hair by watching the first 10 minutes lmao

[@JaynaeMarieXIV]

If you think this made history interesting, wait until you see Oversimplified History videos.

[@zsoren42]

May I introduce you to the channel Oversimplified on KZbin

[@reedwrichardson437]

lol my 6th grade history teacher actually showed this in class near the end of that year

[@klimmr]

6:28 Except, the movie was released in 2014. Which means Sherman is 8 or 9 years old.

[@PrincessAcornHair]

Starting primary school at 8 or 9 years old

[@szabok1999]

That... Was a joke dude... You actually take CinemaSins seriously?

[@alphabloodpaw3233]

Almost like it was joke

[@Dimondwill]

⁠@@alphabloodpaw3233almost like this movie wasn’t meant to have this happen to it

[@Groggle7141]

5:06 Well, she treated him like a dog, so it’s related. 6:53 Well Sherman and Penny aren’t literal babies, they can be left in a room without supervision 13:40 It’s almost like the Trojan war was discovered to be a real event by archeologists, oh wait

[@szabok1999]

It's so fun to see how dumbdumbs get offended when they sin their beloved movies, completely missing the fact that this is a comedy channel...

[@Cookie_Monster369]

He finally did, we finally got the count for Mr.Peabooty and Seamen 🫛🛥️

[@cutiebetutie]

bro

[@xian2themax]

12:33 aren’t you a Star Trek fan? Time travel IS a natural result of fast enough motion

[@cmdraftbrn]

yeah but you usually have to fling yourself around a star or vomit chroniton particles or whatever mcguffin the script calls for

[@ViewerOnline101]

Missed Sin: The plot forgets that there should be another alternate Penny still in Ancient Egypt since the Sherman and Peabody who were supposed to go back and get her merged with their other selves, meaning she was just left there.

[@TheShowblox]

One of the most underrated films ever. This movie is a masterpiece.

[@JamieAubrey]

That Finding Nemo P Sherman joke was *chef kiss*

[@sinosthefox8523]

4:14 We interrupt Mr. Peabody and Sherman to bring you the rivalry between Nate Wright and Gina Hemphill-Toms.

[@LucyAdroit]

Right xD

[@Joey-fm1jh]

Best comment right here

[@androidsenpai1462]

LMAOOO

[@DragonSythee]

The " " was great 😂

[@MollyOKami]

° Forgotten Sin: Marie Antrionnette is NEVER recorded as being the "princess" who said, "Let them eat cake," AND it's not CAKE. the food from the quote is BRIOCHE, a fancy bread that included butter & eggs, something not common for the French peasantry. ° You should get your groceries in person. Boxed items are okay to have delivered, but fresh produce & meats should be inspected to get the freshest possible, you don't want damaged dairy containers, & you also don't want to have to pay for cracked eggs.

[@randallbesch2424]

And she probably never said it anyway.

[@legonicktnt]

That newspaper of Peabody adopting Sherman said it was 2006 when it was published, and Sharman is said to be 7 1/2 in the movie, so that means the events of the movie are set in 2013

[@SSHale21]

Ooooh I’ve been waiting for this one.

[@thomasmcdade1004]

I forgot all about this movie!! I remember my Grandmother taking me and my older brother to see this movie back in April 2014, and later that year in November 2014, me and my older brother saw it again with our Mom😂😂

[@Ella_Eats_Nutella]

IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS FOR YEARS! THANK YOU JEREMY!!!!

[@Professor_Toothpaste]

1:57 I can't tell you how hard I laughed when he said that! I am a hardcore Doctor Who fan! 🤣

[@barnhunter5263]

The rice Krispies joke in the yellow text at the bottom is hilarious (it starts at 7:48)

[@duckboi92221]

“Stop everything, CinemaSins made a video on my favorite animated movie!”

[@randallbesch2424]

Every movie is imperfect and therefor sinable.

[@duckboi92221]

@@randallbesch2424 True. But one of the main reasons I love it so much is because of that.

[@jackaylward-williams9064]

You never miss an opportunity to make a Doctor Who joke, and yet you still only sin one episode of the show per year, whilst going through every other show that you cover on TVsins episode-by-episode.

[@normaperez3084]

About time they reviewed this underrated gem.

[@AniGamerNX]

One of my favorite movies from DreamWorks. An underrated movie in my opinion.

[@PussInBootsTheLastWishFan2003]

Agreed

[@jeffymischevious]

you forgot about the fact that they somehow escaped a black hole which only things that can travel over THE SPEED OF LIGHT can escape, but somehow at the end of the movie when sherman and mr peabody are traveling to the future, it shows how fast sherman is going, its not even CLOSE to the speed of light, and this is apparently the fastest they've ever gone-

[@Kulkogo]

I’m happy to know I’m one of the 5 people who originally knew where the Beethoven Breakdancing meme comes from

[@TheWarmachine375]

All the time traveling and bringing everyone from historical events into the present is one massive Timey-Wimey Ball of Mayhem!

[@Intergalactic-v5z]

My brother… it’s a kids movie. It’s fiction. It doesn’t need to be realistic.

[@RyanMcKennaGosling]

One of my favourite underrated animated films to exist. Thanks for covering it, this movie needs more recognition it deserves!

[@josebrown5961]

It had the opportunity to be seen by everyone and they didn’t go to see it. This film and Speed Racer had the same problem, they were made too late. The time for a Peabody film was at least 10-15 years before when this film came out.

[@RyanMcKennaGosling]

@@josebrown5961 I saw it with my dad on the 2nd week it came out. Yeah I agree, it was overshadowed by 300: Rise of an Empire and Divergent when it came out.

[@ephemerald5]

10:14 i never understood this even as a kid. penny has been nothing but rude to you sherman what do you mean you have a crush on her 😭😭

[@LemonSaber]

Dude how did you not remove a sin for the cake and Beethoven ddr jokes?

[@OftenGuy]

Love how he's 10 YEARS late watching to this underrated movie 😂

[@CalliopePony]

The biggest problem with this movie was that it took itself way too seriously. The cartoons it was based on were unapologetically absurd and ridiculous, which was what gave them their charm. If it had just been a series of wacky adventures in different time periods played for pure comedy it would have been fine. But it bogged itself down by adding high stakes and personal drama.

[@randallbesch2424]

I thought it necessary for it being a movie instead of a 12 minute episode.

[@CalliopePony]

@@randallbesch2424 It could have done something like Mel Brooks' History of the World: Part 1. It could have just been a string of comedic skits and adventures spread across different time periods with no need for high-stakes overarching drama.

[@foxgod232]

Something to note: if the Ancient Egypt part of the movie were more realistic, King Tut wouldn't look as handsome as he's shown to be. He would have a few deformities and a misshapen foot, making him use a cane at all times to get around, he would also have a prominent overbite and he would've married a woman named Ankhesenamun, not Penny. Fun fact: the young kings name "Tut" is short for Tutankhaten, which means "Living Image of Amun". Amun was an important religious figure in Ancient Egypt.

[@LoganReuter-c2l]

First of all, we don’t know if the Trojan horse was really a myth or not. Second of all, Marie Antoinette saying “let them eat cake” was (certainly) a myth. You should’ve included that one in the list.

[@lylamcguinness1646]

AHH YESSS!!!! I’ve been waiting for this video for the LONGEST TIMEE!! A childhood favourite of mine 🥹❤️

[@dawildmegalolo_playsvods4471]

"Go watch Bluey you monsters" 😂

[@TheShowblox]

The only complaint I have for this movie is mainly the lighting. The animation itself is pretty good, but in some scenes the lighting lllls like it wasn’t even added.

[@ButterFromDiscord]

Why are you the one teaching me that the Trojan horse was not real

[@randallbesch2424]

Why are you questioning it that way?

[@GamerFunOriginallyAarush]

I remember watching this as a kid and really loving it!

[@KeilaGelsi]

6:26 Does this guy think the movie came out today? Edit: 14:42 Omg he does

[@randallbesch2424]

He would argue it said present day and he's going with it.

[@KeilaGelsi]

@@randallbesch2424 that would be such a Jeremy thing to do

[@ZCisCool]

I remember watching Sherman and Peabody the cartoon as a kid and the time rules in the movie KILLED ME (my poor poor sci fi brain 😢)

[@brunozeigerts6379]

Outtake for the flying scene: Gilligan, you can't fly, it's impossible! (not sure how many know who Gilligan is nowadays)

[@JoshuaR.Collins]

i do lol

[@randallbesch2424]

When Pippi was told that flying on a broom is impossible she simply replied, "I can because I believe I can."

[@xxtigersharkxx0203]

Been waiting for this FOREVER!!! Thank you cinema sins 😊

[@3lm3r83]

3:16 my friend and I watched this movie years ago and I paused it at this moment and said… “that’s not possible, a manhole cover can’t fall into a manhole” and he said, “yes it can” and we fight about it to this day (he’s a professional gaslighter)

[@Catguysofheaven]

8:37 I think I have that painting in my house

[@Ethanol_jackson]

Same, my dad recreated it

[@Shome2049]

One of the best animated movies ever made. They don't make them like they used to.

[@RyneMcKinney]

I just saw this movie as it's free on youtube right now. I saw a very underrated masterpiece

[@imjerm]

this movie is unsinable. -infinite sins

[@chiefflamehead6626]

You missed that the green light is not an arrow. Mr. Peabody cuts traffic off on a left hand turn. 😂

[@samdemel4126]

12:16 the answer to the question is 69

[@Luffytoro123]

I guess I missed something cause my math concluded in this: 53+16 / 20x21 = 69.8 69.8^-5,318,008 = 0

[@samdemel4126]

@@Luffytoro123 I just used ChatGPT

[@comit8077]

The 5318008 is b00bies upside down idk the significance of the rest

[@Luffytoro123]

@@comit8077 Me neither oh well

[@samdemel4126]

@@comit8077 double joke

[@Ropoid]

Never have i clicked on a video faster in my LIFE

[@Bukem453]

This movie is so underrated

[@immortal-iz5wh]

"No-one should smile. Ever." *gets a smile from me.*

[@tskmaster3837]

Oh right, this movie happened. I could never figure out why myself but here we are.

[@J.TiberiusKirk]

Homer Simpson: "Look at that! I'm the first non-Brazilian person to travel backwards through time."

[@BlueDog241]

13:00 Is this referencing Peter sinking after being able to walk on the water towards Jesus? Because he didn't start sinking because he was told he couldn't do it. Peter started sinking because he himself started losing faith.

[@jordanbeggs2400]

I think this reference works pretty well because Peter loses faith and takes his eyes off of Jesus. When he has faith, he is able to walk on the water, but when he looks away, he is reminded that he should not be able to walk on the water as the fear of the dangerous waters takes over. Regardless, I appreciate the reference! Didn't expect a video on Peabody and Sherman to reference Matthew 14.

[@gentryfields553]

I can already tell th3birdman is gonna have a field day with sin 43 Present day, isn’t whatever day your watching the movie, It’s the day of the movies original release, which was 2014. It makes perfect sense that Sherman would be in elementary school because he would be 8.

[@KCz01]

its funny that I watched the movie this morning, now its getting sinned

[@RUGER5264]

I’m honestly surprised CinemaSins didn’t cover this 9 years ago. Nice vid and movie tho.

[@alexmapp5444]

I used to love this movie when I was younger!

[@LandonEmma]

I’m glad to see this movie getting more recognition

[@sgt.railgungaming1793]

I cant believe he's not done this yet

[@Arthur.Dent_]

Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy mentioned 🚨

[@LooneyNuke]

6:22 you realize the movie came out in 2014 right? That would mean Sherman is 8 in this movie.

[@MrH.09]

Well the date said "present day" so he would have no idea what year it was

[@Dimondwill]

Yeah he probably did realize because he was joking

[@MisterG2323]

I had forgotten this movie almost minutes after watching it, and now you go and remind me why. Great.

[@amitaikatz5929]

If you don't think a dog adopting a boy is possible, why don't you ask Romulus and Remus, Jeremy.

[@kalebsgametimeyt]

I want to say that the reason why it say “present day” not give a year is because its supposed to be vague just like how in the hunger games they only vaguely say in the future so that it is always in the future distopion and so that in this movie its always im the present day (also with the newspaper saying 2006 its just impressive that the designers care enough to put that much detail)

[@reedwrichardson437]

4:39 what do you mean? I think they portrayed U.S. school lunch pretty accurately

[@LzrdLckr9000]

1 hour ago??? On one of my favorite movies growing up??? Today is a good day

[@ExquisiteAndroid]

SMELL MY VICTORY, SMEEELLL ITT!

[@memedood]

This was uploading on Free Slurpee Day

[@pringles3333]

FREE SLUPREE DAYY🗣️🗣️🗣️