Everything Wrong With Mulan In Mushu Minutes

With the new live-action Mulan approaching soon--er... indefinitely delayed... um... we thought we'd go looking for sins in the original animated Mulan. And while this movie is charming as hell, we still found some!
Next week: comic hijinks sins and ninja sins.
Remember, no movie is without sin! Which movie's sins should we expose next?!
•CinemaSins website: www.cinemasins.com •
•Channels•
--TVSins: / @tvsins
--MVS: / @musicvideosins
•Members get MORE! ALL videos early, bonus videos and podcasts, merch discounts and MORE on Patreon!• / cinemasins
•Merch!• teespring.com/stores/cinemasins
•Podcasts•
-SinCast A weekly chat with Jeremy, Chris and Barrett about their love and hatred for movies and entertainment. cinemasins.libsyn.com/
--Behind the Sins: CinemaSins writers Aaron, Jonathan and Deneé, give a behind the scenes look at what it takes to release the previous week's videos across the CinemaSins brand. redcircle.com/shows/behindthe...
•Writers Social•
Jeremy: / cinemasins
Chris: / sincastcinemasins
Barrett: / musicvideosins
Aaron: / aarondicer
Jonathan: / samloomis13
Deneé / deneesays
•Discord: Request on Facebook or Reddit!
•Reddit: / cinemasins
•Jeremy's Book: cinemasins.com/book
#CinemaSins
#EverythingWrongWith
#Mulan

[@ranacroak9156]

When they sing a girl worth fighting for they are thinking romantically, but the song stops when they find a new girl worth fighting for. A small, helpless child. That’s who they’re fighting for.

[@cgphotoandfilm]

*bruh*

[@Sam-gx5hb]

Dude I don't need these feels

[@MulinaTheAngelWolf]

Hi I didn’t need these feels

[@KORDELYA]

Omg you right! So wholesome🥺

[@vcraig2141]

@jpc1918 It would have been better if they weren't driving some artificial "men are shallow" message with the song though. But I mean the whole movie is based on feminism so it couldn't be helped. It would've just been better if they hadn't made the movie a Mulan movie because it would have made so much more sense set in an actual sexist location like Victorian England. This is why the movie bombed so hard in China. People were confused why their folk hero was suddenly championing feminism and why their culture was represented as sexist to the umpteenth degree out of nowhere.

[@cristinamorales2679]

The song “a girl worth fighting for” abruptly ends when they see the doll from the little girl who was murdered. She now becomes the girl they’re fighting for.

[@eeiity8600]

fucking shit good catch, was it intentional by Disney?

[@lg6075]

It's also the last song in the film symbolising that the realities of war have sunk in for the soldiers.

[@cronastar1172]

Dang, never saw it like that, good catch.

[@TheMeta141]

probably the most jarring scene change Disney's ever made, singing and happy to desolation and death

[@cintronproductions9430]

OMG, that was so dark and depressing.

[@AlexIsModded]

Ya know what's hilarious? This movie is more realistic and grounded than the live action version.

[@Han_Niche]

It also isn't a soul less Disney cashgrab

[@elizabethp.7354]

@@Han_Niche didn’t grab much cash :P

[@Hiya8partyz]

mystery person Exactly. It’s wonderful that they made practically no money from it.

[@beethovensfidelio]

Or that a G RATED CARTOON has more violence and blood than a PG-13 live-action film.

[@lugoorstar]

@@beethovensfidelio and it doesn't have shapeshifting witches that use the basics of existence as powers

[@christianhafer9819]

A sin off for Eddie Murphy's voice over performance, no? He was almost as good as in Shrek.

[@marrenby]

Christian Hafer “Ok! Dishonor! Dishonor on you! Dishonor on your cow!”

[@christianhafer9819]

@@marrenby He was good.

[@marrenby]

Christian Hafer Yes, he was!!!

[@desbugfan8429]

Oh. My. God. How did I not notice they were the same person?!

[@johnholloway7168]

Me llp

[@raeallen2708]

Sin for not showing “dishonor on you, dishonor on your cow” 😂

[@trainfan4449]

It would have been a sin off for sure.

[@davincent98]

Indeed. Dishonor on Jeremy, dishonor on his cow...

[@matthewguidera]

This should have been the sentence for the sins.

[@kage1061]

Yeah that was a CinemaSin for sure. *Ding!*

[@kathryndavis9116]

Raé actually I would say 100 sins for that, it’s the best part of the movie!

[@crimsonmaverick8237]

I feel he should’ve taken off a sin for the ending scene with Mulan and her father. After she commits treachery of the highest degree for her family, Mulan comes back and begs for her fathers forgiveness. She gives him stuff; stuff that she thinks will earn her his love; but then he just pushes it aside and embraces her. That is such a powerful scene and it should’ve been recognized.

[@DeO316]

Came here to say exactly this!

[@ourkeving]

More of trying to please your parents sin.

[@KillItWithFire2]

I felt the same thing. Like those are some pretty big deal gifts she brought back. The crest of the emperor and the sword of a general who almost assassinated the Emperor, those two items alone would bring a tremendous amount of status to the Fa family, and Fa Zhou tosses them aside like so much trash. That scene always hits me so hard.

[@PANDASANDRO]

Do you wanna stay for dinner? Hirny grandma Do you wanna stay forever

[@maycake4504]

👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽

[@basiliskboy17]

Periods can actually halt if a woman's body is put under physical stress, usually athletic. Professional athletes feel hardly any if any effects at all from their periods. It's not unreasonable to assume that, since she went through such an extreme training regiment, Mulan's period has temporarily halted.

[@DecemberSfy]

Yes, especially when under severe conditions of malnourishment!

[@existentialrookie5432]

This is so true! A woman may skip period for months, sometimes due to severe physical stress. I have experienced this back in college when I skipped for 3 months

[@nairadoctor9040]

@Zara Nora More like it will halt while you stay in extreme stress and come back when ur life gets normal. It's mostly so u don't loose all imp survival nutrients in the form of period blood I think..

[@indigothecat]

I did not know this, I knew about the malnourishment period halting bit, but not the physical stress. I wonder if a secondary description could be symptoms of PCOS, which can cause periods to be extremely irregular and infrequent as well (without medication that is).

[@blackwolf899]

Thats why, even in agony, doctors urge females to be physically active during periods. Which sucks when you’re appendix burst and you started your period two days before your birthday. Ah good times.

[@IdaSantti]

"This eagle isn't saving all the heroes right now." That's because it's a falcon.

[@probablyjoe_]

UhMm AcTuAlLy ItS a FaLcOn

[@Necromancer0225]

Lmao

[@stmsin]

Another person watching these videos just waiting to make one shitty nitpick. Dude, the videos are not serious. Not meant to be taken serious in any way

[@IdaSantti]

@@stmsin I think you need to loosen up a bit. Cinemasins have made their fame on nitpicking and I can't make one joke about their video?

[@stmsin]

@@IdaSantti you already did

[@Kitten_queeen]

Can’t believe you didn’t bring up “dishonor on your cow” lto emphasize how FAT the horse is 😱

[@JDMHaze]

McKayla Russell lmaooooo😭🤣🤣😂😂😂😂

[@magpie0_026]

No. THICCCC

[@FDBSHAE]

I see no horse, just Mulan's humble steed; Cow.

[@ashleydowney1222]

I always wondered as a kid why he kept calling the horse a cow. The movie came out when I was six and I remember asking my mom why he called it a cow. She quickly told me it was the horse was black and white like a cow. It was until I was a little bit older that I realized why he said that.

[@erickchristensen746]

Why are we here Woth a capital DAMN

[@mynameisnotthathardtospell8199]

I’ve never heard anyone talk about how *thicc* a horse is before. And in that much detail

[@MCLegoboy]

Watch out for bronies then.

[@ix3755]

*hol up*

[@cap3423]

Where have u been all month😂

[@sasir2013]

hello! brony representative here! would you like to know about thicc horses and thicc genitalia?

[@aydanangus]

Look out for donut media then. #buffhourses.

[@anthonynguyen5204]

Sinning a bunch of reflections during “When will my reflection show...” while leaving out the “...who I really am inside?” is the most sinful shit I can imagine.

[@cheyblake2475]

I guess he's quick to say something before actually watching what happens next. Don't know

[@LP-ct9nk]

^^ lol that’s the whole channel. I only watch the vids now to see how badly he ignores stuff

[@amityislandchum]

I miss when this channel actually sinned real plot holes in movies. Now it's just a desperate attempt at humor, full of really shitty jokes written by dumb people who can't even follow the plot of a fucking kids' movie.

[@sharkshakes]

nope he misgendered Ping the whole time@@cheyblake2475

[@letstalk5845]

“ That horse is THICC with a capital DAMN” I couldn’t stop laughing

[@AndrewAce.]

Not removing a sin for _Make a Man Out of You?_ Now that's a sin...

[@unknownwill4th549]

Cmon cinema sins has to get down to buisness

[@yassjun4309]

gamerslayer89 boi to defeat our favorite childhood movies

[@101bajan]

I came looking for this comment

[@unviewsyourmonster8113]

ehud kotegaro Its a good sexism song though lmao

[@AndrewAce.]

@ehud kotegaro "It normalizes sexism" - That's why everyone loves it 🤣

[@nyxcelina219]

"This is sexist!" "That is sexist" and how else is the movie supposed to address sexist ideals without first presenting them?

[@ladyvincenza]

Yeah. I realize Cinema Sins guy is kidding, but presenting characters as sexist doesn't mean the movie itself is. To me, it illustrates what Mulan is going up against. PS This is my favorite movie!

[@tomahawktrouble-streamsvid6885]

You do realise the entire movie literaly sterotype men as disgusting ravonous beasts right? I mean sexism can be applied to both genders, not just the minority.

[@vicefandonna1575]

@@tomahawktrouble-streamsvid6885 I get what you're trying to say (sexism is gender neutral not specifically for ladies) but you can't really call us the minority when we literally account for 51% of the population. You know technically we outnumber you right?

[@gbdeck200]

This Honestly one of his worst sins vid this time

[@D-S-G.]

And this my friends Is the future of warfare

[@guacamolegoddess1342]

Something I realized a little while ago is- Mulan doesn’t sing after she sees the village destroyed by war.

[@naragrace3870]

Guacamole Goddess nice profile pic

[@Dark_Mishra]

After that moment the movie drops the full on comedy aspect to take a more serious tone, so there’s nowhere else to fit in another song. Most comedy movies do this.

[@gingechicken7394]

The last words are also "a girl worth fighting for" and then they see the doll laying on the ground. A popular theory is that the dead owner of that doll is now the girl they're fighting for.

[@fanpet3912]

Yes, because the tone of the movie completely shifted. They've all seen how serious this war is, and the movie becomes more serious as a result, It's very clever.

[@dindjarin1023]

This is so much deeper than the new remake

[@jds7665]

you criticize jokes and songs for being sexist when it was the whole point that hey're sexist and that they need to change

[@assassinnoir1015]

Yea but it’s sexist towards men too and that is not addressed

[@themagicalonionfairy7455]

yeah but the last part of the movie just like says fuck the moral since mulan literally just quits everything and goes back to being culturally appropriate the songs i do not know why he sinned though

[@ArtisticallySpoken]

Huh, it's almost as if this isn't a serious review and more so for laughs?

[@TenshinhanIsKing]

Lol still taking CS seriously in 2020 You must be brain dead

[@MirrenTheDragonKnight]

@@themagicalonionfairy7455 Oh no, how dare a character (if female) want to go back to their peaceful life instead of a high-stress job, even though they had just been involve in, saw the horrors of, and WON a bloody war! I bet you also think it is sexist that Eowyn retired after seeing the horrors of war as well. Never mind that both her and Mulan accomplished something great that would define them in history.

[@inessa8332]

cinemasins always: *sins logos* also cinemasins: *makes new longer intro for their channel*

[@trethestar]

Hey if marvel can get away with it why can't these boi's.

[@dj__projects]

At least it was less than 20 Seconds.

[@madisonowlgirl2002]

8 seconds of logos

[@madisonowlgirl2002]

Ding

[@rayhairston7582]

I hope that was a one time thing

[@NewEnglandModz]

The new intro is no doubt better, but I don't like change, damn it! And that's a sin for me. Ding.

[@myshoesarenowfullofwater]

New England Modz would be great at cinema sins

[@tommerker8063]

everything SPOILERS!!! wrong duh with.

[@UrMumsFavoriteBoyToy]

New England Modz How was this commented 14 hours ago when the video was posted 3 minutes ago? This makes no sense damn it! That’s 11 sins *ding*!

[@plushblueep]

I like it. (Respect the kid behind the first ever ‘Roll credits’ compilation’s opinion)

[@neflufv6392]

My KZbin says you wrote this 14 hours ago😂

[@vlogswithgavin6371]

Mulan: *shows a field of corpses, an entire army getting murdered, and a girl bathing twise* Disney: yup sounds like PG material.

[@beethovensfidelio]

Actually Disney’s “Mulan” is rated G!

[@faith6455]

Well, that’s probably because it was made before the ratings became more strict.

[@beethovensfidelio]

@@faith6455 Yep, nowadays PG stands for “Practically G”, and G stands for “Goo goo gah gah 👶🏻”.

[@ussinussinongawd516]

bathing isn't innapropriate and children should understand war and hardship. it's not horror

[@user-pi3hd2bt3f]

Disney's like "its completly fine as long as theres no blood"

[@chevon1920]

I’m fine with all of the sins except the last one. They didn’t understand her motivation, it had nothing to do with girl power or proving anything to society. She went to war to protect her father and her family so why would she take a post with the emperor and be away from them, 🤷🏿‍♀️

[@christmastiger]

It was also historically accurate to the Ballad of Mulan, where the same thing happens.

[@TheNomad94]

@@hithere2972 An opinion backed by fact. These "sins" are bullshit.

[@Crawlingdreams418]

that's what happens when ppl like jeremy don't do their research. otherwise he would've been aware of it

[@dixiecronin7791]

Didn't she tell Mushu that the main reason she joined the army was so that when she looks in the mirror, she'd see someone worthwhile? I think Jeremy's comment is still valid

[@BlueberryWizard]

@@dixiecronin7791 can people not have multiple reasons for doing a thing? and no one thing is usually a "main" reason, they all add themselves up to be "the reason".

[@mitchelvanwijk]

Not at least one sin off for that moment where Mulan's dad puts the sword and medallion aside to hug his daughter? Bruh.

[@treehugger0241]

Or for "No matter how the wind blows the mountain cannot bow to it?"

[@CLDJ227]

Yep, I was thinking the same thing about both these comments. 😅😅😅😅

[@infinitylies7365]

No sin for when that other ‘dress up ladie’ disappears behind Mulan never to be seen again?

[@howtokdj1498]

No sin-off for casting F*cking Eddy Murphy as the voice of Mushu!??

[@Jake-kt7ws]

No sin for how she should have sliced her hand holding that fucking sword?

[@robjef622]

CinemaSins: *_Hates long intros with a fiery passion._* Also CinemaSins: *_Creates a new longer intro for their videos._* *_"You have become the very thing you swore to destroy."_*

[@bluelandyaandgreenlandya1788]

That's because they hate themselves with a fiery passion

[@remyjones9146]

Also sinned the shortest Disney logo thus far

[@SovereignStatesman]

More like CinemaSins: Hates long intros with a fiery passion. Also CinemaSins: BITCHES about Disney intro being too SHORT.

[@ajiramana]

They lived long enough to see themselves become the villains.

[@cameronmorgan2347]

@@SovereignStatesman that's generally a clear sign that it's a joke

[@blobbertmcblob4888]

Wait until Jeremy here sees the Live-action insult that Disney did and he'll think this version of Mulan is pure gold.

[@muffinman5741]

The one good thing the live action remakes did. They make the old ones look even better and give them timeless cult status.

[@brendankearney3929]

The main thing about "Girl Worth Fighting For" is that they start the song talking about women as objects or servants, but then they find the doll. And with that doll they really do find A girl worth fighting for

[@harleenquinzel2058]

“This horse is thick with a capital damn” ruined me 😅

[@obliviousidiot.]

*thicc

[@clarietta]

Definitely catchy hahaha

[@konaaukai5541]

This killed me too lol xD

[@rmzing]

I think that sentence will go down in CinemaSins history.

[@bl6973]

Amy Mulder Damn *T h i c c c*

[@Eternaldark866]

Legitimately pissed that you didn't take a sin off for the emperor's absolutely devastating line "No matter how much the wind howls, the mountain will never bow to it." Straight up told Shan Yu to sit on it and spin man.

[@ElysiaWhitemoonOmega]

but what about erosion?

[@therealMrA]

@@ElysiaWhitemoonOmega The line is actually "The mountain *cannot* bow to it" which has a different meaning. The line is cool but y'all want CinemaSins to take a sin off for literally everything.

[@ElysiaWhitemoonOmega]

@@therealMrA interesting. nahh, i want them to sin for stupid and silly stuff, like having 15 candles in a bedroom, not things that is kinda noithing wrong with, like the old days

[@therealMrA]

@@ElysiaWhitemoonOmega Sorry didn't mean you with the last bit.

[@ElysiaWhitemoonOmega]

@@therealMrA dont worry, i do still ment what i said, in the older days cinemasins was more fun, with less picky and more weird stuff sinned

[@orchdork775]

10:55 Why didn't you sin Mushu for not breathing fire to to cook the dumpling? He's literally a dragon 😂

[@unapologeticallyava]

CinemaSins: Mushu is a GOD Everybody Else: We all already knew that

[@jessicanatali6837]

This may be weird but for the “period” bit a lot of women’s periods just straight up don’t show up if they’re over-exercising or in a lot of stress and well...I think those both apply to Mulan. Fun fact of the day!

[@AmPhilH3O]

Yeah, she was clearly exerting her body far more than she was accustomed to. So it makes sense to me that her period would stop.

[@NutmegBGB]

It also wouldn't surprise me that Mulan and the rest of the troops are malnourished. During this time period, famine was ridiculously common, and it makes sense that rations would be cut to deal with said famine.

[@violetsnowfield]

Agree with that, overstress and physical strain can delay period for even months

[@oliviafrancis1926]

Plus the malnutrition

[@thecoffeeshopat2am173]

You learn a new thing every day.

[@brogrammerplus7683]

“This horse is THICC with a capital DAMN” -CinemaSins/Jeremy

[@rat4527]

His name is Jeremy

[@waitaminute-113]

Damn. Just damn.

[@deathsheir2035]

I've seen fatter...

[@rat4527]

@@deathsheir2035 o god

[@horatio1316]

Have you seen that horse's legs. It should snap with the weight of that body.

[@renjoku3771]

Can we mention how the emperor just casually walked away from Shan Yu after Shang came to his rescue? Shang and Shan Yu: *duking it out* The Emperor: I’m gonna go make a sandwich.

[@cheyblake2475]

Yeah, he brave. Doesn't care one bit!

[@jeweld.282]

"now she's just going to go back home and conform to societal expectations" ... OR she's going home because she left to go to war without telling her family and they've been worried sick about her and she wants them to see she's alright? Ever think of that? Also, there'd be nothing bad or sexist about Mulan deciding she wants to get married and be a mother instead of a soldier. It's sexist if that's her only option. As long as she has choices, whatever a woman chooses to do is ultimately empowering.

[@musgodness]

That said, she could have accepted the job of an official and better the conditions and honor of her family as it's leader, but she instead chose to live under her father and later under the hunk whose name I can't remember.

[@sirhillarybillary]

The fact that you didn't laugh at (and in fact skipped over to sin) "dishonor on you, dishonor on your cow..." makes feel that your life has been utterly robbed of joy over the years.

[@CHmLgN]

It has. I realized that as soon as I watched the Bad Boys II video. Not to be any sort of way, I'm sure he's great, but recently he's coming off like a grumpy douche.

[@OlEgSaS32]

you are correct

[@UncleJimmi_ID]

Pretty much my favourite line of any Disney movie ever

[@JosephClayson]

I thought he would remove a sin for how hilarious and iconic that joke is.

[@TheAverageMetalPoser]

More like udderly robbed amirite?

[@neflufv6392]

So you took a sin off for the WHINIEST character but NOT for I’ll make a man out of you?

[@denee557]

Yeeep! Some level of trolling is part of the job.

[@almogdov]

That song is worth 50 sins removed!

[@Captaincory1]

He sins the song because sexism

[@fishlee4370]

"This horse is THICC with a capital DAMN!" I wheezed so hard at this.

[@emmapritchett6898]

I was searching for this comment

[@Ekolop]

I did like that Mulan chose her family at the end. They were the reason she started all this and the reason she ended it. She is good at it but her goal was not to be that. She wanted to prove herself and her worth, she found it and it's not about the status but her self love. I loved that message, it's about who you are not your job.

[@silentkat99]

"I should have prayed to the ancestors for luck" and you didn't say grandma wouldn't be excellent at cinemasins for saying "how lucky can they be, they're dead"??? That's a sin. Ding.

[@SofosProject]

Well considering that only one of them died at a young age, seems plenty lucky to me.

[@isaacgleeth3609]

@@SofosProject They're still DEAD! If they were so lucky, they would still be alive after finding the secret of immortality.

[@peacesignlover02]

That's what I'm saying! And he also didn't take a sin off for "dishonor on you, dishonor on your cow". He didn't even show it! (can you tell that I like this movie?)

[@handsomest1]

Ghostberry calm your tits weirdo

[@SofosProject]

@@isaacgleeth3609 Lady Luck doth not be excessively generous. XD

[@neflufv6392]

Mulan has the highest kill count of any Disney character. We stan her Edit: a lot of people have said that this isn’t true but if you google it Disney says it’s canon. She was also the first Disney princess to kill people on screen so I will continue to stan Omg guys I’m here to specify that I am not counting inanimate objects, starwars OR marvel characters and I am aware she is not a princess but she is often lumped in with them

[@TH3F4LC0Nx]

Does she really? Because she causes an avalanche and buries the Huns, but then it turns out they're apparently immune to such shit, so I think the only person she actually kills is the leader guy at the end.

[@silkevanleeuwen]

@@TH3F4LC0Nx only a few of the huns survived the avalanche, did you see how many huns there were before the avalanche? Definitely a high kill count lol

[@derekredden8785]

Actually she doesn't lol 😂😂

[@justsomerainboweyedguy5989]

No dinasuer does

[@jacquietimms3075]

Well yeah, that goes without saying...

[@itriggerpeople4433]

8:42 Speaking of which.... WHEN IS HUNCHBACK COMING? I'm expecting most sins to go to those damn annoying gargoyles.

[@emilydaniel2735]

Can we all please acknowledge the fact that the real life Mulan was a legit badass and by the time they found out she was a girl they didn’t care because she was already a highly decorated war general and was glorified even more

[@mandysmiles5222]

Ok, but the 10 sins for Shang straight up ignoring Mulan when she said the Huns were in the city was deserved

[@Crawlingdreams418]

Not really. She committed a criminal offense which is why she was rendered worthless. Don't apply present day morals to times when empires were still a thing

[@jayreid2513]

@@Crawlingdreams418 Fair. Shang could have acknowledged the warning at least before brushing her off, or ignore her then still act on the warning Mulan was a criminal, but she still tried to save the emperor, not by acting on it at first but by telling someone who can

[@TenshinhanIsKing]

@@Crawlingdreams418 lmao

[@khaotictrash]

@@Crawlingdreams418 She still saved all of them though, and why would she lie about some of them surviving?

[@Crawlingdreams418]

@@khaotictrash true, but considering how patriarchal and legally strict that country was during the day, this is no surprise.

[@tbefilms]

bRUH. How did you NOT give a sin back for the line: "The greatest gift and honor is having you for a daughter." COME ON. It's easily one of the most satisfying endings to a Disney movie!

[@fairystail1]

i always hated that line it's like 'yeah dude she embarasses you and you glare her down saying she brings dishonour to you and your family she then saves China and suddenly being her parent is an honour again well fuck you'

[@therealMrA]

That's a line you'd find on a Hallmark greeting card. This movie is written well but not at that moment.

[@diablorises]

fairystail1 exactly, it just reinforces the old adage that you have to do something great in order to receive your parents praise and love. It is honestly the worst thing about this movie.

[@fairystail1]

@@diablorises also I just realized she didn't have to fight in the war. In I'll make a man out of you shes told to go home. She saved her dad from the war, at the time she is weak and cant fight. Why didn't she just go home

[@tbefilms]

Well dang! I do see these points about the line being cheesy/way overdue. I always heard this line as an apology from the dad. Also for me, the line means something extra special bc my mom would say it to me on my birthday and at graduations. Here's the Ted Talk you didn't ask for to explain why I love the line so damn much. And I'm serious: I wrote way too much. I'm an English teacher/BA holder sooo pls ignore the following if you're uninterested: *This line is something her father has believed all along, and he says it at the end to atone for what he said in anger to her before he left.* In the original poem, the "Ballad of Mulan," she takes her father's place to reinforce fidelity as the most important attribute. Not out of love. Not for honor-just filial duty. (That's via a unit from a professor in college.) Disney's adaptation, on the other hand, despite it being written and directed mostly by white men, has empowered girls for decades. Parents are a product of their times, and there were expectations for families to uphold, so he was understandably (not rightfully) embarrassed by her. When he condemns her, it is out of anger in the heat of the moment. No parent is perfect, and the ultimate goal is just to show love to the child you're raising. Fa Zhou shows love. In the beginning, he *comforts* Mulan after her disastrous interaction with the matchmaker: “What beautiful blossoms we have this year. But look! This one’s late. But I’ll bet that when it blooms, it will be the most beautiful of all.” He does not respond in anger, even though he is probably concerned that she will not have a match. Let's look at syntax because I'm an annoying English teacher: The verb tense emphasizes the point he is trying to make: "the greatest gift and honor *is having* you for a daughter." That's present continuous, so he means it for *that moment and forevermore*. In contrast, when he says "you *dishonor* me" and "I *know* my place; it *is* time you learned yours" in moments of anger, it's simple present. This *can* imply continuity, but is not as direct as present continuous. And how about that hug?? Fa Zhou, clearly wanting to embrace his daughter-seen from the pained expression on his face while holding her comb-lets her speak first without interrupting. The next thing he does is toss the sword and crest-emblems of honor *from the Emperor*-aside to HUG her. We only see a hug three other times (I think). Once is Mushu commending Mulan for taking her father's place *out of love.* And the other two happen in the same scene after Mulan defeats Shan Yu: Chien-Po bear-hugs the crew and the Emperor embraces Mulan's unexpected hug, both totally going against the norms established early in the film. Those hugs show how much Mulan has impacted the people/society around her. And each of those hugs come from a place of love and gratitude. So Fa Zhou's hug before he says his line further emphasizes the love he regrets not showing her sooner. All of this is to say that I love this line and apparently will nerd out over it because I'm a dork who doesn't know when to shut up???

[@loveitall2810]

The entire scene when Mushu meets Mulan should’ve been 20 sins off- *I know the ENTIRE scene word. By. Word*

[@sparkleyspirit4676]

Eddie Murphy did so well in this movie, as a character and comedy relief. Its a sin that you didn't take at least a sin off for his awesomeness.

[@nicholasjohnston1970]

The whole point of the “girl worth fighting for” was that at first they wanted a wife but after they see the dead village they realized that they have a different girl worth fighting for, the innocent people who were getting killed by the war

[@TH3F4LC0Nx]

I like how the first 2 guys sing about how they want a hottie to bang with, then the fat guy sings how he just wants someone to cook for him. lol

[@angelite143]

@@TH3F4LC0Nx and he did.. in the next movie.

[@cintronproductions9430]

@@angelite143 There is no next movie. Mulan never had a sequel that completely sh*ts on it.

[@SenorDexSat]

Yeah, but don't ask this channel to see beneath the surface because it hasn't even attempted to do that since 2018 at least. Yes, the song is sexist, but it has a purpose: what you said and to show that medieval China was, indeed, sexist.

[@ourkeving]

@@SenorDexSat oh jog off. Criticizing Cinemasins since forever. Either enjoy the humour or find another channel.

[@szaboluca5536]

Saying that this movie is sexist, during the scenes where it's absolutely intentional, is like being that mom that wanted to ban the book "To kill a mockingbird" saying it was racist because of the frequent use of the n-word.

[@TheVanishing87]

Szabó Luca I had to read a couple of paragraphs from that book in class back when I was in middle school and it was so unbelievably awkward for me to do so since those paragraphs I read from contained well that word at least five times. And as tho things weren’t already awkward enough, I was the only white girl in my whole class, but my teacher was also white. So what did I do when I got to those words? I just skipped the word altogether. Didn’t even bother substituting. All the while I’m just sitting there thinking, why did the teacher ask me to read out loud knowing full well that that word is written throughout? But sure instead of asking someone else to read it they ask me, the only white person in the whole class to do it? Why? To embarrass me? I have no idea! But in my honest opinion nobody should say the n word anyway. No matter how you look at it, it’s an ugly, derogatory word that has no business to exist in this world anymore. No one should say it.

[@trapper9998]

@@TheVanishing87 or you know becuase its history and you need to grow the fuck up

[@szaboluca5536]

@@TheVanishing87 First of all, I'm sorry about that experience, I honestly have no idea what your teacher was thinking, that must have been horrible. Second of all, you may have misunderstood my comment. I did not say, that it's okay to say the n-word. It's not, I agree no one should do it. But! Saying that this book is racist, is to me extremely ironic, because it was written againt racism, one of the main themes is "don't be racist", and of course it will have that word in it, because it was written in 1960, and the story takes place in the 1930s (if I remember correctly) and those were very very racist times. It is uncomfortable to read, but I find that book really important. (But reading it out loud? What are you even supposed to do?) So yeah, I was commenting on the irony of it all, and I did not want to make anyone think, that it was okay to say that. It's not.

[@thomasrosebrough9062]

Not all sexism is against women. Jeremy is right about the weird messages this movie sends to young boys.

[@zacharycruz1511]

@@thomasrosebrough9062 no he's not lol there's literally no bad messages unless you believe"toxic masculinity" is a thing. which it's not.

[@meemers330]

Missed the biggest sin of all... How the heck was Mulan able to do all that hero stuff in the end? She had her stomach split open! Stitches would've popped open just by riding that horse down the mountain to the city!

[@khaotictrash]

13:40 The entire point of her going to the war was to save her father, not for her own benefit. She knew she very likely would’ve died in the war or got caught and executed, but she still sacrificed herself for her father and as a last attempt to bring her family honor, not for self empowerment.

[@TazariaGaming]

1 sin off for Reflection and 1 sin off for the scene where the dad throws away all the prizes just to hold his daughter. That scene is honestly beautiful

[@Natalia-hj3mn]

Tazaria and 1 sin off for “sign me up for the next war” It deserves it dude

[@justanotherasian4395]

Another one off for 1 sin off “dishonor on your cow”

[@konaaukai5541]

I agree, especially with what he says when he finally holds Mulan after she returns home: "The greatest gift and him or is having you for a daughter." People can say what they like a out this movie, but it's one of my all-time favorites and it's for scenes like this. Her dad could be harsh at times by our standards here, but he cared about her. A lot.

[@aveelovesya]

@@Natalia-hj3mn "Would you like to stay forever?" Honestly any time it shows the grandma a sin should be taken off lol

[@tbefilms]

yES. I JUST commented that "The greatest gift and honor is having you for a daughter" should have gotten major sins off! Gives me chills every time.

[@TheCumberCoIlective]

The "dishonor on your cow" line deserved a sin off and you didn't even play it

[@liberpolo5540]

TheCumberCoIlective We can't tolerate this!

[@TheCumberCoIlective]

@@liberpolo5540 we need to start a petition

[@Ugly_German_Truths]

Meh, he redeemed himself with the LOTR quotes in the epilogue, those were even better than dishonor on your cow :D

[@ardnas994]

If there's so many sins to the original, I can only imagine how many will 2020 remake have.

[@coramaynard2752]

7:05 periods can actually be stopped when you are under a lot of stress. In my junior year of high school I went 4 months without a period because one class and the ass of a teacher who taught it had me so stressed. Mulan was likely stressed enough throughout this whole time that she likely didn’t have a period. Also, like someone else mentioned, physical stress can halt or lessen a period so combine both stresses and she probably didn’t have a period for a while

[@stephsaguudefan1753]

2:59 Uh, no she sings "when will my reflection show who I am inside." Also, I hate when people call this movie sexist. It's set in ancient China where this is how things would have been, and its whole message is that Mulan can do good things even though she isn't a man. What I love about this movie is that it doesn't try to imply that women can be just as strong/exactly the same as men. In fact, Mulan thinking differently is what saves them. It shows that both genders have strengths to contribute to a situation rather than ridiculously stating that men and women are exactly the same.

[@howtokdj1498]

Word

[@annabelsummer2643]

Yeah, this whole video was bad, usually he is really good but he just kept going "sexist" when that was literally the point... they were highlighting the sexism, and 99.9% of people who watch Mulan understand that, except apparently someone who analyses films for a living.

[@moondolphineclipse9]

Annabel Summer it’s almost like the channel has become aimed to be humorous rather than analytical and mentioning sexism at every point is a joke

[@annabelsummer2643]

@@moondolphineclipse9 Can't it be both analytical and funny? There are so many things to laugh at in Mulan, and it seems almost lazy to just go "sexism" the whole way through, instead of finding real things to laugh about. I don't have to be a feminist to know that china at the time saw women as lesser, and still view women as lesser today, (such as aborting girls during the period of time there was a one child rule, and many rural areas currently kidnapping women from neighbouring areas and countries because there are not enough women) was very sexist, and analysing that is infinitely more interesting than watching him misunderstand one of the main points of the film? Sorry, my grammar is terrible lol (I am on my phone which doesn't help matters lol). I feel like someone is about to call me racist lol, we have a big call out culture, even when people just state the truth.

[@LadyOnikara]

Did this take place when Chinese women had to bind their feet to make them dainty and cute? It would be a way for a Disney movie to be even darker.

[@davidpumpkinsjr.5108]

I love the look on Mulan's face when the ENTIRE regiment runs past her naked.

[@sunnygirl523]

freakin love that part funniest part of the movie 😂😂😂

[@justpeachy2005]

David Pumpkins Jr. I legit forgot about that part when I put it on the tv with my little cousins- man I had a serious talk, even though it showed nothing-

[@NoSoiBoobs90]

That's the face I make when I see naked people in general.

[@ketchup016]

That and the part where the panda "horse" climbs a tree were HYSTERICAL to child me. 😂

[@danmarks8330]

David Pumpkins Jr. just wait until the live action lmaoo

[@clarafedde8674]

Last sin should of been when the grandma says "sign me up for the next war."

[@wondliii9046]

I'll save you 15 minutes: that's sexist *ding*

[@dday906]

No sin removal for "Reflection." No sin removal for Eddie Murphy's hilarious performance as Mushu. No sin removal for "I'll Make A Man Out of You." No sin removal for Mulan being one of the most badass heroes in the Disney pantheon. But a sin removal for a whiny, sexist, brown nosing coward, for taking a funny picture....

[@RandoSando.]

No sin removed for the grandma saying "how lucky can the ancestors be? They're all dead" or for the grandma saying "sign me up for the next war!"

[@kristofferbutler3712]

Not to mention completely missing the point of why Mulan went home and sinning his own flawed reasoning

[@jongon0848]

@@RandoSando. or for "Would you like to stay forever?" What a disappointing episode of Cinema Sins

[@franticcarrot6482]

No mention of Goldsmith's amazing "Haircut" score either..

[@calebtsedzik6222]

No sin removal for Mulan's reunion with her father in the end. No sin removal for "How many men does it take to deliver a message?" No sinS removed for JERRY FREAKING GOLDSMITH!

[@danieldelanoche2015]

The grandmother walking across the road with the cricket: "GOOD LUCK EVERYBODY ELSE!"

[@Everlucky_Clover]

you forgot the part where she had her eyes closed :p

[@ilovefunnyamv2nd]

wait, how many crickets has she tried that with? forget mulan, send the grandmother to fight thr Huns, thst woman is invincible

[@pomipomi5632]

@@ilovefunnyamv2nd true, true... Send out an op grandma to fight war XD

[@fenrir-art4742]

More like bad luck to others. At least that cricket is not the one from Cricket on the Hearth animation.

[@thompham6964]

clonesavegir.link/qI1DhkGW_U

[@kamilekamile2222]

the period one is just so good😂

[@daniellclary]

She did not leave home for adventure to to break any societal norms. She left home to save her father. So of course she wants to return home at the end.

[@kraziti]

Can we give CinemaSins a sin for calling Shan Yu's bird an eagle? *Edit: And then later goes on to call it a hawk...* That is a falcon sir.

[@jolantru3085]

It's a bird, ain't it?!

[@octav3k]

@@jolantru3085 Shut up, pig. You're a mammal, aren't you?

[@baboonballoon2115]

octav3k yoo chill out, we all gigantic naked mole rats here aren’t we? We are under rulership of at least someone soo maybe we DID branch off from them...

[@jolantru3085]

@@octav3k Hell, DNA-wise, we're all 50% banana.

[@twobitts7320]

@@jolantru3085 intelligent big brain

[@NadiaS8394]

Why did you skip “would you like to stay forever?”.

[@handsomest1]

NadiaShahira MohdHazmi I have somewhere u can stay forever..

[@dj__projects]

Dinner would be great!

[@NadiaS8394]

Handsome With The Handgun Where?

[@laneblair6491]

He knew it was too good to sin

[@aman7930]

he didn't want to remove a sin. its his content though, but i'm still furious.

[@ItsStormCentral]

"Dishonor on you! Dishonor on your cow!" ~ Mushu 1998

[@imagination8]

11:40 Shang is just pissed that Mulan tricked him into falling for a girl and I feel that.

[@carultch]

Maybe Shang is bi-curious and in denial about it. He felt an attraction to her when he thought she was a man.

[@antoniodelaugger9236]

i understand being pissed but its literally his duty to protect the emperor and he just ignored the fact that the huns inside the walls, seems pretty stupid to ignore that warning

[@lucheng1945]

@@carultch Uh... Im pretty sure that he was just proud of her for learning and persevering so well. Also, guys in the military are probably closer to each other than guys in normal society because of all the stuff they go through together. Also, please dont get offended, but it is a really toxic, sexist standard that men cannot have close friendships. Women can be very close and be viewed as good friends, whereas men would be accussed of homosexuality. This discourages men from forming close relationships and deprives them of support systems is detrimental to their mental and emotional health. It is very sad and we as a society should really work to change this.

[@carultch]

@@lucheng1945 You are putting a lot of words in my mouth. I never said anything about men not being able to have close friendships without being mistaken for being gay.

[@lucheng1945]

@@carultch Oh sorry, I didnt mean that you said those things. I was just highlighting the unhealthy standard that society sets for men, something that your comment made me think of.

[@carlachidiac332]

Me when someone gets upset over their favourite movie being sinned: people need to chill, this channel isn’t meant to be taken seriously. Me when Mulan gets sinned: blasphemy!! Blasphemers, all of you!!

[@Dargonhuman]

I never take this channel seriously because they've said countless times that it's not in any way a serious critique channel, so even when they do one of my favorite movies my reaction is usually, "Oh, this'll be fun!"

[@bloggerblogg5878]

@@Dargonhuman Mine reaction too. Mulan is my childhood favorite and I like till now. So those who upset about favorite movies chill ya'll And enjoy have great time, its isn't against you or your favorite movies. If you get irritated from these things don't watch, simple solution for your nerves.

[@socialgoat5519]

"dishonour on you, dishonour on your family, dishonour on your cow!"

[@catsandcheese]

Are you me?

[@TrickedGecko327]

I love when they do my favorite movies because sometimes they make actual points, and I want to see if he says something I actually agree with

[@rose-511]

the fact that you didn’t take a sin off for the grandma’s comment at the end of the movie (“would you like to stay forever”) has earned YOU a sin

[@katthefab5566]

Was thinking that too😂

[@emo_nerd5853]

Yep me 2

[@varric]

Or the Emperor literally having to push the captain into pursuing Mulan because he's so oblivious.

[@thewolfmasters]

I was waiting for "sign me up for the next war"

[@vampira8966]

I heard the grandma's voice in this comment

[@jeesonkallukkaran8140]

02:39 zuko intensifies

[@jamiepatterson558]

I laughed so hard at your Mushue impression I aspirated my Energy drink. I could've died. I binge watch your videos as I'm doing housework, thanks for brightening my day!

[@MegaSoulHero]

How dare you not remove a sin for I’ll Make a Man Out of You! That song is awesome!

[@F7Wz]

MegaSoulHero how can it be 12 hours ago wtf

[@createnewhandle_]

@@F7Wz Early access for patrons or something like that.

[@creaturefeature.]

F7 that is exactly what I’m trying to figure out

[@chrisp.9385]

If you don't like 'i'll make a man out of you' then aren't a man

[@acdbutrfly]

Chris P. That’s racist *Ding*

[@ladyvincenza]

Re: the fat horse: I read the designers based that on how stylized horses looked in old time-y Chinese art. Yeah, it's not realistic, but neither is a talking dragon, etc.:)

[@osmanthus_wine230]

yeah the horse is a Ferghana breed. While they're not that fat in real life, Mulan's horse does look like it was based on the portrayal of ferghanas in ancient Chinese art

[@daearthflatyeet2261]

nice fact, but all we REALLY need to know is that that horse is a swole motherfucker with the strongest goddamn twigs known to exist throughout any and all history superglued under all of that mass

[@nathenewendzel1825]

I don't think a horse's size is something worth complaining about. It has nothing to do with the story. Also, I don't think that horse is fat. He looks like a normal horse to me except maybe a little smarter. Some people think he's secretly a guardian.

[@nathenewendzel1825]

They based it on Chinese art? That's cool. It's always nice when they include details like that.

[@ladyvincenza]

@@nathenewendzel1825 Yes, I think it adds more depth when the studio includes details like that. This is one of my favorite movies, btw!

[@moonstarsshow8501]

1:47 pretty much what the grandma says seconds later 😂

[@vanessas17]

@8:45 The D&D references were so unexpected they were absolutely jarring. I love it!

[@ben7100]

The only sin that's not a sin is the one where Mulan's Dad say, "If I reveal her, she will be [dead]." Historically, doing what she did is punishable by death. They would kill her as soon as they found out.

[@donovan1345]

Well they didn't find out until she revealed it herself. After she became a general, she went into a battle wearing a woman's clothes. This had a reversed affect on how it normally would affect the soldiers. It inspired the men and they won another great battle. After the war, the emperor was shocked that his finest general was a female, he wanted to reward her. All she asked for was a horse/camel (minor disagreement on what mount she rode) so she could go home. She found out her father died, mom remarried. Her family wanted her to be a concubine and sad became sad and killed herself. I'm sure if she was found out at the beginning, she would have been killed and her whole family as well for dishonoring the emperor. One huge difference in the movie and the lore, is that she knew how to fight at a young age, taught by her father.

[@adwoakumi1174]

Gummie Bear actually they found out she was a girl after she got injured and was taken to the doctor she didn’t reveal it she got caught

[@CrystalWilliamsBrownArt]

@@adwoakumi1174 i believe they are referring to the legend not the movie. The movie is based on a legend I think.

[@koolmckool7039]

I could think of a few more sins that aren't sins.

[@donovan1345]

@@adwoakumi1174 I was talking about the legend not the Disney movie.

[@Booga04]

6:42 if Shang looked down in that scene, this movie would have been a lot shorter

[@_zealos_8213]

OH MY *GOD*

[@wh3156]

I- I'm speechless

[@trinityballard9796]

Ain't that the truth..

[@imagination8]

We trans men have a secret device known as a chest binder.

[@C.C._.]

@Booga04 my sis said the same thing

[@localmenace3043]

“This horse is THICC with a capital DAMN” is one of the funniest things you’ve ever said.

[@theweirdones7544]

jeremy im sinning you for skipping the rest of Mushu's "dishonor on you, dishonor on your cow". Eddie Murphy is a gem 5:30

[@maverikfulfer2601]

he should have sinned the part when the bad guy tells the spy that the emperor challenged him by building the wall even though it took 1700 years to build

[@tanandalynch9441]

He did in a sense. But he said "This is the equivalent of she blocked me on twitter so she must want me to keep pursuing her"

[@maverikfulfer2601]

@@tanandalynch9441 yeah well I should have sinned it twice be cause we both know they aren't almost 2000 years old

[@jardex2275]

Also, 50 foot walls will just sell 51 foot ladders.

[@Da_Swifta]

Idk man, he looks like he uses Black Magic. He might be that old, who knows?

[@maverikfulfer2601]

@@Da_Swifta idk mabey

[@isabelled.7732]

3:15 she wasn't sleeping there, she was going out there to cry dramatically.

[@amethystbangle5302]

9:20 cinemasins misses the chance to call mushu a "luck dragon"

[@Sorrow-loves-everyone]

I just came from watching CinemaSins doing Mulan (2020) suddenly this one seems like a masterpiece.

[@ColdNorth0628]

"This horse is thicc with a capital damn" will give you that one is pretty good.

[@insanitypal5929]

@aviato287 x no u

[@Themanfuhreal]

The only thing that’s good are the disgusting comments

[@moloti6254]

Easily my favorite cinemasins quote

[@cintronproductions9430]

Who even drew this innacurate, messed up horse? His body is thiccer than a hippo and a rhino put together and his legs are sticks! He shouldn't even be able to stand! 😂😂😂

[@insanitypal5929]

@@cintronproductions9430 The sheer power of his thickness keeps him upright. Or hes just filled with helium.

[@hsfhanaa]

7:03 actually, if we wanna get technical she raised her athleticism up basically 98% and when you work out aggressively like that, it can delay that time of month and seeing as it is her first time doing this aggressive of a workout she probably skipped that month.

[@user-id8wp3lb9i]

Or she could of not had it yet. Correct me if I'm wrong but isn't she supposed to be like 15 ish so it's possible it just hadn't started yet

[@hsfhanaa]

@@user-id8wp3lb9i you're right. She was 16 and could've been a "late bloomer" tho statistically speaking, in the past it was normal for girls to start getting their cycle at 18

[@sivad1025]

But couldn't she have still gotten it before the intense training came into play?

[@user-id8wp3lb9i]

@@sivad1025 yes we are just saying that her not having her period is not that surprising

[@hsfhanaa]

@@sivad1025 fair point but any training - intense or otherwise - is more than sure was used to. Also the stress and nerves could've stopped it. A woman's body takes the week to make a fresh new space for a baby and if your body senses something that can harm the baby ( stress or illness) it will stop it short or delay it altogether

[@SuperWolfman9]

I like to think that there's an alternate universe out there where Disney does adult aimed cartoons and the bad guy kills the Emperor before Mulan gets there and when she does she straight up cuts the guy in half. Then in the aftermath China collapses into warring states (as it always does) and Mulan becomes a Warlord who reunites China and becomes empress.

[@minerva147]

her army at least would have girl worth fighting for... Yes, I must....

[@plpmito5519]

Nah mulan ends up a prostitute for shu yu after he fucks over the army

[@vcraig2141]

China breaks up into the Warring States exactly one time in history. It's literally called the Warring States Period. Most of Chinese history is as a whole and possibly the most peaceful country ever. Dynasties typically last about 300-400 years with the exception being the Zhou Dynasty that almost lasted 1000 years or the Xia Dynasty that lasted even longer.

[@vcraig2141]

@@plpmito5519 Doubtful. If we're going with this Shan Yu his wild swings would get picked apart by Mulan's training. Plus historically speaking the Huns never made it very far in their many attempted invasions. It wouldn't be until the Mongols replaced them and invaded hundreds of years later when China was at its weakest that any foreign power made it into the empire. And even then that only lasted like 100 years before the Ming Dynasty took over for another 300 years of peace.

[@hamilcat1138]

Jeremy: THIS HORSE IS THICC WITH A CAPITAL DAMN me: *WHEEZING

[@notnobodynotknowhow8992]

"The greatest gift and honor is having you for a daughter," should have gotten one of those Narrator Starts Fake Crying And Claims He Feels Nothing While A Sin Disappears sin removals.

[@dj__projects]

Yeah, usually Jeremy does better at noticing that. I don't know what happened with this video.

[@SeasideDetective2]

One of the greatest lines in the history of the movies - and I'll defend that to the death.

[@gyakuten7411]

Cinema Sins has devolved from pointing out actual flaws and clichés to making stupid jokes that can easily be refuted with evidence from the movie

[@CharlieQuartz]

Gyakuten Yeah and his criticism of the actual sexism in this movie under the guise of enlightened feminism wasn’t nuanced or insightful, was it?

[@gyakuten7411]

Charlie no, he just said “that’s sexist” at purposefully sexist parts of the movie which are meant to set barriers for mulan to overcome.

[@belladonna869]

13:34 Her goal was never to show the entire world who she was inside, it was to discover who she is, because she felt trapped in the image everyone wanted for her. Her motivation for joining the army was to save her father, and just because she achieved more than that doesn’t mean that her root motivation doesn’t still lie with love for family. It’s entirely understandable that she went back home to take care of her aging parents and grandmother.

[@JDMHaze]

angelface714 If I'm not mistaking I think her goal was to fight in the war in place of her father because he was sick and she didn't want him to die at war, Because I could've sworn she basically impersonating him and went by his name

[@melodi2036]

@@JDMHaze she didn't impersonate him or go by his name. She said she was his son, Ping

[@belladonna869]

Keye Haze she pretended to be his son instead, but yea he was injured from the last war and hadn’t recovered

[@JDMHaze]

Zander S. lmao😅😂😂

[@JDMHaze]

Melodi OK thanks for clearing that up, I remembered they had the same last name but I thought she was claiming she was him so that they would think it was him, as to take his place for sone reason

[@hmonggirl_artist]

At 5:00 CinemaSins refers Shan Yu’s bird as an eagle. At 11:55 CinemaSins refers it as a hawk.

[@robonaught]

It's neither anyway. It's a falcon! Why does nearly everyone think Shan Yu's falcon is a hawk?

[@hannahjoylaurman37]

I wish he removed a sin for the saucy Grandma saying “sign me up for the next war!” Lol

[@heatherreagan8078]

Boy, I hope Jeremy didn't hurt himself stretching so far for those sins.

[@wumbosaurus9121]

😂

[@jess_merch]

Right??

[@TheAngryBookworm96]

THIS

[@lProN00bl]

Everything sexist! We good feminists see!?

[@THEstillinprogress]

“viewer complaining about content on a video they watched anyways” cliche. *ding*

[@bambisbluebell]

"Did they send me daughters when I asked for sons?" Yes. *Ding*

[@ChakatBlackstar]

*Looks at the sons* "On second thought, send the daughters"

[@bambisbluebell]

@@ChakatBlackstar 😂😂😂

[@EmilZ-wb5kr]

8:02 is it just me or is this picture with the emperor just hilarious af? The older I get, the funnier it seems. Especially with the emperor being like "get me outa here"

[@melissawalker5723]

Horse is THICC with a capital DAMN... Omg I lost it 😂😂🤣🤣

[@oliveb5768]

the full line is "when will my reflection show who I am inside" so even though she's looking at a dozen reflections, none of them show Mulan an authentic version of herself/she feels out of place in her current situation also no sin removal for one of disney's best I want songs, which also happens to be sung by the legendary Lea Salonga? that's a sin. ding!

[@zekezzekekan2144]

But he has to ignore that so he can make a sin

[@nthgth]

I guess, but all the lyrics say is what every adolescent human feels (and many adults)

[@skystar1359]

I’m torn between laughing at the “thick as damn” comment and anger that the ONLY SIN YOU TOOK OFF IS FOR THE FANBOY PICTURE?!

[@ARCtheCartoonMaster]

@Boo! Scary! Please tell me you're referring to the guys not learning their lesson, and not to Mulan turning down the government position.

[@Shaznit]

11:44 Could have had a Mortal Kombat music theme joke at the end and 12:55 could have had "IT'S A BIRD! IT'S A PLANE!"

[@Bree-Meets-World]

Ok, but when you started roasting the horse in the beginning 😂😂😂

[@oliviascallan5943]

That you didn’t remove a sin for the final line “would you like to stay for dinner?” “Would you like to stay forever?” Is disappointing

[@dustindial9996]

C’mon. The emperor’s line “No matter how the wind howls...the mountain cannot now to it.” Deserves a sin off

[@faketohma]

Yeah I was like are you seriously talking over the best line the Emperor says?

[@lordroy88]

You said it wrong

[@PrinceTrexus]

Especially since the emperor was played by Pat Morita aka freaking MR MIYAGI himself!

[@catherinemichelle7260]

Dustin Dial it’s bow.

[@SomeNativeOfficial]

No

[@jakebolls3420]

I remember watching this movie for social studies in 7th because we were learning about China

[@Varis...]

Remove a sin for the avalanche. You actually can swim through it. That's actually the recommended way to survive an avalanche. Stay near the top by swimming