Ex IAS On Government Jobs, Tourism, Politicians, UPSC & Salary | Ft Vivek Atray | FO138 Raj Shamani

[@nihar8210]

Yess.....that's Raj Shamani. No over acting, no hyper positivity, no fairy tales. Organic, to the point and honest.

[@official.rajarshidutta]

No Allahabadia was hurt by this comment😂

[@nihar8210]

@@official.rajarshidutta 😂

[@RaoVikasYadav-sahab]

​@@official.rajarshiduttagay + hyper positivity and acting + talking and behaving like girl = allahabadiya 😂😅😂

[@doodleh9318]

Exactly....his calmness and good posture....also no extra head movement are his plus point...

[@MilkMocha56]

​@@RaoVikasYadav-sahab Do women have copyright on certain type of communication skill? And how do one behave gay? You know that gay, trans and cross dressers are three different things right? A super masculine guy(like that chad guy in meme) can be gay. It is sexual preference. People don't "behave gay" How do you behave straight?? According to you only men who speak loudly like women ? Or soft speakers are also straight? You lack commonly known information bro. It's not colonial time anymore ,we don't have anti trans and anti gay laws. Stop being homophobic. Why is being gay or transgender a joke? Fir toh being straight pe bhi joke maro? Kyunki tum straight ,trans aur gay paida hote ho. Tumhe koi jabardasti bole ki tu ladki se nahi ladko se relationship rakh aur unhi se shaddi kar.karoge? Tum gay paida hi nahi hue toh ladko mein intrest nahi hoga. Jis lakdi ko ladkiyo mein interest hai woh paida hi ese Hui toh ismein uski kya galti. This is very normal. There are documentaries made on homosexual animals. It is natural.As normal as a 5 year old kid walking

[@omkarchougale7277]

IAS Tukaram Mundhe sir. He is an IAS officer of the 2005 batch who has been has been transferred 16 times so far. Pure man ❤️

[@ManojKumar-sy7bw]

Poor boy got transferred every time.😂

[@fighterinmkiwiscience3517]

​@@ManojKumar-sy7bwlol😂

[@aj7907]

​@@ManojKumar-sy7bwpoor boy? Teri aukad bhi kya unke baare me baat karne ke liye?

[@ManojKumar-sy7bw]

@@aj7907 bilkul aakhir EK IAS Ki aukad hi Kya Hai? Har Baar bas transfer hi to Hona hai?🤣

[@aj7907]

@@ManojKumar-sy7bw aap kabhi samajh nahi paoge sir

[@rupeshshevgan6142]

I completely agree with it , plan A, B, C,D,E sab hona chahiye.... if u hv to achieve something good in life. If plan A fail then we need support with other plans.

[@mansoortantary333]

This youtuber is doing great job for young generation of india

[@engineerofemotions1183]

This man maintain best level of fluency and clarity in his speech 😮😊 One of the best podcast I had ever heard❤ Hope I will met such kind of souls in my life😊

[@PG-jv5nw]

He has got only communication skills . The top floor is empty.

[@kuldeepandey]

7 C for success Courage Calmness Cheerful Creativity Contentment Compassion Communication

[@saiphogangsa2381]

Tqsm for this 7 c for success

[@shivambharadwaj7879]

​2 more bonus tips...confidence and consistent @@saiphogangsa2381

[@anjankumark]

Roads are mostly good for the tourist places. Governmentt has to make sure it provides clean toilets good restaurants and clean budget stay. This will improve tourism a lot.

[@mpsingh593]

Mr. Vivek Attray is way ahead of the brightest minds in our system. If he can galvanise thousands to set the ball rolling to transform India, we would achieve a superpower status in the eyes of every global citizen.

[@ManojKumar-sy7bw]

🤣🤣🤣🙏

[@misbahurrahman7438]

You are the best one in India as a Podcaster. I met a deadly accident but miraculously survived. I was in coma for many days. As brain had multiple injuries so my interpretation or perspective towards life is completely changed. You may call me as I almost crossed the line between life and death.

[@shobhitbansal9288]

Pls share your perspective of life. I want to learn from you.

[@NanthoiMangang]

I agree

[@suryansharmakvm18]

Vivek Sir visited my school last year... that's the first time i got to know about him and his works... about how he played the Ranji Trophy and then became an IAS officer and now a motivational speaker... And today this podcast has made me a bigger fan of him... Thank you Raj bhaiya...😊

[@Square500]

he was state pcs officer, later become ias with promotion. he was not through upsc, many ias become DM at the age of 25-30, he became after 50, so he cant be even divisional commissioner, secratery is not possible so he is not appropriate to saying ias

[@Sgt.Slaughter]

@@Square500 dont spread lies, he cleared upsc and he is from Haryana IAS cadre!

[@Square500]

@@Sgt.Slaughter He is telling lie by using ias post or name,he is promoted ias, He was passout from college in 1988 that mean he was 22yr old in 1988. he became IAS in 2005 that mean he was 39-40yr old that time. He is brahmin. Before 2013 there was only 4 attempt and 28 yr max age for open category in upsc exam, and he became ias in 2005 before that he was director IT, that mean he was pcs officer and promoted to ias. He became DM or DC panchkula in 2014 at the age of 48 yr, generally ias through upsc at this age of 48 that mean nearly 18-24 yr of service become home secratery level in state or joint secratery or above in central or chief of some department

[@ChaudharyG85]

Being an IAS he is so disconnected with the reasons behind why a common youth from T2/T3 city plan to go abroad. There are not many opportunities here in these cities. Not everyone can make pakoda here and survive with a family. In countries like Canada/Aus with hard-work they can.

[@kabirbroadcasting]

And of course they dont bear the guilt of corruption money. They have a cleaner conscience.

[@Xjhuyebdw]

Ye IAS nahi tha

[@prajakt0789]

Rightly pointed out.

[@satyajitdeb3223]

I lived in T3 city of Assam 3 of my Friends become enterprineur after graduation, one is open 4 men parlour around city , one manufacture and sells bamboo crafts , and do organic mustard oil already opened 2 factories

[@manojitdey4491]

In Canada, which type of job they did, are you aware of that 😂 Whatever your income in canada that is not more than pakoda wala except Highly skills job. Improve your skills only Nehi to jisko chaye banana nhi aata, Uska chaya ghanta sell hoga. I think you got my point ☝️

[@Pikachu-ib8ly]

7c Fearless Creative Communication Courage Character Telling the truth Happiness Contentment greatfull what you have Compassion empathy for other

[@azharkhan-ks8yo]

@45:51 8 C's 1. Courage: Fearlessness. 2. Character: Telling truth, integrity, etc. 3. Calmness: Calm mind to take right decision. 4. Cheerfulness: merry face or jovial - builds goodwill. 5. Creativity: makes life multi dimensional. 6. Contentment: great full for what you have 7. Compassion: empathy for others. 8. Communication

[@KavitaG80]

Vivek ji, you cannot contact a govt officer. I tried to contact the DM of a district, I emailed, phoned 3 numbers from the website, only one rang the other 2 says wrong number. There was 2 email address. My message from one email came back undelivered, other email went to the DM but I never received a reply. Even the DM mobile number is on website he never answers the phone. Indian govt officers are under trained, lazy, corrupt. You mentioned tourism and Taj. My dream was to visit the Taj so made the trip in 2011. As a NRI we paid God knows how much more, waited for 2hrs in queue. The security persons were letting in people through the back door via the paid dalals. We were approached but denied their service. In the end we got in, we took some photos leading up to the Taj which took half hour. We just reached the Taj to go in only to be told by the security guards to leave the Taj, why? "VIP visit". We were horrified. They told us to come back the next day and use the same ticket. But we were not staying the night in Agra. We asked who this VIP was. Some of them said they don't know. As we were going out of Taj other tourists were just as horrified and told us that the VIP was a Supreme Court judge and his family. If tourists are treated like this forget about India being a tourist country. The other very annoying thing is the civil etiquette of the citizens, the glare, interference, asking personal questions and over all trust?? India has a long to go. The mind set and politics is the main problem. India need to mature which will take another 2/3 generations. You need a huge social revolution.

[@harshitasingh612]

He was talking about Chandigarh.. i miss the city so much. Been brought up there. Its the cleanest, greenest city (at least the time I lived it was) Been 7 years since I left the city. But its amazing to live there

[@Nitin_Killawala]

Young people go abroad and settle there because there’s an honest daily life and respect for fellow human beings…across all sections of society…unlike in India

[@learntounlearn3954]

Young people go abroad for money. Nothing else. No one cares for an honest life. Do you think America is all fair? It’s far from truth.

[@crazylearn2204]

Grass is green at the other side

[@tanujarora4906]

ANOTHER WALMART CLERK GOT BUTT HURT

[@Upsc_With_Ravi_]

One of the greatest and knowledgeable prodcast in my life. He's really admirable person , thanks Raj bro to make a prodcast with this person.

[@eurekacomment5719]

7 Cs of Life - Courage, Compassion, Character, Creativity, Calmness, Cheerfulness, Communication, and Contentment.

[@divyasharma9421]

Raj, its a request to bring any personnel who has done core finance studies and can discuss the different finance stream student can pursue and sectors of job and career avenues with respect to it. Also applicability of varied finance courses in different roles in business.

[@kethaniyer5554]

Raj u r better than Ranveer man....ur questions are good and u stick to topic..keep rocking!!!

[@pri012]

Ranveer yha puchta : "sir, kya IAS fap karte hai?"

[@inderjeetchauhan1116]

A great podcast .. An outstanding podcast appearance! His ability to cover every question in a simple and informative way is truly impressive. His insights are as sharp as ever, and it was a pleasure to watch and learn from you."

[@genshinjaiki9117]

Yup wisest philosophy I've even in an IAS who really thinks and can guide an inpired youth for their planning and walking in thier paths🫡🤗

[@ramankit_krishna]

best ever IAS interview i have watched till now , what a communication skill and way of presenting sentence/ view, hats off sir

[@SwamiKhairnar-rd1ev]

Yess.....that's Raj Shamani. No over acting, no hyper positivity, no fairy tales. Organic, to the point and honest.

[@jagdishsaran7329]

Amazing conversation sir !! please make this type of conversation with other IAS officers

[@abdulnabihosamani9685]

Amazing conversation! Depth & Breadth of knowledge 🙌

[@Mr.RailwayMan]

100% right whatever is said about indian tourism potential ❤️

[@THE_UPSC_GIRL369]

Vivek sir is the best 💥😄.... His calmness, communication, stories,examples are 💎

[@kiranmaurya6943]

1 more correction... population to service attendant are less. Less doctor, less police, less admin staff. So we need to increase government facilitating Jobs & service. India is Hulk not elephant, ...it needs right talent & energy in government for further improvement. And same is needed for citizen as well in employment.

[@Nobody09-]

it would be better if two of you are in single screen other than in split parts when you both came together on screen... thankyou for this.

[@77sreedhar]

7c's, great. This explanation by ex officer is worth 1000 personality books.

[@akshat2417]

man who knows his stuff... a wise man who has seen much life ..he's an OG...these type of people should rule politic.

[@moodypeachx]

Thank you for sharing with us this amazing conversation ❤️ highly intellectual and more real I love my country so much but I myself am prepping up for the ielts to leave to Canada 😅 but I will definitely gather some global experience and come back to serve my people for the rest of my life.

[@aishushobha8014]

Govt jobs are best, govt works for country, by doing govt job you can serve the country and contribute in the growth of the country, I would urge youngsters to go into govt jobs.

[@MEB_KunalArya]

Hiii Raj bhai I am again here to watch your podcast. Today I am feeling to watch your podcast because of the way you take your podcast. You make the conversation more interesting and even if I don’t have any interest I’ll get interested. Love you 3000 bhai

[@swapnilchourpagar1423]

call suraj yengde he is harvard scholar and intellectual from nanded maharashtra....great content.vivek atray sir was soo true from inside out.

[@karishmabishnoi7012]

ABSOLUTELY LOVED THISSSSSSS, DIDN'T WANT IT TO END AT ANY POINT

[@madscientist9]

UK railways is one of the struggling sector and so many strikes / delay in service. I left for UK for better education and hands on learning. This was due to luck and lack of opportunity to study. I work in a high paying job, of course because of my hard work and consistency. Also corruption is one of the current major issue I am not heading back 😢. You should teach people how to whistle blow. That's the need for the hour 🙏 Really great talk 👍 keep figuring out and keep sharing 😊

[@mostlymi9963]

Unfortunately Indian Railways is now copying UK railways so expect our service to deteriorate.

[@mohanjitsingh5706]

Vivek aatray is a good man.. i met him in school culture fest in Chandigarh long time ago.. He was the role model among us..

[@Mbbsstories]

Definitely IAS sir You looked the matter of Agra very closely. My Foreigners students highlights problems of huge prices of foreign tickets enourmosly high

[@Royalgirl_998]

Bilkul sahi sawal ask Kiya aapne Bhai main bhi Bihar se hu aur mere parents ko main kitna bhi samjha doon pr unke liye sabse badhiya professional career IAS hi h ..main toh aab thak gayi hu kyuki mujhe kuch different Krna h ..aur mere parents aur meri thinking different hone k Karan bahut bahut arguments ho jaye h pr ....aapki yeh podcast meri liye bahut hi value h .....

[@priyanshisingh9361]

bhaiya please make more videos on ias officer and ask them about the difficulty of being an ias officer , the perpose of an ias , salary , privileges, power , why some ias officers resign from their jobs and what are the reality and expectations of being an ias officer please bhaiya because its is very helpful for all those ias aspirants who want to know about thier career field please ... your podcast channel is the only one which i have found interested

[@shubhamsahu1030]

Bhaiya We want Prashant kishore on your podcast ahead of this elections

[@Adityasharma-ii3dg]

The only thought that has been on my mind over the whole podcast is..If he knew about all those problems in the tourism sector. Why didn't he improve upon those? Why did he leave the service and now making us count all the drawbacks.

[@ermonga]

Tickets ate same way in foreign land too for foreigners, then why not india has the same tickets strategy?

[@purbanchalassam]

nice.. Best Podcaster... Love u brother.

[@anjubisht992]

Raj it's a request can you bring someone who can talk about the growth of uttarakhand region

[@sahabchaus717]

Brother, Please invite TechBurner for his startup " OVERLAYS "

[@abhipatil5707]

Please bring RBI Officer on your Podcast

[@rajhsalgam2083]

Raj should have asked what is the extra income IAS officers make in rishwat/bribes which makes monthly salary a pittance.

[@engineerofemotions1183]

Genuinely it's not the all time, I got my govt job with hard work...... Sometimes we have to face diplomacy, but it's has many perks as well😊

[@mohdfarzankhan991]

Sdm ho kya

[@rattandeepbrar1118]

Mr Atray is not only a competent officer but a wonderful human being many years ago I had met him and what a polished person God bless you

[@lailasiddiqui263]

11:53 - as part of social responsibility , (give them tax incentives to construct and maintain) ask the private companies to pump in money for tourism infrastructure restrooms, water etc and most will gladly do it

[@priyalimallick6923]

Everything is not about money. How much our soldiers get as salary? But still they r doing their service with so much honesty and integrity and love in their heart for our nation. Let's take a moment to think about that. Also everyone don't want to be entrepreneur like you.

[@MistySHAGUN-yp5os]

Logical comment 😌

[@rahulsolanki2421]

Worked as an engineer in India. Couldn't afford my wants...good phone, xbox, car, gaming pc😅😅..Not even rent. Worked minimum wage job here and already have all of those things.😂

[@Rahul-et9oi]

Aap sabhi guest se 1 question or puch sakte hoon Clg me kiya stream liya tha or aage Jaake us stream se related work kiya Esse student bhut relate kar painge😊😊

[@nimishmalu270]

You should have gone deeper into tourism …. Completely ignored medical and corporate tourism …. Cities like Dubai attract more tourists due to the Corporate events and expos compared to india …. We don’t even bid for such events on a world level …. We have the facilities also … plus any Corporate person spends a lot more money than a regular budget traveler …. Such verticals of tourism should be developed faster …

[@alekseireznikov8880]

Haan haan ghar me baand ke baitha dete hain ias ko, uska ghar-baar thodi hai.

[@Uniquethoughtsreflects6819]

Bro your videos are really worth watching and life changing. The questions asked by you are really amazing and challenging. ❤❤

[@rajshamani]

thanks bro, this means a lot🙌

[@Uniquethoughtsreflects6819]

@@rajshamaniDear bro I am your sister not brother. Keep excelling in life. God bless you.

[@anshporwal1175]

​@@Uniquethoughtsreflects6819😂

[@Mufasa0786]

Bhai Mohammad Shami ko lao podcast pe. Itni sheer dedication aur strong mentality pe baat karo.

[@sariyaafseen]

This podcast was just waooooo!🙌 Compelled me to dwell on the different different ideas

[@shivamVids]

Sorry Raj, It is just a normal thought. In this video, we can easily see the comparison between the professional IAS person and a normal person for the way they talk, speak, tell, and their mind set. That is, the IAS officer has a great personality in all conditions.

[@srikrishnadentalcare4416]

Nice one Raj, authentic, ask if you don't know/understand. Be humble. Also continuous improvement - - Kaizen 👍 तितिक्षा M.S.Dhoni 💐

[@hellosikha]

Such a great podcast ❤ I love his podcasts....most importantly he don't get goosebumps in each answer 🥲

[@ranjuchhetri2534]

You know govt nowadays is only promoting the uperr class sector like big States and city but they are still unknown about what's going in the very grassroot level.I am from a village and i know what type of system is in a village..it's totally corrupted ..you should make podcast regarding this issue.

[@mostlymi9963]

British did not create the state governments setup. Lets face it, we indians are very chaotic and hate planning so things are definitely bad in villages, small towns. Basics like water, power, drainage, law and order continue to stay missing.

[@ranjuchhetri2534]

@@mostlymi9963 yes i agree 👍

[@giridharbangalore7162]

Very good discussion., Simple but profound personolity of Mr. Vivek atray., also a good tips for communication, Enjoyed the vedeo.. Thanks.

[@afifanaz1909]

Can you please bring Sonam wangchuk and talk about their school SEMCOL.. and teaching methodology, ideas, admission process, teachers and many more thing.

[@thrustydraculla15]

Ias banene se desh ka bhgya balta to 70 sal se hazaro ban rhee,desh ka future sirf aur sirf industrialist badal sakte hai

[@ashleshwankhade9482]

Ask more questions related to political pressure on Officers and How They Handles it.

[@mostlymi9963]

I was not IAS, but immense political pressure from all parties, some threatening. Associations and courts dont save you. The widely accepted belief that laws do not apply to politicians is responsible for 80% of the corruption, mismanagement and delays in public work. Remaining 20% is incompetence and lack of professionalism among bureacrats.

[@quotation1716]

Can u believe,I never seen professor on podcast,,,even u know ther re top in whole world than ias❤

[@amanbuttar8634]

Punjab has done better in Asian games than the previous times, which is second most medal taker after Haryana even after facing the drug and mass migration problems. Also, there were 10 hockey players just from Punjab itself played for the Indian hockey team which won gold medal in asian games.

[@govindcharan7827]

Dude listen , you are amazing at this u let the guests speak and atleast try to match the level and be on the same page as guest unlike many other podcasters (jinko bas bhooth ke bare mein janna hai sabse) . One request , just increase the frequency of bringing well known guests to your show.

[@shivamkumarsingh8668]

Nice podcast shamani bhai

[@rajshamani]

thank you shivam bhai

[@BabulKaji-d6s]

Corruption is deeply rooted from doorkeeper yani percent pattawala To top person

[@Harry-10]

You can really see how educated he is and well spoken he is,which you kind of expect from an ias officer and im personally impressed with his vocabulary in English this is coming from and english honours student😂 there are some words which he said even i have to scramble to a dictionary for an answer😂

[@ajaymuktan162]

What a brilliant IAS officer 🙏

[@deepakchandrawanshi3408]

K Annamalai sir ko leke aao podcast me ❤

[@modularkitchenbaroda]

About tourism points very to the point... sir

[@chinnu8330]

SBI employees are still very unprofessional and rude with customers

[@primedash07]

Had a great learning time watching this podcast 👌

[@rajshamani]

Thanks for watching🙌

[@kiranmaurya6943]

Bingo ...tourism is 1sector I am looking to invest all because of its potential. 2breaks annually is minimum in last 2zens. But there is no 1considerable Indian company on NSE to invest

[@AnkitG12]

Do longer podcasts . Thank you so much.

[@binagupta3308]

These students have taken student route to get in to Canada. They have not gone there to study. Especially Punjab which has this phoren craze from ages. It is a status symbol.

[@amgvlogging4895]

It seems he knows Amit Sangwan from sango life sutras. His points on civil service are same and he has also left govt job and settled in panchkula which amit ji always talks about in his videos.

[@Sukiiya10]

No words that was not to take, really trilled with new ongoing scenes that's happening with and from different individuals. Next up wanna See Sir MS Dhoni.❤ in Sir's Podcast!

[@Stories4u369u]

Bro this podcast was amazing and knowledgeable for upsc aspirants and students. Chhattisgarh se anuj sharma ko invite kijiye Bhai 😊

[@Knowledgexplainer]

They are the steel frame of our country ❤

[@ManojKumar-sy7bw]

😂😂😂😂🙏

[@brharikiran]

The last tip is too good... I noticed the difference in the videos of mine many times.. but the tip to public speaking opened my mind. Atray sir is so fantastic, energetic, content.. most important is convincing...

[@akashkhambhala8484]

I love this podcast You really help the people

[@capt.vinaykumar]

Do a podcast with an army officer instead...... It would be more interesting and informative.

[@shreyapandey3236]

This person is much better than Beer Biceps I don't understand his way of communicating

[@bharatchaudhary7418]

When the tourists arrive in India and leave the airport, the agency starts taking the tourists to nice places across India (chosen in the location website). The traveler can only pay on the government website and fix the payment location as chosen. And the agency works with the government.

[@keerthynair5961]

43:35 Facts about Punjabi music..🎶 no doubt its wonderful ❤

[@mitulbaishya3678]

Raj shamani's body language is quite better than ranveer Allahabadia

[@virajkabbur765]

Superb podcast I normally don't watch such long videos but something about this video, I watched it till the end.

[@sameerazmi3241]

Please take CA sarthak Ahuja in your podcast

[@raunakchauhan1266]

Raj shamani and Ranveer are not same!!! At alllll

[@shrinivasacharya3511]

25:25 that line about performing when it mattered the most hurts more after yesterday’s loss :(

[@ashishkn95]

Read - The Ultimate Goal by Vikram Sood Ex-Chief R&AW. Try to bring him on to your show, if you're lucky he'll show up. He's writing another book, this gives you a chance. Dimag hill jyga book pdh ke, perspective change ho jyga life ka, duniya ko abhi jaisa dekhte ho voh 180 change ho jyga

[@vanshikatiwari8359]

Thanks a lot for these upsc related podcasts. So much good information.

[@vishalbadri4058]

If you are investigating 58 min in this video, please learn something here. :)

[@dbasannar]

What happened when the BSNL ended? Customers don't matter to private players because their main goal is to maximize profits. India and England are not comparable.