IAS Officer Vs Politicians, Coal Scam, Corruption, India & PM Modi - Anil Swarup | FO184 Raj Shamani

[@artsofguruprakash7265]

Policy can be implemented by this 1. Politically acceptable 2. Socially desirable 3. Technological feasible 4. Administativilly duable 5. Financially viable 6. Judicially tenable 7. Environmally sustainable 8. Emotionally relatable

[@SamikshaGoyal-g4k]

Woww dude. Sounds like a poem ❤️

[@manalgarg5580]

*Judicially tenable

[@sohit112]

Likh leta hun upsc mein na aa jayein.

[@wlqpqpqlqmwnhssisjw6055]

this is pure gold

[@mirhadi5453]

yeh issi nai intreviwe mai bola

[@सिंहजी-श7ज]

बहुत ही अच्छा पोडकास्ट था ...कई चीजों को समझने और सीखने का मौका मिला...अच्छे प्रश्न और सटीक/स्पष्ट जबाब..दोनों जनों को धन्यवाद

[@AnkitG12]

What a person with clarity with his every word. He literally has a dynamic thinking .Which we should learn and apply in our daily life.

[@_rohit97]

This ias officer is a bharwa 2 takke ka tattoo

[@Vivan.Kirpal]

I felt the same Ankit. God bless.

[@satyanathmanur]

So happy to listen to Mr. Anil Swarup. We had no occasion to hear an IAS officer of higher rank about their work culture, problems they face. Thank you Anil Sir. Now I have to search for your book and read it.

[@chandrasekharsarmah3010]

Salute to Aniljee. So long one maintain honesty integrity and ready to serve the Nation in positive mindset he only can keep his head high in all situations. Politicians get control on officers who failed to maintain honesty and integrity in true values forgetting that thousands eyes are watching the officers 24x7 hours to find out his weaknesses in any direction.

[@dr.g.kshirude6265]

This is called as commitment, transparency and ownership in respect of position,honesty and positivity. Salute to Anilji.

[@mithilanandmishra9447]

Ye Anil koi masum nahi hai, sab officer ka kaam (99.999%) netaon ke liye dhan ugahi karana aapni vi balley balley, aab koi party join karega

[@delhimom3486]

What salute.....woh sirf aadhe adhoore principled officer hai according to me.....woh apna bachaav karna jaante hain....jin cm ke naam liye.....yogi....mamta etc agar woh itne hi nek khayal rakhte hote to apne states mein woh kab ka badlaav le aate.....yogi ji ki hote hue kya major change aaya hai education mein?

[@rajarshibasu2676]

​@@delhimom3486exactly.... Ye vi chaturakita vi nirbhar h

[@SvayamSharma-sk7be]

@@delhimom3486 i dont know about education lekin safety, major problem thi UP me, yogi jii ke aane ke baad dekho kitna change aaya hai.

[@mayurpatel3001]

It's good work to call IAS officer and share his view on government

[@EffectiveLearning-ek6vo]

India is a third class country thanks IAS

[@veenanayak3194]

Paper mai mafiya nahi o logo dabhang ko bhar se khareed ke unse karvate hai,

[@saurabhshinde3540]

Individual institutions so to say don't come ​under ministerial purview@asoknyft

[@AbhishekSingh-xf1lg]

He is a great personality ❤

[@arifmohammed7810]

Very nice

[@rishisinha629]

Anil Swaroop Sir is very honest, excellent orator & genius administrator. When he was giving his example as Secretary Horticulture in UP, my father used to be Director Horticulture then & my father being very honest, used to have very nice relation with him. Thanks for getting him in your podcast Raj.

[@nelsonmandi8800]

Is liye up me itna bikas hua hai😂😂😂

[@gyaatagyaani6635]

Bikas ka toh nahi pata per vikas shayad hua ho

[@RinkuSaks-pk5xl]

😂😂😂​@@gyaatagyaani6635

[@shalubaghel-gt9gs]

@@gyaatagyaani6635 😂😂

[@harshithagummaraju1373]

He is giving such a crisp and ground level reality based answer which is very useful for aspirants.Why are you interrupting him before the completion of answer😡

[@satyalaxmi3121]

ईमानदारी का फल मीठा होता है बचपन मे पढ़ा सुना आज इनको सुनकर लगा सच है इन साहब को इतनी शोहरत मिली सच्चे होने के कारण ।

[@the-destroyer_gillu]

सच में मैं भी बिल्कुल यही सोच रही थी

[@satheeshsimhachalam7563]

Interviewer is quite an immature person. Not allowing to answer fully and interrupting a lot. However, Anilji was quite eloquent , clear in thoughts. Great to have such officers

[@vikramrenake795]

Yes, that is true

[@theworldofeducation5664]

Yeah bro..thats true..

[@ptarslatinum2806]

Time limitation!!! He has limited time and needs to cover as many topics as possible in that limited time, so no he is not an immature person, there is also a high possibility that the video has gone through a lot of editing and many questions and answers could have been skipped to shorten the video

[@cdtmunishgrewal2625]

True 😂😂

[@53355_]

Kabhi yeti wale podcaster ko dekhna

[@akshitaiyer3268]

Anil Swarup's willingness to share his knowledge and experiences is greatly appreciated. It's evident that he is passionate, and his expertise added immense value to the conversation. Great Podcast

[@ritarose5206]

God bless and protect a very honest and upright IAS officer like Mr Anil Swarup.Thanks Raj for the informative podcast.

[@sahil_sharmaa_]

I have never seen an IAS officer so interesting, you cannot miss even a single minute of this podcast! He kept me so engaged with his talks!

[@theminervatalkies]

there are many IAS, IFS officers who are honest and doing rounds of the court in corruption cases

[@akshaylokhande05]

मन को आकर्षित करनेवाला भाषण है अनिल सर का 👏🏻 बहुत ही सकारात्मक सोच 🙏 अच्छा लगा सुनकर 😊👍

[@djohntalks]

23:44 > In a democracy if an idea has to be implemented on the grassroot level, then it has to be: 1. Politically Acceptable 2. Socially Desirable 3. Technologically Feasible 4. Financially Viable 5. Administratbily Do-able 6. Judicially Tenable ( able to be maintained or defended) against attack or objection - "such a simplistic approach is no longer tenable") 7. Emotionally Relatable 8. Environmentally Sustainable

[@valuja4012]

But 370 was not acceptable by politically 😂😂

[@akhilmehta6806]

​@@valuja4012so??

[@visionop8045]

❤

[@sureshthakur6560]

​@@valuja4012 but it was politically accepted by 90% and not accepted by 1% and those 1% was supported by 9%..so in this election of 2024 all such anti national political powers will be rejected and ruined by the 90%peoole of India..😂😂

[@premm666]

@@valuja4012Final decision of Political acceptability lies with 'We the people of India', not political parties. And people across party ideologies accepted that decision.

[@harishchandrasrivastava8065]

In my view Anil Swaroop ji has been state forward ,bold government public servant. Its good video report with interview along with a different person of beaurocratic domain.

[@rajsinghraj28]

Real heroes of nation....... Hats off to such knowledgeable administrator

[@VikasSingh-YT]

I was in a special purpose vehicle for smart city project in Muzaffarpur Bihar. There I had seen the working of 2 IAS officers from close. One municipal commissioner and other principal secretary of urban development Ministry. My high regards for IAS turned into hate and a belief that IAS officers are arrogant and visionless. But after listening to Anil Ji I am happy there were and there are matured visionary ethical smart and motivated officers also. A good IAS officer can really change the landscape of area under his responsibility. Like Mr. Pratyay Amrit, IAS officer being power and transport secretary really changed the conditions of roads and electricity for good in the state of Bihar.

[@_sk99]

The way Anil Swarup Sir Ji spoke about public administration is quite impressive. I loved his "bold, frank, honest, to-the-point answering and positive mindset approach" attitude. Got to know a lot about the career of civil servants. Unlike other civil officers, he was quite transparent about internal matters. This episode is enough to prove that "people corrupt power, not power corrupts people."

[@apniduniya..8242]

👍बहुत अच्छी शुरुवात की आपने भारत के सभी ब्यूरोक्रेट(कार्यरत और सेवानिवृत) की ऐसे ही इंटरव्यूव जारी रखे..! लोकतंत्र में कार्यपालिक की भूमिका अहम होती है..शुभकामनाएं💐💐

[@Scorpionz009]

Salute to Anil Ji for being true to the service and we need more people like him ❤

[@dxmshivam]

I Having met anil Swaroop sir personally while working with studyiq ias as a growth lead.I had numerous instances of thought provoking conversations with sir.he is a gem and his book " ethical dilemma's of a civil servant" is amazing❤❤🎉 More of his conversations are available in studyiaq ias channel🎉

[@moglie123]

Share link here...

[@pushpendragaur]

What a fantastic honest officer, India needs plenty of officers like him. Hats off to his simplicity and honesty

[@chandrashekharshekhat3328]

A very good talking session with our revered Ex IAS officer Mr Anil Saheb, he is an ideal for aspiring IAS officers for their career. Jai hind N Delhi

[@tusharpasalkar9012]

Bureaucracy should be the next buzzword in India.If we really want to improvise our government policies and implementation which in return strengthen our democracy. I would like to hear more such conversations from IAS officers. ❤

[@Hi_yayawar]

What about higher and highest judiciary?

[@sheelafoodvlog86]

He is very good open minded person...hat's off to you sir..IAS officers like him to spread everywhere in India

[@bhawanasingh557]

बहुत उपयोगी इंटरव्यू, अनिल सर ने बहुत ही उपयोगी जानकारियां दीं।

[@bharatsharma871]

Respect to him Those who gives fokat gyaan on social media Learn from real hard working IAS officers and understand the ground reality Great video

[@NeerabhJoshi-us9tg]

Loved this podcast and hats off to Anil sir for his contribution to the country. You were absolutely clear. Bought your book just now. Looking forward to read them

[@GeekyVicky]

When the interview started, I thought I would not watch it to the end but it got very interesting and I did watch it till the end. So I request everyone to watch this podcast till the end.

[@animesh8869]

This is the first INTERVIEW I found Very INFORMATIVE ! Keep this up @rajshamani

[@manalgarg5580]

In a democracy, in order to implement new ideas, they have to be; 1. Politically acceptable 2. Socially desirable 3. Technologically feasible 4. Financially viable 5. Administativilly doable 6. Judicially tenable 7. Emotionally relatable 8. Environmentally sustainable

[@laxminarayankeshkar5292]

Answers were not clear

[@keshavsingh0]

Womp womp​@@laxminarayankeshkar5292

[@kushkhandelwal8358]

I’ve been following Anil Swarup sir for so long but never have been able to understand him so better!! Hats off to you man - Raj Shamani 🙌🏻

[@kenyusinlosemy]

Sir you are genuine IAS officer of our country. May the Almighty God bless you good health, wisdom, long life and prosperous life in your endeavors.

[@prashantpradhan3220]

A very good conversation and the ex secretary was quite candid, such people are always an inspiration to others and especially to the younger generation.

[@meghanar1603]

I am so invested in your podcasts because you won't limit yourself of topics for the same, all are very helpful for self development and it is so dam knowledgeable, thank you so much Raj shamani

[@iamanjalibisht]

It's great to see officers with a plethora of experience! Keep getting more such officers or defence personnel. It gives us a multidimensional view! 😍✨ Thank you Raj Shamani!

[@rajshamani]

I'm glad this was helpful, do let me know which guest should we invite next? 💫

[@Mahi_thala]

Mahendra Singh Dhoni

[@krsnaunofficial7972]

​@@rajshamani Bro taking too much serious of his quote stay away from negative comments

[@Amitsingh-098]

@@rajshamani Raj Bhai Apka next Guest Dr. Rahil ( Eye Expert ) aap wo question puchna jo Ranveer bhai ne nahi pucha hai [ Apna Team ko Ranveer bhai ka comment section dheakna k liya bolo wahi se kuch question mil jhayaga jo ranveer bhai na nahi pucha Aur Ranveer bhai ka Dr rahil k sath wala podcast dheakna k liya bolo Fir bahut question mil jhayaga] Hamlog ko ya fayad hoga ki wo quest 2nd Time kab na kab aiyange Ranveer bhai k podcast me aap alag question puch loga toh hamlog fast grow karanga. "Lots of love Raj Shamani Bhai"

[@Amitsingh-098]

Raj Bhai Apka next Guest Dr. Rahil ( Eye Expert ) aap wo question puchna jo Ranveer bhai ne nahi pucha hai [ Apna Team ko Ranveer bhai ka comment section dheakna k liya bolo wahi se kuch question mil jhayaga jo ranveer bhai na nahi pucha Aur Ranveer bhai ka Dr rahil k sath wala podcast dheakna k liya bolo Fir bahut question mil jhayaga] Hamlog ko ya fayad hoga ki wo quest 2nd Time kab na kab aiyange Ranveer bhai k podcast me aap alag question puch loga toh hamlog fast grow karanga. "Lots of love Raj Shamani Bhai"

[@Surendrabohrauk]

Now India needs to these kind of IAS officer. Great podcast i learn so many things.❤

[@shellymathur4680]

Loved the clarity and conviction of the guest Mr Anil

[@neelambarijoshi580]

Very nicely explained complex issues. Thanks for bringing this interview with a very intelligent, knowledgeable and top of all a person who truely loves our country. Great🙏🙏

[@dineshchakate8352]

It's really good to know senior level of ias officer interacted with how to handle political influence and work with your great perseverance. ... please keep calling like such a more officer's.

[@niraj2020]

Very good podcast. IAS, IPS, IFS and politicians. Ex judges, bureaucrats, media persons all needed to bring to the show. They are policy makers and audience very curious to know what is going inside the govt.

[@padhlebhai13]

mefia matlab?

[@bhaveshdhake1165]

Mafia bolna chahta hai bhai wo. ​@@padhlebhai13

[@Sunil_13_7]

Irs crying in the corner

[@niraj2020]

@@padhlebhai13 Media typo error auto correction by YT

[@padhlebhai13]

@@niraj2020 Okok

[@yogeshagarwalbhu]

"Excellent podcast! It was a pleasure to learn about the impactful work of Mr. Anil Swarup. We extend our gratitude to all those who work with honesty and integrity. A special thanks to Mr. Anil Swarup, and to Raj Shamani for hosting such an insightful discussion and posing thought-provoking questions."

[@viky1442]

Haven't seen such clarity of thought and expression in a long time. What an administrator.

[@shakuntlasingh1754]

IAS OFFICER IS ONLY NOT SCARED WHEN HE IS CLEAN HIMSELF!

[@vikramaditya007]

साहब को झारखण्ड भेजो... इललीगल minning की दिखा दूंगा.. कि अब भी कितनी होती है... साथ ही सरकारी कोयले को कैसे इललीगली कूड़े के भाव सरकारी बाबू बेचते हैं वो भी दिखा दूंगा !!🤦🏻‍♂️

[@ravimahajan2992]

Theek se suno pehle vo ekdum se nakaar nahi rahe hai... Hoti hai par jis level ki baat chal rahi hai uss level ki nahi hoti

[@DXREVEAL]

Agri ❤

[@aryanshukla994]

Bilkul sahi

[@aryanshukla994]

Police se lekar SP dc tak commission banta h

[@aryanshukla994]

Bada chor ban na h to politic m jao

[@deepakhem]

ईमानदारी बहुत महंगी होती है, और ईमानदार आदमी को बहुत ज्यादा मुश्किलों का सामना करना पड़ता है। पैसों से, परिवार से और समाज से ईमानदार आदमी को हिकारत ही मिलेगी। एकदम बाद में, अंत में, ईमानदार आदमी को ही सुख मिलता है, सुकून मिलता है।

[@mohanrane4133]

this applies also in judiciary....

[@learnenglishwithpallavianand]

One of the best interviews I have watched offlate of Shri Aniji! Very inspiring indeed. Thankyou Raj to and your team for organising this interview.

[@tokujenni6373]

As I am also aspiring to be an admin this video indeed helps me a lot. thank you Brother Raj Shamani for this interview .

[@tauhongngonyen3522]

This is called Real IAS officer.God bless you Sir

[@knowledgedbrains]

Anil sir was just awesome, I am in love with his positive energy.

[@Nitrocarbon]

he is such a gem attended one of his sessions in hyderabad 2 months back . he really inspired and made a mark on me

[@aloksharma9994]

Awesome knowledge and clarity of the IAS officer- very impressive.

[@prakashbhatt1875]

Wow...IAS officer should be like Anil sir..what an intellectual person he is

[@Pravinkummar33]

He is a fantastic man, knowledge, fearless, truthful.

[@mr.malviya_]

This video is very important, giving a better perspective, at the end it's us what we do do and attract!

[@dlochani]

What a brilliant insight by a person who has played such an important role on ground for India. He is so crystal clear and specific in what ever he spoke. Keep up the good work Raj. Kudos to you and your team for putting up with this great show. All the best.

[@PertinYameng-cz6fs]

Having an Brave IAS officer Made indian proud.. Raj bro great job.. Once again indian Government reality dhoot ka dhoot pani ka pani.. Brave and open minded straight forward IAS officer! Send him to Arunachal Pradesh, all corrupted politician will be severing..

[@gokulanandabehera542]

अर्ध शत्य i had seen when I was in college in 1983. Very nice movie of Om Puri, Smita, shadashiva. Anil saheb told bitter truth, one is to be happy to go any work place ,work hard and should enjoy the work. Never be obliged to leaders. We must think if someone has to go to such inconvenient why not me .

[@amankumarshah103]

what a great conversation, I wish that it would continue for long. Great👍

[@Shashank.30]

thanks man it was great conversation, and thankyou anil sir for sharing such an rich experience of your career with us

[@prasadpatil5506]

His Honesty is beyond the ages ❤

[@drmdehsan022]

बहुत अच्छा लगा..सलाम सर....बस एक प्रश्न पिछे छूट गया ...BJP सरकार के मंत्री पे भ्रष्टाचार के आरोप कैसे लग सकते है जबकि UPA सरकार के तो सारे भ्रष्टाचारी मंत्री NDA सरकार मे जाकर साफ सुथरे इमानदार हो जाते है ।

[@Iam_12395]

इसलिए तुम अभी तक जाहिल ही रह गए

[@chetansrivastava1111]

Run your propaganda somewhere else. Even during UPA tenure, their ministers used to go to jail for corruption and even till date, their ministers go to jail for corruption. The hunger of Congress and its alliance never ends. 🙏🏽

[@pushpachoudhary408]

Apne sayad suna nhi thik se ,unhone kaha UPA sarkar me har koi raja tha means kab har insaan ke hath me faisla lene ki takat hoti h to wo apna swarth pahle dekhta h or ab har faisla sirf PMO leta h , to jab kisi ko faisla lene ka power hi nhi to wo kese brashtachar karega ..jab ek family me 4 bete h lekin faisla sirf papa karenge to equal karenge or wahin har bete ko faisla lene ka adhikar hoga to wo pahle apne bivi baccho ka heet dekhega or pita ko or bhaiyon ke sath dhokha karega

[@kuldeepmalviya9877]

I loved this IAS Podcast ❤ He is so clear and concise Officer.

[@cibohomeware-zb1mb]

Very nice to see and hear a honest officer. Thank 😊

[@suryakantgd]

अनिल स्वरूप जी प्रणाम 🙏ऐसे IAS ऑफिसर और मोदीजी कि जोडी Super भारत बनेगा 👍

[@Suv-rat]

Razor-sharp questions but with the softness of cotton! What an Interviewer/host!

[@lavanyachandrabose7453]

I loved this podcast - especially the parameters to execute an idea at ground level in an democracy. Such an true scenario in a true and diverse democracy.

[@AnkushYadav-dg5ty]

Very Inspiring, pragmatic and optimistic person . Really amazed

[@s.k.sampath3712]

Very Informative and knowledgeable person. Many more such interviews required

[@NittinKeni]

Excellent teaching and revelation of IAS working. Anil ji is a role model not only for bureaucrats but also visionary managers and CEOs.

[@rajgurjar5485]

India needs more brave officers like him..🇮🇳

[@monkeymindat]

Sir is a gem, don't ask dull questions brother Raj

[@himanigupta2662]

My Learnings: 1) Do not expect anything from others if you wish to have freedom in your life because there is always a price to pay. 2) Live by your own set of rules and be consistent with that. 3) Take adverse situations as a challenge and do whatever comes your way with confidence and happiness. This was an amazing session. I heard Anil sir for the first time and I am glad to hear from someone with so much clarity and experience ❤❤❤

[@pradipbhattacharyya3968]

Every government officer should listen to this podcast. Then they will realize how to deal with corrupt politicians. At the end of the day, politicians come and go, but one can only transfer an honest civil servant. And nowadays due to the internet, no place is distant or remote.

[@NischithShetty-so2qp]

What a person.. Truely Inspiring.. Thanks Raj Shamani for the beautiful podcast.

[@sapnasaini3190]

Salute You Anil Sir 🙌 Sir aaj apse sab kuch sahi sikhne ko mila. Thank you very much.🙌🙌🙏🙏 आप का स्वास्थ्य, स्वस्थ रहे, आप ऐसे ही हस्ते रहे। 🙏

[@mahendrathakor4293]

Salute to you sirji. Honestly is the best policy. Thank you 🙏🏽 very much for all the information. 🌎🇮🇳🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟

[@KushagraSingh-d9k]

We need more podcast with top brain like IAS IFS , it's impact our life so meaning full

[@88pianissimo90]

This officer is so energetic and honest.

[@virendrapandey-nd6xu]

कर्तव्य निष्ट अनिल जी हैं, जो भी ईमानदार अफसर हैं उनको सहूलियत से मतलब नहीं होता ओ अपने जीवन काल अपने निर्णय लिया करते हैं

[@jitendrakaya8808]

Kya bat hai best interviewer and bold interviewee. Best program thanks🌹

[@PrakashPalnkar]

ऐसेही कामगार और नामदार होने चाहिये... धन्यवाद....आशा.

[@AlokKumar-sr3cq]

No daily basis corruption is happening in any district without support from IAS ips

[@akshay_persona]

Mastermind is your MP + MLA 🤡

[@techtorialguy1783]

​@@akshay_personaBullshit, IAS are solely responsible for corruption at the higher level, no MP, MLA has any say in how much a tehsildar or a DM charges for clearing payments to contractors or for issuing contracts, at least MP, MLAs are controlled by public with voting happening every 5 years, no one controls these IAS, IPS!

[@allwynrodrigues]

huge respect to Shri Swarup , just positive person

[@jass5184]

Such a charming and lively personality.. need more podcast with him

[@sksofiurrahaman]

India truly needs more IAS/IPS officers like this!

[@IndianFirst1]

Such bureaucrats should come out and share their point of view on different issues. Also the challenges in their service.

[@HighwayContracting]

Very well said sir. 👏 We need more people like you ❤ Jai Hind ❤

[@unique_0819]

Now dhurv's, mohak's and deshbhakt's followers will come and say that sir is also an andhbhakt😂😂😂

[@saumyasarkar1982]

Hum hain andhbhakt....jisko Jo bolna hai bolne do....Chapri KZbinrs ki baat sirf chapri log hi sunte hain.... Tension na lo bhai, aise chapri hamare desh mein bohot milenge

[@_yash_ym]

Areyyy German shepherd hmara desh bachane aaya hai...

[@Diamondshades]

​@@saumyasarkar1982 "aise chapri hamare desh mein bohot melinge"? 🤣🤣 ap be hoh chapri😂😂

[@saumyasarkar1982]

@@Diamondshades burnol laga le.... Tera chapri KZbinr Dhruv Rathee bhi yehi lagata hai 🤣🤣🤣

[@frenzy_mind]

I agree dhruv and deshbhakt is taking one but i am not agree with mohak Mangal

[@prodoshkumardas7733]

Too good🎉🎉🎉... Both the guest & the host match each other's excellence!!!!!

[@rajshamani]

Thanks man!! 🙌

[@charuchandradiwan192]

Nice talk.An honest IAS officer not doing unlawful work of a politician can maximum get transfer,not even suspension.

[@shubhamkumarsoni56]

Waoo what a personality of Anil sir, Amazing💯☀️

[@afritbagani]

23:46 the line my god ❤, that's the real educated man

[@jayjony]

Lovely listening Mr. Anil Swarup. His insight, his approach and interpretation towards the civil service job is tremendous. A lot learn from a champion in this field.

[@AnjaliGore-f9t]

It was so nice talk n inspiring to whole young generation.... Sir is so positive from first to last.... N transferring the same energy. Thanks Raj for this podcast. 😊

[@aradhnatyagi4833]

Glad to see such efficient bureaucrats of our country.Thanks Raj for inviting such eloquent & grass root officer.❤

[@hareshkothari3046]

Anil swaroop is an ideal combination of psychology n iq level...

[@rohansogani]

I would like to see this person holding any of the ministries in the next government…he is just amazing…wish we have more such officers/politicians at the helm