Do Prophets Need to be Perfect? Different Answers in the Qur'an and the Bible

[@Megaritz]

I have a question for clarification-- Didn't some prophets sin, even in Islam? My understanding is that at least a few prophets sinned at least once, such as Adam who was called a prophet yet he was still kicked out of the Garden of Eden. So I'm confused on this. Nevertheless I do appreciate the discussion of how conceptions of prophethood differ between Islam and the Jewish & Christian accounts.

[@Megaritz]

@@mostarac7297 Interesting, thanks for your perspective. And I really liked your long comment as well (the one that begins with "I really would like to ask both"), it makes several useful distinctions and arguments and gave me a lot to think on.

[@unknownpng650]

arent you doing the same thing you are criticising ,doing a tafssir for the quran ? if you claim that youdont and you only report what the quran says then the muslim mufassiroun will say the same thing and i hope you speak arabic at least to make this huge assertions @@mostarac7297

[@eatingeatingeating]

@@mostarac7297 While it is true that Lott is not called righteous in the Jewish Bible, he is in the New Testament: "and delivered righteous Lot, who was oppressed by the filthy conduct of the wicked" (2 Peter 2:7)

[@declansceltic198]

Interesting video! Catholic here, so obviously our stance is known 😅

[@zdmsr]

I like how they are portrayed as realistic flawed humans but sometimes they do things that are unrealisticly flawed ! haha

[@eatingeatingeating]

While it is true that Lot is not called righteous in the Jewish Bible, he is in the New Testament: "and delivered righteous Lot, who was oppressed by the filthy conduct of the wicked" (2 Peter 2:7)

[@fahnikan]

I think you are mainly talking about the sunnah and the Muslim traditions (and not the Quran). It is true that the image of the prophets in the Torah are more human (less angelic), but the Quran refers to the mistakes of the prophets too. There is a Sunni movement believing that the prophets (including prophet Muhammad) are not infallible in matters other than receiving God's revelation and it uses the Quran to show it. Here are a few examples: عبس وتولى. أن جاءه الأعمى. وما يدريك لعله يزكى وذا النون إذ ذهب مغاضبا فظن أن لن نقدر عليه ولا تكن كصاحب الحوت إذ نادى وهو مكظوم ووجدك ضالا فهدى ووضعنا عنك وزرك الذي أنقض ظهرك يا أيها النبي لم تحرم ما أحل الله لك تبتغي مرضاة أزواجك والله غفور رحيم قل إنما أنا بشر مثلكم يوحى إلي

[@slashmonkey8545]

Couldn't the verses you show be explained away as minor sins. I have never heard of frowning being Haram.

[@tonymason8606]

3 sets of adds in just over 4 minutes. I turned it off. Thanks KZbin

[@fairooslebbe3000]

Other category is messengers

[@chrisazure1624]

I was hoping they would discuss muhammad's sins discussed in the Quran.

[@shahirnaseri9722]

Can you tell me a few? I have read The Holy Quran and have not found one?

[@chrisazure1624]

@shahirnaseri9722 You haven't read the Quran if you have ignored Muhamnad saying he had to repent of his sins.

[@shahirnaseri9722]

Can you please tell me the verse? And what sins was he referring to ?

[@chrisazure1624]

@shahirnaseri9722 I'm on my phone. Searching is not convenient. Look it up yourself. Muhammed's sins are not outlined in the Quarn. It just says muhammad needed to repent of his sins. So your prophet was a sinner. We just don't know how bad until we get to the hadith.

[@IslamOriginal14]

He is infallible. You don't understand

[@ResearcherB]

Myths and mythologies always have many versions.

[@berdigylychrejepbayev7503]

ooo really. everything can have different versions mate. read some advanced things other than child fairytales

[@TruthSpeaker.]

@@berdigylychrejepbayev7503 Well, the topic being discussed in this video is about mythology.

[@Kuuzie1]

😅

[@AbdulHannanAbdulMatheen]

👏🙂

[@overmanonfire]

To work for the government, you need a clear record. To work for God, you do not need one? A miserable attempt to defend the disgrace attributed to prophets in the Bible. يا أيها الرجل الْمُعَلِّمُ غَيْرَهُ هَلَّا لِنَفْسِك كَانَ ذَا التَّعْلِيمُ تَصِفُ الدَّوَاءَ لِذِي السِّقَامِ وَذِي الضَّنَى كَيْمَا يَصِحَّ بِهِ وَأَنْتَ سَقِيمُ ابْدَأْ بِنَفْسِك فَانْهَهَا عَنْ غَيِّهَا فَإِذَا انْتَهَتْ عَنْهُ فَأَنْتَ حَكِيمُ فَهُنَاكَ تُعْذَرُ إنْ وَعَظْتَ وَيُقْتَدَى بِالْقَوْلِ مِنْك وَيحصل التسليمُ لَا تَنْهَ عَنْ خُلُقٍ وَتَأْتِيَ مِثْلَهُ عَارٌ عَلَيْك إذَا فَعَلْت عَظِيمُ - أبو الأسود الدؤلي

[@declansceltic198]

If you make mistakes at your job, you’ll often be fired Don’t Muslims admit prophet make mistakes?

[@hackbounties114]

"To work for the government, you need a clear record." False premise.

[@atiharsh1993]

The lady seems very confused about almost everything even about Jewish bible let alone Qur'an..

[@paulthomas281]

@atiharsh1993 What exactly is confused about her points?

[@KhanKhan-uw4gr]

she is fumbling bro@@paulthomas281

[@omarelmorsy139]

As a muslim prophets can make sins but not major sins,and that make sense because they are our role models,but in Christianity they do major sins just make sins like murder,adultery or even incest,why would i follow a man or taking him as my role model if he is that bad couldn't god choose anybody who is better than him.

[@declansceltic198]

We don’t follow the prophets, we follow the message they delivered - and they aren’t our role models, they’re simply men and women God chose to deliver His message

[@omarelmorsy139]

@declansutherland8526 if you met some one who claims to be a man of god and you found out that he committed a major sin will you still follow his message

[@declansceltic198]

@@omarelmorsy139 The message doesn’t belong to him, it belongs to God - so yes? If Muhammad sinned it doesn’t automatically mean the Quran he delivered is wrong, that should be obvious

[@ft7730]

Prophets do sin 47:19 And one of the reasons they become role model is because they are repentant 11:75

[@omarelmorsy139]

@ft7730 oh sorry I forgot I will edit the comment,yes prophets do sins (minor sins) but god protected them from doing a major sins