"Exposing Cultural Insanity" | Piers Morgan vs Professor Gad Saad On Sydney Sweeney And Elon Musk

[@grantman1148]

Most of the discussion of Gaza (95%+?) is about Israel's actions. I've yet to hear anyone speak about calling for the unconditional surrender of Hamas and the release of the hostages. It's quite simple, really. If they were to surrender and release the hostages, Israel would cease its bombing. No more babies killed. Why is there so little discussion about Hamas and their responsibility for the mess?

[@Sneakyhorse12]

The rest of the world hates the Palestinians and want them subdued , even the other Muslims countries, they want to live like civilised humans , how could you ever feel safe with that problem in your area, They are mouthing their support for Palestine while providing weapons to Israel to make themselves seem a little nicer.

[@chuletaization]

Hamas said they will release all hostages if Israel releases their hostages. We never hear about Israel's hostages only Hamas hostages. Surrender in this case is tantamont to suicide. Israel said they will kill every Hamas fighter. The goal is to annihilate them. IDF killed escaped Jewish hostages who tried to surrender. Hamas fighters know they will be executed or jailed and tortured for life if they surrender. Would you under those circunstances?

[@ams914]

@@chuletaization You've similarly done EXACTLY what the OP described by pivoting away from Hamas, towards Israel. Let me clear things up for you. Before October 7th, the only prisoners Israel held, were all terrorists/enemy combatants. The hostages Hamas took were all civilians. Any civilian Israel took "hostage" (they are not hostages, but prisoners, which is a distinct difference) were affiliated with terrorists in one way or another. You can also be assured that the way Israel treats them is leagues better than how Hamas treats theirs. I am also pretty sure that some amount of them were rescued by Israel because they have no family and were defacto orphans, but I can't confirm that. What I do know is that when you investigate, what you will find is that Israel has good reasons to do nearly everything it does. Israel is also the kind of nation that will release a hundred terrorists for the release of merely one of their civilians. There is no moral equivalence between the two sides, and the way that people have spectacularly face planted in moral terms, on this issue, makes me lose all faith for humanity. The OPs point absolutely stands. People like you have totally absolved Hamas in this war, while placing all the responsibility on Israel. Good thing Israel isn't going to do what you want. They'll do what is in the interest of protecting their own people.

[@algernonsidney8746]

Hamas has offered to release all the hostages in exchange for a ceasefire and the Israeli government refused. Furthermore Hamas' horrific crimes on October 7 and it's refusal to unconditionally release the hostages does not morally justify's Israel's murdering of civilians.

[@RalphBoyshline]

You expect any hostage takers to surrender and commit collective suicide? Get real!

[@Justpeace88]

Professor Saad is wonderful. ❤

[@johnsheehy4192]

He is part of a pseudo-intellectual movement that projects most of the world's problems onto Muslims, completely ignoring the fact that the Judeo-Christian Western governments have been messing with Muslim lands for many decades.

[@omp199]

Wonderfully dishonest, as it turns out. Jonathan Glazer did not reject his own Jewishness, as Saad claims. He rejected the hijacking of his Jewishness to justify the actions of Israel in Gaza. He worded it very badly - it is a shame that professional screenwriter Jonathan Glazer has such a poor command of the English language - but that is clearly what he meant.

[@Justpeace88]

@@omp199 That's nice for you. 🇬🇧💙🇮🇱

[@Justpeace88]

@@omp199 That's nice for you. 🇬🇧💙🇮🇱

[@shelleys2769]

he looks like Basem i was so confused for a moment🤣

[@antbrown9066]

Me too!

[@brandenheath1275]

I love how Piers acts neutral. He definitely isn't.

[@thethinkingman-]

maybe he is against raping women and beheading babies! just saying.

[@devilback8871]

You know who is neutral, the muslims are neutral AF, I mean i have never seen more neutral people than the peaceful muslims. So peaceful, so peace loving the muslims are, whereever they go they bring peace and harmony and ofcourse most of the sceintist are muslims today. Such innocent zombies they are 🥲🥲🥲🥲

[@TheLastAngryMan01]

But he has a moral quandary! /S

[@PancakeProduct]

Controlled opposition.

[@damienkearns3654]

Nobody is, some of us can be fair and make obvious how we really feel while understanding an opposite opinion but you stand a certain way on every topic. It's like believing FOX News with their Fair and Balanced claim. They were built to oppose Dems mouthpiece CNN.

[@soilmanted]

I didn't hear Glaser say he was "rejecting my Jewish identity" as Gad claimed. I heard Glaser say "i refute their Jewishness... being hijacked by an occupation [of Gaza by the Israeli military] that has lead to conflict for so many innocent people." Glaser didn't say he was rejecting his Jewish identity as Gad claimed; he said he didn't want his Jewishness, and the holocaust, being hijacked by a military occupation of Gaza. I'm not sure what exactly that means. Sounded rather vague to me. But the gist of it seemed to be that he was indeed Jewish, and that the Jewishness of a nation and the history of Jews having suffered through the holocaust, wasn't sufficient reason for a Jewish nation to occupy another nation, Gaza. Cannot Gad and Piers understand English. Refuting the use of one's ethnicity as a rationale for doing something, is not the same as rejecting one's ethnicity.

[@RobPires]

It is typical hasbra mental gymnastics.

[@donlavacha1968]

Gaza wasnt occupied you nazzi imbacile

[@politefan8141]

When pro Palestinian activists talk about occupation, they are referring to the entire state of Israel, not just Gaza. His speech being vague is precisely the problem and odd coming from someone so concerned about their message being hijacked.

[@RobPires]

⁠​⁠​⁠@@politefan8141Where is your proof that most Palestinian activists mean the whole of Israel when referring to occupation?

[@DZ-wk9hv]

No he did not. He said “we are 3 men that refute their Jewishness AND the holocaust being hijacked”

[@Bravemouth2]

He didn’t say he refuted his Jewishness. You didn’t listen . You just wanted to hear your own voice.

[@TheMythMaiden]

I turned to my husband and said what we were both thinking: "Sydney Sweeney is gorgeous." He agreed and we moved on. LOL No sense pretending she isn't

[@jurassicthunder]

doesn't change the fact that she's a 304. don't give me the "but its art" crap.

[@bertieboo]

Yep us too. Only those in secure relationships are able to see her for what she is, a beautiful woman x

[@jimferris9447]

@@jurassicthunderA “304”?

[@foto21]

She isn't just good looking, she's a total heterosexual sexpot, IN DECENT SHAPE, YOUNG and blonde. That's what the modern idiots can't handle.

[@tubetorpedo]

Same as with e.g. Henry Cavill. Guy looks pretty great, there is hard to deny that. I think both women and men are able to note that. And then life goes on.

[@BiragovDetailing]

That was fun interview!!👍🏼

[@vadimbecker9934]

What a great personality this Gad Saad is!!!

[@Joe-ym6bw]

I agree

[@coolhand1966]

Morgan was sacked at the Daily Mirror for publishing fake photos of British troops abusing Iraqi detainees. Morgan refused to apologies. Should Morgan be cancelled?

[@Allycat828]

Absolutely yes

[@Allycat828]

He still owes all Muslim women an apology

[@EveMe-y4t]

we all know that Iraqis were abused by British and American troops .... and about a million Iraqis were killed due to a lie .... the British gvt should be cancelled

[@artn2950]

?????

[@jojowynne233]

He was sacked in 2004 for the publication of supposedly fake photos. Back then The Mirror and Piers sat on those photos for 3 months while they were investigating the stories of abuse of civilian detainees. The photos were even shown to the Ministry of Defence for confirmation. The Ministry did not believe they were fake at all. So they were published. After some time there were allegations that the photos were faked and The Daily Mirror had been hoaxed. An apology from the paper was issued but not from Piers who was fired. Here’s what else happened. There was a Royal Investigation into the issue of British and other soldiers abusing civilian Iraqi detainees. Several were court-martialled and found guilty. It was happening. As for the original photos that were meant to be fake, no one has ever proven this claim. No one has ever been charged either. In 2004 it would’ve been more difficult to prove or disprove but I’m sure they’d be able to tell using today’s technology. I thought I’d put the facts in because they shed a different light than a couple of sentences. I don’t blame Piers for not apologising. He had the photos confirmed by the Ministry of Defence and still to this day no one can authenticate a fake. 😀

[@osarumwenseobasohan7863]

When Piers asked him if killing of parents and relatives of these Gaza children would lead to more hatred from Israelis, he tactfully avoided answering the question and chose rather to ask how else should they have responded to the oct 7 attacks.

[@eemoogee160]

Cowardly

[@cynthiacools-lartigue5297]

Gaad Sad is a much needed voice of sanity today in a world sadly missing common sense.

[@loupasternak]

lemon is what they call a 'shmuck'

[@vampfashions]

But only a very tiny, insignificant one..

[@MrVvulf]

People like Lemon were described by Booker T. Washington over 100 years ago - “There is another class of coloured people who make a business of keeping the troubles, the wrongs, and the hardships of the Negro race before the public. Having learned that they are able to make a living out of their troubles, they have grown into the settled habit of advertising their wrongs - partly because they want sympathy and partly because it pays. Some of these people do not want the Negro to lose his grievances, because they do not want to lose their jobs.” ― written by Booker T. Washington in 1911

[@Fyrst-kk2ff]

One of my VERY FAVORIT ☝️Gad Saad 👍 ❤🌺🇮🇱🕯🇮🇱🌺❤️ Denmark 🇩🇰

[@frisbeeking7002]

as a Lebanese, I'm proud to discover that this guy is lebanese. Finally someone with enough balls to say the truth!

[@LisaD-yy4gq]

The truth? He only knows how to lie.

[@frisbeeking7002]

@@LisaD-yy4gq you seem to be lacking an IQ digit there maam.

[@shb8053]

What happened to the Jews in Lebanon??

[@blairmulhall9259]

Those Oct 7 GoPro videos should be in the public domain. They would change many minds.

[@annlolmaugh4491]

I don't think I could emotionally handle seeing the videos of Oct 7th.

[@alicee2952]

The first week after the massacre I was getting information from left media that the atrocities claims didn’t happen. So for a hot minute I was duped. However, hearing about the videos and what took place I sought it out and my mind changed on the matter. Hamas is 100 percent a terrorist group. In fact, they are an arm of the Muslim brotherhood. Of course I have seen bombed buildings and dead Palestinians but it comes down to Hamas and how they operate. There could release the hostages and put their hands up but no way when they are winning this soft war for getting more Palestinians killed. They want dead Palestinians, martyrs as they call them.

[@gmw3083]

They show that Israelies

[@zaza_268]

No it won’t. Bc it’s 1200 vs 30k. No moral equivalency

[@TheNedlin]

Watching news from Gaza every day so I guess it’s about killing the innocent people ?

[@royhardy407]

Mr Saad. What an intelligent and learned man, a pleasure to listen to..

[@captainz9]

Just an aside, a decade or so ago my then 80yo parents (91 now) were showing us pictures of their last (as it happens close to last really adventurous vacation) to Peru - and my mom joked at the parade pictures of let's just say busty young women in bikini tops and glittery tassel skirts dancing down the street "your dad really liked the hot young women"...we all laughed and my dad turned red embarrassed, but let's be honest - she's smart enough to know men look at beautiful women. They're married 65+ years now and still love each other (and we worry how she'll handle it when he dies - likely before her)... Not like the young dancers are a real threat to her and their marriage.

[@KarenL810]

I suppose Mehdi Hasan being granted an interview with Elon Musk is totally out of the question then...

[@michaelxz1305]

the guy is a tool.. I never watched a full show on MSNBC (who would watch a full show of anything on MSNBC) but the clips from his show are horrible. the guy is a hack.

[@paulgrant666]

good. mehdi is a total shill

[@stevensica5918]

No. EM knows better.

[@caratheresehodge4255]

innocent babies and children dying in incubators from no oxygen and food is evil and absolutely morally equivalent to another evil. evil is evil

[@markbisson6166]

Um, no. Babies dying in incubators is absolutely not morally equivalent to the holocaust.

[@AbdulSoomro-kj5lt]

Gad Saad is a Jew; what you expect

[@jerzystecher]

Fake news

[@LisaD-yy4gq]

Its not fake. ​@@jerzystecher

[@jerzystecher]

@@LisaD-yy4gq Totally fake, how do you know, are you in Gaza ? Because I have my sources right from there.

[@ag225-ml]

Piers repeatedly puts anti-black zionists on his show.

[@pf1830]

Good interview with someone way above your own paygrade. You did OK, smugness and all😮 Brilliant great man Gad !

[@reezlaw]

Elon said "I could care less". He really _has_ become American

[@masterq2.033]

If he starts talking in imperial vs metric, it's over?

[@reezlaw]

@@masterq2.033 I think he already has

[@jurassicthunder]

i could care less means caring a lil

[@schyllic]

The n’t is implied

[@kaoskronostyche9939]

If you want the phrase to make sense it should be "I could not care less." So maybe he is well on his way to being an ignorant American who does not know how to use English. This would not fly in Canada or any other literate nation.

[@user-ke8st8jc1v]

The hatred of Jews is been around for centuries and was never able to be eradicated

[@michaelwolfe913]

My first time listening to Gad Saad. I hope my first impression is wrong. Glazer said they "refute their Jewishness and the Holocaust being hijacked by" something that they are opposed to. This makes me think Saad isn't very exact or thorough in his thinking. Or perhaps he is even being willfully dishonest. Piers, Saad and the people who signed the petition denouncing Glazer's Oscar speech are all distorting what Glazer said!!! What he said is quite clear and easy to comprehend. Yet these people all react as though they are hearing the opposite of what he intended. The man just made the film "The Zone of Interest" for god's sake!!! There could not be a more clear statement or confirmation of his Jewishness!!!! This distortion of his oscar speech is typical of today's media and internet media world of chaos, distortion, misinformation and fractured, flawed perspectives. Glad to see I'm not alone in my reaction. May Zeus help us!

[@eemoogee160]

He's a propagandist

[@markmorgan32]

Prof Gad Saad is a rational voice in a world full of craziness!

[@jladdyost]

The cure for Dylan Mulvaney is to ignore Dylan Mulvaney.

[@playlynx82doherty47]

For Piers Morgan to not correct him when he lied about "he rejects his Jewishness" just shows his one sidedness.

[@wescolumbus621]

Saad is fun. He is not Israeli, has never served in the army, so he is an expert on the issue, say, like journalist, Douglas Murray. Israelould have bombed Gaza flat. Instead, knowing that Hamas is using its population in the most despeakable way, Israel is risking its best young men and women (and some dogs) to try to save Palestinian lives. Hamas is also lying about the numbers, just has it has a Palliwood industry with horror, oppression shows (like body bags which suddenly get up to make a phone call). So Saad could easily learn a bit (if he wants to watch Richard Kemp, for instance).

[@carefreedelight2355]

And Israel do not have to do this as they are NOT fighting a trained army . They are fighting terrorists or ‘ Liberation fighters’ if you want to be romantic! Israel is not bound by the Geneva Convention in how it is dealing with Hamas’ prisoners. They are not the official soldiers of GAZA.

[@beaverking69]

Love Gad, genius and sardonic comedic commentary, I can listen to him for hours. All the best to you Sir. From a fellow Gooner!!

[@RickCarroll-Canada]

Thanks Piers. Nice to see my fellow Canadian Gad Saad. All the best.

[@makaveli_DK]

Canadian😂🫶

[@contemplatinghistory]

Gaad "The Canadian" Mossad

[@thefalsifiablepodcast]

Gad Saad is completely captured by his audience. If he speaks truth, it’s by mistake. He simply tries to say whatever his small audience wants to hear.

[@SmokeyEternal]

"If he speaks truth, it's by mistake" what a brilliant way to falsely discredit someone. Amazing.

[@jenniferteff]

Piers, if the hatred of Israel was only in response to Israeli aggression, Israel wouldn’t have been attacked in 1948 or in any other war. Why do you not worry about Israelis hating Palestinians for how we have been attacked in 1929 in Hebron, 1936-1939, 1948, 1956, 1967, 1973, 1991, the 1st & 2nd intifada, and now Oct. 7th. Do you expect more of Israelis than Palestinians and assume they are too stupid to understand? Isn’t that a bit patronizing of you to expect so little of them?

[@thomasstevens1157]

The Gadfather is one of the best people on Earth at this time, up there with Musk, Douglas Murray, and Thomas Sowell.

[@onegorgeouschick]

Hear, Hear

[@davidwatermeyer5421]

If you think that I guess you, like he, are a self-righteous arrogant little person. There is no love in this man. None at all.

[@omp199]

How can you say that Gad Saad is a good person after seeing him be so blatantly dishonest in this very video? If I were to say, "I hate people and their words being misrepresented by dishonest commentators," then going by this display, Gad Saad would respond, "Oh! So you hate people!"

[@go2rakin]

Professor seem to have the Amenesia by saying it all started from 7th October. The bias and ignorance toward a 75 year occupation which is never mentioned just shows the Professor’s views so weightless.

[@tradeprosper5002]

He claims others have forgotten Oct 7, but he appears to have forgotten the Nakba.

[@lvince4910]

@@tradeprosper5002 How many Jews live in Arabic countries? How many used to live in Arabic countries? Why do you speak of the Nakba while ignoring the expulsion of Jews throughout the region? And yes, this war started on 7th October. Gaza was not under an occupation on 6th October. They are now to prevent another 7th October.

[@tradeprosper5002]

@@lvince4910 Yes, the Arab countries did react to the Britain taking what was Arab lands to start Israel. Why wouldn't they?

[@lvince4910]

@@tradeprosper5002 What Arab countries were in control of the Turkish Ottoman Empire? It was only a problem when Jews were given a slice of their historical homeland, as was Britain's right to do with the land under their empire's control. There was no prospect of a free Palestine under the Ottomans, it was the British who granted independence with a 2 state solution that paved the way for the possibility of an independent Arab Palestinian state to exist for the first time in history. The Arabs rejected it, immediately declared war on the Jewish state, and were roundly defeated. The Ottomans lost, the Arabs lost, and Israel has continued to show that anyone who threatens their homeland will be taught the same lesson.

[@tradeprosper5002]

@@lvince4910 Not buying your talking points. When did Britain get the right to give over half of area to 1/3rd of the population? The Arabs rejected the deal, but so did the Jews, since they attacked the Palestinian portion and took control of 78% of the area prior to independence. The Arab states acted in response to the Nakba which had already displaced 100s of thousands. The Israelis simply took the place of the British as the occupying force and the Palestinians were never offered true self determination. The Israelis continued to take lands by placing settlements in occupied territory in violation of international law. Lip service was given to an independent state while it was annexed by Israel and controlled as an apartheid region.

[@MoELKadey]

Gad Saad is truely great, such a reasonable person.

[@lisabain8841]

Very smart guest well done

[@komlat253]

his guest misunderstood the words of a video that was played for him to listen to lol.( i reject my Jewishness) ....bro really ? did he really say that tho? like just replay the clip jeez. he dishonest or literally deaf

[@lisabain8841]

@@Tr444ydc6 whatever ...wave the flag from your safe home ...he only speaks the truth...hate will burn you up

[@omp199]

@@lisabain8841 Why are you not interested in the truth?

[@zeitenwechsel7898]

15:43 Morgens "MMmmh" is the best part in the history of this format. For a second i thought Morgan understands what Saad says. But sadly he doesnt get it. Free Speech is not what he likes.

[@petekorovesis2311]

Every once in a while I click on a Piers Morgan media snippet thinking he might have something intelligent to say. Once again, I'm a schmuck!

[@beagleman123456789]

And a Putz’

[@sinerehber]

🤣👏

[@TheDivayenta]

Not the sharpest knife in the drawer.

[@AndrewKagan]

Piers, you really need to drop this proportionality nonsense, it's akin to that ridiculous "pay your fair share" stuff only nobody knows what share is fair and who decides it. This is war and the goal is to apply overwhelming force to your enemies.

[@fz7694]

That's what Hamas did. So you're supporting their tactics?

[@woodsghost9088]

May the stronger side win. Muslims believe in Allah. Jews believe in their god. Whoever is right will win.

[@fz7694]

@@woodsghost9088 Except it's not side vs side, it's a political group Hamas VS nation states Israel / USA / UK/ France / Germany and politically the entire Western alliance. Are you dumb or just ignorant? I know you're immoral because you took God's name in vain for making a dumb and deceitful point.

[@princessnineva7066]

The greatest existential threat is the departure from reason, Amen!!! Thank you Gad saad as always, brilliant.

[@jacleena]

Good grief, he calls himself an academic and yet doesn't comprehend what Glazer actually said.

[@Stevef2022]

He is an extremely highly regarded academic. Look him up.

[@BlackHeartRC]

@@Stevef2022if he was at any point highly regarded he’s doing his best to make sure that’s no longer the case.

[@Stevef2022]

@@BlackHeartRC PhD from Cornell, international best selling author. I’ll listen to him over you.

[@BlackHeartRC]

@@Stevef2022 I never asked you to listen to me nor do I care if you do. All I said was he’s doing his best to destroy his own credibility. I know very well who he is. Ive listened to him and read the Parasitic Mind in its entirety.

[@Stevef2022]

@@BlackHeartRC How is he destroying his credibility? He has been completely consistent with his approach to social policies, politics and other issues all throughout. His credibility was built on this approach. I suggest you read the book again - you didn’t understand his assertions in the first place.

[@RomanMyshoul85]

The funniest and saddest part of this video is when Don Lemon indirectly referred to himself as a reporter

[@thierryfaquet7405]

And yet still destroyed that clown Musk

[@RomanMyshoul85]

@@thierryfaquet7405 Even if your delusion was true, Don Lemon is NOT a reporter unless you mean reports untruths

[@RomanMyshoul85]

@@thierryfaquet7405 YT won't let me respond to my own thread, just consider yourself very not correct

[@thierryfaquet7405]

@@RomanMyshoul85And I'll consider you a clown...

[@RomanMyshoul85]

@@thierryfaquet7405 I don't care what you call yourself in the mirror. Still doesn't make Lemon head a reporter or the winner of that exchange

[@homebg2163]

The comments here misrepresent what Gad Saad's response was. He says that criticism of Israeli policies is legitimate. Saad is pointing out the ideological Jew hatred in Middle Eastern countries and people don't like it being pointed out. It didn't begin in 1948, it is over 1000 years old. Nearly 900,000 Jews were ethnically cleansed from Arabic countries. There was no UNWRA to assist them.

[@vanman757]

How come that Sydney Sweeney has popped up out of nowhere & is all over the show all of a sudden in loads of films ?! I never even heard her name a couple of weeks ago...

[@ChristinaChrisR]

I have no idea who that is (I will in 20 seconds after I’ve googled it)

[@BecomeUncancellable]

I agree and it's weird. Granted it's the very nature of the media to just make stuff up out of thin air and pretend we all should have known about it.

[@jennifersimons4142]

She must of joined the satanic club

[@aldunlop4622]

It was the fact that she accepted criticism over the failure of Madame Web without blaming fans, as had been done repeatedly by major studios (and Woke cast members) such as Disney over the past few years. Then a few days later she was on SNL and openly mocked the movie.

[@theotheoth]

I had seen her in a couple of dramas that seemed interesting but then descended into soft porn. I had pretty much taken her off my curiosity list, but then accidentally watched 'Reality'. Watch 'Reality.'

[@erikwallden]

what´s the ratio killing combatants (terrorists) vs civilian casualties in the current Gaza war? 1 to1,5 suggests some independent reports. Average warfare since WWII is 1 to 5, urban warfare typically worse. Given this war being fought in urban conditions, what is the IDF doing to keep the innocent casualties so low? It can´t be genocide, or...?

[@chuletaization]

That ratio is based on specious claims that dead Palestinian civilians, men women and children are Hamas fighters. We've heard Israel say there are no civilians in Gaza, that everyone is a Hamas fighter. Great way to gin up fake numbers for Hamas fighters killed. Still waiting to see pics of dead babies hung on clotheslines and pulled out of garbage cans. What happened to the organized mass rape charge? Oh, no evidence for it. Is baldfaced lying an academic major at universities in Israel? So many expert liars and so many jobs for them in the govt and IDF.

[@NibsNiven]

I just lost a lot of respect for Saad. He is justifying collective punishment of innocent children because of Oct. 7th, ignoring the decades of crimes that led up to it.

[@meganlovesresearch5944]

He said he refutes his Jewishness being hijacked. So tired of interviewers not calling that out

[@chriscaldow1644]

As far as I understand it, Elon changed his stance regarding Alex Jones because he doesn’t believe in cancel culture and instead is an advocate of apology and redemption. Alex Jones has apologised on multiple occasions for his egregious remarks regarding the terrible tragedy. And his apologies do indeed seem genuine. We have to be careful that we do not create a police state of absolutism where apology is not enough and redemption is made impossible. Depending on the action or crime of course. Alex’s remarks were horrifyingly wrong and were a gross misjudgment of the event, however he only used words, and he did not murder anyone, and has apologised for his awfully inappropriate comments .

[@JakeWitmer]

And, unlike the NYT and Piers Morgan, Alex Jones has been right about most things he's said, and has done continuous real journalism for 24 years, whereas the NYT has been state propaganda for at least 110 years, since they helped the totalitarian Hamilton Wright push the Harrison Narcotics Act of 1914 through congress, using openly-racist "yellow journalism." ("Cocainized Negroes A New Southern Menace," Feb 08, 1914, NYT)

[@karlpatterson8437]

Apologies could be taken more seriously if the bum paid up on the judgments against him.

[@firstsecond-ft1qg]

Correct

[@Lamarth1]

@@karlpatterson8437 He was sued for the GDP of France. I'm sure he's got that stashed in his sock drawer.

[@Lamarth1]

I'm sure you've seen the clips of Alex Jones' remarks. Right? We should have a direct quote here just so that people without the context can catch up and share a reality based experience. Right? Or is Piers exaggerating the Alex Jones situation in order to participate in a witch hunt?

[@dilvishpa5776]

As horrible as Alex Jones’ behavior is, I do not support his being censored. If you do this, then should you not also censor all those who claim that the US government was responsible for destroying the World Trade Center building, not bin Laden? There is no such thing as “reasonable censorship” or “ethical censorship”.

[@Nidal_Co]

Exactly criticism of Israel or any country is not the same as chanting from the river to the sea

[@jesusk1358]

Except when it's the Isrealis saying it and practising it.

[@D-E-S_8559]

Likudis call for "greater Israel" in their-own charter....

[@adamgates1142]

Great point! 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@Stevef2022]

Criticism of Palestine isn’t racist or Islamophobic

[@ConsciousnessLivesOn]

Imagine you get to sit down with one of the most influential people in the world, and you ask them about bad memes on X.. he's a proper lemon head..

[@shway1]

you wanted softball questions for the nazi billionaire? such a free press

[@MCHRQRD]

WE stand as men who refute their jewishness and....This is one of the exact quotes.

[@Omk16]

Professor Gad Saad is an honest intellectual with unbiased integrity. Rare to come by these days!

[@Nadia_Knows]

My question is 1. How does the IDF identify who is in hamas? They don't have military uniforms and they are said to be hidden amongst the civilian population. So how do you identify them? 2. Does this mean that every young man who is above a certain age could be/Must be a part if Hamas? 3. Then, is their military strategy then to "remove" every single male older than a certain age, for they may cause a threat? Is it that they may potentially, possibly, one day, threaten the safety of Israelis? Remove every boy and man then they'll be done? Sounds an awful like Pharoah to me but for those who disagree with my characterization, can anyone explain how it's any different.? These are the questions I would ask

[@10sodot]

We keep hearing about the Palestinian causalities in the thousands. These numbers haven't been verified only asserted by Hamas. Also the term "children" is often used to invoke sympathy. A person of 12 - 17 yrs for example who trained to fire guns or RPG is actually a combatant. The moment you display hostile intent/acts you sadly make yourself a valid military target according to rules of war.

[@danielledanielledan1]

Em, they are pointing a gun?

[@Bigbanks589]

I'm former IDF special forces and in training as well as just about every well trained army drills into you high intensity shooting scenarios until you are perfect at identifying enemies. Have you ever wondered why women and children aren't evacuated by Palestinians like how most nations do on the eve of an attack? I operated in Gaza for the most part in my time and the failure the west has in grasping the situation is that Palestinians for the most part are not like you, don't think like you, or even other Muslim countries. The West closes their ears when the head of hamas (who basically raised the current adult fighting generation) articulates the ideology of their culture... he said the jews believe in life while they believe in death, and that's why they will win. It's not as if you could claim it's a small %% of the population bc the indoctrinated makeup about 80% Maybe 10% don't have a hatred of jews.... not zionist, not israeli but jews. Go back before 2003, and you'll see when the tactics of combat changed. Hamas learned the PR game and prey upon Western values and moral outrage. Before that airline hijacking and bombs, suicide bombers in tourist areas and having children sneak attack soldiers was their playbook, which looked awful in the publics mind. Now they laugh as they confuse the uninitiated by using the oppressor v oppressed mentality that has captured mainstream thought to achieve PR wins. In 2012 gaza War, they learned from many many PR mistakes, especially when it came to leaked videos and casualty numbers. They put out these videos on the internet at the time showing rows amd rows of the dead and AL Jazeera played it 24/7 but almost immediately a leak occurred and the real footage of the director yelling CUT and they all arose comically. A supposed sniper victim suffering came out, which bc of the lack of education on the journalistic ability it was laughed at as dumb amateur propaganda. They haven't improved much and resort to showing dead children being paraded around to tug your heartstrings or wailing women who've been filmed in combat before acting like babushkas. Ever wonder what kind of person would parade over their heads and shake roughly a green tinged toddler that has obviously been long deceased? I bet you'd be holding your child with the utmost of care of you had to hold them bc of the love, care, and respect Could you ever hold your children or family before you taunted your enemy bc in their heads, that's a win win situations. They vastly overextended the imagination of death numbers by claiming thousands of dead a day. The problem was that afterwards, no one could point to where the "bodies" ended up. It turned out that only a few hundred died, and I'm willing to bet 60% of their numbers are inflated. They also included 17-year-old males who were fighting as children. It's awful, but a 14-year-old with an RPG can do the same damage as a 27-year-old. As far as civilians go as to the claim of innocence... well, maybe look into the evidence of how many participated in the attack and then theft of corpes and homes occurred. I could show you my picturea and videos of how before 2005 during the Real occupation by Israeli forces how gaza thrived and was growing prosperous and how most westerners couldnt understand how when we forcefully moved our own pll out the Civilians elected a known active terrorist organization to rule them. Peace, money, and property rights are western value aren't what they want. As for your question on how they know and will they kill all 14+yr Olds... not really. Special forces do the bulk of the heavy on ground actions, and they are highly skilled and selective. Also, the Intell from Aman and Shin Bet are excellent.

[@Croaker-b4n]

It's damn hard to identify who is in Hamas when they hide behind women and children or pretend to be non-combatants. Yeah , every one of em could be a Hamas member. It ain't right to peg everybody as one, but well they don't do much to combat it. Would you expect the Israelis to drop their arms and walk into gunfire with a smile on their face just to keep things politically correct?

[@cq4fun]

​@@Bigbanks589so you are one of the Russians who joined the IDF based on the chosen religion...hmm ..

[@jamesdellaneve9005]

Piers is confusing freedom of speech with defamation. Two different things.

[@Daniel-lk2gi]

Amnesia of causality… correct Palestinians had their lands taken off them by the British to form a state for Jews!! Why would there not be a response from a people who still feel aggrieved.

[@lvince4910]

The British took over the region from the Ottomans, who took over the region from previous Caliphs, who took over the region from the Romans, who took over the land from the Hebrews, who took over the land from the Canaanites. The British then partitioned the land to give a homeland for the Jewish people and a homeland for the Arabs living in the region. Following the declaration of the State of Israel all of the surrounding Arab nations went to war against the Jewish state and were defeated. The Palestinian lands were controlled by the surrounding Arab nations until they were defeated by Israel in subsequent wars. Israel has been defending it's existence ever since and has conquered land from the surrounding Arab nations during numerous wars. Israel returned the Sinai to Egypt as part of a peace agreement. The Israelis withdrew from Gaza decades ago. The only land occupied by Israelis are buffer zones of strategic importance because they are surrounded by hostile neighbors. Land that they conquered in wars defending their existence. The only time the Arabs in the region were given the opportunity to have control of a land called Palestine was when Britain partitioned the region and proposed a 2 state solution. The Arabs rejected this proposal and so there continues to be no such thing as an independent country called Palestine which has never existed in all of recorded human history. The Palestinians never had land for the British to take from them in the first place. Prior to the British Mandate the land was under Ottoman control, who were centralized in Turkey, a country created by the imperial Turks who originate from the steppes of Eurasia, they are not Arabic people.

[@FireBirdSpinners]

A couple of days ago you had a person saying there are 31k dead non combatants and you didn't challenge him at all !!!! Who is shooting at our soldiers????

[@megret1808]

I’m not an expert but I recall reading that on the eve of the year 1000 delirious young men were seen running through the streets throwing their just severed genitals into open windows. All because it was the expected End of Days.

[@jefftaylor844]

Great guest.

[@jamesdevlin6373]

Total lies.

[@Cidduzzu79]

The real question is why did Elon hired Lemon ???

[@elqord.1118]

Hire

[@BecomeUncancellable]

Elon is a conman that's why. He's pretending to be a free speech conservative for the time being because it's an open market for him to exploit. Lest we forget, he's Mr. EV and Mr. Brain Chip.

[@duncanmil1]

If Israel were on the southern border of the USA And wanted to expand into the USA we would call them illegal

[@LaravelHub]

Grotesque, grotesque, grotesque. What about 75 years of occupation? Or is it just more convenient to start the amnesia-inducing drama from October 7th?

[@worsethanjoerogan8061]

Why do you consider Jews having one tiny state occupation? Arabs have like 20 huge countries. Most of which are corrupt, failed states. Instead of trying to destroy the much richer, more free, more religiously tolerant Israel, maybe they should try improving their own countries.

[@Johnwis-gp9yy]

There is no occupation. There is only evil religious cult designed to hate.

[@Kurtlane]

"Occupation" my foot. You might as well add "genocide, apartheid, aggression, colonialism, neighborhood bully, and a kitchen sink." "The Muslims stole wealth and property of the Armenians for centuries, molested and r...d their women, and finally ex....inated them. If an Armenian would try to live on their ancestral lands, either the Turks or the Kurds would kill them. "The Israelis finally stand up for their rights and form a country, and the Muslims call it theft. I say good for the Jews. I hope they never give up their rights to these intimidating thugs." - Dr. Cruel

[@ziadmadlom8598]

How about freeing Palestinians and giving them equal rights. Worst interview ever. Above comments are right, he completely misrepresented Glazers comments. Some gall to say people have short term memories when Israeli oppression was the single biggest event that destabilised the area

[@alisamacrilla778]

Arabs in israel have equal rights. How about giving jews equal rights within the palestinian territories? or in any arab-muslim country for that matter?

[@miramataija1628]

@@alisamacrilla778 Europeans are tired of being involved in your drama. With all the muslims in Europe it will probably be a new Holocaust in a decade or so. Instead of helping muslims Europe should let jews move here.

[@lvince4910]

Palestinians are free to create a society with equal rights. They would have to remove Hamas from power in Gaza in order to accomplish this, which Israel is trying to do. As far as freeing Palestinians, freeing them from what? From Palestine? Where do they want to go? And who is responsible for freeing them? Israel? Egypt? Jordan? Nations are free to choose who they allow to enter their borders. The citizens of nations are not free to go anywhere they want to go. Does this mean we all need to be freed? Do you need to be freed?

[@shb8053]

Palestine never existed... there is no Palestinian people

[@johnneutralobserver5944]

Great interview & Incredible the madness of the total condemnation of Israel ignoring all manner of factors. Cause cannot be simply obfuscated to sanitise Hamas evils

[@ServingGodandcountry]

Outstanding and remarkable work exposing the truth Gad Saad! 💯 God bless you! 💯✝️🕊🙏❤️🇮🇱

[@BlackHeartRC]

Gad is the definition of pseudo-intellectual. He purposely misrepresents peoples positions and is wildly self-congratulatory on his 4 pixel analysis of this conflict.

[@contemplatinghistory]

He is a self admitted Mossad asset to spread Israeli influence in Canada.

[@davedalton1273]

So, two pretty rich guys, fawning over an ENORMOUSLY rich guy. Not MY cup of tea.

[@jamesdeighan7524]

Normally on the same page as Gad, but he didn’t say he rejects his Jewishness 🙄

[@Sara_cy]

Reading the comments make me happy. that shows people don't allow media (Israel) to manipulate them anymore, everybody is woke

[@CBT5777]

This Gad is a snake. I don't trust him anymore.

[@shaimael-elaimy590]

Piers, you do realize that EVERYONE has seen Glazer's speech? Everyone knows exactly what he said?

[@michaelxz1305]

I haven't.. I saw a clip of the rejecting part but that's it. Not everyone cares about the oscars.

[@shaimael-elaimy590]

@@michaelxz1305 it has nothing to do with caring about the Oscars.

[@ignatiuschua5268]

He said the result of all these killings were a result of Oct 7. Well, Oct 7 horrendous massacre was a result of the many years of occupation and seige, and dehumanising the Palestinian living there. I hate it when someone quoted a work by a single person as gospel truth ie. no rape of Palestine women by Israel soldiers. As for 99% poll of Palestine hating Israel, I believe that is true. If I am living in Gaza, I would also hate Jews in Israel. The only way to solve this hate issue is to help build Gaza, let them have a thriving community and to stop the apartheid. You can slowly change the perception of people in Gaza towards Jews by helping them and let time heal their hatred.

[@Stevef2022]

To quote Douglas Murray, try giving them a kindergarten to run without turning it into an arms depot and see where that goes.

[@susanweinberger6882]

@ignatiuschua5268 very nice to see your delusional ideas while sitting on your comfy couch. With whom will Israel make peace? With the innocent “Gazan people “? 85% support Ham 🫏 & what they did on October 7. Which included raping women even after they killed them AKA nechrophilia. I will quote the timeless quote from Golda Meir “We will only have peace with the Arabs when they love their children more than they hate us”! One more from Golda: “If the Arabs put down their weapons today, there would be no violence. If the Jews put down their weapons today, there would be no Israel. Her timeless words aged really well!

[@antalpoti]

Gazans got plenty of help. No Jew stepped foot in Gaza for almost 20 years. They even took their dead with them when they left. Gaza got millions, if not billions, in aid. What did they do with it? They stole one part of it to finance their leaders' luxurious lifestyle in Qatar, the other part went into building tunnels under hospitals. They lived by the sword, now they die by it.

[@ignatiuschua5268]

@@antalpoti What rubbish are you saying? If you want to fight Hamas, then you fight Hamas. Why kill Palestinian? Such a cowardly act. Which military in the world cannot kill civilians if they are allowed to do so. It is akin to a shooting spree against unarmed innocent bystanders.

[@antalpoti]

@@ignatiuschua5268 the Jews would fight Hamas if Hamas would have the balls to fight the Jews, and not hide under hospitals and kindergartens. These are all documented facts. Hamas are spineless coward terrorist who have big mouths only when they can hide behind children and women.

[@wRAAh]

5:15 No Gad Saad, you cannot criticize Israel without THEM invoking anti-semitism and using the suffering of the Jewish people as a human shield, whereby endangering the Jewish people. Then you intentionally misquote Glaser, who had in no way rejected his Jewish identity. Everybody knows this, which makes his smug grin at the end of the sentence extra ugly.

[@jonathangiahn7723]

Great interview Piers! Fun and refreshing!

[@TheMergim93]

Talks aboiut amnesia yet forgets the oppresson and apartheid. Man thinks too highly of himself

[@lvince4910]

Every country is apart from every other country. Hamas are the oppressors of Gazans and Israelis. You don't know how to pronounce apartheid, let alone what it means.

[@Gettingitreal]

“You mess around and find out what’s happening”. That’s justification for children and women dying. Gross.

[@1234singer]

Blame Hamas. All deatgs are on them

[@HughEMC]

Yo Gaad Sad af he did not say he rejects his Jewishness -he said it confusingly but Gaad is smart enough to understand what he was saying. People with wise insight into certain issues only discredit themselves when being disingenuous

[@krugmeister7301]

Piers keeps REPEATING THE SAME QUESTION ALWAYS...HAMAS...😡😡😡

[@jaialaiwarrior]

Go interview them yourself then and see how you can prove that they're allegedly not the problem.

[@christopherrobleto-harvey2876]

He should have just said he rejects his Zionism, not his Jewishness. Simple.

[@omp199]

He didn't say he rejected his Jewishness.

[@Red_Black_Key]

"Amnesia of Causality" is ignoring what happened from 1948 to October 6th, 2023.

[@carolinaamado1854]

He never said he rejects his jeweness…

[@1234singer]

Yes he did

[@istand4truth]

Good of you, Gaad to be unequivocally supportive of free speech. You have been consistent all along. You are reliably consistent. Thank you for standing up for freedom.

[@MagnusGalactusOG]

These two should go to a UFC event.

[@johnpaley8857]

Must be frustrating for Piers living in Alex Jones's shadow.

[@StewartDando]

Alex Jone's shadow? Really? Perhaps he lives in the shadows cast by the tombstones of dead kids killed by mass shooters, wielding guns they never should have had access to in the first place...? Thoughts?

[@tammyschwarz6388]

Enjoyed this!

[@sorgeelenchus]

I’m not sure what the actual misunderstanding is here. The words were pretty clear. They refute their Jewishness AND the Holocaust being used to basically justify an occupation and genocide. You don’t refute your ancestry. That doesn’t even make sense. You could reject your ancestry. You refute arguments, claims, or propositions-not people, or attributes or state of people. There’s a failure of comprehension here or an intent to manipulate the words to deceive others. I have to wonder about what Piers and Saad’s motivations are here.

[@Torrana]

*cynically* ad revenue

[@oloedelman4598]

Genocide? Which conflict are YOU watching??

[@sorgeelenchus]

@@oloedelman4598 I’m not getting my news from The Daily Wire, that’s for sure. I’m talking about Israel leveling Gaza, shutting off power and water to the strip, blocking aid, and just bombing indiscriminately to push out people from Gaza. They’re even taking over more parts of the West Bank. Israel wants the whole land. I’m not saying Hamas doesn’t want the same or wouldn’t do the same if the tables were reversed. That doesn’t make it right for either side.

[@omp199]

The word "refute" doesn't really work here at all. I'm sure his heart is in the right place, but it is a shame that professional screenwriter Jonathan Glazer has such a poor command of the English language.

[@Torrana]

@@omp199 yes I guess it’s despite that poor command of English we see him on a world stage with a tremendous amount of coverage devoted to his speech. I wonder what Glazer thinks of omp199’s writing

[@Hassan-lx5kj]

Free palestine people and country

[@johanna77777]

shut up

[@johanna77777]

wat

[@lvince4910]

Who do they need to freed from? Hamas? Themselves? Having to live next to Jews? They should be so lucky to benefit from living next to such prosperous people.

[@jeffsaperstein4296]

Lots of people refer to genocide by Israelis in Gaza, but neither define genocide nor specifically apply it for urban terror warfare such as we fought in Mosul, Rakka, anad Faluj. Piers keeps repeating the same refrain about tens fo thousands of new civilian casualties. Hamas is making up much of these numbers and there is no way they can accurately support them since they are not operative in Gaza and they do not count militant deaths and casualties separately from civilians.I wish he would interview John Spencer, who heads Urban Warfare Institute at West Point who has testified that Israel has done more to avoid civilian casualties than we or any other army has done in similar circumstances. The IDF has focused their battles in a much more pinpoint way because they have gained intelligence, innovated methods of tunnel warfare, and have reduced considerably civilian casualties. The Shifa hospital incursion this week is a good example. But the refrain goes on. Perhaps there can be a Congressional hearing with military experts who can open the inquiry into whether the Israelis and Hamas have committed war crimes and genocide. Maybe we can get more information that is accurate based on the reality on the ground. Transparency on both sides would be good for the US and the West to come to some clear conclusions. Hamas does not deserve a pass nor does UNWRA for supporting terror.

[@sheikha6]

He Should asked him if his Muslim friends hate him

[@jasonmardoniomeza1711]

On October 6th the Palestinians were happy and healthy? Please lets look at what started this. It wasnt October 7th. Netenyahu admits openly that he never wanted a 2 state solution and is proud he has been the one who prevented a Palestinian state. Meanwhile over the years Bibi allowed and wamted Hamas to get $1.4 billion in order to strengthen Hamas so they could remain in conflict with the PLO.

[@cynthiacools-lartigue5297]

What a load of delusional garbage you spew. There are Palestinians in Isreali government….Arabs living amongst Jews in Isreal no Jew in Gaza. Ironically the most liberal of Israelis happened to be living on the kibbutz where they were slaughtered, some from the very Arabs they hired as help. The Palestinians have been made offers for a two state and every time THEY refused. Your history is skewed by your anti semantics.

[@gailturner8094]

If Hamas is so inbeded amongst the Palistines this is simply these people are all Palestinian

[@blpkqrywa]

Great interview 🙌🏼

[@tam8995]

The question is who started messing around did it start in Oct last year, or did it start when the whole strip was locked down?!?!?!? Does it need a philosopher to answer this question?!?! Or a decent non tribalistic person to answer???

[@yeshuabinyankee5017]

it takes Humanity to answer that. Definitely the latter.

[@bocchithean-cap3404]

There was no blockade until hamas started shooting rockets

[@dbri306]

I’m not saying there were no restrictions before HAMAS started to shoot rockets in 2006 but they were pretty loose. What would you do if your neighbours started shooting rockets at you?

[@jehuty2seven]

Its funny how pierce keeps pretending like everything started on October 7th. His jewish boss, Rupert Murdoch might fire him otherwise

[@orhutubeli5332]

Piers should have John Spenser on, he is one of the most important experts on urban warfare living today.

[@Mark.Sciguerra]

Bassem Youssef without makeup.

[@wheres_bears1378]

😂 I was thinking the same thing

[@AlohaMichaelDaly]

Great understanding of free speech by Gad Saad. 😊 Saad’s pro-Israeli position is off base. Yes we understand Jews have a rich culture but what is it with the culture and faith that turns neighbours against them? Well, it’s not surprising that 75 years of Colonial settlement, apartheid, brutality and murder of pro-Palestinians, unlawful occupation, incarceration and overt genocide triggers a global human response not unlike the cry to defeat Nazi Germany - and rightfully so.

[@MagnusGalactusOG]

I would love to see a conversation between Saad and Lex Fridman.

[@TheJanetford]

Same same but Saad got invited on and refused.

[@SopotKrzyn]

I never had ANY respect for Piers Morgan but regretfully I lost my respect for his guest as well ;-(