F.A.K.E MUSLIM EXPO.SED, ANOTHER SINCERE SHIA - SHAMSI - SPEAKER'S CORNER

To be Clear there are 2 people in the debate, so the Shia man is sincere, however the second person who's is pretend to be insincere.
Membership link Below if you would like to join, Jazaka allahu Kayran:
/ @sfdawah
Donate Generously to continue the Channel & Translations for Arabic Channel;.
Link Below:
www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted...
May allah Reward You.
Don't Miss New Uploades, SUBSCRIBE Share And Like...
******************************************
******************************************
• American Girl Travelle...
******************************************
• CHRISTIAN MAN AMAZED B...
******************************************
• Video
*******************************************
• SHAMSI CONFRONTS THE D...
*******************************************
Some Videos May Contain Strong Words, Some Viewers May Find Some Of The Contents Offensive Or Inappropriate.
*******************************************
Disclaimer: The Viewers and Opinion of Speakers or Debaters In The Videos Do Not Represent THIS Channel In Any Shape Or Form, The Channel Only Represent The Actual Image At Speakers Corner.
**COPY RIGHTS RESERVED!**
Donate for translation please: on the link
contact: [e-mail]
Original contents : @sFDawah
Copy Right Reserved : @sFDawah
Edited and Uploaded: @sFDawah
***THANK YOU FOR WATCHING!!!!***
***THANK YOU FOR WATCHING!!!!***

[@mslondonsuleyman]

When your having a positive Conversation it’s like a Devil sends his minions to disrupt a perfectly healthy and positive conversation 9 times out of 10 every video it’s unreal that’s how you know it’s not a joke keep up your good work bro inshallah 🤲🏼

[@Radknafeh]

Now I get it why Ibn Taymiyyah didn’t make takfir of Shia as a whole and said that their laymen are miskeen. May Allah Swt guide all those who are sincere and make us among those sincere in our Islam

[@mhmadbedrddeen3414]

Ibn Taymeyyah the ignorant said so

[@AbuMusaAlBurtughaalii]

@@mhmadbedrddeen3414 it's best you stop listening to your misguided shaykh's and read the books of the ones they lie about. Read the book ofShaykh Al Islam Ibn Taymiyyah rahimahullah. And the books of Shaykh Al Islam Muhammed ibn Abdul Wahhab Rahimahullah and see that it is not filled with anything except Speech of Allah azzawajal speech of The Rasool Salalahu alayhi wa sallam, and speech of the Sahaba who understood what the prophet Sallaahu alayhi wa salam said best. Allahu Akbar.

[@mhmadbedrddeen3414]

@@AbuMusaAlBurtughaalii I know what ibn taymiyyah the nasibi wrote and i know that most of the sunni scholars of his time condemned him and imprisoned for his deviated creed for saying Allah has eyes and ears and hands, and all of what he said was refuted again and again and he was irrelevant until abdul wahhab with the money from oil came and started spreading the deviant believes that's how ibn taymiyyah suddenly became shiekh al islam to the extent that wahabis say if their was a prophet after Muhammad it would be ibn Taymeyyah, read the works who opposed ibn taymiyyah and then judge, the majority sunni Asharis refuse his deviant beliefs

[@mhmadbedrddeen3414]

@@AbuMusaAlBurtughaalii My scholars urge us to read thr opposite beliefs in all of our religious schools you will find all sunni books, unlike your shiekhs who tell you to follow blindly and stay away from shia books, that's the difference between who knows the truth and firm in his beliefs and the ones who make up lies to misguide ignorant followers

[@AbuMusaAlBurtughaalii]

@@mhmadbedrddeen3414 I mean if you want to reject what Allah says about himself go ahead. I say what Allah said about himself, on Yawmul qiyamah you'll be held to account. How can you refute Quran. Biyadihil Mulk..... yeah Allah says he has a hand, so I affirm it. Without explaining away, and without distorting it and without resembling it to creation. SubhanAllah how simple and logical is the belief of Ahlul sunnahti wal Jammah. Alhumdulillah for Islam.

[@mohamednawfel5172]

These verses are amazing. God bless you all and guid our brothers and sisters everywhere in the world

[@ax3226]

Aameen

[@umz535]

Ameen.

[@mohamedab9033]

This man is blissfully unaware of his own faith, he just follows the culture he's been brought up in without actually reading their source materials. Much less pondering upon Qur'an. Should he be sincere may Allah guide him.

[@PlayGuy200]

Exactly, i sensed that too. Its good to reflect like the Quran teaches

[@playersden]

Ameen

[@mhmadbedrddeen3414]

Yes he's unaware that shamsi is ignorant praying on ignorants fooling and misguiding ignorants

[@user-ew1xu4wq4k]

@@mhmadbedrddeen3414 bro shush. Go speakers corner next sunday and speak to shamsi. Stop waffling in the comments. All ur shia brothers have come speakers corner and never make sense.

[@mhmadbedrddeen3414]

@@user-ew1xu4wq4k will you pay for my flight ticket 😂 And one thing that's not how it should be done, when anyone wanting to speak in these issues from any faith from any background, it should be done by presenting the sources and references to then be if it's authentic and what is not, not two three guys start shouting without listening and speaking from their heads and wishes and desires, I dare anyone to discuss in the comments so i can expose the lies that you've been told and brainwashed since your birth, those shia are ignorent, every sect every religion have ignorants that's why i'm against the clowning of speaker's corner, they speak without understanding without going back to the sources without seeing what is right and what is wrong, i write in the comments to expose the lies that are retold over and over, aren't us muslims should seek the truth even over ourselves? Bro if you're truthful in following the righteous path you would search and read for yourself and see the other narratives and believes to see if they confirm with the Quran and the true sunnah or not then judge, but all i see is ignorants fighting just to score points

[@luqmong2295]

May Allah(swt) guide us all

[@ax3226]

Aameen

[@abdisud1738]

LA ILAHA IL ALLAAH ☝🏼🌹

[@heyhey6821]

I hope Allah guides this Shii brother. He is almost Sunni!

[@r.g.1166]

As long as he stays a shia of Ali ibn Abu (as), he will remain on THE right path.

[@amir123786]

@@r.g.1166 lol why not be a Shia of Muhammad pbuh?

[@r.g.1166]

@@amir123786 Excellent question! The ONLY way to be a shia of Muhammad IS to be a shia of Ali. It's exactly why Ali wasn't the 3rd caliph. He was offered it IF he agreed to follow the sunnah of prophet Muhammad pbuh AND the sunnah of Abu Bakr and Umar. Ali refused and rightfully so, Al-Islam, the perfect and complete deen is ONLY the Quran and the prophet's sunnah. It's why even in sahih Muslim, the prophet Muhammad pbuh said he is leaving us TWO weighty things, the Quran AND his Ahlul Bayt. The true sunnah of prophet Muhammad pbuh can only be known by following his purified family, which makes the Shia of Ali and the other Imams the people that are the real Sunnis as they follow only the sunnah of prophet Muhammad pbuh as taught to us by his Ahlul Bayt.

[@amir123786]

@@r.g.1166 you obviously accept the uthmaani Quran which all Muslims have, within that it says refer back to Allah and his messenger (Quran and sunnah), within the Quran Allah many times spoke good of andar and muhajirun. So if Allah speaks highly of them and forgives them and says they’re higher level than all Muslims who come after, and promised ansar and muhajriun paradise. Why do you Shia not accept ansar and muhajriun ? It is the muhajriun who agreed with abu bakar. Do you think those Allah praised are bad

[@r.g.1166]

@@amir123786 Read 9:100 correctly, it says follow them in righteousness. Can you follow ANY of them? Now continue to the very next ayat 9:101. See just like Allah shows us, I know what you reveal and what you conceal. Who's Quran? The Quran itself tells us who is responsible for protecting the Quran, what you just attributed to Uthman goes against Allah's swt words and THAT is actually shirk, giving a man credit for something Allah swt tells us He is responsible for.

[@farhajaward9728]

The Shia brother MashaAllah has an open mind may the almighty guide him to the right path.

[@umz535]

Ameen

[@zakiyarou]

Masha Allah May Allah swt grant this guy knowledge, he is so humble. Nice to see such a positive interaction.

[@secret049]

25:25 يقول رضي الله عنه ما شاء الله هذا اقرب للسنه وفقنا الله جميعا لما يحبه ويرضى

[@Fayoumi9]

May Allah bless this brother talking with shamsi. You can really see he is seeking the truth but it's hard to accept when your whole life you have been told otherwise. May Allah guide him and guide us.

[@laraib827]

Br Sheikh Shamsi is a excellent speaker. MashaAllah TabarakAllah SubhanaAllah I love his videos..

[@RashidpakAlb2]

JazakAllah khair brother Shamsi.

[@abbey1385]

This man is very respectful and sincere May Allah swt guide him and us all to the straight path AMEEN.

[@dragon4397]

I love shamsi's Arabic

[@abdisud1738]

Alhamdulillah ☝🏼🌹

[@maramahmed3321]

اللهم أعز الاسلام والمسلمين وذل الشرك والمشركين

[@MrFar80]

May Allah give U long life and a good health bro shamsi..p/s bro shamsi i hope U talk slowly and not to fast when give dawah, its more good and clearly..👍💪❤️

[@hamroskadir5031]

Allahuakbar the important point is must follow al quran

[@homtanks7259]

JazakAllahu khairan

[@naimajama8465]

When he said our books 👏 nearly shed a tear 🥲 HAHAHA

[@qhuddusm8444]

Shams you are brave keep it up wassalam Alhamdulillah

[@aharaw007rawat3]

Brother Shamsi your explanation is perfect. U are well versed ...Allah reward u for understanding of quran n hadith

[@rizwanmuhammad6468]

Shams I my man can carry a deep conversation with right hand and can hold a mulhid with left hand while doing that. Mashallah.

[@Ronaldo20070]

MashAllah

[@khozabenhamid9745]

Now I know..there is incident happend 3 years after WW2 in Algeria..thanks for info

[@botbeamer]

brother whole WW2 story is a lie

[@khozabenhamid9745]

@@botbeamer do I said WW2 or after WW2?? Read throughly on my statement

[@botbeamer]

@@khozabenhamid9745 ok

[@khozabenhamid9745]

@@botbeamer watch the video throughly..then you know why I'm make that statement... I know,half of WW2 has a twisted fact..hell,they even try to hide balfor treaty in it(Palestine sold to the Jew)

[@sameerhussain5402]

عليه الصلاة والسلام ...صلي على الحبيب قلبك يطيب.. اللهم صلي وسلم وبارك على نبينا محمد وعلى آله وصحبه أجمعين.

[@r.g.1166]

Righteous companions.

[@zaintbreez5178]

This honest shia will be cancelled by other blind extremist shias. May Allah guide him.

[@mhmadbedrddeen3414]

He's ignorant and shamsi praying on that, a learned shia child would destroy shamsi

[@zakiyarou]

@@mhmadbedrddeen3414 no Shia has ever “destroyed” Shamsi. And never will Alhamdulillah.

[@xy2722]

please the vers about al mohajiron o al ansar what sourat and verse is ?

[@sketpang]

Knowledge is power

[@ajx3866]

I really thought this was a muslim expo event till i looked again

[@aminajama592]

May Allah swt guide the Shia guy, he seems so close to recognising the straight path.

[@r.g.1166]

If he avoids people like Shamsi trying to take him off the straight path, he will continue being what Allah swt and his messenger Muhammad pbuh want, a shia of the Ahlul Bayt.

[@hashh2019]

@@r.g.1166 agree, this guy is just ignorant of references in Quran and the proper tafseet of what Shamsi is quoting. Shamsi turned out to be such a twister of everything- no shame of God or he himself is firmly ignorant.

[@jasondula6108]

I hate they jump around in languages but it was a great conversation

[@amirhussain1449]

Prophet Muhammad peace and blessings on him was the walking talking Quran

[@Asad-2166]

How hard can it be, follow the quran and sunnah period! What dose it take to change the essence of a man?

[@AlsiddiegA]

Allah's will

[@Invective]

Islam was not for just the prophet and his family, Islam was for the whole world, it is ignorance that makes people believe you should follow families, no you should follow the message of Allah, believe in the Quran first, and take yourself away from sects which divides the Muslims

[@mhmadbedrddeen3414]

allah tells us who to follow and not to follow not you, the prophets are progeny of each other, Ibrahim had Ishaq and Ismael, Ishaq had Yaaqub and then Yusuf, Suliman and Dawod... how ignorant you are to speak by your whims and desires instead of following what Allah wants us to follow

[@naimajama8465]

@@mhmadbedrddeen3414 where did Allah say follow the prophets family you ‏ ‏كذاب?

[@Invective]

Yes indeed but Islam is for everyone to follow and the prophets are the examples, so shiaism is ignorance at its finest

[@mhmadbedrddeen3414]

@@Invective Read again what you said and what i replied and don't speak of hatred and arrogance, you claimed that islam doesn't tell us to follow families without bringing any proof of your claim, I countered your claim by giving evidence grom the Quran that tell us the prophets are a progeny from each other and they are our examples to follow so technically we follow a family, Islam for everyone to follow yes but we are ordered by Allah to follow a specific family of prophets so saying Islam doesn't say we should follow families is false, that shows how ignorant you are and that what you said is a result of your blind hatred towards shisim that makes you willing to deny the Quran and the orders of Allah himself just to disagree with us

[@jamesali76]

May Allah forgive Saddam… Ameen

[@muniralam1501]

May Allaah subhanahu wa ta'ala guide the Shia Rafadah and Sufi to follow the Al Qur'an with prophet's and righteous sahabas interpretation ONLY and also guide them NOT to follow their scholars and Books such as kitab al Kafi of kulayni and Bihar al Anwar by majlesi.....anyone believe these Books are NOT MUSLIM OR IN ISLAM......may Allaah subhanahu wa ta'ala guide us! Ameen

[@r.g.1166]

May Allah swt guide you to the real Islam.

[@AdnanAli_313]

One Question how is a Shia a rafidah when Abu Bakr was not appointed by the Prophet and he left us in a state of no guidance its been 36 year of My life still waiting for a reply to this

[@abdelmajiedrais1918]

Who are the ansar that Allah mentioned to follow in surat atawba mention me only 3 please i am going to wait another 32 years for the answer

[@AdnanAli_313]

@@abdelmajiedrais1918 Follow in what exactly I know but do you. There's no mention in that verse about Imamah or leadership only in faith like the Ansar and Muhahajroon for the migration of the Muhajiroon amd the acceptance of the Ansar go back read again. If it really meant anything else we would have this explanation from them. And not from Bukhari and Tabari and when most Hadith are from Ibn Abbas who is a family member. Loook at the verse about Imam Ali go to your Books to see who this Ayat come down in regards to. Surah Al Maidah Allah is your Walli and his Prophet and the one that pays zakat while they bow . The word Walli is used after Allah and his Prophet. So you waited 2 sec and still provided nothing about Abu Bakr and the rest.

[@AdnanAli_313]

@@abdelmajiedrais1918 The verse means exactly what it says Allah has provided garden's.Provided is the key word here keep that in mind. While they have good conduct so that means not all of them because this means during migration some night not have had good conduct other wise Allah would not mention it would he now. For those who migrate and those who were accepting. The verse is talking about Muslims at the time that migrated and the ones that did that are provided with the Heavens while they Migrate with good conduct. Wheres is the word Khalif where is the word Imamah where is the word Abu Bakr I'm saying that because the same is asked of us about Imam Ali even though your books says Quran does mention him as a Walli in Surah Al Maidah.

[@karimrm2479]

❤❤

[@elipasho6757]

Qur'an, Sunnah and Ahl al-Bayt.

[@TakeABreakShort]

And sahaba.

[@kamarudinshariff350]

admin..... why there is no sub here? please admin add eng sub.....tqvm

[@lostandguided5533]

My brothers and sisters. Take care of your health when you lose it your only wish in the worlds is to get it back. Please take this advice preciously dont take unnecessary risks.

[@ax3226]

Good advice MashaAllah

[@ShifaProductions]

Title is a bit too aggressive . I feel like it should be a more neutral title as "Giving dawah to shia" instead of saying fake muslim

[@ShifaProductions]

"FAKE MUSLIM EXPOSED" a little bit aggressive

[@rijadhadzic3396]

The fake muslim is talking about the hindu guy interupting the conversation at the end

[@TheMW3uploads]

أولا

[@iimiboy]

Myfloor poor afgan guy is gonna now claim asylum

[@junaidnaushad3416]

امن یجیب المضطر۔26:02

[@--GP--]

🤣🤣🤣🤣 I adore Shamsi really )))) 29:09 call him ahi ))) ha-ha-ha-ha and then Astahfurullah ))) ha-ha-ha-ha

[@user-wd9mh9qe8e]

Brother shamsi is very knowledgeable when it comes to talking to shias.shamsi knows how to handle them.Where do this shias get there deluded believes from🙈.They more about al buit than the Quran and the sunnah of our beloved Nabie (ASL).Sometimes it just takes one crooked mind to cause all this shirk and to take you of the straight path.May Allah guide nations to islam.

[@psloboy7134]

100 % syiah is not obbey what Alloh SWT commad...

[@guardianangel4223]

CHAPTER 33 VERSE 33

[@hashh2019]

Well Ayesha ra herself said in saheeh hadith, that verse Shamsi said that it was only about the 5 and didn’t include wives. Even Umm Salama was not allowed to enter the rida of the Prophet. Verse of Mubahala- where Prophet went with his family to debate Christians he included his daughter as a representative of women, Ali as representative of his own self and men along with Hasan and Hussain. No Abu Bakr or Umar or wife. Shamsi is lying and stuttering, he is not quoting the verses about hypocrites where God talks about sahaba that have different intentions in their hearts. He also doesn’t talk about hadith which says that Prophet would recognize some Sahaba on day of judgement but they will be taken to hellfire. He doesn’t quote the verse where God praises Imam Ali as being the one giving charity through a rukoo. Also Bukhari is just a collection of hadess, tons of garbage hadith are also present in it, not everything is true. There were many paid people from Banu Umayya that wanted to corrupt Islam just like they killed Al Hussain later on- these people made up fake ahadith. I hope this Shia guy learns more tafseet and details to defend his faith that he is already on truth. Christian and Sunnis just make up stuff and comfuse an unlearned person.

[@r.g.1166]

'A'isha reported that Allah's Apostle (ﷺ) went out one morning wearing a striped cloak of the black camel's hair that there came Hasan b. 'Ali. He wrapped him under it, then came Husain and he wrapped him under it along with the other one (Hasan). Then came Fatima and he took her under it, then came 'Ali and he also took him under it and then said: Allah only desires to take away any uncleanliness from you, O people of the household, and purify you (thorough purifying) حَدَّثَنَا أَبُو بَكْرِ بْنُ أَبِي شَيْبَةَ، وَمُحَمَّدُ بْنُ عَبْدِ اللَّهِ بْنِ نُمَيْرٍ، - وَاللَّفْظُ لأَبِي بَكْرٍ - قَالاَ حَدَّثَنَا مُحَمَّدُ بْنُ بِشْرٍ، عَنْ زَكَرِيَّاءَ، عَنْ مُصْعَبِ بْنِ شَيْبَةَ، عَنْ صَفِيَّةَ بِنْتِ شَيْبَةَ، قَالَتْ قَالَتْ عَائِشَةُ خَرَجَ النَّبِيُّ صلى الله عليه وسلم غَدَاةً وَعَلَيْهِ مِرْطٌ مُرَحَّلٌ مِنْ شَعْرٍ أَسْوَدَ فَجَاءَ الْحَسَنُ بْنُ عَلِيٍّ فَأَدْخَلَهُ ثُمَّ جَاءَ الْحُسَيْنُ فَدَخَلَ مَعَهُ ثُمَّ جَاءَتْ فَاطِمَةُ فَأَدْخَلَهَا ثُمَّ جَاءَ عَلِيٌّ فَأَدْخَلَهُ ثُمَّ قَالَ ‏{‏ إِنَّمَا يُرِيدُ اللَّهُ لِيُذْهِبَ عَنْكُمُ الرِّجْسَ أَهْلَ الْبَيْتِ وَيُطَهِّرَكُمْ تَطْهِيرًا‏}‏ Reference : Sahih Muslim 2424In-book reference : Book 44, Hadith 91USC-MSA web (English) reference : Book 31, Hadith 5955 (deprecated numbering scheme)

[@r.g.1166]

Aisha also NEVER said the purification referred to her.

[@hashh2019]

@@r.g.1166 agree

[@r.g.1166]

@@hashh2019 Also if Aisha and Ali (as) were both included in the purification, they could never had been on opposite sides in battle at Jamal. The verse says Allah swt. desires, meaning it's His will, to purify, nobody then can go against Allah if he wills something, it IS. So it's impossible for the purification part of 33:33 to include the wives.

[@leemajor5003]

that guys is proababyl so starstruck he gets to speak with shamsi lol

[@jayhuss4263]

Then why keep title like that

[@nagasakihirosima8603]

2nd

[@younessrii2276]

Sallamu alaykum brother Shamsi, why do you say prosalam instead of prophet salallahu alayhi wa salam? try to pronounce it properly jazakAllah

[@Lion_Hamza]

Mahfur is severely misled!

[@randomness8819]

Um Hitler actually claimed nazism in the name if Christianity.

[@MalikMalik-rw7xo]

21:20 😂😂

[@MrBest56007]

28:26

[@wahidkhan2147]

Shamsi has ended all the shias ... She never give clear Quran or Hadith..

[@mukhar786]

They are like Christians

[@peoul1]

is Ali greater than rasulullah saw? if we realy need to pray through Ali before allah why not we through rasul?

[@mhmadbedrddeen3414]

We do pray through both and Ali himself prayed through the prophet, as any shia he would tell you that, instead of that you make your false assumptions and follow lies made about shia

[@sheiksaleem3790]

Mind your tongue or may be you will be called open a loser ! Shirq is thin like a hair slip of words will fall us in hell !

[@peoul1]

@@sheiksaleem3790 my question that try to understand shia is answered with threat. nice

[@trealNoOne]

25:35 he is hindoo.🤣

[@Floyd308]

I disagree brother shamsi with you that Saddam was good. He was minafiq who was a slave to communists and capitalist!

[@ZeroCelsius777]

At 1:22...Quran CLEARLY says to FOLLOW THE GUIDANCE of the EARLIER PROPHETS (PBUT)...not just one prophet (PBUH) Surah Al-An'am (Ch. 6) ayats 82 - 90 Al-An'am ayah 90..These are they whom Allah guided, THEREFORE FOLLOW THEIR GUIDANCE. Say: I do not ask you for any reward for it; it is nothing but a reminder to the nations.. It's astounding...the SUNNI SECT takes almost EVERYTHING that Quran says and they try to twist it to mean what they want it to mean. So you know, I DO NOT belong to a "SECT." Not SUNNI...SHIA...SUFI, etc.,

[@mhmadbedrddeen3414]

If you don't belong to a sect or a set of beliefs of a particular sect and follow your own beliefs then practically you made a sect of your own

[@8heavyhchamp8]

If you say follow the muhajirin and ansar then Abubakar became the caliph then those who opposed that e.g ali has disobeyed the Quran? Because reports says 6 months or 3 days or non...someone who didn't follow the Quran has used ali as an example...pls someone explain

[@mhmadbedrddeen3414]

Shamsi is ignorant, the verse says The first the forerunners among the Muhajreen and the Ansar and who follow them in good conduct, It doesn't say follow all of the Muhajreen and the Ansar but it gives conditions so Allah be pleased with them, the sunni narration is all sahabah are good no matter what they did even the killer and the killed both are pleased by Allah and are in heaven, that shows how they are misguided and misguiding

[@8heavyhchamp8]

@@mhmadbedrddeen3414 he is not ignorant...so if you have to count you will find this people as the foremost but if Allah didn't mention names why does sunni and shia pick whoever they want even thoughI'm shia I don't pick names except that I know ali is who ill definitely follow amongst all of them combined but I won't say Allah speaks of Abubakar or not

[@r.g.1166]

Next verse 9:101 explains and shows Shamsi isn't correct.

[@8heavyhchamp8]

@@r.g.1166 thats true to my understanding

[@mohsabkha3928]

@@r.g.1166 it specifically states that amongst the desert-dwelling arabs (Bedouin) and the people of Medina, there are hypocrites. I fail to see how that is relates to the Muhajiroon, the Ansar, or Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, etc.

[@Abou_Salahedine]

​ @R.G. *PART III* On the other hand, the accounts reported by al-Qurṭubī about the circumstances of the revelation of Surat At Tawba 9 : 12 [Tafsīr , 10:122-128] stage the “policies” of the Ancients with regard to different types of invective which are not necessarily directed against the Prophet or against Islam. These are essentially criticisms against the policy of the Prophet as a political leader or against that of his subordinates. In this context, the "ṭ aʿn" has the meaning of false accusation and does not refer to an offense against religion. Thus, to illustrate the semantic analysis of the term "ṭaʿn", the author presents the ḥadīṯh evoking the invective against the appointment of Usāma as governor, and against that of his father ( al - ṭaʿnfī imāratihi ) [See Ibn ʿAṭiyya, Buḥārī (3730), Muslim (2426)]. In order to introduce the legal debates on the treatment of those who accuse the Prophet or his companions of "disloyalty" ( ġadr ), the author relates the account where ʿAlī orders the execution of a man who had called the murder of Kaʿb b. al-Ašraf commissioned by the Prophet, of perfidy, treachery and disloyalty ( ġadr ) [Another version presented by al-Qurṭubī attributes this decision to Muʿāwiya. These developments (...)] . Similarly, as an introduction to the debates on the ḏhimmi who practices the ṭ a ʿ n fī al-dīn, al-Qurṭubī relates the account where ʿUmar immediately condemns a ḏhimmi to crucifixion because he had knocked a Muslim woman off her donkey, exposing part of her forbidden nudity (ʿawra ) [See Ibn al-ʿArabī, Aḥkām al-Qurʾān, 2:893] . Here the "ṭaʿnfīal-dīn" refers to a crime against honor. In general, these accounts reveal a conception of " ta ʿ n fī al-Dīn " very different from the theological-legal conception of Ibn al-ʿArabī [Aḥkām al-Qurʾān, 2: 893. Famous Andalusian exegete and jurist of the Almoravid era, influenced by (...)] presented by al-Qurṭubī without it don't quote it: Invective or offense against religion ( al - ṭaʿnfī al-dīn) is to label religion improperly, or to despise what is proper to it ( isti ḫ fāf mā huwa min al-dīn ) , such as making fun of its foundations or of its derived rules of which there is no doubt and whose truth has been proven and fixed [Tafsīr , 10:122-123. “Limā ṯabata min al-dalīl al-qaṭʿī ʿalā ṣiḥḥat uṣūlihi wa-istiqāmat furūʿih (...)]. We observe that this definition is more legal than theological, in that it concerns neither God nor the Prophet, but the questioning of rules held to be rooted in divine law.

[@nhby]

What saddam was good? Whaaaat?

[@TheOnlyIncognito]

Fix the title mate..

[@SubmittedtoAllah]

Ali Ra. Become the 4th. Caliph anyway.

[@ahjk267]

Even if you follow hazrat Ali, he did not say anything different to prophet Muhammed or the quran. What does it mean I follow hazrat Ali. When hazrat Ali followed the prophet. If you produce a new sect just to curse the sahiba that's just inviting the hell fire. How does this benefit the ummah.

[@r.g.1166]

Correct, Imam Ali didn't say anything different than prophet Muhammad pbuh. But the first 3 caliphs did say things different, THAT is the issue. Thanks for admitting it.

[@friedeggswithbeef]

@@r.g.1166 the why do you attribut fake hadith to Hazrat Ali which contradict muttawatir hadith that Rasulallah saw made? Such as forbidding mutah? Did Hazrat Ali himself make mutah after the Prophet's declaration of making mutah haraam? No. And yet in Iran, a shia state, mutah is legal? What is your deen lol majosi

[@r.g.1166]

@@friedeggswithbeef It mutah was made haram, why did it exist during Abu Bakr's caliphate and he never said anything?

[@r.g.1166]

@@friedeggswithbeef You nasabis are the people of "bidah hasana"...smh

[@sevenscounty409]

How did this demon come to infear in the conversation?

[@jt0094]

What makes him a demon?

[@zahirkhan-yq3gr]

ya Ali CANNOT madad

[@WahidShirin]

So, in the hadith where the Prophet (pbuh) told his uncle to say the shahada and he (the Prophet (pbuh)) will advocate for his uncle, was the Prophet (pbuh) telling his uncle that he could or could not madad? What Shamsi is saying that no one can help someone else (Prophet, Ali, or Sahaba) is untrue according to this hadith.

[@zahirkhan-yq3gr]

@@WahidShirin Prophet(Pbuh) was in this world that time not anymore now lol

[@zahirkhan-yq3gr]

@@WahidShirin where shamsi said no one can help someone else?? u can help if u r in this world not after u died

[@r.g.1166]

Why not?

[@zahirkhan-yq3gr]

@@r.g.1166 Ali couldn't help his wife according to u shia

[@sidco123]

Sufism close to shiaism?!! What kind of ex-sufi was Shamsi? Please explain! Mr shamsi

[@zahirkhan-yq3gr]

sufism n shia religion Both r Shirk n Bidah

[@r.g.1166]

@@zahirkhan-yq3gr The shia of Ali ibn Abu Talib (as) follow the REAL Islam.

[@zahirkhan-yq3gr]

@@r.g.1166 shia religion is Shirk

[@mhmadbedrddeen3414]

@@zahirkhan-yq3gr sunni religion is the worship of a beardless man with 2 right hands as you scholars say that is the shirk

[@trealNoOne]

shia - ya ali ya hassan ya hussain ya zahra ya fatima sufi - ya rasul allah ya abal qadir qadir jilani ya gareeb nawaz ya ghauz e azam ya ganj data hajweri ya kaale shah ya totte shah ya kutte shah

[@am1156]

The first thing the French did after WWII was to reestablish their power over the colonies. The Germans occupying the French was a big no no but Algeria and Vietnam should naturally belong to France.

[@botbeamer]

Your umm

[@am1156]

@@botbeamer ?

[@Abou_Salahedine]

Abu Baqr Seddiq and Zaïd ibn Harithah ibn Shurâhîl Ibn Ka'b Ibn 'Abd Al'Uzzâ Ibn Umru' ul Qays Al Ka'bî are the only one who are not a prophet or a messenger to be mentioned in the Holy Quran, but ...Sahaba ! *Surat Al Ahzab 33 : 37* _And (remember) when you said to him (Zaid bin Harithah رضي الله عنه - the freed-slave of the Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم) on whom Allah has bestowed Grace (by guiding him to Islam) and you (O Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم too) have done favour (by manumitting him): "Keep your wife to yourself, and fear Allah." But you did hide in yourself (i.e. what Allah has already made known to you that He will give her to you in marriage) that which Allah will make manifest, you did fear the people (i.e., their saying that Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم married the divorced wife of his manumitted slave) whereas Allah had a better right that you should fear Him. So when Zaid had accomplished his desire from her (i.e. divorced her), We gave her to you in marriage, so that (in future) there may be no difficulty to the believers in respect of (the marriage of) the wives of their adopted sons when the latter have no desire to keep them (i.e. they have divorced them). And Allah's Command must be fulfilled. (37)_ *Surat At Tawba 9 : 40* _If you help him (Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم) not (it does not matter), for Allah did indeed help him when the disbelievers drove him out, the second of the two, when they (Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم and Abu Bakr رضي الله عنه) were in the cave, he (صلى الله عليه وسلم) said to his companion (Abu Bakr رضي الله عنه): "Be not sad (or afraid), surely Allah is with us." Then Allah sent down His Sakinah (calmness, tranquillity, peace) upon him, and strengthened him with forces (angels) which you saw not, and made the word of those who disbelieved the lowermost, while the Word of Allah that became the uppermost, and Allah is All-Mighty, All-Wise. (40)_

[@r.g.1166]

Abu Bakr is NOT mentioned by name in Quran. Do not lie on Allah swt revelation.

[@AL-FATTAH_servant]

@@r.g.1166 He didn't say ''by name''

[@r.g.1166]

@@AL-FATTAH_servant He quoted translation with the name Abu Bakr and compared it to Zaid who is ACTUALLY mentioned by name in Quran. Can you people not have an honest conversation?

[@r.g.1166]

@@AL-FATTAH_servant Ali is mentioned over and over in Quran, not just once, btw.

[@AL-FATTAH_servant]

@@r.g.1166 Brother, yes Zaid (R.A) is the only Sahabi mentioned by name in the Qur'an. The brother above mentioned also the ayah about when the prophet Muhammad ﷺ and Abu Bakr (R.A) were hiding in the cave (during the hijra) which doesn't mention Abu Bakr (R.A) by name but by ''his companion''

[@user-dv7ik9cm7d]

Just imagine if God made prophet Mohammed’s boys peace upon him stay a live they would have made of them Gods the way that Christians did with prophet Jesus peace upon him

[@r.g.1166]

Hasan and Husain (as) ARE prophet Muhammad's pbuh sons.

[@nepl]

a sincere shia is rare these days may Allah guide him

[@mhmadbedrddeen3414]

Most of knowledgeable shia are sincere this one is just ignorant a perfect pray of ignorants like shamsi to fool ignorants that he is knowledgeable watching the video

[@myproductions6225]

All the sincere one already became sunnis

[@adnanaslam7227]

I have shia cousins . One neutral one quiet one extreme. I told him shiaism is not same. He says 90% shia suni same. I said nothing inside is same just labels are same. I said even ur sister have different belief than u ur father has extreme belief than u. Then he said same places have same creeds. I said. Our shia neighbors and friends have different one calls Ali ra as equal to god another is fighting with extreme shias about not to do chest beating. Another is old and teying to be good in sunnis has different belief and talks about why other shias disagree with him. This is the situation yet they dont seem I told him me and my 4 brothers or ur cousins have same suni belief everything same.

[@ziggazagga9844]

Marring a 6 year old...

[@johnflyer7444]

What’s this title akhi change the title of the video, they are our brothers in Islam we need to unite and learn not shame them.

[@geeenzee1152]

The Rafidah are not brothers in Islam. What are you talking about? They curse our Aisha r.a., who Allah called UMM al Mu`mineen. They curse the Sahaba r.a., who Allah is pleased with. They call upon the Imaams, although Allah says ONLY to call upon him. They have made divinely appointed successors to the prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, where Allah has said that the prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam is the final prophet and the seal of prophets. What are you talking about? What kind of brotherhood do you think we can have with them, when their entire ideology is false. I don't see anybody saying that the Ahmadiyyah are our brothers, so why should the Shia be considered our brothers.

[@aspirin2912]

"Whoever practices the mut’ah has only once, will no longer have to fear the wrath of the Almighty. The one who practices the mut’ah twice will be resurrected with the good ones and the one who practices the Mout' has three times to compete with me in Paradise. " ("Man the yahdourouhou Al-Faqih" volume 3 p 366) "Whoever makes the Mut'ah once will have the status of Husayn, the one who does it twice will have Hassan's, the one who does it three times will have Ali, and the one who does it four times will have my status." (in reference to the status of the Prophet Mohammad) (Tafssir Minhaj Ous-Sadiqin, Fourou al-Kafi)

[@aspirin2912]

Kulayni narrates a hadith from Imam Baqir: “Anyone outside the Shiites is illegitimate. » (Furu'ul Kafi: Kitabul Raouda: 135) Moulla Baqir wrote: “When Imam Mahdi appears, he will start by executing Sunni scholars before attacking the disbelievers. » (Haqul Yaqin: 2:527)

[@aspirin2912]

The chias believe that the Sunni people’s blood and property are legal. Al Sadouq reports in «The Motives» a tradition dating back to Daoud ibn Ferqad: «I told Abu Abdallah what do you think of the Sunni? He said, His blood is lawful. But to protect yourself, if you can bury him under a wall or drown him in the sea so we don’t have any tracks, do it! I said to him: What about his possessions? He answered me: Take what you can! «Al-mahasin an-nafsaniyyah» p. 166

[@mhmadbedrddeen3414]

Thank you brother, these wahabi takfirs even take other sunnis out of Islam, a muslim is whoever says the 2 testimonies regardless of other believes which Allah alone will judge

[@user-ew1xu4wq4k]

With this title and sensationalism your making the shia brother look bad. However, he seems mskeen and more of a laymen shia, and he sounds very sincere and a good brother who wants to learn. He’s not promoting any type of shirk or disbelief or misguidance and he’s agreeing with Shamsi a lot. So please change your video title or make it look better. Shamsi is giving dawah to the shia and teaching him about the differences and about the sunnah and the shia is sincerely listening and interested. This channel looks silly sometimes with the sensationalism titles. It makes muslims look bad when you do this. Your channel is full of amazing dawah and calling to the sunnah, yet you still do the crazy video titles.

[@muhamad2971]

Yet there in the thumbnail it shows "sincere shia" but still the title kinda silly

[@sFDawah]

There 2 people in the video, don't judge before you finish the video..watch the full video...then comment inshalla

[@user-ew1xu4wq4k]

@@sFDawah akhi the ‘fake muslim’ is the crazy guy that only comes in for a short amount of time. Most of the video is shamsi with the shia giving dawah, yet in the title you write ‘FAKE MUSLIM’ in capitals before anything else. Come on bro its obvious that you did that for sensationalism. That crazy guy who doesnt even know what religion he is is a very small part of the video. Hes not relevant and idk why the title even references him. This video should be focused on how shamsi is giving dawah to the shia and he is sincerely taking it in and learning.

[@user-ew1xu4wq4k]

I already watched this whole talk but on Sam Dawahs channel thats why i knew what the video is about, and I knew who u were referencing when u said ‘fake muslim’ but its unnecessary. That guy is mjnoon and not relevant at all. He said buda is better than our prophet (as). Hes a joke yet you still focused the title on him.

[@mhmadbedrddeen3414]

They come to ignorant shias and fool them and the ones who are watching, a learned child can refute shamsi

[@hasibulhasan4716]

is shamsi shia or sunni??

[@AdilKhan_]

Sunni

[@nusldn1]

he is not afghan, they are all iranians

[@aspirin2912]

Taqya !!!

[@r.g.1166]

Taqiya is in the Quran.

[@shoqolatiste]

How are shia at peace with their intellect? 😂😂😂

[@thetruthseeker1234]

In the Last Hajj of prophet (SM), he advised us to follow Quran and Sunnah. But in Gadir e Khum, He (SM) advised us to follow Quran and be careful with dealing with his Ahlul Bait. And warned us about dealing unjustly with his Ahlul Bait. And he (SM) said for whoever Muhammad (SM) is Moula, Ali is his Moula. Now whoever did not act properly with Ahlul Bait and died not repenting, I as a Muslim have no respect.

[@geeenzee1152]

Ahlusunnah loves and respects Ahlulbayt. So we have no problem there. However I want you to tell me what Maula means.

[@thetruthseeker1234]

@@geeenzee1152 Maula means beloved.

[@geeenzee1152]

@@thetruthseeker1234 Great, and Ali radi allahu anhu is our beloved. He is of the rightly guided Khulafa and he is Amir-ul-Mu'mineen. Now my question is, is Ali radi allahu anhu the successor of Rasul Allah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam?

[@mohamedab9033]

This is what Shias are willfully blinded to and refuse to open their eyes to. You will *never* hear a Muslim in the whole world, who follows the Qu'ran and Sunnah of Prophet SAW, curse Ahlul Bait or speak disrespectfully about them. It's a joke at this point, honestly. I just dismiss any shia who claims as such.

[@mhmadbedrddeen3414]

The prophet said hold on to the book of Allah and my family, the narration to follow the book and the sunnah is weak

[@homarcarrion1293]

Can any Muslim prove Allah Is the One True Living God?

[@zaidelakraa6396]

read the quran, there you will find your proof

[@homarcarrion1293]

@@zaidelakraa6396 I read Quran, but it doesn’t make any sense. Like for example. How many Creators in the Quran?

[@zaidelakraa6396]

@@homarcarrion1293 in wich way it didnt make any sense?

[@homarcarrion1293]

@@zaidelakraa6396 In every single way. Like for example. Who’s We In The Quran? Quran 21:17. If we intended to take a pastime wife or son we could surely have taken it from ourselves. How many Creators in the Quran? Quran 37:125. Will ye call upon Baal and forsake the Best of Creators. Why Allah spray hate? Quran 5:14. We caused among Christians animosity and hatred Hate is from Satan. Quran 5:91. Satan plan is to stir up hostility and hatred between you It’s seems like Allah is under the command of Satan.

[@zaidelakraa6396]

@@homarcarrion1293 reffering to the we it is a style of the arabic speaking. Allaah, may He be glorified and exalted, sometimes refers to Himself in the singular, by name or by use of a pronoun, and sometimes by use of the plural, as in the phrase (interpretation of the meaning): ‘Verily, We have given you a manifest victory” [al-Fath 48:1], and other similar phrases. But Allaah never refers to Himself by use of the dual, because the plural refers to the respect that He deserves, and may refer to His names and attributes, whereas the dual refers to a specific number (and nothing else), and He is far above that.” he is one and he is not begotten. the one and only.

[@amarhr1988]

Was with you until you said yazid wasnt responsible like fam do your research

[@mhmadbedrddeen3414]

Every thing he said is wrong and twisted, he speaks out of ignorance without any reference from a book

[@seyedhamidmossavi3226]

How is this conversation supposed to go anywhere and have a clear outcome if the so called Shia fella has zero knowledge of his own faith? Clearly the Sunni guy is knowledgeable about his faith and the other guy has no clue. The Sunni fella should find someone who is knowledgeable about Shia faith and debate that person instead.

[@habiba9311]

Sometimes it doesn't have to be a debate or discussion. He's teaching him tawheed, alhamdulillah

[@zinedine800]

The Shia guy is Iranian

[@ETM12990]

no the sincere one is iraqi he said it himself

[@zinedine800]

@@ETM12990 I know an Iranian when I see one. I am Kurdish myself. A lot of Iranian Shia Say they are a Iraqi but are not.

[@TheMedicalLad]

@@zinedine800 why do they say they are Iraqi?

[@justarshad8354]

Doesnt matter..all shias are same..all of them are misguided and have been deviated from the true path..

[@ETM12990]

@@justarshad8354 thats so wrong on many levels lol look at ur youtube profile u seem like missguided one

[@khalidpeacenowar4474]

Ya Ali.. Ya Ali & Mutaah.. Shia is Kuffar.. Pull Stop.. 🤷🏻‍♂️🤷🏻‍♂️

[@yonahsaunders7102]

He (Nachman of Breslav) said: 'The World has tasted nothing yet. If they would hear just one of my teachings together with its melody and dance, they would all submit completely. The entire world, even the animals and plants - everything - all would submit completely. Their very souls would faint from the sheer woundrous ecstasy. Also, each person who is closer, his movements happen of their own accord, as he senses that mentioned above. Whoever is closer to the melody and dance understands more and performs the melody's movements automatically due to this great pleasure.... Likewise, the closer one is to the holy, that is - the closer to the teachings, the song and the dance - the more the movements occur on their own owing to the holiness. All this I heard myself. - The Scroll of Secrets. The hidden messianic vision of R. Nachman of Breslav Academic Studies Press 2010

[@khalimartins7745]

Mahfour Hahahha

[@daniyalnaeem1404]

The mix between Mahboob & Ghafour MAHFOUR 🤪

[@haidersaujana7991]

Sahabi hazrat Abdullah ib ny abbas said there are 300 ayat in Quran about Ali a.s

[@iimiboy]

Stop lying and bring your evidence

[@omarhaddara6230]

Dubai ? Ya shamsi wallah i follow your speeches and dawah but please never ever ever say that dubai is a muslim place . La3natallah 3layhom .

[@Floyd308]

Shias, ask your selves why Sunnis NEVER curse anyone who's related to the prophet Muhammad pbuh and his companions, yet shias cures the companions of prophet Muhammad pbuh? Why even Christians respect the companions of Issa pbuh, yet you shias curse the companions? You are in the wrong path! Come back!

[@Cogi00]

Leave us out of it. We don't know the same Jesus

[@mhmadbedrddeen3414]

Actually sunnis curse ibn salol and abu lahab the uncle of the prophet, you curse abu taleb and abdullah the father of the prophet and say they are in hell, so don't make silly ignorant arguments, the Quran order us to curse the hypocrites, if a person is found hypocrite no matter his relationship with the prophet he is cursed, simple logic We don't need to jump around to justify for the wrongdoings of some sahabah and by that going against logic and the Quran itself You were fooled the propaganda of that era made for you legends that are far away from the truth

[@mukhtar768]

Sorry me no english. Wen asked about ww2

[@abdirashidsaleh5769]

Please, shamsi be careful what you say when you talking too fast, because Shia aren't followers of Ali

[@mhmadbedrddeen3414]

Yes we are A simple question At the battle of the camel would you fight with Ali or with Aisha against Ali, for me no doubt i will fight with Ali, let's see your answer

[@aspirin2912]

"Whoever practices the mut’ah has only once, will no longer have to fear the wrath of the Almighty. The one who practices the mut’ah twice will be resurrected with the good ones and the one who practices the Mout' has three times to compete with me in Paradise. " ("Man the yahdourouhou Al-Faqih" volume 3 p 366) "Whoever makes the Mut'ah once will have the status of Husayn, the one who does it twice will have Hassan's, the one who does it three times will have Ali, and the one who does it four times will have my status." (in reference to the status of the Prophet Mohammad) (Tafssir Minhaj Ous-Sadiqin, Fourou al-Kafi)

[@efdawahfan]

what is this ?? legal prostitution ??

[@imranhussainsaleh3132]

Is this shia sources? Never seen this before. And is mutah the marriage thing? Doesn't seem right. Sorry for my ignorance.

[@Salafiyahisthehaqq]

@@imranhussainsaleh3132 yes Shia sources

[@geeenzee1152]

​@@imranhussainsaleh3132 Muta is temporary marriage, which was forbidden by the messenger of Allah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam. In Iran, you can marry for two hours or three hours or a day, etc and the Mullahs will cosign this. Obviously it is for no other intention, but to have sexual intercourse, while the "wife" gets her agree upon dowry.

[@justarshad8354]

Fake & fabricated hadith.. 100% bullocks!