F.S Mackintosh Free Energy Machine

[@rhapsodyman2000]

You can hear an air condenser spraying air when the machine moves.

[@user-rs8zg8ey2b]

and the bottom of his shirt starts to wave, BUSTED! That was a lot of work to get caught.

[@jimiboii209]

Ain’t that a bitch

[@zawatsky]

@@jimiboii209 тем кто понимает как работает механика подвох виден даже без звука. :-)

[@stealthfoot68]

If you understand physics , it does insane stuff. This is a clever way of physics, all you need is less resistance of friction on the wheel (axel pivot point & ball bearing groove) than there is being exerted on the wheel. Magnetic pull is waaay stronger here. Clever ! Very clever. And over the heads of the Nay Sayers.

[@silience4095]

@@stealthfoot68 Yeah and if you calculate the force on the ball, it's making the wheel spin! In fact it's not doing anything to rotate the wheel

[@swimmarfishy]

Cool! My uncle once made a door lock from magnets...problem is, the 'key' was a huge magnet, and hard to lug around lol!

[@sleezybeatz]

If "I" discovered or invented something as genius as this, my HEAD would be showing everywhere. What happened to ur head Mr?

[@origamiscienceguy6658]

It doesn't actually work, so probably nothing.

[@ronalddump4061]

+sleezy: Pease explain why you think this is so "genius'

[@SubramaniamLakshminarayanan]

Sure it's a Mr. , and not Ms.??

[@jittenddra]

if he shows his head, Oil companies will kill him.

[@tommymarco]

@@SubramaniamLakshminarayanan mr

[@timwhitrow7975]

It's a nice trick, although you can hear the compressed air being turned on and off when the wheel turns.

[@TheBikerScout]

Nice air hose sound.

[@jamessteidl5260]

To move the wheel, you need gravity to move the over-balanced part of the wheel towards the Earth. The magnet is preventing the steel ball from falling, so there is no force pushing the wheel in any direction at all.

[@panchovilla5400]

HOW ABOUT THE BALL ROLLING ON THE WHEEL??? IS THIS CONCEPT TOO HARD FOR YOU????

[@sinisterthoughts2896]

@@panchovilla5400 are you insane, stupid or trolling? the dude uses an air hose to blow on the wheel, so the ball rolls inside the wheel as it spins.

[@dani777dani]

friction from: air, central ax, ball "falling" and.... magnet vs aluminium lorentz law

[@hogsworthhammer9211]

Beautiful machines; the way they seem to work is awesome.

[@khalidhashmi99]

When he start the wheel some type air sound i heard

[@seanarki]

I know right? That was the first thing I noticed. Anyone with a magnet, a metal ball, and a hamster wheel could disprove this.

[@azrnzala]

If you goto the website the message at the bottom of the page states: "My Perpetual Motion Machines models are of motorized versions that were built to illustrate how they were supposed to work in the minds of Inventors. Never mind what educational level we are at, we all miss something that goes beyond the usual scientific explanations. Fundamental Science, Physics Laws and boring Laws of Thermodynamics bring the ‘flight’ of Inventors’ ideas to land. Growing Technology … We live in an age of consumption. But many of us are still dreaming and believe that the era of creativity has not gone. My PMM models are built for them. I’d like to inspire these people by demonstrating Unworkable Perpetual Motion Machines that were designed centuries ago." So no, these machines aren't real. Nor is the youtube channel claiming they are... they may be trying to mislead some people, but it seems the page at least is being honest.

[@Однивопросы]

Занятно. Надо опробовать,прежде чем выводы делать.

[@slowerthansound]

Two weeks ago, I built one of these using an old train wheel and some sub-woofer magnets, however it has proved impossible to stop and I am worried that it may shake apart the foundations of my house, is this normal?

[@rever4217]

+slowerthansound ROFL

[@dogbiscuit1649]

Yes. That is perfectly normal. *Move along please. Nothing to see here...*

[@crissd8283]

Thank you for the Tesla reference/joke!

[@victorselve8349]

And now you have doomed us all... Thank you very much

[@sethh8892]

slowerthansound subwoofer* no need for a dash.

[@mandavister]

The wheel would only turn, if the vector of force would go downwards from the ball (to the center of earth due to gravity - like a hamster in a wheel). But that is not the case here. The magnet is the important force and therefore the vector of force points towards the magnet - hence, the wheel would not turn. Why ever the wheel is turning - it's not because of the ball.

[@garisatkin9744]

The ball is clearly in the way, so the wheel would spin even more.

[@harrygrounds6781]

I love the faint sound of an electric motor in the background

[@afroteddybear]

One thing I hate about the videos on the channel, is the comments section. If this guy, who has hundreds of these devices, actually believed these devices produce infinite energy, he would have videos about a perpetual motion device powered house. Seriously people are so quick to hate they can't seem to look beyond their own idiocy. Yes perpetual motion devices don't work as prescribed; you know that, I know that, he knows that. What his channel is about is simple devices that run on really slick engineering concepts. If you're too busy looking for the strings you forget to enjoy the puppet show.

[@Branko353]

afroteddybear best comment here hands down

[@ronalddump4061]

Dumb: "simple devices that run on slick engineering concepts". The device does not run at all, so ..............??? The reason for the "hate" is that all his devices like this are lies.

[@tantricmaster800]

Turn up the volume and you can hear air blowing to spin the wheel.

[@alanfrishman486]

The weight of the ball can't push the wheel down because the very magnet that is attracting it is preventing the ball from falling.

[@DanieleTartaglia]

It's a fake, you could remove the original sound. You hear the air compressor turn on before it's wheeled. you're a liar, This is not physical, but illusion

[@skylerbowerbank5847]

Read the channel description dumb ass

[@Michael-pf8we]

Its powering the compressor

[@bruh.5620]

you dimbass its a demonstration, not real

[@nicolasleonn.6459]

Junto con un grupo de estudiantes, construimos un modelo basado en el del vídeo y, aunque fue bastante complejo ubicar el imán, este si logra dar las vueltas.

[@santiagopascalmartinez7296]

Nicolas León N. Olá lo copiaste y funciono por cuanto tiempo ????

[@hamidijafri]

Am I wrong, I hear some hissing sound during the start until the end of the wheel rotating. Some kind of air pumps?

[@worldoftankblitz6743]

dude u are wrong , that sounds come from the window , beacuse they forgot to close it. loooooooooooooool

[@bruh.5620]

obviously this is fake. its a demonstration

[@tubular618]

He's keeping it going with subtle movements of the magnet with his hand. If he fixed the magnet to the base it would stop.

[@lukasschreyer2047]

nobody heard the compressor? I let me also try to blow on the wheel . Im sure it will work ^^

[@ihady2]

I heard it, too

[@E1craZ4life]

+Lukas Schreyer There would have to be things on the wheel to catch the wind, which would create something of a card shuffle sound if they were implemented.

[@FalconFour]

+E1craZ4life There are slats between the spokes. Kind of a long shot, but it's the best clue I've seen so far.

[@E1craZ4life]

Matt Falcon They would need to have a larger surface area in order to catch the wind needed to turn the wheel that quickly.

[@trainzmarcel2074]

+Lukas Schreyer that was an air conditioner i think

[@நக்மாசெல்]

Here the magnetic force is working against the gravitation of the ball and lift it. In a equibrium position the ball will be stable in an elevated state. Since the gravitation is nullified by the magnetic force ball cannot push the wheel down by its wait. If there is a front and back movement in the magnet then there is a change in the forces acting on the ball which can make the wheel rotate. The demonstrator has to take the hands off.

[@XaadeTheBlade]

Funny how it generated sound independently from when it generated movement.

[@XaadeTheBlade]

+Lee Louviere If you put a ball like that, sure it's exerting a downward force on the wheel, from the friction on the wheel produced by the pull of gravity., however, the magnetic force is causing the ball to generate an upward force equal to the downward force, balancing it out. But, Lee, the ball can roll. Sure, but it has no reason to. Once it stabilizes the force will be the combined force of gravity and the magnet, simply shifting the angle of the total force. If that worked, then a ball at the bottom of the wheel with no gravity would cause the wheel to move. The friction caused by it moving up is just more of the upwards force on the wheel produced by the attraction of the magnet. In order for this concept to work, the friction would have to be producing a downward force, at which point, you don't need gravity... see how that creates a paradox?

[@FromRussia_With_Love]

Well obviously the idea doesn't work in reality. But what sound are you talking about? The video is silent. Either that or my audio card isn't working. Which is actually quite likely.

[@XaadeTheBlade]

FromRussiaWithLove There's a very quiet scratchy hum that happens independently of when the device starts and stops moving

[@lltfdaniel]

This is quite easy to understand, magnets alone will never perpetuate so it has to be completed by something else like gravity, this motor is using gravity and magnetic flux, the weight of the magnet ball and flux oscillates to create movement here. So gravity and magnetic flux creates the movement. It is a way of tapping energy and actually does have a perpetual element, but you need 3 forces for it to fully shine as in self run and power a load but this one uses 2, correct me if i am wrong. The magnet can't reach the magnetic sticky point because of gravity and friction, oscillating back and forth creating movement? Knowing about the magnetic river if you put a magnet pass the sticky point it will fly off but with this hamster wheel it is always struck in the river creating movement back and forth and a balanced between magnet flux and gravity to achieve this.

[@Nilsy1975]

No, it is an illusion. The wheel is spun by pressurised air being blown on it by a hose. You can literally hear it in the background.

[@bobbrueckner7498]

Your machines are very well made and really look like they might work. Well done.

[@papajawn]

Now THAT is what I call brilliant.

[@ben8090]

How's this a free energy machine? Once you try to draw any power from the kinetic energy of the wheel it will stop.

[@orvilledennis8217]

Depends on the size of the load n the strength of the magnet relative to the load

[@HumorDash]

what he said

[@ronalddump4061]

+Ben: Not relevant, as the machine does not operate at all. You cannot extract energy from a magnet. Btw, IF it did operate at all, obviously you COULD use it to power devices. (If it could make energy to overcome the frictions trying to stop it, obviously it can be improved to make even more energy to run other devices)

[@mmangla5575]

Thanks For The Information

[@Cotronixco]

This is the refake of my popular 3 years old video in HD now for latest subscribers. In the next video, I will show how well it operates after I cut the drive belt.

[@TAKACreative]

Cotronixco .

[@mhoover]

a:the wheel isn't unbalanced if the magnet, not the wheel, supports the Ball; and 2:the sound cuts out just before the wheel starts up...hmmm...and III:Showing the base confirms it's done with air.

[@brunolourenco729]

I believe in this one. "Perpetual machines" only work with magnets or batteries (for the time they're charged) thats why.

[@metalandwood4u]

The can work on gravity too, especially linked with water flow and pressure, like herons fountain and the bell fountain.

[@silience4095]

@@metalandwood4u No, perpetual motion machines do not exist, nor do free energy machines. It's fake, look in the about page of the channel.

[@rogerdavis149]

Think if you listen close it's the ball rolling that is making the sound. Easy enough to find out if you have the skills to make one.

[@wkb9683]

The first and second law of thermodynamics will fix this.

[@Dplusithicus]

No magnet is permanent, so this would slowly stop working. However, if you could make an electromagnet that was powered by the movement of the wheel itself, then maybe.

[@ronalddump4061]

Completely irrelevant point. The magnet cannot make the device run in the first place. No array of permanent magnets put on a device, can do anything at all to impel that device. For obvious reasons. Magnets cannot do work. Your electromagnet idea is just silly. It will not work w/o outside electricity to power the electromagnet. Then, so what? That is simply an electric motor.

[@pixelmace1423]

“The hardest choice in making a perpetual motion machine is where to hide the batteries” In this case, an air condenser

[@erikgeber9432]

what do you mean?

[@pixelmace1423]

@@erikgeber9432 you can hear a hissing coming from something when the wheel is spinning. I assume it might be a jet of compressed air pushing the wheel to spinning

[@alansanchez9327]

lol, i know they are fake but im finding myself addicted to this guys videos

[@nikhilesraychowdhury4169]

People should respect you. you are a man who dares to break science.bravo,.... Newton (if you heard the name) has failed before you, genius

[@dompan9169]

Nikhiles ray chowdhury lol no XD

[@nikhilesraychowdhury4169]

These people cheating and uneducate the people are social criminals. They should be discouraged with no subscribe and tapping on dislike

[@dompan9169]

Nikhiles ray chowdhury all of the machines are fucking fakes XD grow a brain

[@sinisterthoughts2896]

I take it you're just doing a weird troll. His channel description says he covers false devices. he merely demonstrates how they would work, if they could, which they cannot. in this one he uses compressed air to move the wheel it can be heard and the bottom of his shirt ripples in the wind it generates.

[@jean-lucgilbert3666]

nice that you can hear the motor

[@PreOAP]

i like the idea but why the sound of a motor when it has stopped. Makes this unbelievable....

[@NorfiPL1337]

It isn't engine, only air pomp at top.

[@rltt379]

Well its more like a ball moving on a wheel which has more friction, since it gets pulled against the wheel

[@gowdsake7103]

Before it starts too ? tho its air

[@ezrahaskard3527]

The magnet pulls the ball towards it which we shall call “down”. now, much like a hamster In a wheel, there is a constant uphill or from a different perspective where the magnet is down, downhill. It is essentially on a constant downhill slant and is rolling down hill. If the magnet could touch it then yes, as it has reached the point at which it can no longer go down, as it is at the bottom. But since it isn’t it is constantly rolling down.

[@37rainman]

+Joseph: What kind of drugs do you like the best?

[@64298]

It works alright but needs a slight hand movement to allow some free play in the magnet. I already built one. Make it in a hands off mode and you will have a winner.

[@bobbyboucher2333]

Show it for a long time runing please! :O)

[@ronalddump4061]

Ive had one running out in the loft of my barn for 40 years straight. If I show it to the world, the goons hired by the govt and oil companies will assassinate my, so ............ (Except 20 years ago the bearings went out and it destroyed all my pot plants before it stopped thrashing about, but I installed some better bearings and it still seems good now. Pot is legal here now, so I grow it outdoors, but my meth lab is in the loft. Perhaps I should change the bearing again, I don't know.).

[@thegoodboi]

Wait what

[@bobbyboucher2333]

@@thegoodboi if it's still running,I likeit

[@silience4095]

@@bobbyboucher2333 It's impossible, these things are bogus.

[@LiverbestGibs]

This is a real device, but it's not limitless. The magnet will eventually weaken and stop working. It might be handy for emergency situations where you lose power and need something to charge batteries. The ball spins because there is an equilibrium between gravity and the magnet acting on the ball in different directions. This device would not work out in space, without significant gravity.

[@hyrarls8788]

you can literaly hear the air pressure stream on the video

[@MemeDumpworld87]

Sound of metal on metal..

[@MemeDumpworld87]

I will take that back speakers weren’t turned up...lol

[@Alliswell-jy2vo]

बहुत बढ़िया आविष्कार ए मेरे दोस्त

[@texasfishingwithdan]

I love it!

[@crazynacho9675]

It's not real

[@amirrahiminia2556]

The magnet pulls the ball towards itself. to make the motion of wheel possible, one side of the wheel must be heavier than the other side and that condition can not be existed while the magnet pulls the ball and if it doesn't the ball falls to lowest level instead of wheel turning.

[@jjay865]

As others noticed, too, I heard the sound of compressed air: even after the wheel stopped, toward the very end. (I had to turn up my audio levels to 80% or higher, to really hear all of the sounds that were in this video!) Caveat: I then re-balanced my audio system so that my hearing would not be damaged when I used my ear-buds on other videos...it's easy to forget such things.

[@jakobo8908]

woah, awesome work hidding the motor

[@nauvofact993]

1:04 - Sound of energy.

[@Marcelo_Fischer]

😂😂😂

[@RichardAmuir-f2l]

F.S Mackintosh'S NEXT NVENTION WILL TURN LEAD INTO GOLD.

[@rking342]

so obvious , the sound of air blowing....and the T-shirt moving from the blown air..... Why would somebody go to such a length to create this fake?

[@Rice0987]

Finally! Thanks for honesty. :*)

[@MrU2kite]

At least you don't have to feed and clean up the magnet like you do a hamster.

[@worldoftankblitz6743]

dude is this possible?

[@awatt]

Now you tell me...

[@silience4095]

@@worldoftankblitz6743 No

[@brandonho5266]

Glad to see that people aren't fooled by this :-)

[@ascendingone]

Brandon Ho sorry, this is real

[@TheDutyPaid]

-Motor in the base.-

[@TheDutyPaid]

LETTUCE PLAY strange overly sexual comment?

[@lettuceplay7480]

Nice observation.

[@TheDutyPaid]

Rakanishu Tsuyoshi 😀 your context is very good at insulting yourself.

[@AYTAZED]

Compressor.

[@TurnpikeRecYard]

Not to mention this is called a "free energy device " but does not show in the video that it is applied in any form to do work. So it just spins and will only have enough force to run itself

[@sinisterthoughts2896]

not even that. but to continue spinning it would have to constantly produce enough energy to do so.

[@wimpyentimothy]

and now run through the sound barrier to see how fast it can turn on graviti-force hahaha

[@sebastianstewart6894]

You know there is a limit to kinetic transfer.

[@silience4095]

What?

[@kocnn]

Awesome! There has to be things like this powering homes and even small communities of like minded folks.

[@Cotronixco]

+BuckGreywolfe - I will bet anyone any amount that it wouldn't even do that.

[@rockethead7]

Oh, the blind leading the blind. Look, this device is "working" because there's an off-screen air hose blowing on the wheel. It's as simple as that. Yet, you (Kevin), and you (BuckGreywolfe) are making multiple posted messages in these threads clearly stating that you've fallen for the trick. Seriously, gullibility isn't a positive attribute. I mean, even if hypothetically veproject1 didn't post the secrets in his behind the scenes channel where he shows you the hidden electric motors for many of his videos, or off-screen air hose (like this video), or camera tricks on Gimbal stages (like in his magnetic car video)... even if he didn't reveal how the tricks are done... seriously, why would anyone believe this stuff?? Why?? Because it's on KZbin? Therefore the laws of physics are all wrong? Violating the laws of physics is as simple as putting a metal ball on a wheel?? That's what you people believe?

[@geoffwood5411]

You can hear the air supply blowing I. The wheel

[@thecoolmanstatus]

It ain't got no propellers

[@uniqko]

Real free energy

[@annoyingbaby5071]

Tip: Turn off the sound when trying to fool people with a compressor. And almost everyone here is arguing about a faked video. Very sad.

[@viveleroy1]

+Annoying Baby A compressor for what ?

[@annoyingbaby5071]

Turning the wheel

[@Stickman_Productions]

The point of this channel is to show how old perpetual motion machines were meant to work, not to fool people.

[@DelSqueeto]

Excellent!!! Thank You

[@neelamrana7344]

DelSqueeto is this works

[@neelamrana7344]

please answer me

[@bootleggenie]

NO IT DOESN'T WORK YOU GOOMBA!

[@sethh8892]

Neelam Rana no it doesn't work dumbass

[@calholli]

0:40 y0u can see that it d0esnt' w0rk

[@julianpreciado4741]

turn up your volume to full blast and you can hear the air starting to blow before the wheel starts to spin. They also edit the volume in the video to try and hide it.

[@TheOswald42]

0:41 see that awkward movement?, that is the secret why the wheel rolling

[@bliglum]

+Oswald Rayleigh The moment he reaches down at the base to flick the switch to begin the wheel spinning? Yeah, good catch.. Perhaps he should study a bit more magician techniques, his misdirection and slight of hand need work XD

[@lettuceplay7480]

+Oswald Rayleigh your life's an awkward moment.

[@lettuceplay7480]

+bliglum Perpetual machines need an initial force to carry them on, such as a nudge or push. Dummy, if you fucking read about it you'd know about that already.

[@generico366]

You'd know that perpetual motion doesn't exist if you weren't a complete dumbass.

[@jordanc1224]

+Bas van de Kleut While I do agree with you. There are many machines that are extremely efficient so in the span of a minute and a half video will appear not to be loosing energy (not saying that this is one though I've not figured this one out yet).

[@keymaster430]

Couldn't you have at least edited out the sound of the electric motor after you took away the magnet and picked it up to show the bottom. It was really evident when you did that and the motor sound was muffled. Either that, or explain the sound itself, because I was really impressed with this idea and the simplicity of it and don't really see why it wouldn't work.

[@Simran_048]

Ball should stop at point close to magnet and not rolling It is fake

[@johnpages4627]

je réponds je regardes cette vidéo et je me pose des questions comment cela est t il possible ? après peut on le reproduire ? voilà deux questions qui resterons à tout jamais sans réponse ?

[@davidforcier4]

Ball roll because gravity.

[@kevinrahmatfathoni7896]

have you ever learn pyshics?

[@johnpages4627]

je réponds la gravité n a rien à voir avec cette petite machine qui est sûrement truquer c est évident et je vous fait une petite remarque cette personne qui à fait cette vidéo elle ne s exprimes pas c est bizarre et très douteux vous ne pensez pas ?

[@johnpages4627]

je réponds des pyschiques NON pas du tout ce que j ai écris est la vérité cette vidéo est très douteuse j en conviens de plus vous ne connaissez rien à rien aux techniques et c est facile de comprendre que c est un canular c est faux voilà c est tout

[@Barskor1]

Cold Steam the efficient way to use heat sources to produce electricity and or distilled water explained from basic concept to employment. Water boils at 75 degrees F in a vacuum. Two open containers one full of water the other empty connect them at the bottom and water will reach an equilibrium 50 50. If one is sealed except for the connection the other will remain empty because of the vacuum created in the sealed container. Gravity will overcome this vacuum if the containers are taller than 30 feet. If the tanks are 40 feet tall the tanks will reach an equilibrium of water levels at 30 feet leaving ten feet of hard vacuum in the sealed tank. This makes a vacuum pump set we need two of them if we were going to distill water as the cold side open tank is used to collect the distilled water from it as the continuous input of water needs to go somewhere. Each sealed tank has four valves three at the top two of those on opposite sides (B&C) one at the very top (D) one at the bottom on the side (A), water-based vacuum pump operations are, Close bottom tank valve A and top tank valve C. Open top tank valve D. Fill sealed tank through top side valve B. Close valve B and D when full. Open bottom valve A. This primes the system to let the warm water in that will vaporize and run through the system when you partially reopen valve B (to control flow rate) and open valve C to its fullest. For only power generation need one pump set and one vacuum tank so we can have a Hot side and a Cold side one to boil the water and one to have the low pressure/vacuum to draw the steam in through the turbine then the cooling coils then to the tank. At the bottom of the cold side, tank is a return pipe with the one way valve to the heat source the one-way valve prevents expansion back to the cold side and as the hot side vacuum chamber is the only outlet for the expanding water and it is drawn by the vacuum the cycle proceeds. You can combine the two and get power generation and distilled water keeping the return line from the power generation system will let you switch if you don't need distilled water on a continuous basis in large quantities. I am going to make one feel free to make one as well it is open source.

[@rafmael6127]

Hello veprojects ,i`m one of youre fan i like your`e videos .I wnat to buy some of this if you have some for sell please give me your`e way of contact thank you so much.

[@generico366]

Do you seriously believe this bogus is real?

[@rafmael6127]

+Bas van de Kleut I will know if it`s bogus or real if i make one and try it.

[@generico366]

How did that work out for you?

[@jimmyupson1959]

I need to get some ideas on where the wheel material to make one of these. Thanks -Jim

[@ronalddump4061]

Why, the device does not work at all

[@snwsoul]

чтоб шар крутил колесо он должен вращаться, а энергия магнита имеет определенную направленность. самая глупая попытка которую я видел в жизни

[@ВиталийПархоменко-и5б]

Магнит тоже должен вращаться!

[@onlytruth9857]

Ты самый глупый. Это колесо запатентовано ещё в 1823 году. А ты не можешь до сих пор понять, что оно работает.

[@squidge3986]

Turn your volume up high! You can hear the compressor air, no mistake. Hear it kicking in a couple of seconds after he flicks the ball towards the magnet at 00:39 and turning off again just after he takes the ball off at 01:29. The air dwindling off like a lazy Sunday fart.

[@aesha59das]

Can you grow magnets in a magnetic field?!!!

[@armancz]

No. They grow on magnet trees, go back to skool, dummy.

[@sinisterthoughts2896]

okay, that was funny!

[@JoseA-Divergent]

Si que Funciona. Llega un momento en el que la velocidad es constante. No desafia ningun principio de la Fisica.

[@ИзраБагаев]

Зато физики бы сказали что это нарушение трёх законов сохранения энергии. В природе ещё очень много нераскрытых принципов.

[@Roadietodamascus]

not perpetual motion, they are scientifically and physically impossible.

[@Joso997]

no they are not lol

[@nicks.12]

FreeStyle yes they are.

[@sethh8892]

FreeStyle do you not understand the laws of thermodynamics? If you don't that explains why you actually believe these are possible. Jesus Christ kid get it at least a fifth-grade education.

[@VicVlasenko]

No they are not - just remove acceleration and voila! ;-)

[@silience4095]

@@VicVlasenko Remove acceleration... how is that supposed to help?

[@jigar_k_patel_251]

This looks seriously convincing to me... Explain this if anyone disagree with the concept... (I know that perpetual motion is impossible as it brakes physics laws)

[@silience4095]

The ball isn't being pulled down normally, don't forget the magnet is at play. It's as if gravity for the ball is now pointing in a different direction (the total force it feels is pointing in a different direction), you just see it sit at its lowest point in this new force field, while the wheel gets blown with air.

[@KurNorock]

out of all of the stupid "perpetual motion" machines (yes I know they are impossible) these type have to be the dumbest by far. it doesn't even make any sense. if the magnet it holding the ball at a certain level then there is no actual force causing the wheel to turn. this is not an unbalanced wheel because the ball is not connected to the wheel and is held up by an external force.

[@azrnzala]

The website clearly states this is a motorized prototype of something inventors came up with ages ago.

[@KurNorock]

asm0deus yes I know. But the original concept was supposed to be a non-motorized perpetual motion machine powered only by the fact that the little ball is held to one side of the wheel, a concept that has no basis in physics whatsoever.

[@azrnzala]

Kur Norock Oh yeah, the theory is of course stupid. I just wanted to point out that although this video is misleading, there is clarification on the website in the description.

[@azrnzala]

BuckGreywolfe Not really sure what your point is? What does it turning have to do with anything? This is a motorized device. No shit it will turn.

[@Cotronixco]

+BuckGreywolfe - And yet, a car rolls down the road! (Never mind that engine hidden under the hood.)

[@mrk1075]

But the magnet and ball like that would actually keep the wheel from turning.

[@personwithhat9191]

the laws of thermodynamics THE LAWS OF THERMODYNAMICS

[@thomasranjit7781]

But use a dog to run on such machines and generate kinetic energy...

[@frozensoul8241]

problem 1: heat: it would eventually get so hot repairs would be required. problem 2: magnets: magnets eventually run out, simple as that, replacements would have to be continually made. problem 3: wearing: the wood would eventually wear down to the point it breaks

[@sinisterthoughts2896]

4: physics.

[@garundip.mcgrundy8311]

To all those who enjoy expressing, "Perpetual motion is impossible!" Imagine, even young people say this! So, instead of easily finding fault and saying, "I'm scientific, and therefore, I know perpetual motion is impossible," for heaven's sake, "Find possibility!" The youth of America is supposed to "Find Possibility," not go around like some eighty-year old and say, "No! I know it's already 'impossible'!" So much for youth.

[@generico366]

Could you please make a bit more sense? I can not for the life of me figure out what you were trying to say.

[@garundip.mcgrundy8311]

Oltlthoohotoyu! Gothuo. Foutotow! Gort.

Yes children. Santa Claus is real. Just believe harder.

[@sethh8892]

Nunya Biness that's a strawman but in this situation I guess you are correct

[@sethh8892]

Garundi P. McGrundy perpetual motion is impossible... no matter what technology we have in the future nothing can go against the laws of thermodynamics and therefore perpetual motion will always be impossible. Just because you believe doesn't mean it's actually real. Just because I believe that if I walk in my room a million dollars will be on my bed does not mean that when I walk in my room there will be a million dollars on my bed.

[@groundcontroltomajortom2471]

If there's such a thing as free energy machine, we don't need to fight each other for oil. But unfortunately in the real world, we still fight for oil.

[@ptcman8267]

Yes is fake... but the idea is interesting ....

[@CrazyGamal]

The wheel generates friction on the ball, so the ball gets pulled to earth but it's also attracted by the magnet which pulls the ball upwards. The ball is rotating clockwise because of the interdependency of the wheel's friction and the magnet's magnetic field. The permanent magnet isn't an energy source per se, but by it's physical characteristics the ferromagnetic iron is turning into a permanent magnet, too. Now they're both "connected". While rotating clockwise, this time the ball generates friction on the wheel, which - as you can see - is also rotating clockwise and that's the point: Both are strengthening each others motion in a perfect proportion to the permanent magnet magnetic's field. The ball by getting attracted by it and the wheel by getting rubbed by the ball. As everything in nature works perfectly together (even while the menkind is destroying itself and our nature's planet) the magnetic field and the ball's friction on the wheel are getting in balance. It doesn't take much time because the needed energy to start this circuit is nearly zero, so you won't recognize, but you'll agree when you think about it. We all could live in balance, we all could be happy. You should live with an open mind and never prejudice anyone's opinion or anyone's beliefs.That being said, I want to quote a great person and hope you've ever heared the speech of Charlie Chaplin, because it never gets old... ------------------------- START QUOTE ------------------- I should like to help everyone if possible; Jew, Gentile, black men, white. We all want to help one another. Human beings are like that. We want to live by each others' happiness, not by each other's misery. We don't want to hate and despise one another. In this world there is room for everyone. And the good earth is rich and can provide for everyone. The way of life can be free and beautiful, but we have lost the way. Greed has poisoned men's souls; has barricaded the world with hate; has goose-stepped us into misery and bloodshed. We have developed speed, but we have shut ourselves in. Machinery that gives abundance has left us in want. Our knowledge as made us cynical; our cleverness, hard and unkind. We think too much and feel too little. More than machinery we need humanity. More than cleverness, we need kindness and gentleness. Without these qualities, life will be violent and all will be lost. The aeroplane and the radio have brought us closer together. The very nature of these inventions cries out for the goodness in man; cries out for universal brotherhood; for the unity of us all. Even now my voice is reaching millions throughout the world, millions of despairing men, women, and little children, victims of a system that makes men torture and imprison innocent people. To those who can hear me, I say "Do not despair." The misery that is now upon us is but the passing of greed, the bitterness of men who fear the way of human progress. The hate of men will pass, and dictators die, and the power they took from the people will return to the people. And so long as men die, liberty will never perish. Soldiers! Don't give yourselves to brutes, men who despise you and enslave you; who regiment your lives, tell you what to do, what to think and what to feel! Who drill you, diet you, treat you like cattle, use you as cannon fodder! Don't give yourselves to these unnatural men---machine men with machine minds and machine hearts! You are not machines! You are not cattle! You are men! You have a love of humanity in your hearts! You don't hate! Only the unloved hate; the unloved and the unnatural. Soldiers! Don't fight for slavery! Fight for liberty! In the seventeenth chapter of St. Luke, it's written "the kingdom of God is within man", not one man nor a group of men, but in all men! In you! You, the people, have the power, the power to create machines, the power to create happiness! You, the people, have the power to make this life free and beautiful, to make this life a wonderful adventure. Then in the name of democracy, let us use that power. Let us all unite. Let us fight for a new world, a decent world that will give men a chance to work, that will give youth a future and old age a security. By the promise of these things, brutes have risen to power. But they lie! They do not fulfill their promise. They never will! Dictators free themselves but they enslave the people! Now let us fight to fulfill that promise! Let us fight to free the world! To do away with national barriers! To do away with greed, with hate and intolerance! Let us fight for a world of reason, a world where science and progress will lead to all men's happiness.

[@josuecalebemartinsvasconce2087]

You may have good intentions, but this machine doesn't work and your explanation doesn't make any sense physically talking. Aren't the brute that are rising the power, but the ones who can deceive people with beautiful images and words

[@Scorpionclaw1984]

To all of you who still uses the "this is impossible" cliche, need to remember something.. In 1899, Charles H. Duell , a commissioner of the US patient office said "everything that can be invented, has been invented".. Take a look at the things we have now, 117 year later. Some of the greatest minds on the planet would never have imagined how far we have advanced all ready. While these machines may not work yet as a free source of energy, I find it sad to see so many here that claims to be "smart" by claiming it can't be done. Wait another 50 years or so, and see what kind of energy source we have then, and come tell me that it can't be done. Everything can be done, it is just a matter of time..

[@thepope2412]

Well a true perpetual motion machine is impossible unless you are somehow able to ignore several laws of physics

[@Scorpionclaw1984]

The Pope Well, about that. There are tons of things discovered every day that leaves scientists baffled as they appear to defy all we know about the laws of physics. Empty spaces in the universe, and yet there is gravitational pull. Black holes are still not completely understood. The laws of physics are what we say they are. For ages, physics told us that the speed of light was the only constant in the universe.. Yet, it was discovered that it is NOT a constant, as it can speed up and slow down, defying everything we think that we know.

[@rockethead7]

YOU SAID: "To all of you who still uses the "this is impossible" cliche, need to remember something.. In 1899, Charles H. Duell , a commissioner of the US patient office said "everything that can be invented, has been invented".. " == Yes, because the entirety of science can be boiled down to a single sentence made by someone in a patent office. YOU SAID: "Take a look at the things we have now, 117 year later. Some of the greatest minds on the planet would never have imagined how far we have advanced all ready." == "All ready," huh? Funny. Anyway, look, there's a difference between advancing technology and violating the laws of physics. One is possible, the other is not. YOU SAID: "While these machines may not work yet as a free source of energy" == I assume by "these machines," you're talking about all of the various other hoax videos that veproject1 produces. Yes, he makes tons of these kinds of videos, using various parlor tricks to make it seem like they're working. This particular one is done with the off-screen air hose that's blowing on the wheel. In others, he's using hidden electric motors. In others, he uses cameras on Gimbal stages. So what? YOU SAID: "I find it sad to see so many here that claims to be "smart" by claiming it can't be done." == All physics PhDs on the planet will tell you that it can't be done. YOU SAID: "Wait another 50 years or so, and see what kind of energy source we have then, and come tell me that it can't be done." == Whatever energy sources we use 50 years from now will not be in violation of any laws of physics, that much is certain. The device in this video would be in direct violation of a number of laws of physics if it actually worked. YOU SAID: "Everything can be done, it is just a matter of time." == No amount of time will make 2+2=9. The devices in veproject1's videos are making the physics equivalent claim to the math claim that 2+2=9. This is entry level thermodynamics. YOU SAID: " Well, about that. There are tons of things discovered every day that leaves scientists baffled" == The devices in veproject1's videos will not baffle a single physicist. YOU SAID: "as they appear to defy all we know about the laws of physics." == Pftttt. Name one thing that defies the laws of physics. YOU SAID: "Empty spaces in the universe, and yet there is gravitational pull. Black holes are still not completely understood." == First of all, what you call "empty" isn't the same as what a physicist would call empty. Secondly, the lack of understanding of certain things in the universe does NOT equate to violating any laws of physics. Yet, these were your examples of stuff that violates the laws of physics??? Please explain in your amazing understanding of science (pfffttt) what EXACT laws of physics are being violated in your examples. YOU SAID: "The laws of physics are what we say they are." == No, the laws of physics are DISCOVERED, not dictated. YOU SAID: "For ages, physics told us that the speed of light was the only constant in the universe.. Yet, it was discovered that it is NOT a constant, as it can speed up and slow down, defying everything we think that we know." == Oh, good grief, WHAT? It's been known since the speed of light was discovered that light doesn't travel at the same rate through every medium. Light travels through glass at about 1/2 of the speed of light through a vacuum. But, guess what, that doesn't actually mean that light itself is slowing down (though I doubt you can understand that concept). It merely means that one atom absorbs a photon, an electron reaches a higher energy state in its "orbital" and then releases a photon as it descends to a lower energy state again, thus, every atom in the glass is delaying the light's arrival at its final destination. The photon itself still goes at light speed when traveling from one atom to the next. This stuff was pretty well understood since light speed was discovered. You don't know what the hell you're talking about. Anyway, what on Earth are you babbling in the first place? Why are you defending these hoax videos? Why would you choose hoax videos like these to make these statements? When people say "this is impossible" (referring to veproject1's various videos, including this one), those people are 100% correct. This concept in this video is completely impossible. The only reason it appears to work is because there's an off-screen air hose blowing on the wheel. This isn't a matter of whatever energy technologies are developed in the future. The concept in this video was debunked about 400 years ago. Another 50 years isn't going to magically make this device start working without the off-screen air hose blowing on the wheel. Everything you're typing is pure babble.

[@emercaperlac]

Paw Christensen. You mean like making up more laws that doesn't break the previous laws?

[@christmassnow3465]

When the ball is in balance between gravity and the magnetic force its net force acting upon it iz zero therefore perpendiilar to the hoop and does not spin the wheel.

[@bpyangyang2153]

Making sense. I suppose by using more powerful and larger magnet we can get stronger shaft movement to turn something else and by adjusting the gap between magnet and iron block the rotation speed can also be adjusted. Is it so possible?

[@mart7ini]

my house use the same source of free energy!

[@generico366]

Nice bullshit, this is fake.

[@lamaking1978]

+Bas van de Kleut Alright smart guy, seems your the expert here. Just because you say its fake doesn't mean shit. Prove it!

[@rockethead7]

+Travis Cosentino So, I see you posting in multiple veproject1 videos. Pftttt. It appears that you think you've found the mother load of perpetual motion machines, huh? So, all of these famous failures from history, which would defy several different laws of thermodynamics... you REALLY believe they work? Pffttt. The one in this video is powered by an off-screen air hose blowing on the wheel to make it turn. Magnetism and/or gravity can't make wheels spin. I mean, seriously, what do you think happened here? Veproject1 miraculously made all of these old and failed designs from centuries ago all of the sudden start working?? They didn't work centuries ago, but they work now?? That's what you think? All of the physicists on Earth, building 18 mile long supercolliders, landing men on the moon, building telescopes that can see 10+ billion lightyears away... the smartest minds on Earth... none of them could manage to stick a ball on a wheel, until Veproject1 came along and did it??

[@lamaking1978]

+rockethead7 I think that these ideas are fantastic. Wonderful to see different inventions trying to solve the age old mystery of perpetual motion. I like to be optimistic about all my observations. I did not see any motors, hear any motors. Nothing is impossible, everything is possible. Just because you haven't figured it out doesn't mean that the answer doesn't exist somewhere in the universe. Trolling people about being wrong isn't doing you any good either. Grow up, you have better things to do with your life. Right?

[@generico366]

Perpetual motion machines are impossible. They defy the first law of thermodynamics and the law of conservation of energy. It can't be done, you're wrong. Period.

[@alberttorres4917]

If perpetual motion don't exist then where's the battery for the electron orbits the atom or the power supply when the earth orbits the sun? It's all about a balancing act that's all.

[@GuyFromSovietRussia]

что-то дует на колесо

[@cerjioamoralez]

+GuyFromSovietRussia Да, если приглядеться то видно как дергается футболка от ветра.

[@enosunim]

+Онлайн доход А если прислушаться.... )

[@abdeljalilshimi6441]

عنب

[@АндрейН-щ8б]

Внатуре, автора чуть не сдуло потоком воздуха.

[@norbertoaltarejos7042]

I love that idea

[@Geggslegs]

this is real but its not infinte engergy cuz the magnet will aventuly demegnatize so it is real but no free energy D:

[@crissd8283]

It is not real. Even if the magnets never demagnatized the device would not work. It would not run for a single second with the strongest magnet in the world.

[@erneroful]

stupid or something because You saw video and still regret?!

[@otakum333]

it's funny you think it's not possible because i remember doing shit like this when i was a kid playing with magnets. Go buy some toys and play lol

[@Cotronixco]

Your memory has failed you. You can't roll a car uphill.

[@creatip123]

This one looks fake, but say that it's real, even with the demagnetizing problem, it's still impressive. I mean, think about it. The wheel allegedly just need the initial push, and it will keep spinning until the magnet demagnetize enough to stop making it spin, which should take years. Attach an electro motor on the wheel, and with one initial push you can charge your phone for years with free electricity.

[@andreapinardi319]

Very nice, but there's a big problem: if perpetual motion existed, why we would still use oil, coal, ecc...? Perpetual motion is impossible, because it needs a perfect system where energy isn't lost in tranformations, but that's impossible in real life (Sorry for my bad English, but I'm Italian)

[@sinisterthoughts2896]

well said.

[@MadelnOahu]

Why don't we have cheap or free energy when this exist?!

[@BltchErica]

(facepalm)

[@generico366]

Because this doesn't exist.

[@Jotainkivaa123]

It looks to me that the ball is just rolling towards the magnet. You do work to the system when you pull the ball and magnet separate. Instead of banging back to magnet, the potential energy between magnet and the ball is transferred into rotational energy of the wheel. It just takes a while, because inertia. I wonder what would happen if the contact surfaces were tefllon. Perpertual motion machines are impossible. Cool video though :)

[@chrisgold8456]

It is not Perpetual as it consume energy and will stop once the magnet can no longer hold the ball up...

[@flawns]

peddle your wears else where

[@novaboon2866]

Ha, I get it.

[@NFGprometheus]

wow, I just watched that video

[@henryj7725]

lol

[@riemem261]

U WUT M8? #332&$4

[@paulche40]

gravity force pull down ball, magnet keep ball up - its work! wheel rolling! until its stuck in equal moment of forces

[@AndreyBarashkov]

+paul che Correct, unless magnet is not really a magnet.

[@abigguitar]

+Andrey Barashkov Or, unless there's something under the table. He turned the unit over, but not the table.

[@rockethead7]

+abigguitar - It's an off-screen air hose blowing on the wheel from the side.

[@gurpreetpreet1404]

fake video the wheel is rolling air pressure

[@grimms8783]

Uh, everyone who's saying stuff like "He pressed a switch" or "Air blowing", or "There being a motor", personally I don't see anything, in theory this machine is realistically impossible, my guess is the people saying this don't understand that the magnet is supplying magnetic energy causing the wheel to spin, and that magnets through constant use like that will eventually run out of energy, so there's no special tricks or catches, it's just science from what I see, though I'm not saying it's the way to make infinite energy, of course it isn't that's impossible, but it has good uses for making energy, just like solar panels. It's not infinite, but it can last a damn long time.

[@rockethead7]

YOU SAID: "Uh, everyone who's saying stuff like "He pressed a switch" or "Air blowing", or "There being a motor", personally I don't see anything" == Well, that's because the air hose blowing on the wheel isn't in the frame of the camera, it's a bit off screen. YOU SAID: "in theory this machine is realistically impossible" == So, you understand that this is impossible, but then complain at people who point out that it's being blown by an off-screen air hose? YOU SAID: "my guess" == Oh, you're going to guess now... this should be good. YOU SAID: "is the people saying this don't understand that the magnet is supplying magnetic energy causing the wheel to spin" == Oh, good fucking gods, WHAT??? What "magnetic energy" would that be? What the hell are you talking about? Magnets aren't batteries. Magnets aren't like batteries. Magnets don't supply energy. YOU SAID: "and that magnets through constant use like that will eventually run out of energy" == You have ZERO understanding of magnetism. ZERO. YOU SAID: "so there's no special tricks or catches, it's just science from what I see" == Well, then go watch his "behind the scenes" video where he shows you the air hose blowing on the wheel. You'll see that you're dead wrong. YOU SAID: "though I'm not saying it's the way to make infinite energy, of course it isn't that's impossible, but it has good uses for making energy, just like solar panels. It's not infinite, but it can last a damn long time." == Seriously, go back to school and take a few physics courses before you spew your stupidity all over the internet. You are dead wrong, and you know nothing about magnetism.