F1 Game Comparison: 2010 - 2023 Gameplay Comparison (PC)

Showcasing every F1 game from 2010 to 2023 released on PC by Codemasters with hotlaps around Spa, Belgium.
F1 2010: 0:00
F1 2011: 2:08
F1 2012: 4:14
F1 2013: 6:32
F1 2014: 8:45
F1 2015: 11:03
F1 2016: 13:20
F1 2017: 15:34
F1 2018: 17:46
F1 2019: 19:54
F1 2020: 22:05
F1 2021: 24:14
F1 22: 26:22
F1 23: 28:36
Inspired by the videos of Steven Heartstone, who deleted their channel some time ago for unknown reasons.
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @still_guns
Join My Discord: / discord
Support the Channel, Join My Patreon: / still_guns
Support the stream: streamlabs.com/still_guns1

[@still_guns]

The New Version of the video is here! kzbin.info/www/bejne/iWq5ZqacqseDpLcsi=wQteVlhyE3wIL4WG

[@LoudestHoward]

The F1 2010 intro takes me back.

[@MKArtorias]

or intro F1 2013

[@FormulaProg]

Ian brown 👍🏼

[@st0nemoss]

F1 2010, nostalgic, best intro, best music, best menu design, prettiest cars (imo of course)

[@AJ-dx6bn]

Clearly never played the 23

[@st0nemoss]

@@AJ-dx6bn nope

[@user-vb3bk2sl1j]

f1 2012 2016 and 2018 still the most accurate sound

[@hasanhasib4585]

I agree

[@WSNBM-1908]

2023

[@iJohn_YT]

2023 is way better

[@Sniperdud7762]

Yes 2012,2016,2018 has the best. (My opinion)

[@user-vb3bk2sl1j]

@@Sniperdud7762 the 2022 is better than 23 tho cuz the 23 has very high pitch sounds of the mercedes one.

[@tubularcandy812]

They need to bring nack back the 2010 emgineer he was way more emotional and happy after a win.

[@tun04]

actually his voice actor are jeff YEAH! they are same!

[@hasanhasib4585]

​@@tun04no way! they dont even sound similar

[@tun04]

@@hasanhasib4585 they are actually :)

[@hasanhasib4585]

@@tun04 where did u get the information from??

[@hasanhasib4585]

@@tun04 game credits?

[@cheesyeurotrance95]

2013 is my favorite, the last year of V8 engines and the first game with classic cars and tracks

[@Phoenix1664]

The tyre wear and AI not being fair, were two things that ruined this game for me.

[@MaNiX_xx_M.M.A.]

2020 is the game i always end up on i have all of them but that one just has the balance of features, feeling, and fkn classic cars . Amazing game..

[@mrbungle3310]

for me 2023 is going to be the next 2020...its my favourite f1 game and ive played them all...2023 has red flags+very fun handling+great ai+26 freaking tracks the most ever i think that you can actually mod into your season...its just the perfect game,shame 2024 looks bad

[@szymonxpl8083]

atmosphere in f1 2010 is nice

[@still_guns]

As F1 24 releases in just a few days, a new version of this video will soon be uploaded. Keep your eyes open and subscribe if you don't wanna miss it!

[@robohunter35]

As far as I understand from your video, the best F1 games are: 1-F1 2020 2-F1 2018 3-F1 2013 4-F1 2012

[@still_guns]

That's not actually that far off from how I feel.

[@scottyg22102938]

2020 was just so so good! Loved 2010 and 2018 too

[@Looocath]

The opening of F1 2010 is like no other!

[@chris19260]

Thank you for this Video Mate! 😊🤝🏼

[@adderhoney]

This was a good video. I have 2013, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022 and 2023 and I agreed with your findings. Well done.

[@Werferharfer]

This game series is really outstanding, full package and fun. Some games are not the best , but out of the box they deliver the best f1 experience and I tried all the games. The new game has the best gameplay and simulation, but I still miss championship mode and classic cars (f1 2013 style)

[@Werferharfer]

For me f1 23 has the best gameplay. Red flags are back, the 35% race length is better than i expected. But the attetion to details is for me the biggest deal, like tyre degradation or geeting dirt while driving outside the racing line and depending how dirt the track is , causes the car to lose some speed. The curbs react like real curbs, you can get stuck in one of them. The ffb is great , of course the handling. They really moved towards simulation this year. Sadly the game modes are the same since F1 2021. No championship mode only grand prix. No classic cars or f3 (would be great). I dont give a s... about story mode. Wont support this mode. The best would be something lile motogp, somekind of documentary.

[@christiangrech69]

Even in f1 23 you can still spin out for no reason 😂

[@luca017id]

great video, good at explaining every difference of the games. can you also put F1 2009 in the next videos? it should be from codmasters.

[@still_guns]

Unfortunately, I do not have F1 2009, nor do I have a Wii or PSP to play it on. Whilst I could download an emulator, I simply do not want to. Besides, this is a PC only showcase. 2009 never released on PC.

[@Ninja_PL-xs]

F1 2010 my favourite and first. The music. The vibes, just wow. Loved it as a little teen

[@adamryan4184]

27:12 the scene we will always remember...

[@subie2831]

"The jumping mercedes"

[@dazzle4416]

i waited and waited for this game to unlock on steam back in 2010 with my nvidia gts 250 1gb form sparkle, and waited and waited then finally after midnight it unlocked, then we got the end credits tune chase and status did, which was the supporting sound track for the film harry brown and you got the fear tune, it was fuckin amazing, such a well put together package, now its copy and paste copy and paste assets from previous games. i was bowled over by how fuckin great this game was, all we had before was the ps3 f1 game at that time so i was glad it went multiplat ,a testament to codies for the first game, that inevitably went down hill there after. you still wont beat the coding of Geoff Crammonds gp4 no body can, even to this day there still isn't any fire Marshalls on the track side attending crashes or crane animations or proper race incidents, like GP4,hence so many mods and updates even now for it. f1 2010 has a place in my memory i will always keep because it was a time where i started thinking about pc gaming and just feeling happy with life, shame i don't feel this way anymore. thanks to steam i still have this game in my library, the very same game i bought that same night i waited to unlock, not allot of people can say that especially console gamers, which unless you own a ps3 or a 360 that functions you never will, ill fire it up now and then just for the nostalgia just to hear "you got the fear" on the title screen.

[@bgg921]

F1 2019 if not have good sound, is last game from series with more hystoric cars, and is more enough to be liked

[@TheRageLivesOn]

that turbo sound in 2014 actually started giving me a headache

[@Jt7166]

Still using the same horrible track model for Spa 13 years later😂

[@zsolti8174]

Finally in f1 24 Codemasters will update spa

[@Jt7166]

@@zsolti8174 ha, I gave up on this franchise…hope it’s good though.

[@PINKPEE111]

F1 2023 A most best gamepad with a good start, I’m so happy for playing!

[@wolfwirestudios]

I started playing F1 games from F1-2014. Tried 2013, found it relatively better. Then skipped 15,16 and played 17. Was meh. Tried 18 and I loved it so much I didn't bother with any other entry until F1 2020 which is by far the best. Never tried 21 and 22 had bad reviews but on a free weekend I found that handling was somehow worse. Haven't tried 23, hoping it'll be good.

[@scottyg22102938]

You haven’t missed anything since 2020 mate !

[@diysai]

What gpu do you have? I can run the latest f1 games easily at 1440p ultra with my ryzen 3600+RX 6700.

[@still_guns]

AT the time of this video I was using an i7-2600 with a GTX 1050Ti. I now have an i7-13700K with an RTX 4070. The next version of this video will be much better.

[@silversilence7320]

If im not wrong the major difference started in 2016 and in 2019-20 as the game engines where changed also i think there are 2versions of f1 2015

[@still_guns]

There was only one version of 2015. That's where the then new version of the Ego engine was introduced.

[@RBVJnt]

The misinformation starts with Games for Windows - LIVE, as its servers are still up and actually you can play f1 2010 and 11 online on pc even today, this is because Games for Windows LIVE uses the same backend as Xbox 360, so it will be online until the 360 is offline

[@FormulaProg]

This game series hasnt aged well, what i mean by that is the sheer lack of progress in th graphics is astonishing. F1 23 looks a bit better than f1 2010. The environments have barely changed and the cars still have that toy ish look.

[@ricciardocinti]

I saw that in F1 2012 and 2013 you have the helmets positioned higher than normal. It's so annoying. Somehow, I resolved this little problem by turning on the V-Sync :)

[@still_guns]

Teaked?

[@ricciardocinti]

@@still_guns Sorry, I totally missed the word. I want to say that the helmets are positioned higher than the normal.

[@still_guns]

@@ricciardocinti You're right, I turned on V-Sync and the helmets went to a lower height that looks much better.

[@BlueflagAlpha]

Have you played F1 manager? Is it any good?

[@still_guns]

No I have not.

[@xizza9462]

the Mercedes sounded nice but the Rb7 in f1 2011 was crazy

[@PINKPEE111]

2011 Is my pick for the red flags for comeback, and kers

[@PINKPEE111]

So maybe f1 2015 and 2014 is in still ps4 and xbox one

[@BlueBet8321]

So F1 2015 is better than 2013😊

[@maxrichter6164]

12:00 huh There are Red Flags now in F1 23

[@JohanSebastianMedina]

La vida de un crítico es sencilla en muchos aspectos

[@MikDimitaPiosPaw]

2011 and 2013 for old console 2014 was good graphics for Xbox 360 2017, 2020 and 2023 for new console

[@BimBims]

F1 2010 are Grid Autosport with Mods 😂

[@JayS1622]

In 1 part of your video, you claim there still isn’t red flags to this day. F1 23 has red flags.

[@still_guns]

Will be fixed in the next version.

[@tyger357]

Hey bro, if u get a new PC. Do you mind if I keep with ur old one?

[@Fredz1234Yahoo]

Can anyone please explain how you can make the cars easier to handle? I have 2010, 2011 and 2013 on ps3. On all these games handling is awful with ALL the assists available turned on. I'm not good enough without assists in F1 games, and everytime I loose control over the car. The only game I can manage on ps3 is F1 championship edition! (2006 season). And I use hand controller. If anyone can help I would appreciate it 😊

[@maxwasfound4859]

Why is this on yt music💀💀💀

[@iJohn_YT]

F1 23 is the best of all time

[@gen.zaether4640]

do you know how to download f1 2013?

[@still_guns]

I bought a physical copy. Spent triple digits on a cdkey for the ultimate edition. I'm not a frequent sailor of the seven seas, if you know what I mean.

[@chriscurmi1]

F12020 is the GOAT

[@mcbeaulieu]

OK, I hope my comment gets seen, I've been asking that question for years but nobody has ever given me an answer. Why is there an option to make the TV pod camera move like I was sitting there myself? I, understand that such a movement makes the cockpit view more immersive, but god! I can't imagine the real onboard camera moving the same way on TV 😂

[@still_guns]

I'm not sure what you mean? Do you mean the offset TV pod?

[@mcbeaulieu]

No, that's how I play in fact 😅 I mean, erm, when the camera seems to keep going forward on braking. Is that the "Camera movement" option? I don't know, I set both Movement and Shake to 0 as soon as I change cars 😅

[@still_guns]

I think it might be the camera movement option. It does look much more stable in the later games.

[@Gh0st_MW2023]

When you said you can’t wait to what f1 24 will bring it’s literally f1 23 2.0

[@f0revergh0st]

from what ive heard from beta users, the handling model has gotten worse than its predecessor

[@salami_boi3169]

f1 23 also feels more optimized compared to f1 22, f1 23 runs alot better on my laptop.

[@iJohn_YT]

The "inability to change HUD in Time Trial" is NOT A BUG GUYS!!! IT IS NOT A BUG THERE IS A FEATURE, WHERE YOU CAN CHANGE IT THROUGH EVERY GAMEMODE, IT'S NOT A BUG

[@still_guns]

It was a bug at the time of recording. No matter what I did, I could not change anything on the HUD in time trial, but it was fine in races.

[@iJohn_YT]

I also thought it was a bug. But then I saw, that nobody else had this problem. So I went to that setting again, and I saw something like (Gamemode) down below, and from that point I knew that it wasn't a bug

[@still_guns]

@@iJohn_YT In that case it didn't affect you. I have an unlisted video that I submitted with a bug report. Hell, ut was even in the patch notes a while back. 1.05 I think.

[@eckhardt2006kugler]

What I'm missing is when I win a race I'm happy and that's not the case in the game, I have the impression that they're not happy at all, the faces are dead as always, no emotions to be seen. Why do they do it like that? From the beginning to today nothing has ever changed. Maybe the people who work at Codemasters aren't happy either. Who knows.

[@daihatsucast3063]

You get around 40 to 50 fps when you get f1 2020 to f1 23 i think Get RTX 4090 to get great graphics and the way you intended.

[@still_guns]

I'm going to get a 3000 series card instead. Much cheaper than a 4000 series.

[@daihatsucast3063]

3080 ti buy it

[@daihatsucast3063]

Oh how i love f1 games but i cant have a steam account and i dont have the right pc to play it only my pc can play f1 race stars lol

[@daihatsucast3063]

i play f1 race stars without a steam account

[@daihatsucast3063]

@@still_guns APEX GAMING PCS ARE SO GOOD THEY CAN PLAY GAMES AT HIGH FPS AND CAN PLAY ANY GAME YOU WANT! ALL F1 GAMES AND ANY OF YOUR FAVORITE GAMES YOU LIKE

[@RosssiFacoltativ]

Which one is best for ps4?

[@still_guns]

No idea

[@PINKPEE111]

WT Heck

[@gembelnetjis]

by far for me still 2020

[@iJohn_YT]

Why? In my eyes 23 is the best game they've brought us

[@gembelnetjis]

@@iJohn_YT still can't afford it, it's too expensive for me.. so because I've never played 23, so far it's still 20 for me :D

[@Wyn3e]

@@iJohn_YT💀 bro said f1 23

[@iJohn_YT]

@@Wyn3e exactly. Name me 1 reason apart from the bugs, why it shouldn't. It's still far from perfect, but heading into the right direction

[@Wyn3e]

@@iJohn_YT almost nothing has changed 💀 22 is actually fucked so that's in its own realm 24 just looks 70% shi from I've seen to the point for the first time ever I'm genuinely convinced paying for the £14 EA play pro just to see if it's actually remotely fucking good and even if it's somehow fun im just gonna play that month out and see how much that fun will last 💀

[@simpalacompa2825]

how i can play old f1?

[@still_guns]

Physical copies if you can find them. Not available digitally anymore.

[@craysheet3034]

You'll definitely need a new pc for F1 24

[@still_guns]

Don't worry, I got it ages ago now.

[@MrMarbles]

I hate the new handling in f123, I enjoy more the robust handling from f122.

[@lorenzodicicco184]

The first F1 game by Codemasters was F1 2009 not F1 2010 and I know is not a good game and a lot of people have prefer to forget this game but he remais at the first F1 by Codies

[@still_guns]

Do you see the two letters on the end of the title? And did you read the first line of text properly? PC. First F1 game in 8 years to come to PC. I am aware F1 2009 was the first Codies F1 game. But that did not release on PC.

[@GABR1ELR1EL]

I think the F1 that really has the intention is the F1 23, the other F1 10 don't seem to have the intention

[@VincenzoSanfilippo]

Still not that huge differences in terms of graphic, between 2010 and 2023. EA sports need a new enginel

[@still_guns]

To be fair, I'm not using the full graphics settings of the new game in this video. The next video will be using each game at maximum possible graphics due to my new PC.

[@MK-sw7do]

These new games have really bad crash physics, only the front wing and the tires can be broken, the tire barriers are still rock hard, in big accidents the cars are too heavy and are always stuck to the ground (very boring), i miss the Fun, they don't deserve my money.

[@muradgozelov8658]

Bro my phone Sams a12.F1 2016 not open

[@still_guns]

Sorry? I don't understand

[@muradgozelov8658]

@@still_guns Is there any way to fix this problem?

[@still_guns]

I don't even know what your problem is, your original comment is a mess.

[@YuukiNakamura]

@@still_guns I believe he is trying to say that his phone, the samsung a12 is unable to open F1 2016. I think he doesn't realize that f1 2016 is a pc/console game lol

[@still_guns]

@@muradgozelov8658 Are you asking why F1 2016 doesn't work on your phone? F1 2016 is a PC/Console game, it never had a mobile release.

[@CentraljocK]

You kinda lost me at 'Gamepad' sorry.

[@still_guns]

If you can't be asked to watch the full video because of a single word, maybe you should just fuck off and watch Baby Shark or something.

[@umbertofurlan501]

It's really a shame that from 2018 onwards they didn't implement the possibility to make the halo transparent. It completely ruins the whole driving experience in my opinion

[@still_guns]

For a moment I thought you meant the central support bar, but then it occurred to me that you probably meant the entire halo.

[@umbertofurlan501]

@@still_guns yes, it would have been nice for players to choose if they wanted the halo to be visible or in the transparent mode. i immagine an option on the menu where u disabled the visibility of the halo. this halo thing literally ruin the whole game

[@still_guns]

@@umbertofurlan501 "this halo thing literally ruin the whole game" Ah yes, the safety device that has saved a number of drivers over the years and that everyone has got used to by now is the real problem with the F1 games, and totally not the various other game breaking issues.

[@MrBarniculusBaboonicalshire]

@@still_gunsexactly, honestly some people lack the brain capacity to understand how valuable the halo is, imo I think the cars look better with it, they look cooler and more modern and futuristic like, anything without the halo looks pretty old and outdated but still good enough for me.

[@Ninja_PL-xs]

​​@@MrBarniculusBaboonicalshire I used to be a massive hater of halo and it's still annoying for drivers surely however.... Without it: Grosjean, Leclerc, possibly Hamilton, Zhou would have been dead :(

[@LADRON_DE_CODIGOS]

.

[@AlexRiggs-yd8my]

stupid gear ration....

[@Aubergineman19]

F1 2021 was good but you Can't Say the Music in f1 2021 is God

[@still_guns]

Did I say the music in F1 2021 was god? Did I get down on my knees and worship it for walking on water and turning bread into wine or whatever? No. I said it was fantastic. That's my opinion. If you didn't like it, fine. Don't tell me I can't.

[@Aubergineman19]

@@still_guns Sorry no it my opinion on the music