Is Allowed to Marry a girl who has Committed Adultery after that She repents? Dr. Zakir Naik Q&A?

[@gobble3063]

This is such informational video. Jazakallahu Khair

[@fatonademi4271]

This is a clear sign showing you how forgiving Almighty God is. You can imagine that someone cheated and just because they repented, they aren't considered a cheater anymore. MashAllah.

[@shabnamhassan6631]

Alhamdulillah,I know Allah is soooooo very kind n Islam is soooo easy religion for getting forgiveness oh allah forgive me n i know u r so kind n great forgiver u r not cruel my lord my Allah forgive me

[@ronelningombam4828]

Did you commit too

[@ZinabAbubakari]

Ameen

[@Muwahid999]

@@ronelningombam4828 Don't ask her to expose her sin whatever she's talking about

[@abdurrehman5431]

Yeah sure keep jumping on several 🍌 And Allah is soo merciful he will forgive What a joke

[@Theresia66]

'forced to commit adultery', so she was raped? What did she have to repent for?

[@Jav899]

May Allah have mercy on us Ameen

[@IDK_MAYBE_JIBRAN]

jazakallah ❤

[@bishhh2865]

Telling truth can make us feel dirty anyone's eyes ! So letting it in between with Allah and you is important after forgiveness

[@zeeshansidique8201]

Jazakallah khair

[@dawdamboob3689]

She's a good woman for telling the truth

[@DarkLeoPlays]

No hide your sins don't tell people

[@ChromeMan04]

@@DarkLeoPlaysshe needs to tell if someone asks

[@The_Lightless]

@@DarkLeoPlaysclearly you did not watch the video

[@dariusneidhart1068]

@@ChromeMan04no she is not supposed to tell the truth when someone asks her to reveal her past sins. Lying in this case is not lying. This might surprise you but you can search on this issue from learned scholars.

[@ChromeMan04]

@@dariusneidhart1068 that’s not a shared opinion among scholars

[@fayadseidu4456]

May ALLAH RICHLY BLESS YOU HERE AND THE HEREAFTER ❤❤❤

[@mohammedwaheeduddinafsar9482]

Yes its correct the man committed zinnah he'll get the same women who commmitted zinnah its their wish to marry or not to that man or women if they sincerely ask forgiveness Allah will forgive them

[@usaidneog3909]

Subhanallah ❤

[@mdshihabalimullah2352]

Jazakallahu khairon my dear brother, Zakir.

[@FahimAktharUllal]

Wa eyaakum. Barakallahu Feekum.

[@sabrina3734]

Shukrun, Sheikh Dr. Zakir Naik. You answered this question beautifully and tactfully with wise cautions mA, especially, towards the end. The Qur'anic ayah references are quite detailed as well as the jurisprudential insight you cited. May Allah guide us all 🤲 ☝️ Allahumma Aameen 🤲

[@Benz_Plays100]

I think no one can forgive humans , just Allah forgives the humans like they are new borns. Subhanallah❤

[@SairaChaudhary2111]

Subhan Allah ❤

[@Saa42808]

An open question: Wherever I went, whatever I did and whoever I met in my life I found the majority of them involved in corruption, favoritism, nepotism, deceiving, lying, cheating and using others. Is this the world God made and is this the purpose of life?

[@mdisanas]

Every human sin, but the one who repents are beloved to Allah. That's why we should not allegate others for sinning cz we do not know if they have repented or not, instead we should look on ourselves and correct ourselves, being a righteous n repenting muslim.

[@LaminSowe-yl9bv]

Doctor zakir, my question is if u have intercourse with somebody's wife,should you ask his husband for forgiveness for Allah to for u or u should repent to Allah and let go that sin..

[@zenastronomy]

keep it a secret and repent to Allah. no good will come from revealing this kind of sin.

[@Afridarbaz]

Astagfirullah What will happen when you tell her husband about it, Just imagine

[@sheikhyakin9345]

Do we have to tell our partners about our past if we do any zina. Is it u have to tell them

[@Afridarbaz]

No, never tell them it will be heart breaking for them and you can't be happy

[@OluwadamilolaBabatunde-yn3gk]

As salaam aleykum Can I do nikah outside b4 the date my parents choose for me without my parents knowing because they are Christian but I am al_sunnah but they know whom I want to marry but they are going to doing it in their own ways and I don't want

[@OluwadamilolaBabatunde-yn3gk]

Please sir I need a video for this jazakhallah

[@sheikhyakin9345]

So if a men do zina and the women did not , and the men did not tell her about the past will the marry will be valid.

[@Afridarbaz]

Yes

[@Afridarbaz]

But you should ask forgiveness from God before marriage

[@EverythingEverything0]

OK

[@rxya187]

Poor girl, she was sexually assaulted. It wasn't her fault. She did not commit zina and it is okay to marry her.

[@abdurrehman5431]

Broo listen She is making a story Lemme tell u , plenty of girls have the same kind of stories , that they were forced But in reality it goes like this, they were in love , they went to the hotel, she was expecting him to just do a kiss , $uckling but not !ntercourse but he lost his control and he forced her after the kiss and _uckling to do !ntercourse, but now she thinks she was forced or r@ped.

[@rxya187]

@@abdurrehman5431 what....are you hearing yourself... you just said he forced her....thats my point...its force which is rape

[@Wolflife263]

​@@abdurrehman5431Thanks brother you helped me understand these women may Allah keep us save from them

[@abdurrehman5431]

@@rxya187 if u give milk and meat to a cat , and u expect the cat to just drink milk but don't touch the meat. Do u really think cat is blamable for loosing her control to eat the meat as well.

[@rxya187]

@@Wolflife263 brother what would you do if a man raped your daughter and said he just couldn't control himself. Would you forgive him?

[@Theresia66]

'forced to commit adultery', so she was raped? What did she have to repent for?

[@Muslim.mode.]

Probably a coping phrase as she later says she feels ashamed, meaning she has accountability in the action, maybe pressured by a guy

[@Theresia66]

@@Muslim.mode. it's also a common thing to feel ashamed after rape. Especially in a culture that puts a lot of responsibility on women to avoid it. It is something he should have asked for clarification on before he gave advice.

[@Muslim.mode.]

@@Theresia66 she says she realized her “mistake”, admitting it has her fault (in part, the guy is also disgusting for pressuring her), but I feel like she should not admit her sins as it’s better to say I cannot answer that question, instead of admitting. In both cases this is why Allah say “don’t go near Zina” may Allah keep us far away from Zina

[@ibnarabi7349]

So anyone can commit zina and just ask forgiveness and it's fine?

[@Afridarbaz]

No, But committing zina is a worse sin How do you know God will forgive you ? What happens if someone committed zina and died without asking for forgiveness from God ? Or became addicted?

[@bishhh2865]

Is this important to tell your sins to anyone !

[@ibnarabi7349]

No but it's important to tell if you have done fornication

[@Afridarbaz]

​@@ibnarabi7349no brother not to tell any sin keep it secret

[@abidabegum6390]

Dr. Zakir, please correct yourself.... why are you confusing, like other so-called ulema..... Don't you get this sahi HADITH Sunan Abu Dawood 2052, kitabun Nikah.... GRADE SAHI ( AL- ALBANI) SUNAN ABU DAWOOD 2052 BOOK12, HADITH 7 BOOK 11, HADITH 2047.... Narrated Abu Hurayra razi Allahu anhu: The prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam said: The adulter who has been flogged ( repents to Allah subhnahutala) shall not marry save the one like him... In Musannaf Abu Dawood it is narrated that Abu Hurayra razi Allahu anhu said: The messenger of Allah blessings and peace of Allah be upon him said: "No fornicator on whom the hadd punishment ( who repents to Allah subhnahutala) has been carried out, should marry anyone but one who is like him" and it was narrated that one on whom the hadd punishment had been carried out because of fornication ( repented to Allah subhnahutala) married one on whom it has not been carried out ( i.e.,who was chaste), and ALI, razi Allahu anhu SEPERATED THEM.... Why do scholars ( so-called ulema) hide this hadith.... We have an authentic reference, why do they confuse the people..??? It may not be a dead breaker for some, but it can be one for others, don't you feel like hiding the sin that comes under the cheating category,and it is not permissible at any cost in our deen....do you find any authentic reference, that sahaba had done this type of act... First, the guy (zani) repents to Allah subhnahutala and finds the similar partner who has repented like that guy (zani)... This is what the Qur'an and hadith say.... Don't you think, that hiding the sin , it wouldn't help to build a strong wedding, it is not a sin that concerns only the person, who did but also their spouse, so the excuse of " not wanting to disclose sins" sounds quite empty here, and I am sure that those who hide behind it would be the first enraged if others did the same to them.... obviously you don't have to get too much into the details but being real about such a thing would, on the contrary make you appears as someone honest.its always good to treat with others like we would like to be treated.....

[@MuhammadAli-dk6dz]

I don’t think this is correct. If there are any exceptions to the rule, Quran tend to be very explicit in the text. Like in the following cases: And the two who commit it [i.e., unlawful sexual intercourse] among you - punish [i.e., dishonor] them both. But if they repent and correct themselves, leave them alone. Indeed, Allāh is ever Accepting of Repentance and Merciful. Men are in charge of women by [right of] what Allāh has given one over the other and what they spend [for maintenance] from their wealth. So righteous women are devoutly obedient, guarding in [the husband's] absence what Allāh would have them guard. But those [wives] from whom you fear arrogance - [first] advise them; [then if they persist], forsake them in bed; and [finally], strike them [lightly]. But if they obey you [once more], seek no means against them. Indeed, Allāh is ever Exalted and Grand. But here it doesn’t mention any exceptions: The fornicator does not marry except a [female] fornicator or polytheist, and none marries her except a fornicator or a polytheist, and that [i.e., marriage to such persons] has been made unlawful to the believers.

[@tasinrambo4166]

I think it is more of a generalization than a law that like dissolves like. Otherwise it would be like a muslim fornicator can marry an idolatress

[@minawina9494]

so theres no solution for them? if they repent and they mary fornicator or polyteist that means they just wait to die and go to hell? specially if its a muslim women. where it also said that its not allowed for them to marry and unbeliver..and they did fornication in the past and wish to change their life? so they need to ask the guy did you fornicate before marrying? or choose an unbeliver to marry?

[@abidabegum6390]

​@@minawina9494 According to sahi hadith and the Qur'an you have to follow the rules, no matter if you like it or not....see Sunan Abu Dawood, sahi Hadith,2052, kitabun Nikah... GRADE Sahi ( Al-Albani) Narrated Abu Hurayra razi Allahu said: The messenger of Allah blessings and peace of Allah be upon him said: "No fornicator on whom the hadd punishment has been carried out ( repents to Allah subhnahutala)should marry anyone but one who is like him "and it was narrated that one on whom the hadd punishment had been carried out because of fornication(repented to Allah subhnahutala)married one on whom it has not been carried out ( i.e.,who was chaste)and Ali razi Allahu anhu SEPERATED THEM....

[@ahamedm.h.a9205]

@@minawina9494 these people are clueless, if he/she repents they are good to go. But make sure how important it is to your potential spouse if he/she is someone whos willing to focus on the present and let go of past thats best. But if not being in any type of past relationship is important to them the boy/girl who committed zina should have the intelligence to move on from that proposal and marry someone whos ok with it. But as long as the other party doesnt care about the past you can gladly go and marry them.