Is it photography or Videography is permitted, Dr. Zakir Naik

[@muhammadhamza1705]

MasShaAllah. Now my concept about pictures is clear. Alhamdulillah!

[@khurshidlipi]

Before I wanted to know about this topic, my thinking is clear now...thanks a lot.

[@Antimonious]

The inventor of the first camera, the pinhole camera, was Ibn Al-Haytham. He was Muslim

[@shaikameer3055]

Assalamwalaikum sir khairiath. Allah aapko success aur health aata kareem.

[@FahimAktharUllal]

Jazakallahu qairr

[@FahimAktharUllal]

Walaikum salaam

[@omarfarique6304]

Alhamdulilah this is my question

[@farisazim2941]

The preservation is the different between making picture or just looking/watching. The bad things of picture: 1. Someone could worship it. 2. Someone could make fitnah based on it. And islam is usually favors prevention rather than cure.

[@peacetv9908]

SubhanAllah ❤Alhamdulillah ❤Allah hu Akbar ❤

[@CleverStory]

People will go with the 3rd group.. because it goes in their favor. 😅

[@artahikhan7e210]

I mean does make sense...not just cuz it is favorable

[@aron2015]

Or because it makes sense?

[@walker1337]

Photography & videography is halal. But making images with hands or art work of living things is haram. Photography of a lady is haram or prohibited if that picture is watched by a person who is out of her family.

[@inosuke8127]

Isn't this stupid to believe this even in this 21st century

[@imranshaikh6314]

​@@inosuke8127 no it is for security of women that's the point

[@anassiddiqui7355]

​@@inosuke8127 I don't care even if it would be 25th century....haram is haram

[@SammShk15]

Nope It is not halal cuz that day these technologies were not there but today it is present, pictures are still being clicked no matter the method. We can't imitate Allah's creation ryt

[@SammShk15]

@@inosuke8127 Isnt it stupidity to not consider religion in the 1st place🙂🙂

[@rahmandawah]

My opinion is 1st group is right bcz as the prophet S.A.W said : keep away from new discoveries in my deen and every new discovery will be a new path of misguide May Allah protect us from all fitna and bidaah ❤

[@abdulsaeed5527]

😂😂😂😂 so don't use mobile, car, machine ..etc, because they are new discovery

[@Ahmad-os3si]

Then why you watched this videos is haram for you

[@adeebayub5073]

source? can you give me the hadith

[@aron2015]

Stop using your phone brother. Yes I'm sure you only use for educational purposes 100% of the time. 😂

[@JafarFima]

Jazakallahu khairan brother

[@phenomenaking3862]

Alhamdulillah ♥️.. Well described

[@creativity4455]

Thanks for uploading this video

[@themagamer7289]

This confusion will not end till Allah gives a answer, These days camera photo's are modified to look good by Ai or by software is that not drawing

[@aron2015]

If you take a normal photo without any filters then that's normal. Only enhancement could be just light. It is not drawing anything. Just making parts lighter or brighter.

[@Sigmakuni12345]

What about flower plant we drw on cloths is halal cz flower is also living thing

[@Antimonious]

Videos are literally still images moving at 24/30/60/120 pictures per second

[@Bushra-uu3fo]

Why on earth is it not permitted for women’s photos to be taken if they are sufficiently covered and it’s kept not completely public ? I don’t get it

[@dazzlingvids78]

You can watch @assimalhakeem video on this question

[@a.anonymous0]

Hijab is to hide beauty so a women just showing herself it just defies the purpose of a hijab, and there's weird men out there so it's not a wise decision you should stay as hidden as possible and not let your beauty get out to anyone except your mahrams

[@AnonymousPerson-hr6qd]

This is incorrect, Shaykh Uthaymeen said videos and pictures are permitted so long as it is in digital form and not a physical manifestation such as a photo on paper, as soon as it becomes a physical form such as printed on a paper or on film, then its making images, whereas digital pictures on your phone or youtube video is digital electrical bits of 1s and 0s and as soon as power is off, the image ceases to exists!!!!! That's the key point, digital photo only exists in 1's and 0's with electricity and is gone the moment electricity is shut of like a mirror reflection or pond water reflection, but if you print the picture or 3-d print it, then its image making or scuplture!!!!!!!

[@mariamdiane3437]

Can you send the evidence ?

[@ilovespringrolls]

Is it halal to take videos or pictures of friends and to take vids and pucs of sky and myself?

[@Sajjad_26_]

10:33 nobody's in today's world doing this 🥺

[@revealertalks9389]

Ma sha allah

[@notnatty781]

Isit haram to take pictures of people using a mobile phone ?

[@nicomeschi595]

I’m sorry but.. this doesn’t make any sense. How is looking at yourself in the mirror the same as taking a picture with your phone? You are purely just LOOKING, NOT making a PICTURE. When you take a PICTURE, you are effectively MAKING a PICTURE. For example, you’re with a friend, outside in the woods and a deer appears: The friend LOOKS at the deer and admires it, while you take out your phone to TAKE a PICTURE. This is exactly the same as the mirror thing, the friend is just LOOKING, NOT making a PICTURE, while you are effectively MAKING a PICTURE with your phone. I don’t know why he brought this hadith up, were his Sahaba supposed to dodge reflections? What’s the purpose of this hadith for this issue? Personally, I think it’s very dangerous whatever he’s promoting by saying this. It’s very clearly mentioned in the hadith; DON’T make PICTURES. Please don’t look for loopholes and try to justify this, we are supposed to follow Allah (Subhanahuwa Ta'ala) and his Messenger SallAllahu Alayhi wa Salam as much as we can. May Allah bless you all.

[@FahimAktharUllal]

No comment If you are sure. But take advice from scholars Thank you Have a great day sir

[@nicomeschi595]

As salamo alaykum wa rahmatullahi, Brother, I’m not saying that you can’t take advice from scholars, on the contrary. I have massive respect for the scholars that put in the time to learn the Qur’an and the Hadith of the Prophet SallAllahu Alayhi wa Salam and teach us. That’s how I got to this video in the first place. But… that doesn’t mean you have to follow them blindly without doing your own research and reasoning. Same with my comment, you can take my advice and do your own research, or you can ignore it. I’m not forcing anyone. I can give an example, there are scholars and/or imaams, who believe that the Prophet SallAllahu Alayhi wa Salam did wudhu on his neck. There is only one weak hadith that can be used as evidence for this, but weak hadiths can’t be used for evidence, hence this is bidah. I usually never comment on videos, so the reason I actually commented is just because I feel obliged, as a fellow Muslim, to advice them against of, what I think is bad advice and to think and research it for themselves. Just because it’s a scholar, doesn’t mean we can just take his advice blindly. Even scholars are human and make mistakes and not even all scholars have the best intention for us. If there was a consensus where most of the scholars agreed upon, then I rest my case. But specifically in this situation, there is a lot of debate, which means it’s not as clear cut. That’s why you have to do your own research and take whatever you think is right in your hart. If this issue really is haraam, the Muslims who think it’s permissible, will spread this haraam among the Ummah of which will cause a chain reaction (people will tell other people and they will tell other people) which results them committing grave sins, which could’ve been avoided. The person who caused this chain reaction, he will get all of the sins of whom he told this haraam and of the one who he told to and so forth. When there is uncertainty about something, it’s better to avoid it until good evidence emerges. Otherwise, you might be risking yourself and others for jahannam. I hope I clarified it better and I hope Insha Allah that Allah Subhanahuwa wa Ta'Ala will bless us all and lead us to the straight path. Ps: I’m not a scholar or anything, I’m just a guy that loves his deen. I’m always willing to learn more about my deen, so if there is something wrong about my text, please let me know 😊

[@inspiringmuslim]

Assalamalaikum due to hurry and laziness in internet revolution, we dont pay much attention to english rules. but atleast we should be cautious about Islamic principles. So please write, Allah - not allah Qur'an - not quran Muhammed - not muhammed peace be upon him/SallAllahu alaihi wa sallam - not pbuh/saws Allah Subhanahuwa Ta'Ala- not swt Its not about sin and haram but about respect towards our Rabb!

[@MuazzamSheraz]

​@@nicomeschi595Do You Ever Take Picture Of Yourself ? I Am Pretty Sure You Did That. Right, So Now Allah Gonna Ask You Put The Soul In Your Own Picture You Clicked With Your Own Hand Right ? But Look Isn't It Strange And To Think That We Literally Worship One Allah, But On The Day Of Judgment Allah Gonna Ask Us To Put Soul In The Picture You Clicked. According, To My Understand Of Islam Yet. When You Believe In Allah And Know Allah Is The One Who Created Everything. Then It Is A Stupidity To Say That Allah Gonna Ask You To Put Soul On The Things You Create. So I Think From That Point Photography And Videography Is Halal, Despite Of That Let Assume That, If The Muslim Aren't Allowed To Do Videography And Photography. So The Question Is That Then How Should You Spread Islam Authentic Knowledge In This Century? Also If These Are Permitted Then We Are Also Creating Book By Photostate Machine Which Is Also Technically Same As Photography. Because Photostate Actually Work Little Bit Like Cameras In Our Phones. So That Means The Book We Are Reading Are Also Prohibited. Which Means Making Coping Of Quran Through Photostate Machine Is Haram Too. As Allah Mention That In Quran, First Of All We Have To Follow Quran And Then Hadith. By The Way These All The Things I Provided You Aren't Proved Or Authentic I Am Just Sharing My Understanding Of Islam.

[@nicomeschi595]

@@inspiringmuslim right, an easy way to fix this is to add it to your autocorrect. I have read that someone cut someone else's hands or something because they used an abbreviation when mentioning our Prophet SallAllahu Alayhi wa Salam

[@Alhamdulillah34556]

I am agree with third grp of scholars

[@syedhussain3857]

Brother Zakir Naik, I am very fond of wildlife photography. Is this Haram in Islam?

[@rayaanalam-x4w]

No

[@Ahmad-os3si]

No

[@elmonmohammad8871]

Alhamdulillah

[@learn_more12]

Mobile se photo Lena bhi gunah he kyaa ??

[@Ayesha______]

Alhamdulilah

[@ThahirunnissaR]

If videography is haram then to make youtube videos itself a haram and it includes videos and such things and this video is also a videography which is haram as mentioned by you and i don't get it... I'm definitely not complaining about you.. i just need a clarification and Allah may guide us all in doing right activities..

[@FahimAktharUllal]

Watch video fully

[@farisazim2941]

​@@FahimAktharUllalyou should reply clearly. He's not asking why. He's confused. You can just state that you follow the group that allow them.

[@syedharis6103]

2:37

[@tarunarachmad3976]

9:21

[@amitashsrivastava1857]

Hypocrisy ki bhi Seema hoti hai

[@safee_fa7044]

Salam alaikum ..... photo editing its harram or halal?

[@achraflamrani843]

it is actually haram to edit someones face or body as you are changing Allah's creation. If it is changing the white balance or colors to match the reality, then you are not changing Allah's creation but trying to get the picture to look the same as our eyes do. So Photoshopping people to look prettier than they really are is haram, but cropping, changing color effects or adding effects to make a picture more beautifull is not altering a person or creature as long you are not changing features of the face or body.

[@-zen-00]

@@achraflamrani843 is videography of let’s say anime or cartoons haram? Or is it allowed in Islam?

[@phenomenaking3862]

@@-zen-00 it is haram because you're creating a character which Allah didn't create. So Allah will ask you to put soul in him on the Day of Judgment. I may be wrong but i think this is haram

[@armanbhai4265]

ma she allha

[@nimraadnan1076]

Masha'Allah*

[@sihaduk5558]

🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹

[@FahimAktharUllal]

Jazakallahu qairr

[@mmd2172]

And this is a video🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@mmd2172]

Ohh my god i cant believe we are living in 2022 and having this argument.

[@ren.8137]

Shush

[@priya1608-l9i]

💝💝💝💝

[@taufiquealam1762]

I am not making drawing by thinking that i can do what allah can, i am only making coz its a skill

[@ren.8137]

Lol

[@bemuslims_]

you are hidayat less brother keep repent

[@phenomenaking3862]

Avoid it.. Or make drawing of non living things

[@LotfiKun]

​@@phenomenaking3862 Just wanna ask, are cartoons and anime considered living things ? Because it's not really an alive thing, it's Just a thing that we draw from imaginary.

[@bunskero]

​@@LotfiKunI believe so yes... But I suggest you look more on it because this is just what I heard. Even if they aren't real people they still look like and resemble humans

[@AllahuAkbar398]

Sir watching your face and listening ur voice is not haram ....you are gair mehram ???

[@saleemmohammed9450]

No! But make sure your following the PPL formula in your interactions with non-mehram! #public #puposeful #Limited

[@gokuandmessifan]

Hindu

[@sajidamubarak3177]

Kia film director ki kamai Haram ha

[@nishantsinghrathore9481]

What is quran?

[@achmedabdi9664]

The holy book of the Islam and the words of Allah S.W.A. I can give you one. 🤲🏾

[@ismailahmad0313]

@@vegetal8460 bhaad mey jaa dalle

[@sisterayisha]

@@vegetal8460 bloody fool.! don't dare to say that....be careful of your words when commenting...and you have kept Indian flag as your display picture......???? IN INDIA WE ARE NOT SUPPOSED TO CRITICIZE ONE ANOTHER'S RELIGIONS....what ethics are you following..???..and you are not fit to put our respectable Indian flag as your display picture while posting such kind of comments towards a religion..

[@muhd987]

Drawing Picture,Art work,Photography And Videography etc of a living things Is Prohibited. No doubt.(I Read in many islamic books). But human beings try to make it halal.

[@MaryamMohammadisa]

thn why he is filiming a video for us ¿

[@abdul-rahmanjawhari5929]

Did you not see the video brother

[@abu_alii]

You are commenting this on a platform with hundreds of millions of videos

[@Bushra-uu3fo]

You’ve read it in Islamic books presumably because this is the opinion of some Islamic scholars but this doesn’t mean this is the only possible opinion

[@ANIMExVIBES]

Can you give the references where you found Photography videography is Haram If it was then why do people get reverted just by watching Islamic video which bring them to Deen ? Can Islam ever be promoted by haram things?

[@Poetry_ke77]

Biology porna chor de?

[@Kkanwal1]

Aap jese ko duniya he chor deni chahye.

[@minal3496]

Nah it's allowed if it's for the sake of education Islam is not that strict It's the religion of love and peace

[@Antiphilozistin]

मदरसे में बायोलॉजी पढ़ाई नही जाती।😂

[@rahmafuad3606]

Be amrgna ytorgemln

[@ahadakash7358]

lol

[@muhammadabdulrafi1157]

Assalamualaikum... Quran, hadith ke roushni me nahi bata paaye... Kyun ke ye khud video ke aadi hai...

[@Abdullah-xp8gu]

Quran aur hadees ki roshni isliye nahi Bata paaye quran aur hadees me clear hai hi nahi Aur video daawate islam ke liye use Kar rahe hai Aur aap unhe kya bolrahe ho aap ne khud bhi to profile photo rakhi hai

[@Poetry_ke77]

Kya bakwash hai?

[@pro-mo1130]

😅 what rubbish

[@nihalmusthafa3500]

What is rubbish in this?

[@k1003944]

Are you even muslim when you say that? Don't ever refer to religious issues as "rubbish" ! Are you crazy?! This can take someone out the fold of islam!

[@Kkanwal1]

Rubbish is for those. Who themselves r RUBBISH 🗑:)

[@ridwanullahopemipo2697]

I don't blame him though......he doesn't seem to be a muslim.

[@mmd2172]

Agreeed

[@revealertalks9389]

Ma sha allah

[@inspiringmuslim]

Assalamalaikum write Allah in capital Ma sha Allah JazakAllah SubhanAllah In sha Allah and Allah knows best